Best Amish Potato Salad Recipe! Traditional & Creamy (2023)

Amish potato salad is a delicious and traditional dish that is perfect for gatherings and picnics. With its creamy dressing, tender potatoes, and flavorful seasonings, it's sure to be a crowd-pleaser. The Amish take pride in their simple yet hearty recipes, and this potato salad is no exception. Whether served as a side dish or enjoyed on its own, Amish potato salad is a classic favorite that never goes out of style.
#PamperedChefAThon2023 #pamperedchef #potatosaladrecipe
In this video, I will share the best Amish Potato Salad recipe that I have found. Amish are know for a cooked salad dressing recipe. I am sharing with you how to make this Potato salad from scratch. I use serval pampered chef tools to prep the salad. Check out the coolest picnic cooler for your sides dishes at a outdoor event.
Click here for a downloadable Recipe Card bit.ly/44cz4la
Click here to find the Pampered Chef-A-THon Playlist
• #PamperedChefAThon2023...
Michelle's Open Pampered Chef Party. www.pamperedchef.com/party/vZ...
Pampered Chef-A-Thon. Our intention is to share our favorite Pampered Chef tools, recipes, tips/tricks. Whatever you want to share in a fun and positive way is great! We all have unique styles, and Michelle, Ginger, and Tiffany are all excited to see what you have to share. Please note that a recent change of scenery has brought Tiffany from MuddNMascara Homestead to this team of co-hosts!
Monday, June 26, 2023 is the finale, to be hosted at 2:00 p.m. Pacific/5:00 p.m. Eastern. Viewers need to comment on each video to be eligible for prizes in the random drawing! They do not need to present to win. Unfortunately, only US residents in the lower 48 will be eligible for prizes. Encourage them to add a thoughtful comment and something that they like about Pampered Chef, if they wish.
My Steam Canner amzn.to/3Xslfgt
The Ball Canning book amzn.to/3Ng2d84
My Canning Ladle amzn.to/3NvLWgF
My jar lifter (spring loaded) amzn.to/3B4pplm
My Amazon Storefront www.amazon.com/shop/mennonite...
Links to Amazon.com are affiliate links.
Buying via my links will earn me a small commission from Amazon and this does not impact the price at all. Buying like this is a great way to support this channel and the costs involved in making content.
Thanks for your support!
Follow me on Instagram at bit.ly/3offzXm The_mennonite_farmhous
✅ Subscribe & Never miss a video!
🛎 Hit the Bell to receive a notification when I upload new videos!
👍🏼 Thumbs UP my video if you enjoy watching, please!
Contact Information
[e-mail]
Mennonite Farmhouse
P.O. Box 194
Needmore, PA 17238
00:00 Introduction
01:30 Ingrendients
02:15 Cooking potatoes
03:10 Food Safety Handling Message
03:39 Cooking Hardboiled Eggs
04:27 Peeling Farm Fresh Eggs with Instant Pot
04:53 Chopping Hard Boiled Eggs
05:26 Prep Work
06:26 Cooking the Salad Dressing
08:58 Assembling the Salad
11:12 Pampered Chef Cool & Serve
11:53 Howard's Test Taste

[@BigValleyLiving]

Wow! This looks like an excellent recipe! I never thought to use the pastry blender for chopping eggs. Thank you SO much for participating in this collaboration! I learned the carrot peeling trick just now!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

You are so welcome!

[@karenjohnson6723]

I’ve used my pastry blender to chop eggs for years

[@lindapetersen1800]

I use my potato masher for my eggs !!!

[@lindapetersen1800]

LeAnn You can tell by the smile on Howard's face it is GREAT Like Tony the Tiger says !!! Howard has a smile in his eyes also !!!

[@The_Purringlady]

We like a wet potato salad. Thanks LeAnn for your authentic Amish potato salad ❤😊

[@janetstryczek3311]

Thank you. Absolutely enjoy you showing everything laid out to put together ! Also, showing simple techniques that some think everyone knows & we don't.

[@mary-catherine9237]

“This is your best one yet!” Lol. Howard is a character. Does he know how fortunate he is to have a good woman cook for him? I am definitely going to try this. Thanks and God Bless!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

I thought so too! I hope to improve on making videos. He is a character, a good man! I feel God put me in his life to serve him, he deserves it! God Bless you!

[@wendyzimmerman6002]

I love pampered chef I have so many pampered chef items I probably have more than I don’t

[@itsmyrenaissancegrandma]

Love Amish Potatoe Salad. 😋

[@greywolfoutdoorshomestead9962]

Chrissy is a pampered chef consultant.she loves doing it.i pray that people can give her partys so she can feel better about her self

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

I didn’t know that… I will keep her in mind!

[@greywolfoutdoorshomestead9962]

He's kinda Camara shy huh?

[@theonewhomjesusloves7360]

Who is Chrissy?

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

@@theonewhomjesusloves7360 His wife.

[@jacoleneiu3856]

I like mine wet and a little dill. I've never seen this recipe before. I can't wait to try it. 😊

[@sandhillmom2]

Never ever heard of making a dressing like this. However, your hubby’s reaction convinced me I need to try it!😋

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Hope you enjoy

[@reasbey]

This a very old-fashioned potato salad recipe. This is how my grandmother made it.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Yes, you are right

[@thomastommy1192]

This looks delicious. I want to try it soon. As for the vegetable peeler, I never even saw one till I was a grown man. I bought my first one at the Ames Dept Store. They have been out of business for nearly 40 years, lol. Thumbs up thanks for sharing. Stay well & safe everyone.

[@marygallagher3428]

The potato salad looks sooooo good!

[@imaprepper1866]

Leeann, I love potatoe salad. My husband and I would go to Sugar Creek at least once a month. Our favorite was their potato salad and the Amish cole slaw. Would love for you to do this recipe. Thank you for the recipe and God bless.

[@WillowsGarden]

Oh LeAnn, that looks delicious and Howard really liked it. Have a blessed night!

[@rachalnocchi5600]

Wet, but not sopping for me! I love pickles in my potato salad.❤

[@coreydalton7716]

Looks like a good recipe to try. Please try a damp cloth under your cutting board to allow a safe cutting surface. Chef tip 🔪

[@helenamorozov7256]

Salad looks so good Thanks for sharing this recipe with us God bless

[@ja_Iam]

Can’t wait to fix this. I’ve never used a cooked dressing on my potato salad. It looks absolutely decadent. Well done 👍👍👍👍👍

[@NannyTam]

I love potato salad, and yours looks amazing. Thanks for sharing your recipe with us, LeAnne! 🥰

[@oakleafwellness]

Will have to try this one the next time I need a potato salad!

[@theresalinden3797]

Love Howards taste-testing in every video. 😅❤❤

[@kellymae2421]

Me too :)

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

The best!

[@lyndamclean6786]

Glad to be here from Eastern Canada

[@kellymae2421]

Me too. Nova Scotia. Always amazes me when I run across someone ‘from the area’. Lol

[@lindajames4122]

Me three - Cape Breton

[@crowdedisolation]

I love potato salad with mayo, mustard, sweet relish, eggs, onions, and a tad of sugar and vinegar

[@jacoleneiu3856]

Howard 😂😂 He's loving it. I'm sold. 😅

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Yes! His smile says it all. I wish I could have shown him licking the spatula today!

[@jacoleneiu3856]

@@MennoniteFarmhouse 🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@YogiHollowFarm]

Interesting recipe to include carrots. Never did that before. And the dressing…very interesting. Will have to try it! Yum!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

I can I will send you a video of Howard LIcking his plate

[@ednamyers5760]

I love pampered chef... and all of your videos.. you do a awesome job and make it fun.. thanks for sharing

[@jannie5559]

This potato salad looks very tasty, will definitely be trying your recipe...we have loved all your recipes we have tried❤

[@christine882]

That potato salad looks delicious.. plus I love the skins on mine too and that dressing really looked interesting and delicious ❤️

[@pareneesc]

I made this, the dressing was sweet, but I loved it! Thank you for sharing your recipe!❤

[@MimisDishes]

One of my favorite way to make potato salad..thanks LeAnn..plus the freeze and go it awesome.😊❤

[@annelefevre9457]

Howard and you are funny…..you both bring joy and make me laugh. I’ve never had a cooked dressing on my potato salad. I’m going to try it. Is it the farm fresh eggs that make the dressing so yellow….or just that teaspoon of mustard? Oils you use the same dressing to do a macaroni salad? Fun video. My mouth was watering. Howard is a husband that enjoys food!!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thanks so much Anne! I am glad we can brighten your day!

[@MyAussieGardenKitchen]

G'day Leanne. The peeler trick, now sure, but the word peeler is a sore point with me right now... My fave peeler of about 20 years went missing and I assume someone mixed it with rubbish for the bin. 😭 It never dulled, rusted etc... Made in Germany if I remember correctly. Anyway... The potato salad looks so good. Have not made one in a while and you have me craving it. Winter here, so indoor bbq this weekend I think (everything gets grilled on a super hot rippled skillet). Oh and no "shrimps on the barbie" 🙄 Take care. Daz.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

G'Day Daz, Get the taters dug up! I am sure they are ready! I should send you video of Howard licking the spatula! oh wait that would be rude. I hope all is well with you! All the Best, LeAnne

[@heatherkennedy9973]

my sister makes the best potatoe salad and she always usespickile juice

[@Wendyann1100]

Never made homemade dressing. Also love the idea of slicing eggs with the pastry blender.❤

[@Jiffybob47]

I demand more eggs! Just kidding it looks delicious. I just enjoy the egg texture ❤ 😊 love your videos! I also didn't expect the pastry blender on the eggs, so I learned something today! Much love from Michigan! ❤

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thanks so much! 😊 I agree on the eggs. thanks for watching!

[@tracypaulaiti3562]

Looks wonderful!! Gonna make this. I have a tip to keep your cutting board from moving, put a wet paper towel underneath.

[@swaters3462]

I’m going to try this soon. I’m intrigued by the cooked salad dressing, and the celery seed. A trick I learned from m friend’s mother is to also chop a few green onion and add. Provides good color contrast and crunch. My favorite Pampered Chef items are the stainless steel mixing bowls with lids and silicone non slip bottoms.

[@PC-mz5su]

Hi LeAnn, that potatoe salad looks awesome I will have to make God bless!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Hope you enjoy

[@rosemaryoutler2423]

This brought back memories of my grandma's potato salad. Thank you so much for this, as now I can make Nana's potato salad!!!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Yay!!! I’m glad to hear this!

[@angelacooper4043]

Yum yum

[@ellengrace4609]

This is close to my mom’s except no carrots and add bacon. Also, she sometimes just mixed Mayo and Italian dressing instead of mixing all of the homemade dressing. Shortcut! 😃 Everyone loved her potato salad!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Sounds great!

[@roothogordie2391]

Thank you. Gonna make

[@katehouser3683]

That is a interesting way to make potato salad. It looks good and I bet it tastes good too. I need that knife.

[@kathleenarcher-il8iq]

Leanne, love this recipe. Can't wait to try it. Thanks😊

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

It's so good!

[@kathleenarcher-il8iq]

@@MennoniteFarmhouse I wish you were my neighbor😊

[@elaineengland]

Thanks for the great idea!!

[@Garlands_Fabrication]

lol the flavor! Looks good

[@leighannroemer3340]

I am going to have to try this one soon!

[@irenesgardenandmore]

❤❤ thanks for sharing !

[@Onedayatatimefarmstead7177]

The "LIVE" was so much fun!🎉🎉❤

[@jamiescountryliving]

Oh wow! That LOOKS so so good!! I need to try this recipe 😋

[@kimscheafer8630]

Looks yummy

[@kathryncurry8728]

I’ve always wanted to know how to make a great Amish potato salad, thank you! ❤

[@kburke3849]

This looks delicious! I love a boiled dressing on potato salad, thanks for the great recipe!

[@joylouise5417]

Love that dressing. Thank you for the recipe card. After seeing your husband’s sandwich, now I know where to come for a sandwich! Amazing!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

You are so welcome! Come on over!

[@MuddMascaraHomestead]

Looks good and sounds crunchy!!

[@abbiebarnes2200]

is this the recipe that wallmart sells in their delis? I rarely eat someone else's potato salad but the Amish potato salad they sell here is so good!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

I think I have had it once, I know this is better than that.

[@Angela_Alaimo]

Harold cracks me up. And i really like your recipes almost as much as he does. Take care xo

[@donnaingle391]

Oh girl! I’m going to try this!

[@angelamott8183]

❤

[@peggetennant]

That is my mother’s recipe too. I always make it that way except for the carrots. I will try carrots the next time. Thanks.

[@oldnanz]

Okay I just had potato salad. I’ll be making this the next time. Thanks LeAnn

[@featheredfriendshomestead]

I have never tried pampered chef before the items look really nice. I can believe how easy the fresh eggs peeled in the instant pot I'm definitely going to try that thank you for the tip. Oh yummy your potato salad looks absolutely delicious thanks for sharing this recipe I'm definitely going to try it.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

So good!

[@MyTableofThree]

So interesting! It’s my first time seeing a potato salad like that but it sounds tasty! I love Pampered Chef too.

[@tonyshepard2022]

I lo e all the new gadgets I have seen and the different uses for them

[@user-in2lu6mp7p]

Looks great. I will try for sure.

[@sarahwieland3243]

Wow! I was doing things way wrong! Can’t wait to try this recipe. Thk u for sharing.

[@justme2059]

Another awesome recipe!!! Can’t wait to try it tomorrow. We like ours creamy.

[@ArielleViking]

Oh my word, what a wonderful and delicious looking potato salad. A winner for sure and you taught a great carrot peeling hack. Great job LeeAnn. ❤👍

[@kellierobison9743]

This looks wonderful.

[@madmecyr]

I've never done the cooked dressing before; looks like one I need to try since Howard thought it was the best one yet :)

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

He has been licking his plate clean every time he has had it since!

[@janiceweikel4990]

Looks delicious. I never thought of using the pastry blender either. God bless ❤

[@jerrilynernsting903]

Pyummy

[@mollypurcellmealprep]

this looks delicious :)

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thank you 😋

[@wendyzimmerman6002]

I like my potato salad with lots of juice I have the old cool and serve bowl it’s round

[@jo-annjewett198]

Yum!! Potato salad is my favorite!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

So good!

[@LytonaKirtz]

Definitely going to make this. It looks very good.

[@TheInquisitiveFarmwife]

Another great recipe, Leanne!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thanks so much! 😊

[@jerriscollins-ruth9019]

Looks very good LeAnn

[@lindacurran4179]

Wet. It looks so good

[@2leelouCreates]

That looks delicious! Thanks for sharing the recipe.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

My pleasure 😊

[@mayonnaiseeee]

I learn so much watching your videos. It's not only the recipe, but all these other tips too. Thanks again, this salad looks wonderful.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

So nice of you to say! This recipe is a winner!

[@Onedayatatimefarmstead7177]

I can't wait to try this. Michelle gave a shout-out to this recipe.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Please do!

[@brendatilton1198]

Le Ann, I used your recipe for the dressing in making my deviled eggs. Everyone said best deviled eggs ever!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

I going to have to try that! I’m glad everyone is happy!

[@beckysteinmiller338]

Howard is right it’s the flavor!!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

I told him you said so!

[@granmarene]

Looks delicious love potato salad. Thank you for Sharing

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thank you so much 🙂

[@billclifford4621]

Love your channel, ty

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Glad you enjoy it!

[@Katwinser1958]

Man that looks delicious

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thank you!

[@sherryeichelberger7647]

Definitely trying that dressing! I've been enjoying your channel!😊

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thanks so much 😊

[@eileenpalumbo6578]

I will definitely try this potato salad. Thanks for sharing.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Hope you enjoy!

[@JustinasCountryKitchen]

Thanks for sharing. We love potato salad. I have an amish cookbook i am itching to make something.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Go for it!

[@TizianaTina]

Another great recipe!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thank you 😋

[@WheretoBeginHomestead]

I must admit, I never eat potato salad because the yellow screams mustard at me but seeing how you just made this with very limited mustard makes me want to try this recipe. Thank you for sharing the recipe and all the nice PC kitchen items. Im loving the salad server thingy with the built in ice pack!! I need that in my life, LOL thanks again for sharing a great recipe and great products!!

[@carlenevasseur]

Looks delicious just like everything you make and it's Howard approved. Thanks for sharing LeAnne. God bless.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

I need to make it this week because the potatoes are ready in the garden!

[@Anitalevy156]

Looks yummy ! I`m going to try this.. Thanks for sharing.. I`m new to your site.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Welcome Anita! I’m so glad you are here!

[@lindapetersen1800]

Husband has a sandwich with homemade bread also to go with the potato salad !!! Looks great LeAnne my Grandma would make potato salad like this also with the sugar in it it was of her nationality !!!

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thank you for the very nice words Linda!

[@homesteadingwithapurpose9681]

This looks delicious. We like our potato salad more on the wet side. Thank you for sharing LeeAnn.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Thanks for watching

[@alandenniston8209]

I have never seen a cooked dressing like this, very interesting. I must try this.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Hope you enjoy

[@billclifford4621]

Great video as usual

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

Appreciate that

[@wholenewperspective]

I love potato salad. This is my 1st time seeing it made like this. Thanks for sharing.

[@MennoniteFarmhouse]

It's so good!