Barstool Pizza Review - Marcello's Pizza Grill (Hamilton Square, NJ) with Sally Slices

[@eduardochernia]

I love how confident this owner is. He is not desperate, he does not rush, he just answers and narrates when asked. He is quite my tempo.

[@hook8535]

Completely assured of himself and what he’s doing at the moment in time and what he has done. Not conflicted by social media, not conflicted by trends. Simply living a dream and following it all the way to the grave collecting memories, creating family and resources along the way. This is what life’s about truly

[@stackered]

@@hook8535 A good Sicilian, not what mafia movies make you think we are :)

[@eduardochernia]

@@hook8535 very well described. That is living life to the fullest, indeed.

[@thomasrainbow]

Very cool guy! He knows 8.1 is high as well!

[@americannightmare2109]

You enjoy men's company

[@williamjirek7534]

I love this because it gives a way for all these pizza joints to tell their story because we see 3 minutes of what generations took to create these moments

[@edwardmclaughlin719]

Ahh, just stolen recipes that the mob took and money.

[@michelleper5065]

Excellent backround music, but I will never agree to date you creep

[@lovejones72]

Yes! Exactly. Top comment.

[@SevenHunnid]

I work 12 hour shifts everyday for the rich man .. now i make money by eating food & getting high on my KZbin channel 💯

[@aschrisdecays]

took my thoughts and wrote it. agreed, something very beautiful and unique about it in those terms that deserves its moment in the spotlight.

[@jonjuko8859]

Who doesn't like Sally? Great guy. If Dave's giving that Corleone style an 8.1 and it's not for him that's got to be a must try

[@madcatter1]

He was being nice. It didnt look that good. Half baked

[@jburche2]

@@madcatter1 half baked? Didn't you hear that crunch?

[@xploration1437]

That was an 8.9

[@jenhurley6119]

Right!! Who the Fu@k is Dave, and why do we give a sh*t about what pizza he deems worthy? I'm starting to think he wouldn't know his ass from a hole in the ground.

[@DefeatLust]

@@xploration1437 Relaaaaaax, rookie. Relax

[@4soggy]

i cant imagine the rush of emotions he felt when he got that phone call, this guys the best and his family deserves all the success they can get.

[@garbjbarg6314]

No they don’t, they’re fame seeking scum

[@jessehoward8676]

Only the beeeeest!

[@Last_Tryy]

The best!!!

[@dreamz9844]

@Makula-px8fr Dave has a good size following that consistently watches and has done amazing things for businesses that he reviewed TikTok can be even more volatile than youtube for a fanbase and to promote the business but when somone notoriously going around reviewing pizzas with a fanbase that has stuck around for said amount of time it still would make u ecstatic at the opportunity to promote ur business

[@RyanZe89]

Love that this guy is getting the recognition he deserves. Very respectful kid.

[@tamathawalden2037]

Sally aint bad either !

[@supa4417]

@@DamienTheCat they know you are too stupid to run one. bad investment on their part

[@supa4417]

@@DamienTheCat no bro i dont remember it because i dont sit on the internet and stalk people I dont like so i can talk shit about them in youtube comments

[@supa4417]

@@DamienTheCat literally mad cause they have a loving family shits weird bro go to a therapist and talk out your family problems

[@ImAmexican158]

@@DamienTheCat bruh who tf cares if it’s given to them 🤣🤣🤣🤣. Get your money up not your funny up

[@Kingnickie]

The music, the family, the pizza, the restaurant what a vibe so wholesome

[@escoplayer10]

I’m pretty sure that music isn’t Italian

[@bouch2442]

@@escoplayer10 ok?

[@saullopez1154]

@@escoplayer10 you right Gianluca Grignani isn’t Italian

[@cromulon9738]

@@escoplayer10 its a remake of 'Historia entre tu dedos' but im not sure what language it is.

[@cromulon9738]

@@saullopez1154 Gianluca Grignani was born in Italy lol

[@dylanpaluzzi4514]

Sally Slices getting recognized before Dave, his ego took a hit today

[@doom453]

Well pres was in Sally's stomping ground

[@Bobcat8188]

Sally squirt?

[@quarterbackin3262]

😂😂😂

[@reptar5124]

I think it had an effect on his score too 😂

[@jacksonstiltner9795]

He is infront of his own pizza Shop my boy 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@cbrseth4388]

I’d rather see people like this who have good work ethic and passion for their craft get pushed to being viral rather than these goofy ass influencers that are 90% of the KZbin algorithm

[@phillipedwardness9591]

Amen. 90% of content these days is trash but people gobble it up

[@danielhicks1682]

Humans are coming back in style

[@David_Creyke]

💯

[@Saltfly]

Good work ethic. He was sleeping at 5 in the afternoon.

[@gaypreator8547]

When I hear “Influencers” I go blind - my eyes roll out of my sockets. 😬😬😬 cringe. Always enjoy the banter with Bar Stool

[@patrickvirgie5009]

Sal is one of my best friends. I worked here in high school and absolutely love the Manderucci's. It's truly awesome seeing him and his fam's shop get the recognition they deserve!

[@Farfetch_]

Any cool stories you can share about them they seem so nice and cool 😎

[@JordanJ01]

Now hes going downhill and bringing shame to his name. Sad.

[@Pepadew]

@@JordanJ01what happened?

[@CAPIVAN]

@@Pepadewhis frozen pizzas maybe idk

[@ThroughKinAndClan]

I can't think of a better New Jersey Italian moment than the guy that yells from the road "SALLY BOY!" and Sally's response. Love it! Would like to try this place

[@orangemountain457]

Sally Slices just wakes up and participates in a pizza review like a pro, good job! All three slices look great!!!

[@JohnC-er3rg]

Sally Slices in a Members Only jacket and a Mullet straight out of 1985…I love it!

[@sjgoff]

And he reminds me of John Cusack.

[@bobs8353]

He is the last member

[@pjmac550355]

That's not a members only jacket

[@CubsWin2012]

@@pjmac550355 Close enough. It's the same style.

[@bbtyeahright]

@@CubsWin2012 no its not, not even close

[@MiNCRUM]

I love how genuinely interested Dave is with family histories from these pizza places all around the world. It shows how much he deeply truly cares for the people and their legacies.

[@compacoffeeroasters]

I don’t have a tiktok but Sal is such a fantastic representation of hospitality and what it means to have a great restaurant in your neighborhood. I genuinely look up to sally slices for his love for his craft and while this is my first pizza review I’ve seen, I’m glad to see such a positive reaction. He’s the reason I want to visit central Jersey.

[@mark8479]

Came here with my friends a few months ago. We ordered the Corleone slices and Sally asked us how we liked it. We all told him how much we loved it! Super nice guy

[@TW_LeftyGolf]

“How’d you guys meet” I love when Dave gets a full background on the people and the place, literally makes me feel like I’m right there. Davey One Bite is so personable he masterfully works his way around a place making people feel at home, putting smiles on their faces. Great stuff.

[@JKLMcClure]

Dave occasionally is the most personable millionaire in the world. I love when he gets family stories like this too!

[@socojava]

Cocaine is a hell of a drug.

[@crizzonet]

What a wholesome family.

[@davidmckesey7119]

American dream

[@RRPounder]

You don't know what goes on behind closed doors.

[@crizzonet]

@@RRPounder I don’t care. I don’t know what weird things you do behind closed doors either, so your comment is worthless.

[@americannightmare2109]

Dude looks like he got a face transplant

[@BootyWonka]

I wanna take his sister to pound town. choo choo!

[@bb-nq5qc]

8 minutes of the real sweet life, story telling, amazing people, pizza, love and life. Thanks Dave.

[@brunojuniorst-amand5658]

When Sally’s dad talks about the need for a media push is exactly why One Bite pizza reviews and Dave Portnoy are so great for small businesses and why the One Bite Pizza Fest is a great event! Long live Dave and One Bite!

[@MTDWDE]

Sally slices is the best. Successful, humble, and puts an amazing product out that he’s proud of and cares about. Nothing but best wishes

[@dustindent7829]

Sally is awesome!! " Do you want a corner or a side?"

[@KeithWhalen11]

Dave built a sports media empire but can't balance a slice of pizza, impressive.

[@tested123]

he dropped an entire pizza on a recent one

[@KeithWhalen11]

@@tested123 That was just bad math.

[@NikeRunner210]

@@KeithWhalen11 who can’t do Fkn math? Sheesh

[@tioswift3676]

I wouldn’t say empire. He created a sports news website

[@CarianneRHixson]

@@tioswift3676 net worth is $100 mil…I’d be happy w that news website

[@MatthewBaran]

That tomato pie looks killer

[@davidmckesey7119]

You ever had it ?

[@MatthewBaran]

@@davidmckesey7119 no, but I want it

[@aviationdhuk]

Wish we had these in the UK!! Looks so damn good

[@scottf3456]

I've had it, I've had the corleone too. The tomatoe pie is great but so is the tomato pie at a half dozen places within a mile of it. The coreleon is the pie to get there. It's thinner then a scicilian and certainly not as greasy or doughy. It's a good place to get a coreleone slice too, big, they cut it in half. One slice is like 2.

[@MatthewBaran]

@@scottf3456 🤤🤤🤤

[@bernietoth]

That dad has a FANTASTIC mustache! Sally Slices seems like a great guy with fantastic parents/family. The kind of people that deserve to do well.

[@oi7917]

i love the vibes here. a tuesday evening at a pizzeria with so much backstory and love behind it. along with the music too. Sally is the most humble TT creator and owner on the internet. i am wishing the BEST for this business. hopefully one day i can try these for myself. keep up the amazing work Sally! love from california

[@adamnicholas3155]

One of my favorite reviews. Very cool when the family story gets told and Dave is open and curious to hear them tell it.

[@ebitdareadthebook1535]

Another all time review. These backstories take the reviews to another level, and it feels like the majority of them come out of NJ. Glad he took the time to let this one come together.

[@frenaris]

We fuckn LOVE Sally Slices. So glad you got out to review him. I hope nothing but success for this guy

[@adnauseam7825]

Sal is honestly one of the best social media influencers and role models. he teaches good work ethic, always has something wise and uplifting to say and lives a humble life working for the family business and taking pride in that. Hats off to him

[@Michael-NYC]

I love the way Dave melts with family history owned stores. Sentimental !

[@stevenbrassard6930]

This is what the internet is all about. Getting this guy the attention he deserves. Good stuff slices. 👏

[@robertblue3795]

One of the all-time great posts for Dave. Great characters, great music, great slices.

[@georgeskanderbeg3242]

Yup the song is amazing

[@JoeyRetro]

What a beautiful family. I love Sally Slices. I'm glad he had you try the tomato slice first. Looked killer and up your alley, Dave.

[@HonJazzz]

I’m happy to see Trenton pizza getting the recognition that it deserves!

[@masterofpain120]

Trenton makes the world takes

[@Ferrer.G]

The soundtrack could not be more perfect for this review: la solitudine + la mia storia tra le dita 🙌💝

[@lukemacca4312]

Sally following Royal protocol by waiting till Dave takes his first bite before he does, everybody knows the rules

[@ktpinnacle]

Big Day! Two biggest pizza pushers in the nation, together in one joint. And great pizza to boot.

[@cristianchavez1699]

what a legendary review.. thank you Davey, thank you Sally Slices

[@SonicCatharsis2012]

Great family. Love how Sal completely owned the moment and made the review entertaining.

[@mcfarlandbrothers2209]

glad to see sally get some appreciation seems like such a down to earth chill dude

[@jayh.8676]

I love how Dave looked genuinely embarrassed when she said “we don’t say that around here”

[@TheEmmalinexx]

Timestamp please?

[@billhutchinson4524]

@@TheEmmalinexx 806

[@gordondutch1277]

8:06

[@TheFreekill17]

I bet they are joking every italian family curse like sailors lol even the dad, "you need the bullshit for media now"

[@ABSF49]

Sal says fu*k alot in his videos

[@JoeRiollano]

This is why Dave is so popular. People person that will take time for a good story.

[@SanguineYoru]

Honestly couldn’t believe those slices didn’t end up on the ground the way Dave was handling them the entire review

[@michaelgonzales405]

To learn the owner started in Carteret Nj, and worked his way up, INSANE. Carteret is such a small town

[@billscott6819]

This is america guys. Proud, hard working immigrant families who love this country for it's opportunities. Love these videos, cheers.

[@michaelfromRhodeIsland]

Love the stories of these places almost as much as the reviews. Well done Dave.

[@jsmall1542]

When you see it’s an 8 minute video you know it’s going to be something special

[@vetoland92]

These family style reviews always get me close to tearing up. Love hearing the backstory.

[@neltimothy]

Went there while visiting family in New Jersey, Sally was an awesome guy. Super friendly and the pizza was great as well. Highly recommend Marcello's

[@danielobrien3116]

Saw this place was only 10 minutes away from work so I stopped in today to grab a quick lunch. Everyone working including Sally were super friendly and quick to help me out. 2 slices of pizza and a can of soda for 8.50. The corleone style is something else, for that alone it's worth a trip. I'll definitely be a regular from here on out.

[@eyelilrob]

That’s honestly a steal for some solid pizza and a soda.

[@boomerrawlings]

The shock in his eyes after that first bite was real.

[@bullseyetag01]

The review Ive been waiting for and it didnt disappoint. Great review.

[@Novaargh]

I have no idea why you popped up in my suggested feed a week ago, in those shorts or what ever. but i like what you do. After seeing the short for this video, i had to see the entire thing. What a lovely family these people have.

[@cirruscapo]

As a first generation American of Italian descent love the story, and of course the background music... Bravo.. My father and his family came here in 1955, he was 19 at the time. Love the story, cause it's my story...

[@supergrendel]

Only Dave is brave enough to score Jack Skellington's pizza an 8.1

[@bdwilcox]

Underappreciated comment.

[@DamienTheCat]

LOL

[@Jmitch767]

Ahaha

[@danielrichardson6054]

That’s mclovin.

[@obietrice2824]

I’m from the Trenton/Hamilton area and I love the shine our spots get💯💪🏼🍕

[@trippm102]

This place just went from busy to impossible to get pizza from now, but they definitely deserve it. Pizza looks amazing

[@nonya8080]

Met Sally today and literally one of the coolest people I ever met, definitely deserves those 8.1s!

[@MikeGreenCaps52]

My boy Sally Slices!! So happy he finally got on these reviews. A good moment!!!

[@knockitdown8798]

I always thought this episode would happen but in a way where sal is more out going and louder like his tiktok. But he was calm and very humble and showed portnoy a lot of respect and it made him look like a complete awesome person.

[@NcGolfGuy]

Been waiting for that review for a while, keep doing what your doing Dave love the content.

[@jasonmartinez8840]

Pizza 🍕 so good it left Dave speechless 😅 I can almost taste it!!! “Sally Slices everybody!!!!!”

[@alejandrogarcia3694]

the song playing the back is amazing, i grew up on the spanish version but i like the italian one too

[@1017greyboy]

What’s it called? Sounds familiar but I can’t remember the name

[@akooo-db8ev]

These two dudes may be the two most chill people, unmatched duo, would love to eat pizza with them XD

[@pempem8527]

Dave's leading the league in pie fumbles this season.

[@Mantiz85]

2022 NFL pizza review season has been tough on Dave.

[@justinb2022]

The Corleone is a 9.0+ pizza allday everyday.

[@lucasblanchard47]

Damn I want to visit a legit Italian family-owned pizza place like that someday! These smaller places are what it’s all about. Not super fancy, just damn good pizza made by great people who know exactly what they’re doing. Good reviews as always, much love from Texas!

[@jimduggan8962]

If you watch Santillo's review in Elizabeth NJ you'll see he says he's the "last of a dying breed" and its so true. I've seen so many places like this in NJ close down over the past few years. Or they get bought out by Korean's and the quality goes way downhill. One place was bought by Brazilian's but a few were bought by Korean's and now the pizza sucks.

[@stackered]

come to NJ, they are all around

[@dylanisadragon]

THE REVIEW WE HAVE ALL BEEN WAITING FOR

[@1ftsports678]

Brings a tear to my eye. Just a great American family and business.

[@davidcorvo1192]

I met marcello and hs entire family when we where just kids. Wonderful people. Great example of another high level Italian family. God bless you Marcello. Will bring my wife and my girl to feast at your shop soon.

[@baylenthedogg3242]

Can't imagine the one that's not his style but still an 8.1.... sheesh!! Must be a 9+ for us that like that style, my mouth is WATERING! LOVE the stories btw! Hope this place blows up!!

[@stackered]

he's nerfing Jersey scores, thats a 9.1 in any other state easy

[@jfcha744]

5:54 Of course Dave likes the sister more. Everyone knows the rules!

[@mchammer1982]

Mad to jump her

[@wjkrug]

That’s what he gets for the pat on the shoulder!

[@bobstoner415]

Shes beautiful, of course.

[@peterchrostowski6719]

Lmao crazy comment to make by Dave

[@brandonblack3816]

Once in a while Dave wants you to know what he really goes thru. Blessed.

[@Ty81494]

Love the energy no bad talking of other pizza places all love well respected and bet there pizza is fire

[@Buzz-yq1je]

I love that song in the beginning, I'm guessing that's the Italian version, I grew up with the Spanish version. Both are very good

[@willlazenby1050]

Great spot, great pizza, great guest, overall I score this episode an 8.7

[@garthchrist420]

Great review, even better story! That pizza looked amazing and the family was the cherry. Momma, there goes that man!!

[@Winstonsurf]

The review everyone’s been waiting for. So awesome.

[@pepeboy234]

I loved this. I love when Dave gets in with the people

[@ryanwicks7726]

So so so genuine, great people, great pizza

[@michaels4883]

That was awesome. Legit video and obviously pizza. Starting to look like NJ is better at pizza than NY.

[@TedTeddison99]

We are lol

[@fishing9733]

New Jersey knows this. It’s the rest of the country that just hears about New York pizza and how it’s the best

[@paddy6358]

Sometimes stating the obvious is necessary.

[@magician234]

Absolutely better pizza than NY. Tried both all my life and NJ is a few levels above.

[@arts.4014]

It's the toxic chemicals! :^)

[@Villaino]

Tomato style isn’t something I’d normally go for but those slices looked bomb, the second pizza as well!

[@brax0789]

I swear this is the 3rd one bite review I’ve watched, and Dave literally dropped a slice on all 3 😂

[@metaljew4456]

So the boss and I went to Marcelo’s Pizza Grill yesterday. The place was packed! Dave’s review really boosted their already fantastic business. Let me tell you: Their Tomato Pie is to die for! It’s better than great. This is a take out only place so be prepared to smash it down outside tailgate style or in the car. Either way this HOPEWELL TWP Crüe has a new favorite pizza place! Fly Eagles Fly.

[@josephfalco7418]

I think the two of you together bring sally slices to a new level. Franchise opportunities.

[@scottsmith4571]

Congrats Sal!!! Been waiting a long time for this review!

[@Miadaskate]

Nice of you to invite Andor to a One Bite review.

[@Bobcat8188]

I know I busted so hard I woke up the next morning with my blanket glued to my sack.

[@TannerDavies]

ayo?

[@tomthalon8956]

Can't stand Diego Luna but this guy is great.

[@ashbison]

Their pizza is actually super super good, it’s not a gimmick. The Corleone is like nothing I’ve ever had.

[@Miker0812]

1:00 It’s such a awesome genuine moment when the sister calls.

[@renesarti1882]

Great vibes from the music to the story n family

[@thomasthetrain3942]

Jersey once again providing great pizza and heart warming stories!!!😊

[@scoots2713]

Jersey has the most consistent pizza from north to south. New York has great pies but only in the city itself

[@americannightmare2109]

Heart warming stories? Write about it in your journal

[@ridgejordan1859]

Sally seems like such a wholesome pizza guy

[@jimbaker5110]

This is what owning a pizza shop and business is all about

[@itslaterthanyouthink87]

God bless everyone in this video, great people, great mum and pop business and great review from Portnoy

[@sydneemiller6091]

Sally is loving it, Heck yeah Dave you made his day

[@buttermepancake3613]

Personally I like a pizza with toppings. Something to taste. Something to add flavor, crunch, and color. That being said I absolutly have respect for these pizza places that have been around for decades, passed down in the family, and thier plain cheese tomato pies.

[@rogerar90]

I love how they never run out of New Jersey pizza spots

[@bdwilcox]

There's so many, I don't think you could.

[@Mantiz85]

This spot is literally like 1/2 a mile away for Delorenzo’s in Robbinsville 9.1 from Portnoy and across the street is Papas Tomatoe Pies 8.6 from Portnoy. Central Jersey is LOADED with Top notch pizza places.

[@rogerar90]

@@bdwilcox Moved out of Toms River at a young age and love watching all these

[@monkeymonkerson]

Dave sorta has different modes for every situation and he's good at all of them. I'd really like to meet him someday.

[@Spentastic]

I live in Australia and know I will never meet Dave but I appreciate what he does for small business and who he is. Such a genuine guy

[@mattjm82]

SALT OF THE EARTH ! Thank you Dave for showing these places.

[@viol8r]

Was just looking the other day for a collab between these two gods. Glad to see it

[@jeffreypogue2579]

The Corrleone is best in its class of 1 so has to be scored in the high 9s. Dave disrespected the homeland with that 8 score. Everybody knows the rules, never disrespect the boot!