BABYMETAL Piano Arrangement?! Vocal ANALYSIS of Su-Metal singing "Monochrome"!

[@blooddrunk4957]

Hearing how her voice has matured since the formation of the group is amazing.

[@Grizzlox]

She gets better every year. I can't wait to see what kind of singer she'll be when she's in her 30s and 40s

[@dairallan]

She had one of the best voices Ive ever heard even when she was like 16 and they broke out. Su really is an incredible singer and I think babymetal has been both a blessing and a curse.

[@GPTblacksmith]

I love how she has matured over the years. imo monochrome showcases all her matured talent

[@kevinwilson455]

It's good that she can show it in songs like this... but SU is Babymetal and the live performance... the dancing, stage presence, even the facials she makes during the songs, everything is deliberate and rehearsed and just perfection to her ability. I haven't seen her waver or give a bad performance and there are multiple thousands at this point @@dairallan

[@katzz6444]

We have had the privilege of being part of her journey.

[@kitkat6407]

During BABYMETAL's year-long hiatus last year, Su said, "I was singing 8 to 10 hours a day because I didn't have to worry about my throat." The girl who loved to sing more than anyone else has become a beautiful young lady who loves to sing more than anyone else. Her singing has always been pure musical joy.

[@gaijinguineapig]

Hi Kit Kat! I also like The Charismatic Voice...good to see you here.

[@kitkat6407]

@@gaijinguineapig 🤘😄💙

[@elfcounsul]

White is what is worn during mourning.

[@Ma93nta174]

@kitkat6407 WOWWW! I didn't know that. That is incredible dedication!!! Su literally lives to sing!!! 🎶 🎵

[@kitkat6407]

@@Ma93nta174 my Goddess✨

[@Mark_McMarkster]

This was released just before they announced the new third member Momoko. It’s almost a final goodbye to Yui with the three hooded figures in white holding hands referring to the Karate music video of Su, Moa and Yui. The message of which is fighting through difficult times, pulling yourself up and moving on, which is exactly what they’ve had to do the last 5 years without her. Then they released the second First Take video soon after the announcement which included Momoko as the new third member. Almost as a welcoming for her after the goodbye to Yui. I’m not crying, you’re crying.

[@davidfrazer2303]

We're not crying. Moa is crying.

[@Mark_McMarkster]

I already have my tickets for one of their upcoming live shows. I’ll be flying 9 hours to get there but it’s gonna be something special.

[@seloastral]

@@Mark_McMarkster Enjoy mate, I saw them live 2 weeks ago and they were stellar! Monochrome live was an absolute blessing

[@vegeta6555]

It is very bitter sweet ending to a era. May Yui find the happiness she is seeking. She is missed dearly. That said BM has a bright future with Momoko.

[@CyberBeep_kenshi]

Hope she does well

[@STRAKAZulu]

The album version of this song guts me. THIS version? Instant waterworks. The piano and strings added to their vocals… it’s a soul-deep pain, remembering the two biggest musical influences in my life: my grandmother was a concert pianist, and my mom was a cellist. I rescued her cello, “George” from being lost after her passing.

[@BadEnd98]

Well album version is trash compare to actual live full version tho, the instrument add a lot more punch and power in the live version, and the middle stop where Su call out the flash light from audience phones to form the starry space then start humming... is just something on another level

[@JustFiddler]

😇🎻🌹

[@denshaotoko42]

@@BadEnd98 Agreed, I am really hoping we get a Live album release soon from the concerts, especially the Yokohama ones from April, the atmosphere on those two days was just electric.

[@dennisb.9240]

Good on you that you rescued her cello! May George find a fitting mate to carry on this music legacy! I also agree this version is just beautiful and I had the pleasure to hear it live with the flashlights and Su's humming. I was rather starstruck witnessing it for the first time but it really makes you emotional, such a good moment! Hope you're doing well and a nice day to you!🤘🦊🤘

[@kevinwilson455]

Isn't music amazing... how it affects everyone in a unique way? I know how much music means to you just from your comment, and that's beautiful to me :)

[@forestduffe5576]

Her voice is heavenly. Phenomenal 🎵

[@JustFiddler]

ya setuju

[@わっしょい-x1r]

激しく同意します😢

[@tonygriffin_]

Su and Moa - handing out free goosebumps to the world. That last phrase - "Just Smile" - is too beautiful. 🦊🤘🤘🦊

[@man-utdtoru]

何だろう？Su-METALが歌うと安心感や安堵感が生まれる。簡単に言えば癒し系なんでしょうけど、それだけじゃない、そこに力強さ、儚さ、純粋さが混在する声質。 極めつけは、それが脳や心にグサッと突き刺さる、または直撃する。 私なりには、いつも気に掛けている所は、所作の美しさ、指先々まで意識が行き届いている所作が日本舞踊にも通じる繊細さが有る。それがステージ上でのあのカリスマ性だと思ってます。 そしてMOAMETALはと言うと、天真爛漫さは勿論気遣いの人でもあり、それがステージやステージ裏での彼女の素晴らしさを引き立てている。そしてモアバンギャーでも披露されてた通り十分歌唱力も高く、Su-METALに影響されたのか良いストレートボイスを披露してます。そして今回のアルバムに於いて以前とは比較にならないほどのダンスのスキルも上がり、キレが凄くなっていてSu-METALの歌唱力のスキルアップに伴いMOAMETAL、MOMOMETALのダンスのスキルアップも顕著になってます。 あと、Su-METALの声質は男性の立場的に、より良い影響を与えると言うか安らぎを与えるんだと思います。

[@Zelmel]

I'm always amazed at how crisp Su-Metal's enunciation is, on top of her other great singing skills.

[@griffenberg]

I have been listening to all genres of music for almost 50 years and Suzuka Nakamoto is one of the 3-4 greatest female vocalists I have ever heard

[@jeremyboynowski3784]

Couldn't agree more. Not sure if you've ever heard of or listened to Morissette Amon, but She's another amazing vocalist I think you'd probably fall in love with. Check out her performance of Wanna know what love is, Rise up, Never Enough, Could you be Messiah. Su and Mori I think are my 2 favorite female vocalists.

[@adamazri928]

Her voice is like a very powerful straight line that pierces through every heavy barriers in their music. Which is why Su is the perfect vocalist for the metal genre. I love me some symphonic and operatic voices like Tarja Turunen or Simone Simons but Suzuka is just whole new level of grace, beauty and talent. She was born to be a rockstar.

[@Megatronpt]

Su and Floor are my favourite vocalists at the moment!

[@michaelbartolomeo2926]

Who are your other 2-3 (truly just curious)?

[@griffenberg]

I would have to say Aretha Franklin is probably the best female singer I have ever heard live Whitney Houston, Dolly Parton, and Su Nakomoto Rounding out my top 5 and I will catch crap for this Miley Cyrus now most of her songs are crap but if you can hear her sing a capella or when she sang nothing else matters with Metallica she is a very talented singer but I don't actually like her music it's a conundrum

[@marcoskazu_]

Su, Moa, and Yui were practically born for music and dance together in school. They grew up together in Babymetal throughout their childhood and adolescence. The trio's separation must not have been easy. Of course, there were replacements. But naturally, Su and Moa miss the initial phase. They succeeded in a predominantly male industry as young Asian girls singing in Japanese. Imagine how difficult this must have been. While other children and teenagers dreamed of singing, Su, Moa, and Yui were already performing live for immense crowds at European and North American heavy and thrash metal festivals alongside famous bands. I believe that this heroic and sensitive side of Babymetal is unique. These images remind me of that. It's a little sad. Yui is gone. Su and Moa remain. Mikio, the great lead guitarist, passed away almost around the same time. They are winners. They probably imagined a teenage audience, but impressively, they made and continue to make many adult heavy metal fans happy in different countries. I'm not a parent, but I'm very proud of them. I wish them success and happiness. They deserve it. 🦊🦊🦊

[@kederaji]

"They succeeded in a predominantly male industry as young Asian girls singing in Japanese. Imagine how difficult this must have been." And they are still succeeding. They played three sold out shows in Anaheim this week to wrap up their tour.

[@geniuzzz_]

Just discovered Babymetal roughly a week ago and I already love them, both the clean and more isolated vocals Su performs and the more energic ones with all the instrumental behind. I don't know much about music theory but loved the way you explained everything without too many techical words. Take your like :)

[@richard_n]

When I originally heard of BabyMetal I thought it was just a gimmick band. However I was blown away the more I listened to them. Easily my favorite Japanese band now.

[@TJ_Kat]

I was the same. KZbin kept recommending their songs and I kept ignoring them. Then An Unhelpful Guide to Babymetal showed up and after a while I caved in and watched it. I've been hooked ever since.

[@geenefitz1]

You know, funny as it sounds, that is really what they were, to begin with. All the members were Sakura Gakuin, as a spin-off. They have all said that they had never listened to metal before. Kawaii Metal was a gimmick. Three young girls singing J-pop songs to heavy metal riffs. I mean when you think about it, there is no way that could work. Nobody knew they would catch on as quickly as they did. I am sure it was as much of a surprise to Toy Factory. In fact, the band was originally supposed to dissolve when Su graduated middle school and subsequently Sukura Gakuin. It was after the success of Ijime, Dame, Zettai that management decided not to dissolve the band. So yeah, it was a gimmick band at first, but the gimmick worked. The girls grew into the music and made it something more. So well that they are now a multi-award-winning group.

[@mrz80]

It kind of was a gimmick initially - how can we add a new twist to a teen idol group? How about headbanging metal? They initially toured with a "band" miming the music. It didn't gel into something more for a while. BabyMetal's kind of in a category all their own now, and the girls' vocal prowess keeps growing. Su's a crackerjack vocalist already and has the potential to be absolutely legendary ten, twenty years down the road. People will be going to her shows and telling each other, "Yeah, I remember seeing her when she was just a teenager and she was amazing even then!" :D

[@randomstuff2607]

Easily my favorite band of all time, anywhere on the planet.

[@Halvspenn]

Same. I scoffed at a friend trying to convince me they were good. Took until this year and METALI!! and RATATATA (I'm a huge Morello-fan and always enjoy Electric Callboys antics) for me to go "this girl's got an amazing voice, I guess there's a lot more to them" and then I listened to more and became a fan.

[@Ultra_Fine_Point]

This was their way of saying goodbye to Yui...damn... knowing that, you can really feel this song so much more.

[@man-utdtoru]

日本人の視点から言うとめっちゃ言葉がはっきり聴こえてきます。 そして、息継ぎは聴こえません、そしてクリアでストレートボイス。 聞き心地が良い歌声だと思います。

[@autohmae]

Suzuka/Su-metal has a precision in her singing, which I'm really glad is getting the attention it deserves. Thank you again !.

[@MacTaipan]

Thank you for doing this, I hoped you would! I know almost nothing about singing, but even for me it's easy to notice Su's clear enunciation. For a beginner in Japanese it's very noticeable how much easier her words are to understand compared to most singers or even speakers. Seeing her that close, It's obvious that that's no coincidence, she really puts a lot of care and effort in the shaping of her mouth. And even in this reduced setting, I find it interesting how Su manages to pull us in with her mannerism. She is born to entertain. But most importantly, her voice simply has such an amazingly beautiful sound. Combined with the emotion in this song, it's perfect. I have watched this video dozens of times since its release, and not a single time has it failed to bring tears to my eyes.

[@benjamineer3045]

I don't know if she was born to entertain, but she definitely has trained to be one almost all her life. She has started all this very early and for non-Japanese also disturbingly public in order to become J-Pop idol. I would assume in all the time she had access to best vocal coaches, choreographers and probably even fitness trainers Japan has to offer (and as this is quite some big industry, I sure they have pretty good ones). At to that they ridiculous work ethic they have to go threw and the tough selection process, it is hardly a surprise she is that great now. The international success they have is deserved I an any was possible, since talent, hard work and an (only initially) crazy idea truly bore fruit.

[@autohmae]

@@benjamineer3045 She clearly both had a lot of talent and trained/worked hard with amazing professionals. Her first real work with professionals was at Actors School Hiroshima. If you search online, you can go back and see her sing all the way back when she was 8. Or even see her do modeling on stage at age 5. We know she was already a child model at age 3. If she wasn't born to be in the spotlights, she certainly grew up in the spotlights !

[@autohmae]

In case anyone doubts how comfortable she is performing, when she was 10, she was the youngest in a group of 3 (Karen Girl's) and they got to perform a at a sort of anime music festival at the Saitama Auper Arena, audience more than 20 000 people. The other two were very nervous, but back stage, little Suzuka was sleeping like a log in the dressing room. Honestly, I think the bigger the audience the better she performs. 🙂

[@Not_Ferrari]

Su is such an amazing talent for so young a person. She's always been good, but seeing with each new album and each new performance how she's growing and developing her skill I really feel blessed to have found Babymetal years ago. I'm so glad you've been able to cover some of their songs and I hope in the future you can hear more. They're on tour later this year in the USA and their concerts are always amazing to see, if you get a chance you would probably have a great time.

[@JohanHaagg]

To be honest, she is not that young any more. She is 25 now after all.

[@Not_Ferrari]

@@JohanHaagg 25 isn't exactly old when you have singers performing well into their 70s. She also exhibits skill and control that isn't widely seen in other 20 something singers, her control is reminiscent of a much older more developed talent in my opinion.

[@JohanHaagg]

@@Not_Ferrari Uhm.. sorry mate, but what? I only commented that she is not that young any more. Nothing about her talent or voice. I love her voice, and I think she is extremly talented. Right there up at the top, with the likes of Sharon den Andel, Amy Lee, Simone Simons, Lzzy Hale and some others when they where at that age.

[@lwhauren]

this made me cry 🥲. I now need to hear more of them. thank you! 🖤

[@JDog88]

They have another song they did for The First Take called The One, which is another song that's on the album. The piano version they sing for TFT is unfinished, but it's still an incredible display of Su's awesome voice and talent.

[@lwhauren]

@@JDog88 thank you so much!

[@Proc3000]

A couple months ago Elizabeth tells me to request this on future videos/babymetal videos. Boom....here it is. Not just me but I can tell the fandom came out for this one. THANK YOU

[@Qikdraw]

Pretty much every BM reaction has fandom in the comments. BM fandom seems to like people's reactions to their songs a lot. Especially someone who is new to BM and also has a thorough grasp of the contents of music. I'm music dense but hearing professionals talk about how Su does what she does is really cool. I've been a fan of Elizabeth for a number of years now, not every song, sometimes big gaps in watching her, but I've always appreciated how much joy she gets from listening, and breaking down, songs always brings a smile to my face. Much like BM brings joy for my wife and I. I have been so happy she's started in on BM.

[@DefinitelyNotBender]

Moa is criminally overlooked in these reactions to this video. It really is a shame. I’m glad you spent some time mentioning her.🤘🏼🦊

[@bigtom1948]

She is soo cute and her singing is really good too.

[@KenNakajima07]

Moa is really good, it´s just the nature of the song and clip, Moa has the support vocals, hope she has a chance to shine on other clip

[@Will_Ever]

El coro nunca puede ensombrecer a la voz principal.

[@DefinitelyNotBender]

@@Will_Ever ella también es la voz principal. Pero no con frecuencia. Ella es igual de buena. Tu cita ignora la realidad.

[@jasoneffler9903]

Moa is no slouch either vocally! Moa's actually my favorite.

[@zenarcher9633]

0:44 I love that SuMetal & MoaMetal's entrance is heralded by the sound of their costumes rustling as they walk from off-screen to their mics.

[@Dragonstar-Metal]

Those mics do not allow for any mistakes. They pick up every sound. Su and Moa absolutely no mistakes!

[@autohmae]

@@Dragonstar-Metal If you remember how much they pick up then think about their breath control. If you watch some of the other first take performances, you can hear them breath, but Babymetal you can not.

[@misguidance__]

Chills. Nothing more to add, just chills

[@AcidzDesigns]

Seen babymetal live a couple of weeks ago when they opened for Sabaton. Su-metal sounds identical to her recordings. Honestly best night of my life

[@mattcalder1936]

Only when the mixing is good, I went to the Cardiff show and the mixing was awful, you couldn't hear her voice, only the band

[@Darkness251]

I was to a concert in 2014 in Germany. Really sounds like the studio version. Its incredible. Gonna go this year as well

[@lordrob13]

they are coming to pittsburgh with dethklock in september! this will be my first time seeing them live im too excited :)

[@olilewis7843]

@@mattcalder1936 bit late to this, but also went to cardiff one and wasnt that bad like couldve been where u were possibly but kinda near front sounded aight

[@Minulf]

@@mattcalder1936 Same, I saw them when they opened for Sabaton too in Vienna and the Sound quality was absolutely disgustingly BAD then.

[@raycollins511]

i knew you would love this version. now you almost need to react to the original version and then you can see the same song feels so different. the original version is awesome but this version feels like a totally different song. it makes you feel so different than the original. also i love how Babymetal is always positive in their messages in their songs. love the one phrase in this song where it says "no matter how long the night the morning will arrive" and the very last phrase she sings is "just smile". so powerful positive messages. to me this whole song is positive energy about peace and seeing each other in color not just black and white, hence the title Monochrome. Babymetal did an unfinished version of Akatsuki that you have reacted to. Su had just turned 16 and she brought so much emotion to the song it will bring tears to even the toughest guy.

[@gemaye9904]

Agreed! And any idea where I can find the unfinished version of Akatsuki?

[@raycollins511]

@@gemaye9904 the video and audio are out of sync since it is copied but here is one of them for the unfinished version of akatsuki kzbin.info/www/bejne/bX3EiZKZrLx9qdU

[@tk72231968]

I'm so glad you did a analysis of this version from BabyMetal. It's very different from their normal style, but also shows just how talented those young ladies are. Great video Elizabeth 🤘🦊🤘

[@Grington300]

That was great - confirming (and more importantly explaining) what we have known about Su and Moa and their vocal excellence for years.

[@bigfrankfraser1391]

took me a 4 minute scroll, but i found you

[@road-runner]

Great analysis, thanks! This is why I consider myself an addict to Su-metal singing voice. 😁 And you are totally right, she's able to convey the emotions like no one else. It's just mind-blowing.

[@jakemuller8626]

So glad to see you're back with this beautiful song, I would have love if you share original version with all of us first as well the rest of new singles, so far no one is having copyright blocked issues so don't worry about it and come back soon. BM fans already know this type of unique acoustic version like Akatsuki Unfinished Version live at Legend 1997 or The One - Stairway To Living Legend, so we're used to this SuMetal's vocals power to reach and melting our hearts. Also fans at Sabaton's Europe Tour are enjoying this song (original) each one of the concerts and having a magical moment. They recently released this version and The One - Stairway To Living Legend " for streaming platforms. Thanks for sharing your analysis and hope to see you next time 🦊🤘🌈

[@droidflash599]

Su and Moa are still young but they have over a decade of singing experience each. As I said in the live chat, you should look up to Babymetal's Headbangerrrr with Moametal singing. She only sings the last part of the song but you'll hear her beautiful and strong voice. She's not a belter like Su, but she sings beautifully.

[@Skylaman]

I remember thinking as soon as I saw this version “I really hope this gets reacted to by The Charismatic Voice!” Very excited. Thank you for your reaction! Easily one of my favorite Baby Metal tracks and even better in this piano version.

[@bebimetaru]

So great to see you again with a Babymetal song!! Suzuka/Su-Metal is a very special singer, thank you to brought that to the attention of your audience ♥️ Moa is very good too, but she usually focus on choreography. The fact that they can dance and sing with that same precision is always astonishing 🔥♥️

[@Proc3000]

Watching Moa dance is like listening to Su sing. Moa goes hard. And I'm there for it. And her smile. OMG her smile.

[@STRAKAZulu]

@@Proc3000 you can tell that they both absolutely love to perform, and are still having fun while they do it. And now that Momo is officially the third member, I can’t wait to see them continue!

[@PitifulMage]

LiSA first takes are amazing as well. Their most popular videos are all so good with talented singers

[@Lemon_Force]

Yessss would love for her to check out LiSa's First Takes

[@Lirukazu]

Yes, react LiSA please LiSA is also a big fan of BABYMETAL

[@monarchmonachus3138]

I would love to see her react to the LiSA x Uru “Saikai” First Take, it’s so good!

[@md45s]

Couldn't agree more.

[@flugelhornoldman1362]

Thanks again from Japan 有難う💛。Vowels stand out more in Japanese than any other languages, I believe. The five vowels "a, i, u ,e, o" are the first letters to pronounce and learn for infants. The girls proved that they can do anything. They have forced people to headbang with their heavy music and sharp choreo. Now they can depict various images by just singing and project them into the listeners' brain to move people emotionally. Thank you BABYMETAL. And thank you Koba, the BM producer, for your serendipity. Some 13 years ago, you certainly discovered something amazing and sacred for us. Speaking of the three figures in white hood adding some background vocals, they are certainly homage to BM's girlhood with original three girls.

[@duncantiv]

When I first discovered them, they were fun, adorable kids who were so new to metal, they messed up the "devil horn" hand gesture, which became the fox god symbol in their mythos. At some point, though, they just became titans and, IMO, true metal goddesses. It amazes me to see how much they've grown.

[@kaveman8083]

One of those voices that can bring a tear or two to your eyes. Su’s one of my favorite singers, as for others, for sure

[@KenNakajima07]

This is what I love about J Music, it´s not only being energetic, not only dancing, not only being beautiful, the amount of technique even small indie artists have is great to start with, I think it´s because they do have very strong foundations even when at school level. I like Babymetal since they were out, not a hardcore fan but I truly appreciate them and enjoy them a lot and I´m happy to see they´re back! this clip really pleasantly surprised me when I ran on to it a couple months ago, Su´s vocal prowess is off the charts, if this does not move you and give you goosebumps, you can´t be human.

[@DestructionGlitter]

I am not a BabyMetal fan (though I saw them at a festival a few years back and they kicked ass), and I can't speak Japanese. But in the comments on your last BabyMetal reaction, so many people recommended Monochrome. So I watched it. And without understanding a single word, I felt everything. I understand the song though I don't know what the lyrics mean. And then I went into the comments on that video... I ended up sobbing. The three hooded characters symbolize BM with their third member who had to retire for health reasons. Doesn't that make it all even more heartbreaking?

[@cixelsyd40]

If you turn the captions on for the music video, they have the translated lyrics as an option.

[@christophegadiffert5936]

thank you for this video. Su's voice is so pure it gives me goosebumps. As for Moa, it's a real pleasure to finally be able to hear her correctly, I knew she had a pretty voice and was a good singer, but thanks to this video I feel like I'm rediscovering her. They form a magnificent duo. Oh yes, I really like your videos too ^^

[@Tickle193]

God, how much I was waiting for you to react to Monochrome first take 😍 I love this version so much. Su's angelic voice is from another dimension ❤ It's supposed to be an uplifting song, but my eyes always are getting wet when I hear it.

[@Minulf]

Su-Metal has the potential to be one of the greatest vocalists ever. Not just in Metal but also generally. I mean, if this is anything to go by and judging by the videos of sound checks and acapella-recordings of her singing and stuffs, she is gonna be a force to be reckoned with and everyone who looked down on Babymetal will choke on their words.

[@rKAL-EL]

Damn, now I can see why people love Babymetal.

[@novacrowsnest597]

SuMetal's voice goes right to your soul. MoMetal's and now MomoMetal's are perfect compliments to soften the overall sound. Three very talented and well trained women.

[@Inosuke_Hashibira75]

I get chills with this song. Love how Su and Moa sound.

[@emb5091]

Someone PLEASE send Elizabeth a BABYMETAL shirt so she can wear it whenever she reacts to their songs!!🤘🦊🤘

[@sh-hatman]

I can't recall ever seeing CV smile this much. Being downright giddy sometimes. ^^ (11:08) If you're a BM fan just passing through on your reaction tour, this is high praise. :) And couldn't be more earned.

[@ralfklonowski3740]

" ... a BM fan just passing through on your reaction tour ..." This is the strange world of YT reactions in a nutshell. A world where we embark on a quest to find as many people as possible to tell us that what we like personally is actually good in an objective sort of way. Thank you for coining that phrase, it was an eye opener for me. (Edit: typo fixed)

[@JoshuaLytle-m3q]

I have been waiting for this video analysis. Thank you for this. Thank you for getting us to fall more in love with music with each video you make.

[@forderoc11]

First time i heard this it blew me away. I know cliché take. This is probably the most beautiful song ive ever heard and i have no idea what the lyrics are. I dont need to too enjoy the song. The power and emotion in her voice plus the instruments are just so damn beautiful.

[@JDog88]

I rarely get goosebumps from a song but this is just pure magic. And it's also one of the best things about Babymetal because regardless if one of their songs is super heavy or stripped down like this, they never fail to leave you in a happy mood. That's the beauty of these girls and their band of amazing musicians, their music transcends language barriers and brings people together to fully enjoy it for what it is.

[@MonkeyJedi99]

Danged onion-cutting ninjas are at it again. MANLY tears!

[@alex.blatchsmithypoo]

What's cool about the F1rst Take is that the closed captions are the translations! Love that. This song is so beautiful. I love how you break it down!

[@szakadtcsimpanz]

Oh My God, thank you for the analisis of this video, I've been waiting for this!! Thank youuu!!

[@stevechevy3382]

Nice reaction. Babymetal still finding ways to surprise even their hardcore fans. What you just witness was a small miracle. Both Su and Moa standing still while singing has rarely if ever been seen. Astonishing for them since they've been at this for over ten years. And the results are outstanding. I miss the dancing though and Moa's smile. Since this was performed all at once it would seem Moa was standing directly across from Su. Which is why IMO Su keeps looking up. One smirk or full-on smile from Moa and this one take would be very different. Moa can make anyone smile and laugh. It's one of her Super Moa Chan powers. In concert she's been known to use this on Su and go into funny face challenges with the drummer. Wish they would go back to the face paint so they could do that again. Moa said that when Su sings it's like an angel came down. Moa said that years ago. We knew Su was good, but Su proved just how good she really is with this one. The thing that impresses folks about Su's vocals is her ability to convey emotion through music. And she goes straight to the note. Doesn't fish for it or sing a thousand notes before she gets there. Clear and clean are her vocals. Part of that has always been her pronunciation. Strong is Su in the way of song. Which is why Babymetal was built around her. For Babymetal this is the way.

[@Zikkar]

If you really want to see the power of Su’s voice and do more BabyMetal they I suggest No Rain No Rainbow performed at Hiroshima. Also Rondo of Nightmare with the Mischief of the gods intro.

[@shadowninja6444]

Yes!!! I was hoping you would do a reaction to this version of monochrome!! Amazing song!!!

[@martinmetal7481]

Was hoping you reacted to this version of Monochrome 😁 so much, anylis by you àbout their voices already knew how great they were it just makes me appreciate them even more ( if that's possible) . The original version is a banger, and when performed live, Su does what she can do best and create a Su moment. Will not say what it is so as not to spoil it for you if you ever watch or react to it . Experience it myself, live at Wembley Arena, and what a beautiful moment it was . They are back to 3 members now, and they have done a 2nd take version of "The One," a thank you song written to the fandom ❤❤❤ 😁🤘🏼🦊🤘🏼

[@maxtusker4380]

What a great reaction but more particularly, what a great analysis. F1rst take is such a good way to hear a vocalists voice. This particular video really shows us how good Sue is as a vocalist. It also shows us how well Moa can sing. The other F1rst Take video they did for "The One" has received criticism because people say it has been adjusted in post. Personally I don't care about that, we still get to hear Sue's beautiful voice and get some idea of what they sound like with Momoco's ( Momometal ) voice included. Looking forward to your video about "The One" performed on F1rst Take.

[@heathjeppson5669]

I have been watching these girls since they first started getting worldwide renown... I fell in love with the fun aspect they brought to metal. They have grown into absolute bonifide ROCK STARS! Sumetal's voice is soooo beautiful, it has the power to melt your eyeballs in front a hard core power metal band or to to bring tears to your eyes. Moametal brings a softness that compliments Sumetal like no other. Momometal new girl that replaced Yuimetal seems like she is going to meld in well and I can't wait to see what new heights these girls take their music.

[@jaubury]

Thank you for putting into words all the things I didn't know how to express. I love Babymetal and this version always gets me even tho I've watched it many times now. Su is just so damn good! Moa has an amazing voice too and there is a live version of Headbanger here in YT were Su hands the mic to Moa half way through. It's awesome!

[@Greg-om2hb]

Dear Suzuka is a consummate professional. Watch the live performance of RONDO OF NIGHTMARE. Then watch the First Takes or LiSA singing HOMURA and GURENGE. I think “monochrome hanabi” (black-and-white firework) is a reference to the atomic bomb on SU’s hometown of Hiroshima.

[@paulbenwell3560]

It is just one reason we call her goddess. And was great to hear credit our Angel of Love (aka Moa) - she is a very fine singer in her own right yet rarely gets to show it. Both were trained as singers, dancers, actresses and models from joined Sakura Gakuin (at 12/10). Part of the audition requirement is all members had to be able to sing a cappella.

[@nickydexgg4579]

Three of my favorite women on KZbin in one video!? Heck yeah! I hope you do the visualizer version of Monochrome next! The subtext of this song, with Suzuka being from Hiroshima, adds so much to the emotion of this song.

[@rheykynen]

I knew about them for a while but only just recently gave them a chance. And I'm so hooked, I love it. Su got an amazing voice and Moas quite impressive too, like her version of Headbanger. They were the main reason why I went to see the Sabaton concert near me haha

[@safrisaleh412]

Monochrome By Babymetal:- It's really atmospheric which I like. Divine Attack brought the hype and Monochrome brought beautiful vibes. The next single will bring the heavy vibes I hope. Well, this song certainly shows that the few second snippets don't really spoil or give away the songs at all. The chorus with the is catchy, but the drum riffs are the jam for me upon first couple of listens. Since the snippets don't reveal the songs, I'm wondering if the five songs that will be released aren't gonna reveal the final album as a concept album, once released and listened to in full and in sequence, as most concept albums are meant to be listened to. Being that this album is conceptual, and should probably be listened to as a whole and in order, this could be a fun slow-burn reveal to. As of now only two original Babymetal are in the current status, Suzuka Nakamoto (Su-Metal, Main Vocalist) & Moa Kikuchi (Moametal, Backing Vocals). The third member of Babymetal will be announced soon. Monochrome Song by BABYMETAL Overview Lyrics:- Nanairo's dream that colors the sky 空を彩る ナナイロの夢 I wanted to see you like this forever ずっとこのまま 見ていたかった was shining until yesterday 昨日まで 輝いていた even kiraboshi キラボシでさえも I don't know what to say, I don't know what to say I don't know what to say, I don't know what to say Because it's fading ah 色褪せてくから ah that monochrome あのモノクロームの If it's fireworks, we're oh oh 花火なら 僕らは oh oh What color should I draw the night sky oh oh 何色で描こう 夜空を oh oh On a freezing night in the rain 雨に降られて 凍える夜は I wanted to be by your side, even just for a little while 少しだけでも 側にいたかった I want to feel it until tomorrow 明日まで 感じていたい even the warmth 温もりでさえも You don't have to say it, you don't have to say it You don't have to say it, you don't have to say it Because I'm getting cold ah 冷めてしまうから ah that monochrome あのモノクロームの If it's fireworks, we're oh oh 花火なら 僕らは oh oh Let's paint the night sky with rainbow colors oh oh 虹色で描こう 夜空を oh oh In the twilight of Ragnarok ラグナロクの黄昏に what are we looking at oh oh 僕らは何を見てる oh oh Even if it's a long long night 長い長い夜だって Morning will come before long oh oh やがて朝は来るから oh oh monochrome モノクロームの If it's fireworks, we're oh oh 花火なら 僕らは oh oh Let's wrap the world in rainbow colors oh oh 虹色で包もう 世界を oh oh laugh 笑って Oh oh Oh oh Oh oh Oh oh Source: LyricFind Songwriters: Mk-Metal / Yuppemetal Monochrome lyrics © Sony/ATV Music Publishing LLC Kitsune Up 🦊🦊🦊🤘🤘🤘🇯🇵🇸🇬#notacult.

[@Varksterable]

Thank you. I've loved Babymetal for years and as seems to be the norm I have chased reactions for years too. But to hear such a detailed and professional breakdown as a reaction is just amazing. Insightful, inspiring, informative, clever, beautiful. Thank you.

[@bobadams179]

I never really paid any attention to Japanese girl bands. I must say these young ladies really got my attention with their incredible talents. Wonderful to watch and especially to listen to.

[@tackle47]

Japanese female metal is insanely good, see Nemophila or Lovebites and for hard rock Band Maid.

[@lightblue8818]

One thing i love about Su-Metals voice is how clear it is. She can belt out at full capacity without breaking the note or changing pitch or anything else. She just does it perfectly and it always gives me the shivers. Like you would expect any other singers voice to give out or cut the note or go down because they cant hold it or sing it, but instead she goes even harder and its still crystal clear. Noise cancelling headphones and her singing is a treat i genuinely enjoy.

[@ClockworkSatan]

Why the heck does this version of the song always cause me to well-up? It's just so beautiful.

[@keithmontague6417]

Absolutely fantastic group. Su metal what a great voice. Love the way you describe their voices. Great reaction. All the girls are fantastic in this group.

[@GOT_Clips]

I was waiting for this one and it was just as good as I expected. This is one of the only reaction channels that keeps my attention literally from start til finish, great work. The first take is an awesome project and I love that you've opened the door to this whole world of music. I'd have to recommend TK performing Unravel and LiSA's Gurenge. Both are some of the best I have seen on the channel and I think you will love them. Thanks for this!

[@grumpus5248]

This is a lullaby for me. I love this version. Babymetal's range is so cool...I could go for an "unplugged" version of so many of their songs. The original is great in its own right, but this version blew me away when I first heard it.

[@mikecronis]

The sky decorated in a spectrum of dreams I wanted to look at it forever. Even the bright star that was shining yesterday (I don't know what to say, I don't know what to say) Is fading away. That monochrome firework.. What color can we imagine the night sky? Being drenched by the rain and freezing in the night I wanted to be by your side even just for a little while The warmth I want to feel until tomorrow (You don’t have to say it, you don’t have to say it) Will vanish eventually.. That monochrome firework, we are.. Imagine the night sky in rainbow colors? During the dusk of Ragnarok, what are we to see? No matter how long the night, the morning will arrive. We are a monochrome firework. We will Illuminate the world in rainbow colors. Just smile.

[@fatmanchew909]

One thing I learned about listening to music not in English is when you actually take time to read the translation you get a better understanding of what the song is trying to convey. That being said I can't wait to see them in concert in Vegas later this year with my little one because they're the reason why she's trying to learn Japanese at a young age while trying to grasp English.

[@charlieghostwolf6161]

The absolute precise control is simply phenomenal Thank you

[@larryf4180]

I just saw them live this week and they performed this song, they are very gifted performers, fantastic live, I'd recommend it if you get a chance.

[@johnewiseman]

Thank you for your response to this amazing song. Your expertise in singing has helped me to appreciate BabyMetal more. I was not a fan of theirs until I listened to this song, and now I am hooked and have been revisiting their previous albums. I am eagerly anticipating what this band has in store for the future.

[@yorha19F]

Amazing analysis, you're so on point on all of them, I love seeing my favorite band receiving so much appreciation and space. Please keep up with it of it's possible, hugs from Brazil

[@t_siroto4166]

It was wonderful explanation. I rediscovered the wonderfulness of BABYMETAL by you. Su voice is the appearance which is laser. Her voice is so powerful. I also consent to laser.

[@Psyggie]

So excited to see this on your channel!! Babymetal has stolen my heart and everything about them is just awesome. This performance is so powerful and emotional and really showcases Su's new skills!

[@rrahl]

Can't wait for this, Su-Metal is powerful, precise, like nothing i've ever heard and she gets better with everything Babymetal releases. It's a privilege to hear.

[@Grenader3000]

Was so looking forward to this reaction. Thanks for this was worth the wait. They did another first take song in all english. THE ONE - Unfinished ver. / THE FIRST TAKE worth checking out!

[@cogithefool4284]

Been addicted to this rendition of the song since the first time I heard this. Also, I'd recommend checking out more from The First Take. They have some of the best Japanese vocalists on the industry like LiSA, ReoNa, TK, and many more. Definitely a fresh concept too.

[@stuffguru]

My HS band had a rotating exchange with a HS band in Tokyo. I have never been around such a professional group of musicians in my life. They're worst players were still as good as some of our best. And you can really hear that technical impeccability here. Love it

[@blakethetank]

Seeing Elizabeth react to Babymetal/Suzuka once again makes me very happy.

[@SynicalDan]

I’m a big fan of their arena shows, but a small venue concert, with this approach to the music, composition and sound would be transcendent.

[@AlexTommo]

I managed to get tickets to a London show they're doing this November. The capacity is meant to be around 3,000. The anticipation is crushing me.

[@jadedviper756]

@@AlexTommo completely agree with this, I saw them with Sabaton in cardiff after waiting years to finally get the see them live Su's voice was incredible, I've got tickets to their Wolves date which is a small little venue as well, hype is absolutely real!, enjoy the London Date! :)

[@AlexTommo]

@@jadedviper756 i was contemplating going to the Wolverhampton show, but I managed to get tickets for the Tuesday night in London. I hope you enjoy your show too!

[@actuallynotsteve]

Imagine a 1 hour Babymetal unplugged MTV special, I'm not sure the public is ready for something that movingc

[@davidfrazer2303]

I've been waiting for you to do this performance. Thank you.

[@buzzthebuzzard5267]

Wow this is awesome, love BabyMetal and never heard this before, really enjoyed experiencing for the first time with you.

[@brentfordsandy6271]

All I can say is thank you... Reduced to a puddle of tears once again... It never fails

[@akenawell]

I’ve been waiting for you to listen to this! It’s a truly masterful display. I got so emotional the first time I listened.

[@christopherjq7414]

I think we may have a new member of "The One" in the making here 🦊🤘

[@olias056]

This was a fantastic reaction! I got as much enjoyment out of watching Elizabeth's reactions as I did the video, which is stunning!

[@cassobiker]

a few days ago, i was at babymetal concert and they were singing monochrome too. it was fantastic. Su is amaizing girl 🫶

[@ChimPANTSz]

This group is phenomenal. And I absolutely love their progression over time. I honestly can’t believe though that you have not yet reacted to Band Maid. They are one of, if not, the best rock bands out right now. They have hard hitting music but with beautiful vocals and harmonies! Julia can confirm this lol 😝

[@Proc3000]

What I appreciate about this version is how stripped down it is and you can hear Su and Moa........because this is an absolute banger, especially live.

[@thomasrasmussen2124]

i love Babymetal and everything they stand for. Su-Metal's voice is amazing in so many ways, and shes one of my alltime favorite singers. i would love to hear what you have to say about "no rain, no rainbow" which like this one is a very emotional preformence that really focuses on the vocals. .

[@paulleighton9568]

I was surprised by this version. They need to do more songs like this..

[@srudine]

So great! Thanks Liz for the airing and analysis. I was hoping you would comment (or affirm) the yodel Su makes at 9:27. Lovely🤩

[@egodreas]

I know the last Babymetal song you listened to was Akatsuki, but if you like hearing them stripped down like this, you should consider giving _Akatsuki - Unfinished Version_ a try. Same deal. A one-time performance of a piano and strings arrangement, focusing more on Su's vocals. And she delivers it with even more emotion than she did Monochrome here on the First Take. Except she's almost 10 years younger and singing it on stage as the penultimate song of the evening. There are many a video on KZbin with big bearded men crying their hearts out to that performance. And you'll notice an almost complete lack of vibrato back then. This version of Monochrome is actually the most amount of vibrato I have ever heard her use. I really like that she keeps mixing it up. Give songs like _BxMxC_ or _Shanti, Shanti, Shanti_ a try if you want to hear her doing something a bit different 🙂

[@dobermanownerforlife3902]

Their song BxMxC was produced with autotune intentfully to knock the melody out of Su's voice. She has the control to do that song live. Compare studio vs live, and you will be impressed.

[@Proc3000]

The only time you'll see auto tune used to make someone sound worse.

[@dextacchino7140]

This will be my first time listening to Baby Metal as my “after work treat”! Mornin’, EZ!!! Hope your first Mother’s Day was awesome!!! Much love, gratitude, and respect!! 💛🎧💚

[@edwardfielder8383]

I love this woman she makes a bad day so much better, so tender, so passionate, makes me smile😊

[@denshaotoko42]

Her voice is both powerful and so full of emotion. I have listened to this song dozens of times, and it moves me to tears every time. The funny thing is that the regular metal version of this song is almost uplifting and joyful (and Suzuka herself always said she considers this an almost happy song, and she was surprised most people consider it a sorrowful ballad). But this piano version really is an emotional gut punch to me.

[@jeremyboynowski3784]

OMG, thank you for FINALLY reacting to this song! When I saw last night you were FINALLY going to react to this, I was super excited! I had to wake up, go to work, find out I had to do some shopping after work, then come home, feed the animals, get my dinner and then FINALLY I got to sit down and watch your reaction! I was thinking about it the entire day today lol You are absolutely gorgeous as usual, and your reaction was awesome to see! It made me so happy seeing how happy you were with this performance lol On a side note, I cannot prove it, nor do I know for certain, but I have a gut feeling that the figure in the white robe on the far right (the tallest one) was Momometal. The newest edition to Babymetal that was finally invited to take the place of Yuimetal. Again, can't prove it, but it's just a feeling I have. Maybe one day we'll find out who the 3 were! Anyhow, thank you for FINALLY doing this song in this setting. Babymetal announced recently that they will be making this version of this song and also the other song they sang on this channel (The One Unfinished) available for people to download (I imagine you have to purchase it though lol). So you can get the song and put it on your playlist if you'd like. That'll be awesome!