My Thoughts on Battlefield 1 (BF1 Review and BF4 Comparison)

[@joshtran3232]

Oh god the clip from 6:49 gave me the chills... 7:16 "Please stop firing" It's giving me nightmares :/

[@jumpercable5291]

Josh Tran Only in Battlefield...

[@joshtran3232]

SUPREME OVERLORD So true man

[@Dodalalal91]

Josh Tran "someone do something!!!"

[@speedweedw]

holy shit that was cool

[@chillaxer8273]

looks like halo

[@BDobbinsFTW]

yoooo had to take down that pokemon go video cus of copyright stuff ill be reuploading it eventually sry i know its outdated but it was a neat comm idea so i did it anyways

[@awesome9174]

BDobbinsFTW I'm a walrus.

[@timmaay7181]

BDobbinsFTW you are by far my favorite youtuber

[@____uncompetative]

FTW Query: I don't like Mexican

[@TheDaidai05]

Hey have you ever played rainbow six siege. I love that game and I was just curious on your thoughts on it. If you haven't played it, I highly recommend it

[@MrTrue-ge5ce]

BDobbinsFTW I want your hot dog

[@T--ml5cj]

wow 6:48 felt like the start of a e3 demo or a campaign mission so brutal

[@hit9819]

Hey beginners. If you're a medic and see some people dead and there's no danger, PULL THE NEEDLE OUT AND FUCKING REVIVE THEM HOLY SHIT AND STOP WALKING AWAY.

[@dgun13]

Alexander Blaze js not all medics carry revive needles I use anti tank grenades

[@1ElBarbero]

Alexander Blaze Ikr??? I feel like im the only one reviving my team...

[@midnightmarauder47]

Cam Newton you can't even use anti-tank grenades if you're a medic,only assault can.Plus light anti tank grenades only count for the grenade slot

[@PoisoningShadow671]

I think he meant the rifle grenades that you stick on the muzzle of the gun.

[@midnightmarauder47]

PoisoningShadow671 he probably did,but I agree with Chance Emerson,if you're playing medic you should atleast have the revive needle,theres other classes that have better weapons if you just want to shoot and blow things up,why use medic ? haha

[@oliverkim7696]

I've gotta say, Operations is some of the most fun I've very had in an FPS for a while. I'm talking about about as much fun as Halo 3 multiplayer.

[@GlaciusDreams]

I love rush too. Yeah that's weird I said the same thing about most fun since the good Halos. haha

[@bradenbourbonnais5153]

888chupacabra operations and rush are 2 different game modes

[@ZaveAres]

888chupacabra awkward...

[@OPTSXFilosoofis]

Lord Shrek no way operations is Halo 3 tier

[@oliverkim7696]

OPTSXFilosoofis really its all about perspective. H3 MLG playlist is some of the most intense stuff I've ever played, and it pumps me with adrenaline. But Battlefield 1, while not as intense, gives me the same type of adrenaline cause its so immersive. i love both games.

[@kindledorchid651]

Don't worry guys I bought more lotion. Plenty for everyone.

[@reggie948]

im not sure you brought enough

[@abc123mj13]

Shakey Subtotal yeah you might need some more.

[@gamerboy99995]

Yeah I just used up the last of it

[@movement2contact]

not all of us are mutilated, so we're good... :3

[@movement2contact]

***** wow, you hate turtlenecks THAT much, huh..?

[@chrisjames7961]

6:48 this is why this game is so great. That entire sequence looked like a moment in singleplayer where everything that you see happens no matter what but that was a live multiplayer match. The moments you see in this game just catch you offguard sometimes, ill just be looking around at how beautiful the game is or just be baffeled at everything that's happening that i lose focus and get shot in the head lol. No game has ever done what Battlefield 1 is doing right now.

[@SWAGSLASTHOPE]

I love this game cause of the Era. it is so refreshing not to see people fucking 8 miles in the sky dodging you with their exoskeleton

[@marv4167]

cod player

[@samuelwebster-holmes1213]

The Tumor have you ever played battlefield before?

[@MrChuckles105]

Not sure about 2142, but Battlefield is very much "Boots on the ground." Note that you can still dodge and do similar tricks to win gunfights, but there are no jet packs.

[@beestplayer4444]

monkChuck105 2142 is boots on the ground.

[@Hijynx87]

2142 is the perfect future combat fps. It's nothing too crazy, but it has mechs.

[@mastervidxad5883]

Well, was about to go to sleep, but BDobbinsFTW posted a new vid... Priorities.

[@WadeArchives]

Master Vidxad 58 Same lol

[@subie8769]

Master Vidxad 58 same 😅😂😂

[@DavidSAcero]

Master Vidxad 58 me too i want to sleep but can't !!!

[@provenom8435]

Master Vidxad 58 i just got back from a vacation and its like 12 oclock, i was about to go to bed but i check my phone and see that BDobbins posted. Fuck sleep

[@franklinpeguero7091]

Master Vidxad 58 facts my guy

[@tskwared667]

Holy shit that clip at 6:50

[@deriznohappehquite]

Looked like something out of Fallout 4.

[@garry8468]

How is that in any way like fallout 4? XD

[@minecraftvlogs24daysamonth81]

tskwared667 shit was like an intense movie

[@deriznohappehquite]

TooDank4Me It looks like the glowing sea.

[@DragonArtProductions]

TooDank4Me reminds me of power suits

[@solo9363]

Video games are my passion. Battlefield 1 is a game that shows what people who actually care about making a good product and collaborating to make something truly unique can do. Call of Duty: [Insert Generic Title Here] is just a sad case of dragging something that once was what everyone would line up for opening night at GameStop until 2 in the morning to pick up a copy of MW2. Now it's just a dying soul being beaten into the ground and scavenged for every last cent and shred of dignity it once had. I'm glad that in a declining world of terror and disparity there are people who share my passion and make something myself and millions of other people can truly love.

[@marv4167]

I'm sorry but no

[@boogiewoogie369]

Noah Clark I'm sorry but, YES.

[@abc123mj13]

Solo perfect. absolutely perfect

[@marv4167]

Boogie Woogie No, the Witcher is a game where passion was shown

[@abc123mj13]

Noah Clark it had good intentions. its a pity the witcher 3 played so horribly. beautiful game. terrible mechanics . could barley walk around and fighting was a bore as well as exstremly clunky. Rollin around lol

[@JJAG3]

BdobbinsFTW: "stuff I would do in real life" Jumps like a ninja while getting shot and kills two guys

[@cruxlorewolfe3312]

Sounds about right.

[@jasmont6542]

Activision's hit squad is looking for him. Of course this is like daily routine for him now.

[@PlaceboZypresse]

HP Regeneration is also something that happens IRL

[@Jeff-jr3sg]

KFC Crispy OG hardcore is coming with no hud at all

[@killerdevil980]

There's been more than 5 vids in less than a month. Please keep this up batman

[@kristoffer8740]

BF1 is the most casual battlefield game ever created. it borrows alot from battlefront like behemoths, hero classes, and the fact that it takes 5 shots from a LMG firing 8mm mauser to kill someone...

[@boogiewoogie369]

kristoffer skjordal Don't worry hard core should be coming soon. I'm a little tired of the bullet sponges too.

[@boogiewoogie369]

GhastlyCloud 775 Ok bud.......

[@michaelfox2480]

Boogie Woogie i bet you suck at the game

[@boogiewoogie369]

Michael Fox Look it up for yourself. IWIN72STANGPOWR. Xbox live gt. I'm a lvl 40. What level are u? A 10? Lmao!

[@michaelfox2480]

Boogie Woogie i am level 43 dumbass

[@levioficeland1425]

Damn dude you are just so good at articulating such non-objective ideas. It makes your videos sooooo entertaining.

[@thesneakyslothh5550]

Man your videos are great, this channel is always intertaining and i feel like im learning alot from this too. Plus you have some sick gameplay haha :)

[@pop5454]

Battlefield 1 is trash The only trash I'd keep in the house.

[@aaaleadbattery5522]

cod fanboy?

[@pop5454]

Kane Keenan read more?

[@hi7535]

Kane Keenan Read more dumb dumb.

[@robbiegarza8029]

+Tony Tonflo I know, right?

[@gorkaaustin5306]

Tony Tonflo But, you're still saying it's trash.

[@ProGamerZ3]

The ammount of effort you put into the making of this video and the ammount of content you presented in one single video is what made me subscribe to you( i rarely sub to people). Good going man. You always need to make videos with love compassion and definitely dedication. I see alot of big youtubers out there that dont(Sellouts). Anyways man i dont watch alot of gaming videos as im more so over into producing music. But keep the same energy and compassion going man.

[@ZacAttack1322]

You're like, my fav youtuber. So quick, so full of analogies, so professionals, great gameplay footage, everythings AWESOME. Keep it up!

[@diapersoft99]

BF1 has a way lower skillgap than BF4 imo. The guns have zero recoil and the aim assist is absurdly strong.

[@varcaic9170]

InSighT SyNergie yeah maybe but atleast little Billy can't watch every move I make on the minimap anymore

[@diapersoft99]

GhastlyCloud 775 What guns have recoil? The aim assist is even stronger than BF4 check it. It's even stronger than in CoD.

[@Leon-tx7dm]

Not tap firing with the SMGs and (a few)LMGs will drive your crosshair skyhigh if you hold it down. Medic guns don't have a lot of recoil because they're basically DMRs. And yes,it's dumb they put way more aim assist,but if you remove it,I feel I'm at a terrible disadvantage.

[@diapersoft99]

Does guns are so easy to control. Like seriously they feel like the SAR from BF4. There is a snap on aim assist ( auto rotation ) and there´s even aim assist when hip firing. You can‘t win any gunfight in BF1 without taking some damage cause every idiot can hit a shot with how easy the gunplay is.

[@Kjernekar]

Really? I feel BF1 is much harder so far for me. Sure I still do well, and some of it might be due to having taken a break from videogames, but overall i feel the room for fucking up is much smaller in BF1 as well as the lack of "overall supergood weapons for all classes" making it more challanging. I mean, I could rock engineer with rpg and ACE carbine in BF4 and be top 3 minimum on ALL MAPS and gamemodes because I allways had an answer ro every situation and most of the time I could just hold down my trigger on my low-recoil, low spread weapon.

[@michaelbronsky355]

7:23 "someone do something!" that shit is crazy. Imagine hearing that in combat like im taken away by the work they have done on the game i can't wait to get my hands on this game i would love to have experiences like the one in 6:48 you never get that shit with COD

[@eezz7884]

Yup..

[@erikmerrill8280]

This game is great but it needs a Naval DLC. As it stands, there is like one boat and no maps that support much Naval Combat. I'd like to see U-boats in this game and a Parcel Storm like map.

[@MrChuckles105]

Considering Naval Strike was the most hated BF4 expansion of the 5, I'm not sure many agree with you. I did get into it with this one douche on Empires edge that camped our Boat spawn and instantly torpedoed us over and over, eventually we blew him up, and again and again. But anyway, just like the planes, boats are useful for removing the Behemoth, the Dreadnought. They can also be used to flank the enemy and attack various beaches. Most likely one of the expansions will be the Asian theatre. Not sure if there were many naval battles there. On the Western Front the Germans had a minor victory over the Brits, but were too badly hurt regardless to ever venture out again.

[@prahstik]

monkChuck105 I think naval strike was one of the most liked dlcs with dragons teeth.

[@RJtheMightyStang]

monkChuck105 i want a map the involves huge naval combat? And a ship that is being boarded

[@bruh-hg3fj]

Erik Merrill yea they should give the ottomans the best naval ships too imo

[@greysonbourne]

Alright, so this comment is around 4 months old, BUT. If youve been keeping up with the DLCs, DICE has announced the remaining DLCs. The first one release was "They Shall Not Pass" which introduced the French Army. The next DLC is "In the Name of the Zarr," which will bring in the Russian Army. The last two DLCs are a Naval Warfare DLC and "Apocalypse." So, long story short, there thankfully will be a Naval Strike-esque DLC in the future.

[@journeykeen5471]

Holy shit this upload schedule is amazing, especially considering how high quality the vids are!

[@MoretanJoe]

What does the war tapes audio setting do

[@jacksonlarson6099]

Tanner Hainz Basically puts emphasis on things like gunshots, explosions, screams, etc.

[@mryoutuber6084]

it sucks ass in bf1 for some reason bf4 it was the best one but for bf1 put it to large speakers.

[@MrChuckles105]

This is not correct. War Tapes is the lowest audio quality setting, which makes things sound louder. Basically there is less difference between loud and soft sounds. Note that this is not new in BF1, it was in BF4 as well. It is just a kind name for the crappy sound quality setting, I'm not quite sure what the point is, but there you go.

[@MrChuckles105]

It does not. Read the description.

[@juliobudhai4940]

monkChuck105 it's supposed to emulate actual war tapes where audio equipment isn't the best, but it's loud as fuuuuck.

[@TheColeleon]

I am so glad you are posting again after your 2 month break, keep up the grand work

[@TheGrannMan]

Does anyone know what happened to the pokemon go video?

[@pennsylvaniaball9137]

It got removed

[@pennsylvaniaball9137]

Probably didn't like it and/or realized it was outdated.

[@OhNightfall]

Joe G copyright stuff

[@theojaquenoud419]

he just posted a comment about it, it should be at the top of the comment section. basically copyright stuff, but hell be reuploading it soon

[@aaaleadbattery5522]

dont worry it wasn't very good anyway

[@ATKieren]

SOO GLAD YOUR BACK AND MAKING VIDEOS! Love em keep it up

[@abrahamlincoln4691]

Your videos are amazing... Fact only!

[@BAMBAMii95]

Who else feels as though their day is partially being made when they get the notification for his videos? It's great to watch competent videos about games and how they impact us as consumers. Games are more than just something you pick up to slap some buttons. Good job as always!

[@hawtdawg8049]

3:35 *Sees tank and drives past it* *types to driver that tank is behind them* you see on console the tank just comes up and kills you.

[@MrChuckles105]

I sometimes wonder if PC players are worse, in median, than console. That seems counter to common intuition, but you see youtuber's vids and you're like, "Really?" I've also thought that the lack of control on a thumbstick vs a mouse leads to drastically different playstyles and tactics, as PC players can be much more efficient with their ammo. Aim Assist serves to in effect reduce the aim skill gap on console, on PC good players can get by with better frames and better mice, and a smoother hand lol.

[@poffpoff1]

The gameplay between 6:50 and 7:30 was amazing. It looked and sounded like sheer terror, great editing!

[@imahustlah3609]

I'm a simple man, I see a new Bdobbins video up I click like.

[@Yeomancactus6]

Thanks for uploading bdobbins! Really love your vids.

[@lleytonhargrove4763]

I was about to go to bed until I saw a BDobbins vid

[@benjiikahlil6083]

I'm getting such well structured, well developed opinions here and I have to thank you, I don't play these types of games, but I work at gamestop where I kind of need to have an opinion on them and this helps so much

[@zacharychapman2909]

Okay batman, we get it. You have a girlfriend.

[@hi7535]

Zachary Chapman Someone is jealous.

[@Trotskers]

Zachary Chapman Did you know he smokes weed? I always forget until he reminds me in every single fucking video he's made in the past year.

[@zacharychapman2909]

Baby_face Dude it's a fucking joke lol

[@mushmellow2769]

Jonjey Comms love ur vids

[@Trotskers]

Mushmellow Thank you sir!

[@fredxu99]

Gotta say, everyone talks about the more on-the-surface goodness of Battlefield 1, like how detailed the graphics are or how great the sound design is, but I love this review since it captures the player's emotional rollercoaster during the gameplay and focuses on that more as opposed "There's too many machine guns" or "The behemoths are too powerful" etc. Good review, convinced me to get the game once I get a PC that can run it LOL

[@Old_Man_Medina_Gaming]

Watching the footage makes me jealous

[@-Batemen]

10/10 would recommend

[@Ares_gaming_117]

blaaah45 Oah

[@Old_Man_Medina_Gaming]

Prophet Ares it looks amazing, but I cant justify the upgrade to PS4, not yet...

[@Old_Man_Medina_Gaming]

Good job TW

[@Ares_gaming_117]

Alan Medina Tru Timbo peep always goes hard in the paint lol. But also at this rate you might as well wait for the next gen after this to come out. PS4/Xbone hardware is already kinda outdated and this gen's cycle will run out relatively soon. Or u could get ps4 when ps neo comes out because ps4 will be super cheap; it's upto you.

[@adithyac1001]

i feel like i had more fun in the beta than i did with the full game. nothing really changed between the two, but for me it was really cool playing the beta. i got the game to play with my friends. at the moment, i havent had a chance to do so, but so far im just practicing playing on my own. im bad/around average at games in general, but its nice to practice. its super fun to snipe people with the mortar.

[@thatoneguy-c3497]

Should I get BF4 on pc or BF1 on pc?

[@NeutralGravity]

both

[@stgeorge4559]

Neel Kulkarni well that's a stupid question

[@themoochman3867]

I enjoy both games, but I would suggest BF1 since it has a way higher player population count than BF4. I know because I love BF4, but when ever I go to play it, there's only like 5 filled servers, and all of them are Conquest. But if you don't really care about there being a chance to be able to play a game, as opposed to knowing you'll be able to, I would suggest BF4. I love BF1, but the clips you see in this guy's videos are not the clips you'll be seeing in game. The majority of the time will most likely be repeated deaths.

[@the_dylansage]

Dude that was an awesome video! I loved your clip of trench war fare, reviving, shit exploding around you. You explained the immersion of Battlefield very well. Subscribed

[@steveozone4910]

Enjoying the game but it feels more like Battlefront than battlefield to me. I think they screwed up on the lack of weapon and gadget variety ( Google ww1 weapons if you think there wasn't a lot) sentry kits are basically hero pickups and the flying mechanics are ripped straight from the starships and Behemoths are basically walker assault.

[@fanfictionscrutinizer3875]

Steve Ozone lol ok

[@gognamm2400]

Steve Ozone lol no

[@Kjernekar]

I don't think lack of gadgets and variety warant calling it "like battlefron". Both Fifa and Rockectleague have a lack in variation on pitches, doesn't mean they are in anyway similar games by design, gameplay, pace, balance, controls, skillrequirement etc.

[@team3am149]

Where in BF1 do you see people going on 100 killstreaks with sentry kits like on Battlefront? These are balanced classes meant to provide variety, each meant to fulfill a specific function. The flying mechanics are straight out of previous Battlefield games, which is completely different from flying mechanics in Battlefront EA. Behemoths are only given to the losing team, or on second or third attempts. They are not the focus of any gamemode, unlike Walker Assault

[@satnav1980]

Steve Ozone it is pretty bad

[@OKCThunder4]

That clip around the 7 minute mark is fucking incredible. I love this game, great video

[@TheAuzze]

6:48 is the reason why I find Battlefield to be superior to call of duty

[@NFStrife]

The two minute mark was by far my favorite moment with BDobbins description of the game comparison.

[@beverson4963]

B, you should start a cult; you already have a good following.

[@1ElBarbero]

Brian Everson If Trump could make it to be nominated for the presidency, so can BDobbs... One can hope...

[@Spright91]

Your videos are seriously high quality .You deserve all the subscribers

[@justinyancey6086]

Fuck. I was about to go to sleep...

[@TunezCottage]

Hearing that BF: Bad Company 2 menu music was amazing. You're awesome BDobbinsFTW.

[@pinnacalada9448]

Hi

[@ghostirq]

That's what turned me off from this game. Maps are too open and flags are a death trap. It takes too much work just to disable a tank. BF3 was the last BF that I actually enjoyed for a while.

[@user-nc8xb8rx9w]

xxx RedBlueGiG No.

[@diegomartinez5100]

Your content is insanely entertaining man. Keep it up

[@makoshark7445]

Long time CoD and BF player. I'm really enjoying BF1 lots of things to do to help the team where as in CoD its usually down to one thing to do B flag and in CoD you can't hardly find 1 person who plays the objs really a sad group. Getting burnt out on the cartoon graphics games like CoD has become. BF1 at times looks almost real and thats what I have always looked for, for a long time. I'm looking forward to some MWR in a few days but like you said come Friday night I'll be hanging at BF1 for my weekend gaming fix. So far I rate it at 9.4 of 10.

[@InoSense85]

I'd already bought the game, but if I hadn't that clip that starts at 6:50 definitely would have sold it for me. Great review by the way, had to watch it twice.

[@kinglos7840]

Make a video about the Nintendo switch & Titanfall 2

[@mouse2588]

@ 6:47 this scene is riveting! When the enemy gets skewered by a soldier's sword, when one soldier screams "stop shooting" or the other soldier cries out "somebody do something" right before a mortar shell hit. The visuals, visceral, the audio, awesome. It brought tears to my eyes, it was so immersive, thus, so realistic.

[@KBWrecker]

lol yea it's so authentic. That's why there are so many fully auto weapons in a WWI game. >_>

[@KBWrecker]

Exactly, uncommon would mean that not every engineer has one, for example.

[@actualcheese1313]

You completely misunderstood what he meant by "Authentic" kiddo.

[@carrottop1519]

The video we've been waiting for

[@Summer_Tea]

Sorry BDobbz. I usually agree with you but here I'm going to have to say that I could not disagree more. As a huge BF fan, I think BF1 is the worst in the franchise. I'm not sure what you're seeing, but there is no immersion or authenticity to this game at all. I especially disagree with your hatred of homogenous AR-styled weaponry and tactics. It's far more realistic for every gun to be relatively similar in utility. What it comes down to for me is how absurdly unrealistic this title is. For me, realism = fun. If an FPS wants to look realistic, I am holding them accountable for making the gameplay realistic. I cannot comprehend why someone would want fast-paced, arcadey gameplay in a realistic setting. I enjoy my arena-based shooters, and I enjoy my milsims, but why mix them? Sure, the other BF games weren't the most realistic, but they were realistic in just the right areas to make me happy, and they were unrealistic in areas that didn't bother me. BF1 just does everything to piss me off. Its pace is way too fast, the gunplay is stupid rock, paper, scissors hard counter bullshit, and all the equipment that is used is disproportional to reality. The game is a complete travesty to me. I really wanted it to be like Red Orchestra in WW1.

[@Dioxety]

Really? Most people are saying its the best Battlefield since BC2. Your the first person ive seen not like it. personally my favorite battlefield ever.

[@Summer_Tea]

Dioxety I love BC2, it's one of my faves. I think BF4 has surpassed it though. Also most of my friends who love Battlefield hate BF1 as well. I actually have found that most BF veterans hate the game for a huge variety of reasons. I think the game hit an unhappy medium where lots of different people are pissed off for lots of vastly different reasons.

[@edizcabbar3260]

you gotta be bullshitting me right now. All equipment that is used is disproportional to reality? oh so you just wanna sit in the trenches with your sniper rifle all day every day for the next 2 years. people are saying there is no variety in the game yet you are criticizing that it has too much unrealistic weapons and equipment. homogenous AR-styled game ruined bf4. if you are a recon, your job is to spot enemies from a distance and inform your team about the enemies location. if you are a support player your job is to suppress the enemy. you are not supposed to go around like a crazy mad man with ACW-R and stuff. you could literally snipe people with AR, and even with fucking PDW wtf are you talking about? and if you think tap firing is a skill, it is not. after some time, even a 3 year old kid would learn how to tap fire. this is why recoil is non-existent with most of the guns in bf4 after 2 weeks, making every automatic rifle very effective from close range to long range. "Far more realistic for every gun to be relatively similar in utility" this is the stupidest shit I have ever heard. why would you wanna use anything but ACW-R for carbine class. it literally makes every gun feel redundant and that is why 75 percent of the guns in bf4 felt boring to play with, because they either felt the same or get obliterated by any other gun in the game. if you have a machine gun your job is to suppress the enemy in medium range. if you have a smg you excel at close quarters. if you have a sniper rifle you excel at long range. they actually make every class unique yet you want more of a homogeneous play style. I mean there are no difference between G36C and Type35B-1 and AEK and MTAR and you find this realistic?

[@Summer_Tea]

Not gonna read all that, I can tell you are not after the same game experience as I am. To me, the most compelling infantry skill is the need to observe angles of exposure. This means paying extreme attention to your angles of fire and the angles you can be fired upon. BF4 does this better than any other BF game because any weapon can tap fire you to death from just about any range. There are still subtle advantages and disadvantages which I find compelling, but gun choice should not be a major factor in every firefight. But in BF1, the angles don't matter as much. You'll get killed quickly up close by assaults but they cannot reliably shoot you at mid range. LMG's will give you early warning signs with their negative spread mechanic, thus allowing you to bunny hop back into cover, and the same goes for medic rifles which need to stop and pace their shots due to the ridiculous spread they suffer from. You don't have to play a geometry game at all except against snipers, which have that stupid sweet spot mechanic. Basically, the guns just rock, paper, scissors each other. This may be a personal preference thing, but I fundamentally disagree with hard counters in any video game, ever. I despise any form of hard counter systems so much, I consider them terrible game design just because of how unfun and casual it makes a game feel to me. Again, the main skill I think a military FPS should emphasize is angles of exposure, and teamwork should be relegated towards providing more coverage on that front. I really hate teamwork in the sense of spamming RPG or MOBA styled class abilities. Actually, now that I think about it, if you like Overwatch, you'll probably like BF1. I personally hate Overwatch and the MOBA genre in its entirety, which probably explains a lot in why I hate BF1. P.S., yes homogenous weapons are more realistic. Go play Arma, Insurgency, Project Reality, and Red Orchestra. These are all milsims of various types. You know what they have in common? Extremely homogenous weapons. An SMG will beat an AR 6-7 times out of 10 up close. Vice versa at mid range. That's how it is in milsims, and that's how it is in real life. A single bullet or two from any gun will kill you. That is why the differences are far more subtle, but still important in both milsims and real life. I enjoy this far more than playing a war game dressed up as an RPG or MOBA genre. I really hate those two genres with the exception of turn-based tactics RPG's like Fire Emblem or XCOM.

[@edizcabbar3260]

Natsu observe angles? what angles? your minimap? you didnt even have to listen and see your environment to know where your enemy is. you just had to look left and there you go. you have all the information you need in a couple of seconds. And no i hate overwatch and I love bf4. but there were so much that devs needed to fix about that game. even after 3 years guns are not even balanced, and the game is full of shit like M320 airburst and FLIRs and 40X scopes and lock on rocket launchers. if the gun choice should not be a major factor in a fucking FPS game I dont know what is. you just want every gun to be OP as fuck in every scenario, making them feel redundant and literal replicas of each other. there were nothing special about sniper rifles in bf4. there were no reason to pick SV over SRR, M40 over JNG. they were all the same.

[@theojaquenoud419]

It always makes my day to see an upload from this guy. There is no better way to procrastinate that 4000 word paper due tomorrow :P

[@cloudwaves1648]

The game's autenticity is piss poor, and there's too much hud to immerse myself into it

[@MrChuckles105]

You can turn it off lol

[@cloudwaves1648]

monkChuck105 But the game is designed to be played with the hud turned on, so it's awful playing with hud turned off

[@gognamm2400]

Then why the fuck are you complain about the hud? Lol

[@cloudwaves1648]

kok namm Holy shit, how old are you?

[@DANZSEVEN4]

hardcore is the place for you man, cant wait for that

[@austinhess4967]

your so fucking underrated it's ridiculous your reviews and just everything is so God damn on point . amazing

[@ARuiz-eu3hk]

7:00-7:30 that shit look fucked up and real.

[@DatGrunt]

6:48 does that music play while you play? That's haunting...so good.

[@Personell101]

No, the music he added in from the game's prologue (everything else was in-game tho)

[@DatGrunt]

Oh well. The soldier crying for help was fucking badass.

[@MrChuckles105]

There is music that plays at certain points, particularly in Rush and Operations, some aren't into it, but it's very exciting. The feeling when you take a sector, kill all the enemies in it, and then rush forward with everyone yelling at the top of their lungs, it really doesn't get old. What's great about operations, this was something they held back from the beta, and it feels really fresh.

[@DatGrunt]

I've heard...the only thing putting me off is premium. Bought it in 3 and 4 but I got them really cheap.

[@MrChuckles105]

FollowMeInfantry I get that. I think expecting dlc to be free was naive, but I do wish they would just make the maps free, somehow. That's my main concern, that you'll have to play the new expansion for a bit, get bored of playing the same 4 maps, and then have to switch back and forth. Or that Operations won't have enough players, which already seemed to be a problem on off peak times. I do think that it will be worth it, premium is a good value.

[@jugulator95]

battlefield 2, 2142 and bad company 2 are all better

[@WadeArchives]

jugulator95 No

[@jugulator95]

ImStadoc tell me have you played any of those games because i doubt it

[@JyoungPvP]

jugulator95 cool?

[@jugulator95]

Chance Emerson have you even played the others battlefield used to be a more skill based game but ever since bfe Dice has made them for cod kids

[@ghostirq]

Where is BF3?

[@jaycordeiro5057]

Bruh your food analogys are always on point

[@stan7444]

I F*ckin love battlefield 1 my wife really hates it though lol

[@loganoates6683]

RoachClip 614 What....why? How can you hate such an amazing, immersive game?

[@FruitLoopsHD]

Your videos are so relaxing to watch

[@ZombieKillerKingHD]

Bf1 is not an authentic game. There's a ton of automatic weapons

[@boogiewoogie369]

ZombieKillerKingHD All weapons in that game were all used in the war. Some not until towards the end though.

[@landonzuchowski6029]

Automatic firearms became a thing on the late 1800s. There was a plethora of automatic weapons used during WW1 aswell.

[@ZombieKillerKingHD]

RagingGamerzNation I wouldn't care either but they claimed it would be authentic

[@PoeticWhisper]

It was authentic to the time period. People said that Bf3 and Bf4 were authentic, but it was even less authentic that Bf1. There no no guns or vehicles in this game that didn't come out before or during this war.

[@MrPhantomFury]

Ur vids get likes from me even b4 I finish watchin' 'em as I know u're always on point & the script & wordings r simply eargasmic xD

[@jaws3007]

I think BF4 is better still.

[@ibeatputtherina1v157]

Callum Docherty bruh lmao

[@nickchapman5328]

SPECTRE 182 BF1 definitely isn't as good as I thought but it is better than BF4 buy little bit

[@jaws3007]

Callum Docherty LOL Why's that?

[@jaws3007]

__INFINITY __ BF1 isn't terrible, but I prefer BF4 simply because there is more customization, like attachments, vehicle modifications etc. Also, I feel BF1 is more noob friendly than past games

[@nickchapman5328]

SPECTRE 182 that's because of the sniper bullshit as well as assault is easy not to mention the elite classes but you gotta remember this is 1918 not 2014

[@Shuki..]

dude once you put in that ominous music along with the gameplay i busted all in my pants. it was like watching a movie. pure genius what you did there.

[@Guerrilla727]

My thoughts on bf1 summed up. It killed infinite warfare.

[@osu2238]

Thanks for the awesome video! Keep them coming

[@deathitself4330]

I'm so gonna get fucking crucified for this but I don't like battlefield 1. I don't find it that fun. I enjoy battlefield 4 a hell of a lot more and no, I'm not a fanboy of modern shooters. I just can't play this for long. I want to, but I can't.

[@Makrel94]

I feel the same way.. I hate the melee combat the most, there is nothing worse in my opinion than being killed by some lockon spam f bullshit.. And because i dont support companies bullshit DLC practices i dont have acces to any of the content.. Wich should have been in the game from the very beginning.. Fuck EA and everything they stand for.. PUBG is my thing right now, play it every night with my friends and it's allways a blast to play!

[@THEsunnyinpa]

Perfectly sums up why i love battlefield, great video man

[@thedyslexicorangutan8049]

this is all BS. the game is stale and lacking enough content and too chaotic. the maps have no flow to them, it seems like the game isn't even complete yet. The graphics and the sound yes are amazing. But all in all Battlefield 1 gets a 4/10 and is easily the worst battlefield game I've played. The gunplay is just so boring and bland.

[@varcaic9170]

Camden Osborn lol

[@connorcoates2751]

Camden Osborn you do realize that WW1 was very chaotic and the battles didn't take place in places with "flow" the game is meant to be different. If you don't like it, that's fine, but don't say that someone's opinion is wrong because your opinion differs from theirs.

[@danielhunter34]

Camden Osborn #facepalm ✋

[@user-ly2ll5od1r]

Camden Osborn how in the flying fuck the game doesn't have enough content? I have over 55 hours into a game and i only unlocked 30% of the stuff. IT'S A WAR, you want it to be a colorful; fun racing tank game lookung like cod aw? Btw how the gunplay is boring when it's literally the same as bf3 or 4 or hardline, just new animations on guns etc. Jesus Christ i got aids from your stupidity

[@coryrandolph5986]

Camden Osborn thatd you opinion

[@desallis]

Thanks for this video, as a long time player of the battlefield series from 1942 onwards I wondered why I found bf1 so hard to get into and enjoy compared with the earlier ones. The instant gratification factor I have with a lot of other games was absent, I have been playing a lot of overwatch and went in with a focused team objective based overwatch mindset with set chokes and enemy paths then getting wrecked from everywhere when perhaps I should have been thinking like a paranoid DayZ player instead. Subbed!

[@Chimpathic]

Probably the most insightful battlefield 1 video I've seen to date. We'll done sir.

[@unl_zephyr_3108]

This video is absolutely A creative masterpiece. seriously. Dobbins, this is THE battlefield review!

[@EnderDude9000]

You deserve more subs. I haven't watched 1 video of yours that I haven't enjoyed.

[@dominiceugene]

You are the greatest at this. I was laughing my ass off when you broke Battlefield, Call of Duty, and Titan Fall to a hot dog and burrito. Great Stuff man I'm going to have to Subscribe.

[@devinshearer7523]

BDobbins should have more subs every video is good, edited good, great gameplay, original content, and packed full of info unlike other KZbinrs that draws out the video just to make one point so they can get over the 10 minute mark so they can squeeze more ads and try to make more money

[@devinshearer7523]

Please keep doing what you are doing I love ur videos

[@lamarharris7754]

Bro that 6:49 clip felt like a movie one of the best I've seen and the music great clip

[@dalendria]

I love BF1. I played BC2 and BF3 but am not really into FPS multiplayer. I get bored quickly. Until now. I cannot stop playing this and can see myself playing for much longer than in the past. Agree with your vid about the emotion it causes. The most intense times for me are when I find myself alone - lost my squad or everyone is dead. My heart starts pounding and I keep saying "stay alert and move, move, move but don't panic" lol. Great vid. please do more on your BF1 experiences.

[@Cranky0ldMan]

Well thought out commentary and very good visual examples used to prove your points. Great run in the fighter too. This is first class content. Love our Battlefield. Thumbs up.

[@oorah2438]

I think 6:47 shows how great of a war game this is. The visuals, the amount of people, the sound and the screaming. Hearing someone dying and yelling for someone to do something while gas, grenades, fire, constant shelling, and close quarters combat sometimes even requiring bloody hand to hand combat is all occurring.

[@lukeoehlerking8648]

I was late getting into video games, I didn't get my own video game till I was 19 and that was a ps4 with COD ghosts, I really enjoyed COD until I got Battlefeild 4, at first I didn't like it, it was different and hard but once I started to understand how to play the game and a few experienced guys showed me a few things I really started to love it, it was like the more you play it the better it got. I ended up buying Battlefeild 1 and I love it! I'm never going back to COD. You do a great job on your videos and I really enjoy them keep them coming buddy!

[@baroquegarcon]

I love ur analogy's and comparisons

[@migs8171]

im new to battlefield and i just love the variety of gameplay each match offers, every match is unique, I can see it keeping my attention for a very long time

[@marcalbert674]

That feeling when you're holed up in a trench at an objective, unoticed, waiting for all enemies to desert the point...feeling secured for a brief moment until you hear the tank engine approaching and stoping next to you...

[@andym4179]

Great take refreshingly different review and perspective on the battlefield franchise

[@qw3738]

love your videos man

[@P-DUBZduharte]

yes i was hopen you would drop a video soom great job as always

[@vicvega861]

This guy kicks ass. Love the channel, Batman.

[@gibby8879]

Talk about Titanfall 2

[@Malluc]

titanfall 2 looks fun

[@CDLightt]

+Potaishee it's great.

[@maykellguerra]

Bro I'm a new subscriber of yours and gotta say man your videos are f'ing amazing, great ideas and great execution. It'd be good if you uploaded more often though. Any ways keep doing your thang bro you are bound to get bigger than drift0r's sorry ass

[@JustGavYT]

awesome video man!! really enjoyed it

[@everettgaspar3482]

When you were talking about "the battlefield burrito" I just sit back and thought, damn this channel is great

[@MajorLeague2423]

aye man i fux witchu always got good vids and splendid commentary keep it up....

[@DreadJester448]

6:45-7:35 ish was the best way I have ever seen anyone put their point across in a video. ever.