Anthony and Benedict basically saying, _“you better treat her right, or it’s pistols at dawn!”_ I definitely gave my younger brother that exact same talk on his wedding day. 😂
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
I will also give my brother this talk on his wedding day because his fiancé is now my favorite
@mercedesfp50948 ай бұрын
ok but that "Then what good am i to you" broke my heart, i'm gonna suffer this second half
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
It’s just so raw! It is definitely going to put us *through* it. And I am so, so excited we’re going to get to see that vulnerability. But yeah, suffer for sure.
@gabrielleduplessis73888 ай бұрын
I hope we don’t suffer for too long.
@brandiweik64218 ай бұрын
It looks like they’re wearing the same outfits in that 1 second kiss we see at the end of the trailer so I THINK they’re okay 😭
@teresabragg18958 ай бұрын
Me too. I tear up for Colin at that part.
@allier18678 ай бұрын
same. I don't wanna be sad and cry but I guess I am.
@dcal37758 ай бұрын
When she says that she can take care of herself, I don't think that he's upset that he's not her rescuer. I think it's more that, in a partnership, most especially a marriage, you're supposed to take care of each other. It alienates him when she makes that statement. Everybody needs to be needed. Can't wait to see how it plays out!
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Oh absolutely! And I didn’t mean rescuer in a bad way. But we’ve also established Colin is a people pleaser. Of course he wants to take care of those he loves as any good partner does! But that part of his journey too is realizing he is worthy of love on his own, that he doesn’t have to “earn” it. Part of his journey is making sense of his place. There’s going to be a lot of levels at play exactly because of what you bring up; Thanks for mentioning that nuance!
@bleucha8 ай бұрын
@@bookishmelody Since the first season we have seen him looking for purpose. That why he wanted to wed Marina. So wanting to be an help to his lover is more with his purpose issue than his people pleaser issue
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
I think they’re connected not an either or. So tied back into that finding a sense of place in terms of what his place in the world is.
@ltdowney8 ай бұрын
I agree with you, even though for the time and in their social class it was absolutely expected/customary for the man to completely provide for and “govern” his wife (for lack of a better term) - and his initial reaction to Penelope-as-Whistledown may incorporate this perspective briefly before he fully processes the situation - Colin is a good guy, he’s not so weak or shallow as to be intimidated by her financial success/independence. I suspect that Penelope is partly reacting in anger / lashing out just at the shock of being found-out - like she says in that other shot with Eloise, “Whistledown is power,” losing her anonymity would take that power away - and it’s her words to which he’s reacting. After suddenly realizing he loves her, they already have a deep connection having known each other & been friends for years, and what she says cuts deep. Like, “I thought you loved me… you don’t need me?” ☹️ At least, that’s just how it reads to me, obviously it’s just a short clip of a scene. In any case, we’ll get the whole context in a week.
@ceriseanne18 ай бұрын
Speaking of insecurities: when has Penelope ever experienced being truly seen and appreciated? In her day-to-day life, not so much. She was best friends with Eloise, but as we all know, Pen kept so much close to her chest, and the feelings she did share were often missed by Eloise. And now she has to expose her greatest secret. I hope to see a lot of real growth for Penelope and for Colin. This could prove to be so satisfying emotionally. Hoping the writing offers Nicola and Luke the opportunity to deeply explore being vulnerable - both actors are more than capable of conveying these deep emotions given the opportunity. GREAT REACTION btw - I so appreciate your insights and enthusiasm! :)
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Important points! This is *exactly* why we’re on the edge of our seat with the mirror scene 👀🪞 (or I guess it’s why I am; I can only speak for myself) And thank you so much for the kind words!
@mkg21248 ай бұрын
I think we will absolutely still get a moment where Colin defends Penelope against Portia, even if it doesn’t play out like in the books.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
If they made sure to give us the hand cut, surely they gotta!
@gabrielleduplessis73888 ай бұрын
I hope so. Wanted to see that on screen since reading the book
@ninaking50888 ай бұрын
I think it will be with Eloise, they posted a still with her and him in his study 👀👀✨ i can totally see her questioning him about the speed of the engagement with pen ✨
@phoenixfrommars58328 ай бұрын
in the book i thought it felt much more cruel than anything, which for shure with this setup will not come in. I think with Portia pressuring Pen into what she thinks an Ideal Wife does, he will soon recognize and confront her and i wo want to see it.
@mkg21247 ай бұрын
SPOILER: What did I tell y'all!
@solcarlosofficial8 ай бұрын
I’m really sad we won’t have the featherington scene after the carriage. That was by far my favorite scene in the book. And it really shows us that Colin loves every aspect of Penelope. It wasn’t just a lust thing. He explains in details everything he admires about her. Also the scene is so funny and here it seems it will be more tension
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
It will be missed for sure! Hopefully we still get some moments of comedy amidst the tension. Even Macbeth breaks for some laughs.
@bleucha8 ай бұрын
To be fair he already told her what he loves about her. His friendship declaration on the first episode of the season said a lot. He more than once recognized her intelligence, kindness, even that she can be sharp,...
@KiwiRuby-rf8ot8 ай бұрын
Please do a psyche and Eros analysis! I love listening to you talk about this show. Who better to do a breakdown of the trailer!!
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
That truly means so much; thank you!
@vanessarussell70488 ай бұрын
I just re-watched all of part one last night, then woke up this morning to the trailer release for part two!!!!!! Perfect timing! I can’t tell you all how many times I have watched this trailer on repeat. I am so flipping excited. 😂
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
You brought it into existence for all of us 😂
@LouisianaStitcher8 ай бұрын
I really enjoyed hearing your thoughts! I absolutely loved the trailer. Cressida's red dress totally reminds me of Scarlett O'Hara's iconic red dress when she goes to Ashley's birthday party in Gone With the Wind. The dresses look so similar. Also, did you see the Queen entering the ball with the flower prints floor to ceiling? Roses are everywhere and the guests are wearing red, cremes, pinks, and greens. In that scene, Queen Charlotte totally looks like the queen of hearts from Alice in Wonderland. You know the scene in the rose garden where the queen of hearts yells off with her head? So much to take in! It feels like part 2 might give us the Bridgerton drama finally.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
That Queen of Hearts scene was way too tense for me as a child 😂 Great catches as always!
@KarenM-kf7eq8 ай бұрын
Love your reaction and analysis. You articulate your points so well and connect them to the book in a really insightful way. It makes me think about the show in a deeper level. I appreciate the way you explain Colin's and Pen's inner struggles with his protectiveness and her independence.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Thank you that means a lot!
@apender017 ай бұрын
Ha! I too was minding my business and here we are 😂 Great take on what we are seeing. I am fascinated in seeimg how they pull it off!
@bookishmelody7 ай бұрын
At least we only have a few more days! Though I haven’t minded having the interim to digest.
@georgiadufresne33608 ай бұрын
💜 Your hair, make-up, and outfit are making you look so beautiful!💜
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Oh, honestly that means a lot because I was in “going to be on camera for a Monday team meeting” mindset not a filming mindset when getting ready 😂
@melody_shmelody8 ай бұрын
For me the sexiest thing that can happen in part 2 is Colin quickly realizing what a rock star and bad*ass Penelope is to have pulled off Lady Whistledown and respecting the crap out of that. I will give him a short while to mope and be weird about it but he needs to come out the other end even further in awe of and in love with this woman. If anyone should realize why she did it and what it meant to her it should be him. Saw a great analysis about the difference between his family and hers, his position in society versus hers, and just straight up the different ways men existed versus women during those times. When all of those are taken into account he should come to his senses!
@bleucha8 ай бұрын
Well he said he want to tear down Whistledown in pieces. I hope he will give her the ear that Eloise refused to give, to let her explain why she had done what she did. Like the fact that outing Marina pregnancy was her last resort because she tried to talk to everybody and didn't wanted to see Colin trapped in that wedding. For the people she loves she had tried everything she can do before using Whistledown for some sort of damage control. Maybe she was always did what was best, but she still a very young lady with no power outside her writing, mistake make people grown.
@bleucha8 ай бұрын
Well he said he want to tear down Whistledown in pieces. I hope he will give her the ear that Eloise refused to give, to let her explain why she had done what she did. Like the fact that outing Marina pregnancy was her last resort because she tried to talk to everybody and didn't wanted to see Colin trapped in that wedding. For the people she loves she had tried everything she can do before using Whistledown for some sort of damage control. Maybe she was always did what was best, but she still a very young lady with no power outside her writing, mistake make people grown.
@melody_shmelody8 ай бұрын
@@bleucha Agreed---what a great way to put it: The ear that Eloise didn't give her. Exactly!
@TheKD1088 ай бұрын
I'm so impressed with the level of detail you went into on this trailer. Off to watch the rest of your Bridgerton videos. :)
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Thank you! ☺️
@ashleehughes11948 ай бұрын
I had the day off today and overslept and woke up to the Bridgerton/Polin fandom having a meltdown. Such a great surprise! And this is a PROPER trailer I was not expecting. Also I was ready for more clock/countdown type of PR but they went full on with the tension and drama, and honestly it worked. It has me so hyped up!
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
I know! When a teaser was at the end of Part 1 I was like “ok maybe we aren’t getting a Part 2 trailer” and Bam!
@C94-p8k8 ай бұрын
Wow great analysis based off the trailer alone!🙌
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Thank you! how long I can sit and analyze just the trailer (and not touch on everything) is what gets me in trouble when it comes to the actual episodes 😂
@gabrielleduplessis73888 ай бұрын
It is so weird hearing about or seeing Anthony being protective of Penelope without thinking of the fan fiction I read of them as a couple. But am glad we are seeing how important Penelope is to the entire Bridgerton family. Wish we got more of that.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
I’ve always found it odd I haven’t really gotten in to Bridgerton fanfic. Maybe because historically I use fanfic for non cannon ships or to expand on relationships I feel don’t get enough and-in theory- romances are a complete and satisfying emotional arc. And yet, you’ve got me here like “wait do *I* need to read Anthony/Penelope fanfic” 😂
@gabrielleduplessis73888 ай бұрын
@@bookishmelody i did not realize I needed either until someone recommended them to me. What really got me into Bridgerton fan fic was Eloise and footman john fan fiction and then I read the Penthony fan fiction and by god, they are so good
@vanessarussell70488 ай бұрын
Me too!
@melody_shmelody8 ай бұрын
There’s Penelope Anthony fanfic???!
@gabrielleduplessis73888 ай бұрын
@@melody_shmelody that was my exact thought too. There is tons of it. I read a few and was surprised at how good they were. They actually made me like this ship. Still not my favorite, but they were wholesome and cute in the fan fiction.
@ashmeyer218 ай бұрын
Something interesting that has not been brought up is maybe Penelope is keen to holding on to Whistledown because of the financial situation that her family has always been in. In that era women were expected to rely on the male protagonist for support. She has witnessed first hand how that can easily fade away by the lost of her father and the other male family member betrayal. I also believe she has a clearer understanding of the working class since she is around them often. I also believe she truly enjoys deep down being a girl boss since Something like that was unheard of in that day in age. My prediction is that it will cause Queen Charlotte to have respect for her if they have the queen eventually find out.
@bleucha8 ай бұрын
I agree. I can understand her wanting to keep that power. She's a young lady in a world where old men make the rules and women, and even more the young one have little to no power depending on their beauty, their money, or their father/husband power. And for most of the ton she have none of them. (Yes she made a good glow up but she still lack some charisma when chatting with people)
@sylvestglenn8 ай бұрын
I'm also up for an Eros and Psyche comparison! Thanks for the review. I very much enjoyed the first half of the series and understood that, as in the book, the tension would come later. Honestly, there's enough tension in life. I'm happy with a frolicking rollick! ☺
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Everything is awful; we deserve a little frolick
@rocketsoccer18 ай бұрын
I was STRUGGLING to wake up this morning and half awake scrolling instagrm and i saw the trailer, talk about a much needed shot of adrenaline 😂
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Right? Like it was just a random Monday (when I took a half second to think about it I was like “ok the timeline makes sense”-but we have jobs 😂)
@vanessarussell70488 ай бұрын
Me too 😂
@iamrachelrach8 ай бұрын
On the third of June, in the year 2024-precisely 10 days before season 4 part 2-Netflix released the final trailer for Bridgerton a show we love. It was, in a word, thrilling. The world shook. Our heart leaped. The moment was breathtaking. And, we were able to tell ourselves with some satisfaction, Polin fans-felt precisely the same way. 😏🐝🪶💎🪞🪭 🤣🤭
@icestarable8 ай бұрын
Still overwhelmed by how incredible this trailer was but I absolutely as always would love to see more videos and analysis from you especially Cupid and payche and more character analysis or how they seem to be pulling from the books in such an incredible way it’s giving more depth and thought to each book scene and still being consistent with how they work it in with the show characterisations 😊
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Cupid/Psyche analysis will probably come after Part 2 when I can look at the whole arc. I’ve definitely been trying plot out some more analysis videos between work and social life (and still trying to read 😭). And I so, so appreciate the interest! I don’t take it for granted that anyone is interested in what I have to say ☺️
@kailyns81598 ай бұрын
A bit back there was an interview clip floating around where Luke is responding to a different question and ends up saying something like “it was fun to confront Portia.” Then Nicola replied something like “we love Polly, but Portia…” And Luke continued with “yeah, she’s being so mean to Pen and I overhear it and sort of put her in her place; it’s a great scene.” Based on that, I’m fairly sure Mama Featherington vs Colin is happening. Unless it got cut from the show and the actors weren’t aware of that when this particular interview happened.
@melody_shmelody8 ай бұрын
I do want the Eros and Psyche analysis!
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Noted!
@vanyacalderon8 ай бұрын
Yes!! Please do an analysis of the Eros and psyche parallels I NEED IT. 💖
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
👀👀 after Part 2 and I’ll start gathering thoughts now
@bleucha8 ай бұрын
The mirror scene seems to be in a room with some sheets on furniture, like they are visiting a house they want to buy, or maybe in their new house.So maybe before or just after their wedding.
@merelhaans2568 ай бұрын
I loved watching this video thank you!!! I would really like to see more of your reactions/break downs of content🫶✨️
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Thank you for watching!
@melody_shmelody8 ай бұрын
Hello from another Melody! Speculation: Colin finds out this season but the rest of the Ton doesn’t yet. I think they will drag that part out to be their character arc for Season 4 since they are coming back. I could also see it being a really good cliffhanger. I desperately need Peneloise to make up this season. I really don’t want to wait for that.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Hello fellow Melody! I could absolutely see them keeping that revelation from the rest of the ton, but we’ll see!
@jillybean13738 ай бұрын
I really hope we get a true declaration of love where Penelope can finally truly let Colin in and depend on him. I want her to take more of the reins in that since she seems to be coming into herself and gaining confidence.
@SunshineWhenItRains18 ай бұрын
I have a theory! The 'spicy' scene we get a glimpse of in the trailer will not be the mirror scene, it will be their first time scene. I think the beginning of that scene might play out similarly to the 'mirror scene' in the book, where he describes the fantasy then says 'later'. THEN later on after the Whistledown reveal is cleared up between them, we will get the ACTUAL mirror scene!!
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
I like this theory!
@barbarafrings92318 ай бұрын
At min 1.51 there is a very short scene of people dancing at a ball (on the left you can see Penelope). From the enlarged standing picture it seems that some have on masks (look at the two dancing women in the middle, their faces seem unnatural, like they have on masks). Is this the masquerade we meet Sophie?
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
🤞🤞
@melody_shmelody8 ай бұрын
I really think that’s what all the midnight references are getting at! 🤞
@nataliesavage54388 ай бұрын
love your videos just ordered the romancing mr bridgerton book
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Thank you and enjoy!
@SecondlookNZ8 ай бұрын
A spinoff for Polin is definitely a must!!
@Girl2TheCity8 ай бұрын
Men generally find their role in being protector of their spouse so Colin stating his purpose was apt. I’m here for your Eros and Pysche comparison 🎉🎉🎉 I have so many thoughts trying to piece my ideas t together from the last two trailers 😂😂 I have already agreed to a friendly ladies bet on when Lady Whistledown author gets exposed before or after the marriage. Can’t wait to talk part two 2️⃣ with everyone and compare it to the 📕 book. In true fashion I talked my friends into theming out watch party 🎉 into Lady Danbury gaming den. Let the games begin 🎉🎉🎉
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Wait you are doing a Lady Danbury gaming den watch party?? How do I become that cool?
@writerbynite8 ай бұрын
I think after.
@sunway24648 ай бұрын
Any thoughts on why they cut out Felicity Featherington from the series? She is the 4th sister in the book, of Featherington sisters.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Streamlining the narrative in terms of the number of people within the Featherington household when Felicity is more developed than Prudence or Phillipa-and knowing they wanted to expand Portia’s role-I would imagine. Additionally, without Felicity it cements Penelope as on a kind of island in her own household which ups her stakes and makes her motivations clearer. It will become a wrinkle come Hyacinth in terms of her having relationships outside her family but we’ve got a while to solve that one.
@morgangriggs8 ай бұрын
They said that there will be lots of mirrors in the show so the first one isnt the mirror scene. It should be later in the show. I think the clip might be when he says ehat he wants to do to her in front of the mirror but not right then. Lol I cant wait for part 2. I love the hug Violet and Pens hug.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Violet and Pen’s hug definitely got me!
@saavinisanganeria8 ай бұрын
The scene where Francesca and Kilmartin dance in the background we can see Pen in a white dress (maybe her wedding dress) dancing with Colin. They mention Colin is very swift with Pen. So they may get married quickly and the drama may unfold afterwards 🤔 ❤
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Oooh good catch; They are also swift in the book so this would track in both worlds!
@melody_shmelody8 ай бұрын
I think the scene where they are in the church is actually going to be Francesca’s wedding! Now I need to go look for the screen you talked about.
@melody_shmelody8 ай бұрын
I also think your prediction would be in the spirit of so many of the books. For so many of the books there are still issues to resolve after the alter and for season 2 they skipped over that/changed it. So your theory would keep with that.
@pandorasboxbraids8 ай бұрын
OKAY RIGHT? the red lip is BAWWWWTHERING MEEEE 😩
@tasiamrios42198 ай бұрын
Love your reaction
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Thank you! 💜
@whatsitwhichandwho8 ай бұрын
Tick tock tick tock - clocks can be race against the clock re: LW reveal -- Pen vs. Cressida vs. Queen (and Eloise's ultimatum), Colin's discovery of truth. Also seems to be a nod to Benedict's story.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Oh absolutely a race against the clock for Whistledown, and I think a specific timing in the episode as well - but we’ll see the specifics!
@gabrielleduplessis73888 ай бұрын
12:00. Midnight. Cinderella. Duh!
@vanessarussell70488 ай бұрын
I love that, great thought. 😁How’d I miss that?!
@TRfan88 ай бұрын
@@vanessarussell7048 there are a lot of Cinderella parallels this season.
@MiZzzzRC8 ай бұрын
What if the party is a certain masquerade? It would be the perfect way to tie everything in.
@meganduffyellison49778 ай бұрын
Would LOVE Eros and Psyche analysis!
@mscam09188 ай бұрын
Hi, did anyone notice Lady Sharma behind Queen Charlotte?
@moyeling-ling18778 ай бұрын
Guys we may just get 1 wedding this season and it’s Francesca’s 😭
@MiZzzzRC8 ай бұрын
This is what I was thinking. I don't think Polin will fully wrap up this season at all....
@missadm90818 ай бұрын
Did you see in the trailer that Penelope is dancing in the background with Colin in her wedding dress?
@gabrielleduplessis73888 ай бұрын
I definitely got book vibes from this trailer. Spoilers for book. Sorry. I can’t help it. It is clear we are getting the mirror/bedroom scene we are looking for. I love the theory of them dancing in the church being a replacement for them dancing in Berkley square. I hope so because I loved that scene in the book. The “what good am I to you” seems to be him following her to the church or print shop like the book. I just hope his silent treatment and anger doesn’t last long. From both trailers, it seems we are getting the Cressida black mail at the engagement party.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Excellent thoughts all around! And I know the Berkeley square dancing was a fave scene in our reread so that will be such a nice moment. I’m so excited to see how the second half of this season is going to be drawn. There’s a lot more action from the book to mine, and they also have so many creative directions they can take it!
@vanessarussell70488 ай бұрын
I was always weary about a possible Cressida redemption arc. I could never fully believe it. You can blame upbringing or personality, but I’ve still always disliked her
@moyeling-ling18778 ай бұрын
I’m for it if Penelope needs more time to be courted by Collin and postpones the wedding. I want what is best for her and she deserves so much! She has her money and this could just be her moment to realize she never HAS to marry to feel of worth she already is incredible and that she can marry if she WANTS to.
@sean-lu8bw8 ай бұрын
Love listening you talk abt this show! I wanted to say: I think its very interesting how, the stakes of this season seem to be in the woman’s hands more than the previous seasons! My fav couple fr
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
That means so much; thank you! And absolutely! And a great observation! I love all the variations of love Bridgerton gives us, but a wallflower storyline is always gonna have a special place in my heart.
@sean-lu8bw8 ай бұрын
Also: I don’t think the Featheringtons’ scene doesn’t really fit the show because Portia is made to be a way more caring mother in the show than in the books. She still has faults but again and again it is portrayed to be out of a place of love and care. So I don’t think they would be able to nail the scene without destroying two seasons of character development for her.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
I think it could have worked *if* Felicity still existed. As she doesn’t, it’s a moot point. But I love the payoff we’re seeing of Portia’s character development this season!
@beatyz28 ай бұрын
To me, part 2 Colin of the show has nothing to do with book Colin's storyline anymore. I am not a book fan. I.e. I likely read it once in like 2019. TV show Colin has a whole different set of conflict to address. This, as much was it was in part 1 as well, rightfully should be shifted to address a younger Colin and a younger Penelope. I.e. the featherington drawing room scene, as adored and influential to the context as it might be by readers, is inappropriate for 23-year-olds Colin. He fully isn't the Colin of the book. He's not there yet.. so to expect them to put a scene in there that doesn't make sense with the character we're trying to expose as the true him.... I think changing that saved them from some level of disingenuous.
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Absolutely! And I think his conflicts, while being distinct from book Colin as you said, still feel close to those same inner conflicts from the book. I’ve really enjoyed how the honor the spirit of the book while telling their story, so I definitely more approach it as how the two are in conversation more than trying to be a purist. Great thoughts; thanks for sharing!
@beatyz28 ай бұрын
@@bookishmelodyI think that's the really exciting part. There is a whole lot of the story to come that can't be spoiled by the book because it's just a framework. It's an inspiration. So very interesting to see how it will turn out
@reading17138 ай бұрын
You didn't warn that you would give book spoilers and so spoilt how Colin finds out for me. I thought you would at least give a headsup.
@DeborahWalkerXOXO8 ай бұрын
The clock could be about Sophie and Benedict?
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Absolutely think that could be in play! I was like 👀
@lilj48188 ай бұрын
Honestly, hyperventilating ahhhhhh
@bookishmelody8 ай бұрын
Appropriate, I think
@iamrachelrach8 ай бұрын
On the third of June, in the year 2024-precisely 10 days before season 4 part 2-Netflix released the final trailer for Bridgerton a show we love. It was, in a word, thrilling. The world shook. Our heart leaped. The moment was breathtaking. And, we were able to tell ourselves with some satisfaction, Polin fans-felt precisely the same way. 😏🐝🪶💎🪞🪭 🤣🤭