Carhartt vs. Duluth Trading Co.

[@MrBill-mq7ti]

After hurricane Ireine blew through, Carhartt showed up with tractor trailers full of clothes (coats, pants, gloves and hats) to pass out for everyone effected. That sold me on Carhartt. Great product and a great company.

[@CarlMurawski]

Man, you can’t beat that. Very cool!

[@grantquinones]

So welfare changed your mind oh ok

[@MrBill-mq7ti]

Welfare? Dont be a simpleton. Carhartt came to the aid of a devistated community in the time of need. They didn't make a huge media event out of it, they just sent truckloads of product to help. That's a company I will proudly support.

[@jakeedgell591]

@@grantquinones Welfare is when the government burns up taxpayer dollars on the jobless. A private company using their time and money to aid in a natural disaster is charity.

[@grantquinones]

@@jakeedgell591 so you graduated middle school you're a smart dude

[@badidea9381]

I have worked in construction for 50 years. I have worn every brand of work clothing made. I have worn Duluth clothing exclusively for the last 10 years.

[@CarlMurawski]

Now that’s all the proof I need! Experience beats theory any day of the week.

[@kylekayser2291]

Switched to 5_11 tactical pants 5 years ago they are the most comfortable and great for heavy construction work underground utilities. They have a fit like military pants and dry quickly when wet. Every pair of carhartts always tore out in the crotch and the legs soak up water like a candle wick.

[@justbob1968]

@@kylekayser2291 Thanks, I'll try them.

[@johncooper7663]

@@kylekayser2291 5-11 gear is no joke. Its very durable

[@bigdog77]

will they make my thighs look to big..?

[@Andresortega-nd2js]

My dad (who is a field technician for direct tv) was using Carhartt up until 2013 when he found out about Duluth. Since then he’s had 3 pairs of the firehouse pants, and I have 2 since I’m a field tech too, and I’ve gotta say, they’re not only the best for work, but also skating and doing mechanic work. Still have a couple old Carhartt jackets tho lol, those are tanks.

[@trige000]

My Carhartt is from when I entered Middle School and I still wear it today, I am 25.

[@wesowsley7625]

DUUUUUUUUDE! ALL MY DULUTH GEAR IS AMAZING FOR SKATING! AND THATS WHY I LOVE IT!!! Even some of the female garments are amazing. Like the Garden Overalls, they're amazing for summer days when ya want a lighter material, but still quite durable. I haven't seen menswear made from the same material so I don't mind buying female hahahah

[@DarthAvi73]

Personally I LOVE the "overbuilt" nature of Duluth's clothing. I was sad to see that the "ultimate cargo pants" were no longer offered with the more abrasion resistant nylon reinforcement.

[@codeyroberson7128]

The Duluth Deadhorse Jacket is by far the warmest and most durable jacket I have ever worn. It is also super flexible. Being an arborist both of these things are important.

[@phrayzar]

One request to all workwear and outdoor wear companies. STOP stone washing all your gear. You are literally removing years of wearability from them.

[@markyates7006]

Carhartt has actually stopped, and new replacement products are coming out this year.

[@rolledsocks5167]

I don’t understand what this is?

[@markyates7006]

@@rolledsocks5167 a process that gives new clothing a worn-in appearance. Usually accomplished by washing goods in a drum with pumice or with chemicals. Can reduce the life of the product and can be harmful to the environment.

[@rolledsocks5167]

Mark Yates I bought a Carhartt jacket last fall it didn’t seem worn when I bought it how am I supposed to know if they stone washed it?

[@1911geek]

Fashionable why trend who knows keep it simple

[@Rose-rh3ib]

I work in a Duluth distribution center. I can confirm the clothing is very thick and heavy... getting boxes full of pants down is quite the feat.

[@ccampbell7214]

Wheaties

[@mattg1987]

I used to wear carhartt for work and always had issues with the crouch wearing out (6'4" 300 lbs), now with the Duluth trading flex denim the gusset plus the flex is amazing. Never going back to anything else.

[@amywarfield8913]

Try Duluth long tail tees!!! My hubby is 6'3" and 300 lbs. No plumber butt!!

[@Scmd37]

The things i like most about duluth are the thoughtful little details and you think what a great idea. How come no one else does this. Wide rear belt loop, zipper garage, magnet buttons on some of their dress shirts ( very handy for someone with dexterity issues) I will continue to be a satisfied customer.

[@shanen457]

The best thing about Duluth is their commercials. 😂😂😂

[@shannoninalaska]

I just discovered Duluth Trading Co. after recently moving to Alaska. The style here is definitely aligned with the work wear and outdoor activities. I don't have a lot of experience wearing Carhartt products but Duluth just looks and feels like quality. I am still waiting on several fire hose jackets and wool beanies to be delivered this week. They have beautiful clothing.

[@Daynaleo1]

I moved from Carhart to Duluth about 10 years ago and haven’t looked back. Most days, everything I have on except for my socks and boots are made by Duluth. Even my skivvies. I had a hard time justifying the cost at first, now I don’t even blink. The fire hose work pants you showed are the ones I buy. I have some that are 5 years old with nicks and caulk and paint and... on them. Still work in them. Almost forgot, EXCELLENT REVIEW. If I ever have time, I want to do some comparison reviews on tools I use and disposables like glues and caulks.

[@erikdale9145]

You should try their slip on boots. Totally legit and great for MN -30* dog walks even, never a slip

[@tmcricci456]

Go For DARN TOUGH SOCKS! THEY'RE AWESOME!

[@truebeliever320]

how do the firehouse pants fair in rainy weather?

[@spoperquimix1]

PLEASE do the caulk comparison. It would be greatly appreciated.

[@plumber77mjr]

The 7-yr socks are pretty good. Deciding between those and some wigwams I have.

[@bbqphantom1638]

I have been happy with all the Duluth clothes that I have worn. I found that Carhart sizing is in consistant and tends to run smaller so a bigger guy has trouble finding carhart that fits.

[@CarlMurawski]

That’s one thing Duluth gets right is their full cuts.

[@jimwhite2893]

My biggest pet peeve in the world is having to try on every piece of clothing because it all fits differently. Duluth fits the first time every time

[@toddpawly8354]

I came across Duluth Trading Co. back in 07 (give or take a year) with their mail order catalog. Bought two pair of jeans from them, still holding out strong. I do like that Duluth uses larger zippers on their pants (much easier to work if wearing gloves (or have big fingers), and they have larger pockets.

[@rickemerson1451]

CARL I HAVE WORE BOTH CAR HART AND DULUTH OVERALLS MY FIRST PAIR OF DULUTH PANTS I HIT IT WITH A CHAINSAW BY ACCIDENT AND IT DID NOT THROUGH AND CUT ME. THAT SOLD ME ON DULUTH TRADING . GREAT CLOTHS.

[@Saw_Squatch]

I've always thought Carhartt has a better, smoother, tighter weave in their canvas, I really love Carhartt for jackets and bibs, but the innovation that Duluth is known for really shows over the "tradition" of Carhartt. Also Please do a CCF filson workwear review, I'm interested in what they have to offer and it'd be great to see if filson can rediscover it's roots a little

[@johnweymouth5685]

Duluth hands down! I've been buying strictly Duluth since 2010 for both work & pleasure. even those I bought 8yrs ago are still going strong. And yes they make fire hose 5 pocket jeans. they make them in heavyweight & midweight in both fire hose & blue denim & they make a 10oz flex Jean in both with a 1oz spandex they block the wind but still cool enough for summer. And their buck naked tees in a variety of colors are more comfortable than underarmer in hot temperatures.

[@mikelikesknives428]

I have a closet full of Duluth. Their clothes are top notch. They are built tough and warm for colder climates. Customer service is also fantastic. They offer a complete line for all tradesmen or women.

[@Tman0517]

As a big man, the only brand that's fit me comfortably has been Duluth. So they've got my business 100%

[@logansmith9431]

I'm a big guy I wear alot of carhartt big and tall by big I mean 6ft 1 and anywhere from 265 to 305 depending on the season

[@Boatflipit]

That’s the problem their stuff is all oversized. I’m 6ft 190 and everything they have is way too big.

[@Boatflipit]

@3wsqydirsp7e8pdyfivhcinpvysjrsl they are all like wearing dresses for me but I have a pretty short torso and when I drop sizes it gets tight around the shoulders

[@peterv1318]

@@Boatflipit - I know exactly what you mean the pants fit me like I am wearing those 90s style baggy pants.

[@Essex626]

​@@Boatflipit I'm 6'2", 310, and have a long torso. Duluth has been a godsend for me how well their stuff has fit me, so I can see how it would be for someone who is opposite.

[@michaelyciano2123]

I’m totally done with most of My carhartt collection. Pants and Sox last less than a year. Now looking for quality American made work clothes. Thanks for these videos.

[@jacobyates4016]

I’ve wore carharrt for years (I still do) but when I bought Duluth Trading company pants I can’t go back. They are hands down the most comfortable pants I’ve ever worn.

[@israelrimpler7098]

Thank you for the great video! I've been wearing carhartt pants for 10 years and noticed that there quality is definitely decreasing. They have removed 2 belt loops from there pants, making it eaiser to bunch up. They do not offer the double knee padding anymore. I have a few items from Duluth like there gloves and found it to be very durable and its lasting a long time.

[@barbatloosenutproductions2027]

As a female, trying to find a sturdy pair of winter work gloves, it was almost impossible. Trying to even find men's gloves in a small? Forget about it! Enter Duluth Trading Company. Yes, they carry women's work (and I do mean extra sturdy) gloves, and yes, they're warm. They also have a layer of Neoprene. Water stays out, but they "breathe" so your hands don't sweat. They're not cheap, but after one winter of hard work? They are like brand new! Wow! Most gloves that are warm, are usually ripped up in a month! So, yup, I'm sticking with this company!

[@CarlMurawski]

Awesome to hear! I love the fact that they've really developed their women's line as far as they have.

[@debrussell4921]

Have you tried their womens pants or overalls? I am asking as I am a full figured woman and I train dogs and jeans chaff and athletic pants can't stand up for more than a month of wear! Have a fab day!

[@Gelathius]

@@debrussell4921 Now I can't personally attest to how great Duluths women's wear is but I can say (as I am a sales associate) that most of our clothing does run slightly bigger and our plus sizes are made to fit a lot better than the regular sizes. The regular sizes are based off the small size if I remember correctly and just scaled up or down while the plus sizes, they took the time to add fabric where it is needed to help clothing fit just perfectly. I hope this helps you a bit. If you are able, I would highly suggest making it in-store as they will be able to help you a lot.

[@StellaWaldvogel]

I tried a couple of their longtailed shirts and while they're OK, I wasn't overly impressed. The quality was about equal to any cheap fast fashion t shirt and I wish I'd sized up, since they fit closer than I would have liked for work.

[@hankhill3417]

For use in the kitchen?

[@Bulletproofwest1]

This was a great watch. I was a lifelong carhartt guy, but made the switch around 2014 to Duluth on a whim. I wish I’d had this video then. I scoured the internet looking for a decent comparison, but wasn’t able to find one. I’m sure a lot of people found this useful.

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you, I certainly appreciate it!

[@smashtoad]

I bought a couple of burly weight flannels from Duluth, and fell in love. Two years later, bought the same shirts in other color, a couple as gifts, and they were thinner. Their popularity has bought them what they obviously thought was some insurance to lower quality.

[@haroldconner2645]

Same with stocking caps

[@Orlanzepol123]

You should have more subs. Your content is always informative and hones. Many KZbinrs kiss arse because they’re sponsored. I like that you don’t sugar coat anything and tell it how it is. Thanks

[@kch4580]

My husband is in the oil field 20 days at a stretch and our Duluth trading firehouse pants are amazing for him! They run in rotation with 6 pairs for about 11 months. At the end of month 11 the left knee will have a hole and the right back pocket will have a hole from his metal wallet but he uses every pocket everyday for the same designated tool. I can’t talk about them enough after five years we will not be changing anytime soon

[@1hdoilfielddad244]

How can he wear them in the patch? Everyone requires fr for everything. Been that way for years.

[@kch4580]

@@1hdoilfielddad244 he uses his FR bibs over top with easy access panels sewn in. It took a bit of ingenuity and good seamstress for the FR stuff but I understand it’s need sadly they don’t make FR Duluth!

[@chriscruz3797]

I pipeline and almost everyone I work with is all about cinch jeans or wranglers heavy starch. I wear the Duluth firehose bibs and the hold up way better to sparks from welding or grinding. And last me over a yr before I got my first hole in them. I also love their pants as well

[@MatthewSmith-if5wp]

I do love both Carhartt and Duluth, as well as Dickies. However I've gotta say my favorite work wear these days is Australian work wear. Brands like Hard Yakka, King Gee, etc. The quality is just so good.

[@tenji8084]

Australia’s highest demand in work are majority tradesman, It’s nice to see some love for Australian workwear.

[@wegaz00tie]

@@tenji8084 they produce in china too

[@invictusbp1prop143]

Are the Aussie brands you’re talking about more the pants that look more like… idk how to say it…they don’t look like the style of either of these two brands but more like they’re made like a uniform or something? Not sure how to describe what I’m thinking of…. I’ve seen workwear from the UK and other European countries that doesn’t look like clothes that you would wear if you weren’t working. The pants almost remind me of motocross pants in more subdued colors.

[@tomwhite2368]

Thanks for the info I'm going to check those brands out

[@lockandloadlikehell]

​​@@invictusbp1prop143trades in their Hi-viz neon yellow fight fight fight on their drive home

[@jamesmorrison7847]

The Duluth firehose pants have a built in hidden front right pocket that makes a perfect holster for my legal concealed carry Smith & Wesson BG 380. It stays in place all day and no one notices it. The flex firehose pants are even a little better because they have a little "give" to them and are more comfortable to work in.

[@bryanthrift3933]

The Duluth underwear and socks are money. And their flannels have a lifetime warranty. But I’m also a huge fan of Carhartt.

[@howardwayne3974]

It don't pay to limit yourself to one brand only . I mean I totally understand brand loyalty ( I have carhartt AND duluth myself ) but if you make yourself blind to what else us out there , you could loose out on some good stuff .

[@bryanthrift3933]

@@howardwayne3974 I don’t limit myself sir... I have tried all different brands. I have found though through my time in the military and working construction the Duluth socks have worked the best for me. As for the underwear I wear different brands but again I prefer the Duluth ones. Now with Carhartt it has just lasted me the longest thus far. I also have worn walls and liked their products well but the Carhartt again has been my preference. But thank you for your comment.

[@rockhardnipple6633]

Duluth's Buck Naked underwear is the best!

[@hiibeyonewneigba]

@@bryanthrift3933 nailed it

[@DB-xo6xh]

Im a Duluth kinda gal. Ive gotten all the men in my family hooked on Duluth clothing and accessories like their belts. Really great quality and super thoughtful.

[@zombenut]

Need more clothes made in the good ol USA.

[@HollywoodColt]

It's not made in the USA look on the tag.

[@kellypenrod2979]

If your looking for USA made clothing, forget craphart, not made here anymore. And it's a shame too, but like so many others, now you are just paying for the name.

[@tjellis1479]

Bangladesh, USA...Making Asian Goods Again.

[@JB-1138]

Levi's now has USA made jeans.

[@kellypenrod2979]

@@JB-1138 I quit purchasing Levi products 25yrs ago, when they made the statement that truckdrivers, and others of (that class) simply weren't who they wished to cater to.

[@da1paulino]

I've been a Dickies guy wearing the classic 875 but fell in love with Duluth flex carpenter pants. Oh and their boxer briefs are very comfy too.

[@jnsd891]

Only 12% of customers are in building trades. That doesn't mean those are the only trades using the work wear, Industrial, gas and oil, welders, mechanics, longshoremen, machinist, assembly, maintenance are all buying this stuff also. So while the building trades may only be 12% of customers I would want to know what percentage of trades in general make up the customer base. Great video, for me there are some things I like Carhartt for, but the more Duluth clothing I buy the less I like carhartt. Duluth is more expensive tho

[@nikhilsinha7730]

I am not a blue collar worker but I love your channel, your videos are immensely informative and your energy is incredibly captivating and it is for those reasons I have now subscribed

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you so much!

[@HankHill757]

Deluth all the way! I love the cargo pants and don’t notice the weight issue you mention.

[@charlessawyers7339]

I have been wearing Duluth for years and I absolutely love them! I don't use the back pockets and I leave the cargos open or tucked. My black pair faded after a couple of washes and I popped the crotch on a couple of pair, but I just patched em up and kept moving--Love em!!

[@papasteve215]

I really like Carhartt stuff but I mostly use Dickies and I’ve worn them for years building and working on houses/ buildings, farming, sawmilling, etc. I did buy some Duluth light weight summer shirts in 2004 and wore them almost daily through five years in Iraq and Afghanistan so they’ve taken some serious abuse. And I still wear them to this day. Can’t say enough good things about them.

[@_DJ708]

Got my first pair if Duluth Pants about 9 years ago maybe 10 and haven't looked back. I have many of their pants, jackets, hoodies, socks, Buck Naked Boxers (best i have ever owned), the USA Leather Work Belt (lasted longer than any belt i have ever owned) Flannels, winter clothes as well and not only the most comfortable but also the most durable.

[@danthemaintenanceman]

This is an excellent review. I work in a industrial/port atmosphere. I own both Carhartt and Duluth trading shirts, pants, vest, jacket and even wearing a pair of the Duluth slip on work boots right now. I did find that the Duluth Trading products to be slightly better. The Duluth line Alaskan Hardgear products are pretty good as well. Will always like the Carhartt line, but Duluth is a little more quality.

[@dboygoode]

Just found your channel this week when I was researching a new pair of boots on youtube. I've watched a lot of them since then and you make great content man. Keep it up.

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you very much!!!

[@joejoelesh1197]

Berne bibs have treated me great. Same quality as Carhartt, for 1/3 the price. For me, price is an important part.

[@CoDisafishy]

Yeah, Carhartt is good quality, but they're definitely paying extra just for the Carhartt name. That's what happens with so much brand loyalty...

[@jesus_simons7281]

Love carhartt but I'm going to try Duluth after this review to expand my work wear

[@michaelmckay]

what did you find?

[@kennethseden]

I love Duluth Flannels and Firehose pants, best fitting clothes. I also love Carhartt jackets and coats. Both have their pros and cons

[@michaelk487]

Not for nothing those firehouse pants are absolutely one of the best they have another one for riding bikes That's absolutely out of the world and their jeans are the best you can find

[@MEANlowGREEN]

I like Carhartt a lot but my favorite workwear is Pointer Brand by L.C. King Mfg. They are the oldest single family owned cut and sew clothing company in America and all their clothes are 100% American made. You're gonna pay a premium for that but their clothes are long lasting. I think it evens out in the long run.

[@CarlMurawski]

I agree, looks like I need to get some of those!

[@mojonojo3]

you really do, best pants on the market hands down

[@kenbollenbeck1491]

Evan Streamer h

[@splashpit]

I have a few of the chore coats some for work and when they did the specials with contrasting pockets I grabbed some for street wear , I love how they fit .

[@Lex-Rex]

Never heard of them. But damn, just hit their site. Thanks.

[@calumkuhn4071]

I hunt with the firehose work pants. Love the pockets and range of motion. Gives me some security about my legs especially around boar or walking through thick unknown brush.

[@bowhntr1210]

Great review. This is how reviews should be done. Didn't take FOOOREEEVVVER to get to and make your points, and not a lot of ummms, errrs ect. Good job, pleasure to watch.

[@shannongodbey7420]

I researched a bit on the Toastmasters club and they have an Ah-counter, which is a person who scores speeches based on filler words/ long pauses. Anyway good video

[@stevemotley808]

I own a few carhart product 2 hats 2 jackets 1 Brown 1 black. Both awesone. The black is insulated. I beleive it was called Arctic. Have had it for atleast ten years. And i absoulty love it. The things i have put it through. Would total kill other jacket's. I put cigarettes out on it used it fir a ground cloth. Even used it to carry bricks in and it still holding up.

[@phredocassera2939]

I had ripped a lot of Carhartt stuff over the years workin and then doing searches leashed to a SAR/cadaver dog.. constantly dragged trough thorn bushes, fallen pine tree limbs that break and leave sharp ends, dragged over sand dunes and down river beds.. through abandoned structures and construction sites and crack houses, etc. Spouse looked at me after a bad 3 day chase.. thighs ripped through, butt had a triangle rip in it...belt loops ripped out, dirt ground in and sap stuck in them .. She went surfing to find a better answer than the blood soaked Carhartts. 3 days later I got 2 pairs of black Duluth Fire hose work pants.. Never going back, ever! Spent years in the trades until injuries took me out of the field.. wish these were around 30 years ago. The fire hose weave seems to breathe and shed dirt much easier, just let it dry and brush it off with a stiff brush in the field. No more rips from thorns.. yeah they can get through, but don’t tear open. Belt loops never rip out. Pocket you can drop a full sized pistol in and retain it.. put a piece of plastic in those thigh pockets and zero “printing” so you can ask the public questions without them freaking out. Duluth has always been great to us, Wife loves their underwear, shirts, work pants as well .. they just opened a store nearby but we bought online for years prior to that. There are even more durable work clothes out there, well drillers, ocean platform workers and fire jumper need even stronger stuff.. but 5 times the price and pretty stiff until broken in ( fine for boots, but pants.. no).

[@salvatoresaccoccio2379]

Carhart clothing has gotten more expensive and cheaper in quality, when Duluth goes that route I’ll give up on them also.

[@harryboud2688]

I couldn’t of said it any better

[@Schneids71]

Carhartt has become a fashion line, it’s not for working men anymore.

[@ungabunga8380]

@@Schneids71 yes it is?💀

[@jacobsebastien3910]

My Carhartt pants and coats hold up to my abuse. Carhartt is all I buy. Definitely the Only pants I wear.

[@michaelharris2502]

Excellent review! From my experience Carhartt runs small in sizes, and a much stiffer feeling work wear. Duluth runs a bit larger, and the only issues I've ever had is the buttons. They'll wear and give out a bit quicker. But overall, I'd choose Duluth everytime because buttons are an easy repair.. The flex ballroom carpenter jeans are one of my favorites.

[@CarlMurawski]

Thanks for sharing!

[@fokkerd3red618]

If you buy a carhartt shirt, go down one size or it will be to large. I've found that out with all there shirts.

[@capnbobretired]

What an intelligent, informative video. TY. You opened my eyes on certain aspects of both companies.

[@CarlMurawski]

Much appreciated my friend!

[@travishinman1840]

4 years late but I just found your channel. I am currently wearing and LOVING my Filson Mackinaw vest. I've had it for about 5 years. It's very comfortable, warm but not hot and I get compliments on it nearly every time I wear it. The thing I was most worried about were the buttons. No issues at all. Thing is built to last. I'll look for your video about Filson.

[@offroad5798]

Duluth's Buck Naked boxer briefs are worth every penny. Bought a pair for ever day of the work week. Highly recommended!

[@mjp5429]

I love my Carhart Artic lined. I personaly tested it in -35°F and riding in the back of a pickup going 55mph. Can't say I was sweating but I wasn't freezing either.

[@edplourde8653]

Just got 1st pair of Duluth Fire hose fleece lined. Absolutely love them, also own numerous Carhartt items. Will be adding more Duluth when I need them

[@mattberg6816]

Try the wrangler fleece lined they are $17 at Walmart and last a few years. (Pipe fitter)

[@myfatherstwoacres6717]

Love my Duluth colthes. The pants, the flannels and the tees. 2 years so far and no holes or thinning. Color has faded but still look good

[@joshuaparsons8800]

I’ve got a carhartt jacket that I got when I was in HS in 2006. Almost 20 years later and I still wear it every winter and it’s still in perfect shape. It doesn’t get abused often, but I can honestly say at this rate I will have it the rest of my life.

[@os2958]

Thanks! That was very informative. I will be going with Diluth. I am a woman looking for a couple of work pants. Styling matters.

[@Gillysaurxx]

Duluth hands down. Im a bigger dude and Duluth pants offer better range of motion than Carharts for me

[@Gillysaurxx]

Thomas Jefferson lol both. Ive got what i call varsity thighs that seem to burn a hole in the crotch of every pair of pants i wear. But with Duluth Trading pants it happens far less and they are extremely comfortable, for me anyway

[@ReMz10184]

Agreed here. I'm 6'4" with a 6'7" wing span. Hard to find proper fitting clothing - I'm currently 240lbs, so a bigger dude. Duluth has "XL Slim Tall" size that fits perfect.

[@olney28]

@@ReMz10184 I'm sold then. I'm 6'2" 251lbs and jeans/pants are the hardest things for me to find. Duluth it is.

[@ReMz10184]

@@olney28 cheers brother. Best part about Duluth is that if you don't like what you bought (even after abusing it in a work environment), you can return it no problem. I have yet to return anything from them. Very worth their steep prices.

[@rontownsend8235]

wrangler utility pants all the way, short legged fat guy that really works.

[@Charlie-ro7un]

I love both. I just bought three Duluth shirt jacs and I'm about to buy a fourth just to leave at the shop. So damn comfy and the firehose version seems extra durable.

[@mikemckenna4816]

I find the 5 pocket fire hose pants vary wildly in size. On 3 occasions I've ordered them and the length has been off by 2-4" and consequentially went back to Carhartt. The Q.C. isn't great.

[@Odrunkmonkey]

All the deluth pants I’ve bought have felt like MC hammer pants.

[@socaloutdoors7355]

@@Odrunkmonkey 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@IamCaleum]

I am a mix, for rugged outdoor work I will be rebuying Duluth stuff that I had to sell when I went on disability, and Carhartt for more normal wear since they are durable and because they tend to be lighter, more comfortable to me.

[@johnnyshell2839]

I'm 4 years late. But for work jackets and coats it's Carhartt. But only the stupid expensive USA made ones. They have the new rugged force pants that I love. But my go to is the Duluth firehouse flex. Shirts are regular t shirts provided by the boss.

[@tomhaire4758]

I am a 65yo guy that worked in the aviation warehousing and much more. I have worn Duluth and Carhartt both and I love both of them. With that being said, I absolutely love my Duluth socks, they actually hold up to a lot of wear and don't create holes like most socks do. the pants are rugged and comfortable. I won't ramble on but Both are great products, you would need to try each one to decide what you like.

[@thomast6096]

Duluth rocks! I grew up with Carhartt before Duluth was available, but once I found Duluth I never looked back! Great video!

[@martinsnibbor7691]

Dulluth is the best my husband loves them , he's an electrician and has most of the styles , he recently burnt a hole with battery acid and dulluth exchanged them no questions asked . My husband carries a flashlight in hammer loop on left and a Murphy pouch from atlas 46 on right hammer loop . He claims this is his favorite carry.

[@sharkfinplays2760]

You made a amazing video showing the differences of these two brands, nice job! Also Duluth all the way!

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you so much!

[@bquick80]

I wore Carhartt’s for years but a duluth store got built near me a few years ago and Ive never looked back. I have everything from work pants to flannels to underwear. Hands down my favorite store now.

[@jon10231]

Duluth. More comfortable, not as stiff. Belt loops are larger for bigger belts. Work in construction you will appreciate the flaps, keeps dust and stuff from getting in. You can flap the covers inside easy access. Pockets are bigger. They have some without the flaps if you don't want them. Sewn in pocket for knee padding that isn't pinching your legs all day long if you need to wear them. Fend off finish, helps to keep you dry from rain and stains. Their lined pants are really, really warm. The relaxed pants are larger legs, I wear a knee brace and greatly appreciate that. The flexfirehose, oh, my the best in movement especially in the summer when you are sweating, well worth the money and they are more durable than regular firehouse.

[@reclhoss]

Unpopular opinion time! I have Carhartt, Duluth, and Wrangler Riggs. I prefer Wrangler mainly because the price point. I wear them all out at about the same rate and Wrangler does a pretty good job balancing out quality for price. I have noticed that wrangler has stopped making the canvas pants though. I was able to get 10 pairs on sale a few years ago and the rip-stop replacements are not great for being a commercial electrician. The major problem I have with carhartt is, the cargo pockets seem to be the weak point in the construction. I always get holes where the pocket points to the crotch. I need cargo pockets at this point, I love them. That being said, Duluth underwear is my favorite piece of clothing ever, period.

[@airborne_fpv1983]

I am a Aircraft mechanic and I wear Duluth and love all there products Duluth flex firehose cargo pants buckednaked underware and longtail tees there's shoes are nice also

[@andrewdg90]

Wow! Reading the comments, Duluth seems to be pretty popular over Carhartt here!

[@vincentvonblack140]

Duluth is the shit.

[@Mamaofthehooligan]

I can't speak for carhartt but I'm pleased with Duluth they may be expensive but when you consider how long they last it balances out this is just one person's opinion

[@myfatherstwoacres6717]

Just try a pair of thier pants

[@redhedkev1]

I have a Carhart vest, 15 years...everything else is Duluth Trading.

[@Mamaofthehooligan]

@@redhedkev1 I got a dickies jacket & 4 pairs of the original firehose pants,& 1 of the Duluthflex flex nothing against Duluthflex but I personally prefer the heavier cotton canvas of the originals.they're not a heavy as in weighing you down or anything,just a much thicker material than Duluthflex

[@BrianMorris-zc4md]

Hi Carl, I'm your newest subscriber! Merry Christmas to you and all your loved ones. Thanks for all the work you put in creating your videos, I've really been enjoying them.

[@CarlMurawski]

Thanks for subscribing and Merry Christmas!

[@lancefrasier2912]

Bro, thanks for the video! I'm an electrician myself and have recently purchased some Duluth Firehose pants and I'm hooked! Also Duluth does make other Firehose pants with different pocket configurations!

[@mike81399]

When I was a young adult working rough construction, just couldn’t afford Carhartt, so ended up having to wear off brand, and always looked for made in 🇺🇸.

[@HoldYourBreat4]

Same! When I started as an Ironworker apprentice I wore Walmart jeans

[@k1zer100]

2:30 Carhartt WIP is the stree-wear normal fit Carhartt sub-brand. The OG shirts are made from less premium products and are marketeed towards workers, not as a drip peice.

[@LostInTheAdriaticSea]

Carhartt sold out to the hipsters. Should've stuck to work wear and then the hype beasts would stick to nike and gucci

[@pkweisel]

Duluth for me. I have many of their products, but my older version of their Trade Tech Jacket is bomb proof. A few snag holes, but solid as the day I bought it 15+ years ago.

[@toddbertram6556]

Been a steel fabricator for 20 years and I can burn through double knee carhartts in 3 weeks. Oddly, or not, fine thread fabrics are much more abrasion resistant. Im sure they do well in other applications, but not so much in a machine/fab shop.

[@alt7244]

I never had Duluth pants since I'm not really in the trenches anymore. wranglers or Smith carpenter pants last me 2 or more years. But... in my opinion... Duluth tee shirts are the best. The fit is fantastic. I'm a well rounded (a-hem) guy. A 2x shirt fits like no other shirt I've bought before. Even carhardt fits a little snug around the belly. The Duluth are heavy duty. The don't shrink that I've noticed. I still have 4 year old tees with no noticeable fading, stretching or thinning out. I bought Duluth coats for the winter and I like the fit better than carhardts. The carhardts jackets are either too short or the longer style is too boxey. The Duluth are long enough so I can bend without exposing my lower back and has more of a functional shape. So... thats just my experiences

[@cephasmcpher67peteroutdoorspip]

I like and own clothing and a pack from one or both companies. Like you mentioned Carhartt is starting to gear there product towards the "Hipster" crowd right along with Redwing boots. I have an older Carhartt jacket and I love to being able to just crash through the underbrush without worrying about rips and tears same thing with the pants.

[@veg7nlif376]

In my opinion Carhartts quality has been declining in the last 10 years.

[@CarlMurawski]

You know, I’ve heard this from a couple other people. I wonder what’s going on.

[@sylvain4093]

A lot of people of my school are wearing carthart, it is the same story as levis. You smell money and then you decrease your quality.

[@gilbertoflores7397]

I know, they're trying to modernize their products, and making things "slimmer" by removing a lot of their materials that added that great durability and quality. I wanted to rebuy the same work pants I had from 8 years ago, nothing wrong with them, still in great condition, I just wanted to have a spare for the colder months; so I go onto their site, and they no longer make it, instead, they offer the "newer" model, I go ahead and order it. The older quilted lined work pants have been replaced with flannel lined pants. What use to be a jacket for you legs in the old model is now just regular pants with pajamas bottoms sewn into the lining. They were completely subpar to what they use to make. So I go hunt down every mom and pop store that would carry the brand, hoping that they might still have some for sell, be it no one bought them from them, or whatever. Unfortunately, I didn't find a pair. But that's what I've noticed about them, they're not building quality garments anymore, they're an established brand, and feel like they cheapen their standard because they're so trusted. Now if you want their proven durability, you have to buy their premium line, meaning same old quality, but a bigger price tag.

[@JJ-lu6mg]

Carl Murawski I believe the problem with Carhartt as far as their quality today. I think a lot of the fashion version of there clothline is getting mixed up with their original gear. Carhartt has a lot of different options now from very heavy duty to light weight durability work cloths on top of their fashion line and it just making it harder for most people to know what to buy for work.

[@loucifer323]

No they haven't sound like everyone who says Dewalt isn't the same since Black and Decker bought them but didn't realize they bought them in 1960

[@AlmightyThor82]

Machinist here. Love my Duluth gear. One con to the Fire hose pants, they're hot in the summer time. but overall awesome.

[@CarlMurawski]

You’re right, they’re a bear in summer!

[@kjo22811]

Sorry for the old reply - try the DuluthFlex Fire Hose CoolMax pants. I live in the south, summers are brutal, and the CoolMax are a lot more comfortable and lighter than the regular FireHose, and almost as durable. Sizing is a bit a weird compared to the other pants, though.

[@chriscruz3797]

Carhartt was my go to work clothing until a buddy turned me on to Duluth and I absolutely love their bibs

[@michaeldunsing9461]

Great review! Ive been a sprinkler fitter for 10 years and i must say from buying so many different pants i will always like the duluth flex fire hose. I still have pairs from 2015 that i still wear to this day and the picket layout for me works 👍

[@trishawinters2973]

I am a woman and I liked your comparison video very informative.

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you! It’s always a pleasure to get feedback from a woman’s perspective.

[@williamstaggjr8432]

I switched over to Duluth Trading Company Clothing and Haven't Been Disappointed

[@danovila]

Duluth for me. Everything is just so we'll made. One of my favorites are the flex fire hose pants. Very comfortable.

[@charlestrainor4133]

Maybe 12 years ago I ordered two, "fire hose" material, caps from Duluth Trading Co. They are still in every day use in the Fall and winter. The caps are equipped with fold down ear flaps. They show no wear at all even after numerous washings. These represent the kind of investment I strive for because I'm thrifty and I appreciate quality.

[@mikekuczynski1552]

Thanks for the review, i have been a Carhartt guy for over 40 years and like there products but recently I been looking at the Duluth Trading stuff so I am glade you posted this .

[@DUCKxGRIZZLY]

I'm a commercial electrician and I will not buy anything other than Duluth. I've had dickies and carhartts, but my Duluth clothing lasts much longer and everthing is much more comfortable.

[@CarlMurawski]

I had the same experience man.

[@davidhess1184]

Do they make arc flash clothing?

[@heavymetalmechanicX]

Carhartt started manufacturing "fashion" clothing for hipsters and yuppies. Turned their back on real working people. Even their "real" work clothing isn't as tough as it used to be.

[@jeremyrock9305]

You are correct most people that wear it now don’t actually buy it for work they buy it to pretend they need it for work! My carhartt coats didn’t hold up ! I have duluth holds up well and is actually warm ! I have fleece lined firehouse work pants have been through hell and back like 15 years old now even saved me from a run away grinder

[@jonthelamb4549]

I’ve got an older car hart zip up sweater and it’s stained to shit and crusty and I wear it everyday when I go to work and the only place it’s ripped is where my wrists are my friends from school are scared to wear theirs when they eat lunch.....

[@KippySmi7h]

This is true. New leadership at the top has encouraged it and they’ve moved to designer rather than practical. We sell Carhartt women’s socks at the yard now...I only see it getting worse.

[@dalewilliams7484]

Living in portland oregon i see people wearing carhartt or other work wear brands as fashion

[@AmericanArgonaut]

And it’s happened in the last five years.

[@shovelyjoe1059]

I’ve worn Carharrt pants off and on, and my biggest complaint is they never fit right. Something about the cut does not fit. Particularly, the crotch is too tight and the front pockets are too close together. Leg pockets are not placed where my hands naturally fall to grab tools. I’ve moved on to Duluth. Specifically their flex firehose paints. They are no where near as durable as their regular firehose, but for the type of work I do, they are the best. I need the cargo pockets and the flap on the rear pockets. My only complaints with the paints, is that they have a sizing problem and they shrink up and you get high waters. I can order 3 pair, and at least one pair does not fit like the other 2. It seems to be with a particular color and I always end up sending pair back and/or sticking to 2 colors. For the high water shrinkage, I order the next longer length and after about 4 heavy duty washing and drying cycles they fit perfectly. I’ve tried their polos, and it’s a great polo. But, they went too crazy in length. Sure, no plumbers crack, but untucked, you’re wearing a dress. And Filson? Brand new? I wouldn’t call 1887 “new”. But alas, I can’t afford them anyway.

[@Chellees]

My husband swears by Duluth’s firehouse flex pants! He is still wearing paints he purchased 4+ years ago! These paints are put thru hell daily as my husband is extremely rough on his clothes and has a very physical job! I’m very impressed by Duluths quality and we still add to my husband’s collection often!!

[@kevinfort5301]

Carhartt for shirts, pants, coats, and gloves. They have a line of pants without the cargo pockets but with a great cell phone slot that works for me. I have about a dozen of them. Not too heavy, not too stiff. Now when it comes to underwear, you can’t beat Duluth’s buck naked boxer briefs. Super comfortable.

[@Mrgoofyoops]

What you don’t like about Duluth pants is what I love about them - the flaps that secure are the best feature, for my needs. Also really like the cargo pockets. Those two features are the biggest reason I buy Duluth.

[@dvulpis29]

Yeah his negatives were positives. I’m guessing he wanted to point out positives and negative’s of both brands but couldn’t actually find negatives about Duluth.

[@gypsyboomer]

Spent some time as a fitter and then a welder, have used most brands of work clothes and found these to best "bang for buck" in their areas. Carhartt Coveralls as a cold layer but you will need more on the river in Ohio, Dickey for lighter duty, Carhartt pants and Wells Lamont jackets. All shirts shrink eventually so gussets are nice but stick to flannel mostly. All of these items have remained wearable/usable for at least a work year, most last longer because I have more than one, which makes them more economical too. Longer post than usual, but I like your channel. Why does no one talk about socks, every bit as important as other high wear garments.

[@firejim1232]

Thanks for the great review. Since the Duluth store opened in St.Charles,MO, I’ve become a Duluth junkie. The trick to save on their products, is to get on their email list. My favorite items are the Duluth flex and dry on the fly pant and shorts. I’m very picky on size and color of any purchase, so it’s nice that I can go to their store and try them on. Almost every item I’ve purchased, has been on sale for 30-40% off! I have a carhart jacket with bibs that is 14 years old that I still wear. It’s strange that the Duluth store that I mentioned is next door to a carhart store that seems largely ignored!?

[@keverc]

I am a Carhartt fan. Been wearing the same Carhartt winter coat for years and it is still in great shape. I also love my Carhartt bibs!

[@Gelathius]

I am actually a sales associate for Duluth and not too long ago I was talking with a trucker and he said every piece of clothing he owns is Duluth and doesn't buy anything else. I was honestly pretty surprised just the fact that he doesn't get anything else. So most of the time he spends almost a grand when he comes to the store. I have to say since I have been working here and have had the chance to try their clothes ( where one of their armachillo polos right now matter of fact), they are probably some of the best clothing I have ever worn and have been quite impressed. If you don't like the price so much( which I encourage people to bite the bullet because they are worth the money), don't worry there is their 40 grit line where they will cut a few corners to make their products cheaper but still keep them the highest quality.