Big Brother (US) - Who Would I Vote For? (2024)

In this video, I redo another of my Who Would I Vote For vidoes from five years ago where here I go through every single season of Big Brother US and discuss who I would have voted for at each Final 2.
Twitch Channel: / themeranianreview
VOD Channel: / @themeranianreviewlive

[@bobbyhall994]

Thank you for the compliments to Steve. I can’t imagine prepping and planning a game plan and actively maneuvering around Vanessa the way he did.

[@AlphaOutlaw]

Steve has one of my favorite winning games in the series thanks to his self-awareness, ability to stick to his plan to win, and ability to manage the painfully conplex dynamic that is Vanessa. I think that only one other winner could definitively do that with two other possibly doing so with Vanessa as well (those being Andy as the definite and Dan and Derrick being the possibles)

[@abf9596]

@@AlphaOutlaw Jun would be interesting against Vanessa

[@AlphaOutlaw]

@@abf9596 Definitely, but I worry a bit for her odds in that case since both are way too similar in some regards to not clash at some point

[@abf9596]

Jun, Andy, Derrick, Vanessa all dangerous...all legends.

[@AlphaOutlaw]

@@abf9596 True, but I don't think many of them would be able to pull of the game Steve did

[@justinguidroz9659]

Taylor never got voted out of the game. She was going to be voted out of the game but got saved due to the Paloma quit.

[@OakInOasis]

And even then, it really wasn't gonna be her fault if she got voted out.

[@boris12709]

also the twist that week was the evicted houseguest would compete in a comp against the loser of the twist, which woulda been paloma coincidentally. So the outcome would remain the same. Paloma out, Taylor in. Unless Paloma would be able to pull a win which i doubt

[@angry_sza_fan9006]

You’re forgetting that the twist would’ve saved her tho

[@justinguidroz9659]

@@angry_sza_fan9006 I remember the twist. Taylor still would have been voted out however. My point is that, because of the twist, Taylor was never voted out like he said in this video.

[@angry_sza_fan9006]

@425v-s she would’ve have survived without the cancellation…

[@WypsotorNyloff]

27:30 bro said postmerge. Survivor brainrot is real

[@baileylynn5562]

I didn’t even notice it either 😭

[@luxx4]

😭

[@BigBrotherBunker]

😂😂

[@mechanicalthephantomonial7757]

While I dont agree with everything (like Porsche v Rachel for instance), I appreciate you being willing to share your opinion even if it goes against the grain.

[@WilsonReviews]

BB14 and BB24 are tough because I feel like my vote would depend on what criteria I go with. If I was voting based on gameplay, I would vote for Dan/Monte, while if I was voting based on story, I would vote for Ian/Taylor

[@raheemfielder-bey998]

You shouldn’t be voting on story if your preach gameplay as a juror.

[@boopityb00p]

Monte’s gameplay is shit tho

[@raheemfielder-bey998]

@@boopityb00p literally ran the last few weeks of the game with Taylor literally going along with what he said.

[@devondonato4609]

@@raheemfielder-bey998it was comp based and he was listening to Taylor when she got him to turn on Turner

[@devondonato4609]

@425v-s Taylor was always going to use that campaign against Turner though. Like why the hell would she not if she’s in the final three with them? She already knew her best situation was Brittany and Monte in F3

[@superwilly55]

Wow this came out just after I was watching the 2019 version “who would I vote for BBUS” yesterday.

[@NikkiC-hl3bg]

I’m still wishing Tiffany had won season 23. You can miss me with X and Big D making it to final 2. I couldn’t stand either one of them.

[@cullerjones]

I would never vote for Monte after he took Taylor to Final 2 over freaking Turner. I don't reward you for epic stupidity.

[@tajneeley]

Lmao, my Brother who has only watched snippets of BB15 and BB20 overhead J-Maries name and runs into my room and screams I’d vote for Jeana Marie! In a thick New York accent.😂

[@eliasmg9144]

But why???????

[@Qsurvivorfan]

The king uploaded right in time for my lunch break 🫡🙌🏼

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

its always noon

[@snowballglobe5176]

This is crazy i was just watching ur 2019 version last night

[@od2152]

Can someone please tell me when Taylor was voted out of the game??? Like that literally never happened, there’s never a point on the season where a majority of the HG’s go into the diary room and say they vote to evict Taylor. And it’s not like a Jag situation where he gets voted out and a twist saves him- Paloma’s quit was the week 1 eviction and that’s that, it’s not that hard to comprehend

[@tajneeley]

Not the same as Jag but she would have been voted baring twist / paloma exit.

[@smitty5967]

Voting for Curtis Kin for BB1? Bold move

[@princessbubbles9222]

Porsche is incredibly underrated in my opinion ... even without the twist I do think Rachel wins eitherway

[@mechanicalthephantomonial7757]

Idk, without the twist, the veto comp wouldnt have been a repeat of Rachels HOH, so theres a decent chance she places sixth

[@andymarten]

@@mechanicalthephantomonial7757 Well, assuming we didn't have the duos twist, but we kept the same veto, Rachel still probably would win that, but Jordan most likely would have been leaving at 6 if we didn't the duos twist. I would assume Rachel still wins the Final 5 HOH and probably Shelly might have gone there. I know she faltered Final 4 veto, so my guess would be Rachel would have been 4th place if she didn't win the veto. I doubt the other three newbies wanted to keep her. But the duos twist really helped Rachel out for sure.

[@mechanicalthephantomonial7757]

@@andymarten my assertion is that the veto wouldnt be the same

[@mechanicalthephantomonial7757]

@@andymarten the thing is if shelly gets 5th, Kalia is the most likely winner. If kalia still gets 5th, Rachel probably comps out if she can sway porsche

[@andymarten]

@@mechanicalthephantomonial7757 It’s been a minute since I watched that season, but doesn’t Rachel comp out anyways-with the exception of the F4 veto? Because in the real timeline. Rachel won F6 veto, F5 HOH, and F3 HOH. The only two comps she didn’t win were F5 Veto (which wouldn’t have matter because she was safe for winning HOH) and F4 Veto. Maybe if Final 6 Veto was different, that could have changed the original result. Personally, I think Rachel still wins that veto that round. I think what really helps Rachel in the real timeline is that she had Jordan for two extra rounds and she was able to get rid of Kalia where then Rachel was able to rekindle the Porsche relationship. If she didn’t have Jordan, most likely Kalia and Porsche would have been in the game and if we still had a similar result of Adam winning Final 4 HOH, and Porsche winning Final 4 veto, I don’t think Rachel breaks into Porsche/Kalia bond. It is hard to say, but that’s why I think Rachel would have been fourth.

[@galacticpool1262]

For me: 2: Nicole 3: Danielle 4: Jun 5: Drew 6: Maggie 7: Begrudgingly Boogie 8: Dani 9: Adam 10: Dan 11: I guess Natalie 12: Hayden 13: Rachel 14: Dan 15: Andy 16: Derrick 17: Steve 18: Nicole 19: Josh 20: Tyler 21: Holly 22: Cody 23: Xavier 24: Taylor 25: Begrudgingly Matt

[@kimwilliamsii2122]

Your Season 21 and 24 picks along with CBB season 2 and 3… All I have to say.. CHOICES…. 😬

[@lamb9770]

I’m always voting Liz over Steve but I agree with the rest

[@-Affendio-]

Why?

[@lamb9770]

@@-Affendio- I honestly feel like she was more active in the game then him.

[@MRrichthe7th]

Here’s who I would vote for each season BB2:Will BB3:Danielle BB4:Jun BB5:Drew BB6:Maggie BB7:Mike Boogie BB8:Evil D BB9:Adam BB10:Dan BB11:Jordan BB12:Hayden BB13:Porsche BB14:Dan BB15:Andy BB16:Derrick BB17:Steve BB18:Nicole BB19:Paul BB20:Tyler BB21:Michie BB22:Cody BB23:Xavier BB24:Taylor BB25:Jag

[@ZavidWebster]

Me: Will Danielle Jun Drew Maggie Boogie Danielle Ryan Memphis Jordan Lane Poursche Dan Andy Cody Liz Nicole Paul Tyler Jackson Enxo Derek F. Taylor Jag Morgan Ross Tamar Meisha

[@lucasmoro9543]

Memphis???!

[@ZavidWebster]

@@lucasmoro9543 IK I based some of them off looks ngl😭😭😭. Memphis, Ryan, Enzo, Cody, Lane, Jackson & Paul r so fine.

[@MRrichthe7th]

Brother there’s no way you put Enzo, Memphis, and Ryan on this list and Liz is absolutely unbelievable over Steve who played an extremely good game

[@MRrichthe7th]

@@lucasmoro9543so true

[@ZavidWebster]

@@MRrichthe7th IKR. Ngl I'd only vote for them bc I think they're hot

[@traciemac9533]

on the feeds natalie and michelle said "mom & dad" (meaning the dr) told them to keep corey & nicole. Nicole laid up in a bed for the season. I'm shocked on this one. I'd vote for mr. jenkins over Nicole.

[@DVal-bl7hm]

One other thing I find rather funny about Natalie and Michelle's co-HOH that nobody ever seems to talk about, is that even if they DID target Nicole and get her evicted that week (instead of Victor), Nicole would have simply won the battleback competition and ruined their HOH anyway, just like how it was ruined with Victor returning. The battleback comp completely screwed over Natalie and Michelle's co-HOH regardless of what they did. Without it, Nicole's endgame is not so clean-cut.

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

what about BBOTT

[@kaderaidisreal]

2 will 3 daniele 4 jun 5 drew 6 ivette 7 mike 8 dani 9 ryan 10 dan 11 jordan 12 hayden 13 rachel 14 ian 15 andy 16 derrick 17 steve 18 nicole 19 josh 20 tyler 21 jackson 22 cody 23 xavier 24 monte 25 jag

[@whats_holden_up]

Who id vote for 2: Will 3: Danielle 4: Jun 5: Drew 6: Maggie 7: Boogie 8: Dick 9: Adam 10: Dan 11: Natalie 12: Hayden 13: Porsche 14: Dan 15: Andy 16: Derrick 17: Steve 18: Nicole 19: Paul 20: Tyler 21: Michie 22: Cody 23: Xavier 24: Monte 25: Matt

[@judahdar6552]

What about austrilian survivor?

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

what about it

[@judahdar6552]

"Who would he vote for?" 2024

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

@@judahdar6552 im sure hell do it

[@evald5373]

Lee, Jericho, Sharn, Pia, David, George, Mark, Liz, Feras. There you go

[@raheemfielder-bey998]

The amount of people that over played what Todrick said on cbb3 are literally just haters who easily manipulated by a tv edit because it’s not worst than what people have said on other seasons.

[@flipcamgamer]

Here’s who I would have voted for: BB2: Will BB3: Danielle Reyes BB4: Jun BB5: Drew BB6: Maggie BB7: Mike Boogie BB8: Danielle Donato BB9: Adam BB10: Dan BB11: Jordan BB12: Hayden BB13: Rachel BB14: Ian BB15: Andy BB16: Derrick BB17: Steve BB18: Paul BB19: Paul BB20: Tyler BB21: Holly (out of spite) BB22: Enzo (out of spite) BB23: Xavier BB24: Taylor BB25: Jag

[@darriusbethea2373]

I do way social game heavily in my opinion so I would vote Will over Nicole I think Nicole played a dominant game but fairly unlikable game to where she loses against almost everyone. Like it not like Survivor where we hear secondhand accounts post show edited. BB we actively see it or someone sees it & youcan dig up old feeds which sucks btw why tf live feeds aren’t on Paramount+ for past seasons? I would vote Taylor over Monte because only difference in them is Monte won a lot of challenges which I feel like in modern BB doesn’t impress me as much from someone like him because yeah YOU would win these. Taylor had a better social game not to say Monte was a d*ck but he did ignore people that wasn’t in his alliance. Like he focused all his time with his buddies which bit him. I also gotta fault him for that terrible move to bring Taylor over Turner because anyone could see Turner had no spine & wasn’t gonna be respected. Matt over Jag. I personally didn’t care for Matt because of his various comments but Jag also annoyed me towards the endgame with his lack of awareness & his hypocritical cockiness. I personally Matt over Jag. That really it everything else I kinda agree with more or less.

[@mechanicalthephantomonial7757]

I personally think Nicole's social game on average was better. Will just had better jury management.

[@tzxyuaesthetics9338]

with bb19 maybe if it were it like an anthony/bayleigh situation i would be fine with josh winning but it feels like josh's one good move (combined with paul's terrible jury management, earned him the win) and he has very little pros as a winner. from a good tv perspective it was funny watching him win but in the back of my head i always misremember the season with paul winning

[@_reigner]

Monte sucked and I didn’t like the comment about the black women being nominated in BB25 (…they lost the competition fair and square) but the rest was great! Thank you for the video.

[@randomnerd2332]

It would be cool if they incorporated an America's vote for the jury vote where what would be the first juror is replaced by America. Might encourage flashier gameplay for players.

[@raheemfielder-bey998]

Absolutely not because someone who’s playing a good game that isn’t liked by America would win!!!! Ivette beating Maggie, lane beating Hayden and pourche beating Rachel due to America would have been a shame!

[@ryanmeneo6301]

Im down to have America Lopez vote every season

[@AlphaOutlaw]

The audience should never have a aay on who wins a social game they don't participate in. There's a reason Russell Hantz got lambasted at the HvV reunion when he said that

[@DAP1212]

Absolutely tf not??? 😭

[@randomnerd2332]

​@raheemfielder-bey998 1) in my suggestion I would have the first juror evicted be replaced with America's vote, something that wouldn't change BB12. 2) there is no guarantee Ivette beats Maggie, Ivette was despised her season while for Maggie they didn't show any of her controversial statements on the episode that would make casuals hate her. 3) controversial but Porsche deserved to win over Rachel considering how much help from production Rachel got her season. Lawon's eviction, the battle back, & the infamous Porsche Pandora's box all benefitted Rachel to ensure a vet won.

[@idkwhatsgoingon4584]

Completely disagree with you take in BB2, while Will did have a bad start and mever won comps, he literary controlled the whole game by just stating he was a goat, and then getting everyone to befriend him ansd then got almost everyone to listen to him, and got people to realize while he was a liar and a sneak, everybody was, and he was the only one to admit it

[@kitwalkerscumsock]

i feel like you severely underestimate Porsche’s game ESPECIALLY compared to Rachel who got saved by multiple twists (pandora’s box, Brendon coming back, vets vs newbies). Porsche in my opinion was one of the more competent strategic players within her alliance while also having relationships with Adam and obviously Rachel which carried her at the end. She for sure beats adam at the end and at least has a chance against Shelly. Porsche was able to get to the end despite the Pandora’s box twist where rachel just lucked out. you said Porsche was aloof for the first half when really that was just the perception that Jeff/Jordan had since Porsche didn’t talk to them at all, which is definitely her biggest flaws. Comparing Porsche to Rachel, Porsche by far had the better game and its not close.

[@JairoD.Garcia]

Yeah it bad final 2 game wise for BB13 for female player but fixed in BBCAN6 (7 years later) final 2 for the opposite of BB13 game wise.

[@brianregan5933]

The problem is Porsche actually didn’t talk to a lot of people though. She talked to Brendon, Rachel, Dani and that’s about it. She had no bond with Adam, she never spoke to Jeff or Jordan, her relationship with Shelli was actively bad. And the most egregious thing by far with Porsche is the fact that if Lawson doesn’t do what he does, which is an INSANE circumstance, she was about to be backdoored that week, partially because up until that point she literally didn’t speak to Kalia either. And the plan WAS to vote her out over Rachel. And Rachel, despite *probably* being helped by the twists, it’s not a guarantee that she loses without them. Brendan came back in a spot where Rachel wasn’t the target anyway, and Dani was actually planning on throwing that HOH until she saw Brendan back. As has been stated a lot, Rachel likely gets to the end anyway even without Pandora’s box too, considering Porsche was even considering taking her to the end over Kalia Rachel’s game is flawed, but Porsche’s is BAD

[@devondonato4609]

No she isn’t bro lol, Shelly and Kaila were much more competent and strategic players. I actually think Porsche is pretty bad and inactive for the endgame

[@danielcphotography957]

When did Taylor get voted out?

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

never

[@monib111]

She didn't, but, I think he's talking about the speculation that if Palm Oil (Paloma) stayed in the house and the vote went on as planned, Taylor would have been voted out to face off against one of the houseguests that were part of the Backstage Twist.

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

@@monib111 she was staying no matter what

[@WilsonReviews]

@@bigbrotherspoilers9756 probably but that’s the exact same as being voted out and coming back like what happened with jag

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

@@WilsonReviews taylor was never voted out. taylor never came back because she was never voted out.

[@realityrob1951]

2 - Will 3 - Lisa 4 - Neither 5 - Drew 6 - Neither 7 - Mike 8 - Dick 9 - Adam 10 - Dan 11 - Natalie 12 - Hayden 13 - Porsche 14 - Dan 15 - Neither 16 - Cody 17 - Steve 18 - Paul 19 - Neither 20 - Tyler 21 - Jackson 22 - Cody 23 - Xavier 24 - Monte 25 - Matt CBB1 - Ross CBB2 - Ricky CBB3 - Miesha

[@devondonato4609]

Is Meisha really the only woman you’d vote for over a man 💀, I’m not even trying to make it a sex thing but this looks ridiculous. And Cody over Derrick? Lol

[@owenpierce4874]

why not andy lol

[@NikkiC-hl3bg]

I agree with all of your neither votes and justice for Tyler because he was robbed.

[@MRrichthe7th]

Bro why are you dunking on Andy and Jun

[@realityrob1951]

@@MRrichthe7th Jun literally loses sitting next to anyone else on that jury in the final 2. As for Andy. He was just lucky to be on the side of the house Elissa sided with due to the most ridiculous twist power she got early game which swayed the house majority voting power clearing out one side of the house. Andy basically won from that point on by keeping his mouth shut and let the players remaining get taken out by being rude and bossy. Really nothing special about the victory. But again, this is just my opinion. People do not need to agree.

[@KarateKidBB]

Really disagree on your BB2 assessment. “Nicole had more agency” sure. But she wasn’t actively using this agency to make necessary game moves for herself. Very often Will was able to have individual convos with her (hammock, smoking area, HOH room) spearheading his plans into her head. None of the mid/end game decisions she makes were advantageous for her game or win potential for that matter. If anything she was actively squandering her agency and win potential by keeping Will long term into the game and getting a wedge driven right in between her and her supposed closest ally in hardy simply because she was buying into everything Will was selling. How is being okay with Kent and Bunky leaving two people on her side good for her? How was her dropping the ball with her relationship with Monica good for her? How was keeping Will long term good for her? How was wanting to go to the end with Hardy good for her? She obtained power through her and Hardy’s ability to win comps. They won back to back to back to back and through that ability Will was able to properly attach himself to them and steer them in ways he deemed most fit. I mean you tend to put tons of emphasis on his early struggles and negate his clear ability to play so effectively from bottom? What about his destruction of the UT alliance? Or the fact he was able to persuade Kent and Monica? And even to a lesser extent bunky? I mean Kent was OPENLY willing to work/keep Will long term (Hardy too) despite their early game goals to solely be destroy CT and not let a member win. What about Nicole being outplayed in the diary room? We put tons of emphasis in modern BB on jury management but would you not say weaponizing the jury to build yourself up as best as can is smart? Would you not say pointing out the clear hypocrisies of the other HG (specifically Nicole) is smart? So I don’t get your point. He’s not downplaying his threat level because he’s not a great competitor? You’re acting like the BB2 comps were complex. They were very crapshoot throwing a disc into like the pool nonsense. Or keeping your hand on a key. Nothing that takes a certain skill set like modern BB. Yes. They underestimated him. But yes. That’s exactly the narrative he was crafting inside the house and outside. He boxed Nicole constantly into corners to force her to be the bad person. No debate Will’s game was much better.

[@helenkellerstampon]

Nah Nicole better

[@KarateKidBB]

@@helenkellerstampon I mean, no. lol. Notice how you had 0 rebuttal

[@helenkellerstampon]

@@KarateKidBB you didn’t even give a reason why dr will was better you just took what he said in the DR for the truth when she dominated most of the game. The comps she won was very fair compared to the crapshoots comps we are seeing in BB26. Nicole brought will to the end because it was the best move she could’ve made strategically to win. Nicole was always controlling Hardy’s hohs and other people in the house. All will influenced her to do is to let himself get dragged to the end

[@KarateKidBB]

@@helenkellerstampon Did you not read? I gave numerous examples of him outplaying her specifically at the F4. Specifically when he had her openly saying in the DR he was her #1. Specifically when she was openly anti Hardy because of Will’s influence. Specifically when she took out people like Bunky and Kent > Will. She gets outplayed from the Krista vote out on. Every competition in BB2 was crapshoot based compared to like 3 (sorta) thus far no where near comparable. Throwing a disc into a pool doesn’t require skill. And lol that is such revisionist history. What people did she influence? What votes bar the week 1 house flip? If anything it was Will influence Hardy and blowing up his spot. Specifically when he influenced him to blow up his position with thr UT and OP. Also, multiple times he fed the ego of Hardy and pushed into his short temper (displayed in the fight). His entire mid/end game is fostering the Nicole/Hardy relationship and influencing them to take him to the end of the game “because he has no way to win, he’s loyal, he’s got their backs”. And THEY wholeheartedly believed him. “You didn’t name anything”. I guess perfectly crafting inside and outside the house hatred for Nicole isn’t outplaying her? Cornering her in spots to slash her way through the game and paint her in a hypothetical light isn’t outplaying her? Did you just purposely forget Monica’s words to Nicole when she got evicted? Did you also forget where Will says right before throwing the F4 HOH “I said I was gonna be the evil guy from the start”. Again, jury management. Yano a staple of the game in modern BB? I guess convincing her it was most ideal to take him to the end isn’t outplaying her? I guess the F3 deal they made was advantageous for her? lmfao. Also, to your earlier point “that was her best move” no it wasn’t. Will had a guaranteed 3 votes automatically (one of which was nullified) so two secure/locked votes. Bunky (who funny enough leaves due to Will’s influence) would’ve been a much more logical F2 path as she 100% gets Hardy, Will, Shannon, Boogie, and Krista.

[@KarateKidBB]

LOL, my point exactly. Actually watch the seasons if you’re gonna assess their play.

[@jerryberry8181]

I vote for Big D > X on principle alone 😤

[@Fitzbits687]

Your joking 😂

[@kalebdunaway]

Paul is a grown man. Call him he/him lol. Corny.

[@Samirdelrock]

For me 2. Will 3. Danielle 4. Jun 5. Drew 6. Maggie 7. Erika 8. Daniele 9. Adam 10. Dan 11. Natalie 12. Hayden 13. Porsche 14. Dan 15. Andy 16. Cody 17. Steve 18. Nicole 19. Paul 20. Tyler 21. Holly 22. Cody 23. Xavier 24. Monte 25. Jag Bbcan1 Jillian Bbcan2 Jon Bbcan3 Godfrey Bbcan4 Kelsey Bbcan5 Kevin Bbcan6 Kaela Bbcan7 Anthony Bbcan9 Tychon Bbcan10 Kevin Bbcan11 Ty Bbcan12 Anthony

[@MRrichthe7th]

Yo why are you voting for Erika over Boogie

[@Samirdelrock]

@@MRrichthe7th cause I don’t like either of them. But Boogie’s a bigger douche bag than Erika and his game wasn’t that impressive for me to overlook it.

[@kaderaidisreal]

so real for double voting cody dan and duggie