Benjamin Bulldog vs. Hercules Bully - Air Rifles

At last a fair and complete comparison between these two popular air rifles in 357 magnum caliber. Dr. Russ encourages each viewer to weigh the strengths and shortcomings of each air rifle to their own typical, hunt style. The phenomenal 357 magnum pellets have no trouble breaking up cast iron frying pans and penetrating all 4 inches of 2x4’s. Deer, Hogs, Turkeys, Wood Chucks, Snapping Turtles, Fox, Coyotes, and Squirrels have met their match with these large bore air guns. Join Dr. Russ and Hollow Head on their shooting deck, as they present and compare the features of these two great air rifles.
Awesome Accurate Air Rifle by Dr. Russ videos are for your educational and documentary, purposes only. Duplicating any of the activities shown in our videos, is solely done AT YOUR OWN RISK. You must treat air rifles and air pistols as REAL FIREARMS WITH REAL BULLETS IN THEM. They are very capable of harming and even KILLING YOU AND PERSONS NEAR YOU. Any and all upgrade work on air guns should be done by a qualified and insured gunsmiths. Dr Russ videos as well as KZbin will not be held liable for any injury or harm to yourself, or others within shooting range of your air gun. When attempting to duplicate any or similar activities shown in our videos, Awesome Accurate Air Rifle by Dr. Russ videos, as well as KZbin will not be held liable for any harm done to you, others near you, or damage to your air guns. We do not manufacture, distribute or sell Airguns, Airgun parts or Airgun equipment. By viewing this video, you are acknowledging the serious contents of this disclaimer and the personal responsibilities that go with them. By viewing or flagging this video, you are acknowledging that you have read this disclaimer. Please advise us if anyone attempts to change or charge for our videos.

[@MrAnkurbarua]

The best video i have ever seen on PCP comparison and analysis. Thanks Dr. Russ. Please continue to share your knowledge.

[@russelljones4132]

Thank you for the comment Ankur ...Welcome to our channel ... and I hope we continue to share info that will keep you .... Air Gun Sharp..... Good to hear from you.... Dr. Russ

[@williamlazu7024]

Thank You Dr. Russ You have a GREAT way of explaining things. Please keep us updated.

[@drsrussandpaula]

William Lazu ... thanks for your compliment... please keep us in your loop of air gun experiences, helping us help everyone stay air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@josephbryan2524]

I pump up my bulldog from around 1800 or 1900psi to 3000psi with a hand pump. It takes around 115 to 120 strokes. And a total time of 4 to 6 minutes depending on how long I let the pump cool off halfway through. Granted I'm not a small person. But it's not hard to pump by hand.

[@drsrussandpaula]

Joseph Bryan ... it is good to hear from you... and thanks for the tip. I have found that I shoot almost everyday ... and perhaps 500 to 1000 rounds per week.... so using a hand pump just doesn't provide the time I need .... however.,.. I respect those who do... Dr. Russ

[@jaykite357]

Very informative. I may never own one of these, but you added enough info on shooting in general to make it very educational for a bigger like myself. Thanks!

[@drsrussandpaula]

Jay... it was good to hear from you... and glad that you found our video informative. Please know that I am available for any question or concern on air guns that you might have. This was our 18th KZbin video... and we have some interesting ones planned for this summer. Dr. Russ

[@mariebrewer4016]

Thank you for describing both guns in such detail really enjoyed your Video

[@russelljones4132]

It was good to hear from you Marie.... please keep us in your loop of air gun experiences. We haven't been paid to promote any product or company ... so I hope our information is helpful. Dr. Russ

[@jdp5704]

Could not have asked for a better video on the topic. Subbed!

[@russelljones4132]

Josh ... good to hear from you and thanks for subscribing... Please keep me in your loop of air gun experiences ... so that I might remain air gun sharp too and share with our viewers in the future.... Dr. Russ

[@matthewvannoy500]

Thanks great video and comparison

[@russelljones4132]

Good to hear from you again Matthew ... glad you are watching several of our videos.... if you click the oval photo of me ... you will access all 35 videos completed to date. Let me recommend the one on Woodchucks ... and accuracy ... Dr. Russ

[@joeramirez6126]

Thank you for everything you do! I subscribed, liked, and commented 😊👍

[@russelljones4132]

Joe Ramirez ... it is good to hear from you and glad you subscribed. You can click onto the small photo of me in every video and gain access to all 38 of our air gun videos ...plus 2 new ones each month.... please keep us in your loop of air gun experiences so that you can help us keep everyone air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@fidelmartinez7817]

Great Video look forward to your next one!

[@russjones6497]

Good to hear from you @fidelmartinez .... I have a new video being launched early next week that is based upon some new research. It will cover the areas of improving the rifling in your barrels ... plus storing your air guns with the barrel down. This allows lubricants and lead particles to drop out of your barrel rather than back into the air compression chambers... keeping your air gun out of the repair shop... Dr. Russ

[@jarsen321]

That’s how a comparative video should be produced.

[@drsrussandpaula]

Good to hear from you jarsen321.... thanks for the compliment ... next week we have two videos coming out that compare the AEA 50 caliber Challenger with the AEA Zeus 72 caliber.... and while it is obvious that the 72 is a bigger slug... the comparison shows some interesting similarities.... please share your air gun experiences with us ... helping us help everyone stay air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@IsaacCruz-ln6pc]

Great job, very informative.

[@russjones6497]

Thanks for the compliment User-cb4wt7ip ... and it is good to hear from you ... Dr. Russ

[@Nattybread]

Nice review, Doc. Thanks for your efforts.

[@russelljones4132]

Nathaniel ... we have a son by the name of Nathaniel..... good to hear from you and your compliment... Please write again.... Dr. Russ

[@darrylsmijan9123]

Great video thanks for the info

[@russelljones4132]

Darryl Smijan ... it is great to hear from you. Please keep me in your loop of air gun experiences. I am always glad to use them in helping everyone be "air gun sharp" ! Dr. Russ

[@stephenknight883]

Incredibly detailed and very grateful for the education that I have received I currently own a Benjamin bulldog but I have been sceptical about the bully and I think that you have encouraged me to buy it. Think you again for the knowledge and the wisdom keep on making the videos I am very glad that I stumbled upon you on KZbinThink you again for the knowledge and the wisdom keep on making the videos I am very glad that I stumbled upon you on KZbin. God-bless you and your family alike and as always stay safe and shoot straight

[@russelljones4132]

Stephen Knight ... it is good to hear from you ... Please keep me in your loop of air gun experiences ... and write anytime friend ...Dr. Russ

[@mikepupa]

Great comparison & information! Really love your videos! Please do more shooting with different weight bullets IE nozzler and the like. Thanks for all your work!

[@russelljones4132]

Good to hear from you Mike Pupa .... be sure to click on the round circle photo of me ... and watch two videos on pellets.... which cover the good (nothing bad other than expense) of Nosler Partition Bullets for hunting ... as well as every other type of pellet imaginable. Future videos will cover these pellets and bullets too. Please continue to keep us in your air gun info loop ....so that we can help everyone remain air gun sharp.... Dr. Russ

[@simayeux1717]

I am considering on Purchasing a Benjamin Bulldog and I thank you for the information you have shared. Please continue the good work!

[@russelljones4132]

Si Mayeux .... it is good to hear from you and thank you for the compliment. I hope that you continue to share your air gun experiences with us ... and that you stay air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@TheExplosiveGuy]

Can't go wrong with a bulldog, I love mine. Consider some of the aftermarket mods and parts you can add to it, including drilling out the ports, adding a 4500psi chamber and internal 3000psi regulator, you'll simultaneously increase FPS and shot count. There is also a moderator/suppressor that will let you shoot anywhere you want without bothering anybody (it's not a quiet gun stock).

[@domparisi3913]

THANKS Doc. I purchased my Ben Bulldog 3 yrs ago and had it "upgraded" by a professional airgun smithy who properly modified Benj Bulldogs and also incorporated higher quality equipment for safety. Your information on the 'hold' was enlightening. I knew that there was a difference compared to the springers but not on the heavier duty PCPs. this info may give me tighter groups now that I'm informed and properly compensate. My speeds are probably a little higher but I'm using much heavier pellets and slugs. I have a more kick {{and noise (definitely not back yard friendly)}}. With more kick, it is probably giving me hold sensitivities issues that I had thought were PCP minimized, which now needs to be addressed. Altho' this video was made 3 yrs ago, it is still very relevant,, and possibly even more so, now that equipment keeps improving. THANK YOU for this video.

[@russjones6497]

Domparisi .... thanks for writing about your air gun experience ... please keep us in your info loop... Dr Russ

[@nathanielcohen9890]

great info DOC. I have been attempting to wade thru all the info out there in order to make a big bore purchase that suits me best. I looked seriously at the .457 pile driver and this .357 bulldog. after a while, the info just sort of muddied together and I really couldn't tell what I was looking at with so many manufactures and their hype. this simple, informative presentation made that world crystal clear. I'm am going with the bulldog and its sister airbow. thank you for the crystal clear explanation. you made my decision much easier, less stressful, and looking forward to hrs of enjoyable shooting. you are a rock star among air gunners....lol.

[@drsrussandpaula]

Good to hear from you Nathaniel Cohen .... Glad to be of help... Dr. Russ

[@rickm4130]

Thanks for the video, going to get my Bulldog out today and do some shooting with it. Mine out of the box pushed the pellet at 860 fps and yes its loud.

[@russjones7981]

Rick... always good to hear from you... our next video will be a comparison of the Armada and the Hatson Bull Boss.... both 25 cal. and both close to the same cost... (something that many airgun comparison videos ignore) ...always good to hear from you Rick... Dr. Russ

[@duanehopland7506]

Love your videos my brother!

[@russelljones4132]

Duane Hopland ... it is good to hear from you again. thank you for the compliment... some good videos coming out in the next week... Dr. Russ

[@raymondabrego5621]

Just found your channel. Subscribed. Good stuff Sir.

[@russelljones4132]

Raymond Abrego ...it is good to hear from you.... Please continue to keep us in your air gun info loop ... so that we can keep everyone air gun sharp.... Dr. Russ

[@montylacey4618]

Hey Dr Russ sure appreciate your video and all the knowledge you shared I think I'll be buying my first bulldog 357 soon 🇺🇸👍🤠

[@davidallison8246]

nice educated review, thank you.

[@russelljones4132]

David ... thank you for the compliment. We will launch our 22nd video this week ... part two on Pellets and Slugs. Next week is # 23 on hunt tips and trail cameras. You can see all by typing in .... Dr. Russ Air Rifle. At age 75... I hope to provide a great deal of hunting and shooting tips while I am still here. Thanks for writing and don't hesitate again. Dr. Russ

[@carlosdominguez3053]

Nice video Dr. Ross

[@drsrussandpaula]

Carlos ... good to hear from you again.... thanks for the compliment ... Dr. Russ

[@johnbrenchick1414]

Great video! Very coherent and concise. I was already interested in the bulldog. That’s what I was searching for. Your video helped solidify my opinion. Though both are good air rifles. The bulldog will suite my needs a bit better.

[@russelljones4132]

John Brenchick ... I believe that the Bull Dog is my pick as well ... because it comes ready to site in and shoot. The Bully has all of the power adjusted forward to make a statement I believe... and in the end ... it requires time to back the power off to where the gun is accurate.... I usually find that 950 fps is that limit on any caliber... Dr. Russ

[@smokingunclefrank6037]

Awesome until recently I didn't know there was such a thing when it came to air guns I'm impressed

[@drsrussandpaula]

Good to hear from you Smoking Uncle Frank ... please keep us in your air gun experiences loop ... helping us help everyone stay air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@yakuachbach6083]

Thanks for your channel I've been reviewing these rifles but a lot of channels have guys acting and carrying on about their dog or something.I appreciate your style. which one would you say is more sturdy long term?

[@drsrussandpaula]

Yaku achbach ... it is good to hear from you .... Both air guns are good ... but I believe the Crosman Bull Dog is lighter and is my favorite between the two... Dr.Russ

[@wadehallstrom7260]

Thank you !!

[@russelljones4132]

Wade ... good to hear from you ... please write anytime ... we have some great videos coming up in July and August and some great hunt videos coming up this Fall .... Dr. Russ

[@johnmorton7577]

Great content

[@russelljones4132]

Good to hear from you John Morton.... please keep us in your loop of air gun experiences.... helping us help everyone stay air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@morromk7538]

Boy no kidding on the hand pump I hand pump my Seneca wing shot 357 and am sweaty and numb armed every time. Awesome channel brother.

[@russelljones4132]

Thanks for the compliment Morro MK ... It is good to hear from you ... and I appreciate you sharing one of your experiences.... air pumps are difficult challenges ... especially if you use up a lot of the air in your tube. Consider re-pumping after 5 shorts ... etc... until you find a pattern that allows you to always look forward to shooting your air gun. You have a great one by the way. Again, keep me in your loop of experiences... Dr. Russ

[@randomcuriosities8441]

Superb presentation thanks for the video

[@wesjamison5467]

Thank you Marco Diaz .....We have several good videos coming up over the next few months.... one compares the Bull Dog 357 magnum ... against a Bear Crossbow. The next two videos will give some knowledge about finding and attracting nuisance critters with an air rifle ... and using traps ... both live traps as well as deadly traps.... Dr. Russ

[@randomcuriosities8441]

I would definitely be interested in those. I'm a new subscriber. Cant wait to see them.

[@RM-xj7tl]

I am your biggest fan! Great stuff!

[@russjones7981]

Always great to hear from you RM.... these videos wouldn't exist without great fans like you... Dr. Russ

[@dejagerlaubscher5127]

Wow your backyard is Awesome !

[@russelljones4132]

De Jager Laubscher .... thanks for the compliment ... I have a video coming out in a week that is titled ... The correct air rifle caliber for you ... and while there are many considerations covered in the video... being back yard friendly for your back yard is first to consider... also consider hitting the small circle photo of myself to access our library of 40 videos ... consider the one on Bull Dog or Self Defenses to get a view of our shooting area from the back of the property ... also consider one on Accuracy and another on Woodchucks ... to cover those two subjects.... Please keep us in your loop of air gun experiences ... helping us ... help everyone stay air gun sharp.... Dr. Russ

[@JIBREAL1967]

Thumbs up..every single time Dr Russ.

[@russjones7981]

Always good to hear from you Shun ... we have some interesting videos coming up in August and some hunting videos this fall ...I hope hear from you again....Shun.... Dr. Russ

[@JIBREAL1967]

@@russjones7981 definitely looking forward to the videos. Education about air weaponry is definitely needed. People get hung up on the next big thing and are ignorant about the capabilities of the tools they are using.

[@Bigbopperairguns]

Love your video’s, Absolutely love your shooting range. You can actually see how far you’re gun will shoot with the water in the back ground. You can tell where your Bullet drops.. I’ve always wanted to do that.

[@drsrussandpaula]

Good to hear from you Big Bopper Airguns... you are right... and thanks for the compliment.... please stay in touch ... sharing your air gun experiences so that you can help us help everyone stay air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@craigsmith5360]

Good video txs

[@drsrussandpaula]

Good to hear from you Craig Smith .... please stay in touch ... sharing your air gun experiences with us ... helping us help everyone to stay air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@ianfoo7103]

Great presentation. Lengthy but, very informative.

[@drsrussandpaula]

Ian Foo .... It is good to hear from you ... please share your air gun experiences so that you can help us help everyone stay air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@RochelleM491]

Awesome, this is great instructive content from many different angles, I have the Benjamin bulldog in 357 cal and the Ataman AP16 in 22 cal.. neither gun is backyard noise friendly..lol!

[@drsrussandpaula]

It is good to hear from you Michael Rochelle.... and yes ... without suppressors ... those two can be noisy ... Anticipate getting a suppressor ... or shooting slightly inside your home thru an open window (extra safety precautions required) and you may keep your neighbors from hearing... Dr. Russ

[@gaoutdooradventures]

I know this is an older video, but I just watched it. Great comparison of both of these AG's. I'm much more familiar with the Benjamin than the other brand and now that Benjamin has this model Bullpup in .457 (wish I had one..). I really like your mention of the butt pads on PCP's (or even CO2 power plants) and that padding is not needed. These PCP air rifles are like shooting spit balls though a straw...meaning ZERO recoil for the most part until you possibly get into the much bigger bores like .50's. I agree that the manufacturers want to emulate a powder burner in their aesthetics. Great video!! I keep watching all of your vids when I can. Two thumbs up Doc!!👍👍

[@russjones6497]

It is good to hear from you again G A's .... and you are absolutely correct. I have a Zeus 72 caliber which has a kick ... but I would survive without a butt pad cushion. ... however, Dr. Paula does enjoy hers ... even in 25 caliber. Thanks for writing ... Dr. Russ

[@billietyree2214]

Doc, if you ever tasted buttermilk corn bread with chopped jalapeños that was cooked in a properly seasoned iron skillet that was properly preheated to 450 degrees, you would have more respect for iron cookware. Nevertheless, thanks for the video. I learned a lot by watching it.

[@russelljones4132]

Good to hear from you Billie Tyree.... trust me when I tell you that I have had cornbread cooked with jalapenos in an iron skillet... and I use them at home and in the field both..... however, I also have respect for my wallet ... and I have found that iron skillets bought for $5.00 apiece at a flea market cost less that the steel target plates that run north of $25 everywhere else ... including Walmart. In fact, the iron skillets make a better sound when hit than the clink sound of steel plates... Keep writing friend,... sharing your experiences with us... Dr. Russ

[@pauldeckard2181]

I do like your videos. I just got a Benjamin bulldog and I like it very much.

[@russelljones4132]

Good to hear from you again Paul Deckard. It only comes in 357 magnum cal... and actually shoots 9mm. or 35 caliber slugs and pellets.... not 357 slugs (which is actually 38 cal.). As you probably already noticed ... the sound is considerable louder than smaller air rifles ... especially the ping sound that you hear with your right ear up next to the stock. Fortunately, others don't hear that ping ... but they might hear the pow when the bullet leaves the barrel. If you don't have to buy a moderator ... don't.... and you will save about $300 and a very long air gun. Paul ... please keep me in your air gun experience loop. Dr.Russ

[@Sumdrumer]

Great vid sir! I have the bulldog and, couldn't be happier. Every time I shoot it, my jaw hits the ground because of the incredible power of these rifles. I'm looking forward to seeing you hit that drone with powder in a bag. I also fly drones however, unlike you, I'm no Marksman. So, with my luck, my drone with a bag of white powder hanging from it would probably end up in the hands of the DEA LOL! Looking forward do your next vid.

[@russelljones4132]

Sum... thank you for writing... as well as your comments. I have shot the bag under the drone once for our intro.... but will provide a video on it and the remote control boat we have pulling helium balloons around the pond... with some tips so that you can do the same. We havent shot it yet because we need an extra participant controlling the boat or the drone while a second films and I shoot..... but it will happen soon. Dr. Russ

[@CoachKatanaHead]

Great content Dr. Ross! The Bulldog has been impressive since day one.

[@russelljones4132]

Good to hear from you Tony Gunn. Please keep me in your loop with any experiences you have ... that I should pass on that will help everyone become Air Gun Sharp. Dr. Russ

[@mwaldyke]

Some of the pellets you showed at the beginning looked a lot like cast bullets for black powder cartridge guns. Do you cast any of your own pellets? If so, what has your experience been with them? How available and how expensive are the commercially made pellets? My experience with commercially cast bullets for black powder is that they can be, well, pricey. Well-made video on an interesting subject. Thank you!

[@russjones7981]

Mike... thanks for your note... this was our 18th youtube video... and we were a bit nervous because it was also our longest... 33 minutes... the rest ranged from 8 to 21 minutes... so far it has attracted 140 viewers from around the world in less than 20 hours... To answer your question about pellet/cast bullet costs... pellets in the smaller calibers are cheap.. 177 caliber being just a few cents each... 357 pellets an be 20 cents each... 357 ball bearings as much as 82 cents each.... and I have found the cast bullets at gun shows.. not for black powder... but for reloaders of powder bullets... and I have found bargains at 30 cents up to 45 cents when you buy several hundred at a time. Copper jacked bullets are even more expensive... but not recommended for air rifles because their barrels are not as strong and durable as a powder gun. I hope this helps you... consider subscribing so that your knowledge of this growing sport continues to keep you informed. Write anytime... Dr. Russ

[@garyleemccoy5428]

Very informative video. I have been looking at both. Being a major purchases I want as much information as possible, and you answer most if not all of my questions. What charger/compressor do you use for recharging?

[@russelljones4132]

Garylee McCoy... good to hear from you ... I quit using hand pumps several years ago ... they took the fun out of shooting air guns. For the most part, I use scuba tanks.... but I also have a small Hatsan air compressor which I can use in the field with 12 volt power from my car ... or at home with 110 volts from a wall socket. Consider clicking onto the small circle with my photo on it for access to all 40 of my videos... and consider watching the one on Scuba Air..... Please keep us in your air gun info loop ... helping us keep everyone air gun sharp. Dr.Russ

[@skweekykleane9810]

Appreciate the vid DRARA ! BeaUTIful spread you got there for plinkin', for sure ! No Big Bore here... yet. Prayerfully, not too far of in the near future ! Peace ! SK David

[@russelljones4132]

Skweeky Kleane ... good to hear from you ... Keep your sights high and you will reach them.... Also keep us in your loop of air gun experiences so that you can help us keep everyone ... Air Gun Sharp ... Dr. Russ

[@johnhawk9321]

Good video

[@russelljones4132]

Thank you John Hawk ... good to hear from you. Please keep us in your air gun info loop ... so that we can help everyone remain air gun sharp ... Dr. Russ

[@rahkkh]

Awesome!!!!!!!!

[@russjones6497]

Always good to hear from you Honey Bee Sting like a Bee... keep us in your loop. Dr Russ

[@bubaraydoingitright]

I have a 357 hatsan bully with no suppressor I get great groups 1 inch groups at 100 yard and killed a big doe at 90 yards with a 81 grain Diablo JSB and busted several ribs and stop just under the skin on the other side that 81 grain Diablo jsb is a very hard lead it will do the job if you have a hatsan Hercules bully be sure to tighten all the Allen screws uptight especially on picatinny rail and you'll get great results to

[@russelljones4132]

Thanks for your experience with this great air rifle Jerry .... and it was good to hear from you. Congratulations on that Big Doe ... and you obviously found her to get your results. It also helps me ... and I should have included it in this video ... to have the side lever action just above the trigger like other rifles ....instead of most bull pups having the lever action far back to the rear. Please write again. Dr. Russ

[@user-ki1ys5wz1q]

Looking at an old 357 Bulldog good p😮rice or should I go for the new model m357 more power?Ty in advance

[@eddiecahall3824]

These are very nice pcp air rifles. But there are better ones out there. Air force Texans ., Air Arms, AEA etc etc. With little more power and velocities. One thing I'd like to note about spring piston and gas ram break barrels is that the artillery hold is basically a myth with these. Because of the piston slamming forward or even reverse with torque I found most of them more accurate if you actually put a hold to it like a shotgun will group much better. There are some basic springers that like the artillery hold that seem to have not as powerful air rifle break barrels out there. This has been proven time and time again. I have a very large collection and I also own a chronograph for testing. This is my experience with break barrels as well. I also own many many pcp air guns. They seem to like a lightly hold for accuracy even the big bores. My hats off to you friend. Good video and fair shooting! Ed The Professional Backyard Sniper Man😎👍

[@russelljones4132]

Eddie Cahall ... glad to hear from you and your experiences with air guns... and glad that you have a large collection to utilize and speak from. Please share your favorites for our viewers ... Dr. Russ

[@sunnywilder7042]

Thank you for the info I now know what I am buying

[@drsrussandpaula]

Good to hear from you Kevin Kearney ... please keep us in your loop of air gun experiences.... Dr. Russ

[@ElRealista7]

cool video

[@russjones7981]

Matias... it is good to hear from you... Comments like yours teach me motivated to do more... Dr. Russ

[@BayAreaWrecker]

1:00 so truee bro, that's me I'm the dude that sprints for two miles looking for squirrels , no joke

[@drsrussandpaula]

Good to hear from you Ronaldo Zevach .... those squirrels maybe hiding on the other side of a tree while you sprint past.... thanks for sharing... Dr. Russ

[@gilbertmartinez6538]

Where did you get that air nozzle adapter for the Hatsan? ...I am having trouble finding one

[@ElRealista7]

what ammo works with the bully air venturi? 127 grain and do they work also in the bulldog? cuz they are cheaper then noslers

[@russelljones4132]

Yes they are cheaper ... and each rifle barrel has to be tested with a variety of pellets to determine their accuracy in that barrel... it isnt just the barrel differences ... but there are differences between lots of pellets ... much like there is slight differences between lots of paint. While I am sure all 35 cal and 357 caliber work in these two rifles... you will have to personally test with different pellets. It was only a matter of time before different pellet makers would prove that pellets similar to Noslers could cost a lot less.... Dr. Russ

[@jimragan9432]

thank you for another great video. this is now the third time youtube has unsubscribed me from your channel. it has unsubscribed me from others as well.

[@russjones6497]

Thanks for keeping me informed about your subscription problems Jim Ragan ... and thanks for your persistence in re- subscribing... we are checking on it ... Dr. Russ

[@miquaelmiquael1079]

Dr. Russ, I absolutely love your posts..! Very informative and knowledgeable. I ran across your review of another weapon that I am considering (the Blitz Full Auto), and was so impressed with your review of it, I decided to subscribe - and happy I did. I considered these very weapons when first looking for a big bore PCP rifle. I am ex-military (US MARINE CORPS), which had me leaning more toward the Hercules Bully's "post-apocalyptic infantry armament" style (if there is such a thing, LoL) - but I ultimately purchased the Benny Bulldog for a very valuable feature that set it apart from anything else on the market at the time: It shoots the Bolt Arrows as well! ...and quite impressively I might add - It's no novelty act - It's powerful and very accurate, and excellent for hunting with a variety of different arrow heads available to add to the mix. Anyway, Keep up the great work, and I will be eagerly looking forward to whatever else you put up!

[@drsrussandpaula]

Miquael Miquael... good to hear from you .... and yes youi have a very efficient air rifle that should provide years of enjoyment and even critter control ... maybe even a deer or two.... please keep us in your air gun experience loop ... helping us help everyone stay air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@fanaticsforpneumatics6005]

Why won’t the bully shoot the air bolts? Don’t they just stick into the end of the barrel?

[@jpochron]

Enjoied your Video Dr.Ross. Like to know what type of scopes you used on both of these rifles? Thanks again and God Bless

[@drsrussandpaula]

Jeff Pochron ... one of my favorite scopes isnt made any longer ... it had a leveler built right into it... plus all of the other features I look for. Consider going to Field Supply . com and typing in scopes ... then look for two Center Point ( Crosman) refurbished scopes at half their normal prices... one is approximately $ 40 and the other approximately $60. these are not the cheap scopes that they put on low cost rifles. Consider the $60+ scope which has 30 mm tube versus one inch tube ... and an illuminated retical ... both of which help during low light hunting...I have purchased 6 ot 7 of these without a problem.... also consider clicking onto the small circular photo of me to access our channel of more than 50 videos.... watch the one on Buying refurbished air rifles and accessories.. Dr. Russ

[@scinner28]

Now i know why it is 😀 both not regulated so you have to find the sweet spot in pressure ..man i was so dumb year's ago ..LUV you DR.Russ.

[@Lozanosjewelry888]

warranty on bulldog and customer service is where it's at! Although I noticed even though shorter barrel you had better grouping with Bully. Great job comparing.

[@russelljones4132]

Thanks for writing Armando Lozano ... The Bull Dog is best out of the box ... and the Bully is best if you play with the power adjustment screw until you get the velocity down to 950 are lower.... otherwise .... you will be hitting a larger circle of bullseyes... Consider clicking onto the small circle of myself ... accessing our library channel of 40 videos currently.... watch the one on Accuracy ... and another on Woodchucks.... Dr. Russ

[@lorenray9479]

I went thru a full size grocery bag of all pellets to find accuracy for 40 yd. Vermin and one hole fun. 6 guns and as many scopes led me to RWS, Diana and umarex. 34 .177 and 350 .22 brake barrels with hawk airmax. I still want better consistency and power. Maybe a pcp would enhance my retirement.

[@russelljones4132]

Loren Ray ... thanks for sharing.... if you keep the break barrels .... go to the heaviest pellets possible and lube them (don't use oil that runs) ... squeeze trigger like I describe in our video ... "Accuracy"..... lastly, upgrade to a PCP for retirement.... I did ... Dr. Russ

[@cedarspaw4180]

Great Video! I just got done telling my brother that I was trying to decide between these two bullpups when I found this video. Did you have any trouble using slugs in the Bully? Some of the reviews I've read said they can only fit Pellets in the magazine. From what I've read the Bulldog seems to accomidate a much wider range of ammo. Also, do you have a preference as to the locations of the cocking levers on each gun? The Bulldog's lever looks a bit awkward to me. Thanks so much for the info!!

[@russelljones4132]

Cedar's Paw ... it is good to hear from you. The contest between choosing between these two air rifles can be determined by the following. Do you have neighbors who might complain about "Back Yard Friendly"? Both have a loud ping sound in your right ear when you fire ... but pretty much ... only you hear that. The Bully is louder ... especially when it arrives with the air power on full. You will have to be somewhat savvy to taking off the stock and tuning it down almost a third to get the Bully accurate. KZbin Videos can help. The Bull Dog comes ready and accurate out of the box. Once the Bully is tuned in.... both are equal in their power. Bull Dog only comes in 357 ... and as far as I am concerned ... the only large bore caliber that you will ever need ...(remember that most deer rifles are 30 caliber.) Hatsan is a great Turkish company ... well respected in Europe ... but still trying to build a service company in America that answers the phone and fixes their rifles quickly. Nonetheless, the Bully comes in all of the calibers... and I wish mine was in my favorite ... 25 caliber ... which is very deadly and more quiet. Cedar ... we have some great Videos coming next month including a contest among two Hatsan 25 calibers ... and later a 357 contest with a crossbow. Consider becoming subscriber so that you dont miss those.... and please keep me in your loop of air gun experiences ... Dr. Russ

[@LordAn0bis]

If you still have the bulldog. I highly recommend the huma air regulator. It keeps the pressure constantly at the sweet spot. And you can still fill it at ful pressure

[@drsrussandpaula]

Good to hear from you Ch Bo .... great advice and it has been on my to do list too long... thanks.... Dr. Russ

[@Mustafa0949]

hey Dr. Russ, I enjoyed your video, I don't have the Hatsan, but I do have two bulldogs, one camo, with Pittbull magnum compensator on it and I love it, and the other with Donny FL Emporer on it. I like big bore guns since I've gotten into them, and Sother gunner is also one of the guys I follow. I also have two Texans, one .45, and one .50CFAnd my favorite riffle is my Seneca Dragon Claw.50cal..It shoots .50cal pellets and shoots air bolts, so lots of fun and good hunting. But, anyway, since I'm retired now, and loving it although I do miss shooting all those break barrel rifles but there's only so much time in a day and the wife keeps me busy ...lol but I liked your video and your range is something I wish I had, but I do have 45yds. so it's ok . Keep up the videos because we old guys can always learn something, thanks.

[@russelljones4132]

Mustafa0949 ... it is good to hear from you and thanks for the compliment. At age 75 ... my wife keeps me busy too. You have a great collection ... Please keep us in your loop of air gun experiences so that you can help us help everyone to stay Air Gun Sharp.... Dr. Russ

[@russelljones4132]

I would be happy with two Bull Dogs too...Dr. Russ

[@ice4278]

Hi Dr Russ I am seriously thinking about buying the Benjamin bulldog but I have a question before I do what is the difference between the shroud to keep down the noise and the moderator do you have both on your gun or just the moderator and how much does it cost to feel the scuba tank each thanks.

[@drsrussandpaula]

ice427 ...Its good to hear from you ice427 .... be sure to watch my recent video on "Moderators, Suppressors, Silencers and LCB" for a complete answer... just click onto the small circular photo of me to access our complete library of videos... Please stay in touch.... Dr. Russ

[@rpb1961]

What weight bullet do you use for deer hunting with the bulldog? Thanks great video.

[@russelljones4132]

rpb ... different weights will shoot different distances and different accuracies. It turns out that they are not all 357 caliber exactly.... and therefore may or may not gain a tight fit with your barrel. So try several .... start with heavier pellets or slugs and working down. I also recommend that you start with JSB's made in Checoslavakia... More expensive pellets are more consistent in sizes ... with a slight lube on them to make a good tight fit...allowing for more accuracy ... which at the end of the day ... is what all shooting is about. Dr. Russ

[@damianbaptiste3833]

Very impressive work comparing these two .357 rifles. Thank you!!! What of scope rings did you use for your bulldog? Did you use a riser mount?

[@drsrussandpaula]

Damian Baptiste ... sorry I am just now answering your question.... I was reviewing our comments and found yours unanswered... my appology. Anytime you are using a scope whose front lens is 40 mm or 50 mm ... you are going to need high rings that lift that scope up high... DR Russ

[@johnaverick7468]

I'm sorry, I noticed you Favored the Benjy. I Do like the longer barrel aspect. And the much longer guaranty. ( i've had glaring QC issues with Benji / Crossman 6 yrs back btw . But I just gotta have that side lever near my trigger. That just seems to carry a lot of weight with me in my purchase. Thank You so much for the comparison and little nuances that a lot of other vids just won't cover. Keep um commin.

[@russelljones4132]

John ... our next rifle comparison is about a month away comparing two 25 caliber rifles ... the Umarex Gauntlet and Air Venturi's Adventure. I feel the best service I can provide is to find and share any differences... and let each viewer place their own values on those differences. Accuracy is always at the top of my list ... and these two rifles were very... very close in that department. In fact, if I spent the time tuning the Bully down another hair ... it may have beat the Bull Dog. Good to hear from you .... Dr. Russ

[@2002ZRX1200R]

Stick to the best bell curve pressure, and it's hard to beat the bulldog with jsb's starring at 2900.

[@russelljones4132]

Phil Audio ... it is good to hear from you.... you are absolutely right.... plus you have to know something about air gun mechanics to slowly turn down the Bully's air pressure ... to the point that it begins to shoot accurately. Too many gunners strive for power and velocity .... and then let their air guns sit in a closet because they just aren't accurate for targets or critters. I found the Bull Dog accurate right out of the box. Please keep me in your loop of air gun experiences..... Dr. Russ

[@freedomchannel3656]

I just received my hatsan on .45 bully My slide when I cock the gun seems really stiff and I got to really pull back on it to cock it is yours like that? Also I have some Seneca .45 caliber slugs but when I put them in the cylinder/clip they move around in and out and it causes jamming issues because if the slug protrudes out too far of the front of the clip when you go to cock it the lead catches .. I just ordered some Hatsan .45 cal pellets I'll see if I can get a snugger fit out of those. Thanks for another good video ✊🇺🇲

[@russelljones4132]

Yes Freedom Channel .... the slide is stiff for about 100 rounds ... It should work out to something easier ... or it needs some sanding or grinding to allow it to move easier. Your pellets cannot be too long ... or they must be loaded one at a time to get them in. That 45 cal has some real knock down power. Keep me in your loop about your progress ... Dr. Russ

[@freedomchannel3656]

@@russelljones4132 I appreciate the reply and I'll keep you posted I'm probably going to do a video with it myself in a very near future I plan to buy a raw turkey and see what several different calibers does to the flesh and bone.

[@drsrussandpaula]

@@freedomchannel3656 It is my believe that there are several different 45 caliber air guns ... and the same bullet or slug will not work well in the others... The Hatsan Bully is designed for 45.5 diameter ammo ... while others are 45.2 ammo ... and yet others that are even larger... Round balls do not do well in any air gun that uses an open cylinder like Hatsan 45 does... since they are ready to roll out whenever possible... Dr. Russ

[@cheapairgunner1966]

I have the Bully in .45 and prefer the side lever action positioned more over the trigger area for follow up shots to the rearward/shoulder area that many bull pups have.

[@russelljones4132]

Cheap ... I like the side lever above the trigger too ... and should have included that in my video.... Another video in 2021 will allow that ..... Thanks for your input. Dr. Russ

[@Imperial_Rc]

How many feet per second does the billy push the largest round you had first shown?

[@russelljones4132]

702 fps Lawrence .... good to hear from you.... Dr. Russ

[@chrisp.5272]

I just started shouting the Benjamin Armada in .22 Caliber, and it’s an absolute tack driver and amazing small game rifle. I get 30 shots per fill, and liked it so much I ordered the .25 Caliber as well. I was debating between the Bulldog and Amanda .25 Caliber but decided on the .25 Cal as I can still shoot that in the backyard.

[@drsrussandpaula]

Chris ... please keep us in your loop ... I am interested in knowing what air guns and what calibers you have. I have everything up to the 72 caliber Zeus ... but my overall favorites are 25 and 357 calibers.... they fit my back yard perfectly ... and are backyard friendly... Dr. Russ

[@nsboost]

Great video! I just ordered a bulldog kit with the case/scope/bipod and got it for $800 shipped! Being a tinkerer… I don’t know if I’m more excited to shoot or mod the gun. Thanks again!

[@drsrussandpaula]

Good to hear from you nsboost... please keep in touch sharing your air gun experiences shooting or modifying your Bulldog... which I know you will love... Dr. Russ

[@drsrussandpaula]

nsboost... if you take all the poly off ... you will find an air gun that resembles all the rest. Dr. Russ

[@rogers1379]

You're the boss, Dr. Russ.

[@russjones7981]

Thank you Mr. L. Rogers

[@KINGBREAKBARREL]

@@russjones7981 I WAS JUST LOOKING AROUND ON KZbin AND BUMPED INTO YOUR CHANNEL YOU SEEM LIKE A NICE GENUINE PERSON LOVE YOUR VIDS LOOK FORWARD TO WATCHING MORE OF YOUR VIDS DR RUSS 👍👍👍

[@verZatile_bmotp]

Thanks for the informative video. I have the Hatsan Hercules Bully .45 caliber. I see that you're using .356 caliber rounds for your .357 caliber bully. How many diameters will fire properly for the Bully? .357, .356, .355? FYI, I just thought about cast bullets for reloads last night and saw your video today and see all the cast bullets I was considering last night, so your feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thanks

[@drsrussandpaula]

verZatile it is good to hear from you... and I know you love your Bully like I love mine. Last year, it was difficult getting a lot of the ammo that use to be available due to Covid. My favorite was 35 or 9 mm.... but when it wasnt available, I experimented with several other sizes that never seemed as good as the 35 or 9 mm. So today, I am back to JSB 35 caliber... and happy with them ... easily killing woodchucks at 85 yards. Please keep us in your loop ... Dr. Russ

[@Bigbopperairguns]

I would love the opportunity to shoot from your deck to see how far it will shoot. I don't have that kind off room.

[@russelljones4132]

Brad Arnett ... a lot of requests to do the same ... perhaps too many ... but anticipate some sort of get together planned and announced before winter comes again... Keep us in your loop of air gun experiences ...Dr. Russ

[@cliffb.2416]

Dr. Ross, Question about the moderator on the Hatsan. Is it the DonnyFL shroud adapter and what size moderator size is it for? Is it? I see you answered my question in a comment below. So the normal adapter on Donny's website for the Hatsan shroud will / has a hole big enough for a .357 cal? Same with the moderator? Is the thread pitch still 1/2-20?

[@russelljones4132]

Cliff Backler .... good to hear from you. DonnyFL has 3 or 4 size moderators. The one in this video is the Emporer... and is the largest. They still come for specific calibers ... so that the pellet will pass successfully through the moderator. The big concern is getting the correct shroud adapter to fit the rifle ... and to also fit the moderator. You really need to communicate those requirements with DonnyFL ... who will then mail you the correct adapter and moderator for your rifle. Please keep me in your loop of experiences with air guns. Dr. Russ

[@cliffb.2416]

@@russelljones4132 thanks! I'm thinking about getting a .30cal, but the .357 sounds interesting? I was thinking the Hatsan Hercules rifle (double bottle), refurb (way cheaper). I have numerous pcp's, but not anything bigger then a .25cal. Would love something with more power. Maybe even try slugs out of it for longer range knock down power. Thanks for your video!

[@russjones6497]

@@cliffb.2416 Cliff B... I just launched a KZbin Video on buying the right caliber air gun for you.... if you haven't purchased your next air gun yet... you might want to watch it... Dr. Russ

[@lindseyzacek5211]

I would also prefer a locking safety on the Benjamin bulldog trigger safety works just well but accidents do happen I would prefer to have a locking trigger slider on the side of the gun

[@russelljones4132]

Great idea Lindsey ... and it was great to hear from you again. Please keep us in your loop. Dr. Russ

[@juggernautherculesgarcia6076]

I also noticed that you have a bunch of magazines ready to continue shooting the Bully, I’m stuck with the choice of which to purchase, bully or bulldog, I want the immense power, loudness, and accuracy with many shots per fill for I’d use a hand pump, I’m very strong so I don’t mind pumping, so which should I get , question is which is stronger fpe

[@russelljones4132]

Thanks for sending me a note Gustavo. I trust you and your family will enjoy a great Christmas this week. The Bully arrives set at maximum air power ... but not maximum air power and accurate too. You will need to get it down to 850 up to 950 feet per second before you see your pellets become accurate. This will take some time .... taking your rifle apart several times and screwing down the power key substantially... The Benjamin will likely arrive and be accurate. Using a hand pump ... you will want to pump the air back from 2100 lbs to 2600 lbs. The Bully has a larger tank so it will take a little longer. Both will require moderators if you need them to be "back yard friendly." Otherwise ... you will be happy with both. Therefore, I recommend that you order the one that looks the best to you. Please write again with your air rifle experiences. Dr. Russ

[@gulfrep61]

Liked your video on these guns. Good and to the point informative info to anyone who may be considering a future purchase. Do you have a preferred dealer for your airgun rifles and supplies? I currently have a .25 cal. Benjamin, but I'm considering upgrading to a .357 to hunt larger game. Keep up the great videos!

[@russelljones4132]

good to hear from you Gulfrep61.... keep in mind that everyone's backyard is different ... and with different neighbors. I am fortunate to be able to use 25 caliber in mine ... which allows me to shoot year round at targets and critters. When you upgrade to higher calibers you run into several problems ... for example ... 357 might not be backyard friendly any more... even with a moderator...second you can only use big bore air guns in the fall during a few weeks of hunting season.... and lastly, your state may not have hunting laws that allow air guns yet ... so check all of those. Aside from this long answer... I recommend the Benjamin Bull Dog is you are not well versed in making power adjustments on air guns .... The bulldog arrives ready to go with a magazine that hold 5 pellets.... the Bully requires numerous adjustments on power and trigger to obtain maximum accuracy at around 950 fps velocity. However, its magazine holds 8 pellets I believe... Please keep us in your loop of air gun experiences... so that you can help us ... help everyone become air gun sharp... Dr. Russ

[@russelljones4132]

Gulfrepe91... good to hear from you ... and thanks for the compliment.... please keep us in your air gun info loop ... helping us ... help everyone wanting to stay air gun sharp..... Certainly Pyramyd Air has some of the best info on every air gun possible... so begin by reading up on your favorites there ... along with customer responses.... Many of the Air guns I have personally purchased were a little cheaper at Field Supply for Hatsan ... and of course Hatsan's offices in Florida where you can buy some refurbished air guns... which I have liked. Also Ebay and Amazon ... Hopefully these sources will help you ... Dr. Russ

[@c.l.j.reallife1730]

Im debating on either gun in this video. Have been for a few weeks now. I really want one but am stuck on deciding which one would be my best first airgun?? Any help

[@russjones7981]

CLJ .... It is good to hear from you this morning and I can understand the concern in your question... I assume you are considering the 357 caliber because that is the only caliber that the bulldog comes in.... I would go with the Benjamin bull dog because it is all set up for you when you get it and the hats and bully requires some skill and knowledge to down tune it could be an accurate pair rifle you still have considerable expense and determining a method of filling your air rifle with air.... If all of this seems expensive to you then I would change to the new air rifle from Air Venturi ...their new Avenger in 25 caliber ... you can get it online from Pyramyd air and Arizona Air Guns... I will be testing it soon but there are 6 or 7 tests on KZbin already.... it comes with an air regulator for $300... an unbelievable value... leaving money in your pocket for an air source.... stay away from hand pumps.... I hope this information helps you we have some excellent videos coming up this summer and some hunting ones coming up in the fall consider subscribing so that you don't miss them I hope to hear from you again and you can give me a report on your new air rifle...Dr. Russ.

[@c.l.j.reallife1730]

@@russjones7981 Thank you for the response. I agree, i was just going to purchase the bulldog today than i just came across your message. Yes, you are right, the expense is fairly on the large end but at the end of it im sure ill be happy. I will also be purchasing the nomad 2 air compressor for my air source. Seems like a reliable source. I hope so anyway, haha. I have subscribed to you' r channel after i came across your first video. Out of all the airgun videos on youtube I can relate to your choices on which guns you own. Each one you have literally are the guns i was debating on buying. Besides one i think which is the hatson bullboss. I wish they made that up to 357 caliber. But anyways thanks again. Look forward to the next video.

[@airpower7692]

what slugs fit in the magazine I'm trying buy some but need to know which ones

[@russelljones4132]

Air Power... it is great to hear from you. Both of these 357 calibers (really 35 calibers) certainly have the power to shoot slugs. While the key is to purchase the heaviest pellets possible for this caliber ... the reverse is true with slugs. I have better accuracy shooting the lightest slugs possible. I believe there is a sweet spot in there for these two air rifles. The round ball bearings in 35 caliber are not as accurate ... so stick with the first two. Do not buy 357 magnum slugs at a gun show... they are too large and can get stuck in the barrel which requires a rod to push them back down to the chamber. Only purchase 35 caliber slugs. Please keep me in your loop of air gun experiences... Dr. Russ

[@airpower7692]

@@russelljones4132 thank you very much have a great day

[@dr6638]

Great information. Do you know where I can get the arrows to fit the Benjamin Bulldog? Also I just bought a Benjamin armada .25 and was wonder what it am able to hunt with it? Thank you

[@russelljones4132]

Good to hear from you Dennis Rounsaville. I don't believe arrows can be shot from any air gun that is made to shoot pellets. I believe they are only available in air guns made for that purpose. I also believe that they come with up to 3 arrows ... and that more can be ordered off of eBay and or the source where you purchased that special made arrow air gun. Your Benjamin Armada was made to hunt small and medium size critters ... up to and including a coyote. I know of a few who have successfully shot deer with a 25 caliber air gun... but I believe many more are wounded than harvested. Check with your own state hunting laws about what and when you can hunt with an air gun. It is interesting to know that in every case I have checked ... that they are limited to powder rifle rules and not bow and arrow rules. Please keep me in your loop of air gun experiences ... Dr. Russ

[@cedarspaw4180]

Not to Correct Dr. Russ, as I am truly grateful for this video, but if you search Airgundepot for .357 Air bolts you will find the arrows you're looking for. I've seen them used in the Bulldog, but I do not know if you can use them in the Hatsan Bully. (Personally I stick to my bows and crossbows when it comes to arrows.)

[@outdoordiscoveryandadventu7603]

@@russelljones4132 Thanks the Benjamin armada is a great pellet gun and my son says it is not loud so he can watch me shoot it.

[@blackswordshinobi]

Hi Dr Russ i own the bulldog357 and put lot bell on it an swizzles yes get lot weight on it i put bi pod and laser and good scope next flash light i did put supereon Ronin add some barrel length of 41 inchs but real question really want to ask did you really put big fat whole threw a cast iron pot soon or later i will hit some steel at 100 yards

[@drsrussandpaula]

Blackswordshiobi ... yes those holes were put in a cast iron frying pan with a Benjamin 357 and a Bully 35. The holes did not appear on the first shot at 65 yards (be careful with ricochet back at you) ... but after about 19 rounds, the holes started appearing. Now target steel plates are different and are not made of cast iron... but rather rolled steel ... and holes will not appear on them until they are hit by a 50 caliber powder gun... Dr. Russ

[@blackswordshinobi]

@@drsrussandpaula your target option look like fun to try but your right be careful i was think tin pie pans be for go to the steel

[@ihaterats1234]

What size is that adapter for the hatsan or where can it be purchased. Thanks 👍

[@russelljones4132]

Craig ... good to hear from you. The adapter and the modulator are available from the same Ronin Company in Florida ... together or separately. I hope we can continue to be of value to you .... in your quest to be Air Gun Sharp. Dr. Russ

[@joedokes8641]

Donny FL is the maker of these moderators @donnyfl.com....... Ronin is a model name they make several for most airguns.

[@makerofmanythings8447]

I was wondering if you de- cock the trigger with the mag in place and a pellet in the chamber, will it double feed another pellet if the mag is installed when the gun is recocked? Does the mag need to be removed after it has been de- cocked, and shoot it and then the mag can be reinstalled for normal use? Thank you very much for the video, great job!!👍😎👍

[@russelljones4132]

Maker of many things ... it is good to hear from you again. I don't know of any way to de-cock a rifle with the mag in the rifle ... without the possibility of loading a first or second pellet into the barrel. In de cocking... your lever or bolt has to go all the way forward and that is likely loading another round into the rifle. Please keep us in your loop of experiences.... Dr. Russ

[@makerofmanythings8447]

@@russelljones4132 I just bought a Hatsan Hercules bully. 45 caliber. Have you had any experience with one? Thank you Dr. RUSS.

[@russjones6497]

@@makerofmanythings8447 That Bully in 45 caliber is a gun I just ordered ... so no experience yet... Please share any experiences that you have had... Dr. Russ

[@drsrussandpaula]

@@russjones6497 ... the Hatsan Bully 45 caliber is designed for 45.4 + ammo with a barrel that is 45.7 in diameter. Some slugs are only 45.2 and they can easily fall out of the cylinder .... as will round ball bearings .... so I believe you need 45.4 up to 45.7 ammo... You also have to know slug length and not exceed the width of the magazine cylinder ... or you wont get it into the breach...so we need to be careful and measure any 45 caliber ammo other than Hatsan 45 caliber pellets. Dr. Russ

[@motorgearhead]

Did you notice any improvement in grouping with moderators installed?

[@russelljones4132]

None at all Motorgearhead.... Not on any of my air guns with moderators ... Moderators have a hole thru them that is slightly larger than the caliber of the pellet that they were made for. In fact, I have read that on rare occassions, a moderator is flawed and one of the internal components does get in the way... which is quickly determined and must be taken apart and trimmed ... Good to hear from you .... Dr. Russ

[@Bigbopperairguns]

I shoot a 145 Grain Benjamin ballistic tip 899 FPS, (I have it on video) that's 260 FPE. That was quite the kick. LOL Nice video!!

[@Bigbopperairguns]

That was with the Benjamin bulldog

[@roonimac]

@@Bigbopperairguns what all work done to it though?

[@Bigbopperairguns]

@@roonimac nothing I don't know how

[@vetteconnoisseur9531]

Your chronograph had a hiccup...I watched your vid and there's NO WAY you gained over 200fps on one shot with a stock Bulldog...in fact your chrono results are quite low as I'm averaging 775fps for the 1st 5 shots on a 3100psi fill

[@ChildofYHVH]

I have a question. Are you familiar with the Hatsan flashpup qe? I’m looking to buy my first pcp and was wondering if this would be a good choice?

[@drsrussandpaula]

Childofyhvh .... it is good to hear from you again.... and yes I own one and the flashpup is an excellent gun ... particularly in 25 caliber... Dr. Russ

[@ChildofYHVH]

@@drsrussandpaula Ty for your response. I truly appreciate it. Looking forward to owning my first pcp!!

[@drsrussandpaula]

@@ChildofYHVH You will love that Hatsan Bull Pup ... its small and light to carry ... and consider 25 caliber for it.. Dr. Russ

[@ohioutony100]

What scope is that and how much is it? Finally would you recommend that same scope or a different one for the bulldog?

[@russelljones4132]

Good to hear from you again ohiotony100 ... I may have answered this question earlier for you ... please get back to me if I didn't... Dr. Russ

[@nationalmatch1]

Informative, interesting and relaxing all at the same time!!

[@drsrussandpaula]

National Match ... it is good to hear from you ... and thanks for the compliment.. please accept my apology for taking 3 months to answer .... Dr. Russ

[@ricardosmith6479]

Great video thank you for sharing. I on the bully and I love it but one thing you forgot to mention was that the bulldog take Polly Max and bully chamber is too short to cycle poly Mags. In addition the bulldog can also take The nozzle or bullet.

[@russelljones4132]

Ricardo ... thank you for your response. I understand that the Polly Mag is now available in a Short Polly Mag ... which may allow the Bull Dog to shoot it. Secondly, the Bull Dog can shoot slugs and especially the 357 Nosler. Thanks for writing ... I will include these items in the future. I hope to hear from you again. Dr. Russ

[@jessarenas9540]

Which one would be good for hunting once a week which is more reliable?in your opinion

[@russelljones4132]

Jess... thanks for writing. Both would be great in the field ... the Bully weighing a pound or two more with scope etc.... might be a distraction over time. If you need a moderator, the Bully will be longer too. That Bully would also require several days of de-tuning to achieve accuracy... at least mine did. Of course, if you decide on a caliber different from 357 magnum... you will have to pick the Bully. It will also provide 50% more shots once filled with air. The key is you determining which features mean the most to you. Both rifles are great ... and I would be hard pressed to sell one over the other. Dr. Russ

[@joelcantrell7931]

What is your experience in bulldog with flat based pellets

[@russelljones4132]

Joel Cantrell ... it is good to hear from you ... Not sure what you mean when you say "flat based pellets"..... if you are referring to flat nose pellets ... then I havent used them in the Bull Dog.... Flat Nosed Pellets would be used for competition using circular targets because they make a perfect round hole in paper versus tears found using other types of pellets. I am not sure I have even seen flat nose pellets for 357 since most competitions use 177 caliber. I hope I answered your question. Dr. Russ

[@kenfan5666]

Hey Dr. Russ!!! I decided to take your advice and reconsider the Benjamin Bulldog .457 vs. the Benjamin .357. So I'm watching and rewatching your video. What would you consider to be the maximum effective range for the .357 Bulldog vs. the .457 Bulldog? Thanks again for the excellent video. Stay Safe, Be Well, God Bless.

[@drsrussandpaula]

Ken Fan ... good to hear from you ... I don't have a 457 Bull Dog even though I have 45 caliber in two other air rifles.... and I still prefer the 357.... because it is my believe that the same compression chamber and air pressure remains the same... so with that info... along with the fact that the larger caliber minimizes the shots per fill to only 4 - 8 ... so you spend more time filling ... the suppressor is larger and more expensive to quiet it down ... the cost for slugs is more .... you shoot it less .... and the range is about the same.... 80 to 110 yards... Dr. Russ

[@kenfan5666]

@@drsrussandpaula Thanks for the prompt response!!! I'm not sure if I can legally hunt deer in Md. or Va. with a .357 caliber air gun. I'm pretty sure it is legal with .45 or higher. Do you have any recommendations? Also, do you know if it's worth it to buy the .357 Bulldog that shoots bolts is more effective in harvesting deer with bolts vs slugs? Thanks again for all your excellent tips and advice. Stay Safe, Be Well, God Bless.

[@drsrussandpaula]

@@kenfan5666 ... it is good to hear from you again... go on Pyramid Air and check their hunt license sections for all 50 states. It is my belief that 357 is about as high as any state goes... and I haven't heard of any state that requires of 45 caliber or higher... Dr. Russ

[@KGisthename]

Dr. Ross my little range in my backyard in Phoenix is 28 yards, so if my neighbors are out in their patio they would be about 45 yards away. Both are laid back people, but I dont want to overstep and be obnoxious, would you consider the Hatsan Bully backyard friendly for very ocasional couple of shots? Seeing that my backyard is not like your air gun heaven of a property 😄 It would only be a couple of shots here and there but that's it. It would be equiped with a DonnyFL Emperor moderator and I am thinking either the 35 or the 45. It is hard to tell over the phone speaker just how loud it is moderated.

[@drsrussandpaula]

KG for your size back yard.... I would drop down to 25 caliber.... keep in mind that I have 3 of these bully's .... in 25... 35 .... and 45 calibers.... and you have to downsize the power as well as the size pellet or slug you are shooting so that you achieve a 775 to 950 fps velocity.... don't worry about that 25 caliber... with good placement it can still kill wild hogs, coyotes and woodchucks..... Take a Sam's or Costco pie over to them ... thanking them for not complaining about your air gun.... and let them know if there are any destructive critters or rabid animals in the area.... to let you know... Dr. Russ

[@KGisthename]

@@drsrussandpaula Thanks and good idea.

[@davidb.8786]

Have you upgraded the power on your Benjamin do you feel it's necessary

[@russjones6497]

David B.... it is good to hear from you .... I haven't found it necessary... usually upgrading air power is at the expense of accuracy... I,ve killed a tough Woodchuck at 96 yards with it... it took 3 shots but the first kept him in place...Accuracy was key in that shot... However, please share your air gun experiences with us ... helping keep everyone air gun sharp. Dr. Russ

[@russjones6497]

David B ... In the future ... I might increase power after I check velocity and energy with some heavier slugs.... than the Heavy JSB 35 cal. pellets I am using....Dr. Russ

[@bryantrumbo7645]

So I've been looking into the Benjamin bulldog for some time now and really want to know if it would be effective on coyotes at around 100 yards I have a Shin sung 9mm and I'm just not sure with the power never took it out but want to but don't want to just wound a animal that is intended to be food or a nuisance animal and where did you pick it up and how much really looking for a deal on the Benjamin bulldog

[@russelljones4132]

Good to hear from you Bryan Trumbo .... I picked my Bull Dog up from a man on ebay ....and then spent another $300 with Pit Bull for an extended moderator that I installed myself.... helping make this large bore air rifle .... back yard friendly ...The 357 magnum ... and 35 caliber ... and 9 mm airguns all shoot the same size pellet. I believe mine will kill a coyote at 100 yards ... as long as it was a head shot .... practice until you believe you can hit that 4 inch circle yourself.... otherwise ... wait until the coyote comes in closer.... Consider clicking onto the small circular photo of myself and accessing our entire library of 40 videos.... and then consider watching the one on Accuracy as well as another two on Pellets .... Please keep us in your loop of air gun experiences.... helping us ... help everyone stay air gun sharp.... Dr. Russ