Big Brother (US) - Winner Rankings (2024)

[@calebos268]

Remember: This is a ranking of their winning games, not how they are as a player.

[@seamino8329]

we get it

[@ultimate-xw6jl]

​@@seamino8329shut up

[@seamino8329]

@@ultimate-xw6jlfatty

[@FruitySelection]

they mean the same thing

[@mechanicalthephantomonial7757]

@@FruitySelectionno they dont lol

[@doggydogworld533]

another huge knock for jag is the invisible hoh twist that literally breaks a fundamental rule of the game and lets him become hoh the very next week, where cirie would have won and probably nominated him and bowie, he wins veto, and either matt or bowie leave. losing one of those two hurts his chances of winning by a lot

[@noahnussbaum8693]

ok but thats literally not his fault. You cant hold that against him.

[@adoyle13]

@@noahnussbaum8693 its still him being GREATLY benefitted by a twist, which is something that was held against all the other winners in this ranking. definitely worth mentioning.

[@noahnussbaum8693]

@@adoyle13 I mean fine, I get that. But I don’t think this is huge compared to others considering this twist would’ve benefited literally anyone who won the hoh in that way.

[@SeanMcD-gn2cl]

​@@noahnussbaum8693not the way comps were last season. Jag won essentially the type of physical same comp over and over again. And he also told everyone about the advantage when the whole point is to be "invisible". And he played that week the worst way he possibly could. Getting a twist like that to be hoh twice in a row is huge deal ( 1st time in us history). Especially when the comps were so similar to each other.

[@noahnussbaum8693]

@@SeanMcD-gn2cl that’s not the point. Theoretically anyone could win that first comp and have that same advantage. Also you don’t need any special abilities to win 2 mental comps in a row.

[@kitwalkerscumsock]

the number one choice gagged me i’m ngl. much deserved tho

[@JairoD.Garcia]

We’re get to Survivor - Winner Rankings at somepoint because I heard Dee & Kenzie could be a very higher tier on a Winner Rankings. And it could be a possibilities beating a Kim Spradlin winner of Survivor. But way better than Hayley Leake in the modern day of Survivor in term of Winning Games of the New Era (2021-Onward)

[@jaimeabaya6728]

Dan got robbed

[@evald5373]

@@JairoD.Garcia that´s not happening

[@uglyaniimals]

@@JairoD.Garciahe has done survivor winner rankings before -- spoiler alert, one of your reads is correct and one isn't

[@darkwa2000]

How did you comment this 4 months ago?

[@francesca-selfproclaimed-bleep]

Cant wait for Angela to be part of this list 💅🏽

[@tajneeley]

🤣🤣

[@tajneeley]

Still better than Jag If she wins.

[@francesca-selfproclaimed-bleep]

@@tajneeley Forreal 'cause if she wins, she'll likely set a huge precedent for playing a truly individual game.

[@P2-xy4fu]

@@francesca-selfproclaimed-bleep the only way she wins is if she goes on a comp run and pulls a miracle picking the right person going to the finale

[@francesca-selfproclaimed-bleep]

@@P2-xy4fu The gag is, Kenney is whining wanting to go home this week. Tucker said he wanted to pull a BB13 Brendon move and pull queen of the individual game Angela off the block. 😂 She has the house wrapped around her finger at this point.

[@WilsonReviews]

We don’t agree with every ranking (I.e. I think you have Ian waaaayyyy too low), I love your effort and analysis on your rankings. Thank you for your efforts TMR :)

[@noahnussbaum8693]

Ian basically comped out from like the final 9 on (i may have that 1 or 2 spots wrong), when he wouldve been targeted if he hadnt won those comps

[@jasmine1stan857]

I think Ian should be below Rachel

[@someperson3883]

@@jasmine1stan857Due to the 2nd veto, I basically view Ian as an evicted player who came back into the game. Don’t respect that

[@turntapeover5749]

I understand your point about Jun win equity but thats where I think Jun pulled the most genius move of the season: She realizes she has no win equity. She looks around the room and sees Allison, which people hate a lot more than her and approaches Allison, the person she herself hates the most in this house and be like "Girl everyone hates us, the only chance we have is each other". Having the emotional intelligence to recognize that, to me puts Jun wayyyy higher than numer 9. I dont think a lot of people would put their ego aside and take a long hard look at their win equity and would be ready to work with someone they hated for the sake of winning the game. She did not have win equity, she created it out of thin air and thats what makes her an incredible winner. She threw all the variables aside and saw the equation for what it was and ran with it.

[@ColleenJones-vk6ox]

Yes totally agree. And most people would not be willing to do that, they play emotionally. Which is a credit to both Jun and Alison. Games before feelings and friendships, well done girls.

[@iamkonner4813]

Wow Josh at number one bold but respected

[@Me-TVVV]

This is how it should be 😮‍💨

[@jobedobe5991]

I would’ve unsubscribed so fast

[@tajneeley]

Not to mention Jag one HOH two weeks in a row like thats a crazy artificial advantage.

[@chrisgaertner1289]

Huge fan of the #1 ranking! Thank you for this!

[@FrogInTheAlps]

Another point to how shit Dicks game is the fact americas player was Eric Stein. Eric was the only person on the cast who could’ve maneuvered into saving Dick at multiple points while still staying in the game themselves.

[@mechanicalthephantomonial7757]

Major respect for recognizing will’s bb2 game is kinda below average

[@alpha_gem]

I personally have some disagreement with the placement of Taylor because I believe that her biggest quality is better than most people up to Jackson at 14 is that she doesn't seem to have a scenario where she goes home from week 3 onwards. The closest times that she had been to going home would be the final 5 where she convinces Turner to vote against the one person they can likely beat in the end, and the final 3 in the event that Turner won the HOH. In every other week, there were never circumstances where she was going to be the collective house target or HOH target because of some of her positioning and social relationships. In addition, she does amazing jury management for people leaving that (even if we were to not view the conspiracy of juror being pressured to vote for her) she would have so many locked votes that she wins against most people in a final 2. The only person that she had the chance of losing to would be Michael, but she knew very well to avoid that outcome at all costs.

[@melfeasance.]

Absolutely this. I don’t think she’s top 10 or anything but I think she deserves to be several spots higher because she did play an amazing social game once she was actually allowed to. And it was genuinely through no fault of her own in the first couple weeks that she was targeted for a false narrative that was painted about her within the first couple days of being in the house. I know almost going home has to be some kind of ding but she didn’t earn that position by any of her own actions so it shouldn’t be as big a ding as it is to place her as low as she is.

[@jaimeabaya6728]

Jun should come back for like a winners season or All Stars 3

[@BrianSchaffer]

She wouldn’t come back. She talked bad about Julie on the feeds and wasn’t voted in or chosen on BB7 version.

[@dougierichardson484]

18:25- Alex and Jason DEFINITELY take each other to Final 2 over Paul if they are in Final 3 together, both are more likely to win final HOH than Paul as both are great at comps, and both beat Paul for sure in a jury vote (especialy Jason). So that part of your assessment is dog shit crazy.

[@michaela2368]

i would have taylor above will and maybe jackson. i think taylor potentially going home first isn’t a fair thing to hold against her given how she did nothing to make that happen

[@michaela2368]

also xavier should be way lower lol

[@voodoomcspaghettipants4082]

Yes and no on the Taylor thing. While she dealt with maltreatment that definitely harmed her in week 1, she also made zero headway in making social bonds when we saw her just a week later be able to do so. When her back was against the wall in week one she wasn’t able to find the right people to align with. While she eventually corrects that mistake, it took her longer than it needed to. To put her above Jackson and Kaycee is a bit unfair since those 2 had higher highs than Taylor (Kaycee’s positioning, Jackson’s utilization of his comp wins and final 5 move). Taylor luckily escaped week one, was on the bottom until the formation of the leftovers (not something she actively did), rode with the leftovers despite being positioned poorly within it, gets benefitted by the Kyle situation to where his power structure crumbles, is placed in a better position in the new power structure (although not a main driver until the very end), and then gets taken to the end by Monte despite it being against his best interest. While you can credit Taylor a bit for convincing him to take her, the decision is mostly a fault of Monte in being wildly off on everyone’s jury perception. Taylor played an active game and fought very hard, but the things that actually advanced her round to round were predominantly out of her control

[@BGYMix]

I hate Michie but I also feel like Taylor is severely overrated at this point. Many people are trying to place her in the top 10 and she just isn’t worthy of being that high

[@RelevantMoose]

Andy number 1 is a surprising, but good take. 👍

[@turntapeover5749]

It's not surprising at all. He was hands down the best player the show ever had because unlike Derrick, who isolated himself in a layer of alliance, Andy dictated who left the show by working ALONE behind the scene.

[@BrianSchaffer]

⁠@@turntapeover5749 On top of that, he never the or making himself the target in any group he was in. He was easily the least targeted in 3AM. While the exterminators was formed a week earlier, he fully turned on 3AM at the exact right moment to get Amanda out because after that, he only had McCrae to worry about. Then always had Gina Marie’s mouth to rely on going off.

[@random_jae5886]

​​@@BrianSchafferNot to mention, there really was never a situation aside from a final 4/3 solo moonshot where Andy could ever have gone home.

[@jkingisbeast]

I think the other thing that puts Jag at the bottom is that Camron was voted out week 5 and due to a twist he comes back to the game and makes it to the jury after winning HOH. Camron was one of the biggest supporters of Jag in the jury house, so there’s a big possiblility that Jag would have lost to Matt if it was either Jarod or Meme in his spot.

[@jackmcg0]

I don’t think that Cameron really changed anyone’s mind. He had by far the worst social game of the jury, so I doubt he changed anyone’s mind in the jury. From the exit interviews it seemed like Matt never took credit for moves, while Jag took credit for being the strategist(when he wasn’t).

[@MicheleDee]

What screwed Matt was not Cameron championing him, it was his garbage goodbye messages (for at least Cory and America, which would have been enough to change the outcome)

[@DVal-bl7hm]

I think another thing to note is that this season only had 7 jurors. If it was 9 jurors, then Jared + Mecole are in jury, too. I feel they would likely vote Matt over Jag.

[@legendarysingh2173]

@@DVal-bl7hm jag still wins then 5-4…

[@harrajansinghgrewal4072]

@@jackmcg0 it was also Jag's strong social game, both Matt and Jag had phenomenal social games

[@dougierichardson484]

I laugh how you say Boogie only "probably" loses to Will in the Final 2, LOL! He maxes out at only 1 possible vote in Erika in that Final 2. And if he betrays Erika probably loses even her vote.

[@superwilly55]

Ready to watch this before I see some discourse about your opinions on social media.

[@psychospike7458]

I was fully expecting cody to be number one. And i wasn't expecting andy to pass Derrick

[@turntapeover5749]

Whats amazing about Andy imo is that despite him not being in power in any significant way, HIS target was walking out that door every single week. Calling the shots from the shadows without having anyone realizing youre actually running a train on everyone is something only a few people in this universe can pull off.

[@ColleenJones-vk6ox]

Yes total summary of Andy's game. IMO the best single Big Brother game in history, rivaled only by Derrick of BB16. But I go with Andy since he didn't benefit from garbage like Battle of the Block and Team America which while I think he still wins anyway, made things easier on and helped Derrick. And dominating a house that much (as you said often from the shadows) as a GAY man, on probably the most bigoted season in history, is super impressive.

[@noahnussbaum8693]

In terms of the Rachel situation with Lewan, Rachel was never going home that week bc America would've always voted for Brendan to playin the comp and Brendan would've always thrown it to Rachel. That doesnt really mean much in terms of this list but still

[@lolno6975]

I respect the list, but i think Jag needs some respect. You dont just win 10 comps, break a record that people legitimately think never wouldve beaten AND have such a good social relationship with many players tha they would sabotage their own game to save Jag. Yes Jags game is pretty horrible in the beginning/middle section, but he also has some amazing flashes of tactical gameplay, such as in the final 5 where he actually plays it literally perfectly I feel we dont respect the physicality of BB enough, and i see no way that anyone touches that 10 comp record, at least any time soon. But yeah, Andy number 1. And i actually have him as the far and away front runner to win an all-winners season (if it ever happens)

[@DVal-bl7hm]

I will also say in Jag's defense that the Cirie, Izzy, and Jared pregame relationship made it pretty difficult for anybody who wasn't aligned with them early on to get much social capital in the game. It doesn't excuse Jag's poor gameplay when he was at the bottom, but he could have probably had a cleaner game if he was on a typical all-newbie season.

[@shafiislam5404]

I personally believe Xavier should be right before Lisa on the list, at 17. Xavier NEEDED the cookout to help him get to the end. The only good work Xavier actively did was having a great relationship with Big D and Azah, who each had little social capital and were terrible at competitions. Most of the house wanted Xavier, and even Big D, out of the game. Due to circumstances beyond the game, it helped Xavier get to the end. Tiffany, Kyland or Hannah for sure would’ve won without the cookout. Had Xavier not been eligible for the cookout, he would’ve been taken out like the 1st 5 boots that season. Lisa, Will, and whoever else was in between, had either a great enough social capital and standing in the game to help them get to the end, so they should be higher than Xavier in my opinion.

[@joshkuhn8906]

Boogie wayyyyy too high when he was consciously playing for 2nd

[@IanLemes-cc7yg]

Nicole over Jun is crazy lmao

[@footbal218]

Another knock against Cody should be the pre-gaming advantage of an All Stars season. He had close personal relationships walking in the door

[@ColleenJones-vk6ox]

I mean so did Nicole Franzel, one of the all time best players and possibly the best female player of all time, and she still wasn't able to play as strong a game as Cody.

[@guyfierimtwi]

7:44 Rachel would've been against Brendon in the comeback & Brendon probably throws it

[@TripleBBBBB]

Yeah but then Daniele just backdoors rachel the nest week

[@geroge9915]

So glad to see the #1 spot, I stand by his winning game being the best of any winner. Wish we could see him on the show again.

[@SG-sj5in]

Love your takes. The one thing I'll debate is about Nicole's early game. I think she knee exactly what she was doing from beginning to end and made it happen to get her to the end game

[@christiancore3189]

Dare I say that Chelsie is #4…

[@SentryColumnSentry]

For the most part I agree and think your rankings are completely logical and unbiased. However, Jag and Taylor were on the block on eviction night and votes stacked against them, yet you still ranked him at 24 and her at 19 despite the fact that she was saved and given a second chance by producer interference without needing to do anything, where as Jag was saved by a power that another houseguest had to be willing to use on him. Also the argument that Taylor would have won against Paloma or Alyssa is completely redundant considering that’s a completely different game. Nobody knows if she still wins BB24 if that happens.

[@harrajansinghgrewal4072]

he has a hate boner against Jag, Jag was a big reason the power shifted cause Cory couldn't flip the vote without Jag convincing Matt to go against Cirie which is underrated aspect of his game

[@minerzach1236]

Shocked you had Maggie at 4 but she played a good game.

[@geroge9915]

you forgot to add Leah Gheesling

[@tuckerm101]

Ik u just did this video idea last year, but any chance would u do an updated BBCAN seasons or winners ranking? Considering that BBCAN is currently cancelled and we don’t know when/if it’ll be renewed. Just really curious how you’d rank BBCAN 12 and Baileigh.

[@BrianSchaffer]

If you watch the questioning of the jury, I think the F2 votes in BB3 would be near exactly flip flopped if there was a sequestered jury. With Steve, I think he wins against anyone in the final 6.

[@joshbeaudry7633]

24. Evel Dick (Jag may of been voted out but he would of been voted out 3 times if it wasn’t for Americas player) 23. Jag 22. Rachel 21. Ian 20. Taylor 19. Jordan 18. Will 17. Josh 16. Kaycee 15. Lisa 14. Xavier 13. Adam 12. Jun 11. Jackson 10. Drew 9. Steve 8. Mike 7. Nicole 6. Dan 5. Maggie 4. Hayden 3. Cody 2. Andy 1. Derrick

[@genaroparra1884]

We’re fighting if I ever see you irl for putting Taylor so low 😭😭😭😭

[@joelsahmaunt1305]

The goat is back 🙌🏾👑

[@TheOpinionator1610]

I would put Jag at least above Evel Dick. And Taylor is WAAAAY too low for my liking.

[@masonban1]

I’m for Andy Harren being #1

[@ZareaKN]

Another knock to Jag’s game is that the Path of Power twist that saved him likely was a last minute addition because of the expulsion and production needing to have some way of keeping the game going to 100 days. My hot take is that without the expulsion, Jag would have never won

[@TripleBBBBB]

I don't think that take is hot at all. I 10000 percent agree

[@harrajansinghgrewal4072]

Jag was staying before the power was introduced, it was than Matt and Cirie deciding to put the vote on him to flush the power to appease Cameron and Red whereas Jag would have stayed prior

[@noahnussbaum8693]

Realistically Jag is not the worst winner. I think someone getting voted out shouldn't automatically put them at the bottom. I still think he's worse than Dick with that. Also I think you're a bit harsh on him for taking Matt to the end. There is a human aspect to this game, he literally said in his final speech he had to do what made his family/Sikh community proud.

[@brainrot1551]

Including using military tactics on an elderly woman?

[@nicksavagester3666]

@@brainrot1551???

[@brainrot1551]

@@nicksavagester3666 Jag, along with Matt ans Bowie Jane all isolated Cirie and Felicia in bb25 near the end.

[@nicksavagester3666]

@@brainrot1551 oh gotcha. I didn't know what you were referring to at first

[@noahnussbaum8693]

@@brainrot1551 huh???

[@cjmomma3092]

Where would you rank Chelsie

[@realityrob1951]

this is so all over the map..

[@Daddyoh94]

Every season has specifics that could never be replicated, but how you gonna win when you lost? 25 after Izzy left was lame

[@NicolasTiedemann]

Love the video but in my opinion there's NOOOOO way Josh is above Taylor and Michie is above Will 😭

[@tahiirxwest]

I believe I said something similar to this in the last winner ranking but anyways. The argument that Will’s game was outdated doesn’t make sense because you aren’t comparing the players skill set, you are comparing how they performed in their seasons. So if you are going based off of that. The way Will played his format of big brother was pretty impressive. I agree that the first 2-3 weeks were rough but after that there is literally no luck involved in his win it’s all just relationships that Will was able to build and use to his advantage. That being said he was able to get to the end without having to win a single HoH. He also played up his character in the diary room knowing the jury was watching. He played his format very well I don’t believe he should be placed low because of the og format.

[@ididwhatihadto369]

Just watched the original the other day

[@someperson3883]

7:14 Brendon would have thrown the baddle back to Rachel. Not great, but she would have stayed that week

[@HolyAlondite]

Admittedly, the question then becomes what happens in Dani's HOH the next week. Since it's entirely possible Rachel goes then depending on who she targets

[@someperson3883]

@@HolyAlondite Probably Rachel, but maybe Jeff doesn’t throw the veto to Adam, keeps moms the same and Adam goes home

[@fr0ztibytez]

If there’s an all winners season I bet good money Andy wins.

[@whats_holden_up]

Based on winning games 24. Jag 23. Rachel 22. Dick 21. Jordan 20. Josh 19. Ian 18. Lisa 17. Adam 16. Steve 15. Taylor 14. Maggie 13. Kaycee 12. Michie 11. Xavier 10. Nicole F 9. Will 8. Boogie 7. Jun 6. Drew 5. Andy 4. Hayden 3. Cody 2. Derrick 1. Dan

[@heater1237]

Even youtube chapters forgot about Andy… oops

[@ZavidWebster]

My Rankings: 30. Josh 29. Jag 28. Jordan 27. Eddie 26. Dick 25. Rachel 24. Tamar 23. Adam 22. Lisa 21. Ian 20. Steve 19. Andy 18. Nicole (Reigndeer Games) 17. Meisha 16. Morgan (OTT) 15. Taylor 14. Xavier 13. Drew 12. Marissa 11. Kaycee 10. Will 9. Jackson 8. Boogie 7. Maggie 6. Cody 5. Nicole (18) 4. Hayden 3. Jun 2. Derrick 1. Dan

[@theycallmehdavid7009]

Where's Chelsie at?

[@someperson3883]

Top 5

[@evald5373]

So Derrick´s game is worst because of twists he didn`t need?

[@TripleBBBBB]

But he did need the rewind twist most likely

[@evald5373]

@@TripleBBBBB how? Without the rewind it's everyone againts frankie at final 4 and frankie can't play hoh (with derrick wins) and caled and cody wanting to take derrick to the end.

[@TripleBBBBB]

@evald5373 yeah but if Frankie wins out which was very probable he prob cuts derrick and wins

[@someperson3883]

@@evald5373Frankie was a comp beast and could have won final veto and final HOH. If that doesn’t happen Derrick wins

[@jumpy4912]

I think it's wrong to put any winner below Dick. Dick had one of the greatest players in Big Brother history give him the free win. Production had to literally interfere and rig the game against Eric by not letting him use the veto he won for Dick. Dick only won the jury vote because Eric campaigned for him in the jury house. Dick goes home in multiple scenarios, if not for America's player...

[@lucinda5563]

Quinn trie to make Angela look like a resit to T'kor and then went into the Dr and laughed about it BB better do something about this it can ruin her life!! "NOT TODAY SATAN"

[@scottbynum7816]

Taylor would have been voted out, but she wasn't actually voted out. So how can you punish her for that like Jag? Who was actually voted out.

[@DVal-bl7hm]

Taylor couldn't get the votes to stay, and neither could Jag. It's basically the same thing.

[@harrajansinghgrewal4072]

yeah and Jag was staying before the power was introduced and it was his social game with Matt and Cirie that saved him

[@harrajansinghgrewal4072]

@@DVal-bl7hm Jag had the votes before the power was introduced

[@daltonbartlett6584]

My rankings: 24. Jag Baines 23. Evel Dick Donato 22. Rachel Riley 21. Jordan Lloyd 20. Ian Terry 19. Josh Martinez 18. Taylor Hale 17. Lisa Donahue 16. Will Kirby 15. Adam Jasinski 14. Xavier Prather 13. Jackson Michie 12. Kaycee Clark 11. Steve Moses 10. Jun Song 9. Drew Daniel 8. Nicole Franzel 7. Mike Boogie 6. Dan Gheesling 5. Hayden Moss 4. Maggie Ausburne 3. Derrick Levassaur 2. Andy Herron 1. Cody Calafiore (I get the argument that Cody was in more danger than Andy and Derrick somewhat but Cody doesn't go home in almost any scenario outside of Enzo and has control over the entire game. A final 4 yes he was in danger if Christmas won veto but if Memphis or Tyler were there, he is likely in danger anyway due to his threat level so it's not enough to knock him out of number 1.)

[@chrispoppenger9104]

Thank u thank u thank u!!!! For giving Andy his due ❤

[@CraaazzzyDog]

i do consider taylor to be a bottom tier winner but she definitely is better than josh. At F5 3 players (Alyssa,Monte and Brittany) wanted taylor to be in the final 3 and also having two players in monte and brittany want to take her to final 2. This is spectacular positioning and she tried to have the his position which gives her good winning chances. Similarly to Taylor, Josh was also in danger at the beginning of the game and was semi saved with a twist in the golden apple. Josh also wasn’t positioned well at almost any part of the game until mid jury and still had little win equity. So comparing the games of taylor and josh. They both had poor early games but slowly gained a better position however taylor got into a much better position to win the game in comparison to josh.

[@EvanCollins-x8s]

Can you do big brother what if it was winners v final jurors I know you did it for survivor but never for big brother I’d love to see it!

[@jobedobe5991]

Josh, Jordan and Adam were all pretty high imo especially Josh and Adam their games were horrible 😭 great vid tho

[@harrajansinghgrewal4072]

Jag should be way higher his game from week 5 on was phenomenal, Dr Will should be in top 5 at least. Maggie is way too high

[@bobdigital21]

My ranking. We will disagree a lot on certain people not as much on others. #24 Dick #23 Jag #22 Jordan #21 Rachel. All those wins are tainted in some way. I almost don't want to count any of them. #20 Josh #19 Xavier - Both wins were due to crazy things happening. One being the cookout, which is an alliance i hate as there is nothing you can do against it (unless they admit to being in an alliance)... Basically means Xavier won a 6 person BB (where he floated kind of) and Josh's big move was banging pans and being next to the most hated house guest. #18 Adam (weird twist and super weak house and no impressive game play really) #17 Boogie (he was carried by Will) #16 Taylor (confused game play and socially not savy) #15 Ian (executed his plan more or less, but it was him being used by others more than him pushing the game) #14 Michie (should have been voted out as a comp threat but dumb house, good single clutch lie at the end, not that that should have saved him). #13 Drew (helped form an early alliance, then did.... almost nothing. No notable mistakes but didn't control the action IMO). #12 Kaycee (Solid enough, but not someone who felt in control of the game more than others. She should have lost the vote too). #11 Steve (underrated winner. A lot of bad things can be mentioned about his game but a lot more good. Never lost track of his position in the house and expertly positioned himself and a low key comp beast when needed) #10 Lisa (Solid game, made good choices, but not good enough to be higher) #9 Hayden (Good player, but did the least of his alliance to get him to the end IMO. Lance at least was able to control Britney.) #8 Maggie (now we are into high tier winners. No shame in her game, just not as dominant as others imo and i feel her emotional appeal strat wouldn't translate well to other seasons and if there wasn''t a strong counter alliance in the house all season.) #7 Jun (just a good game that feels very repeatable. But didn't truly control the season the way others did) #6 Nicole (A very solid season, but needed just a little luck. Still it felt like she had a good hold on it most of the time). #5 Cody - (Great season, but the massive pregaming taints it a little for me, still i need to give him props for great execution) #4 Will (Very good social player, but needs to be able to win comps). #3 Derrick (Perhaps the most dominant win ever.... but if his strat cracks can he adapt? Not proven). #2 Andy (Great win. proven he could be thrown into any house and do great). #1 Dan (Nuff said. But every time i think about his season i wonder how'd he'd do if given another shot).

[@ColleenJones-vk6ox]

Andy's BB15 game is easily the best IMO. Only rivaled by Derrick's on BB16, which also has a case. Dan's BB10 game was great but would rank it behind Andy BB15, Derrick BB16, and possibly Cody BB22 too. As a player I probably rank him #1 when you add in his BB14 game, but as a winning game no way is BB10 #1 over those. Andy and Derrick had almost everyone in the house taking them to F2 and beat everyone in a F2. Dan did not have everyone taking him to F2, in fact the only one who probably was is Memphis, Keesha and Renny were taking each other, Jerry was taking Memphis or Renny, and of course none of Libra, April, Ollie, Michele were ever taking him. And he does not neccessarily win every F2 either. Renny probably beats him with Keesha, April, Ollie all locked for her over Dan, and quite possibly Libra, Michele, Jerry voting her too. Keesha would be close. Michele would be close, not that this F2 ever happens. April too.

[@ColleenJones-vk6ox]

And I totally disagree with Xavier being that low. Yes the Cookout existed, but it was one of the strongest alliances in history with 5 of the 6 (minus Derek F) being very strong players, and he easily outplayed and beat them all at the end of the game. And the rest of the house were totally outclassed by the Cookout, so obviously none of them deserve to win more than him either. Every house has over half the house never standing a real chance, and atleast half of seasons have a big alliance that dominates anyway. He is overrated by some people, but no way can he be near the bottom with all the bad winners on Big Brother.

[@FloydMickenbooder]

As an anw fan, what da hell is going on with big brother 💀🙏

[@turntapeover5749]

Ironically, when a player has the best game and is so dominant *cough cough* *Derrick* it makes for the most boring season because steamrolls are sleep inducing and kill my interest to watch the show.

[@haydanellsworth]

I think Derrick is the best winner but I respect ur list

[@bobbyhall994]

Steve Moses hive rise!

[@devinthesupersmosher]

Man admits will played up to the cameras knowing the jury would be able to see them and played the game in the way that is effective at that time then said ye but that’s not how it is nowadays and ranked him horribly even tho it’s the same guy who talks up Danielle Reyes as one of the best to never win lmfao

[@mechanicalthephantomonial7757]

he literally wouldve gone home if Shannon didnt decide she wanted to quit the game.

[@devinthesupersmosher]

@@mechanicalthephantomonial7757 so you decided to not dispute anything that i said in my original comment and spout a random schizophrenic agenda

[@cougar33333]

Michie should have been kicked out for eating while a have not.

[@simgoesgaming4877]

taylor one of the best social players ever! 19th?! over people like josh,jackson kaychee?! this not the challenge its big brother! if she get saved by a twist. then if one of the winners of the bb ai arena comp is then also gonna place low bc save by a twist🙃🙃 she makes inpressive socials moves as this show is.

[@tajneeley]

This is based on their winning games , Taylor is also not one of the best social players of all time .

[@tajneeley]

Ya Im a huge Tyler C fan and Kaycee has way more agency than Taylor.

[@Mrdonjuliothewicked]

I wouldn't exactly call being ostracized the first week, being put into a new majority alliance, mainly because it's a vote (yes I know it's also for personal reasons on how she was treated but the alliance even said it's a number for them), and having a bit of hoh-itis when you had power, and sleeping with the hoh when you had the potential to be put up and taken out (not to mention rubbed people the wrong way cause of her relationship with Joseph) as one of the best social players of all time lol. Not saying she's bad socially at all but definitely not the best or close to it.

[@aviraes]

@@Mrdonjuliothewickedher not trusting joseph was literally due to all of them telling her he couldn’t be trusted lol she isn’t the best social player ever but that’s a dumb thing to hold against her

[@jcartist5881]

Id rank Derrick lower. Too reliant on comp beasts

[@enmanuelcruz9104]

I agree with most of your list, I'm thankful for the video, really enjoyed it, I only disagree with Andy and Steve, Andy is a great winner just not the best imo and Steve for me was a floater. Rachel and Evel dick are not as great and I'm glad you pointed that out, also thanks for giving respect to Maggie, she ran that house. Great video!!

[@SZAlanastan]

if Chelsie wins I think shell be top 10

[@DRGOAT999]

Bro ur rankings always be trash, good content tho

[@tajneeley]

Wrong , his rankings just Trigger casual fans because casual fans favorites are at the bottom.

[@DRGOAT999]

@tajneeley talking to the wrong one. Not a casual bro u just guessing on why i trashed the rankings. Been watch him for a minute every rankings be trash

[@harrajansinghgrewal4072]

@@tajneeley as a live feeder his ranking are complete trash

[@sweetJokerJMcLovin]

You think Jag was wrong for choosing Matt calling it a mistake, but he won. So “you’re” the one making the mistake. Your list is filled with conjecture and bad opinions.

[@harrajansinghgrewal4072]

agree like its even more impressive Jag took the harder opponent and still bodies him in the questioning and the vote

[@turntapeover5749]

Dan Gheesling is so overrated.

[@Nick-l6o]

I hated jag

[@blueberrysunoo3572]

this video is creeping me out because you sound exactly like my dad….. dad is that you?