So THIS is that famous scene I've heard about all my life! Absolutely magnificent. Other films have desperately tried to recapture this, and many have come close, but nobody's been able to recreate the jaw dropping brilliance of this scene.
@finrodbrs3 ай бұрын
Depending on what you've heard, you may be looking for the scene from the remake with Charleton Heston. Both are made by C.B. Demill but I think the 1954 version is the more famous today.
@johnmanno20523 ай бұрын
@@finrodbrs Actually no! It's this scene I've heard about. I've seen the Charlton Heston monstrosity, and think it's barely a pale shadow of this, also Novarro is a FAR, FAR better actor than Mr So Stiff He Can Barely Move Heston. Finally, I'm one of those VERY weird people who think that silent film is superior to talkies, but please don't tell anyone because I don't want to be lynched by an angry mob.
@davidmoser35353 ай бұрын
@@finrodbrs 1959 William Wyler cb wasnt involved in remake
@eugenio120317 сағат бұрын
This is THE scene, it was so ambitious that the project being so big had a lack of safety protocols, a lot of horses and stuntmen were hurt and others died, it’s because of this film that hurting animals (and people) was strictly banned in Hollywood, next year this gem of the film industry will be 100 years old
@paullatimer16393 ай бұрын
I've heard that there were up to 25 cameras filming it from every angle. What a job for the editor! The film is a masterpiece.
@steveweiss64423 ай бұрын
They did a fantastic job on this.
@crazyman84723 ай бұрын
That was some awesome camera work! 😎
@DavidGarcia-h5l3 ай бұрын
Truly kicked ass..and 35 years later was inferior
@andywomack34143 ай бұрын
@@DavidGarcia-h5l Indeed. The Charlton Heston chariot race was an unrealistic and weak imitation.
@SathishKumar-gs1qn2 ай бұрын
Unbelievable camera and editing... Marvelous 🎉🎉🎉
@willlockler94333 ай бұрын
Absolutely fantastic editing job, for any time.
@DevenderKumar-ds4st3 ай бұрын
Superlative! Filming such a hectic sequence in the sikent era is a wonder in itself. Filming this incredible-like sequence twice is a stupendous thing when filming even once is too much. None other than de Mille coud do this. The solitary figure in the history of motion picture that has carried the film making profession on his shouldets. Am shortcof words. What would you say. Spellbound!
@RogerWilmut3 ай бұрын
The optical effects work is magnificent. Only the bottom tier of the audience existed, the rest being a model suspended in front of the camera to blend in exactly, the same device being used for the towers. The joint is comopletely invisible even though the camera could pan. The miniature spectators could be moved to appear to jump up and down.
@greglbennett21 күн бұрын
Proof that all the computers and CGI environments in the world can't hold a candle to physical sets. This is amazing filmmaking for 1925 and its better than almost anything you'll see today.
@thegoddessdiana91853 ай бұрын
Film making completed 99 years ago (I'm writing this in 2024)! Impressive! I remember the 1959 successor film very well as I saw it as a 10-year old. I have both the VHS tape and now the DVD.
@rustythecrown93173 ай бұрын
Up Jupiter , Up Mars.
@mitchellminer95973 ай бұрын
That was magnificent! Thank you for posting. The author of the Ben-Hur book, Lew Wallace, was a Civil War general under Grant, and also the governor of New Mexico who had to deal with Billy the Kid.
@rustythecrown93173 ай бұрын
Wrote in his spare time between gigs.
@davidmoser35353 ай бұрын
bad general, and wasnt honorable to billy. You can look it up.
@leebrandt859721 күн бұрын
No horses were left unharmed during the filming of this movie
@glenrich-uu9zr3 ай бұрын
This film is so precious and spectacular. It is hard to say that it can match the film of 1959 by Heston. But considering the techniques and the early stage of movie production, it is no doubt that a marvelous and entertaining work, a good model of its successor.
@arteguey3 ай бұрын
For all the glory of Heston/Boydd performance during the race, this first version seems to me more beautiful. OF course, its a matter of opinions...
@glenrich-uu9zr3 ай бұрын
@@arteguey I am totally agreed that the exciting, the oppressions and tensions of the rhythm of chariots race is echoed in every audience mind.
@vulpo3 ай бұрын
This seems like a fantastic work of cinema, perhaps even better than the 1959 version, until you learn that one of the "effects" they used was to trip the horses running at full gallop using trip wires. A hundred horses were deliberately killed in this way for our entertainment pleasure in the making of the Chariot Race for the 1925 Ben Hur. The technique was banned a few years later.
@glenrich-uu9zr3 ай бұрын
@@vulpo It may be sad or an appreciation to the clever minds of the poineers of the movie production. They used ropes, basic tools, hard working, utmost patience, with a little bit of luck to fulfill the mission of impossible.
@markbeck83843 ай бұрын
Some pretty theatrical costumes, but really spectacular. Amazing what they could pull off!
@biggerock3 ай бұрын
Beautiful and horrifying at the same time. Wow!
@chookaschookas4443 ай бұрын
Our local symphony orchestra (Auckland Symphonia) played the music for the showing of the whole film. I don't know if it was the same music as this, but the conductor has played this around the world. It was thrilling and at the end of the chariot race, the orchestra was cheered loudly. It was in a local "Picture Palace" built for silent movies, although it is now an updated fully functional theatre.
@davidwoodbridge94333 ай бұрын
It was the Auckland Philharmonia Orchestra, I was playing First Trombone - the chariot race was non-stop playing for the whole orchestra and particularly tiring for the brass section - especially when doing two shows in one day. It was great to hear the cheering afterwards from the audience! ( It was the same music - written by Carl Davis, and conducted in our performances by Sir William Southgate ). The theatre was the Civic Theatre which still does every year silent films with live orchestral accompaniment. It was built in 1929 and was at the time the largest movie theatre in the world after Radio Music Hall in New York City. It was restored to it's original grandeur in 1999 and is fascinating to visit.
@chookaschookas4443 ай бұрын
@@davidwoodbridge9433 Aha - I chose the name of a previous incarnation of the orchestra - Juan Matteucci's time I think. The performance was exhilarating, so thank you for your contribution.
@713davidh423 ай бұрын
I think it was Carl Davis who composed the music when it was shown on Turner Classic Movies (TCM) in the U.S.
@713davidh423 ай бұрын
This is the film that put the M-G-M studio on the map. The chariot race in the 1959 remake pales in comparison to this silent version. The film editor did a fantastic job of splicing it together. Sadly, there were horses and perhaps human lives lost although I don't think it was intentional.
@kristoferzamojski71403 ай бұрын
Tylko wersja z 1959 roku jest najlepsza!
@faming11443 ай бұрын
One might find one more appealing than the other, but to say one is better than the other is comparing apples and oranges. E.g. this 1925 version has that typical generic face make-up of silent Holywood movie actors that for me doesn't agree with the location nor time-period of the action. I don't now what music was played in the theaters, but the score used here I find horribly overdone and hardly matching the visuals nor the time-period. For the silent movie lovers out there, the 1959 version has no music during the race at all, just the sound effects of the race itself. This makes for a very intense, none distracted experience.
@713davidh423 ай бұрын
@@faming1144 The 1959 race is certainly good, but I to me 1925 race is better filmed and edited even though tragedy happened. The music used I think is from the TCM showing of the movie was composed by Carl Davis. The 1959 remake is better than the silent version in several respects such as a more authentic Esther character, but not with regard to the chariot race which hopefully no horses were lost in the later film. I've saved the last intertitle from the earlier movie in my documents.
@713davidh423 ай бұрын
@@kristoferzamojski7140 If you get Turner Classic Movies (TCM) where you live, I recommend that you watch the silent version whenever it is shown. I watched the entire movie on TCM and found it to be very moving. The 1959 remake is as good in many respects, but not with regard to the chariot race. I hope my comments translate well into your language.
@713davidh423 ай бұрын
@@kristoferzamojski7140 If you have Turner Classic Movies (TCM) where you live, I recommend viewing the silent version whenever it is available. I've seen the entire movie and found it very meaningful. The 1959 remake is almost as good, but not with regard to the chariot race. I hope my comment translates well.
@davidmoser35353 ай бұрын
William Wyler, director of 1959 Ben Hur, visible running in 1 scene.
@stephennewton22233 ай бұрын
A look at the cast shows many giants in uncredited roles.
@TorrediPisa523 ай бұрын
Astonishing movie!
@DMBall3 ай бұрын
Among the extras who worked on this shoot: Clark Gable and Myrna Loy, at the start of their careers
@tomc81153 ай бұрын
Joan Crawford too, according to some sources
@elvirgil35883 ай бұрын
¡¡¡Qué película!!! efectos fabulosos, grandes tomas en una de las escenas más complicadas de filmar d etodos los tiempos. hace 100 años y la verdad nole pide nada en absoluto a las películas actuales. Eso sucede cuando hay un artista al mando. Un tesoro invaluable
@Milordvega3 ай бұрын
The 1959 version is greater, but for 1925, this version is even more epic than the 1959 version was for its time. Kind of like how the effects in the original Star Wars (1977) would not be so impressive today, but for 1977, they were just mindblowing. So this chariot race must have wowed audiences in 1925 even more than how the race in the Charlton Heston/Stephen Boyd version surely amazed viewers in 1959. I hope I make sense.
@fshoaps2 ай бұрын
Sorry to the dead horses, but cool scene.
@teastrainer36047 ай бұрын
In 1968, at age 69, star Ramon Navarro was beaten to death by two hustlers who mistakenly believed he had a lot of cash hidden in his home.
@DavidGarcia-h5l3 ай бұрын
Who was Roman Navarro?
@teastrainer36043 ай бұрын
@@DavidGarcia-h5l It's Ramon Novarro, and he was the star of the movie.
@DavidGarcia-h5l3 ай бұрын
@@teastrainer3604 hee won the race and do you know his origins!. very interesting
@johnmanno20523 ай бұрын
Sad. Sad end to a superb actor
@track19493 ай бұрын
Omg, I had never heard that before. 😢
@theophilos09103 ай бұрын
So basically our fearless editor (poor Lloyd Nosler) had nearly 45 hours of raw footage to work with for this one scene alone Talk about a daunting task when instructed by his masters to pare all of that raw material down to a mere 12-minute scene - ouch (that’s ALOT of raw footage that could have been salvaged for the Smithsonian !) Which means (very roughly) with 2,900 minutes of raw footage at a shooting cost of est. $20,000 per minute for a total of nearly USD $60 million-expressed in to-day’s modern currency value-for this one ‘single 12-minute set of scenes-in-a-series’ alone ! Try explaining THAT to those tight-fisted overweight Lowes’ bean-counters back in 1925 - ! ROFL
@pathdalyАй бұрын
That's some pretty intense stuff I must say, but I have to think there MUST have been some injuries (or even deaths?).
@十蘭コメント2 ай бұрын
Thanks. オリジナルのベン・ハーは、トーキー映画時代の大作だった。
@riofest88932 ай бұрын
(1) As far as action scenes go, I think it surpasses the 1959 version....8:48 The camera lying down was completely absent in the 1959 movie. 12:20 The crash scene is also different, and it is said that 100 horses were killed during filming.... Don't miss the sea battle with pirates in the full version. (2) The Mexican actor who plays Judah is not as good as Rudolph Valentino, but he was a popular Latino actor who had a miserable later life as a gay.
@kitt2000car3 ай бұрын
Must of been a lot of work to train all those horses to drive in open bridles??
@randyhebbebusche36443 ай бұрын
So sad that animals and people could be replaced so easily. Poor horses, stunt men were expendable too.
@monikagrosch96323 ай бұрын
Those buildings! And the costumes!!!
@DavidGarcia-h5l3 ай бұрын
brutal...the frekin helmet wings.. OMG
@Hunpecked5 ай бұрын
Wow. Pretty good for 1925.
@wyzrd7773 ай бұрын
Francis X Bushman (Massala) was my great uncle. Visiting him as a child was like time travel to the 1920's. His house had lots of items from his movies.
@LillianSteele-u9v2 ай бұрын
He was one of my aunt's favorite actors. She was the late Mrs. Lucy Jane Barker and I am named for her and also her mom who was my grandmother. I am a retired museum educator and it is an honor to discuss this with you, sir. She saw King of Kings when she was in middle school in Georgia in the late 1920s.
@Ivan-cr3vc19 күн бұрын
My first knowledge of this version. For 1925 "they did good". A couple of things may have even been better. The only difference I noted was in the 1959 version Messala's chariot had those large knives on the wheel hubs and the Sheik warned Judah at the start.
@deniseeulert25033 ай бұрын
That this film had the race take place in Antioch made it truer to the book. The 1959 film had the race in Jerusalem but there was no huge stadium ever in that city.
@713davidh423 ай бұрын
Good point. The silent film specifically mentions the chariot race takes place in Antioch while the remake seems to presume that it occurs in Jerusalem. 👍
@cavramau2 ай бұрын
Monty Python, what do I do with the Holy Handgrenade of Antioch? Are there instructions?
@rajeevkumar-cv4uw3 ай бұрын
99years ago released this movie.
@dovbarleib32562 ай бұрын
The outfits, esp. of the women, seem to reflect the fashions when the movie was made.
@JamesSimmons-d1t3 ай бұрын
The camera truck pulling is of course method. Civil war general wrote novel. Like 'The Robe' , Christianity reverse chronologized. My classics professor The Lawrenceville School, app 1966, said he fell asleep in theater for Heston/Boyd film. Probably in Leper Colony. He was smart and educated and a real idiot. Helped write AP test. Large Deal. Classic silent, of course. The silent era 'flashing eyes!' bit always kills me. Try Youngson film clip collections, esp 1st..DAYS OF THRILLS AND LAUGHTER.
@kedharisivashankar99053 ай бұрын
About a century ago! Fantastic!! Watch it in 75% speed for more realism. (This is a 16fps cinematography, not 24fps we are used to watch).
@frankgesuele62982 ай бұрын
Play Magika while watching as it adds to the thrill🐎🐎🐎🐎
FOR IT'S AGE IT IS AS GOOD AS CHARLTON HESTON'S FILM. AND PROBABLY 100 TIMES BETTER THAN THE LATEST VERSION.
@mariuszamfirescu53903 ай бұрын
Just : wow !
@lonl1234 ай бұрын
If you watch closely, after the final big crash, you can see someone running on the track that looks to be in a long coat...this was actually the director as the crash was really quite bad (And unscripted) …many horses were killed and I think one of the stunt drivers was killed as well...though I'm not 100% about that part...a stunt driver did die during the filming of the race though.
@713davidh423 ай бұрын
I watched a 2nd time and saw it too. Thanks for pointing it out. 👍
@RogerWilmut3 ай бұрын
Actually it was assistant director William Wyler.
@lonl1233 ай бұрын
@@RogerWilmut How right you are! Thank you for the correction...been years since I saw the Documentary.
@davidmoser35353 ай бұрын
It was AD William Wyler, director of the 1959 Ben Hur
@ramaraksha012 ай бұрын
So the changes with the Charlton Heston movie is no Wheel spokes on the villian's chariot? That seems fair I never like those spokes - that would be an unfair advantage & would not be allowed in any competition Also Heston did not use a whip on his horses - here the hero whips his horses
@pameladowe24923 ай бұрын
A spectacle then, a spectacle now!
@alfredoreitano34263 ай бұрын
UN FILM SPETTACOLARE. UN COLOSSO DELLO SCHERMO.
@Sam-nb1rm16 күн бұрын
It was reported that over 150 horses died because of this scene
@rjlchristie3 ай бұрын
Many animals were proudly stressed and maimed in this production.
@elibravo97103 ай бұрын
pobres caballos 😢
@christoph4043 ай бұрын
well it is a spectacular sequence , but it came at a price, over 100 horses were killed filming the race, a statistic that is usually overlooked . The first crash 8:02 is gut wrenching, those horses got mangled when the chariot crashes...the second one at 12:15 was a pile up, multiple horses and chariots crashing on top of each other, goodness knows how many takes they did for that.
@rustythecrown93173 ай бұрын
Yeah , it was a massacre for sure. But to be fair , all those horses are dead now anyway....
@SKINWALKER973 ай бұрын
Never mind the horses, 3 people died duering the filming of this scene.
@ScottRossProductions2 ай бұрын
It ain't no Ben Hur... wait... great stuff.
@ashokpawar79663 ай бұрын
Almost 100 years back Hollywood at the best! Indian Bollywood is lagging behind although Dada phalke given them horizon to march on.
@williamwong78203 ай бұрын
it out Ben-Hurs Ben-Hur
@Bhagwandeokar-m2n2 ай бұрын
पहिला बेनहुर १९२५ सालि आला होता ( मूक पट " ) त्या मधील रथा ची शर्यत .
@DavidGarcia-h5l3 ай бұрын
Mr . Classic Hollywood.. you are the man go to the head of the class.. OMG.. that was fucking awesome from a film aficionado that i am..no contest 1925 BEN HUR ...KICKS ASS ..it took 35 years for the remake... Shame on 1959 ... BTW never knew of the 1935 version.. although the JEW was buffed...most JEWS aren't buffed ..the opponent was much more chiseled naturally.. great piece
@JamesSimmons-d1t3 ай бұрын
Chiseled. Well gay is your right. we can only imagine...a mound of snail flab with a Bud. 12. The internet was sure to devolve. This I saw when I first heard of 'social media'...like 'Truth Social' and 'Military Intelligence, contradictions in terms...and in reality in facts. My dad was an important research scientist and national director of most divisions of Western Electric Co. he would come up to me...strong man superb athlete when young...tears in his eyes... "If we only KNEW!"
@행호할캥홍2 ай бұрын
우와우
@mtpocketswoodenickle26377 ай бұрын
So sorry Cecil B. Demille. Wasn't you!
@713davidh423 ай бұрын
Cecil B. DeMille did a couple Biblical epics during the silent era: King of Kings from 1927 and his 1st version of The Ten Commandments in 1923. The 1956 sound version of the latter film is I think DeMille's best work.
@dipalidas562 ай бұрын
Silent movie !
@andywomack34143 ай бұрын
Ben Hur, a story about Rome written by someone who seemed to know very little about Rome. Although the architectural giganticism is not something that I think existed anywhere at any time in the Roman Empire, the chariot race itself makes the Charlton Heston version an embarrassing weak and unrealistic imitation.
@tooleyheadbang42393 ай бұрын
Only because the Novarro version was TOO realistic. Irresponsibly so.
@andywomack34143 ай бұрын
@@tooleyheadbang4239 How many horses died in the Navarro version? How many actors injured? Any stats on those issues? I doubt CGI could replicate the carnage. And the movie likely did not show the worst of it.
@pauleypavillion60883 ай бұрын
Hard to imagine that all adult people in this video are long dead. Only a few that were born in 1920 are 100 and over that may still be alive today in 2024.
@tooleyheadbang42393 ай бұрын
Not hard for people living in the real world.
@adamodeo93203 ай бұрын
ben-hur - Hebrew for son of freedom
@davidevans32272 ай бұрын
and the music! 😃
@cosmicwartoad25873 ай бұрын
Did anybody ACTUALLY survive a chariot race?
@andrewsafarik50603 ай бұрын
1925 PROBABLY 90% OF AMERICANS HAD RIDDEN A HORSE
@phaasch3 ай бұрын
Normally id call myself a purist to an irritating degree, but I would love to see this spectacular footage treated to a 60fps, motion stabilised upgrade. With colourisation. Just because...
@mirai3856Ай бұрын
ハリウッド映画 👏㊗️👏㊗️👏㊗️👏㊗️
@rjlchristie3 ай бұрын
Quite a cast of flapper hair styles in the audience.
@rustythecrown93173 ай бұрын
It Was the twenties after all.
@oluhamilton21217 ай бұрын
Magnificent Hollywood FOOKERY. Wonder how many horses were sacrificed for the sake of realism.
@jamessheridan43066 ай бұрын
I've seen figures of up to 150 but who's counting? This is the film that put the newly minted Metro Goldwyn Mayer on the map. Considering all those fabulous stars they would go on to use up like Kleenex and then kick to the curb once they'd finished with them, what are the lives of 150 horses give or take? That's Entertainment!
@crazyman84723 ай бұрын
IMDB says “several” horses and at least one stuntman were killed during the chariot race. Several extras were possibly drowned during the sea battle. 💀
@DavidGarcia-h5l3 ай бұрын
Fookery ???.. never heard that explain
@DavidGarcia-h5l3 ай бұрын
@@saluki7651 who you voting for?..all being said
@ChanceKearns3 ай бұрын
@@saluki76515:52
@shaguftasayed40223 ай бұрын
F1
@LillianSteele-u9v2 ай бұрын
Everyone, this movie is interesting and the race really was run. However, the characters Ben Hur and Messals did not exist. I discovered this when I was in the 6th grade and it led me to major in History.
@ramaraksha012 ай бұрын
I don't get it - they have all this music blaring but when it comes to words, they can only do sub-titles? Just a joke people
@robertmain47732 ай бұрын
They didn't have sound in 1925. The first big showing used a live symphony orchestra, most theaters had organs for the sound. Talkies came later.
@gpozdol79126 ай бұрын
The js were thick then.
@DavidGarcia-h5l3 ай бұрын
J s???
@gpozdol79123 ай бұрын
I did not post this.
@JamesSimmons-d1t3 ай бұрын
@@gpozdol7912 Really! Want to know guilty party. Hmm. Anyone have access?