BEAUTY FAVORITES from 4 YEARS AGO: Do I STILL Use Them? 🤔

[@JenPhelps]

Thank you so much for all of the compliments on my hair! 🥰🥰I was inspired by Blake Lively's Superbowl Hair and I took out my old 3/4" curling iron to create the tighter curls. Also, there have been a few questions about whether I've changed my hair color...this is the same color it's always been. Unfortunately, my makeup room has warm colored walls and I think that combined with the artificial lighting makes my hair look much warmer than it actually is. :)

[@embeth446]

Your hair looks great! That’s interesting I’ve actually wondered if something about your lighting makes things pull warm because for example I have some of the same eye shadow palettes as you, and I’m always amazed how much warmer certain shades look on you compared to me. We are basically the same skin tone with many of the same foundation shades. This was a fun video btw!

[@teresabyars4595]

Love your hair

[@greatsmiles]

I had the same thought as soon as I looked at her!

[@laurarivera1992]

Wow your hair! Beautiful

[@emiliebreault3425]

Oh my gosh yes ! I would love a hair tutorial. 😍

[@katydidknits]

You look absolutely gorgeous today! The lighting, the hair… it’s just really working for you!

[@silentbahamabeauty]

I would love to see this as a regular series. There were so many products that were "ride-or-die" faves back in the day that I am curious to know how they stack up today. I am mostly interested in knowing dupes for products that have been discontinued or were limited edition releases. Loving the natural lighting on-the-floor throwback!

[@libena1973]

100% agree.

[@VanessaJuliet-ty1sk]

I love this idea! And how you even made it extra special with the location and T-shirt. So fun. It’s also really interesting to hear your thoughts after time and what’s replaced those products. We talk so much about what’s new, it’s fun to hear about long-term favorites that are behind-the-scenes.

[@cs-yq5ed]

"Past you" and "Current you" are both lovely, Jen!

[@lynettefinnigan9540]

4yrs and doesn't look a day different ❤

[@donnakarnisky907]

Side part for the win❤

[@thcusandsunny]

Absolutely love this idea! It's always a breath of fresh (stale? 😅) air when my favourites bring back older stuff plenty of us probably still keep.

[@Trudee99]

Your hair tho- 💜🔥 I love revisiting old favorites.

[@heatherparker9820]

Your hair looks amazing! The natural light is also incredibly flattering for your skin and hair. You look amazing !!

[@emiliebreault3425]

I completely agree !

[@marianelavelasquez9696]

You are so sweet to make the effort to create everything as it was in 2019. I love your videos, super informative. Your voice is so calming. Lots of love from London ❤

[@BonaTaylor]

This Video feels like director's cut to the version from 4 yrs ago because of the self aware set up of background hair and shirt. 😅❤ love it. Great job. 👍

[@libertychic8926]

U look beautiful today, Jen! Loving the hair!!

[@bryndabaker6782]

Anyone else notice Jen doesn't seem to age at all? Things that make you go "Hmmmmm..." ;) Great video, Jen, thank you!

[@JenPhelps]

Aww thank you for saying that! 🥰🥰I was actually watching that old video and thinking I looked so much younger only 4 years ago, haha! 🤦‍♀️

[@daezeechayne462]

@@JenPhelps its weird right! Gravity is not our friend! (51 here!)

[@kaivickers166]

My vote is vampire. Like Paul Rudd.

[@kristentrep5038]

@@kaivickers166lol! That’s a good vote! And I couldn’t agree more about Jen not aging at all!

[@BrendaBostonGirl]

What a fun idea and I love how you recreated the hair style as well as wearing the same shirt. Would love if you revisited your top 5 palettes or other top 5 in other categories from past videos and which ones are still in that position or have been displaced by others.

[@susannadler9791]

I’d love to see this as a series!

[@tdsollog]

I remember the original video! I hope you do a take on a “will I buy it” type of video… looking at your older stuff as if it were being released now… so, “Would I buy it… now?” type of a video.

[@ginnyburley9552]

It’s interesting how things change over time. Between discontinued products and improvements in new products, a lot changes in 4 years!

[@jo4vt]

This would be a fun series. It made me remember that I first found you on KZbin through older videos of you sitting on the floor rating Zoeva palettes!

[@pame8872]

That is so funny that U tube recommended your old video to you!! I also love the flower beauty blush brush. This was a good video idea, A trip down memory lane

[@mariep4512]

I love seeing this comparison in products from then and now. I didn't watch you that long ago, but the CYO dupe video is how I found you 2 or so years ago.

[@MyCleverHandle]

Absolutely I still use products I was using four years ago! Number one on my list would be Olay's Gentle Foaming Cleanser. Super gentle, but it is my second wash every day. Fragrance free, no dyes, lathers up just enough without stripping my skin, still cheap! And of course Maybelline's Expert Eyes Brow pencil, the old red wooden ones sold two on a blister pack card. The Blonde color and the formula just can't be beat. That's been my go-to for over twenty years, sometimes in combination with other brow products to add a slightly different tone and more depth of color. And Maybelline's Dream Fresh BB Cream makes a great base under a light dusting of Bare Minerals OG loose mineral powder foundation. This combo has also been with me for over twenty years. Love the video Jen!

[@20thcenturyrelic]

Ooh, I also love the Olay Gentle Cleanser and the Maybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream! Although I switched to Vanicream cleanser because I prefer to do 1 cleanse, and the Vanicream removes my makeup with just 1 cleanser.

[@katherinekelly9689]

Hi Jen, I enjoyed watching this video, yes please on making this kind of video a series. It’s interesting to look back at one self,& the changes we make or products we continue to use. Love Katherine xoxo

[@Seoulsearch616]

Jen, you're always beautiful but my goodness, you look gorgeous here! You are giving much-needed summer-look vibes! 🥰🌹❤️

[@jenniferw392]

I really appreciate the variety of video content you create! You always stay true to yourself, which is why I find you trustworthy, but your content doesn’t get stale, at least for me! I’m sure maintaining that creativity is more challenging than it seems, but your work is not unnoticed!

[@JenPhelps]

Aw thank you so much for saying this! I have to admit I've been questioning myself lately because my views have been down the past few weeks and I can't figure out why. But it's good to know that my content is being enjoyed..maybe it's just a weird algorithm thing. 🤔❤️

[@RitaVernoy]

Just starting the video, but your hair and skin is perfection!😊

[@lawwife2005]

Yes, I love it when creators revisit their old favorites lists, whether a monthly version or annual favorites.

[@MusicLover-sb7mo]

Super fun idea. Loved how you still have the gray T-shirt and that you recreated your hairstyle, shot the video in your hallway and edited in clips from the original video. Clever! The only product I still use from 4 years ago is ABH Brow Wiz. But I have been trying some dupes. Otherwise I am constantly exploring skincare, hair products and makeup. I have more of everything than ever before in my life. I keep putting myself on probation as I don’t need a thing and need to focus on using up what I have.😊

[@katfayegarrett3872]

Make it a series ❤

[@grespinosa]

she looks unrecognizable 4 years ago! How interesting some products stood the test of time! 👍🎉

[@mochacola72]

You look beautiful Jen🎉

[@lynnctodd]

You look gorgeous! Love your hair! 😍

[@janicewright8139]

Yes please make it a series. I’m a new subscriber so this kind of video keeps me from missing out on your previous likes.

[@kristentrep5038]

Whoa! Time really does fly! I actually remember that video bc I loved the CYO foundation initially via Taylor Wynn, and I remember getting the soap and glory bc of that video! It was a fav! I forgot I picked up the complexion crush from Ulta!! I’m going to need to try it out tomorrow! At 51, I could use all the help I can get with my foundation. My current go-to is the covergirl one with the beads!

[@SarahHovley]

Series!!! 🎉🎉🎉

[@meitalkabeli509]

I still use the ND bronze and glow, and finally hit pan on the bronzer side. The Lancome Monsieur Big mascara is still one that I go back to, and still love the way my lashes look when using it.

[@gstang8241]

Love the side part

[@BlingyBea]

Wow Jen you look stunning🥰 I was sad when they discontinued that CYO foundation then the Soap and Glory, they were so good on my dry skin. Yup got that Ulta one you recommended and it’s a good one.

[@DaniL-hr9xo]

You look even more beautiful than usual today✨️

[@mochacola72]

I can't believe I haven't heard anything about Clinique high impact mascara. It is soooo nice. I don't wear false lashes so I'm always on the hunt for good mascara.

[@JenPhelps]

The new one or the original? I've tried the new High Impact Hi Fi and I LOVE it! I've talked about it a few times on my channel. :)

[@mochacola72]

@@JenPhelps I don't know how I missed it. I usually buy the mascara and lippies that you like.

[@kathleenmoortel5449]

I love the Flower Beauty blush brush. I heard it from Kelly Gooch. I like the brush for sheering out a more pigmented blush and I bought my brush on Amazon.

[@JenPhelps]

Yes! She's the only other person I've seen mention it but it's awesome! I noticed that in the video from 4 years ago I had purchased it from Walmart and they don't even carry Flower anymore, haha!

[@kathleenmoortel5449]

@@JenPhelpsthat hair color from 4 years ago looked so pretty on you. You pull off both hair colors really well.

[@maryrose7842]

@@JenPhelpsis that brush suitable for cream stick blusher?

[@notimportant123]

@@maryrose7842I have it and no, I wouldn't really suggest it for that. It's a little too floppy to pick up cream.

[@LauraHodos]

@@maryrose7842 I think it's a little too fluffy and flexible for cream stick 😊

[@jennyyu8674]

Can you do a tutorial on how you curled your hair? It's soooo pretty!

[@Songbird8302]

PLEASE keep doing this!! I'd LOVE seeing a video from maybe even 20-25 yrs back.

[@elcehl]

Great video🎉. I have heard the "Good Molecules" works well. I am now going to purchase, Ty Jen🥰🌷🤗.

[@cheriyost2780]

Great hair!!

[@claireplauche7724]

Aww Jen!!! Not surprised u would do this! You're the queen of the thorough review!!! U look fantastic in both videos!!💕🎉🎉

[@janetv2928]

I saw another KZbinr mention the flower blush brush and I had it in my Walmart cart, but then bought it on clearance at Marshalls for $4 back in the fall. I love it!

[@sherryjohnston725]

Would love this as a series. Great reviews Jen!

[@l.c.8798]

What a fun concept! 😄

[@idreamofparis7233]

That CYO foundation was amazing.

[@baileydubs]

I love that maxi reloaded palette! Actually good quality that applies super well and such a good variety of neutrals! Not a huge fan of giant palettes but I do really like it

[@cheyrlreynolds3]

Great video Jen! I'm 55 and trying the ulta crush foundation for the first time! I'm loving it! ❤

[@melindacochran5193]

Hi Jen..haven't changed a bit just as beautiful as ever! Loved the video, your content is always amazing!❤

[@rags3901]

Fortunately I don’t have the red lip problem with City Lips…I use it every day…every night…love it…it’s the only product that has ever solved my aging lip situation! Love your channel!😊

[@cindyb9830]

I really enjoyed this video and would love to see more like this. I purchased the City Lips when it was on sale during Christmas based on many content creator reviews, and am so disappointed in it. Not only does it burn, it makes a red outline on the rim of my lips. I may try the Lawless, it sound more comforting!😅💚

[@DMV8662]

That's unusual for City Lips...🤔 The Lawless one DEFINATELY has a tingle... I can't live without the clear City Lips.... Its the ONLY product that cures my dry chapped winter lips overnight..👍🏻

[@20thcenturyrelic]

The City Lips burn is probably from the citrus grandis (grapefruit) peel oil, cananga odorata (ylang ylang) flower oil, and citrus aurantium bergamia (bergamot) fruit oil that's in it. These are very irritating ingredients. And the Lawless product has menthoxypropanediol in it which is a synthetic derivative of menthol, and Capsicum Frutescens Fruit Extract, which is tabasco pepper extract. This product will also probably irritate your lips. Actually, since plumping lip glosses work by irritating your lips to make them look bigger, it's probably impossible to find one that won't burn, tingle, or make your lips red. If you want a moisturizing gloss at a reasonable price, Jen recently gave a favorable review to the Neutrogena Hydro Boost Lip Shine. It has no fragrance or plumping ingredients in it.

[@cindyb9830]

@@DMV8662 lucky you, I'm glad it works for you!

[@cindyb9830]

@@20thcenturyrelic Thanks for the info!

[@lindasadler6338]

Your hair does look amazing! I really need to try the Complexion Crush!

[@robinwaibel6852]

I love that Flower beauty brush so much. I have one in my regular brushes, one in my travel bag and a backup.

[@LisaMarlene.]

Your hair looks SO good, full of body…❤ It’s also nice to see you in a different setting, gosh you haven’t aged a bit!!! ❤

[@kathleenmoortel5449]

A series would be so fun 😊

[@oceanbird.]

Wow that's neat to hear the comparison between Ulta complexion crush and the cyo because I love complexion crush and I've always wondered about the cyo one since I never got to try it. I'm happy to know it's similar, and if it's similar I can see why so make people loved that cyo foundation because the complexion crush is awesome!

[@monikad.7411]

Oh my goodness! Your hair back then! I forgot all about it. Looks so pretty.

[@littlelamb3417]

Great video! Your hair four years ago though…😳 The color you have now is soooo… much better!

[@JenPhelps]

Haha back then I colored it myself. Now I actually go and have it done. 🥰

[@peggyalaniz3880]

I just bought a Flower Beauty make-up brush last week that looks just like the one you referred to at TJMaxx. I bought it to use as a blush brush..i thought it was a brush for highlighter. I loved it because it is small and i don't wind up with clown cheeks.

[@louisesharpy]

I love that you did this. And I’m loving the Blake hair. She’s so pretty.

[@amandagrace906]

Jen, you have glown up this year! ❤ everything from your eye looks to your hair. Love to see it! Also your spot on about the flower beauty blush brush. That is my absolute fav blush brush. It is magical💜completely transformed my blush application

[@lynettefinnigan9540]

Love your hair with side part and soft curl..you're looking particularly gorgeous today ❤❤❤😊

[@kristenreehil3196]

I loved Makeup Revolution's Reloaded Provocative Palette and it was a spot on dupe for Urban Decay's Naked Cherry Palette which they stopped making. Elf's Flawless Finish Foundation was my favorite four years ago and still is till this day on.

[@SharrellKline]

I'm so happy to see that there is something close to CYO -- which was my all-time favorite for texture and the absolute perfect shade match. Unfortunately, I'm retired in Mexico and can't get Ulta products unless someone visits us in the future, but I'm putting on my "if someone visits list" and will cross my fingers. I've spent so much money on products that can ship here trying to find a replacement and so far, no luck. My choices are very limited even with Amazon, but this gives me hope!

[@d.8709]

Just gotta say, You look especially beautiful today.

[@tinabratland4027]

Yes, make this a series!

[@laur83]

adore the hair and your lighting and location!! feels much more relaxed 🥰 this is a great video concept, revisiting products you used to enjoy to see how your tastes and makeup itself has come along in the time that has passed.

[@joycepestlin833]

Great video!! You look beautiful!! Never dull videos with you!!

[@christysmith9791]

Thanks for making your videos family -friendly! 😘

[@tracyfrederick5606]

I've been following you longer than 4 years. I remember ,it was during the pandemic and you did videos in different places. ❤

[@m.c.8680]

you look so so pretty today. that pink shadow is ABSOLUTELY for you !❤ Smokin',girl !!..skin hair...whole shebang. Gorgeous👏👌

[@heathernelson4886]

I use the ND Mini Bronze & Glow as eyeshadows too! The shades are too dark for my cheeks, but work great on eyes!

[@nasstasjiap]

You look sooooooooo beautiful today!!!!!!! You deserve so much more hype girl!!!! Keep up the good work!!!! We love you!!!! ❤❤❤❤

[@debedwards1717]

I have two of the Flower Beauty blush brushes, one for blush and one for powdering my under eyes.

[@user-mo3sn4ce6g]

The hair! So beautiful and flattering to your face shape! Gorg!

[@nidiadoherty5405]

This was a fun video. Always interesting to see what stands the test of time - and reminisce about products and brands that are no longer with us (RIP CYO.). Cute touch pulling the same shirt out, too.

[@leelee2925]

Woooahhh Jen looking like a blonde bombshell in this video! Love your hair. U look gorgeous as always

[@samanthahernandez6286]

Love this kind of content! Thanks!

[@lisapetitpas9476]

You look gawgeous! Love your hair too❤❤❤

[@TinaHBeautifulJourney]

You look gorgeous in this video! Thank you for the comparison of CYO Lifeproof Foundation to the Ulta Complexion Crush! I' have a tiny bit of the CYO left and I"m going to do a side-by-side comparison. I LOVED that foundation. Fun to see how your faves have changed or stayed the same.

[@Alice-fr1ef]

Hi Jen, I love the Colourpop palettes especially the large ones. I have many of the smaller ones also. I was not sure I was seeing what I saw but you look the same to me today as you did in the previous video 4 years ago. The lighting is just different but you look the very same. Thank you for a great video with some very good products. City Beauty is a very good product too. I enjoyed this video very much Jen and thank you for making it.💗❤🌺🌸💐🌹🌺

[@lorrainegreen6782]

I’m still using Timeless HA C, E & Ferulic Acid Serum. Still love it! Your hair looks really beautiful in this video.

[@ProfMary]

What a great idea for a video, Jen! It was so entertaining to see your 4 year old videos versus todays. I use your Doll 10 blush brush all the time. It is my #1 blush brush. I, too, had some of these products and can't find them anymore or have moved on.

[@Tamara-ek1uk]

Jen, when I bought the JEN PHELPS x DOLL10 brush set, I could not help but notice how the blush brush reminded me of the Flower Beauty blush brush you recommended years ago, and now I know why! I love them both (not just the brush heads, but the tapered handles), but your brush wins the beauty contest! It is such a work of art - those hand-painted lacquered handles make me swoon.

[@JenPhelps]

Aww thank you so much!! 🥰❤️

[@elizabethnelson2287]

Such a fun, unique video idea🌟Your hair is inspiring me to go out of my comfort zone for a new hair look💇🏽‍♀️Thanks for keeping up great content, appreciate all the research you do and your hard work is reflected in your videos👍🌞

[@v.blanchard6487]

Yes, I agree with all the comments. I love your hair, and you look gorgeous. 😊

[@sweetcarolineq]

What a great idea! Dressing and styling your look from your video 4 years ago, you haven’t aged! Also used the same Flower blush brush this morning!

[@libertychic8926]

Love the lawless forget the Filler! So good and been using those since they launched!

[@dianeguy7452]

I thought I was the only one using anything Arches & Halos lol. I have almost no brows--plucked in the 70’s-- and I love the brow mousse. It lays down hair like fibers then I go over with a brow pen Milani weekend brow. Perfect duo. Hey from Jersey ❤

[@Ellsped10]

L’Oréal used to have a liquid lip and cheek stain! I still have a little leftover that I use when I want a flushed look which makes me more youthful! It’s something that no other gel, powder, stick, cream blush has been able to do! Also Revlon used to have a quick dry liquid for nails that dries nail polish absolutely quickly! They discontinued and again there’s a little leftover that I use when I have to leave the house immediately after applying nail polish! I have bought from every brand you can think of but it’s not the same! I wish they would give a public notice when something would be discontinued! I would stock up! 😟😟

[@ejbooks]

What’s fun video! You look fantastic, and your hair💕! Wow! Love the whole look🌸. Can’t believe you found the T-shirt and re-created the scene from 4 years ago. Definitely getting th3 Dry Bar spray and a few other products. Thanks for such an enjoyable video. 🌸🌸

[@robynwolf3803]

Love this video! Yr hair looks amazing! Great lighting! So I also use the City Beauty multi-sculpting cream. N now I just ordered the new Advanced Purpose Sculpting Cream! I’m so excited to try it! I loved the old the formula u recommended! Been using it for almost a month. It did pill up. So excited to see the new formula. My dry skin mature skin loves it! I do like Good Molecules Brand. I also use the Drybar u use! Such a great video! I have that ND Bonzer palette! It’s great! I love the eyebrow pens too! I use the Tarte DIY Eyebrow Pen it’s so good! But, I’m going to try the drugstore option as it so much cheaper! Ty for the 2 alternatives! Doll10 is a great Brand! I luv it! Both their makeup & skincare r awesome! Also those Flawless lip items r fabulous! Ty so much for sharing this video! It was really fun to watch! I also want that blush brush u mentioned by Flower Beauty! Love the shape of it! ❤❤Another video I’m saving! U look amazing! U haven’t even aged! Still look as young as u did four years! Just as beautiful & just as youthful! So cute how u recreated the scene n even T-Shirt! Very clever! Ty Jen! ❤❤

[@gladysgarrity5721]

Thanks Jen great video ❤

[@jeanwest1058]

The hair!!! But even more impressive is that the tshirt still fits 😮❤ Oh and you don’t look like you aged at all 😊

[@JenPhelps]

Haha I love this t-shirt! It was only a couple of dollars at Old Navy but still going strong!

[@DeeDee61skin]

Thank you for doing all this work to go back to what you loved and still love now. I think im going to try the dry bar hair products! ❤

[@carolynnettles3767]

Love this video idea! I love looking back to see what products really stand the test of time. We as people change over time but this is interesting to see from someone who reviews a lot of products! Thank you for doing this! ❤