Beth Crowley- How It Ends (Based on City of Lost Souls by Cassandra Clare) (Official Lyric Video)

Ways to get my music:
Purchase Signed Physical CDs: www.bethcrowle...
Download on iTunes: itunes.apple.c...
Stream on Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Let's be friends!
on Facebook: / bethcrowleymusic
on Twitter: / bethjcrowley
on Instagram: / bethjcrowley
Mail me something cool!
Beth Crowley
2690 Cobb Parkway SE
Suite A5, # 109
Smyrna, GA 30080
www.bethcrowle...

[@sierra_h2177]

The moment you realize this song fits perfect in multiple books you've read.

[@warriorstudeo188]

Books and my sisters life

[@cottentwt2226]

Damn we read sad books then

[@banana_lunana]

I wish Beth would make a (Reimagined) of this it's so good, imagine how amazing it would be with some "Cold-Blooded" production 😩

[@janinemelo4960]

YESSSS!! This would be SO GOOD!! I think this song, Skin and Bones, and Pretend It's Home deserves a reimagined version!!

[@MyAnanin]

So im aware its already been said but just once more: this is sooo supernatural! Every word fits the relationship between sam and dean perfectly. the worlds about to end end everythings angsty but they still have each other, always no matter what

[@metrotmobile6769]

Right on supernatural lover number 1 fan

[@mysoxx9547]

That moment when a beautiful song fits perfectly a fanfic you're reading... XD

[@abiahthomas5505]

So true

[@madisencampbell8120]

The Ancient magus Bride.🥰😍

[@fiorev6274]

@@madisencampbell8120 you have good taste

[@haveagoodmourning]

I just realized, even though it says "this isn't how it ends", the title is "How It Ends" instead. And the song finishes on the words "how it ends". So... this *is* how it ends.

[@fasilatsanusi7431]

To God be all the glories and to Him belong the fulfillment of promises, make an honest promise for the prophecy to be truth.

[@crystaldestiny8006]

I love this!! This is exactly how Clary was trying to get through to Jace i CoLS!!!! You're songs are so perfect i can't even

[@jessaminemorgenstern6063]

So i think. :'3

[@skyesthelimit6251]

+Crystal Destiny I know! (:

[@hannahwassel2105]

Beth, reading City of Heavenly Fire right now and decided to revisit this video because it was playing in my head on loop once I started. Please write a song for COHF- because knowing you it will be simply perfect.

[@Bookslife-tt4rz]

Hannah Wassel ikr I love that series!!! Have you read the Infernal devices? It is about Tessa Gray, James (Jem) Carstairs and Will Herondale, I cried when I finished the books (in order: clockwork angel, clockwork prince, clockwork princess). Skin and Bones by Beth Crowley is based and fits the series SO well. All the stories are true.

[@fuzzypanda6987]

Hannah Wassel She has now

[@lakshmimanoj6610]

Books4life 263 that's a spoiler!

[@Bookslife-tt4rz]

Lakshmi Manoj whoops! I tried to avoid a spoiler, but it was really hard, sorry- I changed it though

[@deada-annpeters5991]

I haven't found anyone who I can relate to as much as I do her music. She is awesome. The words of her songs are helping me through a dark place in my head. I appreciate it more than she knows 😊

[@tarinasparks3254]

I`m not to far gone thanks to you!? The demons are always here and your helping me~God gave me you and I am more then blessed! Thank You!🌹

[@Kat-ws8bq]

I know this is supposed to be based on The Mortal Instruments: City Of Lost Souls, but the vibes I'm getting... Adora and Catra from She-Ra. This fits so well.

[@kreddulush]

I came to the comments hoping to find this💖 yyeeEEEESS💞

[@haveagoodmourning]

Omg I see it and it hurts my heart

[@anushkanavetia]

I love how different fandoms just claims this song for their own. Its a true celebration of fandoms

[@serendipity6720]

Dudes I miss Christina grimme 😢. I don't know why but I just remembered her from nowhere. I loved her music and I was small when she Sang and lived but still. 💔We still love you grimme

[@arieshellstormm9487]

shows me a moment , My daughter and I are going through right now

[@taya4818]

I'd just like to say I cried when I finished the Mortal Instruments (yesterday😭)

[@ammaarahdaya6279]

Annabeth Chase LISTEN TO COME ALIVE BY BETH IT'S SO AMAZING AND SADNESS

[@chakshikagarg746]

Annabeth Chase love your name

[@bethferris7768]

Annabeth Chase I know how you, I am like literally 2-3 chapters away from finishing the series and I am going to be so sad when I do because then there won't be any more books in the series, so I am like not reading the book right now so that I don't finish it

[@chakshikagarg746]

Beth Ferris I can't EVER do that, I'm too impatient

[@bethferris7768]

Chakshika Garg I'm pretty impatient too, but in this case I just don't want to finish the book so bad, that I'm willing to be patient

[@AppleWhiteFan]

computer: there has been an error connection me: YOUR BRAIN IS AN ERROR CONNECTION! computer: your life is an error connection me: o~0

[@petralemons]

Exactly - this isn't how it ends, City of heavenly fire is how it ends, and they finally had the ending they needed (but really the ending I NEEDED!!) Herondale's forever

[@katiesanders2990]

This reminds me so much of Mare and Maven from Red Queen! Anyone else agree?

[@angelinaelchammas2506]

Katie Sanders OMG YES!! im a HUGE fan and honestly this is mareven af

[@rileybreazeale]

Katie Sanders Holy crap you’re right

[@lizzy-du6bc]

I was just thinking that!

[@bingobongo8030]

There is a song by Beth cowley about red queen called red

[@ritikamohla4176]

Yes.Maven was such an intense character.

[@mollison124]

This reminds me of the infernal devices series :) love how your music reminds me of Cassandra Clare's music!

[@Bookslife-tt4rz]

Molly Magnuson I love that series! I cried when I finished the last book, especially when Will dies

[@kerisamoonsamy6002]

I think this is perfect for City of Lost Souls, not just the words but the music❤

[@crystalhughes2625]

Omfg I completely obsessed with your voice. This is definitely an accurate soundtrack to my life right now. Thank you for your beautiful talent and for making me feel like I'm not the only one who's felt like this....

[@skyesthelimit6251]

Jace and Clary in the City of Souls!!!!

[@anindobagchi3408]

This song is *based* on City Of Lost Souls

[@milliehays9315]

Is anybody else thinking about Vampire Academy in the fourth book when Dimitri is a Strigoi??? (also I would love to hear a song based off of that book series)

[@alexisstankewtiz5869]

Now I am... 😢

[@cindolbow7858]

Tell me you not to far gone- Sam to Dean when he had the mark of Cain

[@elenadivoli]

THE LYRICS ARE SO ACCURATE!!!! there's a darkness that plays behind your wicked smile (I can totally see Sabastian with that) an aching sadness as you cradle me like I'm a child (what Seb did to Clary) this is madness (Def. SEBASTIAN) we're descending into madness (again) and it chills me to the bone (Clary for Jace) even when you're gone I'm not alone (Clary for Jace) I'm never alone (Clary for Jace) I'm searching, desperate for a fracture in your shell (Shell bc of Sebby) with every passing day it gets harder to tell (harder to tell If it;s him or Sebby) where the demon stops and where you begin (Clary for Jace-> demon=Sebby) but I promise you this isn't how it ends I am frightened as we tumble down the rabbit hole (frightened bc of Sebby) my grip tightens, I'm clinging to your missing soul (missing bc Sebby has taken jace) you can fight them (Them= Sebby and the Clave) together we can fight them Tell me you're not too far gone that I'm not a fool for holding on I have to hold on (clary holds on and she's forced to stay with them) Deep within your twisted truth (twisted bc of Sebby) you made yourself a home but it's a place where I can't follow you (Death if Sebby dies) don't leave me on my own I can't do this on my own

[@katiebosley1517]

+Shreya Varanasy +Helena Divoli Yeah, though it could be both: i am frightened as we tumble down the rabbit hole(Teleporting with Jace) i'm clinging to your missing soul(She is mourning it) you can fight them, together we can fight them(The bad guys. If it was Sebastian, she would think he was permanently gone and just want to kill him) tell me you're not too far gone that I'm not a fool for holding on(Everyone told Clary to let go of Jace, that the only thing to do was to get rid of Jace and Sebastian) I have to hold on I'm searching, desperately for a fracture in your shell(She tries to make Jace remember why Sebastian is evil, but whatever she does, it doesn't work, Jace stills sings Sebastian's praises) with each passing day it gets harder to tell where the demon ends and you begin(The spell that bound the two of them makes a demon out of Jace, but Clary still sees pieces of his old personality)

[@elenadivoli]

Yes I think your is better.. I guess i got carried away of excitement :)

[@justahuman1195]

Amya Engelreid I am re reading CoLS now and all the feels about that omg

[@mementomortalis9592]

What's CoLS???

[@duthich4527]

So true I feel it

[@Rose-bq7bd]

Beth, congratulations on writing such amazing songs. You're an incredible artist.

[@vieletperl]

your voice is just AMAZING! i am obsessed with your songs *___* X)))

[@jadeaustin1420]

Exactly!!!! Even the chorus makes it clear "where the demon stops and where u begin" obvious reference to Liliths blood inside him

[@NormaGarcia-vy2kd]

this songs reminds me of Morpheus and Alyssa from the splintered series its amazing

[@katiesanders2990]

black goku totally

[@ludmilafigueroa7741]

this song is perfect

[@nancytobey9870]

City of Lost Souls !!

[@disneyanimallover1]

Makes me think of Mockingjay and City of Lost Souls. Love it!

[@brokenxsmile2118]

She based it off of City Of Lost Souls

[@julianaferreira594]

Someone has to show your songs to Cassie, you're absolutely amazing!

[@justahuman1195]

Juliana Ferreira Cassie loved Warrior thats why we hoped it would be in the mooe

[@justahuman1195]

movie*

[@cassielopez4576]

*pokes head through air vent* You called?

[@carissapalladino6316]

I know this is supposed to be about the Mortal Instruments but it really reminds me personally of Anakin and Padme

[@russsampson1572]

OMG! ABSOLUTLEY LOVE THIS SONG!!!!

[@amypinfold8511]

I love this so much! I'd Iove a piano tutorial

[@alicereeves1872]

I'm thinking of romanoff and banner from avengers, just me?

[@HannahG-nk2mf]

I'm thinking of them too! I was listening, knowing it's about Mortal Instruments, but I couldn't help thinking about Natasha and Bruce.

[@timduffy9443]

Beth, I don’t know any other artist that has so many songs that are all master pieces, and have such emotional feeling, and truth within them. I can relate to them all. Beautiful master pieces.

[@Lina-qn5hj]

This song makes me fall apart into pieces. I love you, Beth!

[@michalahardin2026]

For the longest time I have been conflicted. I love to play the piano, but don't know if I am any good. I taught myself to play piano, and can't yet write my own music. So here goes nothing...... If I get 10 likes I'll post a video of one of the songs I can play. If I get 15 likes I will take song requests and post all of them. If I get 20 likes I will perform publicly. This is my only test to see if people will even take some interest in what I do. Please help me.

[@juliamaluceli7596]

Essa música é simplesmente linda!

[@jessaminemorgenstern6063]

Am i the only one who cry whit this song? I remember the though of Clary, the shell of Jace... and i imagine Jace, being cool and acting natural, but then, a Jace inside him, telling him that everything it's wrong.

[@meganholbrook7229]

Jessamine Morgenstern I didn't before. Until you started talking about all of that. Thanks. Now I'm going to have to explain to my sister why I suddenly started crying.

[@Lina-qn5hj]

Not only you. ;-(

[@jadeaustin1420]

Nah that's sad but the end when Sebastians eyes turn green and u saw who he was always supposed to be right b4 he died!! That was emotional

[@perpetualsick]

This reminds me of many things but it mostly reminds me of supernatural... and then TMR. Welp, I’m sad now..

[@overwatch-sombra-di.va-rea3716]

This reminds me of Clary and Sebastian/Jonathan

[@sdsgnitro4641]

This gave me MAJOR FEELS.. It almost felt as if I was reading the whole book again.. You captured the theme of city of lost souls perfectly.. Keep making more beautiful songs.. Had to subscribe after this song

[@rahaflabban9375]

Malec. The feels😭

[@clarygniflhor]

Omg! I love youre voice and what it expresses. When I hear the song I always think of Cols and I can feel it. The song is very touching, thank you!

[@ClovistheSheep]

This is like the epitome of Faith and Death's relationship in 'Death is my BFF'

[@madisencampbell8120]

Is that an anime??🥰

[@ClovistheSheep]

@@madisencampbell8120 omg ...this was so long ago lol. Its a book.

[@camilasugui6309]

No words can describe the beauty and how wonderful it is this music. Perfect and amazing as always

[@Deyna480]

Oh my God, you're voice it's amazing!

[@joyakumar779]

This is an awesome song- the type which you can listen to over and over again, not only because it sounds good but because you can relate to it and know exactly what it is talking about. Thanks for this wonderful song!

[@cressantmoon6964]

i love this song it has such a deep meaning to me it's amazing :)

[@phasekatpeirce5016]

Your voice is so amazing I love this song it really tells my story:) thank you for this song

[@MissMusic4Ever96]

This fits perfectly to City of lost souls...Im obsessed I love it

[@laurawilson3107]

This is amazing, I'm obsessed with TMI and TID both and I listen too her songs almost non stop

[@eleonoraparker6367]

This remind me of Emma and Regina, once upon a time, when Emma become che dark one. Wonderful song.

[@xmockingjayfirex]

This actually reminds me of Black Butler :P Beautiful song. :)

[@indysmith1331]

My thoughts exactly XD

[@junesherman6534]

Yes. Just yes.

[@cindolbow7858]

So supernatural, Dean and Sam

[@lexiritto8247]

I know that this is supposed to be for just for how she feels with Jace in city of lost souls but i feel this is how Clary felt at first with Jonathan... Wanting to help and save him... That there was more than just the demon blood and Valentine

[@Rorapia1]

I love this song! I can't get enough

[@torimiller1738]

Love this song! CITY OF LOST SOULS!!!!!!!!!!

[@windyellis8292]

I dunno, man, I got some mad Loki/Jane vibes for some reason. . . I mean, I know that ship isn't real or possible--but danggit, I got vibes.

[@candyprinsesses5788]

i love it

[@LucyGaid]

This is Not HOW IT ENDS. There's still, there's always tomorrow. NO MATTER WHAT

[@beccabutterfly7317]

But I promise you this isn't how it ends..

[@charleshills1408]

Becca Butterfly I love this song and your user

[@FindRichardO]

Promises were made to be broken.😢

[@quelamary602]

your songs are so perfect!

[@lynnwhispers]

I can see Malec, Sizzy, and obviously Clace in this song. Great job! The feels about Malec though......);

[@justahuman1195]

Katie R the feels about everything in those books omg all of it good bad and ugly

[@desireesmith4016]

@Fictional Person there is something that happens with malec that this fits but you have to read the books with sizzy try reading Tales From the Shadowhuntter Academy

[@CarleRodriguez]

I love it. Its a really beautiful song ;)

[@bronwynhunn3338]

Supernatural anyone ?!

[@m.8638]

When I first heard this, I thought she was some famous singer I haven't heard of. Turns out, she was just a semi famous youtuber who deserves some more credit. She has a voice, a talent for the piano and writes bloody awesome songs. She has flair, unlike some of the music artists everyone talks about.

[@leahdalley2929]

You are an amazing artist, so glad to have found you! I hope you keep on writing and release a full CD!

[@jadeaustin1420]

Beth Ferris I k iw how u feel . Especially right before he died his eyes turned green like his sisters

[@abithomas2791]

This song is perfect for City Of Lost Souls. "Warrior" should really be in City Of Ashes. Don't stop pushing for it to be in the next movie!

[@1-2-tritothe-4]

OMG your song of the boocks are amazing!!! is like you can interpretate the boock in a simple song! is excelent you have a eautifull voice by the way...:) iloooove your song! :D

[@LinaCapricorn]

This kind of describe Will & Tessa's relationship in The Infernal Devices. Or at least, in the first two books.

[@violetwolf6121]

I feel like im the only one that connects this directly to Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Its quite literal. Everyone is comparing it to their favorite fandoms but those comparisons are so.... Vague. It reminds me of Angel quite accurately.

[@haveagoodmourning]

I hadn't made the connection, but now I can't unsee it!

[@cindylu2046]

Reminds me so much of Aric from Endless Knight (The Arcana Chronicles).

[@ZarinReadsBooks]

absolutely beautiful

[@sk.1069]

Anybody think of the Divergent series?? "I'm searching, desperate for a fracture in your shell. With every passing day, it gets harder to tell." All through the books, Tris is trying to be honest with Four, as is he to her. They are trying to see a "fracture in your shell" And as Four becomes more distant in Allegiant, "It gets harder to tell" Does anybody see what I'm saying, or have I really gone mad?

[@izzy_hartman]

Oh, my god, yes!

[@p.celeste1307]

True

[@kyliem7331]

YESSSSS

[@ZomPeaceLoveAndMusic]

Am I the only one who fangirled when I saw the lyric video posted??????????

[@kathyfurfari7775]

I love her music I love i living without you

[@absolutezero5961]

I'm an aspiring author. My book will be published someday. When it is, and if it is EVER made into a movie, you will have permanent employment with me. Your music gives me childhood chills, though your music was never a part of it. That's something that I could never forget, or forgive if I let slip away. You have true, ineffable talent.

[@Padme65]

I thought of Alice singing to the mad hatter...

[@rebeccagraham368]

Lady Arisu same here

[@jadeaustin1420]

That's acc a good way of viewing it

[@EsmeraldaGarcia-jq2xl]

Lady Arisu OMG YES!!!!! I've heard this song before but now that you said it, I actually can see that! THANK YOU!!!!

[@celestesoto3355]

I think it is based on Alice in wonderland or at least that's the vibe that I'm getting.

[@Padme65]

Oh goddess... it's been four years since I typed that... Time feels strange some... uhm... time...

[@jocelynhunter6048]

GOD I LOVE THIS

[@willspy4u]

Way underrated! This gives me chills.

[@nalu1198]

You should totally do a song about supernatural

[@maiderzubieta4445]

This reminds me of the book series the maze runner so hard 🙊❤️

[@MisunderstoodBelle]

another perfect song, Love your TMI songs!!!! total fan here !!

[@lisabrown4881]

How does this end???? Beautifully broken

[@marshanahrai97]

This song reminds me of Isobel & Varen from Nevermore by Kelly Creagh.

[@Rinta4]

I'm thinking of Maven and Mare from King's Cage

[@9monkeyj]

i love your songs about cassandra clares wonderful novels! I hope you continue making songs for her books as well as others! :)

[@kimberlydiaz6382]

This song reminds me a lot more of The Infernal Devices than The Mortal Instruments

[@MichaelDecker-th2oj]

This one hits hard honey

[@merlinarthur9588]

Tmi forever city of lost souls!

[@cindolbow7858]

Dean and Sam 💯🥰🥰

[@ellem1842]

Totally reminds me of demon Dean and how Sam feels about him.

[@arynsinger6811]

Yes! I thought the same thing!

[@chasilva6860]

Um, do you mean the demon Sam and how Dean felt about it?

[@arynsinger6811]

I love my cats Sam was never a Demon, he was soulless, and did drink demon blood and at one point was possessed by an angel, but he was never a Demon. Dean, however has been a demon in season 11.

[@chasilva6860]

Savannah Nightfall 617 right, I forgot

[@daisyrisden6934]

not season 11 It's season 10

[@MethuselahWinter]

I'm thinking about Cas and Dean.

[@tashagodfrey638]

I'm not the only one getting a supernatural feel from this!! Yay, I get more of a Sam and Dean feel though, like when Dean had the mark of Cain or when Sam was soulless

[@Demongirl1295]

+Tasha Godfrey Oh my god that is exactly what I´m thinking about!

[@MyAnanin]

+Tasha Godfrey I totaly agree!

[@latata_7514]

OMG thank you! Someone who understands!

[@KingKamidereSama]

I'm thinking about humans that actually exist and matter.

[@nataliechapman4992]

PERCABETH IN TARTARUS.

[@chakshikagarg746]

Natalie Chapman yes

[@shanzea]

Natalie Chapman FINALLY!! someone who thinks like me...

[@idontevenknow-578]

Absolutely

[@desaster903]

YES

[@Kamili_Creations]

OMG! IKR!!!!!!!

[@labinatasfia624]

This song goes so well with a story I am writing. The boy and the girl, they are in a toxic relationship. The girl knows the boy is bad for her. but she can't move on because she hopes that the guy she once loved was still in there, hidden behind the deamon that now replaced her lover...