BEST & WORST EYESHADOW PALETTES OF 2019! RANKING FROM BEST TO WORST

[@kaendicott]

You should do this type of video but with all colourpop palettes 💗

[@angeladesilva7913]

Yes!!

[@DawnARchangeL]

Kari Poore i second this!!

[@DawnARchangeL]

​@Lisa Lightrider don't think so. She's talked about her entire collection but don't think she's ranked her colourpop palettes - not fore a while anyway Id love to see it!

[@jamibabi2739]

Love this idea!!!

[@modernstylehomes7535]

Your right she got us hooked on Colourpop

[@KellyGooch]

I loved hearing your rankings! I’m so glad that you filmed this

[@AndreaMatillano]

Kelly Gooch Thank you for watching Kelly! 🥰

[@Shadow200177]

It’s been about two years since you did a favorite affordable highlighters video, I’d love to see an updated affordable highlighter video to see your recommendations!!!

[@ashleeashers1839]

Can you rank your top 10 eyeshadow palettes in your entire collection?

[@maadag]

Yessss

[@lisadgingersnaps9843]

I'm a wee bit late. But ColourPop is my go to for eye shadow. They are consistent and reliable every single time. I am obsessed. And honestly, their pricing is just the icing on the cake.

[@irisk934]

I bought the Dominique berries and cream specifically because of your recommendation at the end of last year. I've been so happy with it! Every time I do a look with it, I'm in love with how it turns out. It's dramatic and fun and glamorous all at once.

[@marydunn8770]

I really like that one too. Trying to avoid buying the Rustic Glam as I don't need anymore eyeshadow.

[@irisk934]

@@marydunn8770 I looked at it in store and it didn't feel that cohesive to me plus I think it would be too much work for me. If that helps you any

[@marydunn8770]

@@irisk934 Thankyou! I don't think we can get it on store in the UK so that is useful info! I lile the look of the greens and feel like the colours complement the berries and cream 🙈

[@liddyr_]

Mary Dunn if you’re gonna get another DC palette I would choose the brand new one.. it looks so unique and pretty I wish I could buy it!!

[@katygomez9695]

Please make a video of your favorite duochrome eyeshadows 🙇🏻‍♀️❤

[@AndreaMatillano]

Katy Gómez I love that idea! Thanks for the suggestion!

[@surewhynot4647]

Yes please!! Thank you!

[@GretchenVaughn]

I live for duchromes.

[@liddyr_]

Yes!!!

[@AoiSora603]

I just ordered the It’s My Pleasure palette! It should be here tomorrow!! Also, happy 300k!! 🤩

[@AndreaMatillano]

AoiSora603 Aw thank you so much! I hope you love it as much as I do! 😍😍

[@elizabethgreer27]

Is it back in stock?

[@AoiSora603]

It’s in stock now!

[@LillyBlue3224]

I’m addicted to eyeshadow palettes. I have at least 25 of them.

[@ramsam70]

Ashley Oswald so glad I’m not alone !!! I’ve been trying to pass some on but have 18 now 😳 that doesn’t include face or blush either

[@maadag]

I have 15 but for 2019 I'm allowed to buy 2 more but just of brands that I haven't try

[@filiparafael9115]

I've 35 😂♥️ love them and i'm absolutly adicted

[@Muslimah33]

I have 20 and I’m always interested in new ones. Eyeshadow sparked my interest in makeup many moons ago.

[@MHernandez012171]

Around 50... Yes, I have a problem! LOL!!

[@aura3337]

YES! It’s My Pleasure is my new favorite palette too! I absolutely love purple and pinks- they look beautiful on brown eyes! And I’m getting ready to order Just My Luck. You seriously are so good at reviews! Thank you!

[@drsallymanderchoi]

Andrea!!! So happy to see your face always. I am excited to see what beautiful eyeshadow look you will do every time. Also never feel like you shouldn't make a video b/c you don't have anything to add. We watch for you and will always watch even if we already watched 30 other reviews on the same thing

[@JessicaSmith-mw7dp]

I dropped everything I was doing when I saw this video posted! Love everything to do with palettes! ❤️

[@ramsam70]

Ohhhhh- watching eye palettes be handled and discussed 🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽 yes girl. Sunday afternoon indulgence ❤️

[@AndreaMatillano]

Ramona Samuels 💗💗 Thank you so much for taking the time to watch!

[@mistyparsons7710]

This video was so much fun..I would definitely love to see you rank each category of makeup..that would be SOOOOO fun!! Hope you’re enjoying your weekend. Love you, Andréa!!❤️😘 xoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxo

[@jennawar13]

I love eyeshadow! I just got a few new additions and I am so excited to play with them! My palette drawers are getting full, but I just know that brands are going to come out with some more great ones for the next half of the year, so I might need more storage lol

[@emilymorse8163]

I love videos like this. They definitely help when deciding which new palette to try! LOVE your eye look in this video. I have the it’s my pleasure palette (I love purple)! But mine did not give me a real “purple” look it tended to turn more pink. It was a bit disappointing. You should do a video on this eye look!!!!

[@karolgarcia02]

you should do this type of video for other makeup categories. I’d love to see one on foundation🤗

[@LyndaBullerwell]

Yes! Loved this video! I would love to see more ranked products!! Even a ranking of more palettes! maybe by brand?...❤️

[@shelbykim69]

You are so good at putting on eyeshadow and talking about palettes, a master you are!! Excellent video 👀😍!!

[@solbri2758]

Hi Andrea, I would be nice to see more tutorials and when you do, to see the performance of the products you use, for exeample, foundation, concealer. Kind of doing checkings specially for foundations and primers. I loved this video, it's fun to see how you rank the palettes you have

[@taylorbrianne5968]

I've bought a few palettes on your recommendation. I haven't been disappointed yet. I definitely need to buy the Blue Moon now!

[@suesheehan1493]

I was delighted to see the Blue Moon palette at ColourPop. Like you, I just couldn't find the right palette for blending blues, and of course, I purchased it immediately. I loved your reviews of all the palettes.

[@SamanthaMarchxo]

Ranking palettes - or makeup in general - gets addicting lol!!

[@cavlizzy]

I love the "It's My Pleasure Palette" SOOO much that I bought a back-up several weeks later!! (scared they would discontinue) I have never done that before.

[@nairabee245]

I don’t think they’d discontinue it. It’s one of their most popular products overall. It’s constantly going out of stock a looooong while after it was originally released

[@paofacu]

Eyeshadow palettes are my weakness! 😍 I love this video! I love my magic mini palette from Juvia’s place. I use it as an accent palette too! ❤️

[@mimime5376]

Hi Andrea! Great video! I love Juvias Place pallets and was surprised to see them low on your rankings. I only own 4 or 5, but love them all. I was going to get the Magic Mini, but they sent me the Masquerade Mini instead. Of course I kept it. I usually buy pallets with green and purple in it, that's why I wasn't upset with the mixup. After reading the comments, I'm also going to get the Its My Pleasure pallet for the purples in it. Thanks for sharing this. I hope you had a great time on your vacation! Take care! 💚💜🌴😎

[@Reiliferei]

I got the Just my luck palette and I kinda feel the same. I kind wish there were some more mid tone lighter greens. Same for the It's my pleasure palette, I wanted more mid tone colors.

[@jessicaervin337]

I love my tribe palette and that Ashanti shade is so unique and that shimmer shade too bc when it's on the eye it has a hint of green in the shimmer. love that palette so much!

[@watermelongal5512]

Thanks for a great review! I think I am obsessed with eye shadow palettes! I tend to buy too many and don't really need to. Good to hear your honest opinion on each palette. : )

[@christamarie3512]

That shadow you’re wearing today is gorgeous! 😍 I’m living!!!

[@GretchenVaughn]

I love eyeshadow-even if I rarely wear it these days (new puppy!). The Tribe is surprisingly wearable and sheers out nicely. I am busy depotting most of my eyeshadows and buying singles. My Colourpop order is coming today with two of the-$20-12 pan single shadow palettes. Can't wait! I would love to see a video of your favorite singles.

[@makeupjunkie6790]

My greatest weakness is eye shadow palettes.

[@smileyshani2252]

Makeup Junkie same

[@vt2587]

PLEASE do a series of eye showdown tutorials using Colourpop pallets. Pleeeeaaase.😬👏🏻💕

[@alisonmeyer9544]

That would be fun!

[@justsayin1991]

V T she has a fairly recent video where she goes through and does mini reviews on all of her Colourpop palettes! She doesn’t officially rank them. But she does give you a pretty good idea of her favorites and ones she doesn’t reach for as much :)

[@littlereddress82]

I have the blue moon palette and the jefree star blue blood palette. Love both.

[@carriekup]

Wasn't the Ooh LaLa before Its My Pleasure? O could be wrong, I do think I Bought the Ooh LaLa first. Anyway, loved this video! I love almost any eyeshadow palette video, and I love listing/ranking videos. More please! Lol

[@sincerelyalex28]

I live for your eyeshadow palette videos!! Also as a side note, technically Ooh La La was the first monochromatic palette that ColourPop did! I bought It’s My Pleasure “for my grandma” but I borrowed it a couple times and it’s really nice! The shade Mr. Sandman broke over time though since it seems more softly pressed, so I’m gonna order another one - hopefully when they finally do a 9-pan Orange palette

[@daniellefrost1617]

I love your videos and honestly you could never have too many eyeshadow palette videos! I watch them all 😍

[@kristingrywusiewicz7404]

I was right! My guess was the it's my pleasure pallet as your #1. I have it too, it's a great pallet. Also like your eye look!

[@marydunn8770]

Loving the colour of your hair. Love the cherry red. I do like the Naked Reloaded palette for basic/quick looks but I do think that one of the shades has a bad formula. It's the kind of sparkly grey/brown one. x

[@shaylaatiles]

I never thought I’d LOVE the It’s My Pleasure palette, but holy moly! It’s so good and I find it really compliments my brown eyes. I find myself reaching for it a lot more than I thought I would. 💜

[@AndreaMatillano]

I’m so glad to hear that you’re a fan too! 😍 I honestly can’t get enough of it!

[@TeesCornerCloset]

I really enjoyed this video. I’m obsessed with eyeshadow palettes and I love the way you review your products!💖💖💖

[@MissSparkles91]

Love your picks girl. The its my pleasure palette is definitely one of my all time favorite colourpop palettes that I own.

[@shannonreynolds6507]

Funny those are your top two because those are the two colourpop palettes that i was wanting! Now that I’ve seen this I’m definitely gonna buy them. Thanks for helping me make up my mind lol. Your eyeshadow looks Amazing!!

[@stacienichole1198]

That eyelook!!! Kept staring at it. love ur video

[@lacysmith6102]

Love this kind of videos. Please do more. Highlighters, liners, blush. Everything!! ❤️❤️

[@NatalieYTFoster]

I love watching these ranking videos. I recently ordered my first juvias place palette and haven’t even played with it properly yet but have just ordered another one in their 50% off 4th July sale!

[@lisamarie5918]

Eye shadow is my favorite part of makeup, so I always love seeing your Eye shadow Palettes videos!

[@shannonbatisse8882]

I love eyeshadow palette videos😊. I want to add the Colourpop Just my Luck palette to my collection. I own and love the Colourpop it’s my pleasure palette. My favourite shadow colours are purple and green. I have also been into cooler tones too this year. I might just have to buy the Dominique Cosmetics Berries and Cream now, thanks to you😊, there are a few colours in that palette that interest me.

[@thelipstickgal]

I love your monochromatic eye looks, they've inspired me to do similar looks. I'm also in love with the 9 pan palettes from colourpop! They're so good. I know they just launched a yellow one, and I'm curious if you're planning on getting that one. (BTW, I knew you were wearing "It's My Pleasure" on your eyes, just by the shades.)

[@kimrodriguez3626]

I love your style, energy and overall vibe! New subscriber 😊✨

[@iristolenada]

My favorite vids that you do are your eyeshadow palette ones, LOVE these! 💜

[@Heyitskrystal]

What a fun video to watch I’d love to see more ranking videos like this!

[@DMCxxo]

You’re the queen of beautiful colorful eyeshadow. Can you please do some looks with or ways to use the it’s my pleasure palette. Please.

[@jungimkim6782]

I also enjoy hearing about eyeshadow palettes, too. Thank you for your rankings, as your reviews are detailed and have balanced perspective. I also love it's my pleasure and look forward to using other of their monochromatic palettes, too :)

[@samanthaimrie2918]

I love ranking! This video feeds my soul! Def do more like this!

[@talithameyer2077]

Your eye look is amazing , eyeshadow and perfume are my fave

[@AndreaMatillano]

Thank you so much! 🥰 I want to get more into perfume!

[@bigodetarifan]

I always look forward to your videos!! Hope you had a great weekend! 💕💕

[@JoyT01]

I like how you included drug store & high end. I’m being more cautious of my spending in 2019 on makeup related items too. I went to organize my collection & was like enough is enough😩

[@louisesharpy]

Loving the colors. Yes !! Also I enjoy this palette ranking. So fun. I love Dominique Cosmetics palettes. I and dying to get Rustic glam and the Colourpop it’s my pleasure !

[@jennnnnnn13]

You have awesome video ideas! I can listen to eyeshadow videos all day long you're not the only one 🤣

[@sarahelkot5950]

Enjoyed this review so much😍..please when u get the colourpop yellow themed palette..tell us what is the ranking among these💕

[@tikkiesh]

The shade Lumi in colourpop blue moon palette is just sooooo good!! 🤤🤤. Absolute love 😍. I hope they’ll come out with it in singles 😊. I’m keen to see your top rank palettes from ALL of your collection 😆.

[@abby7038]

I LOVE the Dominique cosmetics berries and cream. i just bought it a few weeks ago. The its my pleasure from colourpop is one I don’t love.. but everyone loves it so much that I think I need to revisit it. I love purples and berries.. so maybe I need to give it another try! :)

[@tabathadelp3120]

I love the purple colourpop palette it's one of my favorites as well. Love your eye look! Great video!

[@annabanana6965]

Your eyeshadow looks incredible today!! 💕🙌🏻

[@MandiLou41493]

We have the same favorite. CP has been killing it. I've been using them more than any other palette. Just got CALove and I'm so in love with it.

[@jenniferciliberto3078]

Such a fun video and I really appreciate your reviews!

[@carab1036]

I love ranking videos! Absolutely do more rankings of other products.

[@nicoledoudprado1390]

This encouraged me to go for the Blue Moon palette during the sale yesterday since I've been wanting to play with some blues and peaches since Jeffree's Blue Blood palette came out.

[@joannievh2071]

I agree with you on the UD naked reloaded. Such a disappointment to me! I bought it based on the rave reviews it got and I just don't get it. Ended up returning it sadly because I can't afford to keep make up I don't use. 😔

[@kristiecoleman487]

I returned it. It wasn't worth the money

[@diannajones9525]

I buy palettes like crazy and I agree with your # 1 choice. I’ve used mine so much I’m thinking of picking up another.

[@kdlindgren]

I struggle a bit with the shade selection in the Riviera palette also. I have barely tried it. I need to spend some more time working with it. Thanks for the video!

[@lebabies]

Kristin Lindgren I returned mine! Way too much fallout and I couldn’t get a good look with it.

[@Livslivie]

Literally from the very beginning of this video I was obsessing over your eye look!!! I have to buy that palette!!!!!!

[@AndreaMatillano]

That’s so sweet of you! Thank you!

[@moriganna67ify]

As you know eye palettes are my very favourite thing in makeup. I hate that purple and blue are so hard to get to work well for us. Especially the dark tones. Like you I love pinks, purple and I also love reds. I love mu Huda beauty mini palettes a ton the Amethyst and Ruby are stunning and the other first Obsessions in Electric and Coral are just gorgeous. Lo this video.

[@smileyshani2252]

Loved this!! I don’t use the Warrior 2 palette much either, but like it when I do. I think I still look at it like “why do I have an all matte palette?” Lol. I am still considering the Natasha Denona palette! ❤️💋

[@oliviagordon2865]

Love this vid!! Super informative! Im currently looking for a pink pallette.. and i cant decide which one to get!!

[@girlpurple24]

Are u gonna buy the new colourpop yellow pallette?

[@lisadgingersnaps9843]

Are you? I just ordered the California Love pallet and decided to wait on the all Yellow one. I just can't decide.

[@clairetheisen5888]

Uh huh honey is so worth it! My new favorite palette haha

[@geminiqueen975]

What do you think about the blue blood pallet? 💙

[@Smellywax77]

I’ve been staying away from KZbin makeup lately but I was excited for some good content. 😍

[@colettem.7064]

And the winner 🏆is ColourPop! Nearly a tie. So glad the Blue Moon 🌙 has worked well. Congrats on 300k🎉.

[@bardlover6]

Love the it’s my pleasure palette too. The only other ones I have are Juvia’s place but I rank them the same way. I keep eying the berries and cream palette too

[@AndreaMatillano]

It's such a gorgeous palette! I'm so impressed by the Berries and Cream formula. I think it's fun to use alongside of the It's My Pleasure palette!

[@HeatherAustinmakeup]

I think I'm the only person on KZbin who is obsessed with my UD x GOT palette 🤣🤣🤣 I still want to try Riviera! It looks so pretty

[@apurvaparashar152]

Heather Austin I love my GOT palette as well, plus it’s a collector piece for me considering I’m a Game of Thrones fan !!

[@GretchenVaughn]

Heather Austin GOT sold out so quickly I don't think anyone not on PR got their hands on it.

[@HeatherAustinmakeup]

GretchenVaughn my Ulta still has some but that was in store! I love it so so much!

[@Giulialmo]

I got really obsessed about eyeshadows lately, I used to love concealers and foundations but nowadays I only have eyes to eyeshadows, literally

[@Cassidy.12646]

My favorite palette queen! Love your rankings!!! Thanks for including affordable options! Xo

[@nickyjade01]

Omg your no. 1 is one of my fav. this year as well. I ❤❤pink & purple shadows as well.

[@randilthomas]

CALLED IT! So glad someone else loves the It’s My Pleasure palette as much as I do! 🥰

[@AndreaMatillano]

Isn’t it so beautiful?! 😍

[@odiellehoen8372]

I think I missed the drama from Juvia's Place, what happened? Love their eyeshadows still. And your video's are always so informative & lovely. I have a ton of eyeshadow palettes, more of a collector honestly, even though I love experimenting with looks (:

[@mariafay3190]

What are your favorite green shadows (that you mentioned). Im a lover of green shadows to accent green eyes 😊

[@cmyh8349]

I wish brands would move away from plastic packaging when possible or at least give the option to purchase a palette in cardboard packaging. I would have purchased some of colourpop's monochromatic palettes if it wasn't for the plastic. Just a personal choice.

[@Selsmittenxo]

True, I would love the option of cardboard.

[@miahurtado]

I learned recently that these palettes are magnetic! You can reuse them with new pans! Hopefully this prolongs the loves of them so that they don't immediately end up in landfill.

[@cynthiaalvarado3287]

hi Andrea I enjoyed your video I loved all your goodies that you showed us and I agree with most of your choices I want to get the colour-pop California Love but Juvia's place to is one of my choices I hope you have a wonderful day and I'll see you in the next video

[@SaraMoney33]

Where did you get your plant in the background? I love it soooo much!

[@AndreaMatillano]

Sara Money Thank you so much! I actually got it from TJ Maxx!

[@SaraMoney33]

Andréa Matillano thank you taking the time out to tell me! 🤘🏼

[@marianachamu97]

I need those colourpop 9 pan palettes! The pink and purple ones are just so pretty 😍😍😍 and they released a yellow one too!!!

[@mrsblondback]

This is so great. I have been SO picky with palettes lately.

[@conniek8118]

Love to see more tutorials and GRWM videos Your videos are fun to watch

[@ceciliasanchez5901]

Excellent video, I was surprised at your number one! I thought maybe the blue one. Love you 😍

[@coletteh1218]

Your hair game is on point today 😇😇😇

[@kaivickers166]

Lately I’ve been wearing grungy looks or neon oranges and pinks. Vampy incoming for Fall though...

[@oliviaa195]

I literally love this eyeshadow look

[@joycebenavides8943]

Where did you get the baskets that your palettes are stored in in the background?

[@miarenee]

Do you have a How to with the eyeshadow look you are wearing? beautiful!! I have that pallet 🌸