Canon R5 vs A7S III | Which Camera Is Better?

[@TylerEdwards]

Quick note on ISO comparison in Low Light section: R5 is top and A7S is bottom :)

[@bytomw]

Loved this! Thanks for making it Tyler! It's always nice seeing how our kit stacks up! Also Congratulations!!!! Being a dad rocks!

[@TylerEdwards]

Cheers Tom! Thanks for dropping by. Really enjoyed your Fuji/Canon comparison video. And SO STOKED to be a dad!

[@bytomw]

@@TylerEdwards thanks man. I really loved that camera, mine had a bunch of dead pixels when it came to doing the stills tests. I’m on the fence about ordering a 2nd right now.

[@rjroser202]

Loved this. Having owned both it’s still so satisfying to watch this type of video

[@TylerEdwards]

Haha well thanks for still watching!! Anything you think I left out?

[@henakos]

Hello, quick tip: you can't test R5 IBIS with image stabilized EF lens, because then IBIS is not in use. Only RF lenses can use IBIS and lens image stabilisation.

[@Josh_Sattin]

Great comparison Tyler! Both are amazing cameras.

[@TylerEdwards]

Thanks Josh! Agreed, they’re both great tools!

[@RelaxInAtmosphere]

Good video, dude! 👏

[@TylerEdwards]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@ranjanamitnp]

Thank you for this video, I am going for R5 because I would need something hybrid for just my personal consumptions.

[@puredistancegolf]

Great video. Honestly, one of the best comparison videos out there. Shoot Sony now but cannot stand the size, feel and user interface so plan on switching to Canon.

[@TylerEdwards]

Ergonomics is definitely important!

[@upcomingvillain]

After tons of research I had decided to go with the Sony but after going to the local camera shop I couldn't stand holding the Sony and the Canon I didn't want to put down! Didn't even make it to the menus!

[@puredistancegolf]

@@upcomingvillain You have to feel a connection with the tool or it won't be as enjoyable. Good luck!

[@GriffinConway]

Would you still have gotten the a7siii if the R5 had all the firmware updates when you were looking at? Also, so stoked to meet the baby soon bro 🙏🙏

[@TylerEdwards]

Good question! Probably so. It’s just better for video and it paid for itself after one gig.

[@andrewmcgaha9629]

Tyler... I just found your channel while comparing these 2 cameras. I think we have similar hobbies. Instant sub and like, and I can't wait to binge all your work! Wondering if you could answer a specific question... Complete newb who has gear acquisition syndrome. I'm probably 60/40 on the R5 because of the still resolution, and I want to capture some of the magnificent views I find while hiking and off-roading/overlanding, but one of my main concerns is that I really want to be able to do arrow flight analysis (compound bow / 294 fps arrow speed). I know the A7SIII will shoot 240fps and the R5 is 120fps max. Do you think I could slow the R5 footage down enough to track the arrow and see the flight well enough to analyze at 120fps?

[@TylerEdwards]

I haven’t done arrow flight analysis before so I’m not sure exactly what that entails, but if I needed to slow it down as much as possible, I’d probably be looking at a phantom or that Freefly slow motion camera. 120 (even 240) isn’t all that slow for something moving that fast.

[@GuusStemerding]

Love the vids

[@TylerEdwards]

Thanks!

[@omranmohammed4811]

Tyler thanks for this video man 😍😍😍😍 i got canon r6 and i want to switch to r5 or a7s3 which one you recommend for me 😍

[@TylerEdwards]

They’re both great just depends on your needs!

[@omranmohammed4811]

@@TylerEdwards tyler my needs gonna be little photo but most of the time videos . But not long videos at all just 1 min maximum ….. I appreciate your replay man❤️

[@jaymills1720]

I’d prefer the a7siii for noise AF and dynamic range but canon colors are the best. Any suggestions to get canon colors on Sony :)?

[@greek-freaks]

cool video...just a question: you said that the sony has better dr...than you show 2 situations in difficult light situation where both cameras seems to have the same dr...so...did i miss something?

[@TylerEdwards]

Yes, you missed something. Give it a watch again at the DR part

[@greek-freaks]

@@TylerEdwards highlight rolloff you mean?

[@mariamisharishbonete86]

Hi Tyler I have a question. When Shooting on a Log footage specifically SLOG 3 on SONY A7SIII, should I always over expose my image in 2 stops( is it necessary?) with my ISO or should I use 640 iso and overexpose it a bit with our lights? ( When exposing in a controlled environment) And also about overexposing the log footage. My friend are always using the 2nd native iso (12800) even in a controlled environtment like in studio or sets, but we monitor on creative mode with the ISO of 640 and adjust the lights, but when we switch at slog3 he always changed the ISO to 12800. I always argue with him to change it to 640 and overexpose it with our lights but he doesn't listen. Can you please explain it to me what is the best thing to do? HOPE YOU CAN HELP ME, I'M STILL AN AMATEUR FILMMAKER HEHEHE

[@TylerEdwards]

I sometimes will expose to the right by 1-1.5 stops but honestly I don’t think it is necessary if staying at 640 because the built in NR keeps shadows really clean-especially in a studio lit environment. I’d never use 12,800 in a studio environment for normal taking head stuff as it has less DR at that ISO.

[@Huginn1000]

What's the reason to have two different systems?

[@giancarlodambrosio230]

good video !

[@TylerEdwards]

Thank you!

[@Peony50-z5g]

thank you

[@thatsamuellu]

Hey, Tyler, I am a Sony a7siii user. I am very into komodo's natural cinema look over sony's digital sharpness, even with the mist filter on; any thought on that? Will you make a video of the Komodo vs. A7siii/fx3 comparison video? Thanx!

[@TylerEdwards]

I definitely plan to do some sport of comparison video between the a7s3 and Komodo!

[@thatsamuellu]

@@TylerEdwards Can't wait to see it, Thx!

[@lashello]

love it

[@adi0ne]

Thanks you for this video.

[@thebaptlight]

Merci !!

[@TylerEdwards]

you're welcome!

[@GaryWEdwardsCHS]

Great review. Even the novice could keep up with you...G

[@EverythingFilmmaking]

Sony all the way🎥👈🏻

[@TylerEdwards]

Great camera for sure!

[@GuusStemerding]

Keep it up

[@TylerEdwards]

🙏

[@mbismbismb]

The title should be 'video quality comparison between r5 and a7s3'

[@TylerEdwards]

but if I titled it that then someone would say, "not fair to favor the canon for stills since this is just about video like the title suggests." lol

[@mbismbismb]

@@TylerEdwards i don't see still photo comparison though in this video 😀

[@mbismbismb]

Team Canon here

[@tayo5302]

A7Siii > R5, R5c >A7SIII for video

[@TylerEdwards]

Interesting take!

[@prosunsport1]

Comparison, there is no comparison like a golf gti vs 911.

[@2famous-]

i really want the r5. for sure. ive watched so many videos comparing cameras to it. but imma watch this. but imma still go with the r5 😂

[@bengtturvey5005]

🍀 p͎r͎o͎m͎o͎s͎m͎

[@wadesweeney2200]

R5 for the win

[@TylerEdwards]

Great camera indeed!