Canaanite Origins | DNA | Geneticist Razib Khan

[@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449]

What are your thoughts on the origins of the Canaanites? Support Mr. Khan and his work above! Celebrate the birthplace of civilization and get our Sumerian Shirt | Hoodie | Coffee Mug today! CLOTHES: teespring.com/Sumerian-Clothing?pid=212&cid=5818 COFFEE MUGS: teespring.com/sumerian-coffee-mug?pid=658&cid=102908 Check out our new store! teespring.com/stores/the-history-shop Get your Sea Peoples | Late Bronze Age Merch below! Mugs: teespring.com/new-sea-peoples-mediterranean?pid=658&cid=102950 Hoodies | Shirts | Tank Tops: teespring.com/get-sea-peoples-mediterranean?pid=212&cid=5819 Get your Hittite Merch below! Mugs: teespring.com/HittiteEmpireMug?pid=658&cid=102950&sid=front Shirts | Tank Tops | Hoodies: teespring.com/hittite-empire-shirt?pid=2&cid=2397 Trojan War Merch Below! Mugs: teespring.com/trojan-war-coffee-mug?pid=658&cid=102950 Tank Tops | Shirts | Hoodies: teespring.com/TrojanWarShirt?pid=2&cid=2397 To support the channel, become a Patron and make history matter! Patreon: www.patreon.com/The_Study_of_Antiquity_and_the_Middle_Ages Donate directly to PayPal: paypal.me/NickBarksdale Enjoy history merchandise? Check out affiliate link to SPQR Emporium! spqr-emporium.com?aff=3 *Disclaimer, the link above is an affiliate link which means we will earn a generous commission from your magnificent purchase, just another way to help out the channel! Join our community! Facebook Page: facebook.com/THESTUDYOFANTIQUITYANDTHEMIDDLEAGES/ Twitter: twitter.com/NickBarksdale Instagram: instagram.com/study_of_antiquity_middle_ages/ Facebook Group: facebook.com/groups/164050034145170/

[@Tharmaraj.humanity]

You are an idiot. Look at your self. What are you.who you. You are nothing on planet earth.. what the hell you are talking about you idiot. Thanks.

[@paulbedsonwpgb]

It might help to know that the Natufian (Heavy Neolithic Qaraoun Culture in Lebanese Archaeology) capital was at the start of the Jordan, not at Jericho, when considering the origins of the Caananites. everipedia.org/search?input=aaiha

[@fordprefect5304]

@@Tharmaraj.humanity LMAO and you facts are? Let me help you there are none.

[@medit8iv_native970]

The land of Canaan was classed as anywhere to the east, its talking about all of eurasia, so to the first peoples to leave Africa were from the ancestors of the aboriginal Australians, so why wouldn't the peoples of oceania and the americas be the land of canaan, in our history it aligns with our ancestor kane. The Bible is not good at all because its warped scripture from Egypt and Egypts script was from South east Asia, the cradle of civilization.

[@fordprefect5304]

@@medit8iv_native970 Canaan was part of the Levant no more no less. Take your fairy tales elsewhere.

[@Hollylivengood]

I love this. I used to hate history in school, but when you finally get to read some real history and see videos like this, history is essential to learn.

[@lordguts1961]

You still hate history, and that's why you can't read the book and find the truth

[@ghabilihabennywally9354]

I just opened to your channel and enjoyed listening to Mr. Khan's DNA research on the Canaanite genotypes integration history and find this very interesting and have subscribe to learn more. Thanks alot. God bless.

[@KeithShuler]

Cutting edge doc! And it makes a lot of sense.

[@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449]

Appreciate it Keith! As always your support means the world!

[@davidhill5897]

A very large and complicated subject to say the least. Thank you for your interesting presentation.

[@Brandazzo22]

You really got a top notch professional from the field. I'm definitely interested to see more history and genetic stuff in the future. Pretty cool the I wonder if he can trace the DNA origins of ancient Romans (pre-republic).

[@godschild3640]

YOU💚 JUST 💚LIED 💚IN 💚FRONT💚 OF GOD. 💚BY. KRISTIN ROMEY … living descendants of biblical Canaanites identified. VIA DNA 🧬…. YOU JUST LIED RIGHT IN FRONT OF GOD AND A LIAR GETS TO GO TO HEAVEN LET’S USE DNA IN THE HOLY BIBLE TOGETHER A DEUTERONOMY 20. :17. And. SIDON IN BIBLE ….BEHIND THE PROUD KING OF TYRE WAS LUCIFER WHO FELL TO BECOME SATAN

[@puraLusa]

That's very difficult because early on roman citizenship became a status and not a tribal identity. A roman could be from anywhere in the empire.

[@CalienteDesign]

Already been done by other groups

[@frederickschwarz3883]

My Man! EXCRUCIATINGLY Fascinating - best 13+ minutes spent today 😊 SUBSCRIBED

[@ConnortheCanaanite]

I’m of Natufian ancestry, I’m most ethnically similar to Moroccan Jews, Mizrahi Jews, Libyans, Algerians, Tunisians, Druze, Bedouin, Mozabite and Cypriots.

[@grandwonder5858]

The Jews that migrated from Europe and now occupying Palestine are not native to Palestine. They are white people that have converted to Judaism.

[@NicholBrummer]

DNA nor ancestry are actually the same as ethnic group, which is largely a cultural social construct. Still fun stuff. I have some KhoiSan DNA, about a dozen slaves from asia and africa, next to my mostly rather wide European mix of origens. Does make me feel connected.

[@ConnortheCanaanite]

@@NicholBrummer That’s technically true but there’s definitely an ethnic element to genetic origins. Hence why we can at least moderately distinguish between these various population groups. I have European ancestry as well within my genetics, mostly paternally and maternally quite a bit of my genetics have a Levantine or North African origin. I also have some genetic proximities to Spanish and North Italians, when it comes to Spain or Iberia, it has seen many different civilizations, ethnic groups and populations reside within it. As it has been under control of Basque, Phoenician/Punics or Canaanite populations, Gothic, Jewish, Muslim and much more has contributed to the population that makes up modern Spain. As it was also once the Al-Andalus Caliphate and had many conversions to Christianity from the time of Visigothic control and the Reconquista. These lead to many of these converted populations moving, changing their names and falsifying baptismal records to avoid being considered a Converso or Crypto. My European genetics tend to be a mix or close to that of Irish, Spanish, Swedes, North Italians and Ukrainians or Russian Finno-Ugric groups. Then the ‘MENA’ genetics tend to be closest to aforementioned Moroccan Jews and other groups listed or even Palestinians, Egyptians and Moroccans in general. So that makes it difficult to distinguish one ethnic group over the other. In the US, people often assume or think I’m Hispanic actually but they’re not as familiar with ‘MENA’ ethnic groups as they are with Hispanics due to proximity.

[@davidfryer9359]

I have northern African origins. Would that be the same?

[@natybar-yosef9931]

Dude they lived 12000 years ago dont speak bulshit

[@shanecarubbi7864]

Good video Nick, and that is an impressive collection of books you have 👍👍

[@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449]

Thanks Shane! Appreciate it!

[@thecanaanite]

Awesome episode. As a canaanite myself i can appreciate this

[@thecanaanite]

@roberto lang sure

[@Korilakkumasusie]

Are you evil like the devil ??

[@yousefizziddeann5789]

​@robertolang9684DNA wise Lebanese and Palestinians are Cannanites. Europeans are no where in this

[@yousefizziddeann5789]

@robertolang9684 Cannanites are Middle Eastern if you're not a pure European then yes MAYBE you're Cannanite but if you're full European keep dreaming about being Cannanite

[@AT-gu8by]

Canaanite’s are black they are the son of Ham who is black and African.

[@marnieweaver3935]

He's so interesting and says things in a very conversational way.

[@Bill87762]

Very informative, brings my personal research to cultural mixing in the early bronze age, thanks for confirming

[@adinacohen3675]

Very fascinating! Good work! In line with all my research on the topic

[@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449]

For those with questions on the Philistine study we discuss towards the end Khan sent me this link just for you! Ancient DNA sheds light on the genetic origins of early Iron Age Philistines advances.sciencemag.org/content/5/7/eaax0061

[@SisterWomen]

Looking good. I respect and admire the work of Mr Khan. I also like him and think he's cool. Good stuff.

[@jenniferhill5375]

Intriguing!!!

[@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449]

Thanks for watching!!!

[@SisterWomen]

@@jenniferhill5375 I often wonder how scared I would be if I was the speaker to read the rude and smug and hateful comments. I've been there. But come on. Saying something supportive that's also true is worth it, even if someone acts like a smart-ass, because these folks put themselves out there and I honestly admire them for it.

[@themaskedman5954]

Also mention that he is a racist

[@godschild3640]

@@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449 💋MATHIEW. 17:2. ✝️

[@Alex_Plante]

Finally, an episode that lives up to the title!

[@JayWest14]

I truly enjoy all your work Nick!!

[@alexandros6433]

Great video! A video about the origins of the peoples populating modern syria will be awesome

[@lo-fihi-ki5699]

most are Arabs from the Arab invasion, mixed the phonecian canaanites, turks, and greek/romans... the original inhabitants of the levant had red hair similar to the people of Ireland

[@alexandros6433]

@@lo-fihi-ki5699 sources?

[@nahaloz1816]

I think it’s worth noting that the philistines that in bible time were mainly residing on the south shores of C’naan while the Israelites were inland. Fun fact is that the Roman Empire changed the name of Judea to Palestine at 2nd century CE after quashing the Bar Kochva Jewish rebellion. It is mostly a consensus that it was done in order to punish the Jews but not sure that the reason for the name change is documented as the fact that the name was changed.

[@juniatapark54]

The Greeks had been calling that land Palestine for centuries before the Romans used the name. The Romans were the first to use Palestine as the name of a governmental unit. Roman Palestine was larger than Judea, it included the coast, and if memory serves, the Galilee.

[@sidvicious6505]

Juniatapark is more less correct although not Palestine per say but the Greek equivalent.

[@knows_too_much]

@@juniatapark54 No, the term Palestinos appear in greek sources which is Philistia in Greek. Calling the entire land Philistia is a mistake that only people who had no clue could make. The people actually living in the land called it Israel and Judah/Judea, and the Romans had the province of Judea.

[@SketchyGhettoSpic]

​@juniatapark54 It doesn't matter what the Greeks called the Israelites or their native land. The Greeks were famous for inventing names for dozens of nations which sound nothing like the original names.

[@johnrambo6576]

Facts is pure text's with prof in civilizations based.

[@orchidorio]

Well done. I love learning more about this. Thanks ! (3/20/21)

[@YNomadicDusk]

Oh my word! This is exactly where my interest lay. This is wonderful, thank-you, 🙏. Where can I learn more pls?

[@lo-fihi-ki5699]

look up art from the phonecians and Canaanite and carthaginians... carthaginians made a lot of glass art both of themselves and the babylonians they traded with... canaanites had red hair and babylonians had black hair.. both seem to have blue eyes in some of their populations ... the art of Carthage is beautiful .... after that youbshould look into the scythians who possibly predate egypt and for a while ruled the levant and north eastern loran of egypt... the scythians are said to be the ancestors of the Celts/ and other aryan tribes before they settled in Europe

[@YNomadicDusk]

@@lo-fihi-ki5699 🙏

[@YNomadicDusk]

@@lo-fihi-ki5699 🙏

[@Blalack77]

That's a cool shirt. I think only history nerds would get it - but I guess that's the point. "Sea Peoples Mediterranean Tour" lol... Also, history and genetics mixed together - that makes for an ultra fascinating topic. I always wonder about one when hearing about the other. I'm a new subscriber. This stuff is right up my alley.

[@NormBoyle]

Thanks for the video. This pretty much is what I think most historians expected. Its generally agreed that the Phillistines were called the Peleset by the Egyptians. The Egyptians permitted these sea peoples to settle in what is now Israel to be a buffer to the canaanites. The phillistines were Aegian/Greek, but intermarried with canaanites. From what I have read, most Palestinians today are a mix of canaanite and arab. The Israelis have as much canaanite ancestry as the Palestinians, roughly 50%, but they lack the Arab contribution and have more Greek, Roman Persian and other European dna mixed in. That mixing mainly happened long ago.

[@lebanonchristian3951]

Christians in Lebanon differ from the muslims in DNA , the land of Lebanon were cannites people before the muslims at year 700 started attacking and going to the area and converting some to islam. That explains why there is difference, also the muslims that have canaanites DNA were from the ones that have been converted and but also mixed with arabs . That's facts

[@priestessofanat470]

@robertolang9684 no, they didn't. if you mean old iran, i agree, but not that much as the levantines.

[@priestessofanat470]

@@lebanonchristian3951 "Christians in Lebanon differ from the muslims in DNA" it depends on the references. In general, they don't differ.

[@therealpsychotrader]

This actually is not fact, and based on your name it is pretty safe to say that you're here to spread your own biased "facts".@@lebanonchristian3951

[@grandwonder5858]

The Jews that migrated from Europe and now occupying Palestine are not native to Palestine. They are white people that have converted to Judaism. I even had a couple of Jewish elders told me Jews are white people 100% similar to Irish and Germans despite his insistent that those white Jews once lived in Palestine a couple of thousands years ago, which doesn’t make sense to me since white people were not originally from Palestine! He wanted me to believe that Jews are as white as the Germans, but yet they were originally from Palestine instead of Europe! Which is all BS from what I know about the real Jewish people from ancient time! They’re definitely aren’t white people like the Jews that are occupying Palestine today! They are 100% Europeans that have adopted Jewish beliefs and that’s why they are blond haired and blue eyed! The original Jews are brown-skinned just like the Palestinian people, but they aren’t related to the European Jews in any way genetically!

[@JeffNeelzebub]

Please have Razib on to talk about ancient Egyptian DNA and their modern descendants. It would be a fascinating topic and one that would upset a great many people, but it would be truth.

[@adhamabulhassan6059]

@GIRGIS ATREES ⲅⲓⲣⲅⲓⲥ ⲁⲧⲣⲉⲉⲥ most of Egyptians are actually arabized Coptic arab blood in Egypt is 10 to 15% which makes sense it’s impossible for arabs tribes to replace the entire population

[@uncannyvalley2350]

Yep, the baal worshippers who sacrificed children were white, they're still here worshipping him as Christians. I for one would love to see the look on their faces

[@JeffNeelzebub]

@GIRGIS ATREES ⲅⲓⲣⲅⲓⲥ ⲁⲧⲣⲉⲉⲥ The “Arab Egyptians” also have a larger amount of non-Egyptian North African ancestry (Libyan) and sub-sharan African ancestry. While Copts have all of this too, as well as Arab introgression, the Copts are more “pure” and similar to ancient Egyptian mummy DNA than Arab Egyptians.

[@jhix9155]

@@uncannyvalley2350 ourworldindata.org/violence-against-rights-for-children Yeah, sorry bud. Look where the most violence is against children today. You can't take small religious cult sects and place it on anyone with White skin either

[@daniverson5860]

It would really be great to know the relationship between cultures of the neolithic and chalcolithic Nile valley and those of the southern Levant to try and confirm if the urheimat of the semitic languages is in fact in Ethiopia or if the direction of migration is different.

[@MegaDublinguy]

Fascinating series!

[@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449]

Thank you!

[@PC-lu3zf]

There may have been a small group of slaves who returned home to Canaan but they were Canaanites not Israelites and on their way home they encountered a mystery tribe in north Arabia who worshiped one God and they adopted him and told other Canaanite people from the country side about him. These peoples were escaping possibly the tyranny of the city States ruled by despotic kings who were politically allied to Egypt and may have sent slaves to Egypt.

[@DL-tp2nr]

Sure the Canaanites worshipped baal and ashteroh caanan was the son of Noah’s wife whom ham raped in drunkenness that’s why Noah cursed him

[@dave-o3674]

I recently like within the oast 5 years started reading about Egyptian Mythology after I had been buying gemstones and jewelry, anytime I purchased gemstones I would check on healing priorities luck or whatever was associated with the stone..i was just basically quickly checking on extra benefits of gemstones..amd i came across a story from Roman emperor basically the story i read was the emperor was telling GOVERNMENT SECRETS, basically saying he was trying to find something Moses had, and he was saying the Hebrew majority is lept stupid by thwir leaders, as if currently now if another government wanted to find something your goven me hid ABD THE BELIEVE IT EXIST they will hqve to educated you, even if the plqn to invade later, so basically hevsays Moses dad had Sapphire mines gold and silver mines, he had chemist scientist researchers,..the emperor says the ten commandments were most lilely large sapphires *large gemstone exist with carvings* basically Moses sent his SOLDIERS into Cannan woth out educated them about those people abd didn't want any left alive, , but the canoniites had mines researchers and chemist religious leaders treasures of other conquered cities as if he didn't want his people to know that stuff also there are mines outside Cannon with people maybe canoniites that are slaves that if moses people killed everyone they wouldn't find out about the mines, also there would be holy places magical places the cannonites had outside the city... Anyhow the emperor was telling about that, to find something either Moses had and hid or something cannonites had and was lost or hidden.. as in how big were the people cannonites enslaved or what type of research chemistry did they know of,..,... I came across that type of thinking learning that gemstones can be remade when broken, sort of like gold melted and like glass but LABORATORIES AND BACK THEM THEY COULD TELL IF IT WAS *HEATED*, you buy gemstones that are remade like that but some Don't think of those as natural BUT SOME DO AND THEY SAY THEY HAVE DONE THAT IN ANCIENT TIMES HOW CAN OUR CURRENT LABORATORIES ACT AS IF THOSE ANCIENT STONES ARE WORTH LESS (THEY ARE NOT TOTALLY WORTHLESS JUST WORTH LESS THEN NATURAL STONES)

[@YadinZedek777]

I would definitely allow Razib to analyze my DNA. I think we would definitely have to make a video about it.

[@bencopeland3560]

Always enjoy Razib Kahn’s appearances.

[@mohammedaldadah2178]

I like how this video had no end result

[@Bogey1022]

He's one of my favorite guests. He makes dna make sense

[@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449]

Couldn't agree more!

[@Seekay-oe3qz]

There is no greater joy to be on a field expedition & unearth to reconnect with human & the earth's ancient past - no amount of wealth can equate to that feeling - it's like being in a instant time warp & if it's a city oh boy ! What joy to see the steps taken way back then so we could have the world we inherited wrt knowledge.

[@supr4rce]

The problem with relying strictly on genetics as proof of identity is that it doesn’t truly explain history, it just identifies someone was there. Razib is 100% correct in his genetic analysis of modern Middle Eastern populations but he’s working from an incomplete understanding of chronological Middle Eastern and biblical history. For example; if 4,000 years from now, future geneticists used genetic analyses and artefacts to define ancient American history and nobody explained the Americas were colonized by European people starting in the 16th century-4,000 years from now people would believe the indigenous populations of America were primarily Indo-European due to a dominant Indo-European genetic component and artefacts such as Mount Rushmore, the Statue of Liberty, Christian iconography and the Christ Redeemer statue in Rio de Janeiro. We all know that’s a completely erroneous ethnic history but the genetic analysis and archeological record would remain 100% scientifically correct in establishing a false narrative of an indigenous-European America. Why? Because the history of the Americas being colonized was forgotten or purposely removed to establish a revisionist history. That’s the same problem with using genetics to explain who the Canaanites were-there’s important aspects of Middle Eastern history being neglected and unexplained to formulate that modern day middle Easterners who are genetically Anatolian and Eurasian are Hamitic Canaanites?!?! Ham Also Kham. Literal meanings are hot, burnt or dark (father of the Negroid races - Hamites). He was the progenitor of: Genesis 10:6 KJV [6] And the sons of Ham; Cush, and Mizraim, and Phut, and Canaan. So the first-hand biblical account says the Canaanites were a race of black people (black isn’t a race) but modern geneticists found they were primarily Indo-European?!?! So which should we believe; the first-hand accounts of people who interacted with the Canaanites for thousands of years or modern day geneticists who haven’t and never knew them. Because according to his genetic findings, the Canaanites are more likely descendants of Noah’s son Japheth rather than Ham. Japheth Also Diphath. Literal meanings are opened, enlarged, fair or light (father of the Caucasoid/Indo-Europoid, Indo-European, Indo-Germanic, or Indo-Aryan races - Japhethites). Japheth is the progenitor of seven sons: Genesis 10:2 KJV [2] The sons of Japheth; Gomer, and Magog, and Madai, and Javan, and Tubal, and Meshech, and Tiras. My point is; biblical history chronicles that the descendants of Japheth (Indo-Europeans/Eurasians also known as the families of the north) invading, slaughtering, colonizing and pushing out most, if not all of the indigenous populations of the ancient Middle East and culturally appropriating them. Jeremiah 25:9 KJV [9] Behold, I will send and take all the families of the north, saith the Lord, and Nebuchadrezzar the king of Babylon, my servant, and will bring them against this land, and against the inhabitants thereof, and against all these nations round about, and will utterly destroy them, and make them an astonishment, and an hissing, and perpetual desolations. Perpetual desolation means permanently removed. So how can modern day Middle Easterners be genetically affiliated with people that they pushed out and weren’t genetically related to at all? It’s the same thing as the “native Euro-American” example I gave above-the Canaanites were not ethnically Indo-European or of a modern Arab affinity, they were a race of black people.

[@Msh-ip4vn]

White people aren't Japhetic people and all black people aren't decendants of Ham.

[@supr4rce]

@@Msh-ip4vn ….sure buddy….!

[@Msh-ip4vn]

@@supr4rce So how did the different races come to exist??

[@supr4rce]

@@Msh-ip4vn Do you want the genetic explanation or the biblical explanation?

[@Msh-ip4vn]

@@supr4rce There's only one race whose dna can mutate and create different races. Who has the domininant genes?

[@helmutzollner5496]

Very interesting. Had not known about the Phoenician natuvian link.

[@thomaslangkvist5830]

V - eniseans. As people of Vinece

[@paulphelps7809]

Much appreciate this report and Mr. Khan's research.

[@Changamira]

Look at the Akkadian/Amorite art of the palace of Zimrilim in Mari, or the artwork in the Egyptian tomb of Rekhmire if you want to observe just how phenotypically diverse the ancient near east was, through the archeological record.

[@il967]

Meh, I wouldn't say they are phenotypically diverse. Skin color, hair color, and eye color are only a small fraction of phenotypes

[@danythrinbell1596]

that guys think that great civilizations died after been invaded , it is not the case when the Hittite empire was overrun its people like today seek refuge next door so the people integrated others civilization like the Neo-Hittites , the Hunrians , the Canaanites you name it

[@fivecinco5923]

@@danythrinbell1596 These are fanciful and news theories. I invite you to read the book: "1177 BC, the day civilization collapsed" Eric Cline, American archaeologist, historian and anthropologist, proposes in this book to tell the end of the civilizations of the Bronze Age. Why did centuries-old civilizations collapse overnight? Throughout acts (and not chapters) which span from the 14th to the 12th century BC, the author tells us about the first globalization, the complex systems uniting these peoples and, as a culmination, the different theories that can explain their disappearances

[@TeeSpells]

​@@il967If the art is showing all dark skinned curly to nappy hair people in various lands mean a major population displacement of the orginal inhabitants of those regions because the people in these lands as we speak no longer look like that whatsoever.

[@pennylockhart9553]

​@@fivecinco5923 thanks for the recommendation. Going to check it out.

[@beebee242]

Razib is spot on.

[@freepagan]

Not exactly. See my comment above-- *Razib is off on how modern Levantines relate to the Canaanites. There is substantial European and Caucasian influence on the Levant today. Especially in Lebanon. I'm Lebanese, and I have about 30% European admixture, mostly from Southern Europe. This is not from an ethnicity estimate, this is from admixture calculators that interpreted my raw autosomal DNA. And it's not just me, most Lebanese people have a high amount of European admixture, that's why we look the way we do. There's a deep ancestral connection there. In addition, Razib assumes without question that the Phoenicians were merely Canaanites. This is not true. They were Canaanites mixed with other peoples (Sardinians among others). Check out a paper from 2018 by Zalloua et al that shows that*.

[@aj7009]

DNA Rules❗👍

[@Nabonidus-m7x]

This was amazing! Thank you and Dr. Khan for the wonderful discussion. Could you do a video on the Amorites and their origins? From the Mesopotamian descriptions of the Amorites, it sounds like they were extremely similar to Arab bedouins.

[@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449]

Thanks for commenting! This sounds like a great idea!

[@theconnecteduniverse1video629]

The amorit came from iran steppes " zagrous mountains "

[@box5319]

I think the amorite Bedouin are people carrying haplogroup T

[@فالغارفخشذ]

@@theconnecteduniverse1video629 no

[@lordguts1961]

Amazing lie

[@xHASSUNAx]

Loving Khan's Goldblum-esque way of explaining. Can listen to him all day!

[@daviddurham8583]

Nick, what are your thoughts on the recently discovered 10,500 year old basket found in a cave near the Dead Sea? Sometimes a basket is just a basket, but it could also be a venerated object that was purposely hidden to protect it. It is certainly an unprecedented find. Likewise the 6000 year old mummified child...

[@joshuachalvarro1182]

You asked a question to a ghost. He is dead, in God's hands.

[@godschild3640]

@@joshuachalvarro1182. They 🩸murdered 🩸my white 🩸family🩸 and they🩸 will continue🩸 to murder us until 🩸Jesus Christ🩸 who is God in the flesh comes. 🩸✝️. They murdered Jesus Christ, who is God in the flesh for being white and the kings of Israel. You can see David’s picture a white man it’s all about the hate of white people and all the lies that you vomit out and we are not these people thank you Jesus Christ not using the holy Bible and not using DNA white people are not these people.

[@YadinZedek777]

Khan is correct and I can fill in the blank's for sure but only after he analyzes my DNA!

[@il967]

There are mostly Neolthic Anatolian + Chalcolithic Iranian + a natufian component

[@Schnooklebear71]

Very interesting.

[@TonyfromTO]

Im inclined to believe the canaanites, phoenicians,carthaginians and israelites are one in the same lineage. From the Levant to tarshish and perhaps even across the ocean. Many of the cconquistadors were previously moors and sefards after all. They possibly originated betwen east africa and the Caucasus mountains.

[@old_school_egyptian2903]

It's called the Aryan race.

[@TonyfromTO]

@@old_school_egyptian2903 aryan is iranic persian. Aryans and semites would be two branches of the caucasian stem.

[@TonyfromTO]

@Papisco Camara africans predate the bible and its patriarchs. Its biblical history that is a joke. Canaanites were afro-asiatics speakers ans being form the levant probably had fair and dark complexion. I would guess they were bronze skinned like native americans. Not "black", not "white"... probably had blue or green eyes too

[@yaruqadishi8326]

@@TonyfromTO the Land is Palestine aka Canaan.

[@TonyfromTO]

@@yaruqadishi8326 pun chanani

[@simonsays2774]

What nonsense, Israelites are not Canaanites, as he claims. Abraham came from Ukresh in the north of Mesopotamia, and probably had haplogroup T. From Abraham to Isaac there was a mutation which created haplogroup R1b. R1b predecessor haplogroups are often found in Jordan which do not go back to V88. Israelites had R1b, i.e. a completely different haplogroup to Canaanites with J1 or J2. The earth is also not older than 6000 years. This can be calculated using the biblical dates. The Radokrabon method does not work. Science knows this, but they use it to support the evolutionary ideology. Because it gives us incredibly high dates. And in the end, all talk of the Ice Age, Stone Age and Bronze Age is also part of the evolutionary ideology. DNA, especially Y-DNA, was initially much more reactive after Noah landed on Ararat. There were significantly more genetic mutations and new haplogroups in the first generations after the flood...

[@ieetrgun2620]

this comment is a perfect example of exactly why religious people are so extremely underrepresented in science and score much lower on iq tests

[@zache.1226]

Ashkenazi/Sephardi/Mizrahi Jews, Palestinians, Samaritans, and Lebanese = Canaanite derived populations

[@noahtylerpritchett2682]

yep

[@rgfhjfghjk.]

No, Jews and Palestinians are never related The closeness between them is the heart between a Palestinian and a person from Malta 1- The Jews are very diverse. The difference between the Jews of Laskenaz and the Mizrahi is like the difference between the Italians and the Iraqis Ashkenazi Jews, the closest people to them are the Italians, and they have only 10% of the genes from the Middle East. The Mizrahi Jews are the closest people to them, the Iraqis, and they have a higher percentage of the genes of the Levant 2- The Palestinians are closer to each other than they are to other peoples They are the most similar people to the genes of the people of Palestine in the Iron Age (the era in which most of the events of the Torah occurred) no the are not And these are the reasons

[@kakistocracyusa]

"Fused" BY the Bronze age. IOW, the Canaan was obviously completely intermixed long before Judea, or even ancient Egypt, ever existed. Life is complex.

[@WerIstWieJesus]

What is the relationship between the amorites and the canaanites?

[@pabloalvez915]

They were both Semitic peoples. Canaanites were a Western tribe, whereas Amorites were a Northwestern one, more closely related to Arameans. Im ancient Mesopotamia, with the sole exception of Sumerians, all peoples belonged to the Semitic Family, which also included Hebrews, Phoenicians, Chaldeans and Arabs.

[@benavraham4397]

The Bible in Genesis 10:15-19 names the Canaanite nations, and Amorites are among them. (Also the Hittites are named as being Canaanites, although the Hittite language was something like Greek and Armenian, and thier homeland seems to be what is today Turkey. Perhaps the Canaanite Hittites were a separate nation from the Anatolian Hittites, merely sharing a similar name. In Anatolia they were actually called "Hattites").

[@someone-wi4xl]

same people Canaanites = city dwellers Amorites = Nomads (mostly) their descendants are today's Arabs proven by Y-DNA

[@WerIstWieJesus]

@@someone-wi4xl That is exactly my guess. ... And I would add old testament jews.

[@someone-wi4xl]

@@WerIstWieJesus yes for that the Cohanim hyplotype Y-DNA meets up with Bedouin Arabians in 5000 years under this line www.yfull.com/tree/J-YSC0000234/ the same line has remains from Amorites Canaanites Phoenicians and above it (J-Z2331) found at 50% in Ebla , which has the oldest Semitic writing 2500 BCE

[@jibaruz]

Wow this guy is very intelligent Mr. Khan I will look more into you! Very educational and as a political nationalist in the current state of palestine I see this needs to be mentioned more - our canaanite ancestry.

[@koopon3900]

Are Palestinians Arabs or no?

[@jibaruz]

@@koopon3900 “arab” is a complicated identity but to put it into short, no, the palestinian identity refers to all the people that have lived in the land of palestine that today hold palestinian nationality. Most Palestinians are “Arabs” due to us speaking “arabic”. But this is the only factor for most of us, as our culture roots from Canaanites and we are the descendants.

[@Donnell91]

I know that everybody doesn't take biblical accounts for true history but I thought from the account of Genesis the Canaanites were mentioned along with Put, Mizraim. So would the ancient Canaanites have history in North / East Africa?

[@sargon4451]

I think the Hebrews applied the name Canaan to a figure that was cursed and designated to be forever subservient to 'his brothers' because it fitted their colonial, genocidal or expansionist agenda. The name Canaan was (and continues to be) a very popular surname in Lebanon and Syria and was a term describing tribal nationality since before the supposed exodus account.

[@uncannyvalley2350]

As I understand it Canaan is a Phoenician word for Serpent Kings, and imo denotes the fact Canaan was a colony of Egypt after the campaigns of Tutmoses III whose siege of Megiddo exactly mimic the biblical account of Jericho, even down to the counting of hands, looting of bodies, the narrow path access and use of ropes to enter the city. What we have is 2 egyptian colonies one of the Sun worshipping Egyptians and a more northern establishment following the Moon worship of Arkenahten at Tyre, aka Troy, as Jews begin their day at 6pm not 6am. They were well known to worship the stars, and in fact it was their knowledge of the constellations that is encoded in the Bible and allowed them to navigate the Mediterranean at night. Israel is the Phoenician word for Saturn aka El, fruit of Isis and Ra. This would also explain the accounts of a great war at Meggido (Armegeddon) which sat at the border of the two territories

[@sargon4451]

@@Lagolop It seems you didn't read the bible lately. Yahweh ordered the Israelites to kill all the inhabitants of the land of Canaan. Harsh it may be but if you have any complaints on this issue I am not the person who can help you with them.

[@fordprefect5304]

@@sargon4451 So why didn't they kill themselves?

[@carlomariaromano4320]

Well the Ancient Egyptians were pretty closely related to people from the Levant.

[@rnedlo9909]

Here is one outstanding fact: Our ancestors got around!!!!

[@PC-lu3zf]

The Bible take is legend I’m Jewish and I see the facts vs the myth. Also in ancient days people were telling stories not literal fact for fact history.

[@rayajao1566]

Jewish is not a real Jew

[@georgyzhukov6409]

@BRICKY MINDSET TV 💥 you need help😂

[@salchaw]

fascinating !

[@tzotzbalam7264]

Appreciate the hard work and effort you put in. Interestingly, Robert Graves in The White Goddess, wrote: "at different periods in the second millennium B.C., a confederacy of mercantile tribes, called in Egypt "the People of the Sea", were displaced from the Aegean area by invaders from the north-east, and south-east, that some of these wandered north....and eventually reached Britain and Ireland; ...Still others invaded Syria and Canaan, among them the Philistines, ..." He also mentions:"To the Egyptians these were all "Peoples of the Sea" forced by the pressure of the new Indo-European horde to emigrate from the coastal parts of Asia Minor as well as from Greece and the Aegean islands. The Pulesati became the Philistines of Southern Phoenicia;..." PEACE

[@ChroniclesofAlicha_Balaam]

@Tzotz Balam A great book indeed!!!

[@Historian212]

That book is very old, and a lot more is now known than during Graves' lifetime. I suggest you update your reading list.

[@English-Mark]

I would like to find out more about the tribe of Dan that he mentioned

[@shdwbnndbyyt]

Hmm, as a long time Bible reader... i NEVER thought of the Canaanites as mere punching bags. The Israelites were ordered by kill off 6 tribes, all of which were associated with the nephilim... the rest of the Canaanites were to be slowly driven out of the land because of their practice of child sacrifice, so that the Israelites would not adopt their practice -- but they did not drive them out and they did adopt the child sacrifice practice. However per the scriptures, people like Rahab, a Canaanite, married into the Israelites and into the lineage of King David.

[@thomaslangkvist5830]

Dey-fed. King of ancien waiils. Red Dragon royal house

[@EasternRomeOrthodoxy]

Absolutely false! The Greek DNA found was not of the Philistines (unless it was mtDNA) - it was from the Macedonian period! The Egyptian DNA that is found there is the one belonged to the Philistines who were an Egyptian subrace. Learn correctly the ancient findings. The tribe of Dan was not the Denyen and wasn't a Philistine tribe - another dumb secularist Zionist theory🤦‍♂️

[@regularbahamian]

cite ur sources

[@anthonyjordan8620]

I thought this guy didnt answer the questions. Only if your not schooled on how DNA or genetics works will you be happy with this guys answers. Inconclusive is what i hear and see. You cant cherry pick a few certain strategic locations for geopolitical purposes when it comes down to history. Better questions needs to be asked, how did the first group get there and from where did they come from? No group is just indigenous and thats it. Human migration, and we know that comes out of africa. He also mentioned that a genetic link merged from the north in turkey and greece. How does the dna test state WHEN certain genetic traces get introduced. Finally i hate when a "scientist" researches historical things with a biblical lense with a CHRISTIAN perspective like this guy kept alluding to, past history has shown that these opinions and research has been very biased and has been caught lying and white washing history. Over and over and over again

[@4sp3nF41r7]

What is your take on tying this in with..a blood types? And I know recently they have a new blood type

[@ronniereloaded]

Quite comprehensive. It would have been good to have quantitative info on percentage of Greek and nearby DNA among Philistines.

[@yaruqadishi8326]

They are mainly Canaanite locals the Philistines are. Youre using one side facts and info its not complete.

[@fordprefect5304]

@@yaruqadishi8326 Philistines are descendants of the sea people. The Egyptians wrote it in stone.

[@yaruqadishi8326]

@@fordprefect5304 sea people and Canaanite Palestine people. Your claim is a half truth here.

[@fordprefect5304]

@@yaruqadishi8326 The sea people invaded not just Egypt and the Levant but Anatolia and brought down the Hittite empire and went as far east to challenge the Assyrians. They were Mycenaean and western European. They destroyed Canaanite and Phoenician cities. You need to read a real history book

[@yaruqadishi8326]

@@fordprefect5304 sir I read real history books I read books I know where to research and actually make info and how to make info as well as find it and the point of what you're saying is incorrect there's ample proof that the Philistines are mixture of local Canaanites are Palestinians on the coast as well as Greek island and cyprien Pirates as well you're looking only at the Greekside not the Middle East part plus they don't speak Greek cuz their language is not even close to Indo-European or Hellenic there's so many people living in Palestine so they are in fact local Palestinians native Canaanites

[@ksrao269]

I am sorry. It's very very confusing. Somebody is chasing your guest speaker and he is in a great hurry to omit what he knows. Not useful. Rather a waste of time to watch the video.

[@elihinze3161]

Fascinating guy to listen to!

[@1trushadowclw642]

It seems like you avoid it saying that they were Hammatic like the Put, Cush & the rest of Africa. It's in the Bible 😊

[@thetartanu1535]

Can u please do a Assyrian Orgin! From a Assyrian💯🙏

[@fethimut645]

Kurdisch 100%

[@cheights1317]

When I think of the Canaanites I think of Ham, and his son Canaan and the 12 tribes of Israel and the land of Canaan

[@TeeSpells]

Even the old remains that they found which people fail to mention was basically identical to that of the very black Africans.

[@about2mount]

You must know that Shem outlived Abraham's wife Sarah by ten years. So Shem being the ancestrialvfather of Abraham must have been Meclagesedak King of Salem who actually owned all rhe lands that the Canaanites later took for themselves. Why else would Meclagesedak have Blessed Abraham ? Blessings were never done for bloodshed or battles. A high priest blessing a Descendent Son is more feasible.

[@TeeSpells]

@@about2mount Melchizedek was the most powerful prophet basically the Messiah before the Messiah existed. The Ethiopian bible has more details. Nonetheless Canaanites have always existed because the term Hebrew just came about due to the fact Isrealites spoke a Canaanite language.

[@about2mount]

@@TeeSpells He was still Shem and it was Shem who wrote this verse in Genesis also. It's actually rhe Prophecy about who Jesus was before being sent by God to become the savior. He Had no mother or father and was A Perpetual King and High Priest. As Shem was King over all of Israel's lands before the Canaanites took it after he died. So he blessed Abraham to be that Promised seed carrier. And only one man at that time was Blessed by God to be a high priest after Noah and that was only Shem. Being that Abraham calls him a High Priest let's us know as Bible readers that Meclagesedak is in fact Shem.

[@TeeSpells]

@@about2mount I would like to make a few points here. As I stated before the Canaanites always existed now to that point God only designated the Hamites land out of Noah's 3 sons. King Melchizedek was the King over the land of Canaan which is Ham seed. JERUSALEM was built by the Caanites before the Israelites/Hebrews ever existed because Abraham was known as the first Hebrew. He changed his name from Abram to Abraham. Abraham would become the father of many nations and his seed will grow in numbers. Abra-Ham is the the orgins of the Afro-Asiatic language. The Israelite tongue comes from the Hamites first and branched off to Western Asia. S-hem is Ham in the so called semitc language because of the vowels are interchangeble. Shem the semites means half Semi half of Hem/Ham-Asia. With that said just go through the genealogy of the Bible because Ham and Shem have always shared lands and bloodlines. From the very beginnings. Noah had 2 Ethiopian wives, Moses had Ethiopian wife, Solomon had Ethiopian wife, some dwell even dwell in the lands of Kush and had families of Ham etc.. Paul was mistaken for a Egyptian, Joseph and Moses. Jesus was sent to Egypt to hide. The Western Asian people looked identical to the Africans in Ancient times the East North Asians was more pale and had different features mixed with the Western Asians to become what we have today. Go look up depictions of the ancient Elamites they look like bearded Africans. The Island Elephanttine is Upper Egypt and they still look very much African different from the Lower Egypt. The Hebrews spent many years on that Island but that population never changed unlike the Lower Egypt. Which many migrations of other seeds changed the scope of the population. Tarahka the Ethiopian/Egyptian King saved the African Hebrews from the East North Asians that being the Syrians. You can also look up those images and see the very short hair kinky bearded orginal Asiactics. Why would Hebrews spend time amongst the Africans of Upper Egypt? Why would Hebrews ask the Ethiopian to save them? Also from my understanding it's the opposite away around Abraham gave tribute to Melchizedek in the form of tithes .

[@daniverson5860]

I wonder if anyone has done any work with genetic samples from the Ghassulian populations (4500-3500 BCE) specifically. I've read that general linguists seems to assume that they were pre-Semitic languages, but I don't understand how they come to that conclusion. There doesn't seem to have been a huge population turnover between the Natufians and the iron age, why/how would there be a significant linguistic change ? Alternatively, most of what I have read seems to indicate that the Ghassulian culture was a recent immigrant culture, which makes me wonder if they might not represent the incursion of Semitic languages into Asia ... is there a connection to say, the Badarian culture of the Nile (?)

[@pascalheimbach861]

We would like to have the Canaanite point of wiev in their struggle with Israel. There is not such Bible at disposal. Thank you for the work, but has it been done with the Israelis of Jewish faith for comparison ?

[@anthonyjordfan3312]

Ancient Gold Coast (Akwadaa) are the nepheline or the cananite

[@KnowledgeOverIndoctrination]

According to the genetics that Razib Khan referenced the Ashkelon_Iron_I_Post Ramses III "Philistines" carried YDNA Haplogroup J-L862 mtDNA T2c1c, YDNA Haplogroup R-M269 mtDNA H92, mtDNA I1, mtDNA T1a1.

[@KnowledgeOverIndoctrination]

@roberto lang Then you belong in the Flintstones. WILMA!!!

[@Biblical_DNA]

@roberto lang Yabba Dabba Doo! Bennett Greenspan belongs to Haplogroup J1. Natufians belonged to E1b1b1b2. The women are another story. MtDNA H, J2a2, N1b.

[@Biblical_DNA]

@roberto lang By the way, there is no such thing as European Canaanite. You sound silly. 🤣

[@Biblical_DNA]

@roberto lang I bet. Show me in Genetic Research. Give me the Article name.

[@Biblical_DNA]

@roberto lang Baqah were Haplogroup J1. They were not European. I am assuming you are trolling.

[@crhu319]

The plagues are likely real outcomes of one of the Thera/Santorini eruptions that were one or more absolutely catastrophic climate destroying events between 1450 and 1150 BCE. These absolutely destroyed Mycenaean and Minoan civilization and very much weakened Hittites who collapsed later but soon after. The plagues do logically follow in an order reflecting likely effects on the Nile ecosystem of an eruption about that far away. They seem to have been reported twice a couple hundred years apart, and they match fairly closely the Exodus list. There is a theological explanation of the later plagues in Tuts time. That being that the old gods wanted Amarna abandoned and their worship resumed - which DID happen. So where did the monotheists go? Probably northeast where other monotheists - Zoroastrian predecessors - already were. And where there were a ragtag bunch of survivors of tsunamis and subsequent pirate raids in a place Egypt abandoned: Canaan.

[@emanuelatodeva487]

My question to the speaker and the host is - why historians and DNA analysts link the Balkan samples to Greeks, when historically we are talking about Traco-Ilirians on the Balkans before the Greeks, or even earlier cultures - such as the Danube culture and Varna culture? Perhaps it is time to revise some historical records. It is already known that the so-called Greek DNA has a strong African component and it is not the most representative of the Balkan DNA. Using inaccurate labels has caused so much damage to our historical reccords - perhaps a broader framework will enable a better interpretation. Tracian tombs, ceramic vessels, golden artifacts, and ceramic plates precede the Greeks on the Balkans and some Mediterranean civilizations with at least 1000 years. I would like to suggest also more light on the Phrygians and the Gaelic kingdom in Anatolia and on the Balkans - to start bringing to surface those hidden migrations of people and cultures in these pre-history times. Let's use this wonderful program - to revise the historical misconceptions, and not to reinforce them! A suggestion also is to look at the work of Evgeni Delev - the genetics of the Bulgarians - for more light on the Balkan migrations.

[@jasona3884]

What are your thoughts on grandson of Esau reigning in area near Greece?

[@here_we_go_again2571]

@@jasona3884 Esau (Edom) lived in the area of Mt. Seir (modern Jordan) to the Negev (modern Israel.) That includes the area between the Dead Sea and the Gulf of Aqaba. Edom also can mean "red" ... The color of Esau's body hair according to the Bible. The red also refers to the red sandstone in what was once ancient Edom. The Torah discusses *Esau/Edom* vs. his younger twin brother *Jacob* But it is referring to the types portrayed by Jacob and Esau, the *sons of Issac* and Rebecca *Jacob* = God followers/peace vs. *Esau* = Rejecting God/anger/war The ancient Jews referred to the Romans as being warlike. It didn't help that the Roman client king of Biblical infamy was an Edomite named Herod the Great. He was a great builder but he was a really, nasty violent man. So, that was another philosophical link between Edom/Esau and Rome. The Torah discusses a similar analogy used earlier to describe *Issac* and *Ishmael* the *sons of Abraham* Issac was the son God promised to Abraham and Sarah. Ishmael was the son by Sarah's Egyptian maid named Hagar. (It was Sarah to encouraged Abraham to lay with Hagar) *Issac* = the child of promise. vs. *Ishamael* = "Wild ass of a man" fighting with everyone (He eventually repented)

[@Phar2Rekliss]

I like how he said nothing about palastinians having any ancestry from that land.

[@johnhbaldwin9178]

Not as insightful as I was expecting, more like we don't know yet and can't yet tell you the truth about what we're finding out, but keep watching.

[@mikeappleget482]

Sounds like you’re buying into the Khazarian Conspiracy Theory..

[@johnhbaldwin9178]

@@mikeappleget482 Are you Khazarian? I reread my comment, and have not seen where I mentioned Khazarians or King Bulan. Don't worry I'm not going to say anything bad or conspiratorial about your people. But I'm gonna keep my eye on you. LOL

[@old_school_egyptian2903]

The guy doesn't wanna say Aryan race. That's why it doesn't make sense.

[@deanfirnatine7814]

Umm that is not at all what he said

[@wolfsbaneandnightshade2166]

MORE!!!!!

[@studyofantiquityandthemidd4449]

Will do!

[@il967]

Proud to be Lebanese 🇱🇧

[@IvorMektin1701]

I like women too!😜

[@sargon4451]

That makes both of us but thankfully I hold only Cryptos, Gold, Silver, real estate and Indian stocks not Lebanese Pounds 😁

[@IvorMektin1701]

@@augustbliss Beirut is the Paris of Mediterranean

[@danythrinbell1596]

proud to be a iberian descendant of branch of the iranian hunther gathers and Egypt faraouns we are special

[@yaruqadishi8326]

Good love brother. Proud to be Palestinian and Lebanese too. 🇵🇸

[@Miki-fl9ez]

11:53. Goliat hailed from Europe it seems. So great that David...

[@brownhornet10]

Your bible says Canaan was Hams son so ..........?

[@fordprefect5304]

that was Spam. Have you tried the bacon flavored? It is really good

[@MoneyB-r2y]

​@@fordprefect5304another fragile nazi

[@keevancrawford6708]

“Curse of Ham” has a lot to do with the framing. Hyksos is said to be Jewish and others, similar to them working with Romans.

[@MelissaThompson432]

Well, that was informative. I somehow never even made the connection between "Philistine" and "Palestine." That will give you a clue about the (lack of ) depth of my knowledge of this area and its people.

[@rhyno9798]

Please do not be misled by these self serving thieves.

[@WTFisDrifting]

Area not the people. It was called Palestine after a region. The philistines were fully absorbed into the cultures by the time the region were given the name Palestinian. It’s region not a people.

[@MelissaThompson432]

@@WTFisDrifting Palestine means "land of the Philistines" in Greek. It's a compelling connection. 🙄

[@Hollylivengood]

@@rhyno9798 What are you on about?

[@lebanonchristian3951]

Christians in Lebanon differ from the muslims in DNA , the land of Lebanon were cannites people before the muslims at year 700 started attacking and going to the area and converting some to islam. That explains why there is difference, also the muslims that have canaanites DNA were from the ones that have been converted and but also mixed with arabs . That's facts .

[@l.b.d]

Natufians are the maternal ancestors of the Canaanites, as the Canaanites invaded and took Natufian wives. But the YDNA of Canaan was J2. The same blue eyed people that Israeli studies are saying transformed the ancient levant 6500 years ago. J is the brother group of I And K, and form the IJK parent group. I-YDNA is heavy for blue eyes and so are numerous branches of K such as R1a and R1b. Its safe to say that these bloodlines, including J, originally comprised of many blue eyed people, but due to intermixing with certain lineages those traits were lost for the most part. In the case of the Canaanites it was due to them taking Natufian wives. Blue eyes and blonde/red hair are recessive so they would quickly be lost, but still pop up here and there. Natufians male ydna was E1b, and Natufian men likely did survive the invasion / transformation. That said, for the most part, the Natufians as a people were wiped out.

[@deepblack67]

Would be neat to hear about the dispersal from the Levant of the X haplogroup that seams to be responsible for the megalithic sites across the Mediterranean including North Africa but also Egypt. Might be two separate developments but.... ? Post 5.5kbce flood seemed to cause many dispersal so very interesting. India maritime moves west, Levant maritime moves west.

[@sahihray8936]

According to the book of jubilees the sons of Ham were given all the territory west of the Nile, but Canaan being cursed went against the order and settle in the land of shem until God sent the Israelites to uproot them.

[@zechariahyudahisrael9695]

So before anyone accuses anyone of lying or instead insulting one's intelligence and calling people derogatory names, get your facts straight. @Study of Antiquity and the Middle Age. This is not directed to you. There are many people in the comments sections that are ignorant, this is not only on your videos this is worldwide, and your efforts at bringing us history is appreciated. Credit is given were credit is due, Thank you.

[@wisedragon173]

Game over for you and your lies. Canaanites were not black.

[@yaruqadishi8326]

@@wisedragon173 they are Palestinians today and we stand true forever as Canaan our home aka Palestine and Levant.

[@garymartin9777]

From an Old Testament point of view, the perverse cultures that satiated the region reviled the Hebrew god. Namely, he intensely despised the Egyptian culture which he considered riddled with perversion and immorality. He also hated the idolatry and practices of the various tribes in and around Canaan -- particularly the practice of child sacrifice as attributed to the idol Molech. He so despised child sacrifice that the penalty for any parent who did so was death by stoning. To rectify this situation he commissioned the Hebrews, whom he allegedly liberated from Egypt, to occupy Canaan which he designated the promised land and to destroy every vestige of the errant cultures. He commanded that every man, woman and child be destroyed, their livestock and their crops too. The Hebrews were then to create a model culture which others would admire for their success , high morality and fair dealings. They would hence wish to partake of the blessings of the Hebrew god to cash in on the peace and prosperity offered to this god's worshipers and adherents. He offered his blessings and guaranteed military success if the Hebrews followed his commandments and the law of Moses. This is the origin of the chosen people label.

[@TBD3.0]

It's wrong what's happening to the people of Palestine.

[@solocanaanite4655]

Plug in certain details into it, and you’ll find the Canaanite/Hittites became the Austronesians of southeast Asia learn you own history my people and find who we really are 💪🏽

[@فالغارفخشذ]

no

[@solocanaanite4655]

@@فالغارفخشذ yes

[@oreeg242]

​@@solocanaanite4655 no

[@user-hx5qz3tv8b]

Genetically, culturally, linguistically, and spiritually, the Canaanites are 100% Arabians. Modern day Syrians, Lebanese, Palestinians, and Iraqis are mostly Anatolians and Iranians. Original Canaanites ≠ Canaanized Anatolians.

[@yaruqadishi8326]

Canaanites are cousins to arabs ancient and later. The Palestinians today me are mix of both but we Palestinians are Canaanites today we never left and we stood true.

[@yaruqadishi8326]

@John High sham? Who the f*** is ham

[@yaruqadishi8326]

@John High Canaanites are people of Palestine Middle Eastern people you guys are way way alien to it so don't lie

[@yaruqadishi8326]

@John High arabs and Palestinians the true peoolw of the lands Canaan. Hence our name. We are Levant.

[@yaruqadishi8326]

@Dark M3ssiAh pseudo theories you using misrepresented points where'd you get it from Egypt origin which is run by a bunch of Afrocentric idiots who don't know anything about Egypt and Dolls don't know anything else

[@staticdynamic1605]

compelling episode

[@KnowledgeOverIndoctrination]

The Canaanites belong to YDNA J2b. While the Canaanite mtDNA carried a few different Haplogroups such as HV1b1, N1a3a, K1a, and R. They were mainly mtDNA H, which comes from a Near-Eastern to Caucasus origin. *Origin and Expansion of Haplogroup H, the Dominant Human Mitochondrial DNA Lineage in West Eurasia: The Near Eastern and Caucasian Perspective*

[@AllenBethea]

The earliest Natufians were found to be e1b1b1.

[@KnowledgeOverIndoctrination]

@@AllenBethea Natufians are Neolithic period. Not Bronze Age. The Canaanites belong to Haplogroup J2b. Haplogroup J was the most dominant Haplogroup in the Levant in the Bronze and Iron Age. The haplogroup you are referring to is E1b1b-M123/M34/M84. This haplogroup never left the Levant.

[@robertmccoy9323]

One one level, I thought the presentation was a good starting point. However, the info about mixed races and types of blending producing Isrealites, Canaanites and Philistines leaves many unanswered questions about the timeline and the outside impact of invaders and how much mixing took place to produce a linguistically or culturally differentiated race of people. So, the relevance of the DNA sequencing is sketchy. take care rwmccoy

[@godschild3640]

BY. KRISTIN ROMEY ,.. movie descendants of biblical Canaanites identified via DNA. .. let’s use the holy Bible and let’s use DNA together

[@megz122]

Jubilees 10:29-31 [29]And Canaan saw the land of Lebanon to the river of Egypt, that it was very good, and he went not into the land of his inheritance to the west (that is to) the sea, and he dwelt in the land of Lebanon, eastward and westward from the border of Jordan and from the border of the sea. [30]And Ham, his father, and Cush and Mizraim his brothers said unto him: 'Thou hast settled in a land which is not thine, and which did not fall to us by lot: do not do so; for if thou dost do so, thou and thy sons will fall in the land and (be) accursed through sedition; for by sedition ye have settled, and by sedition will thy children fall, and thou shalt be rooted out for ever. [31]Dwell not in the dwelling of Shem; for to Shem and to his sons did it come by their lot.

[@godschild3640]

@@megz122 , 🌞KING OF TYRE /. SIDON 🌞

[@canadiankewldude]

The Canaanites descended from Canaan. Table of Nations.

[@vdevendidos8943]

Ancient Levant people became Christian in many villages and cities from Syria and Lebanon, much time before Crusades.

[@pethello3845]

1:22 He said that he is a geneticist BY DAY. How about ''by night'', what is he? :-)

[@moosa9850]

A gamer by night, his the guy from Kings and Generals.

[@JARG]

Descendants of Ham the son of Noah

[@jibaruz]

Canaanite palestinian here 🇵🇸 descendant of the gibeonites tribe in gibeon in the village of jib

[@mutualisme299]

What does Natufian DNA says where they come from?

[@keith1617]

Hammites

[@AltaAnastazYah]

Jewish

[@keith1617]

@@AltaAnastazYah No. Sons of Ham. Esau plays a part, but the Moabites attached themselves to baal worshipping Cannanites, and are one, and the same. Egyptian are Hammites as well. Semitic peoples are descendants of Shem.

[@gregjohnson8791]

Canaanites were from the line of Ham, Noah's son. Hams son Canain(var sp). They were not entitled to the land as Noah divided the lands and this area was Shems land. This is only one reason they had to be evicted the others had to do with evil worship against Yahweh.

[@TheDanEdwards]

Oh dear, Razib Khan. I for one haven't gotten past his association with far right (and very racist-right at that) publishers and polemicists. He may have decided to part ways with them, but I don't know that (as he's not AFAIK written a public refutation of his former associates.) Nevertheless, Razib mentioned Israel Finkelstein. Finkelstein is neither reactionary nor revolutionary by academic standards, but Finkelstein is a thorn in the sides of religious fundamentalists. Finkelstein's work, along with the work of his colleagues, illustrates that the claims of the Jewish tradition (as encoded in the 2nd Temple Judaism writings and redactions in what Christians call the OT) of a Jewish conquest of the "promised land" are not true. There was no real conquest, just as there was no real exodus. Thus, the inhabitants of ancient Israel were just upland Canaanite populations, in contrast to the biblical assertions of who were the "Canaanites" ( who were in fact just the low land (closer to the sea) population.)

[@oki1966]

question. Just like the Magyars, could the Jewish rulers who took over the region become mostly canaanite genetically?

[@baarbacoa]

DNA studies show that the DNA studies indicate the Israelites were Canaanites. The language of the Israelites was a Canaanite language as well.

[@reportedstolen3603]

@@baarbacoathe Hebrew Bible is essentially their historical account of the of the Near East wrapped in myth, war, genocide, spirituality, and most importantly Nationalism.

[@Nnn_k]

No , they were Canaanites how converted to Judaism