CANNIBAL CORPSE All Albums Ranked (w/ CHAOS HORRIFIC!)

[@robscallon]

Evisceration Plague will always be my favorite That albums release and its making of videos were my first real exposure to the band. I also happened to be really interested in learning heavier music on my guitar at the time. Learned the whole album front to back. I couldn’t get enough.

[@forgemastermetal]

Hey man, love your videos and thanks for the comment! CC riffs are legendary and super creative. What’s your favorite tune to rip? Cheers bud.

[@ben2jumanji956]

Forgemaster: cannibal corpse is a fantastic band also Forgemaster: puts the fan favorites in the okay tier

[@forgemastermetal]

haha - it doesn’t matter dude. If you flipped this around, someone else will be mad. Don’t care. 🤷‍♀️

[@richardplasencia5532]

Seeing Wretched Spawn ranked so low pounds my heart into dust.

[@vladanmarjanovic2344]

Yeah. Personaly it's my favourite.

[@forgemastermetal]

I see what you did there.

[@iamablowfish8531]

Same. TWS rules. It’s my third favorite record behind the bleeding and bloodthirst. Severely underrated

[@Kwinten360]

This should be called 2 metalcore bros rate something they never listened to.

[@forgemastermetal]

That's weird because we've been listening to this band for 15+ years. Try again.

[@MrLando0]

The Bleeding is fantastic, their best album IMO. So damn catchy. Though I was just getting into death metal when it came out, the nostalgia is strong.

[@forgemastermetal]

Yeah, great record!

[@bornsinner8718]

agree!!

[@Cwin-ny6bp]

I feel like Cannibal Corpse toned down the misogyny and general shock value almost immediately when Fisher replaced Barnes and significantly upped the musicianship and songwriting. Aside from being a better vocalist and much more likable figure than Barnes (IMO), Fisher also just isn’t quite as demented. It’s still violent splatter movie stuff, but it’s not shockingly offensive anymore. I like the stuff they did with Barnes, but I’m often glad he’s difficult to decipher. I feel like they really prioritized the music over the shock value when they brought Fisher in.

[@forgemastermetal]

You've got some fantastic input here, Forgemate!

[@livetowin8100]

Yeah it can be hard listening to those older songs because of how gross they can get at times. Later bands would take it further like Devourment but Barnes era CC was still pretty shocking lol

[@Morning_Star_Productions]

Agreed, Fisher era (which is my personal favorite) feels like a fun schlocky 80s slasher film, Barnes era (which is great but has flaws) feels like an edgy 15 year old trying to sound cool in front of his friends, although there are still some pretty great tracks, like Hammer Smashed Face, I Cum Blood, and despite it feeling a bit misogynistic, I do admittedly enjoy Addicted to Vaginal Skin, that last one mostly just because it’s honestly creepy as hell to me with the opening dialogue

[@devildozer]

If the album artwork for Butchered at Birth pisses you off then Cannibal Corpse succeeded in the cover art department.

[@forgemastermetal]

I said this already.

[@jeremiaherickson2068]

The Bleeding to me is S-Tier. It got me into Death Metal. P.S. What do you think of the new Suffocation song?

[@forgemastermetal]

Right there with ya. Amazing profile pic, too.

[@jeremiaherickson2068]

Thank you!!

[@c4ss1133]

i really like that you guys gave honest opinions rather than popular ones. ive seen too many rankings, where just because a small number of songs the are good, the whole album is s tier, and that's really not fair at all in my opinion. great video, some awesome discussion and rankings :)

[@forgemastermetal]

We really try to make it a challenge by limiting our S-picks. Thanks for tuning in!

[@zschokks5583]

If you refer to Tomb of the mutilated, I´m 100% with you. Trenches put it in Perfection tier....

[@nickisme]

I love The Wretched Spawn, it might be my favorite Cannibal Corpse album. Good to see a different opinion though.

[@forgemastermetal]

Hey, thank you for being respectful! We don't ask for it, but it's nice to see someone default to it. It's all subjective, mate. Enjoy what you enjoy and don't let anyone force you to feel otherwise! Stay horrific!

[@ilves6664]

Hello! Great ranking guys! Bloodthirst and Kill are still my favorite album by Cannibal Corpse albums. New one is good album anyway.

[@forgemastermetal]

Yusss!

[@drakoniz]

The bleeding... good? Oh dudes you're going crazy😂

[@forgemastermetal]

We are fine.

[@Flugmorph]

butchered at birth is their best album

[@forgemastermetal]

It's fine!

[@nicholasanderson9019]

Love it nice work

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks!

[@scottlowry6857]

Cannibal Corpse doesn't have a bad album, so almost everyone's rankings are wildly different and that's ok! Personally, my top five corpse albums are Kill, Torture, The Wretched Spawn, The Bleeding and Bloodthirst.

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for sharing your picks. We totally agree with you that there really aren't any bad albums.

[@TripDaly_AndiTripDaily]

The first four albums alone will continue to outsell any & all garbage to come out afterwards. Every album with George sounds like a cover of their previous albums being a new cover of themselves.

[@Hecatecrossways]

Do you guys have a 1990s Death Metal albums ranking part 4 ? I'd be interested to hear how you would rank Deeds of Flesh, Disgorge USA California, and Vital Remains

[@forgemastermetal]

We haven't gotten around to part 4 yet. Stay tuned though!

[@dystopicaudiobypatdaniel6227]

Man I mostly agree with your list. I do have a soft spot for "The Wretched Spawn" though. It was the album that got me into Cannibal Corpse and into Death Metal in general. I never could get into Chris Barnes's vocals so I fully agree with your placement of the classics. Man I remember meeting Paul and George almost 20 years ago. For everyone saying "never meet your heros" I guess you picked the wrong guys to admire because those dudes where so nice and humble. Killer band, killer album, I hope they got a few more in the tank.

[@forgemastermetal]

It’s funny how the albums that get us into bands are held near and dear.

[@BluejaySpectre]

Perfect. This video will help give me more context for their discography.

[@forgemastermetal]

Awesome! We love to hear that.

[@zschokks5583]

Oh my god, first people being honest about Tomb of the mutilated! Hallelujah! It´s so refreshing... And I like how you respect the differences between you two. Cannibal corpse is actually the reason why I got so late into death metal. They were my first experience in DM and I totally rejected the whole genre for almost 20 years after this first listen. I don´t agree with the majority saying that CC doesn´t have bad albums. They have albums full of bland tunes, and these are what I call bad albums especially in death metal, which is a "meat and potato" style of music in which you can´t do much wrong. Now i matured and I can enjoy some albums: - Bloodthirst - Violence unimagined - Eaten back to life - The bleeding - Skeletal domain My favorite song though is "Meat hook sodomy". It´s so vicious and gross, and the riff is sick!

[@forgemastermetal]

We want to respect one another and wish some of our viewers would follow those same values. Oh well. Anonymity on the internet turns people into jerks haha. They absolutely do not have bad albums, and even their bad albums have some RIPPERS on em. Thanks for the great comment!

[@2MuchMajinBuuty]

Awesome tanking guys. Personally, Torture is my S ranked album, I think Red Before Black is kinda underrated imo

[@enferex]

As always, great vid. Perhaps my first taste of CC was in Ace Ventura. I totally appreciate their music, but never got too deep. That needs to change, and this ranking can be helpful in getting me caught up, thanks!

[@forgemastermetal]

Glad to do it, mate! Dive on in!

[@NeptuneTowers]

Five minutes into this ranking and I'm offended ;) The classics in the lower tiers, damn you guys.

[@forgemastermetal]

DAMN US TO HELLLLLLLLLLL

[@Cwin-ny6bp]

Torture is like Kill perfected for me, and those might be my two favorite CC albums. I’d definitely put Tomb, Vile, and the Bleeding higher. I do agree with with the general consensus from y’all that the Corpsegrinder era is superior overall. Rutan’s addition as producer and later lead guitarist was a home run too. That guy is criminally underrated and has played with both Morbid Angel (for Domination and the criminally underrated Gateways to Annihilation) and Cannibal Corpse, along with his excellent work with Ripping Corpse and his brainchild Hate Eternal, and being one of the best producers in extreme metal.

[@indieeric6530]

I was very into metalcore/deathcore when I was younger. I wanted to like death metal, but just couldn’t get into it. Then Kill was released. It finally clicked for me and I’ve been a fan ever since.

[@FaustianSpirit1997]

My ranking: 16) Gore Obsessed 15) Red Before Black 14) Vile 13) Eaten Back To Life 12) Gallery Of Suicide 11) Evisceration Plague 10) Skeletal Domain 9) The Wretched Spawn 8) Butchered At Birth 7) Bloodthirst 6) The Bleeding 5) Torture 4) Chaos Horrific 3) Violence Unimagined 2) Kill 1) Tomb Of The Mutilated * This is what i love about CC album rankings: The different opinions, everyone has their own favorite and least favorite. And also i agree with the point about Brutal Death Metal and Slam having some, say, flirtatious attitudes with misoginy to the point that Devourment's frontman came forward to say that he's ashamed of some of the band's past lyrics. And if you know what type of shit those guys used to sing about, you know is a powerful statement. Great video, pretty much what i always expect from both of you.

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for sharing that story about the Devourment front man! We were not aware of that.

[@BeneathTheRemains-ls9lt]

Gore obsessed does not deserve 16

[@FaustianSpirit1997]

@@BeneathTheRemains-ls9lt My personal opinion says otherwise.

[@BeneathTheRemains-ls9lt]

@@FaustianSpirit1997 good for you.

[@FaustianSpirit1997]

@@BeneathTheRemains-ls9lt It's not that i think it's a bad album, Cannibal Corpse don't have any, i just find it the least interesting of their catalogue. My opinion may change though, Bloodthirst used to be my least favorite and now i love that album.

[@ChimairaGod]

The album cover passes you off? You do realize it's a cannibal corpse album? Shocking images is part of it.

[@forgemastermetal]

I literally said this in the video dude.

[@felipegiraldo8100]

Imagine being pissed off by a cartoonish gore art, bet this guy passes out if he sees a real corpse butchery photo

[@forgemastermetal]

Teach me how to be a tough guy like you, daddy.

[@billcowan5539]

The New album is an A for me, I love the Beefy production and that the Bass is so prominent in the mix, Cannibal Corpse are Freaking Legends 👑 Awesome Ranking 💪🤘🤘

[@forgemastermetal]

Yeah, great production for sure!

[@patrickr6505]

MEH..it's too Muddy and Sloppy..

[@xNachtmahRx]

Thank Rutan for the sloppiness and overcompressed production. He never evolved his guitar playing and he probably loves Rick Rubin and the loudness war

[@beastateverything2.07]

This whole rank vid just blows my mind away

[@forgemastermetal]

I wonder what things that actually matter do to your mind then, lol

[@MetalNeverDieswithMarkA]

This is a great list. More and more I find the Chris Barnes albums going lower since the beginning. Cheers guys

[@forgemastermetal]

Cheers, Mark!

[@ethanpinder267]

Absolutely love the new album, personally my favorite albums are anything from Vile to Evisceration Plague. Vile, Gallery, and Bloodthirst in particular are my favorites.

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for tossing yours in the mix.

[@jasonscholl2945]

I also tend to stay in the Vile/Gallery/Blood thirst/Kill/Evisceration/Torture/Skeletal era. For a band with 16 full lengths, i am QUITE impressed at CCs catalogue. Really not one total stinker!

[@shredfactor7]

Bloodthirst was the album that really got me hooked on Cannibal. The production, the guitars, drums, vocals and bass are insane!! Flawless!!

[@forgemastermetal]

Yeeaaaaaa buddy!!

[@danjometaldread4497]

Man, I love how every video ends with Ben's funny, guttural vocal tagline to finish it off. They crack me up and are awesome! Someday it would be sweet to see a compilation video with all of his outro tags in succession!!!

[@forgemastermetal]

Lmao that would rule

[@TheMetalGaia]

One of my proudest metal moments is meeting Vince Locke, the artist for all of CC's albums at a convention. Super chill dude. He did a panel where he sketched stuff and explained the process behind creating the Violence Unimagined cover since it was new at the time. He signed an ad for his art because I didn't have any merch on me or plan on seeing him that day lol.

[@forgemastermetal]

That is freaking awesome. He’s an absolutely iconic illustrator. What about the process was unique for Violence Unimagined?

[@TheMetalGaia]

@@forgemastermetal that's a great question! To paraphrase Vince, I believe he said that these days, the band gives him complete creative freedom to design the covers. He'll get a call from Corpsegrinder with the title and a brief description, and go from there. He was particularly proud of the alternate art for Violence Unimagined (the headshot of the woman with the tongue), and I even told him it was my favorite of the two versions. Vince was a comic artist first, so it was great to get his insight into how he works. Very sweet guy, I highly recommend talking to him if he's ever at a convention near you.

[@raymondrobert3403]

Eaten is my favorite. Absolutely brutal energy from every instrument especially the vocals. I also love the zombie horror movie theme on top of all that comic gore in the lyrics.

[@calebcanatheviphth4654]

I am so happy seeing Bloodthirst getting so much love. That was also the album that got me into them, and under-40-minute album should totally be their thing. It’s savage, George is savage. And also big agree that Chaos Horrific is very attuned to the times. it’s the album that 2023 desperately needed: just super good and super fun.

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for your comment!

[@randycunningham7318]

Got me into them too. My favorite.

[@heavynbrutalaf6568]

For me 16 - Eaten Back to Life 15 - Butchered at Birth 14 - Gore Obsessed 13 - Tomb of the Mutilated 12 - The Bleeding 11 - Vile 10 - Gallery of Suicide 9 - Chaos Horrific 8 - Violence Unimagined 7 - Evisceration Plague 6 - Red Before Black 5 - Kill 4 - The Wretched Spawn 3 - A Skeletal Domain 2 - Bloodthirst 1 - Torture

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@georgecolby7488]

Love your analysis, agree almost 100%. Glad you called out the change of cringey direction in album art/lyric content, early CC is almost a complete no-go for me because of it. I've never been a huge fan, so hearing your top picks let's me be a little more informed when digging in. I always looked at CC just like Slayer: a few incredible must-have albums and an occasional great song on an overall mediocre album. You guys rule, so happy to see such great metal content! 🤘

[@forgemastermetal]

I appreciate that man! We’re getting a lot of flack for rating the older albums so low, lol. Metalheads can be so sensitive when you don’t mirror their opinions.

[@sianthorw5537]

very interesting watching this review. Im clearly much older and Find albums like "butchered" as S tier, Its awesome that people who were 6 when that album came out would be listening to CC now.....nobody thought CC would be here in 2024. Theres a ton of CC albums i have never even listened to (mostly mid era) Im gonna go check em out.

[@SunnDeath]

"The Wretched Spawn" (2003) is my fav. Festering in the Crypt is a fucking hypnotic song!

[@AlmightyWhitey-g6w]

The bleeding is my fav the groove and hooks are amazing 🤘🤘

[@peeledapples4176]

Can't say I agree with all these choices but I appreciate the perspective! Thumbs up for the Bloodthirst love though, that album is fucking SAVAGE

[@forgemastermetal]

It's all subjective, mate!

[@jasonscholl2945]

I saw Cannibal Corpse at end of 2022 and their playing Scourge of Iron is what I think actually caused the venue to collapse 3 months later when Morbid Angel came to town.

[@forgemastermetal]

Holy crap!

[@richardsinclair7661]

Putting Butchered at Birth, The Wretched Spawn, AND Eaten Back to Life in the Okay tier and then having the GALL to put Evisceration Plague in Fantastic is just...I have no words. My fucking around aside, I think your guys' tier list is totally valid. I've seen a lot of varying tier lists for CC's discography and I think the fact that so many are able to have such differing opinions speaks to the bands consistency. My first comment was way too tongue-in-cheek. Oops.

[@forgemastermetal]

I’ll have all the gall I want, pal. I don’t really care if people love those albums. It’s an internet video. It’s gonna be ok.

[@richardsinclair7661]

@@forgemastermetal Dear god, I hope you're joking. If you really didn't read the full comment before replying I'm going to unsub right now. 😂 Actually, I think my comment isn't conveying what I mean appropriately. Lemme do an edit of shame.

[@forgemastermetal]

Lol it’s all good dude. We’re getting all kinds of flack on videos like this. Sometimes I quick fire my responses a bit too fast. 💚 totally agree on your consistency take

[@richardsinclair7661]

@@forgemastermetal I like seeing your guys' differing opinions. It creates interesting discussion around the bands in question. It's not your guys' fault that a sizeable chunk of metal fans can't handle when their favorite groups or albums get criticized. That's why I haven't started a music review channel of my own, haha.

[@Morning_Star_Productions]

Torture is amazing, my favorite album, Scourge of Iron is my overall favorite song of theirs, and I love the character on the cover, I want someone to make a horror movie with him as the main villain

[@J_Stamps86]

Submerged in Boiling Flesh has to be my favourite Cannibal Corpse song of all time

[@forgemastermetal]

Such a sick song title, too.

[@Mr.Goldbar]

Vile to me is the most underrated album CC has ever done, it seems like the exact opposite of The Bleeding in a lot of ways. The Bleeding has Barnes On Vocals, very simple catchy riffs and stuctures, Eb Standard guitars, understated cover art and unhinged lyrical themes. Vile on the other hand has Corpsegrinder on vocals, much more technical and almost tech death riffs and song structures, Way more downtuned guitars (Bb Standard but also C# Standard, the only album they've ever done in this tuning), insane album cover (though not as much as Tomb or Butchered) and more understated yet still violent and even more personal lyrics (Perverse Suffering, Orgasm Through Torture). I think many didn't like Vile because it was so different from The Bleeding, and it was them shifting direction totally. It was their first attempt and I love it, but at the same time I think they got that style together even better once Pat joined.

[@TheEraOfCurruption]

man butchered at birth is fucking great, heavy as hell

[@forgemastermetal]

It's fine.

[@Mr.Turkeylovesmusic]

Personally i love eaten back to life

[@forgemastermetal]

That’s great man!

[@DukeEnlil]

Bloodthirst is still my №1 album, №2 -The Wretched Spawn № 3 - Kill!

[@forgemastermetal]

Awesome picks!

[@resington]

It's amazes me how different everyone's opinions on their discography is. So unpredictable.

[@forgemastermetal]

Dude we got THREATENED because of our picks lmao some of these fans are ridiculous.

[@resington]

@@forgemastermetal that's hilarious! Where's the need for that behaviour?

[@Hecatecrossways]

I bought everything by Cannibal Corpse ,and Tomb of the Mutilated was difficult to get into due to the Vocals being too whispery ( similar to Mortal Throne of Nazarene by Incantation). I bought a remastered Tomb of the Mutilated, and the Vocals were a bit louder in the mix, and Upon the Throne of Apocalypse which is a demo recording of Mortal Throne. Both albums sounded much better. I really only liked the Barnes albums, not because Barnes is a better Vocalist than Corpsegrinder. It's just the earlier rough style seems catchier to me. I do like Devoured By Vermin, Mummified in Barbwire, and Dormant Bodies Bursting a lot though. Kill and Bloodthirst are the only Post Barnes full albums that I like.

[@flyingdutchman8093]

I just have so much trouble getting into them, just so much of it feels like it’s just shock value instead of good song writing. But that’s just my opinion. Oh and just found your channel and I’m getting back into metal and so far great job guys!

[@damyonsim4552]

I have always seen Corpse as a very brutal (lyrically and sound wise) driven band and imo they definitely got softer after Bleeding UNTIL the last 2 releases with Corpsegrinder. Just the way I see it as I have been buying their albums since Butchered was released

[@laurentjrtherrien5131]

Cryptic stench from tomb is great

[@melkor5901]

"The album artwork pisses me off." WHAT???

[@forgemastermetal]

It did it’s job. Calm the f*ck down.

[@melkor5901]

@@forgemastermetal uh, "calm the fuck down" might be escalating but whatever dude. It's just such a strange opinion to have when it's something they are so well known for. It's death metal, intentionally offensive imagery is kind of the tradition. But yeah, metal should become more politically correct I guess? It's shocking to get you to think. What's far more horrific is that the album cover is only an exaggeration of what happens every day.

[@forgemastermetal]

I get what the album art is trying to do. I said this in the episode. I love horror, I love gore, I even said the art was iconic. This is nothing mind blowing. Who gives a shit what I think. It’s dumbass caveman death metal. None of this matters.

[@melkor5901]

@@forgemastermetal wait till he finds out about black metal lmao. Caveman death metal? Not very respectful to what these guys have accomplished including the artwork, it's genuinely a genius move.

[@forgemastermetal]

Lol ok pal

[@simonh.3148]

Butchered is their most demanding and relentless release and much like Deicide's Legion way ahead of its time, people weren't ready for it. But now it doesn't make any sense to me seeing it in the lowest tier.

[@mattirealm]

Most of their stuff is great IMO. Even though it was a single/video, I find Priests of Sodom to be super underrated and super heavy as well. Great band and the Rutan era (on guitar) is off to a really good start.

[@forgemastermetal]

Definitely!

[@shredfactor7]

Bloodthirst and Kill as perfection? I agree!!!

[@jeremiaherickson2068]

Quick, do a Six Feet Under tier list😅😅. Kidding, nobody deserves that punishment.

[@forgemastermetal]

😆😆

[@blackwaterrust476]

would bEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE a Great TiEEEEEEEEEEEEEEElist EEEEEEEE

[@felipegiraldo8100]

Aside Jokes they would probably the type of guys putting Haunted at the top of the list while putting the bleeding in the Second to least line of a Cannibal corpse ranking

[@RedbullSW]

Surprisingly this is way different from the general consensus of Cannibal Corpse all over the internet

[@forgemastermetal]

We are different lol

[@shredfactor7]

My S choices are Bloodthirst, Kill and Evisceration Plague. EviscerationI constantly go back to time and time again.

[@forgemastermetal]

Sick!

[@261290]

Cannibal Corpse + Rutan is a winning combination. There isn't really a bad album for Cannibal Corpse. I think that if any other band would put out any of the "not so good" CC albums, they would be discography highlight. Cannibal Corpse today is quality and consistency IMHO.

[@forgemastermetal]

Definitely!!

[@curdledmayonnaise]

i would put chaos in the top 7, it's a great album and has a sort of simplicity to it while still being brutal. in no order i'd say - chaos, tortured, kill, ep, wretched spawn , skeletal, tomb

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for sharing!

[@HarrisEfkarpos]

For Cannibal Corpse you must cancel the Okay section - thank you💀💀💀💀💀

[@forgemastermetal]

Even their OK albums are good, compared to most other bands!

[@mindful2864]

I loved this new Cannibal Corpse album. These guys are death metal legends and every album they’ve put out has been great. Here would be my ranking: S - Tomb of the Mutilated, The Bleeding, Bloodthirst, The Wretched Spawn, Torture, A Skeletal Domain A - Eaten Back to Life, Gallery of Suicide, Kill, Evisceration Plague, Violence Unimagined, Chaos Horrific B - Butchered at Birth, Vile, Gore Obsessed, Red Before Black

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for sharing!

[@tannerhuskins330]

Interesting list. I somewhat agree but would swap Eviscerstion Plague and the bleeding or tomb

[@forgemastermetal]

That's fair!

[@Jon-vn9sn]

The Bleeding at “good” AND Vile above it?? I’m out…

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for announcement. No one cares.

[@dazedviking3286]

The eaten back to life slander will not be tolerated LOL. Put some respect on that shit, edible autopsy has absolutely one of the most classic riffs the bands ever wrote. The album is a youthful and pure classic!

[@forgemastermetal]

None of this was slander lol

[@hornmoviereviews8739]

All honesty all 5 of these guys are the nicest guys you'll ever meet. The older era of cannibal the gets criticism for the misogynistic themes that was all chris barns writing and he is definitely a unhinged person. But they still play those older songs like Stripped, R****, and strangled live and ive seen cannibal alot live and there is just as much women at the show as there are guys and the ladies go nuts when they hear those songs and have fun.

[@BeneathTheRemains-ls9lt]

Bleeding is S tier no questions asked

[@forgemastermetal]

I see why people think that.

[@Superghoulsghosts]

Butchered at birth- "the album art still pisses me off" Good then it did its job.

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for repeating what we said lmao

[@Superghoulsghosts]

That's about the response I'd except from a channel with a comment reminder to be nice lol Yall are cute

[@forgemastermetal]

What a pointless comment.

[@cancorp29]

The ONLY one I disagree with is Torture. I LOVE that album from beginning to end. Great reviews!

[@forgemastermetal]

Appreciate you tuning in!

[@davidburns6284]

Since Cannibal Corpse is so consistently good, the album rankings I see are all over the place. However, this is probably the lowest I've seen for Tomb of the Mutilated and The Bleeding. Those are landmark albums and certainly much higher for me. Nice to see Evisceration Plague high up here. That one is usually lower in most rankings. The new album, Chaos Horrific, is fantastic. Looking forward to getting into it more. S: Kill, Tomb of the Mutilated, The Bleeding, Torture, Bloodthirst A: A Skeletal Domain, Evisceration Plague, Chaos Horrific, Violence Unimagined B: The Wretched Spawn, Gallery of Suicide C: Butchered at Birth, Gore Obsessed, Red Before Black, Vile D: Eaten Back to Life

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for sharing your list!

[@foxredt2]

Crazy how different CC Albums are ranked. I have the feeling, for CC Albums it's more different than other bands. What do you think? Is that so? And If yes do you have a theory?

[@forgemastermetal]

It's all subjective. My short theory is that people have different albums that "hit" them at the appropriate time and those albums become attached to that person's perception of and relation to the band. It's all subjective! However, there are albums that some people love more than others and the spectrum seems to be more based on what generation / age group you fall in more than anything else. I'd be curious to see some hard data on that, though!

[@blackwaterrust476]

FIRE UP THE CHAINSAW!!!!!!!!!! HACK THEIR FUCKING HEADS OFFF!!!! How Cannibal Corpse is able to make the same album over and over and over and over again and it’s still mostly fucking awesome is seriously so impressive to me. New album proves they STILL have plenty of fuel left in the tank to me Perfection: Skeletal Domain, Butchered at Birth, Kill, The Bleeding Fantastic: Torture, Bloodthirst, Tomb of the Mutilated Great: Chaos Horrific, Violence Unimagined, The Wretched Spawn Good: Eaten Back to Life, Gallery of Suicide, Evisceration Plague Ok: Gore Obsessed, Vile, Red Before Black

[@forgemastermetal]

Great list!! Thanks for sharing.

[@MarceloZ2]

Honestly, I would put all of the Chris Barnes albuns in the okay tier (even lower for Eaten Back to Life). I can’t fucking stand his vocals, even in The Bleeding where it’s a little more bearable. Every time I hear songs from this era of the band performed live with Corpsegrinder I just think how much better of a job he does singing them than Chris did. They need to be rerecorded asap, I love some songs on these records but I just refuse to listen to Chris Barnes sing.

[@BeneathTheRemains-ls9lt]

That's crazy... bleeding is top tier

[@MarceloZ2]

@@BeneathTheRemains-ls9lt if rerecorded with Corpsegrinder, I agree. The Bleeding is easily the best of the first four. But Chris fucking Barnes man…

[@BeneathTheRemains-ls9lt]

@@MarceloZ2 ahh I understand. I don't really enjoys chris on eaten back to life and butchered, but on bleeding and tomb I love em. I love his little screech voice shit that he does. Especially in pick axe and pulverized.

[@felipegiraldo8100]

Rerecording those albums with corpsegrinder vocals would literally ruin everything they are supposed to be. those albums were oriented to OG Brutal Death which has to have Cookie Monster vocals, if you dont like it, bad for you and f off. Cannibal went technical and less brutal from vile and forward. if you like that stick with it. Changing Original stuff idea is jsut ridiculous

[@BeneathTheRemains-ls9lt]

@@felipegiraldo8100 your damn right!

[@takodabostwick8507]

Cannibal Corpse Albums Ranked 1. Kill 2. A Skeletal Remain 3. The Bleeding 4. Violence Unimagined 5. Tomb of the Mutilated 6. Chaos Horrific 7. Torture 8. Butchered at Birth 9. Bloodthirst 10. Vile 11. The Wrenched Spawn 12. Eaten Back to Life 13. Red Before Black 14. Gore Obsessed 15. Evisceration Plague 16. Gallery of Suicide All the albums are good. Some are better than others. But nonetheless, one of the greatest death metal bands of all time!

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for sharing!

[@fergalholmes]

You should delete this video immediately to save yourself further embarrassment.

[@forgemastermetal]

Nah, I’d rather annoy more people like you.

[@felipegiraldo8100]

@@forgemastermetal Annoying is seeing people like you guys being "Metal Reviewers" providing such Atrocious opinions and Ranking. This whole video makes no sense in the musical perspective of things.

[@forgemastermetal]

Cry harder. Literally no one cares, lol.

[@BenFortier]

@@felipegiraldo8100 Oh no, people don't have the same opinion as you. Imagine people not following the herd. Weird.

[@mercyfulnate]

I’m pretty basic when it comes to Cannibal Corpse, The Bleeding and Kill are my two favorites

[@forgemastermetal]

Nice!

[@mikediquinzio1444]

Thank GAWD for two things: 1- Evisceration Plague finally getting the love it deserves, and 2- somebody FINALLY saying “Decency DEFIED” correctly! So tired of hearing people call it “Decency DEFILED” or “Decency DEFINED”. Reading is Fundamental, people! 😂

[@forgemastermetal]

Lol - maybe it helps Ben is a writer

[@PeteHawthorne]

Pit Of Zombies got me into the band! \m/

[@forgemastermetal]

Amazing song.

[@mattmillerguitar]

Wretched Spawn, Bloodthirst, Kill Top 3 imo

[@forgemastermetal]

Awesome to see Bloodthirst up there

[@mattmillerguitar]

@@forgemastermetal first show I ever went to was when they toured on that album.

[@dallaire3345]

I wouldn't re-record The Bleeding. It's perfect that way.

[@forgemastermetal]

The older version would always be available

[@cowsdotricks]

Certain songs elevate albums. eg "From Skin to Liquid"

[@forgemastermetal]

Agree!

[@mang3139]

LOVE the new album. I'd put it in tier Fantastic

[@forgemastermetal]

Nice!!

[@davidpaul6822]

I don't understand the love Kill gets. It's the album I first heard from CC back in the day, but so much of the album is forgettable. The stand out tracks for me are really stand out, but as a whole it just ends up feeling mediocre. I also think Jack brought some great songs to Cannibal; even something like slain from TWS was a nice change of pace on that album. Not that Rob didn't on kill, or later albums, but I think Jack was a better fit.

[@mattack6779]

I have lived in Tampa since being dumped into this fishbowl of shit called life for 60yrs. That being said, the best part of my life was my 20s because I went to every Thrash, Hardcore then a little later Death Metal show in the Tampa Bay area and Corpse along with bands like Deicide, Morbid, Atheist, Bad Brains, Napalm Death, Circle Jerks, Sepultura, etc .played here a lot. They were supported and loved here, TB fans are a big part of the reason Death and other "extreme" genres of music exist now. I know this is a "critical" review of CCs material but their worse albums are heads and shoulders above almost every other Death Metal bands' best material, especially live performances! Show a little more reverence to the best band in the Death Metal" genre ever, Cannibal Corpse! Of course, you can also tell me to f__k-off!

[@forgemastermetal]

I think it's funny how we tool on a band a bit and get called out for being "irreverent." They're an amazing band. We give some albums a hard time (with hyperbole, mind you) but have nothing but respect for them. Some of y'all get so twisted up around our opinions and it's amazing to see the little hills that people will perish on.

[@brians1793]

I've always thought Bloodthirst is underrated too, Pounded into Dust is one of my favorite CC songs and might be their least violent by far that has lyrics TBH, it's pretty tame for CC.

[@forgemastermetal]

Yeah good point, it’s not nearly as violent in a gory sense

[@grimblegromblethegnome]

Good ranking but you guys are crazy putting the wretched spawn so low. And also gore obsessed is too high. Switch those two and it's a bit more palatable. Good list tho.

[@grimblegromblethegnome]

Oh my God I commented too soon. Now you guys are really really crazy for putting Red Before Black so low. Like yeah it's not S tier but my God, "okay"? Smh. It's ok tho, it's cool to have different opinions.

[@grimblegromblethegnome]

Also, your ending thoughts are kinda dumb. Respectfully. "Cringe"? "Tone deaf"? "Misogyny"? Lol. No.

[@forgemastermetal]

Tell us more.

[@erikmathis5321]

The wretched spawn rules

[@forgemastermetal]

Thanks for sharing your opinion!

[@kerbalscuffedprogram4705]

@@forgemastermetal Their outro for that album ripped.

[@FalseNi9e]

😂 Mutilated is their best album followed by The Bleeding then Butchered. Difference of opinions is always great, but I've never seen someone put Mutilated that low.🤘

[@forgemastermetal]

We are the new age, homie.

[@Medicine-n9v]

Dudes! Love you guys, but I really can't relate to you on this tier list. Maybe it's a generational thing. Butchered At Birth and The Bleeding are some of the most iconic death metal records of all time. It's bewildering to me that you rate them so low, given the other music you like. As someone who was there in the 90s, your statement at 5:20: "this is how you do death metal in the 90s" feels inauthentic, like hearsay. Why say something like that if you were still little kids then? There’s nothing wrong with coming afterwards. No need to pretend. With respect, let me add this personal reflection: I’m also offended by this stuff, especially the early records, but for me the discomfort these records cause us can be points of artistic *strength*, not weakness. If you think horrific imagery is “cringe,” then maybe this kind of metal isn’t really your thing. That's part of why this music exists: it creates catharsis for the limit cases of experience. This stuff is *not OK*. It’s probably more popular than it should be. I expect you to understand this, because you guys listen to a lot of awful shit, from a standard moral perspective, and yet you’ve made it your calling, at least for now. If you haven't been taking that element seriously, then you have been trivializing suffering, which is morally wrong. In that case, if it takes listening to Cannibal and witnessing their album art for you to feel hurt, then I would respectfully suggest that Cannibal's art is therefore successful. If you feel disgusted by this art and feel a renewed desire to reject the violence it portrays, then *it’s working.* If it's been a while since the traumatic events you allude to have transpired and you still feel activated by this stuff, I encourage you to dial back on engaging with media like this and seek out help from somebody you trust, ideally a licensed therapist. I’ve had to take a timeout myself, sometimes for years before I could appreciate such aesthetics again. Otherwise, as long as it keeps nourishing you, please keep up your good work, even if this old dog disagrees from time to time.

[@forgemastermetal]

Some interesting takes in here, mate. "If you feel disgusted by this art and feel a renewed desire to reject the violence it portrays, then *it’s working." That really hits home the message we were saying about the album artwork. We appreciate you looking out for us (with your sentiments in the last paragraph.)

[@evilone1079]

KILL!!! I fucking love that album too!! Death walking terror is in absolute banger!

[@forgemastermetal]

YES

[@Sped_Dog]

Bro what eaten back and butchered are ok tf?

[@forgemastermetal]

OK is still good...

[@alexandremarcus4327]

Are you crazy? The Chris Barnes era is perfect ! Much better than George's era...

[@forgemastermetal]

It’s alllll subjective brotha! Cheers!

[@bruno_gatti]

Ranking The Wretched Spawn this low is a blasphemy, you should go back and listen to that masterpiece again

[@forgemastermetal]

We did :P

[@joeblogs4645]

Young nerds trying to rank CC albums... hilarious..come back in 20yrs when you've listened to them properly ffs

[@forgemastermetal]

Too bad you’ll be gone by then 😢

[@sixstringmetal8559]

*ear to eye

[@forgemastermetal]

Butt to taint*

[@felipegiraldo8100]

I was giving you guys an Oportunity by the time you were ranking Tomb of the mutilated but you just basically put all of the most Original and Death Metal-esque CC albums inthe lower positions which is just ridiculous considering the rest of their discography is basically the same with slight changes from album to album... i stoped watching and im not gonna see the whole thing, starting by saying the first albums have a lot of filler, not memorable and not liking the album covers is a very YIKES of an opinion when their later albums are the most same sounding stuff eve.., Kinda tells you guys are just the typical Good Clear Production soft Death Metal Enjoyers... Anyone can tell you are just this new generation of death metal listeners with no clue about what this genre is supposed to be

[@forgemastermetal]

Lol - OH NO AN OPINION. Grow up and grow a pair dude. So sensitive.

[@felipegiraldo8100]

@@forgemastermetal Am i being told to grow a pair and be less sensitive by a dude in his 30´s who gets upset by a cartoonish gore cover art?Oh Dear 😱🤣🤣

[@forgemastermetal]

I’m telling you you’re an immature idiot who cares about things that literally don’t matter. It’s an opinion. On the internet. About dumb caveman death metal. WHO GIVES A SHIT.

[@BenFortier]

The only people that are getting triggered are the old-school-caveman-death-metal fans that are crying we ranked the original stuff so low. WOW. Subjective opinions. Who would have thought that metal heads can be individuals and not follow the herd. Weird.

[@tannerhuskins330]

Yes, because liking early 90s CC is the standard to which all death metal opinions are based. I love CC, but that’s a tad harsh. Let’s not pretend early CC is what invented death metal. It’s great, but others from the time period and before did it better. Liking modern CC more than old CC doesn’t mean you have shit taste. It also doesn’t mean only liking clear modern production. I mean, the old records were made with Scott Burns, who’s records were clearer than a lot of OSDM.

[@MetalThrashingMan13]

Wretched Spawn is the best imo and Gore Obsessed is very forgettable and should have been ranked at the very bottom under everything

[@Ibreaker99]

@6:20 bro hating on an album because of suicide 😂😂😂 weak

[@forgemastermetal]

Didn’t hate on it at all. Try listening, idiot.