Can the US stop Huawei's expansion? | Inside Story

[@ericc.handoko7962]

Because if every country use huawei . the CIA can no longer spy 🤣🤣🤣

[@lisasimpsonisanaddict]

Right.

[@raptordriver7340]

The internet has been and always will be the proprietary technology that has been commissioned by the US DoD. The global standards and protocols in the internet has been set by the same US DoD and adopted by the IEEE and other world body standards. Hence, Huawei is allowed to swim in the web much like the rest of us. Hence, US DoD and intelligence communities (5 eyes) can see what is considered confidential traffic throughout the web and trace its source.

[@ericc.handoko7962]

Matt Bloskey I cant breath...

[@hobbesy4457]

That's bad news for US.

[@kthapa9697]

I dont know abt usa but centrnly no huawei in india

[@entlethobontlebotite93]

People the problem is not Huawei the thing is that US does not want China to lead 21st century because it can see that China is in another level this is all about superpower

[@speedbird006]

Who wants CCP to lead the world?

[@josephineuwamarya7119]

@@speedbird006 they have too many people that they control and they are outsmarting others in technologies and they are homogeneous...

[@onyangojordan3873]

@@speedbird006 We dont care if they do

[@speedbird006]

@@onyangojordan3873 Then you have no more access to youtube though.

[@hullopillow4853]

Free market principle says the better technology wins the market. Huawei has the leading 5G tech, US has none.

[@saschaatta1]

You are uninformed

[@thednk1000]

Acatel, Nokia and many others make just as good of a 5g product.

[@craigsm1820]

From stolen tech mind u. And sorry bud why would anyone want a communist spying on me when the CCP make u law that suit them

[@craigsm1820]

China seems to take the word free too far, they think stealing is free

[@Jubaer21]

@@thednk1000 Huawei's 5g is faster then other company’s 5g. and also they are cheaper

[@moonsorrow77]

Out of jealousy..they can’t compete with Chinese technology...

[@ggc7318]

Yes, Huawei is so cheap. We cannot compete. 😃

[@kumaragurunadaraja2928]

What a funny comment 🤣 then why China still stealing technology? Don't say u don't knw or not proven. There are so many proven cases. Google and read first then comment kid.

[@ggc7318]

@@kumaragurunadaraja2928 China stole and reverse engineering everything ! Speakers to bullet trains ! Even buildings !😂😂😂

[@BinhLe-ne2jv]

@JJ Sundra well said and deep thinking ! India need a revolution led by real communist party, let most of people become real owner of this country . Love India

[@dariomladenovski7047]

nope the Chinese are light years ahead of them in 5g technology, America is losing power to China and they are in full panic mode 😂😂😂

[@aahayob]

All three guest speakers have significant insight. Thank you. To sum it all, it’s like having an unfriendly rich neighbour who dislikes you in general. Then when you are progressing in some areas your neighbour becomes insecure and threatened. He then comes over to intimidate and threaten you. Not only that, he rallies the whole neighborhood around him or otherwise....... Do you know of a country that have such behavior and attitude?

[@JR-vc4gm]

Let me guess... India?

[@bingcishi]

I like your great analogy.

[@garypoon9291]

I would not consider US as rich. What is its national debt???

[@petergreenwood7731]

united states of sanctions

[@ellengran6814]

Human rights!! Yemen, Afghanistan,Vietnam, Iran etc. Does US care about children starving due to sanctions or millions killed in US wars ? Guatanamo and US prisons - human rights ???

[@dssample1239]

Well, you should consider why those countries were sunction in the 1st place.

[@ellengran6814]

ds 123 sample What justifies starving children ?

[@keithliscott1020]

@@dssample1239 O yes prime example weapons of mass destruction Let's kill one and all children included. .... They did not have weapons of mass destruction. Doesn't matter but could have had

[@dariomladenovski7047]

@@keithliscott1020 yep that's why North Korea will never give up their nukes, they saw what the US did to Sadam and Gaddafi

[@keithliscott1020]

@@dssample1239 Because they said it was a threat to national security and the average American isent smart enough to find them on a map...

[@henryyip1]

"HuaWei - Best phone in the world "

[@Yisi.voyager]

Funny how America says using other people's data😂 Edward Snowdon knock knock

[@bestintentions6089]

Haha funny how China harvests organs from prisoners , runs concentration camps and murderes thousands of Tibet monks. Losusts they are.

[@popyocherryXD]

BestIntentions Ask CIA, and those globalist supporters, that’s the reasons, never trust Falun Gong cults

[@mcurtis3359]

@@bestintentions6089 you are f...Ken stupid.

[@Yisi.voyager]

@@popyocherryXD yep Falun Gong is such a bad cult

[@lisasimpsonisanaddict]

Yeah USA and not spying their the boss in spying 😂

[@CondenseFact]

"Financial aid"... isn't that "bribery"? Isn't there a law in the US to overseas bribery? Ironic.

[@lisasimpsonisanaddict]

Exactly

[@rayfonz9128]

Obviously, bribery at its best, we won’t surprised they have been paying the protesters in Hong Kong as well

[@david50665]

I think if china did this it would be considered bribery and grounds for some sort criminal prosecution or economic sanctions

[@chinesecharactersfunnylang9187]

Where is US's fair play spirit?

[@dantse2012able]

USA writes its laws and codes of conduct and attempts to apply all around the globe, and calls that "USA exceptionalism".

[@lisasimpsonisanaddict]

Fairness and US? 😂 You're naive

[@robertgittings8662]

@@dantse2012able *You mean the "Free Market Economy" US had asked every country to follow the last two centuries? That is out of the window as soon as they think they will lose 🤣*

[@jinkela1386]

fair play only when they know they're going to win

[@michaelleong100]

if any US company is asked by FBI/US intelligence to furnish certain high security info, do you think such US company can say NO ? US is now banning sales of chips and certain high tech to China, does any US company dare to defy such an order ? so can we also say that such companies are under the influence of the govt ?

[@excitingfruit]

"if any US company is asked by FBI/US intelligence to furnish certain high security info, do you think such US company can say NO ?" Yes, just look at the case of the San Bernadino terror attack where the FBI requested access to the shooter's iPhone and Apple refused to grant it. The FBI had to employ the services of an Israeli security company to hack into the phone because they had no legal authority to compel Apple to comply.

[@epeew8155]

@@excitingfruit You believe that? :) hahaha

[@excitingfruit]

@@epeew8155 I believe something widely reported around the world including by Chinese state media? Why yes, I do.

[@david50665]

​@@excitingfruit could it be they can haven't escalated some emergency national security laws to bypass this, esp since they can hack it....or you really think there was no way under US law?

[@excitingfruit]

@@david50665 Judges have ruled that the FBI doesn't have the power to compel companies to unlock phones, and they've lost in court over this. They were in the middle of suing Apple when they got help in hacking it and subsequently dropped the case. If they could just override the law why would they have big public court disputes about it beforehand?

[@WhitebeardV8]

Didn’t Huawei opened their source code to UK and German to exam? What more do you need to do?

[@umedavk2011]

Nicholas Sun : and the source code can't be surreptitiously changed afterwards in compliance with CCPs demands ?? There is a law in China which demands that EVERYONE in China HAS to cooperate with the CCP's intelligence organisations.

[@WhitebeardV8]

@@umedavk2011 I would assume the updates of source code will be examed, too. Do you think UK and German cyber securities are stupid or something? and didn't CIA tapped on Angela Merkel's phone calls? I mean, based on the facts US has been spying on everyone for decades, maybe just a time to find some alternative.

[@刘谷-c4x]

its already done. and you can do nothing . Trump said to Huawei: just wait to die, because i want you to

[@刘谷-c4x]

@@umedavk2011 now ccp has spied on the whole world like 8 years? because Germany used Huawei since long time ago. Wait, who helped Huawei in Germany? USA, they broke into Frau Merkel and Sacoci's CELLPHONE. you really think ccp has the ability to spy on the world without being noticing? The Americans have the most spionagetech. and germanys find out.

[@刘谷-c4x]

@@umedavk2011 and Huawei is the only chance china has, to have technique advance against usa, i dont think ccp wanna break it. and if you are right, why is Ren Zhengfei's daughter still stucked in Canada, shoud they know everything, like americans wanna capture their chef's daughter?

[@twood2032]

The two thing people can't buy with money are time, and knowledge. If we look back in time, Huawei has invested both time and money into R&D toward 5G development, this is why they are ahead in 5G technology. By saying Chinese government has given Huawei support is complete meanless, Chinese government have money, however they cannot make people smart, if the people who work at Huawei do not have what it takes, they cannot come up with 5G technology. The Americans keeps on saying Chinese is stealing western tech, how can the Chinese steal something that the American don't have?

[@realcindydadrana1903]

Here in southeast Asia there will be 5g from huawei,we should catch up with that in terms of technology .

[@akosiwaray1837]

Much of South East Asia is still under the sphere of influence of big old Uncle Sam and it's cohorts in the West to control the less developed parts of the world to maintain their dominance. Unless ASEAN integration is finally realized, ASEAN won't be in a position to even negotiate for it's own. We will always be bullied to conform to the will of the big boys in town.

[@anthonywong3393]

I think Huawei will focus much more time and energy on innovation than spend time to argue with USA. As time goes by, people will have a clear picture

[@jonhone1]

Prisms, NSA, Huawei on the wall, who is the safest of all? 🤑

[@zhangangzhang5004]

US: STOP HUAWEI, WHY？ US: We can not spy on you anymore. That's unacceptable.

[@estevencamacho]

The trump administration is vehemently anti-China at the moment but what he doesn't realize that it's going to cost Americans billions and billions of dollars for not cooperating with Huawei and China. I think Mexico will be far more receptive.

[@ebiekem]

In all honesty, this won't have much dent on Huawei global lead in 5G technology. In Africa alone, Huawei and ZTE dominates. In Nigeria in particular, some service providers are even swapping out some western tech for Huawei's.

[@1o1s1s1i1e]

Free Julian Assange!!!

[@ebaypolice8761]

Julian Assange is the innocent boy who told the truthof what USA did , just like the "Emperor's new clothes".

[@cryptone6838]

When it is a crime to expose the crime of another, then we know we are ruled by criminals.

[@Censor999]

And dont forget Edward Snowden.

[@ebaypolice8761]

@@Censor999 Fully agree

[@umedavk2011]

@@cryptone6838 And if Julian Assange had done to China what he did to the US, he wouldn't just be hiding in an embassy - he would be executed by now, after being tortured to cough up all his info sources and knowledge.

[@alicewunder4166]

Good job, so refreshing to see a peaceful discussion from different standpoints and I can actually learn something. I was so afraid that this would be another show where people will just talk bad about a company just because it's from a country that we don't know or frankly don't like because of all the propaganda from our government. I feel sad that US is now a laughing stock of the world, and some of us still talk like we are the savior of the world and keep saying "you are welcome" to others when they only see us as the biggest stupid chaotic war criminal.

[@MrBlinder514]

Recommend the channel CGTN in case if you are interested to know more about alternative views about China. Honestly most NON-CHINESE media don't know much about China.

[@mr.g3940]

I am using my Huawei P40. The best phone in the world. I am typing using Google keyboard. There are ways to get the apps. You simply transfer them from any phone to your phone...

[@craigsm1820]

@Marius Chirita China confuses phones with bats

[@craigsm1820]

@Marius Chirita Your just confused and need some help. Come to the wuhan lab and we can fix you up.

[@garypoon9291]

@@craigsm1820 Do more research before you blame the Wuhan lab. You sound like Trump.

[@andrethorpe6183]

@@garypoon9291 sounds to me that he is clueless as to the genetic research on the various strains of this virus and like a lot of the uneducated is spewing the usual idiotic gibberish from a declining empire too afraid or incapable of reinventing, re-educating their population to meet the challenges of the Information Age.

[@kaiguo3283]

Instead of banning Huawei, I think the US can invest more on 6G research to ensure its leadership in the future's technology....and then...so far, we see America just did nothing except banning.🤷‍♀️

[@generalx5220]

If sanctions get in the way. Move away from the dollar, freely do business with whoever you want, just move out from the dollar.

[@TheKkpop1]

It can slow but can't stop Huawei.

[@leky1325]

The real question: Can news media ever be independent?

[@pgdog888]

America. If we can compete with them. We ban them. 🤣🤣

[@shanservicesgroup2983]

Check out my latest report on 5G

[@joebloe1401]

Right on, Bro, Dats da way we like to do it!!! Ha ha ha! We goona ban you next, you turdball!

[@lisasimpsonisanaddict]

Pgdog888 I totally agree with you.

[@richardpalu7462]

America gunboat diplomacy in another form

[@hobbesy4457]

@Matt Bloskey Why you copy your words again and again. I doubt you are a Propaganda guy.

[@maypastermongalemongale5840]

This just a jealous from apple as huawei is beating them and the American expensive phone. If you can't beat them you ban them.

[@aceman00ify]

Huawei should leave the usa market altogether coz they will never stop moaning about China. Leave the usa to develop its own networks by itself, and China to lead the way in setting a new 5g standard for the whole world without american input.

[@fireballfpv1207]

YES THANK YOU PLEASE LEAVE. China and all of China's allies can use Huawei, oh wait that might be a problem since North Korea is China's only ally hahahaha

[@abhisheksingh715]

Whole world. Ha ha ha. What a joke ? No one needs substandard Chinese product and companies that report to CCP

[@aceman00ify]

@@abhisheksingh715 how can it be substandard if Huawei is leading the world in 5G technogy? That just means that the rest of the world is way below sub standard. America is so mad that they do not have control over this technology, and that's why they say its used by China to spy. What's the difference between China spying and USA spying??

[@dvnmnd5020]

@@aceman00ify The difference is the clear violation and disrespect for human rights lol

[@ggc7318]

@@aceman00ify In USA, you can protest against any politicans and system. USA have had many of such transformation. In China there is only one party, and it is ALWAYS right. One cannot question or challenge it. That is the main difference. If you believe CCP is always right than you can welcome CCP to your country or your digital ecology.Cheers.😄

[@Calvin6169]

Company vs company. country vs country. USA: All the same. I'll start "country vs company".

[@ellengran6814]

How much help did Huawei get from the government ? How much help did/does Lockheed Martin get from the government ?

[@gl2427]

Text book example of the pot calling the kettle black: 1:35

[@adafu2]

The pot calling a China porcelain cup black

[@yowu7446]

@@adafu2 the pot calling the wok black

[@jamesschmames6416]

US: we don't want the Chinese to do what we have for the last 40 years

[@yungchan8914]

US is so scare to lose to Huawei

[@craigsm1820]

How can they be scare when they are the ones banning it. U hVe marbles in your head. China so scare of losing its bats, because it only has 5 virus/deseasing running around in china

[@eastwood8857]

@@craigsm1820 You ban when you can't compete...

[@craigsm1820]

@@eastwood8857 You cant compete with CCP who follow no laws. you may as well be barbarians

[@fankefang]

@@craigsm1820 The barbarian CCP didn't invade any country in the past, not like the civilized western countries, which start wars everywhere, bombing countries like Iraq to stone age. The barbarian CCP contributed 80% poverty lifting world wide, not like the civilized western countries, which colonized the world for centuries. The barbarian CCP saved China from a semi-colonized country to a sovereign country and led it all the way to the second largest economy in the world in just several decades, not like the civilized western world, which put capital a higher priority than their own peoples' lives. Well they are capitalism systems after all, no blame to the leaders.

[@kamalabrahman6925]

@@craigsm1820 Here US is the barbarian. LOL

[@coffeemeblack]

Well said. All the guest speakers are neutral on this subject. I missed Eward Snowden.

[@majorskies7091]

If America is so great. Why can't it build it's own 5G network?

[@tonyvu2011]

Dell and AT&T consortium has had 5G tech even before Huawei, just not a big international market share like Huawei or Ericsson/Nokia

[@ggc7318]

We have 5 G. If you just google it. We are sensitive about prices and that was why all factories moved to China 40 years ago. Nothing new about 5 G. It is about whom we trust. They are all standard parts now. Huawei might have some patents, Nokia might have some patents, we just pay. That's all.

[@tonyvu2011]

@Matt Bloskey Chinese companies are backed with huge USD capitals with little or no interests, thanks to US trade deficit!

[@kaikunng]

Chinese government actually support most businesses especially those involved in high-level of technology. It's just normal.

[@lightening1296]

When China's getting close or ahead, they play dirty😂 After years of scrutiny, no backdoor found on Huawei. On the other side, Edward Snowdon, Wikileak, tapping on German chancellor Merkle lol.

[@pgtan8819]

How long can the US continue to print money for big ticket items ,especially when the economic situation is now so bad ?

[@craigsm1820]

They have more gold than the 2,3 and 4 combines. China sits at 6 before the kingold fraud. With 300% gdp before the covid. China is a scary prospect

[@eastwood8857]

@@craigsm1820 No, they don't, get yourself educated

[@craigsm1820]

@@eastwood8857 That come from my education. if not educated I dont have anything to say

[@norvstv1341]

My Company changing all our Equipment with Huawei

[@craigsm1820]

My conglomerate is throwing all Huawei out the window i cant even sell it. No one wants it

[@craigsm1820]

@Marius Chirita Na it just means hes a CCP 50 cent troll like you

[@norvstv1341]

@@craigsm1820 yeah cisco now no value, junk

[@craigsm1820]

@@norvstv1341 huawei is junk it break like Chinas dams

[@norvstv1341]

@@craigsm1820 cisco no 5G right?

[@waltertagg422]

We need 5G ... but not Chines 5G

[@flhong]

US find it hard to spies if using Huawei 5G so they willng to finance other countries if they use US 5G.

[@chaoranma7346]

Stay strong Huawei ! What does not kill you makes you stronger!!!!

[@Masterinchinese4578]

Huawei need to invest more in Asia ,Asia is also a big market

[@henrychuah9658]

The answer is no, huawei already build a very strong foundation.

[@craigsm1820]

And now its following china down the gurgla

[@Amidat]

@@craigsm1820 Huh? the only major country whose economy is growing is "down the gurgla"?

[@craigsm1820]

@@Amidat Aussie bud. Gurgler

[@manuelwide6791]

NO...

[@America_bombsTSMC]

Huawei is a signal that will prove which political system (combined with culture) is better. In U empire's view, it is more than technical aspect.

[@cklim3614]

USA do not the opposite thinking the signals they sent. It means Huawei must have excellent products to improve human standards of living

[@cyxixi8312]

There is Chinese saying ‘ thrive in hardship, die in comfort’. Thankfully, both Chinese government and people are waked up by US from the comfort dream!

[@craigsm1820]

I enjoy a good laugh

[@cyxixi8312]

craig smith haha, yeah, why not.

[@craigsm1820]

Life isnt worth living without dreams. Chinas dream is to live the life of Americans. I know your all jealous

[@cyxixi8312]

craig smith Of course some aspects of US but definitely not what the Americans are experiencing now, the high death toll, divided national identity...

[@cyxixi8312]

craig smith indeed, US middle class has a much easier and better life than China. but jealous... not that much actually. I have lived in both countries. But I don’t feel like I would only pick one. Both countries are good for me.

[@robertgittings8662]

*With this anchor, AJ sounded more and more like a US State Media 🤣🤣 or US' puppy media, should I say?*

[@noboundaryreporter9115]

Huawei will keep on growing....their research team 7 days a week n 24 hours per day while US is fighting covid-19. !

[@lisasimpsonisanaddict]

No never. Huawei is destined to groww

[@MrGyulaBudai]

US has no any telecom industry, especially 5G.

[@raymondtay3532]

Well done Huawei Superpower. 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽💪💪💪💪💪💪👏👏👏👏👏

[@onlygod5667]

Us ain't gonna stop Huawei...they might've stopped Toshiba in the 80s but Huawei isn't Japan!

[@anujsethi7845]

Why Al Jazeera always invite Indian on intellectual debate for neutral perspective

[@coroner3164]

What I admire most about capitalists is their ability to make the people they exploit willingly make choices against themselves and take pride in it.

[@thestranger7551]

usa is most untrestable alie ...of histry so ...no need advice

[@ggc7318]

We can't trust your bad English. 🤣

[@_feather189]

Yes, US can stop Huawei's expansion, but they can't stop Huawei's success.

[@ablam8]

Right today, Hauwei smart phones are number one in world wide sales.

[@ggc7318]

Really ?🤣

[@BS-wj1qu]

EU: How much is it?? US: It's $ 1billion my friend 😄 China: We can make it $500 millions Sir....plus we'll give you this & this for free 🙏🏻 US: 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡

[@hs5hdrtv]

No way because there are many innovations nowadays. Moreover, China is coming there is no way to stop this drastic world power. 🏃‍♀️🌎🤞💕😍🍀

[@bradpool127]

Documentary "The coming War On China" by journalist John Pilger. KZbin. Just, Wow.

[@empirecases4128]

There is a huge difference with a grant, loan and investment to a state funded company that has full access and control over the company.

[@bazle64]

Can Qatar have freedom for women?

[@MrLandonweber]

Al Jazeera always forgets to bring up that part, don't they! Another question, can China have freedom for women? As far as I can tell all the Asian countries have a problem in this area as well, it's just not as pronounced as in the middle east. Then you will hear the line about..."oh, it's the culture"... what, a culture of oppression...please!

[@saidsaeed2498]

Read my report on 5G. They are deleting my linked comments.

[@bazle64]

@@saidsaeed2498 read my report on home WIFI 5ghz routers

[@eminyilmaz5807]

no

[@joebloe1401]

Can you eat a banana from the inside out?

[@leslie48able]

A great thank you to all three speakers for being neutral in your opinions and insights. What's the logic or what kind of mentality (hypocritically) is this: the US ("government") is willing to SUPPORT/FINANCE (out of jealousy, envy...) other companies to (work for the US government) topple/cripple/downplay HUAWEI (merely on the "assumption that it is financed by the Chinese government")

[@robertgittings8662]

*🛑 With this anchor, AJ more and more sounds like a US State Media 🤣🤣 or US' puppy media, should I say?*

[@junkeatng]

For a business person trying to make ends meet, US policy is increasingly feeling like a ball and chain around the ankle of world trade. America First is feeling more like 'everybody else last'.

[@fireballfpv1207]

Stop doing business with a genocidal organ harvesting authoritarian regime then. The US is decoupling from China for Cold War round 2. China is not prepared

[@sevenadam1349]

these specialists didn't even get the essence of 5G which are eMBB uRLLC eMTC ,while AI is another thing, technic developments should be controlled with techniques not politics. how ignorant 🙄

[@albyrnes3815]

Long live Huawei, and other Chinese companies, may they continue to prosper, and grow and continue peacefully, benefiting their customers, without the interference of the Evil Empire, who’s only goals are death and destruction, and control of the World.

[@iechuanlee9326]

Huawei is the only company working with the scrutiny of and review by UK intelligent. In that point of view the Huawei is completely honest, clean and secure with their technology but due pressure from it's American allies. This really unfair from a democratic country, such as USA. US had done this before, by slowing, stopping companies or countries, in the 80s they did it with containing Japan, in the past with EU and now China. Huawei is one of the largest invested in technology and now they are reaping the reward and US are falling behind because US invest in wars.

[@liltom6364]

You cannot stop Huawei. Huwaei is popular in developing countries and in 3rd world countries too because its cheaper than US brands.

[@jasondong9721]

US: accuse China of spying Germany: who’s watching me France: who’s watching me US: only we’re allowed to spy on our Allie’s

[@eastwood8857]

Ironic, how the USA is worried about privacy...

[@estevencamacho]

Xi JinPing is a man worth emulating.

[@wolf-man-bear-pig-torque]

Yes and No. They can prevent some Huawei services from domestic markets, but entirely get rid of Huawei affiliated products would be nearly impossible. But people have to look at it this way...this entire industry is all intertwined with many different parts from many different companies involving several countries. Some companies have highly value patents instead of parts. All they do is design and legal. Some companies don't do anything else but just make the parts. Some just make the equipment that makes the parts. There's so many unique things about this field. Not one country, region or company has complete control over it. It's been that way for decades. There's companies that do business with Huawei that has parts in Ericsson and Nokia too. Overall, Huawei is just one big piece of this puzzle.

[@cashcash5995]

Nothing the US could not stop Huawei, there will not be one American global internet network , but two .

[@youngz13o]

Another way to ask this question, is can the US stop 5G deployment?

[@Sean-he3cm]

Permit granted to HW for security-based 5G and infrastructure build-up is like contracting a thermal power plant to Green Peace.

[@jricky7981]

Support Huawei!!!!!!!!!!! I love Huawei!!!!!!!

[@customerservice9676]

You know you have advanced tech when a mobile phone is on the skin like a tattoo

[@HuaJarry]

that's the noise that it only can make before falling down.

[@iamas1825]

I'm using huawei tab

[@YoungTang]

This is the rare panel thats actually using facts and being fair on this topic.

[@KL-gp3zz]

that guy lose all creditability when he say Huawei's success is no different than HP or Apple

[@henrysmith1464]

Anchorman is professional indeed, trying to ask most relevant questions on behalf of audience in the States and Europe. Three experts also are good and very diplomatic indeed to please the imagined audience in their minds but with their professional pride not to fake or distort. Only thing I want to add is that all events so far around Huawei mght have quite unexpected impact on shaping a new round of the polictically correct thinking and expressions. People want to have simple answers to sophisticated questions. It is human nature.

[@francislililles8360]

yep the US can they have the influence and capacity but of course this time at a cost as many telecommunication companies already had Huawei as a major part of their infra replacing it would be expensive and they will not do it just because the US said it

[@Luke-iq9yk]

Interesting and knowledgeable guests but says it all really when the university professor will not speak on behalf of the institution that he works for. This is all about who advances and controls the next generation of Technology here. The Americans have been overtaken in some areas by the Chinese and they clearly feel very uncomfortable. I'd say the Chinese are geniuses if they come out of this unscathed and deserving of me buying a P50. Sadly, I think we are diverging and will be forced to choose sides.

[@tanemana1]

You left out one crucial question: Will the country that is putting 5G in be financially able to build the required network infrastructure, and how will security in using the network be confirmed!

[@0MVR_0]

The premise of this video is: 'Can a sovereign nation [that happens to be the most economically advantaged] intervene in the growth of a foreign private organization?'

[@janicechan6427]

What rights has US has to stop other technology, and their claims are baseless

[@geirkarlsen7329]

Because it is stolen technology.. Who has the right to not pay back for that.. Millions of billions of dollars. And then the list of the other millions of items copied.. Copyright is an international law.. Are you living in a world where China is located on the moon?..

[@9up9up9up]

So US govt bought MS Windows licenses, does that mean US directly funded Microsoft? BTW, am I going to get sanctioned by the US for saying this?

[@umedavk2011]

James, you've made a fundamentally important point which everyone on this forum is missing : you have fundamental rights in the US (or any democracy) which govts can't tread over. An independent judiciary makes sure of this. In China................................

[@9up9up9up]

@@umedavk2011 "any democracy" I hope you are including India.

[@Richard-yy8tn]

So much propaganda out there. My gf have been using the Huawei P30 pro for 1.5 years now, no problems. I have noticed that when I talk about things near my Samsung S9+ I would suddenly get those advertisements on my browser. Not saying its Samsung's fault, I love the phone, just an observation.

[@joechua8041]

US is more concern for UK, than US itself. Why.?

[@jeffrythoksapan]

Once we start with huawei , American CIA became hopeless agency.

[@craigsm1820]

Huawei = china = jail keep it!

[@lifeline8489]

Nobody can stop China/Huawei.

[@taniscantu3147]

Yeah just sentence the lady to life in prison for spying or better yet give her the death penalty.

[@AnsonLoo]

John made a very good point, when everyone is scrutinising at Huawei security now, it will be more lucrative for someone to slip into other providers, the more scrutiny Huawei had the more secure it will be, if I want to build my 5G network I definitely will choose the one on the hotspot because I will save a lot of verification cost and having the world top cyber security scrutinise it's system on my behalf, for free.

[@alastive]

If Huawei is a private company, then why would Ren Zhen Fei handover reign of the company to some unknown person? Such thing is never heard of. The other thing is that a lot of conversation had mistook manufacturing for innovation. USA is still leading tech innovations, it's just that America's high cost had made it not fit for manufacturing, but it could change in the near future.

[@laopang91362]

The short answer is no. I thought it was a very short sighted move.

[@pahatpahat9566]

One of the better documentaries on 5G! Fair with plenty of commonsense in their comments.

[@greatvanchang5289]

the question should be why rather than can