Bro Hajji 2 - The Shaykhology Podcast EP. 09

[@53fczunb]

Respect to you both for raising this topic

[@ShaykhAbdulMajidOfficial]

Respect goes fully to him. I was only educated on the situation through his efforts. May Allah accept his sincere intentions and give us all the ability to be a means of Khair for the wider good.

[@53fczunb]

@@ShaykhAbdulMajidOfficial Bro there is a guy called Iqrar Ul Hassan in Pakistan he goes round exposing all scammers… We could do with this here in UK by someone that is respected in the community And has some power too

[@Truthseeker-o9d]

Mashallah brother keep up the good work

[@boostbaa2882]

Bro hajji the legend

[@53fczunb]

You have to interview charity heads who are collecting money

[@researchthefacts-xm2sv]

second question when some charity says 100 percent donation what about t the people who work for the charity who do they get abroad with what money do they use there own money or is the money used from the charity donated to the cause

[@sufyaan7945]

Assalamualikum shaikh. Would love to come and talk about this issue more from a charity perspective. Very good topic. You have experience of our charity before shaikh, so we would happily come. Very good podcast Alhamdulillah.

[@ShaykhAbdulMajidOfficial]

In my humble opinion, reach out to our brother Hajji who has much more knowledge on the subject. I was only made aware of the situation due to his content. That would be much more beneficial in my honest opinion. Allah bless ALL our charities and enable them to be a means of more benefit for the Ummah and mankind at large.

[@sufyaan7945]

Ameen, Jazakallahu khair Shaikh

[@researchthefacts-xm2sv]

one thing i want to know 1 what is the administration fees for charitys is that included in the funds asks from muslims if so why dont you tell the people who donate ?

[@researchthefacts-xm2sv]

3rd question when people say they building wells and people donate all over the world how do you get to the wells if you live in the west does every penny go to the well or do you use some money to go abroad from that which is donated is it a job if your not working is it that the charity collector worker who has no job but know he or she is working as a charity collector and shes diong charity work but where does she get her money for her self is it from the charity donated wealth for the project

[@researchthefacts-xm2sv]

one point where this man keeps making same error and this to take this back is that he keeps saying the ayat of the quran IF A SINNER FASIQ COMES TO YOU WITH NEWS VERIFY IT ) this verse said a sinner but what if hes a truthful person muslim upright do you need to verify it the answer is no bc in the tafseer of the quran of imam shawkani he said about this verse in his tafseer fath al qadeer the verse is something which we call in usool of fiqh mufhoom al mukhalafah which is that the opposite is also true that if a person whos truthful upright not a sinner comes to you with news then you do not need to verify it so hajji needs to recant from that bc what you diong here is generalised the verse to include any muslim also this will be a wrong understanding pls tell hajji to recant that which he keeps mentioning

[@BroHajji]

يفيد أنه إن جاءنا عدل فإننا نقبل الخبر، إلا إذا كان الخبر مستغربا ، أو انفرد به عن الناس ،أو كان هناك دلائل قوية تكذبه ، أو كان يخبر عن قوم بينه وبينهم شحناء ،أو عرف عن هذا الناقل- رغم صلاحه - التسرع والعجلة ،إلى غير ذلك من الأسباب والاعتبارات . The verse is referring to the one is sinful, but we apply it based on the information as the verse was revealed in connection to a companion as per below: وقد ذكر كثير من المفسرين أن هذه الآية نزلت في الوليد بن عقبة بن أبي معيط ، حين بعثه رسول الله - صلى الله عليه وسلم - على صدقات بني المصطلق I will never hold a companion to be a فاسق but it’s the information that he transmitted to the Prophet ﷺ as per the known story. I don’t hold any charities to be completely trustworthy in the general sense nor the fundraising mercenaries. We can agree to disagree بارك الله فيك