Best Bookmark Apps for Collecting Ideas // mymind vs Walling

[@HarryOrenstein]

As usual, Shu, a clear comparison between two great apps. The main problem (which you do not cover) is the "flash in the pan" of these great applications - "knowledge for the moment." [Q1] Have the developers of these apps. built in the possibility of exporting your hard earned knowledge? [Q2] Equally, do the developers allow you to import your previously gained knowledge from (say) Evernote, MyPocket, Instapaper? All the points covered in your excellent review and comparison are really interesting and useful but, IMO, with all knowledge management tools the information garnered must be transferable - otherwise it is uselessly lying in some vault that within time will be inaccessable.

[@ceasec]

Shu, your content is wonderful! Thank you for all the effort you put into your videos-they are a real joy.

[@ceasec]

Omi-sama might be more appropriate LOL

[@ShuOmi_Official]

Aww thank you Christian! Omi sama might be too much though 😂😂

[@DavidFaulk]

Agree with you Shu about MyMind. Easy to gather and to find information. I still use Walling but for other structured tasks.

[@DrDanAllosso]

Thanks for the comparison! I had tried mymind and then bought a year of Walling. But I think you've convinced me to give mymind another try. Because I really have no patience for tagging things manually. Also, GREAT production values!

[@ShuOmi_Official]

Thank you!! Glad to hear that :)

[@iamthebside8087]

I love mymind... even more than Walling. BUT, their lack of an iPad app and no plans on making one is a deal breaker for me. Mymind’s excellent auto tagging is what makes it special and that happens on the backend, server side. So there’s no reason for not at least making the effort. Yes, you can drag and drop into it using a browser, but it’s a pain in the ass. :)

[@salwynmathew8545]

I got access to MyMind just today. Also installed Walling. 100 bricks in both. I don't have to pay. Yay!

[@ShuOmi_Official]

Hope you're enjoying the apps!

[@salwynmathew8545]

@@ShuOmi_Official Absolutely!

[@koushsolanki6856]

Hi Salwyn, can you help me by inviting me to MyMind. As it has only invite option available right now

[@salwynmathew8545]

@@koushsolanki6856 Oh, send me an email @ [e-mail]. I'll share it :)

[@ProspectivePlans]

These productivity apps are just what I needed! 💫 Keep rising to be who you want to be! 💫 #keeprising #risingtobe #aswerise #riser #irise

[@ShuOmi_Official]

Thank you!

[@ProspectivePlans]

@@ShuOmi_Official Your welcome, keep making great videos just like this, please consider checking out my content. 🌟Keep rising to be who you want to be🌟

[@Gael_AG]

Thanks for the review . It's actually tough choice . I 'm using Agenda and started to use myMind and i like iut very much because iof the simplicity. I have to try walling

[@taranazare2633]

Great review - thank you!

[@danieldkang]

Great video and comparison. Thanks Shu! Any chance you are considering more videos about the various ways you use mymind? Feel like there aren’t as much content on the internet for this :)

[@ShuOmi_Official]

That is a good idea! I'll make another video about mymind then!

[@itsjustanumber954]

Quite an interesting video. Thanks for opening our eyes and brains!!🧠🧠🤯🤯

[@ShuOmi_Official]

You're welcome! Thanks!

[@ericmaina6779]

they both are good, I think. However, if one needs to tag what they've clipped to access the content later, then what would be the need to move from the traditional Evernote/Notion type of Apps? I suppose Mymind has just what it takes to tilt the scales.

[@braddahg]

Great review of the apps. I like hearing you describe mymind, I know it's the name of the app, but it sound funny.

[@ShuOmi_Official]

hahahah it feels weird saying it every time 😂

[@jasperjia110]

I found one thing is that mymind can't automatically add tags for other languages (e.g., Japanese). If they can support more languages, that would be awesome.

[@ShuOmi_Official]

Yeah 100%. I thought about that too.

[@BarneyLeith]

Thank you for a very helpful review.

[@ShuOmi_Official]

Glad it was helpful!　Thank you Barney :)

[@loladobler3237]

great vid thank u. that AI ability in mymind is hard to pass up but the organization in walling is helpful. disappointing walling cannot even rec tweets sep. i second the person who asked if u were planning to do any deeper dive into how you use mymind in workflow.

[@ShuOmi_Official]

Thank you! I will probably make another video about mymind then :)

[@mauborba810]

Weird. One year later I got into Walling's page and it feels like they become something totally different, like a productive Kanban board kind of thing. I wonder if it's still good for bookmarks.

[@im_komma]

mymind not supported multi language. for example for search page only working english😢

[@jamesf.jordan2683]

Shu, How would you compare mymind to memex?

[@kazyamaguchi11]

Thanks for the amazing comparison! Have you had any problems with the AI tagging feature of mymind with Japanese articles? I've been trying mymind after I watched your previous video, but the AI tagging feature seems much worse with Japanese articles(compared to English ones) and I'm wondering if its worth it to keep on using mymind.

[@ShuOmi_Official]

When it comes to Japanese articles, the AI tagging might not be as good as on English articles. It sometimes works alright, but not all the time.

[@JanMaas_Home]

Danke!

[@eliam467]

That was awesome. I prefer mymind too

[@ShuOmi_Official]

Glad to hear that!

[@kd.galarza]

I LOVE YOUR CHANEL... And what about RAINDROP?

[@nikamall]

Is this same as Readwise?

[@jackbeltran9200]

Love your content show your personality more bro keep pushing it

[@ShuOmi_Official]

Appreciate that! Thank you Jack :)

[@rezendenetto]

Is it possible to delete all notes, photos, etc. in Mymind at once or do you need to delete them one by one?

[@johnelliott9556]

Hello! I am very curious about mymind but i cannot afford the pricing. Do you know what price it is after the student discount? Thanks

[@spinstermimic]

$5.99 a month. I'm trying out mymind right now and I currently love the ai tagging, but I don't know how much they take away for the student version. There are fewer features but I don't quite understand the difference. I'm emailing them to ask so I'll update after I get an explanation.

[@johnelliott9556]

@@spinstermimic i would really appreciate, i am on the verge on hopping on myMind but im not sure still

[@guthrien]

Mymind's lack of an iPad app is a painful oversight. I do much deeper research work there than I do my iPhone. Not sure I understand their strategy there.

[@ShuOmi_Official]

I know what you mean! It's really a shame that they don't have iPad app :(

[@timbushell8640]

Time spent adding all the tags to make it work with all the benefits is a real loser - the initial benefit of AI tagging must out weight to further benefits after manual tags. Reviewing my Evernote library of 10k notes - only 40% have manual tags, and many of those are batch added due to structured browsing for research, into a temporary notebook, then adding the common tags in batches, works well.

[@Atarity]

Does anyone know about self-hosted alternatives to such apps?

[@spinstermimic]

I'm curious about this too.

[@ahmadridwan8763]

AI feature is really useful for lazy people. btw, there is something wrong with the searchability score.

[@nirajnaveen8007]

Walling doesn't have import features and this is biggest loss

[@dawnduskgamer]

its not free, only 99 cards you can do it. and then subscription basis of 3 variety. per month or per year