Band Teacher Reacts to Band-Maid Puzzle

[@bobcieslinski]

Man these ladies can rock! What did you think about this one? Buy Band-Maid Music: apple.co/44d2Nvh More Band-Maid Reactions: bit.ly/Band-Maid Top Reaction Videos: bit.ly/TopReactions Buy Apple Music Subscription Here: apple.co/3xl0Ey6 Click Here to watch more Reaction videos: bit.ly/ReactionVideoPlaylist Just click the link below to enter your name and email address to be entered in the prize giveaway. bobcieslinski.ck.page/100kgiv... Giveaway runs from April 22, 2023 to May 13, 2023

[@GaryHolloway-810]

When you give it your all & leave nothing behind to achieve something you love doing then you can't ask anymore of yourself. BAND-MAID do that with every song & performance :)

[@jkkansasband7056]

Mincho chugged thru those final shows last year when she wasn't feeling so well. She literally gave it all and persevered for us. Add that to the list of Mincho mantras. 🥰

[@TomClark-Futoura]

Excellent comment! You should write for the Coronation! 📜😂

[@jkkansasband7056]

@@TomClark-Futoura Gary handed in his essay but was rejected again for the line "I'll wait for the coronation for William and Kate. Thank you." 🤣

[@GaryHolloway-810]

​@@jkkansasband7056Yes she did. And a big shout out to her guitar tech who helped her.🤗

[@GaryHolloway-810]

Guys please don't mention the coronation ever again. Tomorrow the whole country will grind to a halt as millions watch on TV & line the streets to see 2 ridiculously rich people trundle past in a carriage back to buckingham palace to dine on phoenix eggs & ground unicorn soup....🤔Tho if i could get some drone footage thru their bedroom window i'll make a killing selling it to the press.😁

[@Davey-Boyd]

Great reaction Bob, thank you. It's not a new song though, it's from their 2017 album "Just Bring It". Often considered by the fanbase as one of their finest tracks this is it's first official video release. The only "Puzzle" is why it took so long! In my humble opinion I think it's a masterpiece of construction and execution!

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Davey! No matter what this song is incredible. Wow!

[@tonygriffin_]

I've been enjoying daily sound and vision baths since my DVD of this concert arrived last week. Although there's a lot of shots of Akane on the DVD, they tend not to last very long, whereas the cameras will linger on everyone out front for longer. I get that the drummer is in the hardest position to film but why no-one has ever used a straight overhead cam is a...well, puzzle! Love Miku's vocal harmonies over Saiki's strong lead vocal and the continous building to crescendos. That last burst into double time is a fine display of just why Akane is the band leader and the engine that sets the pace. There's some shots on the DVD of Akane's trainers/sneakers, and they don't have any laces in them - and also some glimpses of her double foot pedals...and her inevitable smiles!

[@bobcieslinski]

Hey Tony! She’s a beast bavk there just laying down some awesome time and fills. I think a lot of drummers don’t get the recognition they deserve. These ladies sure can rock. Wow!

[@tonygriffin_]

@@bobcieslinski We can see how much you love them already and your analyses help us appreciate their skills in composition, playing, singing and perfecting their performances both individually and as a perfectly balaned cohesive band.

[@bobcieslinski]

@@tonygriffin_ thanks Tony!

[@russellpotter7294]

I have tried over the years to work out why Band Maid have such repeatability. Puzzle isn't a new song but every time they play a song it feels invigorated and sparkling and shiny. So we have band who haven't had an easy time but have kept together and grown together. In the beginning Miku held a guitar like a crutch. She had no idea or great desire to learn how to play properly let alone well. Then Kanami wanted her to learn and take some of the pressure in live gigs and Miku took on the mantle and is now a good rhythm guitarist. But the reason it works in each and every song is that not one part or one member of the band tries to over do it. They do enough to make the song just work brilliantly, they combine so well and each play of a song is another chance to shine. Over the years I have heard great bands and songs. Band Maid are just up there with the very best for me.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Russell! Great points and info!

[@lewissmith4123]

Thanks for checking out more Band Maid Bob ! Kanami's hardest working song imo, she never stops.

[@bobcieslinski]

Hey Lewis! Thanks man! They are all so good. Incredible group and music.

[@edwardallen4051]

Puzzle is a relatively old song from Just Bring It (2017) but it's one that a lot of us have been desperately wanting an official live performance for. Absolute top song in everyway in which Miku now plays an increased role due to her always improving guitar skills to go with her fantastic backing vocals.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Edward! This song was incredible and oh my can these ladies rock.

[@freewheeler2go]

This is a special song to me! The collective talent in this whole group is really awesome! Quite impressive. And the synergy between the five of them is something I have rarely seen. Thank for supporting the Maids!! 🔥

[@bobcieslinski]

These ladies are amazing musicians. I love what they can do.

[@Bekka_Noyb]

Puzzle is a tour de force masterpiece! ♥

[@美津江-m2c]

カナミは天才作曲家

[@themcusbleedingedge]

Hey great reaction Bob, Puzzle is a dope song. Enjoyed watching you enjoy it.

[@bobcieslinski]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks!

[@Slippy6582]

For me personally, the best song that was written EVER! Just Mozart or Beethoven are at that level... Just my opinion, i love the variety of this song so much!

[@bobcieslinski]

It is pretty awesome Michael!

[@cnordegren]

Sir! You will have a WHOLE library of reacting to Band-Maid! There are at least 50 songs, in addition to future albums, that you will be reacting to.

[@bobcieslinski]

Yep wish I had all day every day but I am a full time band director. I try my best.

[@cnordegren]

​@@bobcieslinski go at your own pace. We will eagerly wait for your reaction. As of this writing there is this WHOLE album called Unleash you will be reacting to.

[@Prober61]

This version is new but there is an acoustic version that is brilliant.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks!

[@jamesgodwin868]

I think I read comments that this song was intended to be an instrumental,but Saiki wanted lyrics written for it. I'm not sure if she or Miku wrote them. This mv is so much better than the original one they released a while back.

[@interstellardave]

You might be thinking of “Play”. That was played live as an instrumental but showed up on the album with lyrics, per Saikis’ request.

[@jamesgodwin868]

@@interstellardave Oh yeah,you're right. Thanks

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks for thr info James!

[@jamesgodwin868]

@@bobcieslinski Sorry,I confused the song with,Play,another great song by them.

[@jkkansasband7056]

I'm sure you can you understand why BAND-MAID are my favorite Rock band bar none? Puzzle is a fan favorite especially the acoustic version with Saiki and Mincho. Totally different vibe and emotional as all hell. I'm tearing as I'm writing this. Thanks Bob and have a Hunky Dory Day. Peace.

[@tcntad87]

I dont think anyone actually know how talented and well tuned these superb women are. They set new levels each time and their unplugged songs are beatiful

[@GaryHolloway-810]

Jk Add to Puzzle acoustic the haunting harmonies of Mincho & it is a thing of beauty indeed :)

[@jkkansasband7056]

@@GaryHolloway-810 Without doubt. 😥🥰

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks for thr great comments. I can see why it’s your favorite. These ladies are amazing! You have an awesome weekend!

[@RahimRahmat]

Hey hey, someone else also has the same opinion as me!!! Miku and Kanami's guitars shine. Saiki and Miku's vocals shine. However, it is Akane and MISA that actually makes this song as epic as it is!!

[@1RacerXer]

I agree! Best rhythm section in rock! 😎🤘

[@bobcieslinski]

You are so right Rahim.

[@TomClark-Futoura]

How these tiny darlings can blast the pants off gnarly 200lb. guys while bringing them to tears at the same time is an incredible thing to behold! So it's a complete Puzzle why the entire rock world aren't "YET" crazed Band-Maid Fans! Is there NO God? 🎀🤪🤘Thx, 10-Bob!

[@GaryHolloway-810]

Well i'm only 160lb & i don't cry i just get moist lachrymal glands. Other than that you're spot on.🥲👍

[@TomClark-Futoura]

@@GaryHolloway-810 I hate to say it but... lacrimal secretions are tears. But hey, moisture works too, you big softy. I won't tell anyone. 🤐

[@surfingasongwave]

and then sweetly ask "Are you enjoy?"

[@TomClark-Futoura]

@@surfingasongwave And then her sweet voice goes all drill sergeant, "No, no, no. Big voice now. ARE YOU ENJOY!!" And the hall booms out like a miltary battle cry: "YEAHHHHH!!!" And now our "sweet" little pigeon is happy. 🕊

[@bobcieslinski]

Nice comments here Tom. Completely right too.

[@theohof2204]

I have to confess that this formidable song had disappeared from my radar. The ladies have such an extensive songbook by now that one has to make choices. That's why I'm so glad they brought this brilliant wall of Rock sound back to the stage again. And then - did you hear those vocals? Miku and Saiki are interacting in a really breathtaking way - what a duo.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Theo for thr info and thoughts.

[@Parker--]

After over a decade of cynicism towards new music, a year and a half ago I discovered Band-Maid and they made me love music again. After this many reactions, I don’t need to explain to you why.😊

[@bobcieslinski]

These ladies can do that for people. They are incredible and so fun to listen to. Thanks Parker!

[@ShikataGaNai100]

Saiki and Miku bringing dramatic vocals. And, Miku gets a riff for a change. There is no doubt that they are the best live rock band on the planet at this point in time; maybe ever.

[@bobcieslinski]

I have to agree with you. Great comments.

[@ShikataGaNai100]

@@bobcieslinski Anyone can sing a song; a true pro can "sell" a song to an audience, leaving them forever changed. That is the difference with BAND-MAID...and also with SCANDAL (Japan).

[@etoineschrdlu9382]

When Band-Maid rocks like this, you just have to listen to it over and over: there's so much going on! Misa on bass is is providing her usual spot-on foundation along with her funk-jazz flourishes, Miku is providing that dirty 'Brown Sound" while providing deliciously sweet backing vocals. Saiki is at her impassioned best. Akane is doing what Akane does: play games with the rhythm, keeping it beyond fresh. And then there's Kanami: always changing up that backing rhythm part behind Saiki in between those incendiary solos! There's never a dull moment and you'll swear Kanami is camouflaging some really interesting bits behind the vocals. Band-Maid performs songs you never tire of hearing.

[@bobcieslinski]

Well said on everything here Etoine.

[@Glenner7]

Band-Maid deserves all the accolades they get.

[@GeographRick]

I saw them twice last fall and will see them again in Nashville. Their live shows are incredible. Plus, they are just so likable and connect with the fans in the crowd.

[@bobcieslinski]

Nice you are lucky. Enjoy!

[@claymore2of9]

puzzle is an old song they rarely play these days. However kanami has been reworking this and some other of their older songs due to the improvement by Miku on guitar, this improvement has meant Kanami has been able to allow Miku to take more of the rhythm that the lead guitar had been playing this has allowed kanami to be a lot more busy playing with her lead parts.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Gordon for the awesome info.

[@johndoeman252]

This is the music they composed shortly after getting full control of their music from their original label. With the YOLO EP and Just Bring It album, the Maids immediately sent notice that they were the real deal and were going to be their own high-level rock band. They'd always been good, even great at times, but when they could do whatever they wanted - wow, they immediately set a higher bar and become one of the best bands on the planet. And now...a strong case can be made they are the best act out there.

[@wave8359]

agreed !

[@bobcieslinski]

Great thoughts here John.

[@greylocke100]

As Miku's skill has increased, her parts keep getting modified to take more of the load off of Kanami. And Miku's sound has been greatly modified. Earlier in the band's history, Miku's pedal board was a volume pedal, a drop pedal, a tuner, an overdrive and a distortion. Now she runs a Line 6 Helix Floor Model to replace the 7 pedals she had gotten up to as she has also had a chorus and reverb added that you can hear, plus I think she also has used a flanger setting in a few songs, but I'm not entirely sure. But she IS taking some of the load of Kanami, to allow her to become virtuosic.

[@wave8359]

Thanks for the interesting tech info !

[@bobcieslinski]

Nice thanks for thr great info here Greylocke.

[@frankandre4385]

They truly have an insane work ethic. It is a joy to behold ! They constantly inspire us to be better at whatever we have a passion for...and even mundane things !

[@Kevin6059]

💯

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Frank! You can tell how hard they’ve worked. It’s not luck or an accident.

[@RobinC63]

Great reaction Bob, hope you are well. This song embodies a lot that endears me to Band-Maid. As you mentioned, the individual talent is amazing and then they just mesh so well. I love how Kanami and the rest of the band construct their songs. They can have 2 or even 3 of them playing something that is busy but it never interferes with the flow of the music. It would be easy to have the song sound messy with that much going on but everything they do serves the song. For them the collective is more important than the individual. This is not an easy song to sing as the phrasing can make it easy for the lead singer to run out of air and I congratulate Saike for her performance. Side note, you did get all their names correct (and we won’t worry about Japanese pronunciation 😊😊). Have a great weekend.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks so much Robin. Great comments and you have an awesome week!

[@Charles-ce7ev]

The thing that has always ( four years now ) amazed me about the Maids is how every ones part of every song is incredible. But even more how all these incredible parts come together and sync perfectly. That alone would make this one of the best bands ever. But of course they are so much more.

[@bobcieslinski]

You are right in all points Charles.

[@phaeron]

Take just one of these ladies out of the formula that results in Band-Maid, and this brilliant puzzle just doesn't make a perfect picture anymore. 🤘🏻❤‍🔥 _____________________ 「 _"Our rock never dies ever. Forever!"_ 」 - from *BAND-MAID* - 'Manners' 🎶🕊

[@bobcieslinski]

Nice one Phaeron.

[@stealthcabbie1336]

Band-Maid. Talent for "Miles and miles.". yet No Ego. That's why they are where they are (and rising). Band-Maid are one of these bands that we 35+ have been searching for.

[@bobcieslinski]

I love the fact there are no egos. That always drives me nuts when artists have those egos.

[@haggaisimon7748]

I still prefer Studio Coast 2017 version of Puzzle. Not by far, I’d say this version 100% then Coast is 115%.

[@kent-oveprestberg3578]

Imo the #1 song written by them. Secret MY Lips as a close second. Band-Maid is my life elixir.

[@bobcieslinski]

I can see why. All of their songs are so good.

[@Kenji_Onoda]

As you said, every member of this band has an extraordinary sense of rhythm and never loses sight of the frequent changes in tempo and beat.

[@bobcieslinski]

They are amazing!

[@Kevin6059]

One thing that's not puzzling is why we all love Band-Maid!!

[@bobcieslinski]

So true Kevin!

[@edwardmcalister8743]

There is something special about the sum of Band-Maid's parts. If any one of them were not a part, it would not be the same. These five polite, soft-spoken, almost delicate angels, come on stage, bow, say hello, then MELT YOUR FACE OFF. I saw them a few months ago, and seeing them again in 6 days. Thank you ladies, you made music real again.

[@bobcieslinski]

Wow Edward you are so lucky man. I wish I could see them. They are so far away and I’m still in school teaching right now. It’s nice to hear that they act that way. They gave me that vibe just watching their videos. I love when someone acts humble.

[@edwardmcalister8743]

@@bobcieslinski Ok I've seen them twice now. Let me try to describe the experience. From the moment they walk on stage you can feel the love flowing,,, both ways. From the band to the audience, and from the audience to the band. It's just nothing I've ever witnessed before. The ladies give their all to perform each song with every bit of skill and energy they own, EVERY song. The audience expresses their gratitude with all they have and so the love goes both ways. I'm an older dude and I've been to countless concerts. Never have I been so enthralled with a band like I am with these fantastic, talented, polite, gifted, demure, humble, beautiful ladies. Bob, I don't know where you are, but if you ever, EVER, get the chance to see them, even if you have to travel, do it, do it. You will not regret.

[@bobcieslinski]

@@edwardmcalister8743 thanks for the info Edward. You are really making me want to go see them somewhere. Thanks!

[@miqoto]

Love this band sooo much 🥰

[@bobcieslinski]

I have fallen in love with them too. They can just all out rock.

[@makmiskell3733]

Thanks Bob! That was great!

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks so much Mak!

[@makmiskell3733]

@@bobcieslinski My pleasure. My son and I get to see them in Denver This Aug. Excited To see them in person. 15 min. away. Have a great day!

[@bobcieslinski]

@@makmiskell3733 wow you are so lucky

[@kennogawa6638]

Band-Maid is back this month and in August on their 10th anniversary US tour.

[@bobcieslinski]

I know ken. I was disappointed that they were playing far away from me. I'm hoping they come closer eventually.

[@Greish-esquire]

😁

[@zabriabubakar5982]

Bro, after checking LOVEBITES and BAND-MAID, check also another TOP J-Rock/Metal Bands NEMOPHILA(all female) new songs Rise, Seize The Fate, Revive, Dissension, Raitei, and cover songs Iron Maiden, Motley Crue, KISS, AC/DC, Skid Row, Foo Fighters.. HANABIE(Japanese JINJER, all female) songs We Love Sweets, NEET GAME, Pardon Me... ASTERISM(female guitarist) songs Church, Dawn, Blaze, Gunfire, Rising Moon... ALL THIS BANDS WILL BLOWN YOUR MIND.....I ALWAYS FOLLOWS YOUR REACTIONS ON JAPANESE BANDS AND YOUR COMMENTS AS A BAND TEACHER LIKE THAT WHAT YOU WANT AS A BAND PLAYING MUSIC INSTRUMENTS...

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Zabri! I appreciate the kind words and suggestions.

[@stephenriggs8177]

Kanami fingers faster, but she says Miku strums faster. 😏

[@bobcieslinski]

Wow they are both pretty fast.

[@PaleHorseShabuShabu]

I love the guitar part; it reminds me of AC/DC’s “Thunderstruck” and “The Spirit of Radio” by Rush. Also, I love that the maids write in a way that gives Miku plenty of time to shine. A lot of rhythm guitarists historically don’t get that even if they’re doing backing vocals, but while they’re playing Miku is given just as much spotlight and importance as the other four. I love the balance between all five members. I feel the same way about Wagakki Band and Gacharic Spin in that those three groups achieve a perfect balance between all of their members.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Pale Horse for thr great info. You always have awesome comments.

[@palominokid3002]

Great reaction and comments Bob

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks so much!

[@billmcleangunsmith]

If you can find the acoustic version of this song, you will love it. It is one of the most powerful pieces of music I have ever heard. Even if you don't react to it, listen to it on your own. You'll be glad you did.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Bill! I’ll check it out.

[@kevinhardy8997]

Paintings: Mona Lisa. Sculpture: David. Music: Puzzle

[@mkoose]

Thanks Bob great reaction as always.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks so much Martin! Every song I hear of theirs is sooo good. Everyone is right that they only have great songs, no duds in the catalogue.

[@DavidMISAMISAMISACook]

MISA MISA MISA!!!!!

[@fifis677]

Kanami is THE riff lord. That title was previously held by Gary Holt, but I can't listen to Band-Maid and think otherwise.

[@bobcieslinski]

She’s a beast.

[@guygourley2411]

Probably still a bit early for you reacting to Unlucky Morpheus but I'm waiting, lol. Also, I would recommend Lonesome_Blue Body Rock kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZqXUmWN_lrJ2htE as there are some nice riffs and bass runs. :)

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Guy!

[@DaElfer]

Kanami can do bends very well. Speed well. Slides. Finger tapping. Sweep picking..... what cant she do. If she ever put a metal slide on her finder and did slide guitar im sure it would be brilliant. Bass.. drums.. rhythm guitar. Vocals. They cant miss

[@bobcieslinski]

You said it.

[@k3w1b3an5]

Love your reactions .

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks T!

[@_JimS]

With all due respect, this is not a new Band-Maid song, but a new video. "Puzzle" was released in 2017 on their "Just Bring It" album. Though we are sad when a Band-Maid song must end, at least Akane makes the end enjoyable. Thanks for supporting the Maids

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Jim! I don’t know their catalog and I saw the release of the video so I thought it was new.

[@MusicMike747]

I’m here binge watching all your Band-Maid reactions. 🎉 (Just left your Memorable review) With that in mind, I’ll let you know that there’s a very powerful acoustic version of this song. Kanami and Saiki alone. The lyrics, despite being in Japanese, hit you in a completely different way with that version, if you can find it. Just for your own listening pleasure.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks MusicMike! I appreciate you watching and thr info you gave me.

[@federerfanatic]

The amount of practicing they must do to get this good in public performances is obviously substantial.

[@bobcieslinski]

For sure.

[@bruceveary1758]

For your own, personal experience: play the accoustic live version of this son, then immediate play this rendering of the same song.

[@bobcieslinski]

I’ll check it out Bruce! Thanks!

[@mishi586]

This song has an acoustic live version. It is finished in a completely different song with the same content. Here, anger and regret are expressed, and regret and loneliness are expressed in the acoustic version. It turns out that Band-Maid is an artist.Please listen to it.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Mishi! I’ll check it out.

[@kyles5513]

They're so fn good

[@1000saburo]

Don't you go to see them in US?

[@bobcieslinski]

I haven’t seen them. They were always too far from me.

[@nhy3543]

Excellent reaction and music. Subscribed!

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks!

[@valloriaamherst7607]

Thank you for your reaction! You pretty much got the pronunciation of their names down except for Saiki, which would be sigh-key. Looking forward to the next Band-Maid reaction.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks for thr help! I’m trying to get them.

[@outwest1014]

They have no fear - They know how good they are. Tons of talent with tons of musicianship. Best Rock Band and Song writing team I have heard in years!!!

[@bobcieslinski]

They really are that good. Amazing amazing amazing.

[@wave8359]

Thanks for another great react, Bob. I always am fascinated to hear technical analysis that reveals what I would not ( as a non-musician )have sufficiently appreciated . BandMaid are clearly enough to be magnetic all on their own----but it still opens up more rewards for the ear when there is intelligent explication of the subtleties. so thanks.

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks so much for the kind words Wave I appreciate it.

[@wanderleyjesus6772]

A new suggestion: an old group, the group itself is almost 14 years old, but they renew themselves from time to time. The new lineup is doing things fantastic - they have their own music stile - Gacharic Spin - try: (latest song), , or . they are different from Band Maid and Lovebites, but good musicians (from Japan, an all female band).

[@allanalt8958]

Thanks for the reaction to the THEE BEST BAND in the world today Subbed

[@bobcieslinski]

Thanks Allan! These ladies can just all out rock. They are so much fun to listen to. I completely enjoyed it!