Canada: How Hundreds of Indian Students Were Duped | Vantage with Palki Sharma

[@Firstpost]

We have two brand new shows for you to check out. Flashback with Palki Sharma: kzbin.info/aero/PLEVkQGIATCXLJLVyPJAAUuIEUbdkyZiEq Between the lines with Palki Sharma: kzbin.info/aero/PLEVkQGIATCXLZqGVWVzA7p3QOhkZ545gK

[@lombo5293]

They are not endians. They are khalistanis

[@JOi06-q6z]

​@@lombo5293son in law of porkistsnis

[@JOi06-q6z]

​@@lombo5293dahej me lahor le jayenge Gadar 2

[@everuttejon9886]

....... ......." America is World's biggest terrorist country and threat to the World" - Noam Chomsky...99% World's terrorists groups were created by USA to dominate the World...

[@keneilrichards3014]

Canada hates Kali.

[@RavarsenBlogspot]

Far from duped, they knowingly participated in the scam. This has been going on for many years

[@TWINS-TV-PRANKS]

Exactly 💯

[@rahulvats95]

But the issue is how authorities let them in and stay for years

[@Dragon80955]

More votes for Trudeau!!!!

[@ssa8479]

@@Dragon80955 How? They can't vote if they're not citizens.

[@ssa8479]

Some do, particularly those who know they may not qualify through proper channels but are desperate to study abroad. They get fake credentials, fake transcripts in hope of boosting their applications. Just as some apply for jobs with fake resumes. The best will get in on merit.

[@narendeepan]

I am a Sri Lankan who did both undergrad and masters in the USA. I obtained visa twice for the two degrees. When we applied, we were clearly told that the visa is strictly for education and I should return after my studies. So, showing ties to the motherland, and heavy cash deposits, parent monthly income, and all were part of the process. Although some of my friends remained in the USA by extending their visa by doing multiple academic programs, we decided to come back. The ROI is us teaching hundreds of students in local universities. We teach them what we learned and we help them to obtain better experiences in the future.

[@ichiyazukuri3291]

are you Sinhalese or Tamilian???

[@crypticTV]

@@ichiyazukuri3291 why does that matter? He's Sri Lankan

[@15ruksinn]

Sri Lanka is paradise compared to north India

[@introspectivekumarpoemsand2032]

Talk to 80% of these students, and they will hardly string a couple of sentences in English. How did they even score a bare minimum in IELTS? It is a status symbol to study and live abroad. After spending loads of money, they settle for small jobs. Illegal immigrants arent scammed, they know what they are doing.

[@Ofkgoto96oy9gdrGjJjJ]

They just learn English for scoring well in "Quantitive Aptitude", that's the problem. Don't focus much on verbals. Also, English is a completely foreign "spoken" language for Indians, and I absolutely agree English IS a status symbol for Indians...

[@bibinkunjumon]

There should be second IELTS test

[@swa813]

That's true

[@officalJalgara]

I think the fundamental problem with us Indians are that. If we find a loophole, tons of people will abuse it to a point where Countries start to take strict actions for future legal immigrants.

[@opnion2294]

no one cant buy property or citizenship in india, they are all over

[@debasishraychawdhuri]

Our fundamental problem is that we think any junk university in a white country is going to be better than Indian universities. People even went to Ukraine to study.

[@rajivrohella]

Most frauds happen in Punjab...one has to think why?? 😅😅😅😅 Thats what a Student visa look like without English & core value of community 😊

[@rajivrohella]

@@AA-bh3bz I also hate it 😒 what to do..

[@GAURAV25855ify]

Very true and US is better country then canada in most ways

[@paadipanta2607]

All certificates submitted by Punjabi students shall be verified with a third party. 90% of them are fake.

[@NUiui-eg2hr]

Allibaba 😂😂😂

[@Kyryll_Bondarenko]

True af 🤣

[@UMS9695]

And a good number of Sikhs will turn into Khalistanis!!

[@stellalopezjamea3833]

How do you know

[@rameez328]

Just listen to how they speak😂😂😂. You will wonder something is missing

[@gluejay]

I have a very strong feeling that these Indian students literally...I mean knowning participated in this scam. This kind of scam is nothing new to Canadians. Definately it was pre-planned. And now they are playing victim.

[@shahonchen6661]

You can't trust these peoples!

[@Lennyplays234]

Yes exactly

[@secretservice1816]

Definitely, most of them surely paid to increase their ielts scores

[@venkatm2757]

Most of the students are from Punjab and they desperately want to land in Canada somehow as it is their dream come true movement. I don't think any of these students are innocent and possibly was aware of the risk they are taking( who knows this type of fraud may have been happening for years without being caught and finally Canadian Immigration woke up 😀 to the reality)

[@vimalpatel4017]

Agreed, they possibly doing knowingly.

[@Influential-Critic]

True bro...

[@ri2253]

90% students from Punjab coming to Australia, New Zealand or Canada are fake students. All the ones I talked to in New Zealand can't speak any English. All they do is work under the table in orchards or restaurants. I don't know how they manage their visa or IELTS score!!! Makes it harder on genuine students

[@Shubham-hk6yf]

Their own state Punjab has most number of fraud private colleges so I think they are very well aware of which colleges are good and bad. Waise bhi pdhai krne nhi jaate ye, pdhna hota to compete krte. Maze krne jate hai

[@MickyLion5527]

Yes they get fruit of their own greed 😂😂😂

[@luvaholic]

Nobody was duped. All these people knew they were using forged documents. I hope these frauds rot

[@FabSia]

The problem with those returning after studying abroad and not getting a job is also that they have somehow come back with a superiority complex along with their degrees. Many of these have studied in average colleges abroad which have lower value than an Indian University degree. But just because they have a 'abroad' tag attached they expect a higher position and higher paying job and are not willing to start at entry position. If you've really studied at good University with good grades you would have acquired good skills and finding job won't really be a problem. So it's not as simple as saying '88% foreign returns didn't GET job'.

[@Xoyasal57]

Yes 😂 once these guys set their foot on foreign soil maybe as even tourists or otherwise….. they suddenly get an air of superiority 😂😂, they become foreigners 😂, look down on others…. Typical apna mentality… besides even apne log who reside abroad as NRI ‘ omg they got attitudes, man . …. Even look down on other’s fellow Indians depending on their status or education…… u gotta see that ……. Goras ko chattenge…… kale se duur rahenge, cos they can’t mess up with them … beegi chuhe banege 😂😂😂

[@sahilrana2659]

78 😒

[@Shubham-hk6yf]

Average pujabi life :- oye coke shoke la bai, pols aagyi pols, Daddy menu Kanadda vejo, Daddy menu Southhaul vejo, Kannada di kudi de naal viah karanga, oo pols aagyi pols, coke aur kukkad paad Deni hai aaj

[@VED036]

Many of the students from India going to native-English nations do work which are seen in Indian languages as menial work and as a disgrace to do. So, it is not correct say that there is no work for graduates in India. Indian feudal languages degrade most of work that are in England. The desperation to be with some native-English population is very rampant over here. No one has any thoughts of converting the local areas into English locations. Instead, the aim is always to enter into English nations and spoil them. If this is not possible, then a govt job where the salaries are 10 to 50 times the common man's earnings.

[@VED036]

It is not a superiority complex. In English there is no need for servility. In Indian languages, servility is an essential part of communication.

[@sabugeet]

It's hard to believe all of the 700 students were unaware. I'm sure a large number of the took part in it knowingly

[@shaswatshrey9712]

OBVIOUSLY

[@sheshasaibabagujjari3481]

I mean when did they find out? After reaching Canada? Because she says they realised after applying for PR. If yes then where did they study?

[@teencha1]

they were fully aware

[@guptasagar694]

They were Punjabi Lunds...They know all bakchodi....Siddhu moosewale

[@durango.j-onez]

They knew Trudeau wouldn't send them back

[@sakinastraveldiary4562]

At least 50% of my Punjabi friends who graduated with me from Niagara College are working in Indian restaurants as servers now, best case scenario Dominos or McDonald's. I am the lucky few who still found an office job but that was not in Canada.

[@venkateswarreddy394]

😵

[@AyushKumar-wl8cx]

Wtf really after paying 80- 1 crore

[@riscnx]

What's so special about studying in Niagara that you had to study there to just find a job?

[@darshansmash7278]

But an Indian truck driver in Canada easily able to earn $8000 to $10000 a mnth ( 6.7 to 8 Lakhs) ...Hence tell your friends to go back to Canada. : It's TRUE Edited: Those who are thinking about their expenditure, they are provided by policies that reduces their cost of expenditure almost 70- 80%.. Love India..Hamara pyra Bharat.

[@2Sage-7Poets]

yes i learned niagara college is the cheapest among colleges that offers foreign education

[@prakashkadam1875]

No student is duped here. Students know what they are doing and it's one of the common routes to reach to US/Canada. People from 1 state in India are so obsessed to come to Canada that they will do anything legal or illegal to reach there.

[@shantaamrit7947]

So true

[@shikshZN]

Dream to build empire😂

[@gyadre]

They should apply to colleges and university instead of agencies. This itself shows they are not confident of applying themselves.

[@stankrishna7817]

They fake their marks

[@therealpvc2541]

they should apply to universities, period. Many of these low-income Punjabi students apply to small, private career colleges.

[@ri2253]

Same stories in Australia. Now many universities in Australia stopped admitting students from 6 states in India

[@TomL13]

some of them willingly get duped so they can go overseas and not actually study, but to work and send money back home. Many such cases in New York City.

[@agnescraig2912]

Spot on Indians must stop having more than two children even three is too many as for many countries the base may be low, India started from an extremely high (low) base rate. Overtaken China today as the most populous. Shame on India

[@MohammedAli-pr3dz]

Let's be real, the Indian students weren't duped they were the ones duping the government, It's everyone's dream to study abroad. These guys found a shortcut and now are playing the victim. Personally, I would deport them back to Punjab, but our government needs them for factory and labor jobs 😩

[@mecanuktutorials6476]

Let’s be really real. The government isn’t that dumb. The students are. The government is complicit in marketing these programs to import young and naive students to their country. Without financial support and debts, these students essentially become slaves to Canadian businesses. The impression back in India is that these kids are moving up in life because the previous generation “made it” by doing the same thing and got actual middle class jobs or government jobs doing so.

[@small_joys2022]

Its not "everyone's dream to study abroad." Only the ones who cant make it into good colleges in their own countries.

[@MohammedAli-pr3dz]

@Small_ Joys not really. Indias' education system is just corrupt. Which is why so many students they can pull a fast one on the government here.

[@archangelempress10]

​@@MohammedAli-pr3dznot whole Indian education system, only the states which are ban by Australia are the problem

[@MohammedAli-pr3dz]

꧁Archangel Empress꧂ yeah ur right

[@HornOkay]

These are not students they are immigrants.

[@trinitybricks9522]

That's like saying, You are not human, you are an animal, you are a piece of Garbage troll as well...

[@ferntom6092]

Sorry to comment they are robbers.

[@trinitybricks9522]

@@ferntom6092Sorry to call out your delusional garbage of a mind, but to thieves, others do look like thieves.

[@sunnykumarsingh7971]

Immigrants going to immigrant country were all are immigrant and moreover immigrant government having a budget expectation from their fees so that They can use that money for their permanent imgrants.

[@AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA345]

Of course... they are!! who is not an immigrant in Canada ?except the indigenous people...everyone else is!! The point of getting students to Canada and giving them PR is a win -win deal for foreign students and the Canadian government. So what you lamenting about?

[@FabSia]

Also, how did the visa agency not verify the admission letters? It's also a fault of the Visa agency who do not have the system to verify the documents or the colleges. They should be held 100% responsible for this.

[@kmjkj2]

A lot on those countries happens on trust -> that’s how Abrahamic based Christian countries work

[@g.r.2985]

Not really! It was a scam that the students partook in, knowingly. How is that the border agents fault?

[@chatpapdi]

Vishwagurus are never at fault .......😉

[@FabSia]

@Vire Nero what do you mean? I mean the students who have never been to a country, it is difficult for them to find the authenticity of an institution. They don't even have a system where a student can self verify. But how dies a visa office not have a system? Their own people cannot verify it, how do expect a 18 year old from other country to do so?

[@pranavrk9752]

That is called a fraud,

[@sabugeet]

From my experience in Canada, I have personally felt. People from one state ruin the image of Indians by themselves. You hardly hear south Indians who are also in Canada by the thousands creating ruckus or frauds.

[@mikesheth5370]

Lots of Andhra students were caught and deported from US. They went to nonexistent colleges. Kerala students used to go to fake Christian colleges!

[@Punjab_Punjabi_Punjabiat]

dare to say it directly that you want to blame the punjabis only or may be the sikhs only. Why has Australia banned students from Haryana, Gujarat, UP, Himachal and Kashmir? You can easily find the videos of Haryanvis also creating ruckus. Gujaratis, as in India, are also notoriously famous for committing frauds in foreign countries. How the south Indians are operating the caste system in the Silicon valley is not hidden from anyone?

[@zilistika]

The students from the same one or two states also cause issues in other western countries. So the issue is systemic in those states.

[@Punjab_Punjabi_Punjabiat]

@@zilistika Read about the history of punjabis in Canada, Australia, US etc. They were the first ones to come from India and they were the ones to fight for the rights. If asians are getting citizenships in these countries, it is also because of the struggle by punjabis among others. Now you only want to see their faults.

[@zilistika]

@@Punjab_Punjabi_Punjabiat i know all that but right now they are the biggest frauds and criminals coming here and bringing shame to other decent Indians infront of other nationalities. Everytime you see news if its anything negative about Indians 90% of the times turns out them.

[@angiethebookaholic]

With Palki, it's always everybody else's fault except Indians. Glad that the people in comments are calling her out!

[@angiethebookaholic]

@@sup4767 no, I don't..but when a topic interesting to me is discussed, of course , I do. I am not the one to shut out opinions differing from mine..

[@bansiwalarsur]

None of this would happen if the students got admitted to Universities which have DLI number. Getting admission in Designated Learning Institutes like the top public Universities not only ensure high quality education but also the students aren’t subjected to such traumatic experience. IRCC in their website clearly mentions the importance of education in DLI. I am surprised that study permits were even issued without checking that the admission offers were fake. If the Canadian authorities finally bust the racket which is involved in this scam, they haven’t done anything wrong by issuing deportation notice.

[@borntobemild-]

That's the conversation we are having in Canada now. But also, it's not those kids fault. They are victims

[@laheart1957]

What’s the role of “due diligence” by the Canadian high commission?

[@amtv9686]

@@borntobemild- it’s the students job to do due diligence. Sorry but they’re wrong.

[@borntobemild-]

@@amtv9686 no. They are kids going to school. They are victims. Sorry but that's what matters

[@hacksgeek]

If their admission letters were fake .. why they were given student visa .. they should have checked authenticity of the document.... But when students applying for residents visa .... Now they check all the documents.... This is clearly fault of Canadian officer

[@rajagopalans.v.5068]

What is intriguing is how these students with fake admission notices can enter Canada under Student Visa? Is the Canadian Immigration so bad?

[@kamathmanoj]

Yes. It’s terrible. Did you hear / read of this in any Canada news portal? Nope. “Freedom of speech “ 😂 in Canada 😂😂😂

[@agnescraig2912]

Indians are doing these scams and fake documents in the U.K. Australia, Canada New Zealand Europe and US. They pay people off at every level and have P.Hds in scamming and bribing

[@FabSia]

Exactly

[@nikhilsahay895]

Until those university exist, Immigration officers have no legal basis to stop visa. Frankly there is no scam, they are just not good university in short. Canada can not legally close an university just because they are bad and some fool Indians just want to get in line even knowing the quality.

[@mikesheth5370]

Yes Canadian consular staff in India is corrupt. It's mostly staffed by locals and some Canadian white. They also learn how to accept bribe. Once one applicant was contacted by a lower level staff from Delhi consulate, although I was told no one will make a call. Also lots of Sikhs politicians influence Canadian immigration. Their favourite technique is wine dine etc. Now Khalistani NDP leader is in driving seat! Imagine!

[@PK0608]

There are two group of Indian students. One who chose to study in Elite university and come with a real intention to study abd make a great career. They are always successful without exceptions. Time might vary for everyone. Another group of students are the dodgy ones who has no intentions to study and just do some blue collar jobs like working in restaurants, super market driving taxis. They are the problem makers because they are the one who believe FAKE it till you MAKE it. They chose the cheapest college and worthless courses just to stay in the country and make money. This is the reason a lot of universities stop taking applications from Punjab and Haryana and a few other states of India

[@aimaqadeer125]

Agree with you

[@rockshankar]

Still lots of legal colleges in Canada that will give admissions to a student who is unable to get admissions even in indian university. All you need is the money. I have seen students with 42 backlogs in Undergraduate and unable to do any graduate courses in india as all indian universities refused. But there are canadian and UK colleges gave admissions to him. But he has to pay 16k CAD before landing in canada and then 16k after. There are so many legal loopholes that are exploited for decades. Illegal ones probably make even more money. The Funny things is why would canadian government issue visa if the college is fake? . That is the whole process, you have to submit college admissions, and canadian government have to verify college before giving admissions. This is totally a fault on canadian government.

[@zainulabdin1720]

Agree, their are two categories of students one genius genuine students who want to study abroad in good university and want to be successful person in life no matter if thay dont get good job in abroad thay return to their home country with no regrets because thay trust them self and their abilities but on the other hand some students are very clever thay are not good in studies thay just want to reach abroad by any source (taking admission in any cheaper college university in abroad) using fake documents bank statement just to go abroad and start earning no further studies.... spoiling the name of country doing odd jobs not understanding law of countries where thay stay like Europe Canada Australia 🌏 etc no contribution no innovation nothing again start crime their 😢...very sad

[@Ali-uz8qg]

@P K - I believe your reasoning is flawed a bit. The second group which you say and I quote, "the dodgy ones who has no intentions to study" end quote. So why would they then undergo and torture themselves full time for 4 years to graduate from a college? Yes, you are right that there are young men who really are not interested to study but use the student visa route for easy migration. But those men or students will not be able to apply for legal residence because they never attended or finished graduation. They then cannot claim being scammed or otherwise.

[@PK0608]

@@Ali-uz8qg answer to your first point - They undergo any torture. They get their assignments done by paying other people and manage to somehow score passing marks if they have ed semester exams. usually they do certificate courses or diploma courses which does not even have an end semester exam. You can keep applying to different courses for almost 10 years and make money. By then they manage to find some ways to get their permanent residency. for example living and working in a remote area for 3 years can grant them permanent residency

[@laheart1957]

All of this comes because we believe that anything foreign is the best, and that includes education. If only 22 percent of those with Canadian education get jobs in India it shows the quality of this “foreign” education . As always, it’s always the fault of the student. It’s never the fault of the Canadian high commission which issues the visas or the government there.

[@prateekwatwale4812]

Do your research, Canada is consistently ranked among top 10 for university education

[@RajDas-ob4mp]

These so called students go to Canada and the west to make money. In Canada they make more money in a day like RS 8000- Rs10,000 a day or more than one lakh a month working 8 hrs a day or 40 hrs a week , that too working in fast food like McDonald’s or apps delivery drivers minimum wage in Canada is $15.25 - $ 16.00 a hour ! Over RS 1000/ hr.

[@prateekwatwale4812]

@RajDas-ob4mp true, and people in india toil away their life for sheer survival working 10-12 hours a day 6 days a week

[@shivijain7081]

yes exactly, European and western countries always keep saying India is not safe and scam but I belive it is the same case with countries like france especially in Paris and now Canada

[@rn6447]

​@@dushtsikshana Utter shit ... hmm good description of INDIA. you guy's seek foreign aid not other countries. During the pandemic your doctor's and nurses were posting videos requesting foriegn aid... Canada was ONE of those countries that provided medical supplies and other healthcare equipment. If India wasn't an utter sh** country then perhaps its citizens wouldn't be seeking avenues to travel abroad in droves...yes in droves... that in itself speaks volumes about what India has to offer or the lack off!. Clearly you've lived in a hole your entire life your comment confirms that.

[@vigilante_stark]

I died a little bit 💀 when she said "There is no dearth of world class education in India..."

[@johnsaleem470]

Palki, Indian students getting scammed is so unique and unbelievable. If anyone, I expect Indians to recognize a scam.

[@mangopudding5979]

those scammers must be Indians too, I guess. and its far from a scam, they knowingly participated in the scam.

[@GAURAV25855ify]

Yes its ironic

[@rajivrohella]

Student visa itself a big scam..

[@Karma_243]

Those scamming r Indians too not Canadians 😂 thanks to That minister letting Indian students stay

[@alinadebbarma2553]

Looks like some chat bots in this comment section have found a reason to reverse the blame on India's education system to shift the focus from the topic that has been discussed. And for those who are complaining about palki mam not discussing about the loopholes in the Indian education system,she did it when she was in wion. And this incident is the the fault of the victims themselves who are so desperate to go to Canada or us or uk without realising that the grass is not always green on the other side.

[@RahulSharma-ur2jt]

It's a competitive job market, doesn't matter if it's India or Canada, so if you can't compete then you do not have prospects anywhere. If someone is looking for meaningful careers, it takes hard work, irrespective of which country you are in. Many students that are stuck in this situation applied to programs that in most cases have very limited or no future prospects, and they go to college and universities that very lenient when it comes to their admission criteria. Universities are far more stringent and offer better programs, but the fact is, you need to do your homework if you want to apply to them. Many were duped, but some are complicit too, falsifying numerous information to get admission. Many of them just wanted to get there for any means necessary, that is why when an accredited consultant said No they turn to the illegal one that said Yes.

[@vikaspanchal8015]

These are Pakistanis Islamic Jihadi terrorists.

[@raptortheslayer5538]

Cry baby Channel 😭💝

[@riscnx]

@@RahulSharma-ur2jt Pb people don't want hardwork. Else 3-4hector land is a lot for anyone willing to do hardwork. Then there are some, who just want to escape their join families. And then there are some Dihaties who go to foreign for Dk measuring contest & it embarrassing for them to return jobless.

[@fgwhqawhwqahwqa]

The grass is brown in India from open defecation, i don't blame them for wanting to leave.

[@Rockerstohell]

I am a current student at Canada and I’m from southern part of India. My classmates’ average is 26 and most of them are from Punjab/Haryana and sparsely Gujarat 😀 (sic). Believe me or not , a few chose the course I’m studying without knowing what it’s exactly meant for and someone like me, chose it’s importance(Not bragging). They get references from their Pals at Walmart, Tim Hortons, join there, gain experience and immediately file for PR. 😀😀 they are quite unaware that PR points under CEC are too high. There’s another milking going around, Do another course and get 3 yr permit so that you’ll get PR . Studying 2 irrelevant courses and Sticking to restaurant or retail jobs won’t take them anywhere when your queue gets bigger and bigger. Canada has been a big-time liberal and they must take strict action against fraudulents from any part of India. I hope Mr.Fraser paaji will invoke some more laws to keep his government for 3rd time as “frock True-Doe” is doing rounds here at the place I stay with mild racist attacks against us Indians.😢

[@jithinfrancis82]

Please don’t call them students. Idiots would be an appropriate term. First of all they need to research the school that they seek admission to. I did masters and PhD on full scholarship from Ireland and now settled in the USA. Getting a letter from somewhere and then jumping on a flight is not immigration. Please do research.. at least go through the times world ranking and know where the school stands. Then research whether the school is good enough to procure a visa from the embassy. US schools specifically say that securing admission is not a guarantee that you are entitled to a visa. In fact many schools advise paying the fees until after the visa interview is over. The policies vary from country to country. And many of the countries like UK are not so welcoming any more. In other countries you will only land a job if the field of study chosen is in need. Most countries are saturated with management graduates. So if you are trying to get into a management course and there are natives of the country with the same degree they are given preference. Again if you are going to do a masters in computer science / IT to land on a software job, please work for a couple of years in India and gain work experience before flying abroad. It really matters. Getting foreign students a business for the institutions here. They just want to get the fees , and there is no guarantee of employment. So please do your homework rather than trusting some consultant in India. The university pay them heavily for recruiting students, this is on top of the processing fee you pay to them.

[@sendteams-qr1ot]

I'm sure most of these students were aware of the loophole, risks involved and still tried it. I don't understand how they can blame the system.

[@Kaalki.]

Western marketing should be regulated since it is easy to lure people from this part of the world with minimal efforts.

[@shalinirodrigues6192]

What are the names of these education consultants in Punjab or elsewhere who are responsible for this? They should be exposed so that others do not get into such traps. Thanks for educating people on this front

[@vanybartheeban1124]

Please send all Indian students back. I don’t feel like I’m living in Canada but feel like living in India

[@ashbhasin4674]

They never went there to study primary objective was to get permanent visa to stay in canada it suits Trudeau as he see it more votes for him and khalistanis

[@MTxD]

Doesn't matter what country you are from. Don't apply though any agencies unless it's required from the institute. And, if you think without agency you won't proceed then you should not think about moving abroad.

[@mahilkumar6631]

The scammers should be booked. Our country should take action.

[@pmvarkey739]

India being the 3rd largest economy, even surpassing Canada, can not all these people going to Canada and other places, enjoy life in India. Our country is progressing very fast. Why students don't understand that. Think 🤔

[@debanikgoswami4834]

Because there is a fierce competition to get into top colleges in India (IIT,NIT,IIMS). Not everyone can get into these colleges. Study abroad is better alternative for them than studying in a tier 3 college in India as long as you have the funds .

[@nipunkapur3012]

Govt of Canada should take action against these education institutes.

[@ankitbaral2.026]

They Use Fake Documents and Enter Canada and Complain getting Cheated.

[@rajivrohella]

Scam is down by students not institutes. Lol

[@deepnagare2321]

No of universities in medical should be increased in India especially MBBS and also management colleges. Minimum wages should be increased as well.

[@rohithkumar8708]

we already have way too many mbbs seats in india. but we have very less amount of specialization seats, which is a serious problem. because with mbbs degree alone, you can't sustain a livelihood. If you're planning on not getting married, it'll be enough. but the living expenses are increased to a level where even specialization isn't enough

[@A1stardan]

Bruh there are so many mbbs seats now, that we're on track to becoming next engineering. The avg salary is now at 25k worse than engineering

[@767Alaa]

And that ... Will never happen!

[@darshansmash7278]

Just give NEET and you will realise, quality of education in India is far more higher than rest of the world. Class 11 th and 12 fundamental knowledge (science stream) is enough to make ourselves apart from rest of the world's population... especially developed nations. Those going abroad are either under pressure of society, status or condition.. which they are not ready to face..

[@jitabratanath3631]

Absolutely,83% Indian medical students don't even qualify FMGE exam (basically it's an exam for students who have foreign medical degree but want to practice in India). And majority of these students have degree from Ukraine and Russia.😶

[@kanwalpannu5050]

Lol.. by cramming in coaching institute for 4 years..

[@agnescraig2912]

If it is education which means cramming from books and passingly exams, Indians are possibly good at. But education in the West is opening ones mind and liberal thinking plus diversity. Indians score zero. One example is arranged marriages based on religion caste class status and all the superstition which exists. Education = good job, money , providing for extended families financially. Education is not for the betterment of society

[@dss5295]

I've worked in India, US and Canada. While I agree Indians in general have better technical skills, their overall aptitude is terms of critical and innovative thinking, leadership, management and communication is lacking. Hence, those who come with indian education and work exp struggle in jobs. Indians who study abroad, live and work there for at least 5 years, pick up these other skills and start doing very well like our big CEOs. Point is, indians are most talented but American and Canadian university education is much better.

[@rohithkumar8708]

​@agnescraig2912 if you're talking about education, stick to education. marriage is a commitment and responsibility in india where an entire takes care of a couple and helps in their growth and supports them , also india is the country with the least divorce rates in the world. the only places that do have shitty marriages and higher divorce rates are westernized places in india. statistically relationship instabilities are very common in western society . just by that you can say which type of lifestyle and society sucks at marriage

[@sanjaykumar-xv4xd]

Palki Madam, You have done a magnificent job, KOTI KOTI NAMAN AAPKO

[@AnalystRK]

Students from India brings massive amount of revenue in Canada in form of tuition fee, for third class degree like hospitality and some diploma.Canada has one of the worst job prospect and one of the highest cost of living. My suggestion for all student who are looking to come Canada would be to not waste their money on third class degrees and garbage institutions. Your chances to get PR on such degrees are slim to none and even if some how you manage to get PR you won't have good future here, you will be earning minimum pay and living as poor for most of your life.

[@Ofkgoto96oy9gdrGjJjJ]

College and University is hard to afford for even Americans and Canadians (unless you have savings). Getting a job is equally hard, unless you have the required skill or knowledge/experience for it. Being Indian does not make you special in this aspect, most employers just require a lot from freshers.

[@BullyCanadian]

Please also give complete reporting. The scammers are not Canadians but Indians themselves.

[@preetamrana9172]

😅 true...these are Indian fake representatives..who studied or spent time in Canada and bullying Indian students..

[@MickyLion5527]

LOL with towels

[@CyrusJ]

100% True

[@joelraj1784]

True

[@VoicesrilankaSinhala]

shhhhh dont say that, Palki Karma and her G ---- DI supporters wont accept it and deny that Indian scammers are targeting Canadians and stealing billions of dollars from Vulnerable

[@vimalpatel4017]

Most of them got scammed as they are been told how easy to be a PR card holder once you complete your study! Not being advised about rents, living cost and jobs situations here in Canada.

[@foxfish9940]

Number of Indian Students scammed ----> 700 Number of Indian Students scamming -----> 7000000000000000000000000000

[@wionporky9937]

How can the mother of all Scammer got Dupe? 😮

[@TojiFushigoroWasTaken]

Next time pls write sentences that atleast make some sense....people will get seizures reading such 💩

[@Anil_Dikshit]

Indians always playing the victim card 😂

[@xmkl38]

So true 😂

[@mein3324]

Cuz Scammers exists everywhere.

[@sanmyr4241]

Because members from the mother of all scammer are also involved and many students are complicit in the crime- alas! a chance to go to Canada.

[@terbear6519]

Duped ? Probably by their own people.

[@TojiFushigoroWasTaken]

Ur dp is ew 🤢🤮

[@Shant...]

Same as in USA and Canada. Inside jobs are easier.

[@RamVelagala]

Does that make it correct?

[@nalenilambourdiere9620]

In France, educators help students with free information and recommendation letters. Helping students is part of the job description. Students could approach any teacher of their choice.

[@archangelempress10]

Indian government needs to step up and arrest the scammers

[@VivekKumar-bt2zb]

This problem is worse than you are highlighting, Australia has Banned 5 Indian States because of fake documents, violating working laws.... Also Few Top class graduates won't find jobs in India because of Reservations, Ji hazoori policy, Bhai Bhatijawaad, and underpaid salaries, ........ Could you stop including everyone in the same domain? So they went again. If you want a list I can give you more than 20 names, who are post-doc from the top 100 QS-ranking colleges and won't get jobs in India because of govt. This year 6500+ millionaires will leave India. Ask govt to make some policy on education rather than politicizing.

[@tinaz1818able]

Who can trust people from the global scammer center?!

[@vimalpatel4017]

lol...here we go again politics has to come in in all matter while people doing this knowingly!

[@meghanath5045]

😂 get your logic first , why are top class graduates not getting the jobs if 97% jobs are in private sector.

[@sweetlemon2546]

@@tinaz1818able then ask google and microsoft to change ceo.

[@jyotiprakashshrimali6514]

यह बहुत दुखद है जो इतना समय रुपया लगाने के बाद भी भारत में जॉब नही पाते।

[@Xoyasal57]

So called students going abroad can’t even speak basic English but have airs like no other 😢

[@daytrademantra369]

I have heard they can buy ielts score in punjab. Many do buy good ielts results and if they couldnt then they buy wife or husband who has cracked ielts in exchage of paying their entire tuition fee with a promise to get sponsored as spousal visa. These people are so crazy to go to canada that they can do anything for it. But when they come their dreams get scattered bcoz its its not easy there.

[@agnescraig2912]

But it is way better life than even in the cities of Punjab

[@Xoyasal57]

Some students who were in Ukraine during war and did not return to India, but went to other countries calling themselves Ukrainian refugees 😢in hope that they can slip into Europe…. Some reached Ireland as Ukrainian refugees, 😅. When asked by reporter , they said they were Ukrainians 😮…. And why they didn’t stay behind to fight for Ukraine, as only women n children were allowed refugee status… the guys ( who looked only in their 20’s or late 30’s ) said they were 60 years old 😂😂😂 leaving the reporter shocked 😂😂

[@vision385]

Indians fom India should live and in their own country 😮

[@maxtheo1504]

India has very good colleges but still students going outside paying more fees cant be without reason.

[@svc2461]

Most of these kids are PR hunters. They don't care about an education. If they did, they'd have fared pretty well educating themselves for 1/ 100th of the money in Bharat. Most of these crying Victimhood were definitely well aware of what papers were used. They paid for the extra creative paperwork too. Don't believe? Visit any college (Universities are little different) town in Canada or UK and you'll see these so called students hardly spending any time in academic pursuits. Most are busy working 3 jobs and creating ruckus during their spare time. And... the western nations are USING them to make money and they're ok with that.

[@hacksgeek]

If their admission letters were fake .. why they were given student visa .. they should have checked authenticity of the document.... But when students applying for residents visa .... Now they check all the documents.... This is clearly fault of Canadian officer

[@Ali-uz8qg]

@hacksgeek - The Canadian Embassy in India that processes student visa applications will only check the documents presented at first impression as being valid and true. In law it's called prima facie evidence, a document letter presented that is legally sufficient to establish a fact. It is not their role to dig deeper to further check the authenticity of that document. This is because all and any embassy in the world do not wish to slow the visa issuing process. So it's not the fault of a Canadian officer in the Embassy. If the admission letters are fake, that due diligence is the role of CSIS, Canadian Security Intelligence Service. Only CSIS does a thorough check on an individual applying for legal residence and eventual citizenship. Therefore, if the admission letters found were truly fake and not valid, then the Canadian officer in CSIS did a good job in detecting the fraud.

[@user__100]

Canada uses Newcomers to pay pensions of old Europeans through tax

[@earrth911]

actually, cheap labour

[@RajDas-ob4mp]

I guess you know how Canada works , It is one of the best countries in the world with a very high standard of living.they don’t need , I’ll mannered , rude ,indians who don’t speak English . When there are millions fromaround the world trying to go to Canada .

[@wolfmangoland7972]

Most of the Indians who go to study in Canada go to below-average universities. The top universities in Canada are McGill, Univ of Toronto, McMaster, Univ of British Columbia, and Alberta. Very few Indian students get admission into these universities. Most Indians get into C-grade Canadian Universities.

[@robbenvanpersie1562]

Really? Then what's the point in going there

[@wolfmangoland7972]

@@robbenvanpersie1562 To immigrate and find jobs. Many work on small jobs but the currency exchange rate difference enables them to send money home.

[@titbits2304]

​@@wolfmangoland7972 That's not true . Indians are still richer than Canadians economically . That's why it is fashionable for parents to send their kids to Canada and other countries to study . Canadians parents can't afford their kids to go to university and colleges and kick them out of home when they turn 18 . Selfish Canadian parents !

[@burnttoast9112]

None of these 900 being deported, would secure admission in the top 10 Canadian universities. Colleges that they attended are owned by wealthy Punjabi Canadian. Strip mall located institutions Deport them.

[@StinkyIndianStudent]

🤑

[@satishbamal8447]

I live in NZ, I have seen and heard so many cases where students get into relationships (and pregnant in many cases) with local girls and get their residency and leave them after they get what they need, because of this the overall image of Indian Community is really poor (and for the right reasons).

[@rajivrohella]

Hi Satish, True but thats done by people from one particular state in India in my exp. State where we find ppl without spine, morals & sense of community.

[@satishbamal8447]

@@rajivrohella i know but can't generalise the who community for a few bad apples

[@rajivrohella]

@@satishbamal8447 I don't want to but that what I have experience in last 20 yrs in Australia. Why people from one state mostly get into these visa scams, illegal cash jobs even adds for uni assignment for cash are common on FB communities, cash illegal childcares, illegal home food tiffin service these are the common things are found in mostly ppl from one state of only.

[@satishbamal8447]

@@rajivrohella i totally understand, it's so unfortunate mate

[@AdityaTandel-or5iz]

@@satishbamal8447 Sir I have secured offer from University of Auckland for Masters in Business Analytics program what are your views on this course prospect in Newzealand I have 1 year experience in the IT domain

[@SeshuKumarpanja]

Playing victim card has always been a thing with the Indians

[@rkraja6603]

Korean students went back to their country and developed their country. Indians are not capable to do this-Why?

[@majunair]

I don’t think it’s the agents alone acting here. Immigrants from Punjab are notorious for playing every trick and even breaking laws for immigration. They spoil the reputation and esteem of India and all other Indians who are law-abiding. I have heard multiple European natives in the West say that when these Punjabis are caught, they would say in India, no one has to follow laws and thus give an impression that India is a lawless country and destroy the trust of all Indians, their qualifications/certifications, experiences and capabilities. And after they stand on the shoulders of Indians from the rest of India for immigrating, and once they immigrate successfully, many become anti-India supporters of Khalistan, and they have Pakistani Jihadis as their best pals.

[@rajeshwarisenthil5814]

Indian education is the best

[@debanikgoswami4834]

Only if you get into top colleges.

[@hermit2071]

With all due respect to u.This scam has roots in India,particularly The Punjab and Gugrat states. You need to do a very investigative report on this issue both in India and Canada. If there is a scam and or exploitation of particularly very young Indian girls again look at their parents back in india who are scraficing these young innocent girls. For what u go and ask them . Please do not blame Canadians.

[@suganpal1142]

An Indian cheated on other Indians, how would be a foreign country take responsibility for this??? Isn't it our country which should make the law stringent ??? Especially on those agencies which guides pal to study abroad or work abroad ???

[@jardanijovonovich4916]

The IELTS scam being run in Punjab needs to be investigated. I remember my time abroad. Met this guy from Punjab studying in some institute there. He couldnt even frame a sentence or for that matter write or comprehend in English but would brag about his 8 bands in the IELTS exams. Best part was that there were multiple such people that I came across. I had also heard of people who would get to a foreign country through such means and then vanish. We need to introspect before we start blaming the govts of these countries for deporting such people or coming up with stringent Visa rules.

[@jeffreymiller6116]

People from India scammed by People from India 😮.. Shocking

[@tangoo21]

Honest speaking the students are not victims, they know what was transpiring on and so are the visa officers. The government of Canada finds it embarrassing to admit about the scale of corruption among its officers. The government of Canada does not want to admit that it has had employees who have taken advantage of their positions of power and used it to solicit bribes and other forms of corruption. By admitting this, it would damage its reputation and public trust.

[@dvlx8453]

shout out to canada for being fair

[@alxc2389]

Let me guess, the 80% of the graduates that didnt land a proper job actually end up being a scammer . The pot calling the kettle BLACK

[@Shant...]

Perfect example when people start writing without watching a video till the end. Btw scammers get the 'victim' info from hackers within the target country.

[@raptortheslayer5538]

😂😂😂

[@ninaclemente5944]

How can you have "students" who don't know a word of English!

[@sanish2905]

You must appreciate the Canadian govt for doing this and more importantly punish the perpetrators.

[@umesh6772]

IT is Big UNFORTUNATE Indians going to FOREIGN COUNTRIES to Become GREAT & SIGN their LAVORITIES budget!😮😮

[@deoneforpeace]

But the government has been saying to the Entire World that they are happy to have brought all those people here from India????

[@jagdishchand2006]

Scammers should be Indian too

[@deadskull7866]

Nice style of protesting why dont they block the roads like they do in India

[@arkkk1294]

There is a language barrier in Canada, specially in the East like QC, NL and small parts of ON. Having said that, even after you pass the initial stages there'll be many more glass ceilings the higher you want to climb, mainly because of the language criteria. Just for a fyi causenwe face it ourselves in our own country.

[@VijayKumar-dn4pz]

Indians were duped in India. Canadians are just following their laws. Let that be clear.

[@AeonMusicRecord]

sad state of affairs, these so called students pay agencies to land in Brampton as students with only 1 intention to PR, and Canadian govt see them as cash cow, most of them end up working in restaurant, driving uber or cheap labour in warehouse. if you really want to study then atleast get into a top rated university in Master's degree

[@teencha1]

I am surprised at their courage to protest. Trudeau has made Canada a mess. It is Punjab/Khalistan ,not Canada anymore

[@peterlyon185]

They exactly knew what they were getting into, they aren’t exactly victims here

[@VeveIndian]

If you couldn’t find a job abroad and had to return to India, is it surprising they couldn’t find a job in India either

[@debanikgoswami4834]

If they can't find a job abroad,they can't find a job anywhere in the world.

[@RC-br1ps]

The question is why are so many young Indian's fleeing India? Do they see the writing on the wall, and are they scared? I heard about the expected 'demographic dividend' expected to benefit India's economy but how is tis going to happen if talent doesn't want to stay in India?

[@Letsgo-sg4cy]

In india there is very few white colour jobs. Unemployment is the main reason for this.

[@avirdee5421]

STUDYING ABROAD is a front for emigration by other means. The students and the agents in INDIA work hand in hand to operate this scam. Now they have been caught and the students are trying to play innocent!!

[@surenkv6461]

Who goes to Canada/ Australia for studying.. 90% time work , only 10% time study.. now you can judge about the standard of education.

[@slayphil]

It's not the aspiration of studying abroad but a quest for quality of life.

[@agnescraig2912]

Yes, agree. But be honest and report the reality of people's lives. Also do not fill up stadiums when PM visits with jingoistic chants and Bharat Mata ki Jai nonsense. You are just a number and Modi gets a kick out of you fools

[@kazuma2060]

​@@agnescraig2912 lol why are you getting so offended with modi getting grand welcome and why include modi lol everything bad happens to you is because of modi's fault like before 2014 our India was one of the richest and developed nation of the planet. Can't argue with you fools

[@kazuma2060]

Brother it's not about quality of life okay it's just a new normal I have some Punjabi friends who are filthy rich good business in India but still want to go canada and do minimal job there it's a kind of mindset and herd mentality.

[@thodarundhupayanam5423]

Why would punjabis choose to live a low quality life in canada, when they are blessed with good wealth and a high quality life back in india?

[@jdrr22]

Even resident native born Canadians are looking for a better quality of life... in Canada... while it is steadily going downhill and people cannot afford to keep a roof over their heads. Choosing bills over food. Rent over necessities. Wages do not come close to covering the costs of life. And we see some very poor work ethics in some of those who have moved here for whatever reason. Standing in a job, fully focused on their phones, ignoring customers. It's a fun experience. And it's gross on all sides, for everyone.

[@prashanthb6521]

What about Indian Call Center scamming Canadians ?

[@ssa8479]

India has a huge youth 'bulge' ... young people who need or will soon need better educations and better jobs. If unemployment is already 8% and unemployment among college grads is 18%, that does not bode well. Disheartened, disillusioned youth are a recipe for social and political unrest and possibly crime as well.

[@kazuma2060]

They should do there homework too rather than depending and blindly trusting on middle men so called dalal. Plus they are not doing any great job in canada most of them end up becoming jobless or do minimal jobs thanks to the recession in Europe. And even for getting admission in good colleges abroad you need to give atleast some entrance exams and these guys don't want to do any one of them so what would expect

[@jayvantias4512]

Indian govt literally begged canadian govt not to deport them😂

[@predatorishi]

Return of the investment = door dash, Uber, Lyft and condo security guards in “Kanneda”

[@zhz123]

Studying abroad isn't the lifelong dream for Indian families. Leaving India for a developped country is. It's normal those returning from abroad don't get a jobs in India. They likely applied to low tier schools/or scams to give themselves a chance in securing residency and failed to do so. India's population growth is only good to boost GDP numbers. What it does is ensure unlimited cheap labor which means endless poverty for the majority of Indians.

[@BNSingh129]

When these guys are OK then they say they are from PUNJAB they don't even talk any good about INDIA, when things go bad they say they are INDIAN. remember one thing CANADA is so GENEROUS about bringing new liberal voters..they don't deport anyone unless they come here on very fraudulent documents..which is a major problem with people from Punjab region.

[@suzanaandrade5820]

Scam starts from which Country..

[@viya2234]

The blame game should be even on students, just bcs they want a lavish lifestyle in abroad nd settle there after graduation they flew away from the country and when they face troubles there they again look back to Indian Gov this is totally unfair

[@bkc286]

💯

[@rajeshmukadam20]

Great story why does this happen we need to put a stop I would love volunteer to bring this fake people advertising largely on Instagram I sad be we has a nation need to put these companies accountable 🙏

[@pardeepshori3355]

What can one unfortunately expect when the Canadian Gov blame Indian Gov for interfering with domestic politics, the environment is ripe and budding for anti national stance (K Stan), and ongoing racial related crimes to those of the Sanatana Dharma faith. Now with rampant fraud for attracting students, it creates a volatile mix of anger rage

[@kentclark9740]

You are always crying victim. We all know they were Indians and Indian companies that defrauded the Indian students and the colleges and universities. Now you play victim like your religion is under attack. This coming from the land of mob justice and land of killing meat eaters and gang rapes of children. Land of land mafias and Delhi criminal police that works with land mafia to steal billions worth of property from NRI's. Also, Hindus are the worlds least persocuted group of people on earth. Everybody likes them for the most part. I know I like most of the ones I've met.

[@agnescraig2912]

India and Indians always blame the West and have been doing so for 50+years. But they still go West and Not to Russia China or Middle East to settle. Shaming India has always been on their lips but these unlawful crimes and scams are worthy of praise and not shame

[@ritikaagarwal48]

Thanks a lot Ma'am for such insightful video I think another reason for students living abroad is competition and status symbol, we have reputed colleges and universities present in India itself.