Christian asks "Why Can't God Have a Son?" With Dr. Abdullah Ali

Answer to a Christian Challenge: Why Can Mary Have a Son Without A Consort but God Cannot? binhamidali.co...
Follow Dr. Abdullah Ali @BinhamidAli
What the Pro-Palestinian Campus Protests Are Really About by Carl R. Trueman www.firstthing...

[@arbitScaleModels]

The West has an anthropomorphic view of God because the West is a direct descendant of the Roman Empire in terms of law, theology, philosophy and politics.. The writers of the Gospels were Greek Romans, not Semitic monotheists.

[@mc-x4l]

The term "son of God" exists in the Old Testament too

[@arbitScaleModels]

@@mc-x4l Yes, as in all good people are sons of God.

[@PakTurut-rj6we]

​@@arbitScaleModels Is it gender discrimination to exclude daughters of God?

[@arbitScaleModels]

@@PakTurut-rj6we The objectification of God leads to racial and gender discrimination, among many other errors including racial superiority.

[@bouncyhunta]

@@mc-x4lso Jesus was one of many then lol. Has the trinity turned into a thousand in one now lol.

[@lynnfaulkner2706]

Today, in the company of two beautiful Muslim friends, I took my Shahbahda. Although i have a great deal to learn, (as i will for the rest of my life), i believe with all my heart that this is a wise and good decision. Please pray that I will be led to righteous teachers - as I know John is. The nearest Mosque would be 200 miles away, and this channel is indispensable.

[@siraji23]

Do as much research on Islam as possible and learn the Quran and observe 5 daily prayers and ask Allah to keep you steadfast in His straight path.congrats and welcome to Islam

[@fromhersanctuary]

Congratulations! This channel truly is a gem. I also recommend The Muslim Lantern and Basira Education (the latter has been invited on this channel).

[@maruf2050]

Allahu Akbar. May Allah keep us steadfast on the straight path. Please contact Muslim lantern or Hamza's den. They can guide you.

[@rajababy2009]

you should also follow the Muslim lantern and one message foundation channels as well they have good content

[@cc-cy]

Big mistake @lynn. .you doubt already ..you will be led to lake of fire🔥unfortunately.

[@karimb972]

I love this Cheikh and Paul great as always. Listening while working you make work much better. BarakAllahou fikoum

[@karimb972]

"Something to offend everyone " 😂 Alhamdoullilah!!😄

[@miscgar9663]

1. only Jesus showed mercy to his enemies wheras muhammad killed bad people 2. Only Jesus was persecuted for his good whereas muhammad was like Don and every Don has an end. 3. Jesus christ told to give charity and pay taxes to your government Whereas muhammad wanted more money and power so he took taxes by throwing off the rulers 4. Jesus christ didn't curse humans , he cursed the spirit ofSatan however muhammad cursed men he didnot like. 5. Jesus christ was born of Virgin Mary, so he was Holy whereas muhammad was born of sinful human nature 6. Jesus showed his love by sacrifice himself for human friendship wheras muhammad took blood of others. 7. Jesus was Holy and healed many , raised dead men showing his power of love wheras muhammad had no such power of love. 8. Jesus controlled the nature such as wind and seas wheras muhammad had no divine powers 9. Jesus was divine and Holy fasted 40 days without food and water whereas muhammad fasted intermittently 10. Jesus was raised to heaven and will come back wheras muhammad was dead.

[@التكنلوجياالعسكرية]

mashAllah Ustad Paul is excellent in inviting excellent guests.... Excellent ❤

[@intannera30]

Assalamualaikum, everyone. Jumuah Mubarak. May this discussion bring many benefits for Muslims to strengthen faith

[@davepugh2519]

Why does faith need 'strengthening'? It's either true or not.

[@spatel353]

Great convo - Jzk again Paul for another great upload. I found it striking how simple, elegant, and coherent the prophet's responses were regarding the same questions being asked today: "Have you seen a son that doesn't resemble his father?"

[@irfanahmed6411]

Dear brother Paul Allah bless you are doing great work on this planet and we love

[@abdurrazzak2970]

May Allah Bless and Reward Both of you in this Life and in the Hereafter.

[@jokpomlommk-lx5gl]

@abdurrazzak2970 allah cant do anything,nor curse,nor bless anyone,he isnt even able to have a son...

[@bernadettetormey4452]

Salaams, brother Paul and thank you. Something interesting to watch later ❤

[@BloggingTheology]

wa alaikum assalam

[@Lanalogic-n3x]

Brother Paul you should ask Christians if Jesus did create his mom and made her pregnant by him with his father at the age of 7 years is that logical cuse this will make millions of questions they can't answer .. also who did moses spoke to the trinty or Jesus or who ?? ​@BloggingTheology

[@doneracer5994]

​@@Lanalogic-n3x @user-pu1cx4ig2s You are correct. I have millions of questions for you to answer. You wrote, "if Jesus did create his mom and made her pregnant by him with his father". No, that is not what the New Testament says. *Rather, your comment is a similitude of what the Koran says:* *“And when said Allah, “O Isa, son (of) Maryam! Did you say to the people, “Take me and my mother (as) two gods from besides Allah?”* Obviously, the Koranic 3some is that Allah had sex with Maryam and they had a baby they named Isa who they took as the 3rd Allah. This must be the Trinity since this is in the Koran. Correct? Since that combo is clearly nowhere in the New Testament, was Allah drinking when he said it? Absent-minded? Or maybe he couldn't read Greek? Or maybe this is what it says because illiterate Mohammad wrote the Koran? *I truly look forward to your comments and answers here since these ayahs have always perplexed me. So thanks in advance of your scholarly answers.*

[@thetruthnothingbutthetruth1]

@donracer5994 The Quran does not say Allah had relations with Mary but it is the bibles blasphemous verse John 3:16 that claims the Christian god begot a son with Mary even though that has been taught for centuries it has been thrown out for being a fabrication or lie.

[@doneracer5994]

@@thetruthnothingbutthetruth1 What?? In Koran 5:116 Allah says: 👉 *“And when said Allah, “O Isa, son (of) Maryam! Did you say to the people, “Take me and my mother (as) two gods from besides Allah?”* This is in your own Koran so I ask you why does it say "...two gods *FROM* besides Allah"? 19:17 reads "She placed a screen (to screen herself) from them; then *We sent her our angel,* and *he appeared before her as a man in all respects".* 👉Either Allah or the angel-man Jibril is the father of Isa. Either way, Jibril forced himself upon Maryam (he raped her) and got her pregnant, or Allah[ *We* ] got her pregnant. 👉*So please explain these verses and tell me who is the father of Isa?* according to the Koran. 👉And when you answer this[☝] question, please show me in the Holy Bible where Almighty GOD the Father had sex with the human woman Mary. *“God so loved the world that He gave His one and only Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish but have eternal life.”* John 3:16 Amen!

[@harbisulub]

Amazing host as usual. May Allah bless you both

[@Finnalychangedmyname]

I always used to see ur tweets and I randomly stumbled on ur channel, now I got alotta catching up to do

[@RosewiththornsRWT]

Asalamalaikum. A pleasure listening to Dr. Ali. Thank you, Paul 👍

[@BabaBobo-j8j]

The Christian idea of the Trinity is mind boggling! I tried to understand it from different angles but I always end up with ERROR! Like a calculator when you try to devide a number over zero!

[@jokpomlommk-lx5gl]

is it mind boggling for u that allah prays to someone(chapter 33:56) yet muslims keep insisting theres only one allah in islam?

[@jokpomlommk-lx5gl]

also,theres nothing illogical about 1x1x1 being 1

[@alphauno6614]

@@jokpomlommk-lx5gl That’s a lie. Stop deceiving. This is the work of the devil.

[@goldnapoleon3564]

@@jokpomlommk-lx5gl 1x1x1would mean there the same being z,yet they have different attributes , have different levels of depandacy

[@goldnapoleon3564]

@@jokpomlommk-lx5gl that verse talks about Allah sending blessings to Muhammad not praying . Tasfir is free

[@muslimresponse103]

hindu: why cant god be a cow? there is your answer christians!

[@saidhashi2856]

😂😂😂 I like that.

[@Truth-Is-a-Hard-Pill]

Or an Elephant or a Monkey 👍 Why limit God?

[@Truth-Is-a-Hard-Pill]

@UCHIHAVEGETA-wo4sb The Muslims also stand on top of the Kaaba. It's like you standing on the head of your God Jesus with the h-e-a-d of your God Jesus under your f-e-e-t

[@saidhashi2856]

@UCHIHAVEGETA-wo4sb You make No sense; there is clear difference btwn scriptural arguments and online trolling. The 7 pebbles you talk of are just meant as symbolism or embodiment of the journey taken by Abraham when he was asked to sacrifice his son Ismael, satan wanted to dissuade him from carrying out the task and whenever satan appeared to him Abraham took pebbles and threw at him. Muslims recreate the scene by throwing similar pebbles at a hill in Makka during Hajj festival as a symbolic action and that is rejection of Satan's commands and obeying God. But would a person like you, devoid of scriptural understanding ever reflect and understand??

[@saidhashi2856]

@UCHIHAVEGETA-wo4sb You have Not said anything new so far, you are just repeating same rubbish that online crazy missionaries repeat all the time, with No facts or logic. It also seems that you are confused the black stone at the kaaba with the 7 pebbles muslims thraw at satan during hajj. The Two are Not same by the way. Just copy pasting rubbish which you don't even understand, will make u look quite the stupid.

[@saracentiano]

Amazing!

[@Aljuhani16]

الله يكتب اجرك المحظوظ والله الي يترك الكبر والعناد ويحاول يفكر ثم يهتدي للصراط المستقيم

[@ITBD-c2s]

انت لو تفكر، لماذا يطلب الهك من البشر الجهاد والقتل تحت ذريعة الدفاع عن النفس، او ليس هو من يجب ان يخطف الارواح عندما يريد ؟ صحيح، الشيطان لا يقدر على خطف الارواح بل يحرض على القتل لخطفها، ولكن الهك لماذا يحرض على القتل ما دام قادر على خطف الارواح وحده متى اراد ؟؟؟

[@Aljuhani16]

@@ITBD-c2s هو إلهي وإله العالمين. الله لو اراد ايضا لهدى الناس جميعهم ثم ادخلهم الجنة لايوجد شيء لايستطيعه الله فهو خالق الكون والخلق كله، ولكن ترك للانسان (الاختيار) فاختار ادم ان ياكل من الشجرة رغم تحذير الله. اخي تظن ان لديك اسئلة قوية وحجج عظيمة ع الاسلام وجميعها، وانا اقولها ( جميع اسئلتك التي تعلمها والتي ستاتيك بالمستقبل ) قدم تم الاجابة عنها والرد عليها. لكن ان كنت انت فعلا تريد الحق وفهم سبب وجودك ولست فقط تبحث عن المعاداة فعليك الاستماع للاجوبة بقلبك ليس فقط اذنيك. يوجد موقع لابن باز ومقاطع للعثيمين وابن باز واحمد السيد قد تساعدك. بالتوفيق.. سادعي لك ان شاء الله

[@BasedAkhi854]

An Hour of excellent education and as always happy to see sir paul again. 🇵🇸 #Freepalestine

[@mymore195]

*I feel sorry for those serious Christians who are misled....* *May Allah guide them.*

[@saidhashi2856]

Quran 19:88-94 They claim: “The Most Compassionate Lord has taken a son to Himself.” Surely you have made a monstrous statement. Whereby the heavens are almost torn, and the earth is split asunder, and the mountains fall in ruins, That they should invoke a son for (Allah) Most Gracious. It does not befit the Most Compassionate Lord that He should take a son. There is no one in the heavens and the earth but he shall come to the Most Compassionate Lord as His servant.

[@Bobby-xr4bo]

We don’t Claim God has taken a Son to himself at all though.. that’s a Lie.. Jesus is the Word Made Flesh.. as John 1:1 teaches us.. In the beginning was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God.. then John 1:14 the Word became Flesh and made his dwelling among us.. the Son was always God just as the Father was God..

[@saidhashi2856]

@@Bobby-xr4bo Act_13:33 God hath fulfilled the same unto us their children, in that he hath raised up Jesus again; as it is also written in the second psalm, Thou art my Son, this day have I begotten thee. According to Paul Jesus was begotten/appointed as 'son of God' at his resurrection. The idea of pre-existence was later Christian invention; mainly in the book of John. Mark was different in that he thought Jesus was adopted as 'son of God' at his baptism. Like all things Christian, they are contradicting lies and forgeries often by competing authors.

[@Bobby-xr4bo]

@@saidhashi2856 begotten doesn’t mean appointed..it means generated by procreation. It’s the past particle of the verb beget which means to father or produce offspring. So already you have shown me a lie from the Quran. Contradicting lies? Are you sure you want to make your stand on that hill? Shall we go through the contradictions in the Quran? I think you need to study what your Quran says about the Gospels and the Torah

[@timetraveler2026]

@@Bobby-xr4bo OF WHICH OF THE 45 000 DENOMINATIONS OF CHRISTIANITY ARE YOU????? AND WHICH OF THE 3,142 versions of the Bible do you read?

[@Bobby-xr4bo]

@@timetraveler2026 I am not a part of any denomination. I am a Catholic.. a member of the True Church.. Started by Jesus Christ on St Peter.

[@humayunkabir9279]

If jesus was son of god nauzubillah , 1. who was running the universe between Good Friday and easter Sunday. 2. You mean to say that god has no strength to kill those jews who killed them . 3. You mean to say nauzubillah that jews are more powerful than god. Ponder , dont inherite what your elders said. Learn your religion. May allah give us wisdom to understand and practice true Islam Ameen

[@suhailnoor6898]

They believe jesus is one part of god, so the father was sustaining the world when he died.

[@MasudFahim-h2i]

​@@suhailnoor6898what is the Arabic meaning of ISA name

[@suhailnoor6898]

@@MasudFahim-h2i Its not an arabic name

[@MasudFahim-h2i]

@@suhailnoor6898 it's Hebrew name

[@Troc313]

How can Christians believe that God created Adam from Clay but can't create Jesus. Not comprehending that the creation of Jesus is a miracle itself.

[@waterfallandwater]

Salam brother paul i have question please answer, Jews say if they are wrong then why did zechariah write this prophecy that will happen in end time zechariah 14:16 and zechariah 8:23 ,Jews quote this prophecy and say they are in right religion ,i want you to explain this prophecy and what is meaning of this prophecy , and what is this prophecy meaning according to Islamic perspective, personaly i want Dr Ali ataie explain this prophecy and it's proper meaning thank you!!!

[@doneracer5994]

Wow! A great question!

[@adamaourara2942]

In the book of zechariah, I believe chapter 8 or 9 onwards is written in the 5th century.

[@doneracer5994]

@@adamaourara2942 More like fifth to third centuries *BCE.* As for Zechariah, There are reasons why chapters 9-14 were combined with 1-8: 1- Both sections speak of strange visions. 2- Both sections promise the future glory of Jerusalem. 8:20-23 speaks of all the worlds people coming to Jerusalem to seek Yahweh. Chapter 14 ends with all nations coming annually to Jerusalem to worship Yahweh and celebrate the Festival of Booths. 3- Both sections of Zechariah constantly quote early Scripture, reinterpret it, or allude to it.

[@abdelhadibs405]

May Allah bless you

[@suryaprakash72771]

It's high time Christians come to realise Jesus ain't God, part of God or equal to God.

[@nabilsayed4727]

I asked a Christian friend. Do you know the R.S.V. Bible? Yes, I do, He replied. I said, "What does R.S.V. stand for? He answered, "Revised Standard Version"! I asked: Does God's word need to be revised? My friend tried his best but failed to deliver an answer. I shared this incident online, and a guy from China told me that the revised text was the translation, not the original text. And I gladly said unto him. What about those deleted verses from The R.S.V. Bible? Matt 18:11 Matt 23:14 Mark 7:16 Mark 9:44 Acts 8:37 Mark 9:46 Mark 11:26 Acts 15:34 Mark 15:28 Luke 17:36 Acts 24:7 Luke 23:17 John 5:4 Acts 28:29 He also failed to deliver an answer.

[@lynnfaulkner2706]

I wish I could copy this for my own research, but YT doesn't allow it.

[@richardbradley1532]

How many different translations of the Quran into English are there?

[@nabilsayed4727]

@richardbradley1532 I think more than 30 different translation. But we have the original Arabic Quran as it was revealed 😁. Also in the daily 5 Prayers Muslims only should read the Arabic Quran. The translations are not Quran. But You guys have no original text and the translations of the Bible are considered the current original Texts.

[@richardbradley1532]

@nabilsayed4727 the Mormons have the original and perfect text of the Book Of Mormon as revealed by God. How does that help you?

[@nabilsayed4727]

@richardbradley1532 The Mormons have their own Bible which has more books than the current Bible you have Lets say KJV. Now if you believe that Mormons have the original Bible then you are accusing yourself of following a not complete Bible (KJV). lets remember Deuteronomy 4 : 2 You shall not add to the word that I command you, nor take from it, that you may keep the commandments of the Lord your God that I command you. What do you think? Who is following the not corrupted word of God you or the Mormons?

[@fromhersanctuary]

I am guilty of not knowing your guest 🙈 But I look forward to watching this!

[@mubarakabdi5990]

Brother Paul can you please bring in brother mustafa Briggs, it would be a great podcast.

[@MuslimLifeHackers]

May Allahﷻ guide us all to a deeper understanding of our faiths.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

I'm not Muslim but I appreciate your comments.

[@karimb972]

Salam aleykoum to both of you and jumua Mubarak. I have a question: in the time of prophet Jesus PBUH, he must have known that scripture was already corrupted. How did that mesh with his role as a prophet sent to the Jews and and an auxiliary question would be what about gentiles desire to join the monotheistic religion? Would they have the right to join the religion and how would that work in light of the fact that scripture sent to the Bani Israel was corrupted? JazakAllahou Khair

[@saidhashi2856]

We don't have concrete evidences or record on how Issa (Jesus) a.s dealt with none Jews who had desire to join his community; In my opinion as much as Prophets before Muhammad a.s were sent to specific regions and communities; I doubt wether they would have rejected anyone in the name of race or region. As all people have similar duties and responsibility to God. As for scripture corruption; isn't that the essence of sending a Messenger in the first place. That people must have neglected something or forgotten something or went astray hence God sends a Prophet to remind them, correct their beliefs and make clear what people must have corrupted. This was their major duty. Besides; corruption does not mean just changing words from their place, but it can also mean putting the wrong interpretation, or hiding truth from people.

[@victoremman4639]

Matt 10.5 "These twelve Jesus sent out with the following instructions: “Do not go among the Gentiles or enter any town of the Samaritans." Jesus (as) was a levy, torah keeper, like John the Baptiste : the Israel's sons are people focusing ONLY toward their own community. I gave you one verse, but there is many more in the gospel. Even Jesus said about the non jews they are pigs and dogs. The roman, paul of tarsus the leader, changed very deeply Jesus's gospel. About your other question, we have non clue. But for sure, Jesus beeing a Levy, he rejected pharisies creed, and he had nothing in relation with rabbism, born in the second century and with Moses Maimonide in middle age.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

I usually don't ask "why can't God have a son" because the relationship between God Himself and Jesus Christ is something beyond our comprehension. We probably won't understand it until Jesus returns. However i do ask myself "for what purpose did God send Jesus Christ to us?". He first came to the people of Israel. His teachings are beneficial for everyone. May God's mercy help us to understand the meaning of life and our purpose. Peace...

[@AbelOktavian]

There are things that can be explained with logic , "God cannot have a son" is one of them. Three so called Abrahamic faith , two of them do not believe God can have a son , two of them do not believe in a Trinity. "Beyond our comprehension" is not an answer to this . Job 25:4 [4] How then can man be justified with God? or how can he be clean that is born of a woman? Anyone who was born of a woman cannot be God or equal to God.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

​​@@AbelOktavian I appreciate your honesty and comments. Actually I agree with you that my perception of "beyond our comprehension" is certainly "not an answer" to the concept of Jesus being the "Son of God". I agree because I think the authors of the Gospels in the New Testament wrote "the Son" because it was the best way to explain the relationship between God and Jesus. A relationship between a father and a son is something special. However I personally don't believe that the word "Son" in reference to Jesus really captures the essence of the mystery regarding God Himself and Jesus. So the doctrine of Jesus being the "Son of God" was accepted as a logical explanation for this mystery. Unfortunately, the phrase seems to be confusing to many people and it's been debated for 2,000 years. So actually what I meant to say is that our limited human understanding of God's essence ( or Being) is beyond our comprehension. However Jesus often does refer to Himself as the "son of man" which I think has a strong correlation with the concept of "Son of God". Do I make any sense to you? I think a better way to express Jesus' relationship with God may be the word "Logos". A Greek word meaning "the word" and/or the wisdom of God. Since the Greek language was common 2,000 years ago, the word "Logos" may have been a better way for readers to understand God and Jesus. Additionally, Jesus was often referred to as "the Lord". I think if we consider the combination of the different words ( "Son of God", "Logos" and "the Lord" ), we can obtain a better idea of what the Gospel authors meant. So I actually accept your criticism and your logic. And I apologize for my poor way of explaining what I meant in my initial post. I'm no scholar and to be honest, I struggle myself with understanding the various interpretations of words which refer to Jesus. Obviously people back then used the word "prophet" in reference to "messengers" of God. Instead of concentrating on the words "Son of God", maybe it's better to simply understand Jesus' message. I think Jesus' message and teachings can help point to His identity or position with God. For me, I want to take more time to better understand Jesus' message and teachings. Because his teachings point to the Truth and the ultimate meaning of life. However I don't think we can fully grasp the ultimate meaning or purpose to this earthly life. What do you think? Have a good day and peace of God to you and your family .

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

​@@BuffaloPros Thanks. I definitely need God to "open" my eyes. I believe the life of Jesus opened my eyes when I was younger. But I was too self-centered and my sins began to close my eyes. I'm not seeking to understand everything. NO WAY! God is all-knowing and as a limited human being, I can only understand so much. But God is also all-merciful. And we all need His mercy. Too much hatred in this earthly world. So I appreciate your kind response. Peace of God to you and your family

[@AbelOktavian]

The Messiah, son of Mary, was no more than a messenger. ˹Many˺ messengers had ˹come and˺ gone before him. His mother was a woman of truth. They both ate food. See how We make the signs clear to them, yet see how they are deluded ˹from the truth˺! -Surah Al-Māʾidah, Ayah 75 They both are food , Sooner or later they would looking for a toilet or a bush , you can't help it , God does not defecate. See how Allah make the signs clear to you. There's a reason why God call the believers in the Quran as "people of reason"

[@itlupe]

I feel sad for this boy. he will be shocked when God says: "...I know you not." and casts him into utter darkness and pain forever.

[@withink5187]

May Allah reward you

[@GowthamN-y8z]

The Lord brought me forth as the first of his works,[c][d] before his deeds of old; 23 I was formed long ages ago, at the very beginning, when the world came to be. 24 When there were no watery depths, I was given birth, when there were no springs overflowing with water; 25 before the mountains were settled in place, before the hills, I was given birth, 26 before he made the world or its fields or any of the dust of the earth. 27 I was there when he set the heavens in place, when he marked out the horizon on the face of the deep, 28 when he established the clouds above and fixed securely the fountains of the deep, 29 when he gave the sea its boundary so the waters would not overstep his command, and when he marked out the foundations of the earth. 30 Then I was constantly[e] at his side. I was filled with delight day after day, rejoicing always in his presence, (Proverbs 3:22-30).

[@1GratefulSlave.]

Quran Chapter 21, Verse 26: And they say, "The Most Merciful has taken a son." Exalted is He! Rather, they are [but] honored servants. Quran Chapter 39, Verse 4: If Allah had intended to take a son, He could have chosen from what He creates whatever He willed. Exalted is He; He is Allah , the One, the Prevailing. Sahih International

[@Mk-xw1yj]

I didn't seriously expect a simple answer to this or even an acknowledgement. I conclude thus far that Muslims can't answer this objection to their claim that God CAN'T have a son. This is what I wrote the other day: God can have a son if he wants. The speaker points out that God is not a human. I think we all know that. Let's keep it simple. A son can ALSO be 1. an adopted son (the Quran now apparently states that adoption is not permitted: please explain why - adoption can be so wonderful). 2. a figurative son (like Ataturk is the father of Turkey and my neighbour is a son of Afghanistan). The Qur'an accepts the concept of a spiritual father or mother: "The Prophet is more worthy of the believers than themselves, and his wives are [in the position of] their mothers" Al-Ahzab verse 6. 3. a young man who is guided by a fatherly figure (yes, the word "fatherly" exists in many languages because a young person can feel very close to an older friend whom he respects to the point that the young man feels that he is loved as much as a son would be, or more so. Please realize that no religion can dictate how people feel.

[@jenniferjoseph5914]

If God has a son , why can’t God have a daughter? This is discrimination towards females S usual🤷.well explained .Thank you paul. God bless you always.❤😘✅

[@jokpomlommk-lx5gl]

@jenniferjoseph5914 actualy in islam its the other way around.allah discriminates males since allah have 3 daughters called al lat,al uzza,and manat,according to ancient arab pagan beliefs,yet he dont want a son. according to muslim sources muhammad even told to people to worshipp these "godesses" and said theyre mediators between them and allah,yet stupid muslims insist allah does not beget🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😆😅😅😂😅😆🤣😆 allah is too "majestic" to have a son,yet he have no problem with having offspring of weaker gender,thats right up his alley🤣🤣🤣😅😅😅😂😅😅

[@BenJS2]

It also comes down to the idea of Limited and Limitless. Allah swt is limitless and the creation, us, are limited. Limited also means dependence. Humans are limited because we depend on multiple things, for EX: air, water and food. We first have to acknowledge that God has given us a brain and wants us to understand him. People say that God can do anything but in reality he chooses not to. EX: God could lie to us be he will not lie to us because he wants us to understand him and if he would lie then trust will be broken. Logically, something can not be limited and limitless at the same time. Talking about Christianity, putting these limiting labels like father and son on something that is limitless is not logically sound. There is more to say on this topic but I will leave it at that to keep it simple.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

I'm not Muslim but I really like your comments. As a Christian believer, I also agree 100% that God is limitless and we humans are limited. I think that's one reason why we have such difficulties in understanding theological beliefs and even logic. Regarding the "limiting labels like father and son", you are correct. I think the Gospel narratives were authored by human beings who wanted to communicate in words that were part of the common-day language. Such as "Lord" and even "Logos". Unfortunately the phrase "Son of God" has been misunderstood and even the early Christians debated it's interpretation. I've sometimes wondered if God's logic is different from human logic. But that question seems to open up a can of worms. So I appreciate your honesty. Obviously, my understanding of things is very limited. So I tend to read ( and listen to ) various scholars, including scholars from Islam and Christianity. That's one reason I listen to Blogging Theology. Respectfully from Florida USA...

[@BenJS2]

@@johnbrzykcy3076 Thanks for your comment. I was Christian as well. I am now Muslim. There are a lot of commonalities between the two religions and the major difference is the divinity of Jesus and the idea of redemption. From an Islamic standpoint, the Bible was originally the word of God, but throughout time man has corrupted (changed) it. One small example is why are there different versions of the bibles with different numbers of books? If this book is truly from God you would want it to be consistent and without any changes. Another example I would like to convey is relating the gospels to a math textbook. We would want the credentials of the authors of the math textbook to have a background in mathematics right? We would not want the author to have a background in a different subject like English or have the authors being anonymous. As we look at the gospels, these authors are anonymous and have been named after the disciples of Jesus. Even among these books, there are vast differences and contradictions. Although one could say that these 4 books are different “eye witnesses”, would they really differ that much? Another topic is about the oneness of God. What is the first commandment? Do you think that Christians of today really believe and live this? There are also other videos on KZbin that convey the inconsistencies of Christianity and of the pagan roots of current day Christianity. At the end of the day we all want to understand the truth, no matter what religion it falls under. Feel free to ask questions to me or anyone because there are a lot of people willing to help you. May we all be guided to the unbiased truth iA.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

​​@@BenJS2 Greetings from Florida USA. I do appreciate your time and effort regarding your response. I can't refute your comments regarding the apparent lack of consistency in the Gospels. From historical traditions, most of Jesus' disciples were simple fishermen. But their apparent lack of credentials as authors of the Gospels doesn't necessarily negate the truthfulness of Jesus' teachings. I believe the Spirit of God was able to inspire each author to remember Jesus' life according to their personal experiences. Of course I need to understand the Islamic beliefs of salvation. So I'm planning to read the Quran and a good commentary on the Quran. I prefer the narrative style of writing, such as the Gospel stories. The stories in the New Testament provide guidance to understand Jesus' life. I hope I can also be guided to understand the meaning of the Quranic verses ( although it's written in a different genre and with a different purpose). Again, I hope I'm being sincere. My main problems are lack of motivation to study and lack of scholarly ability. Plus I'm getting old ( hahaha ). I do try to respect people of different religions although sometimes I question the differences between religions ( and the reasons for such differences ). Only God is all-knowing and He created each of us. Again, I appreciate your kind response. Peace of God to you and your family .

[@BenJS2]

@@johnbrzykcy3076 I respect your comment and understand because I talk to my Christian friends and they talk about having a relationship with Jesus, walking with Jesus. As Muslims we also believe in the teachings of Jesus and his miracles, (healing people etc). There is a saying that “You can not be a Muslim unless you believe in Jesus.” We respect Jesus highly as well. As for you wanting to know about salvation in Islam, This is an important concept. There may be slightly different ideas on this but they are generally all similar. When you are still alive, you can do tawba (which is sincere repentance). Feel free to look up tawba. Allah swt not only forgives your sins, he favors to cover this. This shows his mercy and Allah swt can also go even one step further and can turn your bad deed/sin into good. Allah swt is the most merciful. As for overall salvation to get to heaven/Jannah, People have the misconception of Islam in that it is only about good deeds and your actions that will get you to paradise. Yes, these good deeds and actions are important, as I would think in Christianity that one would want to do good deeds in this world as well. But at the end of the day, it is through Allah’s swt Rahma (his mercy) that we are granted paradise. If you look up this video on KZbin “none of you will enter paradise by his action”, It should be the first video that pops up and it is around 10 minutes, it is a clip of a bigger video of a khutbah (talk). The beginning of it is a little dramatic but it dies down a minute or so into the video. (you know how it is, people like to exaggerate the beginning of videos). There are multiple examples of Allah’s mercy but here is one more. sunnah.com/bukhari:3470 As Muslims we follow the Quran and Sunnah and hadith is part of the sunnah. This is from Bukhari which is the most authentic book of hadith. This also conveys the Rahma of Allah swt. He is the most forgiving, the most merciful. Some other channels on KZbin are “One message foundation” and “Sabeel Ahmed” (these are good channels but they can get a little repetitive after watching a lot of them). I don’t want to smother you with too many things, as I am sure you have a lot. Anyways, you being sincere is good and wanting to find out more is good too. There are a lot of people that have too much love for the dunyah (this world), This world is important but it will go by in a blink of an eye. If you are sincere and you pray to the creator (whoever it may be) this creator will guide you to the truth. Also researching is good but it is also good to talk to someone. If you have time feel free to visit a mosque by your house. Most of them should be friendly. (I am sure you know that there are friendly and not so friendly people of all types of groups.) Try to visit a bigger masjid because they may have better resources as well. (Friday may be the best day to visit, around 1pm-4pm as it is Jummah). As Muslims, our job is not to convert people. A Muslims job is to convey Islam through Dawah and at the end of the day it is up to Allah swt to guide an individual to Islam.

[@BenJS2]

@@BuffaloPros haq

[@enesyakac]

Imran Hossein is that kind of person, but because of other reasons. Just watch his interview with Dilly Hussein.

[@majidelmajdoul705]

Macha allah allahoe mabarak. The End of scam shampoo and godonlogic. Alhamdulilah

[@enmei__________]

Assalamualaikum. Can you tell us how you research please?

[@enmei__________]

Can someone comment this line too?

[@thetriumphsprint]

Isn't that a very broad question? Research what? If it's Islamic topics only, then primary source is the Qur'an, secondary sounds are the books of hadith, then the works of classical scholars, then the works of later scholars. If it's comparative religion, then all of the above plus sources from the other religion.

[@salahdin6382]

When He is never dying, why should He need a son ???

[@zee1din]

Salaam! You got a good point but we still have endless questions for Allah in regard to why Adam and Eve besides Hazrat Eesa/Jesus as a son supposedly assumed by some group anyway Jumma Mubarak

[@ridhuan2335]

the cristians need the son to complete the trimurti

[@NoumanKhan-pb4zk]

Jesus was not the son of God but only a True Messiah and Prophet of one TRUE GOD. He never abolished the law of GOD and the law of Moses. not even a single "JOT". it was Paul. Law is ONE. and God is ONE. Solomon advised his son that "Much study is the wearness of the flesh. fear God and keep his TEN Commandments. This is the duty of a Man". God is not the author of confusion. he never changed his WORD. the one TRUE Law from Adam to Muhammad(Pbu them all). which is only Monotheism. i don't know why the Christians are following Paul. instead of the original message of Jesus Christ(Pbuh).

[@Will-vp2yl]

Hi Brother Paul, Please make a Video about Zechariah 12 (Piercing God) and its implication on the Muslim Faith

[@MasudFahim-h2i]

Sahih bukhari hadith number 3477 prove Jesus Christ died on the cross

[@sofisamad7471]

Very good video title

[@Bobby-xr4bo]

Could one of you explain these passages from the Quran please.. 96:2 created man out of a mere clot of congealed blood 15:26 we created man from sounding clay, from mud moulded into shape. 3:59 the similitude of Jesus before Allah is that of Adam. He created him from dust then said to him”Be” and he was 19:67But does not man recall that we created him before out of nothing (Yusuf Ali). 16:4 He has created man from a sperm drop and behold this same man becomes a disputer.

[@victoremman4639]

The concept of God's son in hebrew tradition is not the one of the pagan christians. Aba is the one who deliver (commands) linguisticly, and Son is the reception of these commands. All Israel's son are Son of God, only if they are good recievers, obediant. The N of Bin expresses Unity, with the deliever. Linguistic makes collapse christians fantasias.

[@victoremman4639]

Semantic link between Naby and Bin.

[@mdsyedali7293]

Assalamu alaikum, God is not like Humans being, God not sleep, God is not any body. He is creator of infinity. He is not finite to have son. Dr syed

[@maruf2050]

Alhamdulillah for Islam

[@idrisali1672]

Double consciousness is troublesome.

[@jacqueline1752]

Would anyone be able to recommend a good concordance on The Quran? I have been researching Islam for a few months but would love to be able to read The Quran with the help of a good concordance. Right now it’s just ME trying to understand it.

[@TheMrZek]

If jesus is god why does he needs to born from a womb. If he's god he could simply descended straight from sky to earth let everyone to see this supernatural event. Question is can a female womb bear god which is supernatural in nature?

[@TemanM]

The Christian would say that he took on human form to be like us to get at our level. This way he is more forgiving and he knows us and hope you know how to respond when they say this.

[@ridhuan2335]

​@@TemanM that would imply that God doesnt know much about human if he doesnt become one. it also undermine the concept of prophets that have been sent. since christians also say, god is also 100% god while being a 100% human. it nulify the purpose of "being at the human level". Essentially it means, God failed to become a real Human since human has never and will never have that 100% God atribute. also, scripture doesnt support that claim until at least the NT.

[@TemanM]

@@ridhuan2335 Masha Allah perfect jazakallah khair

[@thetriumphsprint]

Perhaps with regard to protestors, there is a clear outrage with the ongoing G enocide, but also a recognition (finally) that the nakbah is also ongoing. Add to it the simple fact that western governments are materially supporting a state in the perpetration of the G enocide. If we then consider circles of concern and circles of influence, the protesters can see a direct link between the two. They can take their concern and directly influence entities like the universities they are studying in. Prior to the latest invasion of Gaza, people had concerns in the back of their minds, but after, with the stand their own governments took, it was seen that they had significant local influence and they used it. Free 🇵🇸

[@kidsteach938]

In places like California, in the free and fair West, we must say AlhamduLillah! that things are so free and fair that even agents of the state might enter our places of worship and encourage extreme speech, in attempts to discredit us.

[@yaasirshabudin4442]

We should say God DOES NOT and notGod CAN NOT. God DOES NOT beget nor is God begotten. Allah makes a statement that Allah WILL NOT ever set up partners to Himself nor birth Himself through a woman.

[@jokpomlommk-lx5gl]

if allah does not beget why ancient arabs before muhammad believed that allah have three daughters?and even in the quran(or hadith i cant remember) this is mentioned,they are mentioned by name even???

[@extraordinary.verses]

Allah said logically he can choose a son but again logically a created son. Early teachings: Coptic Church taught the Gospel's message according to Mark who believed that to gain eternal life one must bear witness that there is no God but the creator and that Jesus is the Messiah. First schism: During the 3rd century, some groups taught the Gospel’s message according to Arius and others according to Mark. Trinity was canonized in approx. 325. Second schism: Arius refused to sign the document of Osius, advisor to Constantine, which stated: * Acknowledging that there is only one God, Jesus Christ, to whom the divinity was transferred through the Father; * And that Jesus is an only-begotten Son, not a creation. *And has been around since ancient times. * And he cannot be changed or altered. * And that he is not just the will of God, but it is the actual existence of God!!

[@B1ackC3t]

Please invite Middle Nation speaker

[@malhamaulkubra4437]

Why can't god have daughters. Why not wives? Why not grandchildren? Why not a race of divine human family on the Earth? Why not Ganesha too says the Hindu?....

[@THESMARTERMAN555]

Qur'an 3:54 - And they cheated/deceived and God cheated/deceived, and God (is) the best (of) the cheaters/deceivers. God is the greatest of deceivers? Qur'an 7:99 - Did they secure God's scheme/deceit ? So no(one) trusts God's scheme/deceit except the nation the losers. Followers of Allah are the nations of losers? Qur'an 10:21 - And if We made the people taste/experience mercy from after calamity/disastrous distress touched them, then for them (is) cheatery/deceit/schemes in Our verses/evidences . Say: "God (is) quicker/faster (in) cunning/scheming , that Our messengers write what you cheat/ deceive/scheme." - Alah tells you it is lying to you? Abdullah says God is an it? Not once in the Koran does Allah refer to himself as an it? Allah says he sends his words in Arabic to be clear. So did Allah pick the wrong language, so this guy is lying or is Allah make a mistake? Abdullah says have you never seen a son that does not resemble his father? The Hebrew word for Son, literally means in the nature of the Father. It is understood, that Jesus is in the nature of the Father. Just as Jesus is the word of the Father, can you separate the word from God, or they are both God? Abdullah says you have to redefine God if God has a son? Is God capable of anything? Jesus says I am the first and the last, the Alpha and Omega which in Greek is the first and last letters of the alphabet. So Jesus Claims to be the same as the Father, which is God. He was not created. Abdullah says a Son can only resemble his father or mother. Jesus humbled himself as flesh, he is of the divine nature of the Father and the human nature of the mother Mary. The Quran says Jesus is born from a virgin birth, breathed life into a clay bird, spoke as an infant, healed the blind, and Allah cleared his name that is was not magic but of God. So how is he not God? Name one other person in the Quran or Bible who performs miracles like this? Abdullah says Allah is limited? Does that mean God aka Jesus could come down into the world in a limited capacity? Allah says there is no sin in heaven, all things are possible? God tells you to be a good person on Earth but allows you to be a devil in Heaven? You say you do not depict God on earth but what is the al-Hajar al-Aswad in Mecca? Does Allah says it is right hand? If you kiss the corners your sins shall be forgiven? A stone that existed before Muslims, and belonged to the pagan moon god worshipped by Arabs in the area. Aramaic word Alaha simply meaning God hundreds of years before Muhammad. Muhammad's own father worshiped the pagan moon god and his 3 daughters. Abdullah says we can not be made in the image of God? Genesis 1:27, which says, "So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them". Lol he panicked a little bit. Allah created Adam in His image, sixty cubits tall. Is Allah 60 cubits tall?, why are humans not 60 cubits tall? Why does the Quran tell you pray 3 or 4 times a day depending on interpretation. But the Hadiths tell you to pray 5 times a day? Did Allah forget the extra prayer? The Palestinian people are stuck in an awful position and I pray for them. They are stuck between an illegal democratic government of Palestine, a Terrorist group called Hamas that don't wear uniforms, hide in homes, schools, and hospitals. Then media cry when these building are destroyed, but it what they want to happen and the innocent people are murdered because they are stuck in a bad position. The Islamic people are performing on Genocide on Christians in over 6 countries at this time. Can Muslims pray in Israel and have Mosques? Can Christians or Jews have Churches in Palestine and can pray out in the open? I think not, I give it to the liars(Allah tell them to lie) they have good media propaganda. Why do Muslim countries not accept refugees, their own Muslim people? They know they are awful people, and will only bring suffering if they come. There is a lot of hypocritical Christians, but there is even more hypocritical Muslims. They do not even know their own book. If you ask them basic questions, they have to ask a Scholar. You would think that a book(the words from God) would really want to people to study its message. The Bible is written by men, the message means more than the verses, but the verses are important. Jesus tells you he is God, the witnesses tell you he is God, his actions/miracles show that he is God. And even then God gives us free will to worship him or not. Its your choice, in this life and the next. "Verily, I am commanded to worship Allâh (Alone) by obeying Him and doing religious deeds sincerely for Allâh's sake only and not to show off, and not to set up rivals with Him in worship. "If God had willed, He would have made you one community; but He leads astray whom He will, and guides whom He will; and will surely be questioned about the things you wrought." "By no means can anything befall us [his creatures] but what God has destined for us" No matter what you do in life, if you do not pray, if you Murder, if you lie, if you cheat, your life is pre destined. You are just a robot of Allah, and you will join him in Hell as soon as you are born according to the Quran. You all spent more time talking about Ben Shapiro then Jesus as the son of God. Find Jesus Christ, he is truth, the way, and the life. I am trying to save your souls through Jesus Christ, stop following an it, that puts you in hell as soon as you are born.

[@DesertVox]

I'm offended, affronted, appalled by the idea that we have to 'debate' simple truths. Like disproving 1+1+1=1, or God's son or daughter, or God's urination as part of his 100% humanity.. this bundle of logicidal ideas is so offending to me, and equally offending is the idea that so much 'intellectual debating' has to go into convincing the nurturally lobotomized victims of the irrationality of their bundle of blunders.

[@Bobby-xr4bo]

Can I ask you guys.. How did Allah create Man?

[@peterjohntrimnell5065]

Palestine 🇸🇩🇬🇧🇸🇩🇬🇧🇸🇩🇬🇧

[@sriekarnen5093]

MasyaAllah....

[@rashidbagewadi1006]

Then God will have gradson then there great grandchildren. Then children's children's then millions and billions of God in entire the world

[@Wakakakzi]

Sons and daughters are essential for the life of our species to exist on earth. We are not immortals and we are weak because we require children to support us and our children need our support when they are young. Having a son is a weakness which cannot be attributed to a self sufficient being. God does not require a son but we do as human species. Again, if the "son" was not born like a human child is born ( I am not talking about the birth of Jesus on the earth, which Christians accept was not when the son was born otherwise he'd not be eternal ) and if the essence of God is different to that of a man then why even call it a son? I mean we don't even call the offspring of animals sons. Every species has a different name for their offspring. If an automatic factory start making cars, do we call the cars sons of the factory? The reason is that the term son is loaded. The only explanation is the intentional distortion of the term by Christians. If someone calls you a son as a term of endearment, you don't automatically become heir to his property. That's the most ridiculous thing Christians have done but if you start doing something ridiculous, overtime people just merit your position but if you really think this has to be the most ridiculous thing ever said.

[@ahsannaseer8360]

❤

[@pursuingtruth13]

W

[@MrShah-l6d]

Love region Islam Quran namaz shokran Allah. Love all

[@islamicreel281]

السلام علیکم و رحمت اللہ برکاتہ

[@staffan144]

I don't think Christians ask that stupid question. God the Father is a Father by His Son.

[@staffan144]

And refering to Mary, you are not talking about Christians but catholics.

[@AbelOktavian]

John 20:17 [17] Jesus said, “Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father. Go instead to my brothers and tell them, ‘I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.’ ” He said "my Father & your Father" so his 'father' is not exclusive to him , his 'father' is your father too. Do I have to worship you as well ??? And he said his father is his God , so when he said "my Father" it simply mean "my God". Can God have a God ?? It's a yes or no question btw.

[@peterjohntrimnell5065]

Free Palestine 💚🖤❤

[@davepugh2519]

Why spend so much time discussing something that is obviously made up?

[@abnerasturias6380]

FOOLISHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH QUESTION !!!

[@gideonopyotuadebo2304]

ALL MEN ARE SONS OF GOD THE GODLY PEOPLE ARE THE FORE SONS OF GOD THE ALMIGHTY GOD YEHOVAH THE MOST HIGH Alone is God Alone is the most high Alone is the creator Alone is the saviour The sons of God Yehovah the most high are gods Yehovah the true God, the God of gods, the God of all above all in all. the most high God unto whom every kne must bow and all tongues shall swear (oath) alone is the God of his true sons who themselves are Gods God Yehovah the first and the last alone is the first and the last of his son's whom themselves are gods. God Yehovah the Lord of Lords, the Lord of all above all in all alone is the God of his son's who themselves are gods. God Yehovah alone is the husband, the spiritual husband of his people, his son's who themselves are gods. God Yehovah is the King, the King of kings, the King of all, the most high King, of his people, the King of his son's who themselves are gods. God Yehovah is the Lawgiver, the most high Lawgiver, the Lawgiver of lawgivers, the Lawgiver of his people, the Lawgiver of his son's who themselves are gods. God Yehovah is the Judge, the Judge of Judges, the Judge of all, the most high Judge, the Judge of his people, his son's who themselves are gods God Yehovah is the Father, the spiritual father, the most high father of his son's who themselves are gods. God Yehovah alone is the creator of his people, the creator of all, the begetter of his son's who themselves are gods. God Yehovah alone is the Saviour, the Saviour of Saviours, the Saviour of all, the Saviour of his people, his son's who themselves are Gods God Yehovah alone is the most high, the High of the highs, the most high of his people, his son's whom themselves are gods Antilaw anticovenant antiyehovah rebellious pagan Christianity is an ungodly idolatrous religion Psalm 82:1-2,6-8 ASV God standeth in the congregation of God; He judgeth among the gods. [2] How long will ye judge unjustly, And respect the persons of the wicked? Selah [6] I said, Ye are gods, And all of you sons of the Most High. [7] Nevertheless ye shall die like men, And fall like one of the princes. [8] Arise, O God, judge the earth; For thou shalt inherit all the nations. Exodus 12:12 ASV For I will go through the land of Egypt in that night, and will smite all the first-born in the land of Egypt, both man and beast; and against all the gods of Egypt I will execute judgments: I am Jehovah. Exodus 15:11 ASV Who is like unto thee, O Jehovah, among the gods? Who is like thee, glorious in holiness, Fearful in praises, doing wonders? Psalm 86:8 ASV There is none like unto thee among the gods, O Lord; Neither are there any works like unto thy works. Deuteronomy 10:17 ASV For Jehovah your God, he is God of gods, and Lord of lords, the great God, the mighty, and the terrible, who regardeth not persons, nor taketh reward. Psalm 136:1-3 ASV Oh give thanks unto Jehovah; for he is good; For his lovingkindness endureth for ever. [2] Oh give thanks unto the God of gods; For his lovingkindness endureth for ever. [3] Oh give thanks unto the Lord of lords; For his lovingkindness endureth for ever: Psalm 97:1,7,9 ASV Jehovah reigneth; let the earth rejoice; Let the multitude of isles be glad. [7] Let all them be put to shame that serve graven images, That boast themselves of idols: Worship him, all ye gods. [9] For thou, Jehovah, art most high above all the earth: Thou art exalted far above all gods. Psalm 96:4-5,8-10,13 ASV For great is Jehovah, and greatly to be praised: He is to be feared above all gods. [5] For all the gods of the peoples are idols; But Jehovah made the heavens. [8] Ascribe unto Jehovah the glory due unto his name: Bring an offering, and come into his courts. [9] Oh worship Jehovah in holy array: Tremble before him, all the earth. [10] Say among the nations, Jehovah reigneth: The world also is established that it cannot be moved: He will judge the peoples with equity. [13] Before Jehovah; for he cometh, For he cometh to judge the earth: He will judge the world with righteousness, And the peoples with his truth. Nehemiah 9:6 ASV Thou art Jehovah, even thou alone; thou hast made heaven, the heaven of heavens, with all their host, the earth and all things that are thereon, the seas and all that is in them, and thou preservest them all; and the host of heaven worshippeth thee. Psalm 95:3,6-8 ASV For Jehovah is a great God, And a great King above all gods. [6] Oh come, let us worship and bow down; Let us kneel before Jehovah our Maker: [7] For he is our God, And we are the people of his pasture, and the sheep of his hand. To-day, oh that ye would hear his voice! [8] Harden not your heart, as at Meribah, As in the day of Massah in the wilderness; Isaiah 44:6 ASV Thus saith Jehovah, the King of Israel, and his Redeemer, Jehovah of hosts: I am the first, and I am the last; and besides me there is no God. Isaiah 64:8 ASV But now, O Jehovah, thou art our Father; we are the clay, and thou our potter; and we all are the work of thy hand. Isaiah 43:15 ASV I am Jehovah, your Holy One, the Creator of Israel, your King. Isaiah 54:5 ASV For thy Maker is thy husband; Jehovah of hosts is his name: and the Holy One of Israel is thy Redeemer; the God of the whole earth shall he be called. Isaiah 33:22 ASV For Jehovah is our judge, Jehovah is our lawgiver, Jehovah is our king; he will save us. Isaiah 43:11 ASV I, even I, am Jehovah; and besides me there is no saviour. Hosea 13:4 ASV Yet I am Jehovah thy God from the land of Egypt; and thou shalt know no god but me, and besides me there is no saviour. Psalm 47:2,6-8 ASV For Jehovah Most High is terrible; He is a great King over all the earth. [6] Sing praises to God, sing praises: Sing praises unto our King, sing praises. [7] For God is the King of all the earth: Sing ye praises with understanding. [8] God reigneth over the nations: God sitteth upon his holy throne. Psalm 83:18 ASV That they may know that thou alone, whose name is Jehovah, Art the Most High over all the earth.

[@saifsaad201286]

The word ( aravi ) is ( alavi ) they are the Levites themselves. these jews are just a religious sect, not an origin, and not a race. The Arabs are the original,

[@sunrise8015]

Hey Paulie, did you ever hear of asexual reproduction ? Did you know The first forms of life reproduced asexuallly, e.g. an amoeba splits itself to form a child. As the full biological mass comes from a single parent therefore the child is an identical clone of the parent. As the mass is the same the child is also the same age as the parent. How would Jesus Christ explanation this phenomenon to mankind 2000 yrs ago in simple words. In John 10:30 Jesus Christ claims this equal identity with the Father. John 8 he claims identity and age of the Father. John 14:9 Jesus tells Phillip if you have seen me you have seen the Father in heaven. again claiming identity of God. God is Spirit the only way he can have a child is asexuallly without a spouse and Jesus Christ is the child Spirit of God who took human form in the virgin womb of a woman. You guys belive in a flying horse like burak and don't belive what the Quran confirms the virgin birth and calls Jesus the Spirit of God.

[@Sonofthe1655]

Two so called educated men using words they have no understanding of nor their roots the word God is an old English incantation from the 6th century derived from the proto Germanic word gudan meaning to invoke, to call upon a higher power taken from the Christian Codex Argenteus 4th century the Aramaic word for power is El Elohim the plural El Elyon means most high power. Babylon meaning gate of Elyon Baba in Aramaic meaning gate Tower of Babel is David's Tower near Jaffa gate babel meaning door of El bab Arabic meaning door. The word Heaven means to heave upwards like the piece of offering at the sacrificial Altar that was reserved for the High priest, called a heave offering. Immanuel meaning El in man we are light beings vibrating in a low frequency existence the water in our bodies is in a crystalline structure that creates fractal energy discovered in the trans-universal void otherwise known as dark energy out of the darkness cometh the light the cells in our bodies create light photons that send and receive coded messages the pineal gland is made up of piezoelectric crystals it has antenna like hairs covering it many call it our minds eye I refer to it as my built in crystal radio set tuned into the creator it creates our dark matter melatonin mela affixed to meaning black, dark, and our serum serotonin both essential for our physical and spiritual well-being. Over time it can become calcified drastically reducing the creation of both. If thy eye be clear then the whole body is in light but if thy eye be cloudy then body is in darkness, mephilim meaning cloud people or fallen ones nephos Greek meaning cloud. We are created in our creators likeness as within so without as below so above. You're problem is you both think in the flesh. The word atom in Aramaic is Adamah the feminine of Adam. El Elyon in everything and everything in El Elyon. We are fractal parts of the whole. Everything exists from the word. We are miraculous events in time and space we were all present at the moment of creation. You are the epitome of the blind leading the blind. You seek to shackle the creator. You live in fear fear has a low frequency of 5 hz anything lower than 16 hz is harmful for us love has a frequency of 528hz the closest tangible thing to love is Hibiscus Syriacus the rose of Sharon at 320 hz. You forget El walked with Adam in the garden in the cool evening air, He spoke with Kane and marked his forehead, Enoch was taken up to zion by the creator. All three truths you ignore to prove yours and others vain imaginations of what the creator is or isn't capable of doing, the old English word for love is lief so stop being doubting Thomas's and just be-lief. All three Abrahamic faith systems have roots in Zoroastrianism from the 2nd millennium BCE of the Sasanian empire their three golden tenants were good thoughts, good words and good deeds. Try it sometimes

[@VindensSaga]

How is islam true, how does one prove that Islam is the true religion of God?

[@AbelOktavian]

Read the book , study the religion , talk to a Muslim & come to the Mosque , asking random people in KZbin comment section is not a very good place to start.

[@bubbag8895]

Muslims think YHWH can't have a son? (his definition uses human, I don't interpret the Bible to require any of YHWHs children to be human, we will become Sons of God soon, now we are only sons of men. Yeshua is the unique Son of YHWH.) Where do they think Djinn come from? Do they disregard the Old Testament?

[@chekov8852]

The father of jinn was taranus. Go and read islamic books like al bidaya wan nihaya(the beginning and the end)

[@thetriumphsprint]

​@@chekov8852 what are you talking about? I looked up taranus and the closest I got was taranis. "Taranis was the Celtic god of thunder and lightning. He was worshipped in areas inhabited by Celtic peoples, such as the British Isles, France, and Spain. As a storm god, Taranis had domain over the heavens and could bring about bad weather" What do the Celts have you do with jinn? Go read such and such a book, you say.

[@thetriumphsprint]

Your interpretation is clearly wrong and against Christian doctrine. All the prophets were human. Some, like David were "begotten son". Doctrine days that Jesus was human. Doctrine also says he is divine but that was a source of much debate amongst the early churches. Yeshua isn't that unique. Adam had no father or mother. Melchizedek had no genealogy, no father or mother not end of days. Anyway, the Jews would disagree with you as they would consider themselves alone to have this "son" relationship, not us goyim.

[@Mel-w8h]

We humans will never become like God, nothing close. Didn't St.Michael the Archangel in the battle in heaven say, "who is like unto God?" When Lucifer (Satan) refused to bow down to the creation of Adam.

[@chekov8852]

@@thetriumphsprintjust read history of jinn in that book and also there are other islamic books as well. There were not only jinn but also other creatures like hinn, binn etc on this planet before humans. That book has some unauthentic narrations but they aren't 100% wrong they are just ambiguous. The book is accepted by all schools of thought in sunni islam

[@Pasham38]

Have you never seen a cat gave birth a wolf? If Jesus was son of God, nobody could catch him and crucified. Because he supposed to have God features, he could run away, fly to sky or destroy them. Jesus was a human like other prophets. Nothing more

[@doneracer5994]

You know they're desperate when they take almost an hour to explain their answer.

[@AbelOktavian]

You know they're desperate when they always say "Just believe , don't ask question"

[@doneracer5994]

@@AbelOktavian I know that is true. I have yet to have any of my questions about Islam and the Koran answered.

[@doneracer5994]

@@BuffaloPros No. Because muslims cannot answer my questions since to try to do so proves how little of the Koran is true.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

​@@doneracer5994 I'm a simple Christian believer but I've been considering to read the Quran. So far from listening to Blogging Theology ( over 2 years ), I'm confused by some Quranic verses. What do you suggest? It sounds like you've spent lots of time in reading the Quran? I'm open-minded but I need to be careful. Thanks. God bless...

[@doneracer5994]

@@johnbrzykcy3076 Hi, John. I just addressed your previous comment to me when I saw and read your newest one. I would be glad to try to help you in any way I can. If you would like to read what I may have found regarding some Koranic verses, please list them and I will try to address them from a Christian perspective. Some Koranic verses are similar or the same as verses in the Bible and it is enlightening to read and compare them. But there are those which are confusing as well, so I resort to several Islamic commentaries. And just so you know who I am, I am an Evangelical Christian, 70 years old who was born-again in Christ when I was 35, half my lifetime ago. I have always been interested in studying and comparing religions and their texts. Islam, the Jehovah Witnesses, Judaism and the Mormons have interested me. If you want to know more about me, or ask me any questions, please do so. May God's peace be upon you and your house-

[@ElizabethGordon-lh1um]

Ask your self ,am l gay ,if so ,you con not ,let say do l have a woman,am wife,if not ,there is no hope for a child ,now it take a female an a male,to creat a baby, this is my begotten son, from one to nadder ,ask your self ,con a man become pregnant,,why hate woman, father in the son ,son in the father , guy's listen to your self talking .from nothing to something,what god connot do,kno ,is not god . just image ,the world doom day

[@yasinozt40]

Fiiiiiirst

[@sparephone8228]

According to Mufit Abu Laythe, he says the Qur’aan never states that Jesus[pbuh] was born of a virgin woman.

[@JamalAdam455]

@@sparephone8228 he lied than

[@sparephone8228]

Where in the Qur'an is Mary described as 'virgin' ?

[@JamalAdam455]

@@sparephone8228 قَالَتْ أَنَّىٰ يَكُونُ لِى غُلَـٰمٌۭ وَلَمْ يَمْسَسْنِى بَشَرٌۭ وَلَمْ أَكُ بَغِيًّۭا ٢٠She wondered, “How can I have a son when no man has ever touched me, nor am I unchaste?” She declared in the Quran that no man has touched when she talked with god she was definitely saying the truth

[@sparephone8228]

I agree that's one interpretation, like most Muslims and Christians believe in. But is that what the Qur'an is really saying? Could it be that despite what Mary said, God would bring about the circumstances that would allow her to have a child just like any other women, i.e. Through normal physical relationship? Is there historical evidence that Jesus had brothers?

[@JamalAdam455]

@@sparephone8228 there's no good evidence that Jesus even existed let alone him having brother plus it's clear in both Islam and Christianity that Marry is definitely a virgin

[@Faisalbinomar-qx9yx]

Jesus - feature from various/vector activity with Intelligence from signal by utilize of signal. V/R = I Assalamualaikum

[@richardbradley1532]

God could have a son. That much is obvious. He just doesn't for obvious reasons.

[@richardbradley1532]

@@BuffaloPros no creator, no creation, no issue.

[@richardbradley1532]

@@BuffaloPros not really

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

​@@BuffaloPros I like when you said, "A Creator is closer than a father".

[@richardbradley1532]

@@BuffaloPros logic is logic. Hearts pump blood. Two completely different things.

[@richardbradley1532]

@BuffaloPros nothing to do with happiness. Just logic.

[@doneracer5994]

The Answer is in John 1: 9-14: *The true Light, which gives light to everyone, was coming into the world. He was in the world, and the world was made through Him, yet the world did not know Him. He came to His own, and His own people did not receive Him. But to all who did receive Him, who believed in His Name, He gave the right to become children of God, who were born, not of blood nor of the will of the flesh nor of the will of man, but of the Will of God.* *And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us, and we have seen His Glory, Glory as of the Only Son from the Father, full of Grace and Truth.* And if you choose to not understand this, then I will pray for you. In the Most Glorious Name of Jesus-

[@AbelOktavian]

Job 25:4 [4] How then can man be justified with God? or how can he be clean that is born of a woman? Anyone who was born of a woman cannot be God. Cope

[@ridhuan2335]

Everyone knows where christians get the Idea. The question is, why people need to care and apply Harry Potter in their way to salvation. The origin of those bible verses are Questionable. Why trust it for salvation? who wrote it? Is it the disciples? scholars say, the authors are not known. why trust them? even harry potter's author is known.

[@doneracer5994]

​@@ridhuan2335 1 of 3 I'm glad you commented to me since I am seriously looking for answers about the story of Isa as stated in the Koran: *“And when said Allah, “O Isa, son (of) Maryam! Did you say to the people, “Take me and my mother (as) two gods from besides Allah?”* --> Obviously, Allah says he had sex with Maryam and she had a baby they named Isa, who Allah says is the third person in the Koranic trinity along with Allah and Maryam. Correct? The trouble is that this trinity is nowhere in the New Testament. So why did Allah not know that his trinity is not the Trinity of Christianity? This leads us to consider the Koran's story of the birth of Isa: *19:17** reads "She placed a screen (to screen herself) from them; then We sent her our angel, and he appeared before her as a man in all respects".* --> My question is, why on earth does the text say, *as a man in all respects* or *as a well-proportioned man* ? Why it was important that Jibril was morphed into a *man in all respects?* To the reader, it is obvious that Jibril was going to have sex with her regardless of her saying "NO!" So what do your scholars make of this since she then said, ‘I seek the Lord of Mercy’s protection *against you:* if you have any fear of Him *[do not approach]!’* ? --> Honestly, Allah makes Jibril into a man and since we all know what happens between “a well-proportioned man” and a woman when the man insists on having his way and afterwards takes her to a remote location, away from people. --> *Are you aware that Jibril sounds just like a common rapist in today's news?*

[@doneracer5994]

@ridhuan2335 2 of 3 BUT--- *"He said, “Surely I am only a Messenger of your Lord to bestow upon you a most cleansed son.”* And Maryam says *“How shall I have a son, seeing that no man has touched me, and I am not unchaste?”* He then says,, *“Thus (it will be). Your Lord has said, Simple is it for Me, and that We may make him a sign for mankind and a mercy from Us, and it is a Command decreed.”* *So she conceived him, and she withdrew with him to a remote place.* --> WHAT!?! Maryam tells him "NO!" but he tells her he is going to use his "man in ALL respects" (whether she likes it or not-) to get her pregnant because Allah commanded it. Really? Maryam is unmarried, and while Allah says "Simple is it for me", it's not simple for Maryam because she's so depressed and unhappy that she just goes with this rapist to a remote place. No Biblical "magnificat". And then it gets even worse!! *Then the birth pangs drove her to the trunk of a palm-tree and she says “Oh, would that I had died before this and had been all forgotten.” --> So just as she's ready to deliver, *Maryam wants to commit suicide!* Can it get worse than this? She wants to kill herself and wishes it was all over and forgotten by herself, her family, her friends. She's not happy about her baby, her life, nothing. The *well-proportioned man* is the only one around. Too bad the rapist isn't the one having the baby.

[@doneracer5994]

@ridhuan2335 3 of 3 Thereupon *?!the angel below her!?* cried out: *“Grieve not, for your Lord has caused a stream of water to flow beneath you. Shake the trunk of the palm-tree towards yourself and fresh and ripe dates shall fall upon you. So eat and drink and be consoled.* She's alone having a baby & the "man" tells her to get her own water & snacks. What a jerk! *And if thou meetest any mortal, say: Lo! I have vowed a fast unto the Beneficent, and may not speak this day to any mortal. Then she came to her people, carrying her baby. They said: “O Mary! You have committed a monstrous thing."* --> And the story about Maryam, Isa & Jibril-the-well-proportioned man end with *Jibril telling Maryam to LIE by telling people she's fasting & not speaking to anyone.* *Jibril-the-angel-man tells Maryam to LIE!* Awful. simply awful. In Islamic countries today Maryam would be stoned to death for being pregnant & unwed. -->I’m really looking forward to your comments to me.

[@arsalanusa]

The guest is suggesting Palestine protestors contain provocateurs. Shocking to hear that from a Muslim leader. Earlier, the discussion was about how they were disappointed with the anti- Palestine stance of some right wing media personalities. How are our leaders able to find common ground with far right ideologues is baffling.

[@SunsetNova]

What the Sheikh says makes perfect sense

[@skepticalzostrianos9875]

They're just too shocked to accept the fact that this palestinian genocide really shed the light on who is with us and who is against us. For a long time they were preaching that "the right is christian and we should try to find common ground with them, I mean look we're both anti-lgbtq! The left are against our valures!". But this conflict really showed the true face of the right who will not hesitate for a second to support any genocide against Muslims, they pretend to care for the Uighurs, but deep down they hope the US will do the same thing and creates “re-education camps” to “de-radicalize extremist muslims". Like how did these people really expect that Jordan Peterson would be pro-palestinian? It was obvious from the start which side he would be on. These s@lafi sheiks can't accept the fact that the right will always be anti-muslim, despite all their efforts to try to ally with them against the lgbtqs. The left was the only one to stand with the palestinians, look at the student protests, look at the "queer for palestine" or "jewish voice for peace".

[@withink5187]

I think he’s suggesting that some use the cause for fame and material gains and they are not interested in justice. Like those that claim they are against Zionism yet support the criminal regimes in Syria, Russia, Iran or China.

[@matrixman1947]

IF GOD wants a son,.... Then why not a Wife. Why not a pet? Why not a Mum and a Dad? Why not Cousins?. Why not a Society of God's? Why not make GOD a Joke?

[@Jack-xy2pz]

God never speaks to anyone directly 2000 or 1400 years ago. Your own holy book admits it.

[@AhmedHassan-vo5fz]

That’s not true. God spoke to Moses without an intermediary and the prophet during Isra wal miraj.

[@ukimenustah26]

Is that argument supposed to disprove anything??

[@AbelOktavian]

What the hell are you talking about ? There are messengers whose stories We have told you already and others We have not. And to Moses Allah spoke directly. -Surah An-Nisāʾ, Ayah 164

[@staffan144]

The home of the decieved and lost

[@staffan144]

@@BuffaloPros I mean this channel

[@staffan144]

@@BuffaloPros you reply everywhere. You seem to be obsessed? Here is a question for you: Do you understand the most basic and among the most fundamental of Christianity, that Jesus died and three days later was resurrected. Do you understand and accept this or do you deny it and claim it is false?

[@staffan144]

@@BuffaloPros do you understand and accept that Jesus was killed and then resurrected?

[@staffan144]

@@BuffaloPros One more try. Can you answer the simple question (yes or no, so that there are no misunderstandings): Do you understand and accept that Jesus was killed and then resurrected? [yes or no]

[@staffan144]

@@BuffaloPros I give up. You can't answer a simple question. I asked you only one very simple yes or no question. And you still just can't answer it.

[@AshokGupta-oq6hs]

Sir,if God can make Adam and from Adam make Eve then certainly He can have a Son.

[@ITBD-c2s]

My religion is the teachings of Christ, the eternal Word of God alone and nothing else. As for everything that contradicts the teachings of Christ, in the Old Testament or after Christ, they are satanic inspirations. The only one who inspires his prophets to kill in the Old Testament or after Christ is Satan. The one God alone is capable of kidnapping souls, and he does not ask his prophets to wage jihad and kill. As for Satan, it is because He is unable to kidnap souls, so he inspires his prophets to kill to achieve his satanic goals. that's done ..................

[@ITBD-c2s]

@@BuffaloPros did you understand what I have said ? And that all religious wars are from Satan, including Christian wars? Christ was clear when he rejected religious states and called for secular states in which religion was separated from the state, because all wars on earth are satanic, and a killer in the name of religion will not enter the kingdom of heaven. As for whoever fights to defend his homeland, it is up to him to forgive him because the Lord of this world is Satan, when He said, “Render to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and to God what is God’s.”....

[@ITBD-c2s]

@@BuffaloPros Christ was clear when he said, “My kingdom is not of this world.” When people turn away from the teachings of Christ and join terrorist religions, there will be the Second Coming, where the dead will emerge from the graves and all souls will be snatched up into the air to meet Christ, and the dead in Christ will enter Paradise first!!! As for those who considered him a prophet, the response is John’s response to the satanic heresies that considered Jesus a prophet and he was not crucified, but rather made a similarity to them when he said: Revelation 3:16 The Holy Bible (AVD) So because you are lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I am about to spit you out of my mouth!!! That is, be a Jew or a Christian and do not be a Nestorian, Gnostic ( religion of muhammad and his wife khadija ) , Arian or Muslim, because the one God will spit you out of his mouth. He will never intercede for you because you consider him a prophet, but rather he will spit you out of his mouth...........................

[@ghazyalsharif9675]

Bad choice of words by the guest, stopped listening at minute 5

[@davidlagoscelis5373]

Muhammad isn't a prophet of God, Jesus never spoke about him.

[@B11JESUS]

Only fools turn away from Jesus Christ to follow after a false prophet

[@TheMrZek]

Wait you will witness yourself.

[@B11JESUS]

@@TheMrZek what to see Muhammed the arab pediphile in hell?

[@hoodhud390]

Jesus is saying someone is coming after me! -John 16:13 Howbeit when he, the ➡️Spirit of truth,⬅️is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak: and he will shew you things to come.

[@TheMrZek]

@@hoodhud390 brother christians believe that holy spirit is 3rd person of trinity. And all the canonical writings were inspired by the Holy Spirit meaning they are not revelation from god.

[@hoodhud390]

@@TheMrZek 1-Spirit of truth not the Holy Spirit! 2-According to you the Holy Spirit is God and we don’t dictate to God what to say! 3- Jesus is talking in the future tense..but the Holy Spirit was already there: -Luke 3:22 And the Holy Ghost descended in a bodily shape like a dove upon him, and a voice came from heaven, which said, Thou art my beloved Son; in thee I am well pleased. Therefore it’s not the Holy Spirit! Sorry Brother.

[@depriveable]

Even your allah prays to himself..maybe he is also trinity😂

[@Yesunimwokozi1]

Muslims uses 2 hour only to repeat surah aklas as argument 😁😁😁,,Brian stuck in madrasa ,no more logical reasoning allowed,

[@AbelOktavian]

Job 25:4 [4] How then can man be justified with God? or how can he be clean that is born of a woman? Anyone who was born of a woman cannot be God , your own scripture do not even support what you supposed to believe as a Christian , cope.

[@MohammedNazrulla]

Do the christians believe their "father in heaven" has parents? Born to a pair of he and she God? This possibility reaches infinity!

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

No, most Christians believe in God who is the Creator Himself. So although I accept the concept of God being the "father in heaven", I think of the word "Father" simply as a way to communicate through human language the concept of the mystical essence of God's "characteristics. Respectfully from Florida USA

[@MohammedNazrulla]

@@johnbrzykcy3076 why the human relationship when he is not human? Refer and respect god as god! What is the difficulty? He created the entire universe not just humans. Creation by god has no connection to say or address him with animalistic reproduction process and assign the "father" tag.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

​@@MohammedNazrulla Respectfully, I don't quite understand your comments. Yes of course we should "respect God as God". Did I give the impression that we shouldn't respect God? If I did, I apologize to you. Yes I agree that God "created the entire universe", including the Cosmos and planet Earth. Can you clarify what I said wrong? I'd appreciate it. Peace to you and your family

[@MohammedNazrulla]

@@johnbrzykcy3076 which portion of my writing did you not understand? Please copy-paste and ask question(s) where you did not understand. I will explain; thank you. You asked What is wrong: it is, you trying to give a not so convincing explation to force the term father. Why not mother or. grand father? How do you know it is a he? Lol! Absolutely un necessary when we know God is not human. God is God. It is a terrible mistake to address god in human terminology like father, grand father, mother et al.

[@johnbrzykcy3076]

​​​@@MohammedNazrulla I appreciate your honesty, especially regarding the views of Christians who accept the concept of "Father" in reference to God. And I respect your views that such a reference may not be a good terminology. I think the view of God as a "Father" to mankind is evident throughout history in various religions. Of course such a belief doesn't necessarily make it the truth ( or good terminology! ). So I respect your views that "to address God in human terminology" is a terrible mistake. And I don't see God Himself as human because He is our Creator and way beyond our comprehension. I need to ponder your statements because I need guidance to understand better my own perceptions of God. Since I believe God created us "in his image", I do think God has some characteristics or attributes similar to us. Such as love, compassion, the ability to ponder our own thoughts, etc. What do you think? Does or can God have some characteristics similar to human beings? Maybe I'm wrong. I know some of my explanations are not very "convincing". That's because I lack scholarly ability and sometimes I don't think consistently. It's difficult on this KZbin to understand another individual's mindset or views. But it's good to listen carefully. Respectfully from Florida USA .