Bill Maher Exposes Eric Dyson FAKE Concern For Jews

It's time to call out the nonsense.

[@colinneilson2630]

Dyson is a massive wind bag

[@u.y.3643]

Like Biden

[@Red22762]

Yeah, he blows wind from both orifices🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@barrettfenwick8028]

Diversity hire.

[@virtualbeing5195]

He seems fair and considerate to Israel's security, against terrorism, but concerned for palestinian civilian's lives too.

[@abraham4961]

@@virtualbeing5195 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@PrivateCitizen84]

When it's Arab vs Arab nobody cares not even Arabs, but when it's Jew and Arab everyone seems to care. This brings out all the Jew haters for sure to point it's a political cliche. Live long enough you get to witness it in cycles. Dyson is old enough to get how this game is played.

[@shmerelize]

As Mark Twain said, "History doesn't repeat itself, but it often rhymes."

[@gucciadjective7745]

When its arab vs arab the whole world tells the west not to get involved, then when we dont "no one cares".

[@Harris665]

Ask yourself why the Arabs have a problem with you..

[@rogerandes8]

Isn't it funny how that is. All of a sudden Israel is the only bad guy in the middle easy. I'm gay. Guess what doesn't happen in Israel that happens to gay people in countries all around Israel. Just one example. The Dyson's of the planet like to talk about how trump is a threat to democracy. Guess what else happens in Israel that doesn't happen in countries all around Israel

[@morethanahuman6112]

It was Arab versus Arab in the Gulf War, but not many people were opposed to that one. Unfortunately a lot of innocent people died.

[@matthewjohnson1643]

I’m a black man and I can’t stand Dyson. He is stuck in the past.

[@christoferprestipino7433]

wtf does being black have to do with your tolerance or lack thereof ? Are you suggesting black people blindly listen to anyone he is black, because they’re black? What it idiotic position

[@bryguy9231]

He’s a disingenuous race hustler, he isn’t stuck in the past cause he knows exactly what he is doing and you can’t tell me he actually believes it….

[@vergillives9890]

Alot of race huslers are if they cant evoke the past as a shield they would starving in the streets

[@philippusviridi6527]

Thank you and spot on. People who live in the past refuse to move forward in life they would rather just hate.

[@Camhab]

Instead of blaming Israel, why nobody condemn Hamas for using civilians as human shields

[@mohammadsufiyaan5330]

Because it's hoax claim and there's no proof of it and a Hasbara propaganda

[@erikkovacs3097]

Because they're resisting white settler cis-gender colonialism purple monkey dishwasher.

[@RojaJaneman]

Because that narrative has been used by d west for war/regime change as well. They’d like to keep it in d back pocket for d future.

[@lazer8776]

Because that’s not happening.

[@erikkovacs3097]

@@lazer8776 They even admit to doing it. Haven't you ever heard of a Shaheed?

[@rmthull]

Amazing how no one is calling for Hamas to surrender.

[@u.y.3643]

It’s always a double standard when it comes to us Jews.

[@philippealexis]

It's just about always absolutely a mistake to use the word 'always'.

[@jimjames4348]

@@philippealexis Am Yisrael Chai. Israel will prevail. 🤍💙🤍💙🤍

[@chetpomeroy1399]

No one bats an eye and basically ignores it when *hundreds of thousands* of Arabs in Syria and Yemen are being slaughtered by their brother Arabs, but when Israel is involved in a conflict, the "news" media blames the Jews.

[@seansimms6693]

I wonder why???

[@chetpomeroy1399]

Some of us are aware of the *hundreds of thousands* of Arabs being unalived by their brother Arabs, but the "news" media doesn't bat an eye. Such news is only reported when it comes to casualties resulting from Israel's self-defence.

[@anthonyhuber-permanentlyre7808]

*Eric Dyson is not an intellectual, he is a talking head.* Change my mind.

[@xokelis0015]

I would describe him as a race hustler.

[@MrAgnosticman]

I'll do no such thing

[@SierraSierraFoxtrot]

If you consider NPC babble talking...

[@avrahamgoldberg9731]

He is not a talking head. He is a talking ass. Change my mind.

[@vaughnreedjr6592]

He more smarter than you

[@marcmaman7747]

Your analysis is spot on. There are a lot of people nowadays who go around saying they don’t approve of antisemitism but then they start bashing Israel. I call them hypocrites!

[@charleshewitt6180]

Excellent example of completely dodging a direct question. And the line "I don't believe in any terror organization" is a great example of the nonsense ... you DON'T get to decide if you believe in something that objectively exists. If there was any other way for Israel to get rid of Hamas, why isn't any country or individual suggesting it? Maher, Douglas Murray, and many others have been clear in their statements of facts. And the 1 to 1 pales in comparison to the 60-1 in the Mosul battle. And the term "Ministry of Health" is the ultimate in an insane name for Hamas. How would Dyson feel if his next door neighbor broke into his home and killed a family member and openly stated he will kill the rest of his family?

[@theguybehindyou4762]

Dyson would blame white racism

[@polarbear4612]

Dyson is a race hustler. It’s how he makes money so don’t expect any truth out of him.

[@Jessica_Roth]

A less-obvious Henry Rogers ("Ibrahim X. Kendi")

[@gyj1911]

He was calling for ceasefire??

[@wheelz114]

Dyson made himself look like an unintelligent fool in this sit down. I legit feel stupider for having listened to him

[@emodante1084]

He made himself look like a fool before when he debated Jordan Peterson and Stephen Fry.

[@ytsi7505]

8:20 these so called pro Palestinians are knowingly malevolent!!!

[@NewHerseyAccent]

Dyson is to politics what Deepak Chopra is to 'physics'

[@neilrichardson7454]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@robbinsnest6163]

I remember the first time i heard this man talk. It was on a panel with him and Jordan Peterson and 2 others i believe. Dyson not only used "big" words that were just fluff, but he resorted to personal attacks on Jordan Peterson. Rather than presenting his side of the debate with dignity, he chose to insult. When debate devolves into personal attacks on your opponent, you have lost the debate. If it was a simple sit down discussion, that would be one thing, but this was a formal debate and he chose to show his true colors.

[@MrAgnosticman]

Stephen Fry was the second person on the side including JP. The name of the lady I don't recall. It was a Monk debate. If Stephen Fry is not on your side, you should probably reevaluate your position.

[@robbinsnest6163]

​@MrAgnosticman thank you! I could see his face and remember him in movies but could not think of his name😅

[@mrzee4862]

@@MrAgnosticman The Munk debates are fantastic. Douglas Murray was in one 4 days ago and was great.

[@readwatchlisten2863]

In almost every single war of the modern ear, except I think the Napoleonic Wars, more civilians were killed than military personnel.

[@paulanderson5389]

I tell people that fact when this subject comes up. It will most likely get worse in the future.

[@jcarh]

I wonder what the ratio of Hamas:Civilian deaths on October 7th was?

[@mireillepioger92]

what's all that crying for gaza?How many Jews died in WW11,to many...

[@CrisusAttucks]

why is Eric Dyson writing for any journal or newspaper ffs, he is as vacuous as Dyson vacuum

[@Neo_Red_Pill]

Continued prayers for the IDF the hostages and their familism for Jewish people across the world as Christians we stand with Israel bring them home🙏🌼🤝

[@kantraxoikol6914]

you do know prayer never ONCE helped anyone live another hour let alone your sky daddy has never once ANSWERED your prayers....how about stop kneeling and DO SOMETHING

[@pilbomags488]

Why not just rename Palestine to Hamas?

[@derekmitchell1738]

Why not just rename you to "Horse's Ass"?

[@pbjae8140]

There is no Palestine.

[@matthewstokes1608]

Why not just take it and name it ISRAEL?

[@alsosprachzarathustra5505]

Netanyahu implicitly called it Hamastan and Fatahstan. I think we should go with that.

[@adriaanboshoff9754]

Hamastan

[@Michael-h2m1f]

IDF spokesperson Daniel Hagari is right, “Hamas is an idea”. The idea is that there can be an independent state for Palestinians in Israel’s Holy Land. How ridiculous.Israelis are entitled to it all and as much as they want.

[@MichaelSteinbeck-h1n]

This black person stands 1000% with Jewish people!

[@kantraxoikol6914]

did you make a sign too?

[@mikeg2306]

We appreciate you too!

[@ConcernedCitizen-vv5qz]

All decent people must stand together against Islamic Fascist terrorism, and all hate. Why is this complicated? Well I guess I know, anti-semitism is stronger in some than the concept of self-preservation. But there are more decent people than bigots out there, we just aren't as loud and pretentious as the haters who try to cloak their disgusting beliefs as something else.

[@drcrocodile1]

Good for Bill for taking a clear stand and calling out the morally inverted hypocrisy.

[@donnymcilvaine8563]

People will never know the real number because most of the hamas fighters wear civilian cloths and when they die they don't leave the weapons and ammo behind, just the body. Don't think there aren't 12 and 13 year Olds firing weapons and entrenched with the fighters. The innocent ones are truly heartbreaking on both sides. War was the worst thing hamas could've done to get their people more freedom imo

[@chuckbecker4983]

They took a lot of money and never bothered to built a seaport. Just a few miles up the coast is Ashdod, the product of a constructive society. Dyson is unable to see his own prejudice, confusing formal statements with practical judgements. Using Idi Amin in an analogy is a shameful red herring.

[@richardchavez3973]

Would they think the same if it was their family being held hostage? I doubt it.

[@azamnowrouzi7507]

Israel defending them self Israel have no choice but keep fighting . What you think it is war ,people Die in war

[@erad05]

I think that the response of Israel is diproportionat, because israel takes to much regard for civilians in Gaza and do not hit hard enough to eradicate the evil. That is disproportionate, because it takes to much victims on the side of Irael and to much time and makes it harder to to reach all the goals. I stand with IDF, Israel, the Jews and the right for Zion. Am Yisrael Chai.

[@rankobarensic]

Far too nice against Gazans...more than 85% hates Jews...Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱✡️✝️❤️

[@Jessica_Roth]

You can thank Biden and Blinken for that; they've been criticizing and choking the response since 8th October.

[@juliebollman3944]

Stand firm, stay strong we stand with you 🇺🇲

[@arashkamangir9824]

As an Iranian Jew living in exile in US and having families in Israel, hearing all these talks of civilian casualties of Gazan is just disgusting. How none of these know anything about Israel and Hamas and assume that all Hamas are kids with toys and not real guns. Hamas is free and they have bombs and guns. Gaza is not a closed auditorium. They are free and they have lots of guns, and they use them all day long. Stop telling Israel to somehow perform a miracle and separate all these people in plain clothes. They do not wear military uniforms and they use regular cars and not armored vehicles. Stop showing empty emotions in order to capture Muslim audiences you clowns. Go to Gaza and stop the rockets and bombings and then try to give humanity lessons to Israel. Go free Iran. There is an oct7 every single day in Iran. Iranian Jew

[@ntme9]

Moral of the story here is, intent matters

[@fernandoalegria4240]

In Buddhism, intent is paramount, and one, in dealing with others, should constantly question ones intent.

[@henryw5762]

RED FLAG: NEW YORK TIMES REPORTER, AKA ANTI-SEMITE!

[@tombaron5607]

Palestinian 20 year with adidas sneakers and a track suit: civilian. Rocket launcher in his room. Just a coincidence.

[@PBJ5519]

This guy on the right is only trying to make himself look righteous. Good grief. He makes me feel angry.

[@pwk22]

When you talk about the ratio of combatants to non-combatants, you must always note that this is in an urban setting, where more civilians will inevitably die. Most wars are not fought in an urban setting.

[@rodjacksn]

Dyson is a lying corrible hunt😮😮😮!!!!!

[@kiethdyce8655]

Dyson has lost all credibility who’s listening to this snake oil salesman he’s all talk and stupid

[@seltzercoffee]

I am so sick of racists saying “October 7 was abhorrent, but ( fill in anti-Jew rant)…”

[@goldspout]

Dyson in his example using Idi Amin fails to distinguish between Amin who was a perpetrator of terror by enabling terrorists in the Entebbe crisis to hold hostages at the airport. Israel's heroic response against Uganda had nothing to do with Uganda being a black nation. This Dyson character is a wolf in sheeps' clothing.

[@RobertThomson-y4m]

My grandfather was in the British army that liberated Belsen. I stand 100% with Israel.

[@ytsi7505]

2:00 the un average is 1combatant to 9 civilians why does everyone ignore this credit to you for bringing it up😊

[@saraleigh5336]

Did Dyson just say “you’re mistaking Israel with Jews”? I mean, half of world Jewry lives in Israel.

[@miriamgonzalez1394]

WHEN THEY ARE GOING TO ADMIT THAT ISRAEL IS THE OWNER.. IS WRITTEN...

[@almabrisiarodriguez-xh2lo]

WAR IZ WAR

[@jacobcohen9205]

Was it two thousand people killed at Pearl Harbour? How many Japanese civilians died in the fire bombing of Tokyo, never mind the Nukes.

[@stephaniepilecki2774]

Over-response? What kind of bullshit term is that? If I know a group wants my group to be eradicated, damn right I'm going to "over-respond"!

[@wootwoot1075]

Hamas was in charge of their actions. Its no one's business on how Israel REACTS!

[@joostroeters9087]

Question 1 ‘ who is the illegal occupier and who are the occupied and suppressed? Question 2: what happened far before October 7 on the Westbank where Hamas doesn’t play a role? Question 3: before October 7 Netanyahu showed maps of greater Israel with the Palestinian 9:47 territories erased. Who would speak about the Palestinian people today when October 7 didn’t happen. Question 4: which American would accept foreigners entering their land and stealing their properties and being terrorized? If people claim that Israel has historic rights on the land why din’t Americans give back the land stolen from the native Americans? Question 5: how can US politicians be so corrupt that AIPAC can control congress, senate and Joe Biden? Fighting with allied forces to defeat nazi Germany to end the holocaust the US now collaborates with the Israeli nazis to continue its genocide on the Palestinian people.

[@guidobolke5618]

Did the 2000 US citizens killed at pearl harbour justify the 400.000 killed japanese civilians? Shouldn't the USA have answered more proportionate to these attacks and then turn to negotiations? Shouldn't the USA pressured Great Britain to start peace negotiations instead of continuing to support the british aggression and genocide against Germany? Asking for a very confused friend?

[@maxprize829]

Dyson is as intellectually dishonest as they come - he speaks like a preacher so sheep flock to him

[@jeffwilson4693]

Hamas committed 10/07/23. Hamas then hid among Gazans, putting Gazans in harms way. The Hamas could have, at any point, freed the hostages and surrendered. They chose not to, putting Gazans in harms way once again. It it all on Hamas.

[@deathmetaldouglas69]

I thought Eric Dyson went into hiding after Jordan Petersen demolished him at one of those town hall type deals.

[@killablooz]

Dyson - zero wisdom. ZERO. Another unwise intellectual. They're a dime a dozen.

[@georger6624]

Thank you, Bill. I’m surprised I really am. I’m a conservative but right now you’re 100% correct thank you sir.

[@daveh893]

I support Israel, but you can't use polling in Gaza saying that Palestinians overwhelmingly support Hamas. To me that is like polling in Russia showing that Russians overwhelmingly support Putin.

[@janiceridsdale2904]

EXACTLY - HOW SILLY !

[@kashesan]

Dyson seems to know nothing of the history of this area.

[@andrewsilverstein6186]

Yes, war is bad, but if you "play stupid games, you win stupid prizes." Don't start a war, and you won't get the stuffing kicked out of you when the one you hurt fights back.

[@OpinionGuy-cq8hp]

I think all life is precious no matter the race or religion

[@popsy5676]

עם ישראל חי 🙏🏽🇳🇱❤🇮🇱

[@joanmavima5423]

Dyson’s method is to steamroll others.

[@Futuredynamo]

Dyson's entire schtick is to use really big, fancy sounding words to make it seem like he sounds smart, when he is actually making very pedestrian and often times ridiculous/nonsensical arguments.

[@joanmavima5423]

He has no response to the facts.

[@Raydar1234]

Eric Dyson…. Pfff 🙄🙄

[@jasonbender2459]

I wish the IDF had a foreign legion.

[@Camille_Anderson]

Surprised Dyson didn't just say " now you're just being racist towards me!"

[@brandonwalsh13]

Bill Maher is wrong about one thing he said they gave that land back. Israel gave them that land for the first time because it was never theirs. Israel took it from Egypt and gave it to these people in exchange for peace, but those people attacked the very next day so I see no reason why they should be able to keep the land. It seems like in all of these agreements that these people are not expected to live up to any part of their side of the agreement, but that Israel in contrast is expected live up to every part of their side.

[@pallidbustofpallas4679]

The Jewish people cannot protect themselves without a Jewish state. I agree with this. But are other ethnicities and religious groups entitled to their own state? Or is this a uniquely Jewish right?

[@morethanahuman6112]

Iran, United Arab Emirates, Qatar,ect. The crescent is on at least two of those flags which is an Islamic symbol. Then there is Georgia and Greece, which are both Christian states. There are many more. I can keep going… I don’t think you agree with it and maybe do more research. Why is it ok for Christians and Muslims to have their own countries but it’s not ok for the Jewish people. It’s like taking to a wall 🙄

[@mohammadsufiyaan5330]

No amount of evidence can convince an Am Israel Chai 😂😂😂

[@o00nemesis00o]

Can we see some evidence that Mohammad went to Jerusalem? Oh? He simply had a vision about going to Jerusalem? Well can we see some evidence that he even had a vision? His description of Jerusalem is completely wrong. What kind of evidence would you accept for Islam being invented for wealth and power?

[@ytsi7505]

9:18 he thinks he cares about the descendants of שם בן נח as long as they aren't בני ישראל 😅 bill mahers aponent

[@arkyudetoo9555]

Is this the same person who called Dr. Jordan Peterson a "mean white man" in a formal debate?

[@Maryculligan]

Israel must win.

[@Qwaernunos]

The Romans did not exile all the Jews. Neither did the Babylonians. Jews took their name from Judea, rebranded by Jordan in 1950 as the West Bank to erase the inalienable connection of Jews to the heart of their territory. The Jewish peoples have maintained an unbroken presence in their ancestral homeland for over 3,000+ years despite dispersions, conquests, settler occupations, and severe restrictions to where they were allowed to live aka apartheid. It is precisely this indigeneity which confers upon them the historical, legal, and moral right to this land which after centuries of dispossession they now reclaim as theirs.

[@Mohawkmonkey360]

"Huxtering snake oil pulpit talk" -Stephen Fry

[@raymondwatt9773]

Dyson's argument is like saying we should feel bad for the Nazis because of the Dresden bombings.

[@master-l8h]

Great channel! Reveal the truth 👏👏🇮🇱❤️

[@yonatangoldman9759]

Dyson holds Israel to a unique, unrealistic, unprecedented standard. It's up to him to explain why. He doesn't even try.

[@lorirudderham3303]

The majority of Palestinians voted Hamas into power ! End of story !

[@Larry-j9b]

With todays precision arms, i must wonder how close to the terrorist are these civilians standing?

[@anthonyb3714]

I'm really pro-israel but I wouldn't sat it's 1:1 on civilian to soldier (4:1 is what I keep hearing)😢 and un didn't revise the number by half, but the number of woman/children in half

[@popsy5676]

T error ists under 18 are counted as children. They train them to unalive Jews from early childhood.

[@Arthagnou]

Don't start a war you cannot win. this will be the 6th time the Palestinians/Arabs have done this.

[@legalmexican]

Until fairly modern times, yes, wars only killed the soldiers because they lined up on fields and went at each other.

[@rdalge]

At the end of the day, as with many wars before, this will not prove who’s right, but who’s left. Israelis: “It doesn’t matter how many civilians we kill because it’s war.” Hamas: “It doesn’t matter how many civilians we kill because they’re occupiers.”

[@channahcastelobranco]

🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🕎

[@anitamurkes9511]

It’s not an assault on Gaza ! It’s a war of defence ! This man is living in his head-talk,talk- not in reality !

[@HR-op2cq]

I guess you're right. Also, there are copyright issues and such.. So he has to break it up I guess

[@TigerHogan]

Even Maher can’t stand a certain level of fraud.

[@ChryssaEvans]

Let Israel protect its homeland.

[@AllBlacksNZ]

Great episode - thanks!

[@stevenhuffman9032]

How exactly are you polling Palestinians?

[@dr.g3860]

I'm sure he's talking about a recent poll released by the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research (PCPSR orالمركز الفلسطيني للبحوث السياسية والمسحية). It's a Palestinian research organisation and think tank based in Ramallah. They are often cited in the news and they have their own website.

[@edthewave]

Dyson sucks more air than the vacuums that share his namesake...

[@cbs63]

Love Israel. Such a crazy, vibrant, creative, fascinating country. Keeping them on the front page of the news makes them stronger and helps them continue to improve and lead in so many important industries. Their water science, archeology, hi tech, medicine, and literature is amazing.

[@gershonperry5952]

The leaders of Hamas have also accumulated billions of dollars for themselves. Also, the numbers are from Hamas sources even if if some call it the ministry of health because it is still hamas.

[@HR-op2cq]

It's quite annoying the way you do it. Let us listen to the whole exchange and then say your piece

[@MrInfinite43]

Dont watch it then, go find the original. This is a commentary to the show

[@neilrichardson7454]

​@@MrInfinite43😂😂😂don't be so honest

[@shrimpie202]

It is frightening that this man writes for the NYT and is unable to understand the conflict . Worse he conflates the black issue in the US with middle eastern politics. Eric … DEI is really bringing our country down …

[@josephineolshaske4920]

There is a video out there showing a Palestinian selling a Jewish Captive to a Hamas soldier.

[@michaelattia9834]

It is the West Bank of Palestine, NOT Judea and Samaria.

[@dr.g3860]

It's the West Bank of the Kingdom of Jordan. 🇯🇴

[@anonymanonym4900]

The GazaArabs did ignore a basic fact: Actions have Consequences! Basic truth since Adam and Eve. Did they honestly believe that Israel will just sit there and sing a song in response to such a massacre? Total misjudgment hence you now must live with the consequence dear GazaArabs.

[@TheSingofKwords]

Isn’t this all just a radical “ the world’s most peaceful religion” thing? .

[@therichardgravesgroup4747]

I don't agree with Dyson but I think your approach to him personally is unnecessarily dismissive. Dismissive. I think he and a lot of Americans are genuinely concerned about how Benjamin Netanyahu is proceeding and what other motivations he has. I do think that Dyson makes a few false equivalences, but I think it's going to far to say that he is being untruthful when he says he's not anti-semitic.

[@kuruman1]

Dyson is DEI personified. If he was white we would never have heard of him.