Behind the Kundali: Is there fault in our stars? | Nitin Shinde | TEDxRajarambapuIT

[@TarunMusicTv]

Such videos should get millions of views. But unfortunately in our country conmen like Jaggi Vasudev get millions of views from blind followers.

[@m.krishnanunni]

He is saying the disadvantage of astrology for truth.

[@Madara-zt8pn]

true bro. Jaggi be like= Full Moon= Water rise= Personalities 70% water= Personalities get lunatic. Lunar eclipse= Moon goes through every phase= No eating, Fasting

[@sumitk114]

What idiotic!!

[@sahebraomane669]

जबरदस्त. वैज्ञानिक दृष्टिकोन ठेवून माहिती आपल्या कडून मिळाली आहे. निदान त्या निमित्ताने का होईना काही लोकांच्या डोक्यात प्रकाश पडला असेल. मनापासून धन्यवाद. 🙏 ... साहेबराव माने. पुणे.

[@technicalutkranti]

I was searching for logical kundli explanation and no video were able to explain its logic as clearly as this video did.

[@digvijaypatil9269]

Nicely explained sir . Need more awareness against such things .

[@fitrushi]

Simply wow sir... We need more seminars like this one in all over India.. I'm very glad that you're my teacher.. Full gratitude😎😎

[@ashisharora8170]

Thank you for this talk💓

[@YPMR286]

Orion right at the South of night sky ....right now as I'm putting my gratitudes across ❤❤❤ Kudos sir ...ek pid cast sir for 100000000 hours

[@indrajeetnikam8628]

Yeah. Podcast is must I guess!

[@vijayparab6955]

फारच छान कार्यक्रम.

[@atul.jagtap]

I like it so much! Very expressive!

[@omkarbabar9638]

87 dislikes are astrologers [ kundali manufactures ]

[@nidhineeraj03]

😂👍

[@vedicspace]

one more for you 👎🏽😂

[@vijaypatilsataramaharashtr3417]

I reminded your program in when I was in ASC College Ramanandnagar ( Burli)

[@spritualbeing7673]

Logical and scientific knowledge great sir

[@rdc515]

Awesome, needs more views

[@Tuheena14]

Wow.. such a logical explanation 💯

[@Shishir27]

Astrology is nonsense

[@mayurascreation]

Really nice sir nd I am also proud of you...nd I am so lucky bcz u teaching me nd my best ideal teacher...

[@Sakura09034]

Hello can i get shinde sir’s contact no ?

[@harshalchauhan422]

What about the high tide and low tide due to change in position of moon. Why lunatic( emerged from the word Lunar) people bcome hyperactive in full moon nights. Why trees make larger circle due to solar cycle. Why these knowlesge, calculations n science was developed by ancient sages if it is so irrelevant. Aryabhat was not only a mathematician but was also an astrologer why such a logical mathematician got into astrology if its so trivial. Making fun of concepts without knowing it is easy

[@ronaknarkhede674]

Literally all your claims can't be scientifically proven, Provide me some respectable sources

[@onehtw1974]

@@ronaknarkhede674 your view on science itself is flawed. Because something cannot be proved by reason or logic doesn't mean it isn't true. One could simply be lacking the means of understanding it yet. And because something can be proved doesn't mean that it is the universal truth. A proof is made with reasonable framework of given-understandings and boundaries of known physics. Anything meta physical can simply be observed, sometimes just tangentially but not explicitly. The same reasons why most prominent minds believe in a god and the same reason why Einstein knew to work towards e=mc^2 before he actually did it. It was felt before it became proven. Nice talk to put things in perspective, but the way I see it, ridicule is sometimes just a defense mechanism of the bully to make himself feel superior against a topic that he doesn't understand yet.

[@knowledgesharing3479]

What about the 80% dark matter , dark energy in the Universe that science cant explain?

[@akshayrathore2882]

Tides are because differential gravity of moon at water one side and other side of earth. You dont get tides in a lake because lakes are very small. This force is negligible in case of human. FunFact: If you live at ground floor of highrise building, building has greater tidal force on your body then moon.

[@henilsoni1684]

True...💯

[@aasaanhai3073]

don't believe until u know the reality....!!!

[@Thesparkofficial-p5f]

Your genious sir .... All things are clear true

[@ThatGuy0275]

7:29 "very very....fine particle?" 🤣

[@pruthvirajghatage7970]

1 ch number sir and i proud of you

[@ASHISHCHAUHANBCE]

His stand up comedy remind me of a Hindi adage: "KAALA AKSHAR BHENS BARABAR"

[@lonewolf-ok3vy]

Your level of intellect reminds me of a Hindi adage: " AKAL KA CHARNE JANA " 🤣🤣🤣

[@Madara-zt8pn]

@@lonewolf-ok3vy also akal ghutno me hona 🤣🤣

[@DhirajTawlareAstro]

that man has jupiter affected

[@scientificatheist9381]

Haha nice

[@peeper646]

Or you have your brain affected

[@vivek_saathi4392]

This man is responsible for destroying the livelihood of some people. Pity on them.

[@sanjaydutt3280]

As i understand, this gentleman must do a more study and understand Astrology deeper, rejecting something is a very step, and the speech prepared looks very compelling but only on surface. Deeper study will change his perception.

[@हेरम्बनिगम]

I am no one to claim or justify whether this gentleman is right or wrong but All I can say and I am very sure about this.. He has not done a deep study on Astrology.

[@peeper646]

Deeper study did change my perception, and now I know for sure that ASTROLOGY IS SCAM

[@unmesh_mahajan]

You guys have done the deeper study?then how you know he's wrong?

[@chandlerminh6230]

Deeper study of astrology led me to understanding astronomy so well, which further led me to the conclusion that astrology is nonsense

[@fcdt6078]

@@peeper646 even I was also think that But gd vashistha change my life

[@bestofsa8621]

Very good Shinde sir

[@sandeeppatil8900]

Marvelous Good analysis

[@babulipatra4381]

Basic concept of " grah " misconcepted by lecture.

[@praveshvyas1]

Mercury can't be so far from Sun. Please correct :-P

[@anilkumart1024]

It's awesome..

[@theTruthSeeker8]

what are you trying to convey sir?

[@ajaymane548]

Nice... And good suggestion

[@varungupta6412]

What is jesta thing that professor was speaking about? Please clear it.

[@ShivShambhoVibes]

Proud to be your student sir....

[@Arindam4uuu]

When a person doesn't know anything about astrology.. When a person is not aware about sage parashar or vrigu's knowledge.. When a person is half educated then only he can make fun of an advance science like astrology.

[@Shishir27]

Astrology is nonsense

[@Agnostic7773]

@@Shishir27 Everything is nonsense ! Do you living for the sense or pleasures ?

[@Madara-zt8pn]

wow very educated personality here, Arvind Dutta

[@Arindam4uuu]

@@Madara-zt8pn aww.. thnx for your complement. But I also hope you are educated enough to write my name properly. Never mind.

[@arindamguha5328]

Advance science 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@sunny10528]

Good joke proffessor or whoever you are! It's unfortunate that modern day people refuse to believe in astrology. It's based on mathematical calculations and there is a strong basis and reasoning behind it. I believe that in future, Vedic Astrology will explode like anything

[@bloop5206]

Mathematics is proof based. It can be proven using a pen and paper. Give links to research papers related to astrology to enlighten us, please.

[@sairajanvekar6925]

I am waiting for the day when Astrology will vanish fom this world......

[@Sartaj1sheikh]

You are being sarcastic isn't it ? 😐

[@sameer_katti]

lmao, there is nothing called Vedic astrology. The "Vedic astrology" you are talking about was copied from the greeks when they came to India. this is like copying the wrong answer from a friend lol

[@RR_theproahole]

@@sameer_katti yeah each one of the contellation is exactly the same as Greeks and since Indians never went to Greece but Greeks came to India with attacks of Alexander, it only make sense that it was us who copied from them and not the other way round.

[@Sam...49]

If that so, why we are very dependent on the sun radiation If it is 8 min older

[@matsaab6107]

Nitin ji aap nilesh oak or tony nader ji se miliye , unse kuch knowledge le lo , it is my advice, comedy band kro

[@sachinkesarkar8905]

Would be good, if would have more researched on "Varah Mihira", "Aryabhatta", "Shushruta" .... who have made contributions to Astrology .... they all are mathematician, doctors but also contributed to Astrology. Simply because he has got an offer to speak on TedX, this joker is making some fun.

[@peeper646]

Newton too believed in alchemy. Does that make alchemy correct? No. If some great person believes in something that doesn't automatically make it right

[@worldchanger3675]

Actually all of these varah mihira,ayrabhatta , they were actual mathematicians but these scriptures were composed long after them around 11 or 11 century ad so there is norhing about it it is just a mix veg of indian astronomy and babylon astrology which was rejected by many great beings like buddha

[@lonewolf-ok3vy]

@@worldchanger3675 true and many research have found astrology incorrect.

[@Sakura09034]

When all were thinking solar system revolving around earth but when they got to know that it was wrong and even sun is not planet it is star and all planets revolving around sun from that day all mathematician , astronomy separated from astrology .

[@shashisharma6741]

These brilliant mind has worked on astronomy.

[@shivaprasad-rw2ni]

So this man thinks indian sages who were considered far more intelligent and spiritual than him just wrote stories to mock the people....this guy could have choosen a better topic to show off his intelligence!!

[@Sakura09034]

Spirituality and astrology are different things. Don’t misunderstand. Buddha , swami Vivekanand , paramhans , guru Nanak ji like so many supported spiritual life not an astrology . First gain ur knowledge then discuss topic .

[@vamsivuyyuri]

He may come across with some fake astrologers.

[@rajeshkumar501]

hii

[@pallavivilasraochandanshiv2470]

Awakening Call 😇

[@parthshinde5966]

BTW The kundali shown as the example in the first half of video, is actually good 😂 The person would be struggling in life for all acquisitions like job , career , house , relations. But Will succeed in it eventually as Guru maharaj in 9th house of own Rashi 😂😂 Sorry

[@theaditxys]

Astrology is cap 🧢

[@piyushgupta3850]

It was a waste of time to watch it. There was no take away & this guy is full of himself & has a know-all attitude.

[@abhinavshimla]

Well...sometimes you pretend you are intellectual....coz you are not...

[@OtisAdonisChad]

Do one thing. Go to good astrologers who can give a reading and find out how many can give accurate prediction. Don't mock it. Study Brihat Parashar hora Shastra. Experience it. And then decide. Give it 2 to 5 years atleast of intense research. Don't believe or disbelieve anything. I've seen and experienced many things which people won't believe. So I invite people to gain books and knowledge and then experience. Don't believe him. Believe the sages.

[@Shishir27]

No astrologer can give good predictions. astrology is nonsense

[@akshayrathore2882]

Its called cold reading. Search how it works on youtube.

[@rajeshsaliyan7610]

Then how your date of birth saying about your behaviour?? Numbers are saying about u. U can check

[@bharatgyangatha]

But you are. wrong ...when you say we treat sun as a planet ... the planet is not right word ....We use griha ..which means anything that influences or has an effect on human

[@Madara-zt8pn]

how does those heavenly bodies have effects on individuals differently?

[@bharatgyangatha]

@@Madara-zt8pn because of different place and time ...

[@niteku6448]

Bug offff

[@mayursawant111]

lol.. Only unpads disliked the video as they lack critical thinking.

[@rajatsharma2353]

who is that joker.......

[@Sakura09034]

He is a chemistry professor and he is doing this for social work. Also He is work for अंधश्रद्धा निर्मूलन समिती

[@prakharjain4086]

*sigh* This man needs help. He thinks he is intelligent enough to rule out such an ancient science, just by reading google search of all keywords of astrology. Do you know how deep and spiritual astrology is? How can you come to such conclusion before even saying such words. If you are upvoting this, You TRUST this man more than our brilliant ancestors who were following this science. I agree currently astrology is practiced wrongly but please this is not a right solution.

[@naru..3712]

Prakhar Jain are u astrologer

[@prakharjain4086]

No, But I have read a lot about astrology.

[@anshb28]

FYI, Astrology didn't have roots in India. It originated from Babylon and Mesopotamia. Vedas condemned such predictive texts and were only concerned about Nakshatras that too for yajna and fire sacrifices. Also, personalities like Vivekananda, Shri Guru Nanak ji and various others neither accepted, nor preached about it ever. The term "Vedic" here in "Vedic Astrology" is oxymoron.

[@peeper646]

Reading your comment I feel that you need help, not this man. Astrology is not a science. Modern science has proved that astrologers are not more accurate than pure chance

[@prajaktfulambarkar4526]

Hello Prakhar, I am neutral on this topic but this man Making some sense can u share concrete research based article proving accuracy of astrology.

[@sansak14]

Sad the gentleman has made mokery of this divine science.

[@peeper646]

No, astrology has made a mockery of real science

[@akashphate1240]

SANDEEP plz be scientifically awake..🙏🏻

[@mohitagrawal8331]

Divine Science? 😂 , There's nothing divine in astrology. Divine is in Bhgvad geeta, books of srila prabhupada. Even He hated astrology he said it's for materialistic people and it doesn't apply in kaliyuga. Astrology is totally fake

[@niteku6448]

Science or not that's a livelihood made by conning people

[@rajeshkumar501]

hii😂 Awesome

[@rajeshkumar501]

hii😂

[@santoshpatil-xx7cr]

9-

[@AKSHAYKUMAR-fv7gy]

Astrology Needs Mind and Guts to Understand...fuddu bando ke samjh me nhi aati ye...

[@unmesh_mahajan]

Seems like you're professional in this field😋

[@mrdhaliwal8228]

So why do people get aggressive on a full moon

[@vijaynagaraju9701]

No,They don't

[@mrdhaliwal8228]

@@vijaynagaraju9701 I’m a registered Nurse and currently managing an aged care facility. We have patients unable to sleep, getting aggressive on full moons ,

[@preeti3089]

@@mrdhaliwal8228 there is a word in English called lunatic(mentally challenged).. lunar is for moon.. I went to few orphanages where they had many mentally challenged people the sister told me . They don't behave abnormal during full moon or no moon... it's random... I don't know what is the truth

[@mrdhaliwal8228]

@@preeti3089 Great point!

[@mrdhaliwal8228]

@@preeti3089 my gf has a faster heart rate on random days , Always after dark, we see a full moon in those days. It’s novice to use phrases like “ No they don’t “. What a waste of space

[@bloop5206]

Haha! Kundali manufacturers

[@DhirajTawlareAstro]

Accha makaj udaya hai, banda nasamaj hai because he dont have knowledge about spirituality

[@roshanchaudhary9522]

But i never found any spritual guru talking about astrology

[@Sakura09034]

He is a chemistry professor and he is doing this for social work. Also He is work for अंधश्रद्धा निर्मूलन समिती

[@Sakura09034]

Spirituality and astrology are different things. Don’t misunderstand. Buddha , swami Vivekanand , paramhans , guru Nanak ji like so many supported spiritual life not an astrology . First gain ur knowledge then discuss topic .

[@Sakura09034]

Ved is different and Vedic astrology ( people made business by this word ) . Vedas ere Indian roots not Vedic astrology . Who learnt Vedic study they didn’t support astrology . Study about this .

[@DhirajTawlareAstro]

@@roshanchaudhary9522 Because they are master of their life they are not accepted astrology as tool to read karma

[@ramkumarganesh]

What research you have done to say astrology is wrong... just tell me when the astronomy was developed and when so called you scientist found that earth is not flat ... if you don’t know the truth, or just don’t understand how it is done, please keep quiet

[@Sandykxcf]

He is fake guy.

[@mohitagrawal8331]

Not at all , he is a well educated man who said the right thing.

[@Sakura09034]

He is a chemistry professor and he is doing this for social work. Also He is work for अंधश्रद्धा निर्मूलन समिती

[@Madara-zt8pn]

no ur mom is fake

[@niteku6448]

U r fake

[@rajeshkumar501]

hii😂