Batman & Robin By Tomasi and Gleason Omnibus (2023 Edition) Overview & Comparison

[@TheComicBookHeel]

I’ve sold this book twice. 😅 and I bought it for a third time recently. I realized it’s my favorite Batman story and I’m not going to sell it anymore lol

[@NearMintCondition]

Hope you’ve been well, my brother.

[@turtleanton6539]

Oh

[@TheComicBookHeel]

@@NearMintCondition I’ve been doing great kind sir! Hope you and the family have been doing well as well (:

[@comicfilth3700]

I'm in the same boat 😅

[@robertmccauley8366]

This is my favourite Batman series ever and one of my favourite omnibuses. It reminds me of everything I was going through at the time (not all of it good) and it truly saved me. I could not stand the character of Damian, I hated him when I started the series and by the end I loved him. The silent issue had me in tears being a father myself. Peter Tomasi is the most underrated writer in comics today.

[@Carlos-xz3vi]

I’ve been reading this, and I love it. There’s so much heart in it. Love how Damian is developed in this run. I love Bruce’s personality. This omni made me order Tomasi’s Superman omni.

[@HashimWarren]

The best Damian stories.

[@joshread3740]

This run is so good man. It's just a shame that, like many of Tomasi's/Gleason's other books, it keeps getting bombarded with outside story changes that they have to react to (GLC had this problem too) to the point where it felt more like a supplementary run to more important stories. But it's oftentimes the highlight of these stories.

[@NichoMania2]

What other runs had that happen to them? All I know is the Superman run, but I only know it got cut short by the 'Bendis is Coming' stuff. I know Tomasi also worked on Superman/Wonderwoman I think...do wonder if that'll ever be collected, but did that get hit with outside story changes at the time? 🤔

[@Krypton_Ken]

@@NichoMania2 Nightwing comes to mind, I think he got RIP'D.

[@NichoMania2]

@@Krypton_Ken OH! Do you mean like during this omni? I realize Grayson prolly happened around this time...which means he faked his death and all....huh, yeah that'd be a doozy to deal with..

[@Krypton_Ken]

@@NichoMania2 No, Tomasi's Nightwing run and the Batman RIP stuff was several years earlier.

[@NichoMania2]

@@Krypton_Ken Oh wow, I didn't even know he had a Nightwing run. Was it good? [also Batman RIP is when he's already 'dead' but back in time, and Grayson has taken the cowl, right?? or is that something else?]

[@Orville-Tootenbacher]

A green lantern corps by Tomasi and Gleason omni would look great next to this and Superman

[@camerongodsey9847]

Super glad they reprinted this! Controversial, I know, but I love DC’s quantity of Bat-books

[@Flarrow-uo1vf]

@Ryan Wilson ^

[@NichoMania2]

@Ryan Wilson I think it's just controversial since other characters barely have any Omni's compared to Batman's over 20. Not even the other two of the Trinity seem to have close to the amount they put into Batman, let alone side characters people would love to see collected too, from Captain Marvel/Shazam, to Blue Beetle, or so on. Superman especially has a painfully low amount of post-crisis omni's. Besides Event omni's, or team omni's like JLA or JSA, etc, or specific heavy-hitter writer runs, like Geoff Johns and Morrison, it just seems DC's release schedule is Batman all the way down. or reprints, which is nice still. But still...hope the Man of Steel omnibus will get another chance at life.

[@NichoMania2]

@Ryan Wilson It does, absolutely. I'm not knocking them for it, it's a solid business strategy for sure, but seeing DC only cater to the fans of one of their characters, while holding back from doing the same for an entire *universe* of other ones, is definitely a sad state of affairs in my book. It'd be like if Marvel only released Spider-Man omni's and a few Avengers ones maybe. People probably would say, 'that's great and all, Spider-Man's fantastic, spectacular even...but I sure wish they collected some X-men in omni form.' That, and if you compare it to the Collected Editions office of Marvel, who directly take fan requests for omni's into account, and even team up with people like Omar here, outright changing the mappings of their books even, due to fan response, just to make the best omni the fans want.... [and will buy] It just makes DC's collected-editions office look that much worse, or atleast, lacking. It doesn't help DC's office has already got much worse PR on the fan-side of things, with tons of omnibus cancellations, moving release dates constantly, and the whole Compendiums-replacing-omni's thing... It's either an office that desperately needs more budget, isn't using it's properties to their full potential, or is just ouright mismanaged.. But idk, that last part's just speculation really.😅

[@Carlos-xz3vi]

Oh my god, can there be a DC vídeo without someone complaining about DC’s lack of this or lack of that, or some PR BS no one cares about. Just enjoy what they release and stop complaining about what they don’t.

[@Bryndor_]

It’s sad because DC has arguably better stories but they don’t take advantage of that. At least it’s much easier to collect DC omnis since there’s less of them out there.

[@mattgorsuch]

I ended up picking this up. I will put on the shelf with the Superman omnibus. My shelves are all over the place. I have 2 Ed Brubaker shelves, but his Captain America omnis are on with the Marvel books. I have a Garth Ennis shelf with Hellblazer, Preacher and the Boys. I can’t wait for more DC omnis.

[@jabezcreed]

This was the book (first printing) that made me buy an omnibus. Such a beautiful book, great story, great creators, and great run.

[@omnibusman5792]

This was an excellent overview! I've read Morrison's run, and loved it, I was never sure about getting this omni when it was available, because I thought it would be too much double dipping. U sold me Uncle Omar. The Mask Of Zorro screening got me. I have one on the way. Thank u for sharing your knowledge of this thing, we all love and enjoy. It's highly appreciated.

[@jeyepdii7174]

Nice one Omar! Having timestamps for spoilers is great specially for new readers who's starting to get into comics and doesn't want any spoilers:) More power and Godbless!

[@NastyTete]

Flew through this omnibus in a week. Frankenstein is so good lol. At the moment, my fav Batman omnibus.

[@ervingarcia874]

I love this run so much. Is probably my second favorite Batman run of all time, the first one would be Denny O'Neal and Neal Adams or Steve Englehart. The dynamic between father and son here is fantastic, the story is amazing, and made me care a lot more for Damian, he is amazing. And Peter Tomasi gets right Batman, he really gets Batman perfectly.

[@yourtube1424]

So is it just a coincidence you posted this a few days ago 👀👏🏽

[@craigcamplin9580]

Awesome! Made me love some bratty Robin! Does look good next to Supes & Son!

[@johnnyblue2430]

Glad they reprinted this, Omar... Cassandra Cain omni when?....

[@myconiusmaximus1022]

Peter Tommasi’s Batman and Robin was my favorite bat title of the new 52. I actually still have my single issues as well as the original new 52 hardcovers. I had passed on this omnibus the first time around but decided to get this reprint.

[@killerreef7397]

Would it make sense to read the first few issues in this book before reading Snyders run as you said those are pre new 52?

[@kevinvendt5948]

I have the original hardcovers of this which, ironically, I have never actually read. Guess I will have to crack them open! BTW, I organize my shelves alphabetically by character, then chronologically within each character.

[@tomtofu3352]

I organize by creators. My whole top shelf is Grant Morrison ish.

[@spencersoriano5113]

Gonna pick this up holy moly this looks amazing

[@shengcer]

Do you have any scoops if and/or when they will print OHC or omnibus for Batman and Robin eternal?

[@forsakenV12]

I am wondering the same.

[@Taryn774]

Hey Omar! Are you thinking about doing a Batman reading order part 5?

[@JoeLovesComics]

So excited to get my copy of this!

[@scottdiaz9964]

So excited my copy of Batman and robin just came in can’t wait to read it

[@pauldapoo]

I bought this early last year on ebay, cost me $260 Aus & I swore i'd never pay that amount again even though i loved this omni. Fast forward 1 year and the new printing retails for $250 here in Australia 🤣

[@mitch-TO]

Ouch. I thought $195 CAD was bad.

[@pauldapoo]

@@mitch-TO Yes most Omni's here were between $125 & $150 but have now increased to roughly $210/$250 although you can still find a bargain if you continually look.

[@Mixen9408]

Damn here i thought it was pricey that the retailers here in Denmark did increase the price with 25% o_O

[@Motivational_Flavio]

Where do you buy the omnibus here in Australia? Only reasonable prices are on Amazon from what I've found, thanks mate

[@BigOleFishy]

My ONLY gripe is that it doesn't include at the very least Inc #8, to cover the slightly important event. But besides that, it's incredible.

[@reedcoleman5657]

Do you recommend this Omnibus or the three grant Morison omnis I want to get one but not sure which one to get

[@daascia]

I don't understand why stories aren't sold in order. You have to stop reading mid book, to go to another book and read mid way in, just to go back to the original book to continue on. Are there any books where the story is complete and in order?

[@daxota_6750]

Here it is!

[@boombapdoom493]

I’m anxiously waiting for this in the 📫

[@luismonroyRealtor]

Does “Battle for the Cowl” have 8 issues? I just got this omnibus and want to read this digitally before opening up the Omni

[@John_Q]

1-10 scales and pros/cons would be great for these reviews.

[@glynstimpson]

Great video thanks very much

[@NearMintCondition]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@thomas-stilinski8149]

So far I've been trying to do it based on era

[@lennylaserdiscs]

Ordered this and can’t wait to dive into it.

[@devanbarrios9216]

This run is great and (to me) defined Damian as Robin. Gonna get this omni. Also, hope we get a second printing of the Superman Rebirth by Tomasi and Gleason omnibus in the future.

[@planet6288]

I stack my books by author. Could not imagine doing it another way🤷‍♂️

[@kombatevolve]

Looks great! Quick question. Are there knightmare batman omnibus or comics besides the single comics?

[@siniquezu]

Can you make a video on your favorite and least favorite retcons?

[@NearMintCondition]

In can try.

[@DonPancho26]

Does this include Batman and robin reborn?

[@jay_eyeiii1521]

Just ordered a copy today for 60$ One of my favorite stories

[@christianhart2159]

60$!?

[@69seanna]

Which tpb is issue 17 by Snyder in thxs

[@gqd1975]

Mine is in the mail. :)

[@ZsoltSchumacher]

Uhm... you said in the beginning that there ARE page numbers in the book... but as we can see later on, there aren't really. Without reading it, I would still say that my favorite ever Batman run is the Grant/Breyfogle run.... the lonely and dark Batman, this is the definition of the original character. All these to me are like, we have to do more Batman stories, but need to make it somehow different.

[@firewalkwithme1823]

does it double dip much with the morrison omnibus?

[@NearMintCondition]

Not at all.

[@firewalkwithme1823]

@@NearMintCondition thank you! i’m just getting into comics and it can be incredibly difficult finding stuff like that out sometimes haha. Thanks mate

[@tylerscott6640]

Hey Omar. Any idea if DC will reprint the Knightfall and Knightsend omnibuses anytime soon? Kinda strange they haven't yet.

[@NearMintCondition]

No word yet.

[@joshuatehhonguan]

Just finished reading this yesterday and didn't love it. Am currently reading the Superman run too, and Tomasi's tone is a much better fit there then with Batman. This was really unmemorable save for the silent issue. *SPOILERS* This really ran out of steam towards the end and felt like it was taking a "throw it to the wall and see what sticks" approach. Batman's "I won't bring him back, yes I will" shift was whiplash inducing, and I laughed when Glorious Godfrey showed up in the middle of a battle with Ra's, bat assassins, and yetis. It was ridiculous, and not in a good way, for me.

[@NearMintCondition]

I feel the same about Snyder’s run after issue 25. But still great art.

[@Carlos-xz3vi]

Is The Superman omni affected by too many tie in stories as well?

[@joshuatehhonguan]

@@NearMintCondition Man, Zero Year was the one that got me to give up completely on Snyder's run. I don't even know if it was supposed to be in the same continuity as Year One (which is almost sacred to me), but it messed too much with Batman's beginnings for me.

[@joshuatehhonguan]

@@Carlos-xz3vi I'm actual reading the deluxe editions, so switching back and forth between Jurgens and Tomasi's runs. There isn't much interconnected tissue, it feels like. Haven't really read too much so not sure if there's tie-ins to wider storylines.

[@nicktroisi6347]

Holy shit this looks awesome. I’m finally and currently reading the Green Lantern by Geoff Johns Omnibus’ but after I’m finished with that amazing run I’m gonna get this Omnibus. I’m not sure if I should read Batman by Grant Morrison before I get this?

[@mitch-TO]

Maybe it’s just me, but I’ve found that Morrison’s Batman didn’t age well. I was a huge fan when it was coming out (to the point of being livid when I heard some nobody named Scott Snyder would be taking over Batman in the nu52 😂). But I can hardly read it today. It’s just …….not fun.

[@cataclysmicbane9068]

This story was so good and going so strong until it was derailed by a certain event in another Batman comic book run. Damn shame. Still enjoyed it overall.

[@danieldevine1970]

I have to buy the Batman and Superman omnibus by Tomasi and Gleason

[@giuseppe9124]

Could someone please write what do I need to read before this?

[@mattthompson3371]

He suggests in the video what to read and when to read it.

[@shengcer]

Grant Morrison’s Batman omnibus vol 3, and the first 2 story arcs (court of owl and death of the family) of Snyder’s run.

[@pauldapoo]

Omar also has a Batman reading order video available

[@giuseppe9124]

@@mattthompson3371 sure, English is not my first language so I really did not fully understood.

[@giuseppe9124]

Thank you all.

[@mawinstallation6626]

Totally unrelated, but man, you should do an Avengers reading order. It is much needed in order to let our society advance and reach enlightenment...

[@mannyc19]

I bought the 7 Hard cover editions,all which were collectively cheaper and have zero gutter loss,much better !

[@onetone-b5f]

I did pass it up last time. Not this time.

[@jabezcreed]

Who arranges their bookshelves by author like a bookstore?! You have to go chronologically by title when you have comics! 😁

[@turtleanton6539]

Nice

[@Jackfromshack]

Red Hood reading order?

[@marvelboi3416]

It's no spoilers of who Damian Wayne's mom if he been raised my legendary assassins. Bruce has been heavily involved with his mom on and off through the years. Pretty much everyone know who she is by now 😂 lol. It's already been established in Son Of Batman qudrology movies in the DCAU New 52 animated films......FUN FACT: You have to start with Batman & Robin Vol. 3: Death of The Family to enjoy the Scott Snyder run of the story.

[@NearMintCondition]

I got people yelling at me for spoiling the dark phoenix. So I play it safe.

[@marvelboi3416]

@NearMintCondition Oh okay I see why you always playing it safe even when some other people already know the story from the comics and other sources of media.... Wow people still yelled at you from revealing who the Dark Phoenix was when it was clearly the same person for the start 😂 lol.

[@NearMintCondition]

I wish I was kidding lol

[@marvelboi3416]

@@NearMintCondition Oh man..... I'm enjoy your awesome channel. You really got me back into reading comics/graphic novels. I haven't been doing that for a while but now I can go back into reading the source materials that the movies haven't adapted really well. Also I have purchased my Omnibuses from Cheap Graphic Novel really appreciate the recommendation. I recently bought the first three volumes of Miles Morales plus the Spider-Verse/Spider-Geddon. I really started my collection with him and can't wait for the Secret War Omni in February..Thank you Omar!!!

[@marvelboi3416]

@@NearMintCondition But you do give out spoiler warnings and give them the options to skip ahead.

[@chitownbud4769]

👍

[@jeffjohnson7942]

Sadly I think im done buying omnibuses, so tired of them not being complete and having to jump around from different books just to piece together a story.

[@TheComicBookReport]

🦇😍🦇

[@kurumais]

why the F did they age up jon?

[@mannyc19]

LGBTQP trash is why.

[@mrawesome3915]

Bendis

[@THEBATMAN_396]

I organize my books by author last name

[@donaldallen9804]

I hate Damian, that is one character that never should have seen the light of day

[@a.a677]

Based.

[@karsher666]

U r just jealous because u r not the main character in Ducktale

[@dhmcadams662]

Man I miss young Jon and Damian....

[@TevyaSmolka]

Such a amazing run of Batman and robin that was probably the only good book from the new 52

[@zoydack]

Hi Uncanny Omar, what’s the word on DC omnibuses for 2023? There is literally nothing scheduled for release that I can see anywhere!

[@NearMintCondition]

I’ll be talking about that on Saturday. Or at least what I can talk about.

[@daxota_6750]

You said assassins like how I remember spelling it lol ass-ass-ins

[@gigaberg5717]

First