Biggest Moments in the Karen Read Case | Killer or Cover-Up Murder Trial

Could #TrooperProctor's behavior impact other murder trials? #CourtTV's Vinnie Politan and experts analyze some of the biggest moments in the case against #KarenRead.
#CourtTV - What do YOU think? ⚖️
MORE HERE: www.courttv.co...
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.co...
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.co...
Join the Court TV Community to get access to perks:
/ @courttv
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
KZbin / courttv
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE
www.courttv.co...
HOW TO FIND COURT TV
www.courttv.co...

[@CourtTV]

#CourtTV What do YOU think? Verdict Watch LIVE - MA v. #KarenRead - kzbin.infoOFn_SQX27wQ

[@dylanburney396]

@@ClauTo-oh5qu really what..? lol.

[@maud9460]

she is innocent and you suck

[@pattieboyd2832]

I'm surprised a woman in the USA is getting support, so she must be innocent, as I'm so used to the internet being full of USA men who spend their time promoting hatred against woman. Like those incels who are angry and confused why women prefer men who want to make them feel good.

[@erm1317]

Yes to all you lawyers, it’s NOT clear or simple. Its confusing. So many things like not getting the instructions in writing, in my state of NY not being able to take notes? It’s nuts. When u r deciding major things like this, u should be doing everything u can to make it clear. In my industry in healthcare, lawyers wouldn’t automatically understand either. It’s just a fact.

[@dawnieb.7394]

I think it's crazy that, for the most part, your guests poo-poohed the defense's reconstruction expert. The man not only wiped the floor with Trooper Paul while making it EXTREMELY clear why JO'K couldn't have been hit by a car, but he did it with SCIENCE. And a yeet cannon.

[@tnsloek]

Whether you believe she’s guilty or not, I truly don’t think that anyone could look at this case, and honestly say that there’s no reasonable doubt, and that alone means she shouldn’t be found guilty.

[@thatgirlray2765]

Exactly this Maybe you think there’s a good chance she did it, but do you think it’s BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT she did it? If your confidence is any less than 99.99% you must acquit

[@Lisalisa-zt2pw]

Pieces of her cars tail light were at the scene. There's nothing in the area for her to have hit BUT him . There's no doubt in my mind . Her ca made contact with his body. Hit n run. Guilty

[@jory6795]

⁠@@Lisalisa-zt2pwyou must not have watched the whole trial. The first day they had a lot of officers searching the scene, even on their hands and knees. Not one piece was found. Then magically a lot of pieces were found days later, some as large as a salad plate - after Reads car was impounded. A child could have found a huge piece of red plastic in a yard. But not a bunch of trained officers? Ok.

[@stevenprice6957]

No doubt. Guilty

[@GrandWren23]

@@thatgirlray2765Yep! “And to a moral certainty” in Massachusetts.

[@reneearnett8761]

isn’t the jurors suppose to find Karen not guilty if the prosecution didn’t prove their case??????? Because they absolutely DID NOT prove anything

[@2hearts1song4ever8]

That’s how it’s suppose to be, but there’s probably at least one juror that has no logical reasoning or common sense.

[@chhansen9813]

It only takes one juror to hold out and they cannot be intimidated by the rest of the jury! They will continually be sent back to deliberate for quite a while before a hung jury is called!

[@modeangelis7913]

No evidence, but lots of gossip, that's for sure...Lally's timeline didn't even say when he was hit?!? 😂

[@mandy2117]

pos fecked up he dot the timeline wrong then tried to say half 12 i thiught thats when pp were drink driving taking pp home only one person said they saw a lump on the lawn but i heard she was more drunk than the rest of them how can they bring charges when the fbi said she didnt hit him wi the car he was beat up in that house.

[@stevenprice6957]

Guilty. Proven.

[@michelecandelaria9550]

Just because that's the way it's always been done does not mean it is right or the most clear for the jurors.

[@noodlesmom01]

Judge Bev should study Maya's judge, Judge Carrol. Or even Murdaugh's Judge. Those judges listened to both sides and attempted to apply the law fairly. Auntie Bev was blantly biased. Disgusting to our justice system.

[@Kleed41344]

I wonder how many times that verdict form has caused a juror to mistakingly tic off a box just because they assumed they had to? It is most definitely more confusing to the jury, than t is the lawyers in this court!

[@lindafinch1520]

Very well said.

[@ryancox7155]

@@noodlesmom01 I hate bev, she is prolly the most unprofessional judge I’ve seen far as sighing and showing emotion. That being said it’s not uncommon for a judge to heavily favor the prosecution unfortunately. If you think that’s not the case you haven’t closely paid attention to many trials. In front of the jury bev actually plays the game pretty well and is pretty fair to both sides. Outside the presence of the jury she’s been very bias against the defense. I will say the defense especially Jackson has really been pushing the envelope and has been borderline aggressive, antagonistic, and demeaning. That puts a ton of pressure on the judge to referee things.

[@carlaamanda86]

@@ryancox7155well clearly Jackson has to be!! Bias Bev is so inappropriate in so so many ways. I wish the jury knew what we all know about her being in with the actual guilty parties. She is a disgrace.

[@Dgrimz4162]

They were in court but not JO’S funeral?

[@deeannwebster6030]

I think you’re relaying incorrect info.

[@acovert8241]

Who didn’t attend the funeral? McCabe and Albert’s?

[@reneearnett8761]

Yep!!!!!!!!

[@reneearnett8761]

It was said to one of those lying witnesses on the stand! They in fact did not go to John’s funeral

[@ficalli4743]

They did go to the funeral, stop spreading lies please.Karen on thr other hand did not go.

[@carrow1057]

One problem Joseph, this is one of the worst police investigations of a 'brother' in history, and consequential cover-up.

[@kellyalyse8408]

If the car didn't hit, you must aquit! Physics doesn't lie! Not Guilty!

[@luisaramirez7502]

Guilty

[@flairball]

@@luisaramirez7502, I’m curious. Why do you think she’s guilty? Both medical examiners have testified that the injuries were not consistent with being hit by a car, and both accident reconstructists hired by the Feds testified that if the car had hit someone at 24mph, as the prosecution claims, then it would have had much more damage. What are you seeing in the evidence that is more compelling that that evidence?

[@KatenJace]

@@flairballshe’s a jealous woman with internalized self loathing. No other logical actual argument. Pitiful. Notice those saying that never give real reasons? They compare her to ppl she’s nothing at all like. They yell about red flags and sleeping around. Make up stories. They sound like 1800s Salem MA witch trials. They want Read to wear the scarlet letter and be stoned in the town square. 😂

[@logicandreason8090]

@@flairball he has cognitive dissonance

[@2hearts1song4ever8]

@@flairballhe has troll fever. He must troll for attention.

[@sophiapetrillo3008]

I didn’t have strong feelings about this judge because I don’t understand enough about proper form and when certain questions are proper or not….. but that single interaction spoke volumes about her professionalism and character. She didn’t want to concede or backtrack as the judge - and then she took her frustration out by calling out the defendant for reacting with frustration. It’s her life on the line, judge, no I doubt she thinks it’s funny.

[@j.c.7555]

Someone needed to put her in her place. She is up against some serious charges but her snarkiness,flirtations, smirking etc throughout the trial is hardly appropriate under her circumstances imo. The Judge had it with her watching the behavior for weeks. She ended up folding anyways.

[@lenaknight7571]

Wow the Albert's are actually sitting next to the victim's family is wild...They can sit next to the family in court BUT DID NOT come out of the house when he was laying on their front lawn

[@facesofmeth666]

2:31 "Her Majesty was feeling tired", this Judge is a sad joke for the Justice system

[@markbaz]

She is a political employee of the state that represents the prosecution. That’s how it appears. She is so pro-prosecution and it is blatantly obvious.

[@lisalaursen3684]

@@markbazYes, at least she toned down all the dramatic sighing, only at the defense, after the first few days. She was probably reading all the comments 😂

[@mariaramos-on6hl]

Mr. Jackson is correct she’s like trying to lead the jury to say that she’s guilty of of the charge. If you don’t put boxing not guilty how can they determine what can they say that she’s not guilty that they’re gonna have to check one of the boxes that are there if that’s not available then you directing the jury to say that she’s guilty.. But she is NOT guilty

[@daviddavis3389]

I think that she is guilty as well.😅

[@cherylquell]

What in the world is taking this jury so damn long?

[@2hearts1song4ever8]

Reminds me of jury duty with pauly shore.

[@chhansen9813]

OBVIOUSLY the McMorons know someone on the jury, or the judge gave out their names so the McMorons could bribe them or threaten them! Its okay though because the FBI has been monitoring all of their phones, calls, and texts with amongst each other, and who they call and text, and who they call and text, and who they call and text. Their cars are all being tracked as well as their GPS location data on their phones, etc...Their homes were probably bugged a long time ago! Dont worry, even if theres a guilty verdict, it wont matter, the Feds are all over this case and waiting their turn. Karen will be free!

[@GrandWren23]

Right?! Hos long to reach a verdict?

[@Jack-bc5xg]

I don't know. She hit him and confessed.

[@PostalWorker14]

@@Jack-bc5xgShe never confessed not on tape at scene

[@MissteryDiva]

Brian & Colin Albert & Jen Mcabre sat in front of jury for closing arguments to intimidate them, but Action Jackson intimidated them‼️ KARMA

[@j.c.7555]

Another out there comment…intimidate who? Who’s them?

[@danieldmann]

The judge had a slight laugh before trying to call out Karen for it. Hmm.

[@lindafinch1520]

Yes, she laughed at Yanetti yet calls KR out for laughing. What a hypocrite.

[@russianaloha4576]

The FBI Better hurry up & conclude, cuz this is Crazy!

[@chhansen9813]

They wont do anything until AFTER there is a verdict. Its going to be okay regardless of the verdict! The Feds have been monitoring all of their calls, texts, locations, and probably bugged their houses! Alan Jackson WAS a big time prosecutor before he became a defense lawyer, hes worked with the Feds hundreds of times. Be patient!

[@westernhemisphere2205]

I would just write not guilty with a big red marker across the whole page. Just so there would be no confusion! And I would write it very clearly so the judge doesn't miss it😂

[@noodlesmom01]

I like your thinking 😂

[@8Platinum8]

😂 your silly

[@graciewhite8108]

These cops didn't get up one day wearing corruption they have been corrupt for some time.

[@daviddavis3389]

I have trusted the police all along! That poor police man...I don't understand some people.

[@lil_PowPow]

Weren't the Alberts and Nagels so "fearful" of the Turtleboy journalist, as an actual reporter he was banned while they were on the stand. (Despite the video evidence of them attacking 🐢boy and his gf.) The Alberts have been pointed out as a powerful family presence in the community. For them to be in court, much less staring right at the jury.... Intimidation to anyone who has any personal concerns on that jury. This judge, local and state LE is out of control. I hope the feds come and open all the doors and windows. Oooo the secrets that are hidden with past cases or "incidents", light is being revealed upon them.

[@CamB82]

70 witnesses are in on the conspiracy? That’s so unreasonable

[@tiffanyhawthorne2687]

Your panel members definitely have not been watching the same trial.

[@MatteoBarrera4830]

Karen somehow found the best attorney in the world

[@SorbetthekindUbuyina2ndhandsto]

Agree

[@CamB82]

If I were on the jury I would be turned off by Jackson’s disregard for the MA legal system

[@LoveFlowers1]

And the O'Keefe's inviting the McAlberts to the final testimony...makes me sick 🤢 they are sitting next to the ppl who murdered their son..their brother..their brother in law ..and the McAlberts where there to intimate the jury.. oh . this case makes me so sick there is no justice for John O'Keefe.. No justice!!

[@GML_123.]

Clearly, they don’t share your sentiment. More importantly, they are the victims family And should be afforded whatever comfort they seek.

[@Maggiemae856]

I still think she is guilty, not of murder but guilty.

[@annemarie2437]

The prosecution presented a weak case with a lot of heresay and accusations without real concrete evidence and they had even weaker experts. There is so much reasonable doubt that I could never in good faith send someone to prison. I hope the jury is smart and come back with not guilty.

[@viviendoconedna]

It just stinks. The judge, the prosecutor, the police and anyone that thinks this is right. I imagine all the ones who do not have Alan Jackson or a Yennetti to fight back. Also, not recognizing that all KR did was respond with disgust to the judge attitude. It IS PUTRID.

[@trickortrump3292]

Since when is anyone going to get away with showing disrespect towards the judge and not be reprimanded? There’s not a different set of rules for Karen Read.

[@viviendoconedna]

@@trickortrump3292 Expalin how she disrespected the judge? Lol

[@trickortrump3292]

@@viviendoconedna Please don’t be dense. “…all KR did was respond with disgust to the judge attitude”. I’m not going to sit her and spoon feed you an explanation on how that is disrespectful. My point stands. Nobody gets away with that in court.

[@lindafinch1520]

@@trickortrump3292 Wow, Judge Huff n Puff laughed at Yanetti and then admonished KR for laughing. Judge Bias Bev is a hypocrite! Also Judge Aunty Bev does not deserve ANY respect. She deliberately set up this court room to intimate Karen Read and the jurors. This judge is a disgusting criminal!

[@viviendoconedna]

@trickortrump3292 You won't, but you do sit to answer my comment. She did not disrespect the judge. If anything, she has been stoic in a situation where her civil rights have been violated. It's unbelievable.

[@jillmcbain88]

Jury needs to convict her. So obvious.

[@samariagraham4502]

Them being there looked like- we did it, we're gonna get away with it, and there's nothing you can do about it

[@guadalupelazar2384]

MR. PROCTOR UR SUCH DB.

[@terrarayner8766]

Higgins best bud the former chief needs to come clean

[@auieswow5052]

JURORS ARE NOT LAWYERS, LAWYERS MAY UNDERSTAND THE PAPERWORKS EASILY BUT THESE JURORS MAY ONLY BE SEEING THIS FORM ONCE IN A LIFETIME. THIS MAY BE THE FIRST AND LAST THEY WILL ENCOUNTER THIS!

[@josefinasoderholm6488]

Actually there are a lot of research saying that if there are 2 or more choices but only one boxes to check. We are more inclined to check that box (heard mentality) And. This verdict slip is so confusing I found it remarkable that anyone believes that 12 ordinary citizens should be able to understand it at all

[@SorbetthekindUbuyina2ndhandsto]

Amen

[@francescaspano-kl3cu]

He’s such a jerk

[@leticiaarbore2979]

Well if it was “hearsay”… than it should’ve never been presented in the trial! If it was presented in trial than the jurors had all the right to see the report!! 😮

[@hammertime1]

The Dedham, MA court room should have NEVER been used. It’s way to small and set up like that be design. This the worst layout of a court house in America. ❌❌❌

[@alikat1053]

Guilty

[@amyntazoe9831]

I have so many questions and she never took the stand. She's guilty but her lawyer did an excellent job of creating the tiniest amount of doubt. She will be acquitted but there will never be Justice.

[@portcityminis]

Not having that not guilty option is insane

[@ninastanek3388]

Trooper Proctor and others from the Karen Read case are also involved in the Sandra Birchmore case. Canton‘s finest!!

[@jcash3535]

What is up with that old dude, claiming it was an injustice to the public bc courtroom was small? Are you kidding me? It was televised and being live streamed, globally, DAILY- what the hell would 30 subpar “journalists” being able to sit in person and watch what we were ALL watching with our own two eyes do for anyone? How would that give us more access than what we already had? A few dozen media members to tell us what to think about what’s going on, has proven to be detrimental to ALL trials since the beginning of time. That’s the thing about 2024, BOOMER- we no longer need news filtered through journalists. We can see it with our own eyes… Thanks though. 🙄

[@michellestlicitra9105]

Guilty 💯💯💯

[@TheSandrafabian]

I find it astonishing that after watching the trial, some people still want her to be found guilty. I suggest they go back to day one of the trial and work their way up. Ignorance is really not kind.

[@combatgremlin2188]

I knew this court room was tiny. John O’keefe’s brother was almost smelling Karens hair, that is how annoyingly small it was. Not the best.

[@melissaomara2949]

I would take it the very way this lawyer is saying it. So hes right. Its time that banana republics get called out.

[@Mandola-Jane]

What are the odds that Joseph votes for Trump?

[@Mimi-w5f5u]

The judge is educating the attorney! Slimy attorney!

[@michellel2773]

What I learned from this is why lawyers didn't go into math 🤣🤣

[@migdaliamazziotta373]

Karen Read, Guilty of voluntary manslaughter’s injuries

[@Cinder_311]

No way

[@thatomofolo452]

Demon woman ♀️

[@sergio_grez]

Those 15 seconds opinions about evidence is an awesome section. Please do more of these!

[@1beatles]

I think shes GUILTY. A retired cop friend told me there is no way in hell a bunch of friendly cops are going to commit a conspiracy, also killing a fellow cop. I agree 100 percent

[@galina2061]

Hand-pick your investigator, have secret friends and family meetings to get your story straight, delete your call history, make mysterious phone calls at 2:22 a.m., delete Google searches, monitor police activity, get rid of evidence, get rid of your dog, destroy your phones, destroy your SIM card, let your investigator decide on a narrative early on, don’t go to the crime scene, don’t take witnesses in for questioning, question all the witnesses together, ignore witnesses who don’t fit your narrative, allow friends and family to contact those same witnesses, don’t record interviews, write vague and false police reports, omit witnesses names, omit witnesses interviews all together, don’t photograph the evidence, don’t conduct any forensics, don’t document the evidence, don’t document the log, leave all of the evidence in the hands of one person and then manipulate that evidence.

[@giigity]

I’m not sure what the jury is questioning. Nothing has been proved. 😂😂 The state didn’t do a good job.

[@NicholasSmall-iw6db]

Couldn’t have found a better photo of the missing child? Did proctor take that?

[@mevansmrichard]

It is open to the public, but there's nothing in the law that says the size of the crowd can't be limited due to the size of the court room.

[@beverlyaragon2328]

Big mistake you just made mrs read you were laughing 😮😡😡

[@shelleyhershberger1242]

I think the dog scratches and bites happened after he was already laying in the snow dead. He was laying in the snow dead and the dogs went up thought it was a predator!

[@LovetheLed]

😂😂😂

[@jlow2920]

I thought that perhaps happened to as far as animal or dog bites.

[@texasrefugee7888]

Hey, Oh, they found a body out front. Oh, it's just John. We did him in down in the basement last night. It was an accident we were all drunk as hell. Its Proctor gonna investigate.Let'ss go to breakfast. He's not even going to talk to us. Just pretend like this all happened somewhere else.😊

[@1beatles]

? Didnt kalren read, from the back seat of the car while searching for John, saying there he is there he is in the middle of a snow storm?

[@galina2061]

What are you writing? And the lantern has the same marks as a dog's nails? shame on you

[@portcityminis]

Thos judge is biased

[@deborahhockett]

I actually Do, think she got set up. Definitely, did not feel that way, in the beginning.

[@chilenitaprotrump]

This trial reminds me of the Laurie Bembeneck trial - Run Bambi Run - She was also framed.

[@ILoveWoolerbear]

This is a soap opera. Those are scratches and bites definitely from a dog. They started fighting with John O'Keefe in the house and the dog got excited and defensive as dogs can. They accidentally killed him in that house and THEY left him to die, not Karen Read.

[@joolz1063]

Alan Jackson was absolutely BRILLIANT and Not putting up with her CRAP, because what ??? She's TIRED 😱😱😱😱Bev you need Anger Management !!!!!!!!!!!!

[@stevenprice6957]

Ha trying to bluff. He’s bluffed many. Unless he luffed the jury then this phantom cover up might blow up in his Face.

[@j.c.7555]

@joolz1063. The Judge needs anger management? I hardly think that’s the case at all! Did you even watch the trial and listen to Karen’s screaming Voicemails to John? 😂. Glad you are NOT on the jury!!!

[@MissteryDiva]

​@@j.c.7555 Even if Karen hit him-Dr.Russel testified&Autopsy show beaten to death dog bites & hypothermia-Brian&Colin&Higgins brought John to basement.He reported Colin for dealing drugs-MOTIVE‼️ glad YOU'RE not in the jury!

[@lisalaursen3684]

@@j.c.7555Your talking apples and oranges. There’s a huge difference between Karen’s angry VMs when she thought John was out and possibly cheating, and the judge sighing and acting snarky only for the defense. One is someone being upset in an emotional situation, the other just unprofessional.

[@mandyrayner783]

Not tired oh swinging on her chair tiring lol The world is watching we see a lot of let's say pro CW

[@houndmommy]

The two (independent) science guys said he was not hit by her car. That's all I needed to hear.

[@lindafinch1520]

I agree, it's just unfortunate that the jurors weren't allowed to know that the FBI hired them. The jurors also were not allowed to know that many of the prosecutor's witnesses are currently under investigation by the FBI in this case and the Sandra Birchmore case. Those currently being investigated (to my knowledge) are DA Morissey and Troopers Proctor, Higgins and Lank.

[@MEMELIFEBABY]

You could play wack-a-mole with the reasonable doubt in this case.

[@GML_123.]

Competing testimony from experts. Obviously that’s not the entire story or the jury would be back by now.

[@GrandWren23]

Trooper Paul or Dr Wolfe? I’m done. Not hit=Not guilty.

[@CamB82]

Except they didn’t look at all the evidence, they didn’t look at the actual car & headlight, they weren’t at the crime sign and didn’t examine the body in person

[@reneearnett8761]

The MCALBERTS should NOT have been allowed in that courtroom on the LAST day of court! They were trying to intimidate! That’s obvious

[@ashadecastro276]

Alberts

[@lostsojourners6587]

@@ashadecastro276we call them McAlberts. The Canton Mafia.

[@lindafinch1520]

@@ashadecastro276 McAlberts is a term to describe the Alberts and the McCabes who are related, friends, conspirators and murderers.

[@lindamateri7298]

What ??? They lost Another beloved family member!!!!

[@LovetheLed]

⁠MCabes were there also. They filled the entire row behind OKeefes family 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@venusrodriguez9645]

To her credit she changed the form because the feds are involved.

[@acc4465]

she makes the calls in this trial. feds opinions don’t matter at all.

[@lpt369]

but not as originally requested by Jackson.

[@lindafinch1520]

No credit deserved by Judge Aunty Bev.

[@syon600]

Ruined it all at the end. Curveball reissuing jury directions

[@8Platinum8]

@@lindafinch1520exactly 🤣

[@katherineripley2967]

Trooper P is disgusting. Who would want him showing up to protect them! He’s a disgrace!

[@pennicochrane8886]

You can't blame him for calling her every name in the book HE LOST IT, THEY WERE ALL CLOSE FRIENDS FOR A VERY LONG TIME! YOU CAN'T BLAME HIM! PUT YOUSELF IN THE COPS SHOE SHE KILLED HIM. BLAME

[@sunnycali4984]

@@katherineripley2967 apparently him and his superiors are no different. How scary is that, they are a menace and I ask the universe to protect the jury from all of them (including the judge)

[@Patricia-kz4rl]

Aaaww.......your feelings hurt because not everyone believes psycho Karen? She IS a nut case. She killed one of his people. She took an uncle away from his niece & nephew who had already lost their parents. She took Paul O'Keefes' only sibling he had left. And now his parents have ONE son left. They had three children. Because of her jealousy and rage, and because she had NINE drinks, she saved her own ass and left John to freeze to death.

[@wiseup8729]

Beyond disgusting. He is vile. His mind is a complete sewer. Disgrace to the human race.

[@MakerInMotion]

@@pennicochrane8886 What you just described is called a "conflict of interest" and nobody who has one should be allowed to do an investigation.

[@gulliblesbabbles]

So glad she had to eat crow and make the necessary changes. So much attitude coming from that judge.

[@viccij]

This judge gives me the impression from her sighing and moaning that she really doesn’t want to be there

[@TheTruth-kh2im]

Exactly

[@evan1586]

She probably doesn't, it is probably heart breaking to her that so many law enforcement officers behave as such.

[@Findpepperbridge]

I mean… who doesn’t get annoyed at work? Especially when you are constantly arguing.

[@Kleed41344]

​@@evan1586She (The Judge) has behaved as unprofessional and biased as the rest of "law officials" 😡🤦🏻‍♀️ she doesn't want to be there because she realizes her "side" will lose

[@lindafinch1520]

Yet she refused to excuse herself when the defense team asked her to do so.

[@subri120499]

This Joe guy is ALWAYS anti Karen. No matter the evidence, he is pro Guilty. Pretty silly.

[@kimberlychelen9890]

Yesssssss... definitely a hater of Karen Read.

[@RationalNon-conformist]

He’s stupid, really stupid.

[@lindadoniz2322]

Very pro guilty., the defense experts were indeed qualified in comparison to the prosecutions. The last 2x experts were hired originally by the fbi. This guys does not make any sense. Just common sense tells you she’s not guilty .

[@DeniseHonest]

He is definitely a troll!

[@OneChikwu]

Pretty sure he's trolling

[@Headcase650]

I personally am 100% convinced that Michael Proctor planted all the tail light evidence. The video of her leaving John's house after backing into his car clearly shows her tail light was at least 80% intact. Then add to that that not a single piece of tail light evidence was found until an hour and a half after Proctor took position of her car. Proctor and the other officer testify that no one was ever around that tail light in the Sally port, presented video evidence that was later determined to be manipulated intentionally because the timestamp was flipped to cover their tracks. When you flip the video to the correct way it's obvious they were all huddled around that tail light and people going in and out of that back door. If he's capable of planting evidence in this trial it should put into question every piece of evidence he's ever collected or handled!

[@8Platinum8]

i think even if she bumped him and he fell hard cuz he was drunk the light pieces were still planted

[@lisalaursen3684]

Yes and the fact that the FBI is doing their own investigation speaks volumes. Why would the FBI get involved in a hit and run?! Then of course the judge wouldn’t allow the jury to know that the defense experts, who independently investigated the case, did so for the FBI.

[@donnakehoe478]

This 💯

[@yvie9627]

This is a clear set up, i felt it immediately.

[@daviddavis3389]

​@@8Platinum8where you there to be qualified as a witnesses.? We all have our biases, no matter what case it is.human nature...my gut tells me GUILTY!

[@vee483]

I believe Jennifer McCabe 💯 why did Read go to Jennifer when she already knew where John was? Read had dropped him off at Fairview, and she already knew he was there! HELLO!!

[@jenniferruth812]

Please, Vinnie, I beg you to get higher quality people on your panel. It's so hard to watch these fools. An investigative journalist should be outraged when there's clear evidence of injustice & corruption.

[@acc4465]

i don’t like what your panel says - too much common sense. i want to hear lies and things that couldn’t possibly happen. let’s make fiction real.

[@Findpepperbridge]

Kevin drives me crazy. He’s only trying to disagree with Rocko.

[@KatenJace]

Agree. Vinnie himself has been terrific tho. Surprised me. ❤

[@TwistOfFate444]

@@acc4465don’t care if I agree with the panel as long as they’re experts with no dog in this fight.

[@8Platinum8]

I hate it when they miss what the question actually was and or answer improperly and clearly have no idea the facts of the case irritating

[@LoveFlowers1]

She is a HORRIBLE JUDGE..she allows for the jurors to leave early..she is rude to Jackson..she criticizes Karen for laughing yet she laughed first at Jackson and brushed him off like what he had to say had no meaning...she is obviously Bias. And wants the jury to select that Karen is Guilty... She needs to retire after this case!!

[@chhansen9813]

I think Karen just smiled!

[@MissteryDiva]

Judge's brother defended Albert for DWI death & got him off‼️- Biased & conflict of interest ‼️They call her "Aunt Bev"

[@cassandratq9301]

She's intimidated by the police.

[@policecamsreact]

Judge ... i was tired !!! i would laugh at her as well !!!!

[@lovemylittles4758]

Yes it’s funny sarcastically judge ! ITS HER LIFE ! THATS BEING PLAYED WITH! She can laugh if she wants too

[@ericas2423]

Karen Read’s lawyer is fantastic. He didn’t back down at all.

[@sunnycali4984]

If I were a member of the jury in this blatantly corrupt town, I’d be super worried for the police retaliation. They have shown what they are capable of and how they are still suffering no consequences…

[@lindafinch1520]

right, I'm sure there are juror who are scared.

[@GrandWren23]

They know that. That is why they were in court for the closing.

[@lisalaursen3684]

No consequences yet but the FBI is investigating them all. That “other grand jury hearing” the prosecution witnesses were repeatedly asked about giving testimony at was for the FBI. It’s just judge Bev wouldn’t let the jury know that so the defense couldn’t mention the FBI. Also, the independent accident reconstruction experts (who weren’t asked to investigate by the prosecution or defense) had done the investigation for the FBI.

[@Juliette_4]

This judge is awful. She's insulting, and unnecessarily rude when she scolded KR. Very telling.

[@DrewsReviews07]

Yeah its personal for her she’s gotta protect her thugs in blue however she can

[@Lisalisa-zt2pw]

The car hit him . Tail light pieces by his body proves she hit him . There's nothing else in the area she could have hit BUT him. He may have tried to crawl to the house . Then passed out. She is GUILTY. It's plane and simple.

[@LovetheLed]

😂😂😂

[@reasonable342]

Absolutely the car hit him. We don’t know the exact interaction but the credible evidence clearly shows thus. It is quite obvious. The defense is simply trying to poke holes in this but people really need to consider the likelihood of their claims in the context of the rest of the evidence. It’s interesting what people will believe….

[@LovetheLed]

The CW of MA ME testified that the injuries were NOT Caused or consistent with being hit by a vehicle

[@juanacastillo7154]

Hit and Run case. John probably hit his head against the Electric box or the Fire Hydrant in the area. She is guilty 💯

[@GrandWren23]

@@reasonable342What credible evidence? The state’s own medical examiner said the injuries were inconsistent with being struck by an SUV. And the only CREDIBLE science in this whole trial was the accident reconstruction Doctors. Damage was inconsistent with pedestrian strike. Physics doesn’t lie. Not hit. Not guilty.

[@Curtis-1231]

Here’s a good one about our Bev. Bev's brother was an attorney for Chris Albert when he committed a murder and he served 6 months. Also indicted in child pornography. And 65k accumulated unpaid tax.

[@JosephineB63]

I'm gonna have to research this

[@Curtis-1231]

@@JosephineB63 Vinnie had him on this episode. I was shocked. 😳

[@lisalaursen3684]

The whole family probably has a lot of skeletons in the closet and dirt on each other which is another reason they’re covering for each other.

[@theresafeeney2756]

I heard about the dui where he killed someone. Didn’t know about pornography or back taxes. Doesn’t surprise me

[@ritayoung6040]

Love Action Jackson

[@LanellLambert-m2i]

This is disgraceful to not respect John OKeefe outside the courthouse!!! What happened to people? That they would rally around Karen and not the families of the deceased 🥺

[@angelas520]

Here's how Karen is guilty: Karen lied when she said she left him at the bar. Karen lied when she left VM to John, stating she was at her home. Karen; at aprox 5 am, said "he's dead". Karen's car, aprox 5 am, headed towards the crime scene right before she said "he's dead". Karen repeatedly stated "I hit him I hit him I hit him". Karen is the only one in the car, while in back seat, that spots his body, in the dark, no street light, camouflaged under snow. The other two in the car didn't even see him until she ran up to him. (and one of those witnesses DEFINITELY had no connection to the so called "conspiracy"). She was drunk. Data shows he never entered the house. Her voicemails and children's testimony indicates she has issues and "all was not well in relationship". Missing video from John's ring camera during crucial times. (definitely indicating her cover up) Her "over acting" on the crime scene, classic of guilty people. DNA on the inside housing of the taillight. The drink glass fragments found with taillight fragments on his clothing. I hate you, you pervert voice mail in rage type anger. 24 mph in reverse!!! And then during trial NEVER a tear, not even remotely close. In fact she laughs. If you can't see through this OJ style defense then you have a closed mind. And coincidentally; the prosecution was not very good, just like the OJ trial. She might just get away with murder like him.

[@stargazer6328]

Hope not. The turtle boy bullies don't help the jury feel like they can make an informed decision.

[@1beatles]

I agree wholeheartedly .. so much acts by her showing guilt

[@bjohnjackson1083]

Well said

[@nicolelugo1]

I still think she’s innocent and he prob got into a fight at the party and they accidentally killed him and put him in the snow

[@GrandWren23]

@@angelas520 Everything you stated is speculation and interpretation of how YOU think she should be acting. I don’t like KR. But I do like science. And I like physics. There is serious incompetence in the handling of this case. NO chain of custody on those pieces of tail light so none can be relied on. I have no doubt she is factually innocent.

[@anacelizreyes3971]

Justice for all no one is above the law period. Practice what y’all preach (law enforcement) Proctor should get suspended and charged for unlawful doings

[@angelinaanderson481]

The Okeefs are being controlled by the guilty party!

[@ashadecastro276]

I know it’s so sad eh

[@Findpepperbridge]

That happens a lot. It’s sad

[@riannarodriguez9759]

I think they just have a hard time coming to terms that some cops are corrupt since JOK was a cop.

[@Jack-bc5xg]

The conspiracy theory is ridiculous. It's all they got to point the finger away from her.

[@angelanewbury4920]

Given the evidence-it shouldn’t be taking this long -😢

[@Findpepperbridge]

There’s a lot of evidence to go over and if one person is saying guilty then they have to pursue them.

[@pamnovotny2364]

Hair could have frozen to the bumper. Guilty

[@nonenamed1511]

Sir to say that’s not a dog bite simply means you’ve never treated a dog wound. That’s exactly how it looks when a dog attacks not just a surprise nip. Took me years in trauma to realize 90% of dog bites actually look like long contusions. Plus no way he was hit by a car…..again this is literally what I see daily. And no medical expert that actually works in trauma to see actual results, would disagree.

[@Lisalisa-zt2pw]

I think they could be dog scratches...but it doesn't change the fact her broken tail light was next to his body. She hit him with her car. She had to have felt the contact. She drove away. He died. The tail light proves it.

[@Ania-cd2sh]

@@Lisalisa-zt2pwyou are seriously delusional or didn’t watch the trial at all and I was hit by at car at 10mph I had a broken leg and arm with massive large bruises. 24mph and none of that? He must have been made of steel besides his head and scratched arm I guess

[@evan1586]

That is one of the reasons why they don't want to prosecute law enforcement it will call into question all of their legitimate arrest.

[@DrewsReviews07]

Scumbags

[@eastcoastgirl3770]

If the victim was covered in snow..how did karen know it was john?..it could have just been a mound of snow...she knew

[@normacolon9618]

cause he is missing and what other person would be there or snow mound or bump.

[@monicarenee7949]

It was a human sized lump under snow. She couldn’t find him anywhere why wouldn’t it be reasonable to think he could be outside if she saw a human sized mound

[@melindaloggins7383]

Y r y’all supporting a cop killer

[@kimdebruno]

I dont understand what is taking so long to come back NG? Mountains of reasonable doubt.

[@Jacqueline888]

it’s a good sign. fast verdict = guilty.

[@pennicochrane8886]

She killed him they are taking their time and big chance a hung jury! You forgot about John O'Keefe!! The defence are big CALIFORNIA Attorneys CELEBRITY attorneys!! She was in a drunken rage 53 messages screaming profanities BUT it was not.ok for that cop to air his loss and anger over what she did to him with her car!

[@StilettoCutsQuick.]

@kimdebruno - my guess is that they the jury will not agree.

[@StilettoCutsQuick.]

I’m mean that they are having a hard time agreeing with each other.

[@j.c.7555]

Because they don’t agree …too many guilty votes!

[@acovert8241]

Alan Jackson has plenty to appeal on.

[@DanielBoon-st8tt]

Without a doubt ‼️ hands down

[@Lisalisa-zt2pw]

Guilty clearly. The tbeoken tail light near his body says it all. A dog may have found him after the fact. But the hit n run is what lead to his death. Clearly

[@GrandWren23]

His injuries were not caused by being hit by a car. So. Not guilty.

[@CH-vm6cq]

There wasn’t a broken taillight near his body. They didn’t start finding pieces until days later.

[@subri120499]

Joe says not sophisticated Dog scratch expert 😂😂 compared to MSP Paul?? 😂😂

[@koreo7318]

I've seen so many experts come out and say the same re them being consistent with dog bite & scratches. The K9 guy on yt also says the same

[@anacelizreyes3971]

Too many thugs nowadays holding a badge

[@dewise4768]

Why is it so hard to believe a drunk, angry and vengeful Karen would drop him off, back into him, and leave pissed. You heard her voicemails. Bully defense team coming up with crazy alternatives that a small town with families who grew up together tried to cover up a murder and left him in their own yard?! How stupid would a fellow cop have to be? Don’t follow the crowd, think for yourself. Find her guilty.

[@bjohnjackson1083]

Well said

[@anonymousgirl799]

@dewise4768 WHERE is the strong evidence? That's what should be considered, not emotion. Why blunt force injury to a tall man's head and marks on O'Keefe arm, if from a car light???? Where was his lower body damage...O'Keefe's head was near a tail light????? Bull. Take a physics course.

[@jjsmama401]

How did he get the dog bites? How did he not have any injuries around the area where the bumper would have hit him? Why didn’t the Albert’s daughter and other party-goers see him laying there?

[@nicolelugo1]

The wife googled how long to die in cold or something. At 2 something in morning

[@joleenspelbrink3265]

That judge is cranky and arrogant! On the prosecution's side!

[@8Platinum8]

😂 finally finding comments that match my thoughts for the last 9 weeks

[@joleenspelbrink3265]

Exactly

[@chhansen9813]

Thats normal

[@DrewsReviews07]

The judge is always on the prosecutions side around here

[@sunshinewildfire7087]

So many SHADY moves by the prosecuters and the judge. This trial is a huge miscarriage of justice. It is obviously a cover-up. I would not even vacation on Massachusetts now. So shady!

[@Soulshine67]

Don’t believe a word out of Jenn’s mouth

[@300sl5]

Why is she smiling & laughing all the time? Everyone who is wrongfully accused would be upset & angry. She is not innocent.