Backing Up And Cracking Up

The plaintiff says the defendant backed into his car, so he's suing for damages. The defendant argues he has backup sensors on his vehicle and never even hit the plaintiff's car.
Subscribe to our channel:
/ @peoplescourttv
Case # 32-203
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court

[@neutralcommenter7800]

She let the defendant go through his whole explanation then says, "You know he has you on tape, right?" Lol

[@Itsroccib]

I’m crying! 😂😂😂

[@JayJay-me8zk]

The "Perry Mason moment"

[@shanimorrison8730]

The best way to do it lol

[@marleonetti7]

ironically , the tape proves the defendant DID NOT HIT the other car . the tape only shows the defendant trying to park in a certain way but clearly shows that no contact was made between his vehicle and the other vehicle . i would appeal the decision based on what the tape actually shows .

[@neutralcommenter7800]

@@marleonetti7 You are 100% wrong as it is impossible to conclusively say he didn't hit the plaintiff's car based on the video at 16:07 - the defendant's car is blocking the plaintiff's car and there may be contact at this point. This is a civil case which does not require conclusive proof, but rather that it is more likely than not (i.e. 51% likely) the defendant hit the car. There was video evidence that showed the defendant's car possibly touching the other car, the damage on both cars matched consistent with the video and the defendant was unable to provide an explanation that made sense (and once he lied about having pulled in head first that took away his credibility as a witness). You could appeal all you want but it would not make a difference as the appellate court would accept the Judge's findings based on this evidence.

[@user-cz5ny3tn9t]

He is playing stupid like he doesn't understand

[@colleenknapp8626]

Oh, he understands, but he is still stupid. 😂

[@johnsradios484]

That guy is fighting so hard to avoid paying anything !

[@marleonetti7]

the video clearly showed that the two vehicles did not touch each other , because the plaintiff's car would have moved a little if it was bumped and the video would have showed that .

[@ls253]

I think Judge M lost about 40 mins of her life on this defendant. Jeez.

[@mmmfun77]

So did we😂😂😂

[@thatONE____]

I think she did it on purpose 😅😂

[@Mishel33020]

Absolutely ​@@thatONE____

[@hanypants]

22 minutes

[@conphuze]

The only reason he ended up parking head-first in the garage was to hide the damage that his car sustained when he hit the Plaintiff's car. Had he never hit the other car he would have continued manuevering until he was able to back it in.

[@natasharobinson2008]

💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@humaneleaguelancPA]

Plantiff is very calm and confident, he let the video speak for itself.

[@marleonetti7]

but the video showed that THE CARS DID NOT TOUCH . bad verdict .

[@spacepanda9037]

​@marleonetti7 are the the defendant bc you are under every comment going hard for him 😂

[@marleonetti7]

@@spacepanda9037 no , im just a guy on youtube giving my opinion .

[@spacepanda9037]

@marleonetti7 under every single comment lol you really wanted to give that opinion

[@almathomas8325]

I don't know what was more frustrating, the defendant explaining himself parking, or video of the defendant actually parking.

[@barbarawallach1334]

Absolutely 💯

[@crystalshaw8744]

Moral of the story, don't back that azz up.

[@Mocharocks9966]

THis comment is underrated

[@Jay_realistic88]

😆😆

[@keiariabailey8739]

This comment has me cackling

[@nodnarb3540]

…..I’d make an addendum to that: don’t back up unless you know how. I always back in, because I’m terrible at pulling in normally.

[@Idontwantafuckinghandle588]

Unback, antiback, reverse reversal,

[@biancalathetravelerssoul]

"My heart is crying" 🤣🤣🤣

[@NubianP6]

*My heart is cryin’”,* and you MOUTH was LYIN’! 🤣🤣🤣

[@Nurse_Nash]

😂😂😂😂

[@Itsroccib]

💀💀💀

[@allthingsartwmari]

🤭🤣🤣🤣

[@magmian]

😂

[@inukoko2012]

Lmfao 😂

[@Panhandlers007]

This is why it should be mandatory for folks to retake their Drivers License after a certain age. Everything he did while trying to park was worrisome 😩🤦🏾‍♀️

[@kellyrowe398]

As a 70 year old, I couldn't agree. I'm not quite as good as I was 40 years ago but I still got it!

[@SuperNoahsmom]

@@kellyrowe398as a 60 yr old I 💯 agree there needs to be mandatory retesting!! My mother is a fucking danger to EVERYONE on the roads!!

[@KAKE-26]

No damage. Damage. No damage. Damage. 🌼

[@18missmm]

🤣🤣 Clever!!

[@nikkisjeans]

😂😂 I also act confused when I'm stalling for a lie.

[@Julie-sl8ul]

This is soooo painful to listen to

[@saramichele7366]

EXTREMELY frustrating!

[@mikemontana3443]

Defendant -- "There is no damage to my car. That dent and scratch on my car came like that from the factory. I special ordered it with a dent and scratch already because I didn't want to feel bad being the first person to damage my car."

[@donnapfeifer6589]

They call it "gas lighting". The defendant was so dishonest. He lied about everything.

[@barbarawallach1334]

Hahaha

[@PHOENIX1699]

"He doesn't think you hit it from the back!" - Marilyn Milan

[@marcdinsmore8690]

Classic!

[@mimim8532]

Naughty!

[@kenhawes4695]

Defendant is such a freaking liar! I could tell by his angry face as he walked in that he was most likely a liar.

[@mmmfun77]

That age not taking accountability. Ridiculous

[@barbdolson139]

Liar, Liar pants on fire.

[@mikemontana3443]

"There is no damage to my car. That is a scratch. Quit trying to confuse me with semantics."

[@jscalding]

Seriously, watch the hallway interview with Doug at 0.25 speed. 😂😂😂😂

[@luzleon9321]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@williammartin5569]

Oh wow. Thanks

[@williammartin5569]

That was the best suggestion ever. 😂😂😂

[@williammartin5569]

It was youuuuuuuuu

[@18missmm]

​@@williammartin5569Best part!🤣🤣

[@SkelzaDawn]

44 point turn 💀

[@user-cz5ny3tn9t]

Sometimes you don't really feel it when it's a tough but it still does damage to your car

[@mikeyh0]

Man, I just love Judge Milian. Her demeanor, her obvious physical attractiveness and her intelligence. I can't watch those remote cases, however.

[@18missmm]

I only watch those while doing chores or busy work. They're not as interesting, but you can afford to be distracted while watching. Otherwise, you're right! You get the best interactions and reactions when they're in person. And the comments are icing on the cake!😂

[@mikeyh0]

@@18missmm Stay frosty or is it stay frosting? Which is it? I sing, you sing , we all sing for icing. Espresso is my friend. lol

[@18missmm]

@@mikeyh0 😂 I think it's "stay frosty"

[@Mishel33020]

They drive me crazy too. So I listen/watch them while i'm driving. Lol

[@saramichele7366]

The defendant is full of CRAP! He's just babbling nonsense! Why did she allow that to continue for so long?!

[@mikemontana3443]

OH, I did not know that you were visiting your friend of 70 years. Obviously you could not have hit his car because no one who is visiting their friend of 70 years hits another car. Thanks for providing that very relevant evidence.

[@margaretkoziel1643]

Omg the defendant is lying thru his teeth !!!

[@alienproperty]

Edward “ cut them off” lol

[@khayriyyahcrosby7592]

Lwad I caught that too 😂😂😂😂

[@annajacobson3299]

Is anyone else confused about why he backed into the space? He pulled in just fine the first time 🤣. Could have avoided this whole mess

[@yenilu.a10cio]

Why do they insist on naming just about every accident case "Back Up Crack Up" 😐😒 Give it a rest, jeez

[@msteinberg7]

but you must admit it's not as bad as harvey's '...he hardly knew her' line

[@roxiebkdime5224]

Yeah the hardly knew her is more annoying. But not by much

[@mmk07135]

Backer? I barely knew her

[@raeneal3825]

​@mmk07135 😂 You've managed to make them worse, right when I thought they couldn't! And it's hilarious!

[@18missmm]

​@msteinberg7 Exactly what I was about to say!😂

[@stephaniehowe0973]

Haha I had back up sensors on the Chrysler Pacifica. They go off too late.

[@KingBoxingandFitness]

My boy drowning gasping for air in this case 😂

[@ingeweeda]

The tape showed mostly the 2nd lie about parking in one move, immediately nose forward. The lie about the non-existing damage was already pinched. Once a lie means always lies... its that simple... and in court a no go!

[@misunderstood136]

I haven't laughed this hard! Listening to him had me ☠️🤣🤣

[@genevievegutzmer]

“You’re killing me” I’m sorry I’m so sorry! 😂😭😭😭

[@jennifer_mertens]

Defendant: "No, yeah, no. I did not do it, but I did"😮. A "44 point turn"😂---that's go one foot, back up, go another foot, back up, and on and on. He shouldn't be driving, he can't park for sh1t.

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

Judge to defendant: You're doing like a 40-Point Turn... what are you doing in this video??!? 🤔🤪🤯😫😖😰😣. 🤣

[@ashleighhhhhhhh]

I wouldn't have thought the judge drove a Pacifica lol

[@oldageisdumb]

Agreed. Thats not a very good quality car. Would have thought she would make better choices in life

[@Stressless2023]

@@oldageisdumb My wife and I have owned a 2018 Chrysler Pacifica for 6 years and it's been a great van with very good quality - Judge Milian's "choice" to own one likely has been as positive as ours.

[@oldageisdumb]

@@Stressless2023 I’m glad you have had a good experience but they are known to be poor quality vehicles. Look at almost any report by experts.

[@Stressless2023]

@@oldageisdumb "Experts" are not "owners" - And accusing people of not making good choices by purchasing things that you don't agree with is silly, especially a millionaire TV personality who can afford what she wants - Apparently judge Milian liked her Pacifica as do my wife and I, it has not been unreliable or poor quality. Try not to repeat nonsense that you heard or read without any personal experience.

[@oldageisdumb]

@@Stressless2023 It’s not something “I don’t agree with” lol It’s stats

[@SL-rh9og]

When she asked what makes you a mechanic!? I would have used her excuse " i come from afamily of mechanics"

[@drewizkoollikeicecre]

I agree with the judge, never seen someone have that much trouble with a pretty easy parking job.

[@familytv9585]

I’m invested!!! Haha he needs his own show!!!😅😅😅😂😂😂

[@tmotytmoty2]

This video should be titled - Back it up, back it in, the legal woes are about to begin!

[@nellesmith7184]

"You think everyone has to do a 40 point turn!?" And Douglas face 😅😅

[@adventuresconjuan]

The defendant did it😂😂😂😂😂

[@kycutecool5891]

What a mess of a testimony 🤣

[@rashidax432]

He said, " Heart is crying"😂 The way he says he HAS to back in, sounds like he's trying to justify the accident. Accidents happen.....own up, take car of it, n move on

[@markbrandon7359]

It would be much easier backing into that spot

[@paulthomas8066]

This case is intriguing. I found myself in alignment with Judge Marilyn as she adeptly questioned the plaintiff's supposed expertise in assessing damage. Initially, the defendant vehemently denied any involvement in damaging the plaintiff's car, offering responses like 'No damage' when evidence suggested otherwise. It seemed he was attempting to imply that any damage predated the incident. However, his stance shifted when the judge probed further during cross-examination. Despite the defendant's attempts to deflect, the inconsistencies in his testimony became apparent. While the video evidence provided some insight, its brevity made it difficult to ascertain the full extent of the situation. Judge Marilyn's emphasis on the preponderance of evidence, what is most likely, guided her decision-making. As the defendant's testimony unraveled under scrutiny, it became clear that his initial denials were at odds with the facts, ultimately leading to a ruling in favor of the plaintiff.

[@maryserrato1024]

Good judgement

[@RaiokIncaris]

I passed out while KZbin was playing these, and this one woke me up right in the middle, all because this guy couldn't figure out how to park his car 😂

[@keeper6458]

" You cannot go like this and go like that!" 😂😂

[@Ellie80681]

Why say sorry if you didn’t hit him ? 😂

[@kimt8795]

Mr. Lewinsky's heart is crying😅

[@findioyinthenow]

They've used this title over and over and over

[@navynick7307]

He’s back & forth, hahaha

[@Germinate16]

This dude will keep his license until he's in his 90s and the state wont care.

[@ScanMan1967]

The defendant was lying thru his teeth. He was way over animated telling his BS story. Never believed it for a second.

[@loveyoutube2177]

That van is too big for that old guy. He shouldn’t have a license anymore. He aged out.

[@pinkbuttercup2023]

He sounds like Count Dracula! Old liar 😂

[@izibear4462]

My heart is crying? 😂😂😂

[@elwyn5150]

The defendant's attempt to park was atrocious. What was he thinking?

[@soghetto666]

Judge Milian drives a Chrysler?!!?

[@Stressless2023]

Shocked me too - Chrysler Pacifica's are nice vans but I didn't expect a millionaire TV judge with no small children to drive one 😂

[@stratfordbaby]

Gives new meaning to PULL UP TO THE BUMPER by Grace Jones.

[@saronmalloy6074]

😂😂😂😂 the defendant

[@frankgiuliano380]

what is wrong with the defendant!!! the tape is so clear. admit it already!

[@maryannegunter115]

I love the sound of plaintiff's voice; it's pleasing to hear, sexy too.

[@claudiachavez5820]

Im listening to this case i swear when the plaintiff was announced i heard his last name as "cut him off" 0:02

[@sparkie7]

nowadays, there's cameras everywhere so if ur someone who tends to stretch the truth, ur better think twice before leaning on ur habitual, quick tongue to get u out of trouble. the truth isnt always convenient but it exudes integrity, which the defendant obviously lacks.

[@keithkemp3008]

🤣🤣🤣Goor try but you hit him !!!

[@stephanied8388]

Wait judge MM drives a Pacifica? Somehow I expected a ferrari or something!

[@sailorminaa]

Honestly? I was rooting for the defendant because his accent was so entertaining LOL not sure if he’s Greek but his accent reminded me of the dad from My Big Fat Greek Wedding 😂

[@stratfordbaby]

Two of the Chosen in court.

[@musicalme27]

Do you have a problem? When the litigants are POC, do you say two brothas in court? Two amigos in court? Or you're just a bigoted anti-semite.

[@cutemsladybug]

* blink * * blink * 👀 JM: " *i* drive a Pacifica! they aren't that high." i'm trying to picture JM drivin around miami and hialeah in a frickin minivan💀🤯

[@lorirogers9304]

Plaintiff’s getting a taste of living and driving in Florida 😂

[@zenobiachapman1636]

It appears he is trying to straighten up

[@meadow8787]

His poor crying heart 🥲😋

[@jncuttie]

Holy hell that was painful to be watch

[@renelopez2726]

You have to heart, if you lied. 😊

[@scotthewitt258]

Also, Judge Judy would have been "concerned" that the video had time jumps. Why not present the full video?!?!?

[@200xMarcus]

Almost sounds like bad Arnold schwarzenegger.

[@Spac3_Gh05t]

This case proves that 5,5in is something really big in the right eyes.

[@Manihsi]

I just keep fast forwarding the video to avoid listening to the defendant.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

Time to gang up the keys, gramps.

[@zoeg7985]

Oh my goodness the defendant ha

[@BobBlumenfeld]

This defendant seems to switch between positive and negative answers to the same question a lot. Is it a language issue with him? For instance, when he said there was "no damage" to his bumper, I think he meant "no NEW damage," but he never re-articulated it that way to the judge and she took his words at face value.

[@arianefr78]

The defendant is so irritating, he just can't stick to his own story, even when he is watching the video, he doesn't know how to drive, OMG just shut up and accept responsibility...

[@QS0924]

JP never want to pay.

[@jerrypearce5920]

Good job

[@ugoddessthepoet]

Steel on steel.... 🙄🙄🙄 bumpers on these new cars are made out of plastic Marilyn.

[@deloresgutierrez8964]

There is no proof that he hot the car. I hope the plaintiff don't get remors in the future. Could be his dad ....

[@alfreddavis9116]

The defendant talks too much and is saying nothing.

[@oldageisdumb]

She drives a Pacifica? I’ve just lost confidence in her judgement.

[@toaugiewitluv3197]

Painful and my heart is crying 😢

[@JayseGreene]

I think it would have been prudent to have a Russian-speaking interpreter present. The defendant didn't understand.

[@jenniferbart3060]

He understood perfectly he’s just playing dumb.

[@alfredpettit7230]

She's much more fair than Judge Judy.

[@aaronhollowell5788]

It was probably the guys friend that did it!

[@user-hs1zr6mc5d]

First time in people court history judge let's a litigant ramble that long with no interruptions like the defendant did starting out.

[@stratfordbaby]

That last space in the parking is the bish spot. Because of the wall and the post, you can't turn a vehicle in there head first, it will hit on the sides of the car. You have to reverse in, but really, you need to actually be coming all the way down the driveway in reverse.

[@kyleemon1852]

Why would the plaintiff not v show the video before. Court to not have a case lol

[@ryans413]

The guy can’t drive simple