The WORST Albums of ALL TIME (According to Metacritic)

[@beyondartv]

What's the biggest agree/disagree you saw on this list? Remember, Metacritic is not an individual site/person, it's an AGGREGATE site (like Rotten Tomatoes) The Worst Albums According to RateYourMusic: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pYavo4Fsir97l9k The Worst Albums According to Album of the Year: kzbin.info/www/bejne/d32qpqmIlM-mmNk

[@georgecoxy]

Beyond ARTV Screaming bloody murder- my personal favourite album of all time. Have got used to mixed reviews of it at this point though.

[@Flamingbro69]

Still better than pitchfork

[@julconnor]

I’m most disappointed that this list has One of the Boys! That’s my favorite Katy Perry album :(

[@Thesportsmusicgod]

You should react to allmusic

[@MetalUpYourAss618]

I disagree with Nickelback because Side of a Bullet off of All The Right Reasons has Dimebag from Pantera on it posthumously, and Just to Get High off of Dark Horse is actually pretty good. I also disagree with Good Charlotte because the River with M. Shadows and Synster Gates from Avenged Sevenfold is a good tune.

[@avanicollle]

the masterpiece that is angelic 2 the core better not be on this list 😤😤😤

[@PollyGammy]

ava nicole you, Ava, are my new favorite human.

[@avanicollle]

Lynnie Shaw IM HONORED

[@VictoriaSobocki]

Yes hahahaha

[@FlamingRaccoons]

Ascension Millennium 😍😍😍

[@vitaminwater9662]

quirky

[@ToxPhy]

I forgot there was a point where Katy Perry was the most controversial artist in pop. Those were the days.

[@melloncollie3321]

MUCH better days. 😢

[@johnjoefitzpatrick8483]

I don't like One of the Boys that much but it's not terrible by any means.

[@ToxPhy]

John Joe Fitzpatrick I didn’t mean it was controversial cuz it was bad or anything. I meant cuz the songs I Kissed A Girl and Waking Up In Vegas (mostly I Kissed A Girl) got soccer moms upset because they thought the lyrics were edgy which they sadly kind of were by 2008 standards.

[@johnjoefitzpatrick8483]

@@ToxPhy I suppose but imo those soccer moms would've shit themselves if they heard Lady Gaga. She was way edgier imo.

[@Merdicano]

Controversial?, more creative back in the day

[@claudiax233]

That Chris Brown album is definitely horrible.

[@Benlovescheese]

Which one?

[@claudiax233]

CheeseMan Fortune. I haven’t listened to Graffiti.

[@Benlovescheese]

Freddie faulig yes

[@julenliantrehe6780]

Chris Brown is horrible.

[@Cthulu1985]

That Chris Brown is definitely horrible. There. Much better ;)

[@corbinm5237]

Are you wearing that shirt to tell SOAD to get it together now that Tool actually released a new album?

[@kylehegedus5498]

One can dream!!!!

[@sirspookybones1118]

When pigs do Aerials anyway

[@ericb.1384]

Everybody knows that activists can't get along with each other. Almost like they are extreme people...

[@dhritvanalva1128]

You called it

[@bruhmomentmaker4979]

They did

[@8nicopink868]

So Can't be Tamed by Miley is on here but Dead Petz isn't? WHAT?!

[@squeallymaniac]

Critics have gotten nicer lately

[@8nicopink868]

@@squeallymaniac Only to Miley, apparently. 'Cause there's some recent albums that are low on the list (Like the Tekashi album and the Charlie Puth debut)

[@squeallymaniac]

@@8nicopink868 good point, I'd say they've gotten nicer to female pop artists...like Katy getting below 50 with one of the boys 10 years ago is ridiculous

[@HeavyMetal-jy4vj]

This was critics being unsure if Miley was a music genius Voice of Her Generation or not. Critics are too afraid to be savage with Miley because they don't want to get embarrassed in the future "see what Mrs. John Lennon got for Dead Petz when she invented music for the 2020s! how scandalous!" lol

[@Raacelavigne]

Dead petz is an amazing album, for that album i came a Smiler, i think the experimental trippy sounds are awesome

[@nomoreyt4657]

i strongly disagree with one of the boys. if anything, i personally think it’s katy’s BEST album.

[@peytonjames]

i looovvveeee OOTB

[@camerondeshun6943]

GEOFF GRANDE that’s her worst work omg

[@nomoreyt4657]

camerondeshun tasteless.

[@camerondeshun6943]

GEOFF GRANDE is what you are

[@nomoreyt4657]

camerondeshun bet.

[@mrflibble1259]

Why are all these "worst albums of all time" rated at like a 5 or 4 out of 10? They're not even hugely bad scores

[@supertenor2767]

5/10 = 50 = F Lol

[@Sound_Judgement]

It’s because they are aggregate scores, so some would give incredibly low scores and some would give higher, though not too high, scores which averages out to something higher than one would expect. The average music score on there is probably in the low to mid 70’s, which shows how kind critics as a whole generally are to music. So for something to average below 50 is a pretty damning comment on that music not being able to appeal at all to quite a few different people. It’s actually interesting to note how different reviews look on different mediums on Metacritic. Several movies have 1 out of 100, but the lowest album is 15 and I believe the lowest T.V. and Video Games are in the 20’s or 30’s. Video games enter the Yellow category of Mixed Reviews at a much, much higher threshold (I think it’s 75, if I remember correctly, as opposed to 59 for everything else), which is its own cause for debate. And television often only has scores for first seasons of shows unless the show is getting a lot of hype (like Game of Thrones or Breaking Bad), so something like Supernatural has only one score for its first season, despite being a cult hit for over a decade now, because not enough critics reviewed those latter seasons of shows like this for it to get a score.

[@mrflibble1259]

@@Sound_Judgement in short, metacritic sucks

[@ericb.1384]

Video game review logic. 7/10 = terrible

[@HotStrange]

supertenor Thats not how it works at all you dingus. A 5/10 is not a terrible score. This isn’t high school.

[@Acadiaspartan]

When your band name is literally "LMFAO", then how could you possibly expect any music you make to be taken seriously or rated well? 😂

[@Regent192]

@@deathstrokethemerc6023 you must be very young that acronym was around wayyyyy longer

[@iliketrains3495]

Was their music meant to be taken seriously?

[@solarion13]

They aren’t even a band lol.

[@liammcnicholas918]

They're the poor man's Lonely Island

[@vz2428]

@@tylerhackner9731 because parties

[@bgl1335]

If you think that screaming bloody murder is one of the worst albums ever, then you should listen to WAYYY MORE MUSIC

[@rogainegaming6924]

That's what i thought. Screaming Bloody Murder isn't even a bad album let alone one of the WORST EVER.

[@ellielovesbands]

it's one of my favorites of all time.

[@raphaelovicstrassovic9440]

It's in my top 3 sum 41 albums..

[@TheScoobyRawShow]

Hell naw boy 😂😂😂

[@djsmith1166]

I think you’re the one who needs to listen to more music lol

[@quentinbringthenumetalchil5125]

Lil Xan’s album was a little deserving, but I would put it down ten more spots.

[@Thesportsmusicgod]

Yes lil xan is trash

[@Slycoomer56]

Xan is not terrible. People just like to hate on anything. His Pac comments fucked him for life though.

[@markocenic299]

Delet dis he is trash. Pac thing is just another thing destroying him in life.

[@Slycoomer56]

@@markocenic299 You have em as your pfp of course you would say that.

[@markocenic299]

Delet dis the only reason i have eminems photo is coz i like his music . Its a fact that lil xan complete utter garbage who has nothing to offer in game just like other 60% of todays mainstream artists who sound the same.

[@gibbysmoviecorner8286]

This one will be fun, also nice shirt! (Ps can’t wait for the fear innoculum review)

[@animatedCHUG]

Seeing "Take A Look In The Mirror" by Korn with a score that was below 50 made me question the people that criticise these albums ... Smh

[@miahthorpatrick1013]

@XMasterX Mk2 It is one of their worst but I wouldn’t call it terrible. I think it got slammed because it had Nas as a guest rapper. And Y’all wanna single received a lot of hate

[@animatedCHUG]

@@miahthorpatrick1013 The only Korn album I've heard and thought was kinda bad was The Path Of Totality (or whatever it was called)

[@dannyliebs702]

XMasterX Mk2 honestly, I thought Korn’s untitled 2007 album was worse, but TALITM wasn’t exactly a good album in its entirety tbh.

[@HotStrange]

It’s probably the worst (IMO) of their “peak” from the debut to See You on the Other side, but definitely isn’t a terrible album. It’s a least a 6-6.5/10. It can’t compare to the albums before it though. Especially Issue and Untouchables.

[@hoovy1163]

Am i the only one who thinks that Take a Look In the Mirror is literally better than anything they released after? It sounds so unique heavy loud and angry, ik the production sounds kinda weird but i actually love it, the bass is perhaps the best part about this album, the other albums after just don't do it for me the way this one did, not even SYOTOS

[@AJARyan-yn2uv]

That description for Federline’s album is pretty savage.

[@excelsiormusicreviews]

Just to clarify, Mutt Lange’s last name is pronounced like Lang. He’s famous for working with AC/DC and early Def Leppard. He was married to Shania Twain.

[@starfox878]

@@ASmartassInHis40s there are plenty of other creators making content like this who actually do their research. This guy fails every time he strays out of 2010's pop punk.

[@belltolls1984]

Yeah the fact he had no idea who Mutt is was ridiculous.

[@Thesportsmusicgod]

Good list I love your reactions and yes Nickleback are very overhated

[@Sound_Judgement]

I agree that Nickelback are overly hated, since Silver Side Up, The Long Road, and their recent Feed the Machine are actually decent to pretty good. But I don’t agree if we’re talking about the albums on this list, specifically. They are both on my list of worst albums I’ve ever heard, and I personally don’t think they have any redeeming qualities. I can admit to liking both somewhat at one point in one, but over time they have soured on me to the point that I could live happily without ever hearing even the “best” songs on them ever again.

[@Merdicano]

@@Sound_Judgement I love Feed The Machine

[@bobbyfagan7760]

I don’t hate them, they just haven’t had any good songs

[@nitromagilou597]

I was pretty indifferent towards Nickelback. While they're not great, there are a few songs I did like.

[@HotStrange]

They’re definitely over-hated but still, they’re not a great band.

[@dcp10200]

Mutt Lange (Pronounced Lang) is the producer behind bands like AC/DC, Def Leppard, Foreigner, Bryan Adams, and The Cars. He also produced Drones by Muse and pioneered some of the editing and mixing techniques we use today in Digital Audio production on Analog Tape.

[@iliketrains3495]

I'm surprised he didn't recognise him as the producer of Drones

[@HotStrange]

I Like Trains yes Lange is an otherwise great producer.

[@prairiedog5875]

Mutt not only produced most of Shania Twain albums..and was married to her.

[@K3BBO]

Nickelback honestly aren’t even that bad. In fact they are quite talented and make catchy music. The thing is the overwhelming majority all sound the same.

[@alexswift456]

I love Billy Talent III. Hard disagree there

[@nitromagilou597]

It's blasphemous seeing a Billy Talent album on a worst list.

[@cymeacham4102]

Same!

[@gergoretvari6373]

they should get a better opinion

[@tintinabello]

I'm offended, confused and disgusted about Owl City's inclusion on this list :(

[@ronstoppable5659]

and Sum 41

[@iliketrains3495]

And Imagine Dragons

[@Merdicano]

@@iliketrains3495 I still forever be a fan of Evolve, no one will change my mind

[@kriigd]

Manuel David Rendon Acevedo nah evolve deserved it

[@MrBrezelwurst]

Me but with I Love You

[@jowens197]

I've barely heard any of these. My ears are grateful for good taste in music 😅

[@iliketrains3495]

The only two I’ve heard are Evolve and One More Light

[@mikaeruu0309]

im sad bcuz i cant confirm or not, my fave albums arent on the website D:

[@Merdicano]

@@iliketrains3495 Which I like, even if I'm the minority

[@HotStrange]

Hol Horse lol what?

[@GustavoEPerez-gj7qz]

69 LIKES!!!!!!!!

[@kitea007]

I Love You by the Neighbourhood remains one of my favorite albums of all time since it's release. They get way too much undeserved hate :(.

[@jobmeyer4442]

One More Light should NOT be on here... sure, it is the band's worst, but I really don't see it to be that bad. It surely isn't good, though. And Incubus' If Not Now When?! Seriously!? It may not be one of my favorites by them, but I thought it was decent! I found 8 to be worse though. It's the band's worst album, but I don't see it to be that bad, personally.

[@HotStrange]

IMO, Light Grenades was their last good album. That said, all he’s doing is listing albums from Metacritic’s website. Be mad at the critics.

[@ForbiddenFruit73]

I honestly think "Liz Phair" is a pretty good pop album that got way more hate than it deserved.

[@kriptyk]

Results May Vary - One of the worst albums of all time. Big Rigs - The worst game ever made N-Gage - The worst console ever made 2003 - The worst year to do literally anything

[@uwu-nr9mh]

One of the boys STRONG disagree

[@sayaloal373]

SAME

[@miahthorpatrick1013]

@Adriana Ortega Yeah this one surprised me. I still have my copy. Not a burned cd. Actually bought the album from a store!!!

[@HotStrange]

Miah Thorpatrick Lots of people have bought albums from the store, but that doesn’t make it a good record.

[@wolfydafloof1720]

I disagreed with both Nickelback albums, the Megadeth one, and the Linkin Park album. Actually love all of those lol. ( Don't hate me please xD

[@HotStrange]

Please listen to better/other music.

[@danielalmeida7382]

Fr supercollider isn’t even megadeth’s worst album

[@danielalmeida7382]

@@HotStrange listen to risk than go listen to supercollider and you will see he is not wrong

[@solangemorell2048]

Why is I love you by The Neighborhood on that list loool??? Those guys brought back that sound in like 2013. It’s actually a decent album

[@kitea007]

that album is on of my favorites of all time!!

[@MrBrezelwurst]

I don't get it either. They may be 'edgy', but their songs are actually not bad

[@SOBEKCrocodileGod]

Honestly surprised to see Take A Look in the Mirror (honestly a solid nu metal record with some standout moments) and Screaming Bloody Murder (I haven’t even seen Sum 41 get hated by critics THAT much unless you count punk elitists on Internet forums)

[@FabulousKilljoy]

Those Nickelback puns tho 👌🏽

[@bubbles2215]

I agreed with most of these except One of the Boys! It’s kind of held up better then Teenage Dream and I think it might honestly be Katy’s best album.

[@miahthorpatrick1013]

@bubbles One of the boys was just fine. Not deserving of such a low score!

[@taylorjames14]

I really like screaming bloody murder, good morning revival, one more light, nine track mind and one of the boys 🤷‍♂️

[@HotStrange]

You should get into some better and different kinds of music.

[@steamboatwill3.367]

​@@HotStrange) "better" to you

[@williamfernetducharme]

9:29 yes, 1234 by Plain White T's was on Big Bad World.

[@jamesdodsworth3481]

Mutt Lange is pronounced like lang. Very good producer, worked with Def Leppard on albums like hysteria and was also married to Shania Twain for a bit

[@StationaryWilburys]

Made me think of “Tom Delöngé”

[@bryanfahey3144]

I literally just said the same thing...about a year later. lol.

[@djentyman4002]

Produced Highway to Hell, Back in Black and For Those About to Rock with several other huge best seller albums.. easily the best producer in music

[@stuartmayberry666]

Also produced "Back in Black".

[@ThatM84Guy]

I came here to basically say this. Foreigner, AC/DC, Def Leppard..... he was as big as it got in the 80's. Multiple diamond albums under his belt.

[@andyitliong4333]

Screaming bloody murder has some great songs on it, no one can change my mind

[@MrFrye12345]

Time For You To Go is my personal fav

[@InfiniteBeak]

It's the second best Sum 41 album after Chuck, no one can change my mind

[@biological_slicer]

For a moment i actually read it as "scream bloody gore"

[@cementman_]

@@biological_slicer yea so did I

[@SamC_182]

One of the best albums I've ever heard

[@ThesharkStrangler]

Metallica is my favorite band but Lulu is the worst album I’ve ever heard

[@kylehegedus5498]

John Spence I AM THE TABLE!!!! 😂😂😂😂😂

[@s.hi.1076]

Lulu is the 2nd best Lou Reed album and the best Metallica album.

[@HotStrange]

Disagree. I thought it was pretty decent.

[@plantdaddy2371]

Same with Black Eyed Peas and The Beginning

[@Highrollinhunter]

Metallica is also my favorite band omg I thought St. Anger was bad due to Metallica moving in a Numetal genre and using that trash can snare with no guitar solos but Lulu made me almost puke I AM THE TABLE

[@TheRiverLeW]

Kinda surprised you didn't at least mention Hinder's wretched sophomore album "Take It To The Limit," which should have been somewhere in the 49 range.

[@CynicalScorpio]

There's actully quite a few albums on this list that I like: If Not Now When (Incubus): Yes, it's very slow paced, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. Most of the melodies on the album are incredible, it has some of the strongest and most emotional ballads they've ever written. The atmosphere is also quite meloncholic. Sure, the production is a bit too clean perhaps, but it works fine for the album. I Love You (The Neighborhood): Like John said, it has great atmosphere. It's just the right amount of eerie. I love the beachy, washed out guitars as well. Some of the choruses aren't the strongest, but it has plenty of other postive qualities. All the Right Reasons (Nickelback): Not a terrible album by any means. It's just a generic rock album at its core. But I have a soft spot for Nickelback, mostly for nostalgic reasons. Evolve (Imagine Dragons): It's got those huge, anthemic choruses that Imagine Dragons is known for, just with more electronics than the first two albums. A lot of people rag on them for it, but I really think they have a knack for conveying that grand and epic feel. Sure, they use this motif a lot, but that's just their style. They make arena rock. Hating Imagine Dragons for this is like hating a punk band for every song sounding "too punky." The album also has plenty of variety. I do have some issue, like the overly polished production. But overall it's a good album if you like Imagine Dragons. Results May Vary (Limp Bizkit): Call me crazy, but I actully quite like this album as well as Limp Bizkit. They're one of those bands that aren't meant to be taken super seriously. And according to most criticisms I've heard, people only seem to take issue with Fred Durst rather than the band as a whole. Yes, he's obnoxious and his lyrics are juvenile. But it's so over-the-top and kinda tongue-in-cheek. They have charm. It's a dumb and kinda goofy charm, but still charm none the less. Anyway, Results May Very is the closest they've come to writting a serious album. Just listen to Let Me Down, Lonely World, Build a Bridge, and you'll see what I mean.

[@HotStrange]

Disagree except for the Incubus album. It’s not amazing but definitely not one of the worst things I’ve ever heard. Light Grenades is still their last good album, IMO.

[@ideiasradicaispt9772]

I guess Limp Bizkit must have been a generational band. I loved chocolate starfish and I don't know many people my age who don't like it. Results may vary, we can agree on, but definitely not on Limp Bizkit as a band.

[@Juli_is_Online]

This made me realize Chester has already been gone for 2 years now ;( R.I.P

[@tiffy3787]

I love Billy Talent! I saw them in 03 when I worked the concession stand at a local venue and I have all their autographs from way before they got anywhere.

[@KM-kc2qr]

Hey jon are you wearing a system of a down shirt?

[@818cantfail]

Limp bizkits debut album was great dont care what anyone says

[@grg981998]

The truth is even better👌

[@818cantfail]

@@grg981998 very good

[@HotStrange]

Chocolate Starfish is great, too.

[@DL500316]

Hey ARTV, great video. But I just gotta ask, where’d you get that sweet System of a Down shirt? It looks nice.

[@beyondartv]

Got it when they performed at Boston Calling music festival this year! Thanks!

[@lizziepurdy6415]

Jon what are your opinions on Kasabian??

[@lolaab0702]

Thank you so much for sticking up for “One Of The Boys”. Some of those tracks are my childhood.

[@GaryLucasMusic]

Jagged Little Pill acoustic is brilliant - her voice sounds more refined I guess, so those looking to access nostalgia through her wild, unrestrained vocals might have found it too cleaned up. But I love it. And Liz Phair's self-titled album is my guilty pleasure. Such catchy pop-rock songs - Extraordinary, Favorite, Rock Me. Even had a really sweet moment with a song about her son called "Little Digger". Love this album.

[@kevinsmith7841]

Mutt Lange has been a legendary music producer for nearly 40 years and you mention him as if he were some obscure inconsequential figure in music history. Lange literally helped shape pop music as we know it.

[@justinchico]

This dude needs to do his homework before posting.

[@BassPlayerSusan]

@@justinchico I agree.

[@madisonking4176]

could you do a video about the best albums on metacritic?

[@thecosmicblueautie]

There will be reissues on reissues listed, if he does. I'd love for him to discount those, if he does.

[@Sound_Judgement]

I’m pretty sure they have a list which excludes those. Right now, number one is massive jazz album called “Ten Freedom Summers” by Wadada Leo Smith, with a 99. It’s not one for casual or easy listening given that it’s 4 1/2 hours of free jazz with the Civil Rights movement as it’s main theme, but if jazz is your thing, it’s arguably a masterpiece and worth your time.

[@sophiedufresne7459]

Is it weird that as someone who never really listened to Good Charlotte, I sometimes get the urge to binge listen to "I don't wanna be in love (Dance Anthem)"?? 😂😂

[@battlep0t]

Screaming Bloody Murder should not be on there at all. One of Sum 41's most underrated albums.

[@andrewh_25]

Where is the last 30 Seconds to Mars album?

[@HotStrange]

Seems like a lot of people don’t realize that John didn’t make this list. It’s from Metacritic’s worst rated albums.

[@riddypr]

Funny thing about Plain White T's, "1, 2, 3, 4" was taken off Big Bad World on (UK) Spotify and instead placed at the tail end of the album that followed it. No idea why they did that.

[@legendbtv]

I still wonder how Nickelback was so hated, yet sold SO MANY RECORDS!!!!

[@alanwright2842]

His voice and some of the lyrics

[@natalieshannon7659]

IMHO any mumble rappers like Li Xan, six nine, LIL Pump need to automatically be put on worst albums of all time. One song of mumble rap is hard to listen too. A whole album is torture.

[@nicoshoot94]

I loved Screaming Bloody Murder. There are so many great songs on it.

[@matteopera3479]

Screaming bloody murder is a GREAT record

[@MoMo-hg4jk]

One of the boys is so underrated it’s actually Katy’s best album imo🤡

[@jurgenstrang6366]

Screaming bloody murder is a fantastic album, before Order In Decline it was sum 41's best record

[@aimee-hyj]

I can't believe "I love you." is on here !! I love every song on that album :(((

[@kitea007]

sameee

[@davidellis5141]

Mine are both especially terrible records because the artists are so talented. Chinese Demoracy by Guns & Roses & Metal Machine Music by Lou Reed. Coda by Led Zeppelin was a record from the vaults that should have stayed in the vault !

[@HotStrange]

Lmao I think you missed the point of Metal Machine Music. It was made to be grating. It’s an experimental record and it excels at what it does. It’s unlistenable but it’s supposed to be unlistenable.

[@austinfusselman656]

Coda by Led Zeppelin WAS pretty bad for being Led Zeppelin. Haha

[@Stefan_Gerards]

i used to be obsessed with LMFAO in 2011/2012.... but i completely agree with One of the Boys, i thought it would've been in the mid 60s o.o

[@dimetrealexiou5633]

I'm very surprised about Billy Talent III. "Devil On My Shoulder" and "Rusted From The Rain" are great songs. There's some filler, but I hardly think it's a bad album.

[@ashleedawn456]

I'm surprised Angelic 2 the Core wasn't on the list.

[@s.hi.1076]

It's actually one of the more entertaining albums of all time.

[@Agostina999]

7:07 On behalf of all the Barnes and Noble booksellers who had to listen to this pompous album twice a shift, thank you Metacritic. Thank you for understanding our pain and suffering

[@flashjet21]

10:55 I bet it was all the criticism that led chester to commit suicide, i remember when that album just came out everyone was complaining that the sound was not linkin park and he was getting pissed because that wanted to try something new

[@squeallymaniac]

Liz Phair's album has some very high reviews as well as some very low ones. Why Can't I is a great song

[@clubfaist]

I agree, that album is certainly not her best album. But Extraordinary, Red Light Fever, Little Digger, HWC, and Why Can't I are really good songs that borderline save the record. Honestly that album gets a bit too much hate imo.

[@MMMedia]

Next you should do the worst albums you own in cd or vinyl c:

[@ChrisNorwood3]

@1:50 Mutt what?

[@michaelcanada6583]

One More Light is a great album. But if your looking at it with a closed-minded outlook then it isn't a good Linkin Park album. But if you look at it as artists musically experimenting and being lyrically transparent about their lives, then it is a great chapter in LP's story.

[@cameronlambert5185]

I don’t mind that it’s pop but the thing is it’s not very good pop

[@onestarcloser7410]

Glad not to see any Coldplay on here considering they’re pretty much the most hated band in Britain

[@Merdicano]

Why?, no seriously, why?

[@mccoyyoung4806]

I don’t understand why they’re hated either, Chris Martin is a really humble guy and they just make solid I don’t see what the issue is

[@mccoyyoung4806]

Also Fix You is just amazing, my favorite song ever

[@Merdicano]

@@mccoyyoung4806 People don't like them because of the "bands trying to be different" issue, but I myself I don't think they've changed at all

[@onestarcloser7410]

@Manuel David Rendon Acevedo I truly think they've changed, but I still like them

[@FabulousKilljoy]

7:41 Twelve-year-old me is screaming 😂

[@iliketrains3495]

It’s only been two years

[@titanfighter12]

Dark Horse is one of Nickelback's better albums too

[@ShadowOfADoubt9]

I like Screaming Bloody Murder but whatever. Also I don't like One More Light but it isn't THAT bad.

[@FELCommentary]

It's almost like the entire industry and fanbase forgot that Linkin Park was always changing their sound since their junior album. I admit it wasn't good but Jesus Christ Angelic to the Core, St Anger and Chinese Democracy weren't even on the list.

[@mustafa_ali_]

I love Linkin park's album one more light listen to it cover to cover

[@iliketrains3495]

Probably irrelevant, but you share a name with a wrestler

[@nerdyoutube7847]

Title track is a banger and I enjoy a few others

[@counterforms8756]

The Chris Brown albums are primarily rated so low because of the Rihanna abuse.

[@InfantGoose6565]

Am I the only one questioning how the hell he knew like every single album?

[@darkstormmwe2566]

No,Me too 🤣🤣🤣

[@iliketrains3495]

He had never even heard of the Alanis one and many he didn't know were omitted from the video. Although I think with some like the Limp Bizkit one he just ran with the majority opinion

[@godbrandrecords]

When I was 11, Dark Horse was my favorite album. In my defense I didn't know anything about anything. One could argue I still don't.

[@HotStrange]

Lmao I was a Nickelback fan when they first came out as well.

[@drmmr561]

Keep Your Hands off My Girl from GC's Good Morning Revival remains to this day one of my biggest guilty pleasures.

[@archiecook55]

2:37 I'm more of an Ocean Eyes fan but I'm right there with you defending All Things Bright and Beautiful

[@Borgmatha1027]

I'm literally the only person on earth who doesn't hate Evolve by Imagine Dragons. While i will say it is their worst album, even worse than origins, but i like some of the songs. Walking the Wire, Whatever it Takes, Mouth of the River, and even Believer are songs that i like. But, i do see why it's here. To me, the song Yesterday automatically tanks the album by like 20%.

[@onestarcloser7410]

It's fucking Thunder that brings it down for me

[@Merdicano]

You're not the only one, I'm also here

[@charlottexroyalty7819]

My biggest disagree on this list is Mariah's Charmbracelet it is easily an 8/10 to me.

[@squeallymaniac]

Maybe if it had a hit, it would have better reviews sadly

[@Betta66]

Hey, Luke did a Regretting The Past video on some of these

[@OwlEye2010]

Glad to see someone else who liked (or, at the very least, didn't mind) All the Right Reasons! That album is such a nostalgia trip for me. :)

[@mrc-rrn]

One More Light doesn't deserve a ranking that low

[@Ashannon888]

Yeah deserved lower.

[@toadetteremotewithwiimotio3330]

I‘m just here because i saw Screaming Bloody Murder on the thumbnail and i‘m kinda upset

[@bigcm5531]

Is st. Anger on the list

[@bigcm5531]

Wtf st. Anger isn't on the list??worst album EVER

[@iliketrains3495]

Evolve isn’t a great record but it’s a bit of a pisstake this is on here but every Ariana Grande And Cardi B album has a green. also you thought every song sounded too different? I thought every song sounded the SAME lol

[@riahlexington]

What if it’s because Ariana’s albums are actually decent I haven’t heard Cardi’s album

[@iliketrains3495]

Ariana's albums are FAR from even decent lol. But you're doing the right thing by not hearing Cardi's.

[@riahlexington]

I Like Trains ok first of all that’s a matter of personal taste, I reviewed them all on my channel and gave them 6 of above and no I’m not trying to get on a bandwagon. It’s personal taste and ok if you don’t like it but your opinion doesn’t dictate critical consensus. And doesn’t Cardi just have the one album?

[@Merdicano]

I still love Evolve, no one will change my mind about it

[@lightningboy2879]

I Like Trains it must hurt that Ariana gets better reviews than green day

[@norbs3802]

i wish evolve wasnt there i dont think thats a bad album

[@alex_flamer]

Albums that should have been on there: St. Anger - Metallica Angelic to the Core - Corey Feldman Speeding Bullet to Heaven - Kid Cudi Taking One For The Team - Simple Plan California - Blink-182 Teenage Emotions - Lil Yachty Heartbreak on a Full Moon - Chris Brown Scorpion - Drake Origins - Imagine Dragons Red Pill Blues - Maroon 5 V - Maroon 5 17 - XXXTENTACION Catharsis - Machine Head America - 30 Seconds to Mars When Legends Rise - Godsmack The Click - AJR Neotheater - AJR Self Titled - Prophets of Rage Illuminate - Shawn Mendes Frequency Unknown - Queensryche

[@iliketrains3495]

AlexFlamer444 nah the Blink, Imagine Dragons And Shawn Mendes ones were fine

[@katiedelafuente]

Ooooff. Metallica hit rock bottom with that album

[@Merdicano]

Guess 30STM can't catch a break, oh well

[@凍結數據]

I like 17 and Scorpion. HBOAFM was just too long.

[@MrBrezelwurst]

The Big Day by Chance The Rapper

[@John-uy6ks]

I actually think one more light is pretty good, if you listen to the lyrics they have a really deep meaning and it definately takes a few listens to appreciate it

[@theabacross1581]

I'm surprised there wasn't more Limp Bizkit albums also where's St. Anger?

[@spamsingles5948]

St. Anger is one of the worst albums I've ever heard

[@iliketrains3495]

Maybe he skipped St Anger. I can’t be arsed to go to the site and check

[@Highrollinhunter]

Lulu is worse than St. Anger frantic is my favorite song on St. Anger

[@mackalrath]

the only one i would 100% go to bar for us the Owl City album - the whole record is amazing, and Deer in the Headlights is one of my favorites songs from my childhood. I have no idea why it’s on this list.

[@denniskillingsworth4436]

I can't stand Metacritic.. How can they rate Screaming Bloody Murder so low when they have several good hits on that album??

[@KhaosKontroller]

Results May Vary has some good tracks like Eat You Live, Creamer and Head for the Barricade.

[@sxcxmusic]

convinced Ashlee Simpson’s I Am Me was only included bc of the misogynistic hatred towards her at the time. critics took their dislike towards her out on her music, which was always top quality. would love to see you revisit it today.

[@ronstoppable5659]

Her voice is pretty much unbearable for me to listen to, she wanted to be the next Avril Lavigne, Alanis Morissette, or Michelle Branch but she sounds like she's doing a really bad Courtney Love impression

[@beyondartv]

No, she was just terrible. Not everything is about gender or politics lol. You gonna tell me they did my boy K-Fed so dirty bc of similar reasons?

[@sxcxmusic]

Beyond ARTV have to strong disagree, maybe you should re-visit the album with an open mind, you might find it’s actually quite good pop/rock music

[@Jayagebee]

Hey Jon! Have you heard Bloodhound Gang’s 2005 record Hefty Fine? A 28/100 on Metacritic. I bought it when it came out and oh boy do I regret that 😅

[@germanbushin9723]

I Love You by The Neighbourhood is in my Top-30 favourite albums of all time, sometimes I have no fucking clue what critics are smoking. It may not be someone's cup of tea, but the fact that general critical reception of this album was the same as Total Xanarchy's reception is just fucking insane

[@murlough23]

I was definitely caught off guard by Jagged Little Pill Acoustic being on the list. I can remember critics being rather “meh” about it, but I didn’t think it had gotten enough outright hate to give it THAT low of an average score. UNPOPULAR OPINION ALERT: I actually find JLP Acoustic to be more listenable than the original JLP. I know a lot of the rage and shock value is gone in the mellower acoustic versions, and that’s probably what originally drew a lot of people to Alanis. But I think the newer versions of songs like “Perfect” and “Forgiven” that were dark horse picks on the original are downright exquisite; I could barely stand the rough vocal takes on the originals. She was in a healthier place in 2005 and was looking back at the songs that launched her to super stardom with more introspection, and I guess folks were only interested in hearing her heartbroken and pissed off. I also thought the moment in “Ironic” where she subverts the expected rhyme with “knife” by changing the lyric to “meeting his beautiful husband” was hilarious.

[@cerablossoms]

I Love You by the Neighbourhood doesn't deserve this kind of slander- it's my #1 favorite album of all time and I even have the album art as a tattoo it was THAT much of a masterpiece. People afraid of the truth i guess