Which Carhartt Jacket is WARMEST?

[@CarlMurawski]

The Warmest Carhartt Jackets: 1- Yukon Extremes Parka: bit.ly/3uD3xbA 2- HV Sherwood Jacket: bit.ly/2Ym8YzG 3- Super Dux Insulated Coat: bit.ly/3izff2a 4- Yukon Active Jac: bit.ly/3mhpKbm 5- Yukon Coat: bit.ly/3uFdnJM 6- FR Duck Active Jac: bit.ly/2X7wrnV 7- Firm Duck Active Jac: bit.ly/2YpaaCz 8- FS Cryder QD Jacket: bit.ly/3aaxF4o 9- FR Duck Traditional Coat: bit.ly/2YNf2S0 10 -Reversible Fleece Jacket: bit.ly/3mKSsl3 11- Washed Duck Sherpa Lined: bit.ly/3l8XqbN 12- J130 Active Jac: bit.ly/3uJ8cZp 13- Duck Traditional Jacket: bit.ly/3moEIfJ 14- FS Ripstop Jacket: bit.ly/3iwhdQN 15- FR Full Swing Quick Duck Coat: bit.ly/3FHf8LB 16- Super Dux Active Jac: bit.ly/3lg1RSp 17- Washed Duck Sherpa Utility Jacket: bit.ly/3B9PRqQ 18- Lightweight Insulated Jacket: bit.ly/3a5CbkN 19- Yukon Fleece Active Jac: bit.ly/2ZXHktu 20- FS QD Insulated Traditional Coat: bit.ly/3axBSzw 21- Sherpa Lined Coat: bit.ly/3uGLqBF 22- Blanket Lined Chore Coat: bit.ly/3orVoWm 23- FS Armstrong Fleece Lined Active Jac: bit.ly/3Fi7O99 24- Fleece Pullover: bit.ly/3FF7IbY 25- FS Armstrong Jacket: bit.ly/3C7eDI5 26- Full Swing Washed Duck Trad. Coat: bit.ly/3Bb1IVL 27- Thermal Lined Active Jac: bit.ly/2WJnVv8 28- Rockford Lightweight Jacket: bit.ly/3DcuXYU 29- Detroit Jacket: bit.ly/3orVfCi 30- FR Full Swing Quick Duck Jacket: bit.ly/3au9M8g 31- Crowley: bit.ly/3Db6GCy 32- Hooded Rough Cut Softshell: bit.ly/3uSoijL 33- Super Dux Detroit Jacket: bit.ly/2Yj5HkA 34- Rough Cut Jacket: bit.ly/3a2wdkR

[@Ornelas11B]

I live 30 min from CMU. Chippewa country.

[@ThePaPappy]

Old Detroit jacket dominates the "new " Detroit ( old top pockets were like the "chore coat") . Top double pockets and a nylon quilted red lining that didn't act liker a swiffer, picking up animal hair, lint, dust.....

[@subwayjrod1]

Something not mentioned here but worth a thought is that fleece wear down much quicker than canvas. The fleece might be warmer initially but if worn and washed a lot will loose its warmer advantage quickly.

[@jcolt84]

I bought the Yukon active jack two years ago while searching for the warmest coat that I can find. They make a parka version of it also, but I can't imagine needing a warmer coat. I purchased mine because I was working on a car lot, and walking across that car lot in the dead of winter would chill you to the bone, but not with the Yukon active jack! The wind resistance is just as impressive as the warmth factor that the coat provides. I'm so glad I own the coat, but for Southern Illinois, it's definitely overkill!

[@hosseintajik6764]

I apprecite your time to help others esp Surveyors know how and what to wear in freezing cold weather

[@simplespeed84]

Im a truck driver who may be in 60 degrers one day and below zero the next. Limited space for storing too many different jackets in my truck. A combo that has worked for me is a carhartt sherpa lined hoodie and a sherpa lined detroit Jacket. When the weather is too much i wear them both. Perfect combo for me. My jacket is 9 years old and still going strong. Im to the point of buying a new carhartt just because I want one lol. Seems like they never wear out and only get better.

[@Zakcary_Kaiser]

My Grandma got me the quilted flannel active jacket for my birthday and I gotta say it's one of the best birthday gifts I've ever received

[@CarlMurawski]

Grandma gets points for an awesome gift!

[@wilhelmseleorningcniht9410]

this is a very useful video, thank you! Love Carhartt, I had a coat donated to me from my church when I was a little kid, am in my 20's and it's still going strong aside from some tearing. 'd love to get another again.

[@markmullen1852]

I have a Yukon Extreme from like 15 years ago. It's THE warmest coat I've ever had. The wind doesn't get through either. I can only wear it if it's sub 20° outside. Just walking I start to sweat. It's that warm.

[@Ozzymandias33]

As a former retailer of the Carhartt WIP range in the UK I find these vids very informative. My association with this wonderful brand goes back over two decades however here in the UK (i’m in Northern Ireland) they are best known as a streetwear icon …while there’s a general awareness of the workwear heritage (more so recently as the European side has wisely been referencing it more) it’s very difficult to get the main line range here …in fact off hand I can’t think of anywhere. I’d love to get a walk around some of the US stores such as Dave’s New York etc…maybe someday. Thanks again.

[@scatpack2721]

run yo pocket

[@Math_Yeww]

RuffnTuff clothing are a UK stockist of Carhartt workwear

[@scottowl75]

Their Sherpa lined vest is great very warm , and the Detroit is doing well in English conditions . Some great quality gear from carhartt 👍🏼

[@CarlMurawski]

Right on!

[@dennisjensen6142]

Picked up the Duck Traditional Coat in 2004, zipper finally gave out on me. Definitely getting a new one. I didn't realize that it wasn't the warmest coat Carhartt makes

[@Heartland-zv8vi]

Man you made my choice in jackets easy. I settled on the super dux insulated traditional coat. I love that thing thanks for all your help.

[@markc9949]

Hey Carl! Your content is truly great and I've become quite the Carhartt fan! I live in PA and have HORRIBLE circulation despite working out daily and a healthy diet. I would absolutely love a video on gloves and socks. Truly high quality, warm, well made socks and gloves, although I know you don't deal with anything less! Keep up all the great work!

[@n00bstacle]

I've found for warm socks, the carhartt winter socks have been the best for me. My dad also swears by them and he works outside in Northern Saskatchewan during winter. I'm not sure their official number but they are white and gold. Or you can get heated socks, gloves and insoles as another option

[@Kaybee3104]

I wear Darn Tough through and through. They are super high quality merino wool, made in america, and have a lifetime, no questions asked, warranty. (Although I bought 14 pairs about 5 years back and still haven't had any holes or problems). They come in a variety of weights, but the full cushion boot sock is my favorite. For gloves I currently use either the Filson merino wool gloves or the vermonter from Vermont Glove Co. , the latter being made in america and fitting my work wear needs.

[@MrKinghuman]

What's your healthy diet? Grilled chicken and greens? I'm born and raised in Sicily. Which is basically north Africa, it's hot pretty much year round compared to North East, I'm in New York, and I don't have problems with cold weather and circulation, but I also eat red onion salads, fish and occasionally organ meats, which I'm told are all good for circulation. If.you don't already eat those, maybe give them a try.

[@JimGreenFootwearOfficial]

The video I needed🙌 A jacket is first on my “to buy” list when I get to the US for a visit.

[@Wickedreptiles]

Depends on the area your going to. The southernmost states you don’t need a jacket during winter, as to the northernmost states you’ll need a snow suit during the winter

[@adolfouresti7561]

yes sir carhartt is a great durable brand I use it for work and daily, their jackets, overalls, shirts are outstanding pieces of work gear

[@buttweinerfacehead8818]

if just visiting there’s no need to blow a bunch of money on a nice coat

[@funk_face4744]

I don’t think non Americans are allowed to buy Carhartts. Non American have to buy from the WIP line.

[@Jackman66666666]

This needed to be done! Carhartt offers a dizzying amount of outerwear to choose from!

[@seanangermeier3266]

I wore the Sherwood jacket last winter and so far this year. I am happy to report that it is very, very warm. This morning was 19 with a breeze and I was pretty comfortable with it and two layers of shirt underneath just walking around doing a site precon.

[@adamjameskramer]

Such a great video, I am sure thousands of people (if not millions) will benefit from this video when needing to know what jacket is best for them! [Carhartt - buy this man a drink!!]

[@davidbrown-vd5wo]

I was actually wondering JUST this when i got to my jobsite this morning! Thank you!

[@CarlMurawski]

You're so welcome!

[@856Dropout]

Having the Sherwood and knowing how ridiculously warm it is I can give you a gauge of 1.83. It’s so insulated you can wear a regular t shirt under it and be comfortable working in single digits and 30mph winds.

[@yyc976]

Awesome! I honestly could not have predicted that order...

[@sylermran]

i got my first carhartt jacket last year and it was amazing, i got the J140 active jack, worth it

[@chrish3720]

I used to have one with the blanket lining it was the best by far.

[@rollingpanda4198]

Very helpful video, thank you for putting this out here.

[@CarlMurawski]

You're very welcome!

[@dombridges01]

you should try out some ventile jackets. Id recommend Hilltrek, all made in Scotland with excellent craftsmanship

[@CarlMurawski]

I'd love to!

[@ES-qe1nh]

Fluorocarbons

[@dombridges01]

@@CarlMurawski or country innovation, check out the rover jacket

[@rollandklontz]

Having experience with the Sherwood hi vis jacket i can say first hand that Carhartt needs to utilize some seam seal because it will start to leak in the seams on the arms/arm pits.

[@CarlMurawski]

Good to know!

[@JohnBeebe]

Good to know since my site manger just bought us a bunch of them

[@MDP673NJ1]

Great video wish it was up last year. I got a traditional duck coat last year and love it it's warm and it does wear like an armor...

[@_thomas1031]

GREAT video! Definitely keep this in a Playlist when looking for new Carhart jackets👏👏👏

[@jakemeyer5678]

Just purchased a Super Dux Insulated Coat for winter and chose it over the Yukon Active Jac, and Firm Duck Active Jac. I'm glad I did based on your video and their tests! Care to do another video for gloves?

[@CarlMurawski]

Good choice! It will difficult to get this level of scientific data on gloves, but I'll try!

[@csscott9803]

I just got a Carhartt coat for Christmas and I love it so much.

[@CarlMurawski]

I love them! Huge value for sure.

[@brucemurray2520]

Love my J140 jacket. Made in USA.

[@townieoutdoors8121]

Great video ! Appreciate all the info. I have the firm duck active jacket with quilted flannel lining. I like the j130 updated version of the active jacket but had to have the firm duck of the j140.

[@CarlMurawski]

Right on!

[@AndyB718]

Bibs with the zipper on the side are truly the warmest thing to wear. I'm a construction worker from NYC and work in building foundations,piers,High rises etc etc.

[@alejandrodiazgomez6333]

BRO!! First time in my life that I listen Yellow Hills from Daniel Kaede in a Video!! Good video and good taste of music!! Cheers and happy new year 🥂

[@LittleMusicBoy]

Awesome video, really informative! It would be really cool to see a comparison of all the active jacs, it seems like they're up there in popularity and they're the ones I'm looking into buying.

[@Tziq_San]

Great guide! Thank you Carl Murawski!

[@CarlMurawski]

My pleasure!

[@WARDISWARD]

During the mid 90´s I 've bought a carrhart jacket which was iirc pure wool and had a stylish fischerman jacket look , the carrhart logo was also not patched on the jacket . Too bad they don't make these anymore

[@0Gaaby]

Such a great video, well done wish you more viewers and likes great quality video

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you so much 😀

[@nobeanchili]

Would love to know why they didn’t include the FR Extremes Arctic Coat/Parka.

[@kielbasamage]

Now I have to wait for when you review hats, I’ve been looking to get a full brim Minnetonka fold up hat, but I’ve hesitated because I know jack about clothes.

[@DAVE_WHITE]

I have number 4 the Yukon extreme so far it has been great

[@Drippinonthedroop]

Need this rating info for the sweatshirts and then we'll be able to get some sort more ideal clo to temp rating

[@mistermark4496]

Great informative review, keep up the good work.

[@CarlMurawski]

Much appreciated!

[@B1gtommy]

How do the top 4 jackets 🧥 compare to brands like Canada Goode or Moose Knuckles?? Are they the same warmth?? What does Clo mean for temperature? Is a 1.75-2.0 Clo means you can wear it in -15 F??

[@jamieeisenhower1560]

I like all Car hearts that have a cuff Around your waist around your wrist usable friendly lastibility long cuff Coats wear to easier and to long over your hands And They hold heat better With being lighter

[@anonamos6086]

The Yukon Extreme Parka is the warmest coat I’ve ever put on.

[@emilelsborg961]

Have you ever tried the Carhartt Sawtooth parka? I live in Denmark, and sadly I'm not able to get the Yukon Extreme Parka, which is the one I actually want, but I'm able to get the Sawtooth. But there's not a single video on it on KZbin. So in case you've ever used it, I would love to hear your opinion on it. No matter what, thank you very much for all your videos! they are very helpful and intertaining

[@hasanmakki2387]

Nothing will ever replace my Carhartt rancher sandstone. Sad to say they don't make it anymore

[@floppa4934]

I really like the chore coat I'm saving up for it

[@Dan27894]

10:34 where can I find the video you make on the j130?

[@repairdrive]

I have that Sherpa jacket! Super warm just like they said. Some times it beats wearing a vest. Just sucks that the hiviz get dirty so easy.

[@XAVargasX0206]

Thanks for making this video

[@DrRolexPhD]

What an amazing video. Thank you Carl!

[@CarlMurawski]

Glad it was helpful!

[@SigfridSWE]

Cool video. One of my favorit winter coats are the Lined Mackinaw Wool Packer Coat from filson. Sutch a good look.

[@truckerkev7067]

CARHART SAVED MY LIFE WORKING IN THE MIDWEST

[@adrianrobinson7953]

Kind of crazy Carhart fr artic parka high vis wasint on the list

[@amandaburger3312]

Appreciate ur vids thanku.

[@Jsarson1976]

Very informative thanks you 👍🙏

[@nicholasford7398]

Great video as usual

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you so much!

[@drealmall2412]

Cool idea!

[@wizardofahhhs759]

Working in a Cryder jacket with nothing but a long sleeve T underneath with a wind chill of 18°-20° F I'll be washed down in sweat. It's fine if Im standing still but I'm a hot natured person so I have to dress in layers in the winter.

[@tanksouth]

Thank you.

[@amandaburger3312]

Great vid.helpful .

[@TexasJuggernaut]

Any videos of like big guys with Carhartts? I'm 6'1 240 thinking of going with a xl tall but there's no videos for the bigger men lol

[@nicktully6360]

Video on carhartt pants and jeans soon?

[@augustusgloop9330]

Is the Detroit blanket lined jacket a work jacket?

[@Infamouscoma885]

Just bought the full swing cryder insulated jac and it’s super comfortable but mane the 3xl is short. I might be returning it for another full swing jacket or just the regular extremes active jacket. Not a fan of how short it is.

[@philmannino4567]

What do you recommend for hoodies the Yukon Fleece or the rain defender fleece/Sherpa for keeping warm TIA

[@psychosamba]

Fantastic!

[@d66paynter1]

What do you think about the Carhartt's Shoreline Jacket that Chevrolet sells for warmth?

[@aikido775]

Please tell me what happened to the Sawtooth fur hooded jacket? Thank you....

[@cyclelife9179]

which vest is warmer? sherpa or arctic lined? im not sure which insulation listed is equivalent.

[@rossfinman9148]

Love your videos! Spend way too many nights watching them. I am in Seattle and am looking for a work jacket that can be used around freezing with some light rain for the winter. Would you recommend a Detroit jacket, full swing active, or a waxed cotton Barbour style?

[@wizardofahhhs759]

The Detroit jacket is only good for temps 50* and above, a Barbour jacket isn't a winter jacket at all unless you wear a ton of clothes underneath.

[@eagleeatsmonkey3621]

very good info tks

[@Kaykavallinetwork]

I’m tryna get the duck traditional jacket but I don’t know if I should buy the a two x for sleeves or a Big and tall xl because I’m 6’4 and I’m arms are long

[@michaelspornak3173]

Sorry buddy, I enjoy your reviews and Carhartt makes an outstanding product line. I own a couple thousand dollars of Carhartt clothing. Unfortunately I made the decision yesterday to no longer buy their product. They went woke and I don’t agree with their decision. I’d rather be wet and cold than buy their stuff any longer. Keep up the good work and reviews

[@adamb724]

Get a durable shell/canvas jacket and the layer it with down. Nothing compares to down on retaining heat. I'm talking real heat, sub 30 below, get yourself a Mountain Hardware Absolute Zero or a Rab expedition coat, then a canvas cover for protection.

[@stonerwitch666]

I'm surprised to not see the storm Defender coat I just got. Not sure the model but it was 160 bucks.

[@CarlMurawski]

Yeah, they didnt include those in the study... Im not sure why.

[@zyzzuschrist3410]

New subscriber. What is the Patagonia equivalent to the Carhartt Detroit jacket?

[@CarlMurawski]

I'd say perhaps the ranch jacket

[@brianda5793]

I’m not sure if I missed it, but are they water snow resistant repellent?

[@DAVE_WHITE]

ok so for number 1how does the synthetic down hold up? Does it pile up and move after a few years of service and washing? I have a LL BEAN jacket that has this issue, after 3 years the elbows are no longer warm at all as the synthetic down has moved to other areas of the coat, and we followed all washing instructions?

[@MFSHECKS]

In this type of ranking, where would the v01 firm duck vest land?

[@JoaoSilva-hl4fy]

I would like to buy a detroit jacket, but in portugal you dont get to try one, just online, so i dont know how it would fit me, id like the length to be at the waist, so if you have any tips let me know, maybe comparisons to other carhartt jackets.

[@CarlMurawski]

I'd recommend sizing down if you can. They're pretty big and I wish I'd gone with a medium.

[@JoaoSilva-hl4fy]

@@CarlMurawski How tall are you? just for reference.

[@matthewwade4609]

Hey Carl need your opinion please. I been looking at #11 for a month now I love idea of the sherpa inside lining. After watching your video I'm also now looking at #8 now. I live in NJ so it gets pretty cold here. So what's your opinion on wich one you think I should get?

[@andrewoldacre2940]

We need Denim jeans at the wear guard store in Union Nj...

[@wt8213]

I need help with sizing!🤔 I'm 5'11" 170lbs. I'd like to be able to wear a hoodie underneath comfortably. I'm stuck between the "Yukon extreme full swing" and the "full swing traditional". I live in mid west canada. I work out in -30c at times but I don't want a jacket that is to heavy. My father has the tradition from 2000ish era and his is a size large tall yet he is only 5'9"ish 190lbs and it fits him well so I'm wondering if they changed there sizing over the years or his just shrunk being washed so much in 20 years. As I have a different Carhartt jacket that is a large tall from 2019 that is way to long in the arms for me.

[@b8tzim767]

Are you familiar with the Carhartt WIP line? I have a Michigan washed duck wool lined water resistant version that's warm and versatile. Also, wondering if you've used Timberland Pro workwear, Sorel hunting jackets or Spiewak cold gear?

[@IJLook]

I do not see the Cryder QD active jacket I got a few years ago.Did they discontinue it?

[@ChrisYX19]

Hi! I need a winter work jacket, but I already have a thermal lined active jacket, can anyone tell me if the washed duck sherpa jacket can keep warm in -10 degrees（14 ℉）, maybe paired with thermal underwear and a hoodie can resist -20 degree（-4 ℉）weather, or should I buy a J140 active jacket? Thank you so much!

[@harrynelson9203]

I need a certain carhart jacket but i’m in the UK, other youtubers call it the (sierra) looks exactly like the J130…. i think home depo sells it but always out out of stock, it’s fleece lined jacket but can’t find a single person posting over seas, they say it’s the second warmest jacket they sell, it’s ice cold in the UK at the moment 👌🏻🇬🇧 What is warmer the j130 or the sierra with the sherpa fleeced line???? Thanks

[@ryanpgiron]

What about the Full Swing Chore Coat 102707?

[@alexhunter6141]

Can you do a video on Ridgecut jackets? By Tractor Supply Co. They are fairly new. But I haven't seen any reviews on them

[@buckwild6587]

I'd love a full review on #21, originally i wanted a csrhartt detroit as a replacement for a jacket I hadfor years, but on a random trip to bass pro in happened upon this exact jacket and I honestly prefer this over the detroit as my medium jacket, but theres next to nothing as far as reviews go on youtube. I think it was originalmy called the ridge coat

[@rad7595]

Done with Carhartt

[@shizyninjarocks]

Thanks. Getting ready for Germany 🇩🇪

[@petertopjian4095]

Why don't they ever mention the Montana rated 4 for warmth it is up there with the Yukon jacket 🤔

[@brywong93]

Do you have the title of the video you made about the J130 jacket?

[@CarlMurawski]

I believe that was Carhartt vs dickies work jackets

[@alejandroperezroulet-747]

what about jeans jackets ??, tipe coat

[@believeinjesus8300]

What carhartt vest is the warmest ?

[@alastairgreen1709]

What happened to the J140?

[@dumbojo]

So you’re saying the Yukon active jacket has the same warmth as the original firm duck active jacket ? Then why would you pay an extra 70 bucks for a Yukon one?

[@CarlMurawski]

The Yukon series has a few differences, but the major one is the shell material. It’s far better in the snow/rain all day.