GREATEST blues rock song of all time? Led Zeppelin’s “Since I’ve Been Loving You” [Guitar Lesson]

[@Saul_HUDSON]

Man, it was not a KZbin video, it was a Masterclass !!! Huge ! Thanks !

[@garanceadrosehn9691]

I'd be happy to have a similar breakdown for _"Tea for One"_ off "Presence", which I think is often skipped over because it's in a similar vein as _"Since I've Been Loving You",_ but I think it's an excellent song.

[@1111MJR]

I prefer Tea For One...I find Since I’ve Been Loving You a bit histrionic.

[@JayEastward]

I'm in the same camp. I feel like Tea for One is the grown-up, bruised and healed, mature version of SIBLY.

[@seydutz975]

I can't decide between these two both brilliant. and try hard to play the solos.

[@jennifers6055]

I prefer TFO honestly. The dynamics on the guitar solo is unbelievable. He's whispering so softly that you have to really pay attention. ❤️

[@grantshenton7079]

Written in the same key and Page never played exactly the same solo twice live ,he interchanged phrases between the two songs a lot .

[@kaewonf8]

The break where Plant sings "I saaaiiiiid I been crryyyyyiiiiinn!" has to be the greatest moment in rock n roll. Thanks for the lesson dude!

[@michaelstrauss3769]

In my mind, maybe the finest LZ song. All 4 members are wonderful and essential. What a collaboration.

[@neilfriedman]

It is one of the greatest songs ever, and definitely the best song Led Zep ever recorded. They never sounded better than on Since I've Been Loving You.

[@wesmckenna8287]

The best broken heart song of all time definitely

[@bane1240]

I already agree and have been saying this is the rockinist blues song of all time. Its also one of my top 3 favorite Zep songs ever. Never get tired of hearing it.

[@BoGuest2571]

The might be the best song ever written imo…god it’s so damn good. I could listen to it a million times and it would never get old

[@johnsample5628]

When they are playing this in TSRTS film, pay attention during the solo, when the big balloon is shown bouncing around the audience. The lick Page plays is one my all-time favorite blues lick. It just DRIPS off the guitar like honey.

[@markymark560]

Yes I love that bit too.

[@ralph6968]

Yeah just before they show the mesmerized policeman

[@rafaeldiasms]

Never noticed before. Got a timestamp?

[@johnsample5628]

This is link to performance: kzbin.info/www/bejne/lYvMf5KEprlgi9U And the bit I am referring to starts at 4:56

[@johnsample5628]

@@rafaeldiasms Here is link to performance: kzbin.info/www/bejne/lYvMf5KEprlgi9U The time stamp is 4:56

[@tazador793]

Carl is a magician. He has worked so hard to understand the secret of Led Zep. This is so incredible. As many of you, the song that this in your brain forever once you hear it from the first time.

[@Walrus1701D]

My favorite Led Zeppelin song, my favorite Jimmy Page guitar solo and my favorite Robert Plant vocal. The perfect package!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

That’s all that needs to be said!

[@DevinLester-t6p]

It's good to see people showing what they know on Jimmy's playing cause I've just been watching the 1977 live video over and over again.

[@dondu_1533]

Just hearing the intro of the song give me goosebumps

[@cslloyd1]

Sadly Jeff Beck passed away today. That leaves us with just Jimmy Page. Thank you Carl for documenting the genius of Jimmy Page. One of a kind.

[@Web_ca]

@CarlBaldassarreMusic : THE "GREATEST blues rock song of all time" ...absolutly ! I never get tired of listening to this masterpiece.

[@patrickcrowley2268]

Had this album when I was 16 or so...went out to the back yard one day, not thinking of a thing, just sitting on my tree swing...and this song came into my head. I went back into the house, put the record on the player, and...whoa. I realized that this was one of the best tracks I had ever heard in my young life - out of the blue, so to speak. Still love it at 61.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

I’m with you!

[@paulmoss2664]

Yes! Best blues song. Best rock song. Best song ever!!!

[@MrRAINEMAN]

Hello and thankyou Carl for your confirmation of what Ii always knew from the moment I first played this album as a budding rock guitarist and singer atr14 years of age.in 1970's UK..I saw them live in their heyday in 1973. Their best song and the best crafted guitar solo of any rock band still chills 54 years on as I try to arrange a version for my band. It is fitting tribute to the master that only now do think I have the skills to pull it off! Your tutorials for all their songs are inciteful and delivered with an obvious passion and love for the people and times in which they lived and worked. I WAS THERE! and so glad that you understand their significance and can share your musical knowledge and talent to help us all.

[@zososhep]

To answer your question: YES! Yes this is the greatest blues rock song EVER! I have been saying this for a very long time! No other blues song by a rock band comes close-like you said, it is in another stratosphere!!

[@dizai]

I couldn't agree more

[@haydenwalton2766]

it was 1970 - where in the hell did that solo come from ?? it's like it just dropped from another dimension

[@grahambambrook313]

Still brings me to tears over fifty years after I first heard it. Lots of teenage angst!!!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Me too!

[@timothyslaughter476]

Dudes had a knack of creating new sounds and feels for every song...every album.....thats genius....

[@spnsoccer]

Another great analysis, this is my all time very favorite Zep song, and agree that it is perhaps Page's best studio solo ever! The only comment is that the importance of Bonham's fills in the final part of the song is understated. Thanks again.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Agreed!!

[@mike_money69]

jimmy’s phrasing is out of this world

[@RealDougFields]

That intro was really impressive. You did that so incredibly correct and musically perfect.

[@drsts000]

don't miss out among his sophistication, style, and insightfulness, carl is a monster guitar player.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

So kind!

[@saintbrando]

The Song Remains The Same Version still sends shivers down my spine. Squeaky Kick Pedal Pagey could never fix. Amazing video Carl!

[@the_rover1]

haha, yeah. once you notice the squeaking sounds, you can never unhear that again. especially in the beginning seconds of the song. like the screaming sounds of bonham in 'whole lotta love'. they'll always stick out and catch my attention.

[@pr0ct3r0]

It’s them all at their finest!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you!

[@centaurus5676]

This composition is an absolute masterpiece, as was your analysis and explanation and superb feel you gave whilst playing. Everybody on Earth should listen to this song, even if only once in their lifetime. My father was a jazz musician and said to me the only music i like, that you play [on vinyl] is Queen and that slow blues one by Led Zeppelin! That to me, summed up which was the best track, to a seasoned musician's ears. I wish my father was here to watch you break down this piece, he would have loved it. Sorry for the long comment, very emotional song for me, which to this day, i cannot listen to it all the way through. I'm 57 and it still rips my heart out. Thankyou.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you so much!

[@centaurus5676]

@@CarlBaldassarreMusic Thank you for taking the time to read my comment.

[@isaiahparadiso8044]

I love the context and history you present here. I always felt this was the best Zeppelin song of all time. The guitar solo has the most feeling of frustration, pain, love, and anguish I’ve ever heard. You feel all of it. A true blues masterpiece.

[@southjerseyjim5049]

This song, long one of my favorites, has been bringing me to tears for decades. I very much appreciate Mr. Baldasarre’s references to classical music as I’ve often thought of this as piece as having the emotive power of such monumental works as Durufle’s Ubi Caritas, Mozart’s Dies Irae, Stanford’s Beati Quorum Via, and Bach’s Crucifixus. It’s just that powerful. I think it transcends the genre.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you!!

[@stevemercier6590]

Carl I can’t stop watching you play SIBLY

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

That’s so awesome. I hope it continues to inspire!

[@stevemercier6590]

@@CarlBaldassarreMusic oh you will Carl, I’m sure you will.

[@joetrava3808]

Thanks for sharing my all time favorite band with us. You are a great teacher. you're motivating me to pick up the guitar again and work on the solos. You're playing is just great also you are up there with the eternal genius of Page and his mind blowing music craftmanship it is in fact the greatest blues song of all time it represents the best progresive blues rock.

[@davidmckenzie420]

As this is my favorite Zep song...and my favorite Page solo...I thoroughly enjoyed this. Thanks.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you!

[@instantrameng0d36]

This song used to scare me, but now I love it, Like what song can embark so many emotions inside you. it's so crazy! Love the breakdown too, so many subtle things u never realize.

[@Rick_Cleland]

I remember when I was seventeen and bought the *_Led Zeppelin The Song Remains The Same_* DVD which was the live concert at Madison Square Garden in 1976. The whole thing blew my mind, but _"Since I've Been Loving You"_ gave me chills. I ended up going out and buying an Єpipɧoɳe 𝓛𝓮𝓼 𝓟𝓪𝓾𝓵 just because of that song.

[@xipo199]

My favorite song of all time. I love the solo and am always amazed that guys so young could come up with such beauty. At the end of the live version on TSRTS Robert says “Jimmy Page, guitar”. I think this is because even he was like “Damn! That was impressive guitar playing”. This was a great breakdown.

[@dondamond7151]

Finally!! Someone calls this what it is! One of the best blues solos and songs ever! Feeling is knowing…

[@pauldbrown1010]

Wow, what a tour de force of a song review! I could listen all day! Carl, your love of music and deep technical knowledge, combined with the gems from your research into the historical details and anecdotes provides an utterly engrossing experience. On top of that, you absolutely channel Jimmy in your playing. You've shed such light on one of my lifetime favourite songs. It IS the greatest blues guitar song of all time, and I love it even more now. Thank you!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

You’re so welcome!! Peace and love, Carl

[@foesfly3047]

It’s impossible for me to identify one Zeppelin song as my favorite but this is on the short list, along with Tea for One, Stairway, Kashmere, Battle of Evermore, No Quarter…

[@pcatful]

This music directly affected our teenage minds with actual appreciation of the arts. I remember my friend mimicking "it's a drag, drag, drag, dtag.... ahhh...it makes a drag" and appreciating the true expression. Here's one song I wish Mozart could have heard.

[@OtterCreek]

One of the things that has always struck me about this song is how up front the drums are, and Plant is almost buried in the mix at times. I still am looking forward to a breakdown of No Quarter. Thanks Carl!

[@mindsigh4]

to me Plant sounds his best when he gets buried, swamped by the tide, he pushes through & his voice is distorted thru the maelstrom like thru some kind of feral guitar stomp box...the voice as another instrument

[@ignatiusb.samson977]

Really awesome. I love hearing your analysis of the chords. I've always been in awe of this song in terms of it living squarely in the blues idiom while simultaneously sounding fresh and innovative.

[@ericstewart9742]

The best thing for me about videos like this is seeing someone speaking their appreciation of the same particular aspects and points of interest of a song that I notice and appreciate myself. I’m a musician and I fear that non-musicians are deaf to these things.

[@robertlawrence7958]

I am an english speaking, non musical fan of Led Zeppelin. Listening to you explain the music behind one of my favourite songs is like listening to someone talking a foreign language. BUT, I was simply transfixed ! I have just retired and as someone who has always liked listening to music, especially electric guitar, but had absolutely no musical talent whatsoever, your videos are tempting me to go out and buy a guitar and get some lessons.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

That’s wonderful Robert!

[@johnwilliams1223]

This is one of those songs that still gives me a chill down my leg.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Me too!

[@jaimemoreno55]

All the questions I ever had about comprehending this great song were answered with such clarity and eloquence, thanks, I appreciate you Carl!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

That’s so kind! Thank you!

[@georgamann3743]

I'm in a quite ... "emotional" state of mind right now (in a good way) - yes, it's like you said in one of your earlier videos: the difference between hearing a song and listening to a song. I just noticed that for over 30 years now, I wasn't *listening* to "Since I've been" enough (I *heard* it on an almost daily basis). Well, that changed (the "not-listening"-part). Thank you for your giving me more and more insights, I very, very much appreciate it. Oh, and keep your smile and very positive mood in your videos, your vibes are just so great! :)

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you Georg! I really appreciate your encouragement!

[@swhoover1]

This song is on another level, but so was each member of the band and it comes through from beginning to end. Fantastic breakdown Carl, it makes it even more special learning how it all gets put together. Amazing!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

You’re so welcome Shane!!

[@marting3614]

"That's my parlour trick". No, your parlour trick is absolutely nailing these breakdowns and this was no exception. Amazing!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you!!!

[@miparedro76]

La mejor canción de Zeppelin sin duda alguna. Temazo.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Acordado!

[@SuiGenerisMan]

Omg I've been working in this song off and on for 6 months, trying to get faster and cleaner, and waiting for this song to get your special treatment. What a treat, THANK YOU!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

So happy to help!

[@madisongraham9307]

Wonderful analysis. Hats off to Carl! I purchased the LP the day it was released- I was a senior in high school. Still have and play it often- just played the Page reissued version on my iPhone through my HiFi system… times change, but some things are classic. Really enjoy your LZ videos. Peace.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you Madison! I hope you join along on some of my other classic rock vids I’m going to do!

[@dukeallen432]

Regularly play my old zep records.

[@tolgaylmaz1027]

This is the best song I ever heard. good video

[@amarshmuseconcepta6197]

😉👍and mine.

[@lindsaydouglas381]

Thanks Carl for clarifying a few mysteries to this song. In my opinion, this is the best song ever, and arguably the best guitar solo. The texture and emotion that Page puts into this is unequalled. If I can master playing this I would die happy. 🙏🙏🙏

[@robertweaver2960]

**** This IS and ALWAYS HAS BEEN my Absolute Favorite song. The Emotion, The Heartfelt Yearning, The Pain is Absolutely Amazing.

[@-jeffk3339]

Thank you Carl. Your breakdown was so enlightening . This song has haunted me (in a good way) my whole life. SIBLY has and will be my favorite Led Zeppelin track of all time.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

I’m so happy you enjoyed my effort!

[@Macnee2]

It's not just the guitar bits, which are amazing. Plant's lyrics and delivery bring together all the best blues concepts/stereotypes perfectly.

[@TheCelticlion]

Very very interesting. I was once asked to write an article for a mental health newsletter about 10 years ago. I'm an engineer not a author, but when it was published it just stopped everyone who read it. Even some with degrees considered it probably the finest piece of English literature ever. A couple of months ago I was listening to Since I was Loving You, there was a familiarity to it. I realised my piece had a almost identical 'format' to Since I've Been Loving You. I have spent 2 days days deconstructing both works. I'll type it up as a finished piece over winter. I have found this video absolutely fascinating as I can identify with the content coming from a different perspective. Eg where you talk of an inversion of a chord, I deliberately changed the order of words so even though they still make sense literally they give a different and unique feel. I might even make a KZbin video that will compliment yours. How the lyrics and overall format work with the chords etc.

[@danielovermyer9122]

Led Zeppelin still lives in their music and in our hearts, and may they one day reform, those that remain, to relive a bit of the magic akin to the past.

[@Gruuvin1]

That Cmaj is such a beautiful lift. It's hard to imagine this song going into another universe by that point, but then it does.

[@tnondillo]

The best guitar KZbinr, for sure!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Wow!! That’s so kind!! Please share my links and help me grow my channel!

[@rupertstreet13]

A superb analysis of this apsolutey stunning classic track so well done top chap 👍🎸

[@georgesargent7770]

Great stuff Jimmy did with the chord progression and lead and Robert with his singing, it almost sounds like a Janice I love that organ sound from John and John Bonhams drumming really good

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Great observation about Robert!!

[@poppajretired410]

The arpeggiated chords in the third verse behind Plant’s vocals have always been my favorite part of this song

[@lordviewer7305]

This is the most comprehensive lesson of this masterpiece. Congratulations man.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you!

[@heneverreturnasahorse9773]

I had been a Zep fan since the fall of '69 but this most soulful of slow blues/rock floored me beginning my freshman year in college. Let me add there were some tremendous songs in the fall of '70!

[@Mike-rw2nh]

Thank you for the thought that goes into your content, and thank you for your generous answers to questions I posted on previous uploads (I’m still working on improving my pocket). This channel really is something special. I always feel inspired to play with the ideas presented, just to see where they lead me creatively. All the very best, good sir.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you Mike!

[@HeathWatts]

Yes. That’s a great song. The live solos that I’ve heard all differ slightly and are great too. Page is a great player and improviser.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Agree!

[@chrisschmitt291]

Fantastic explanation of what made a great song Great! I would love to see you, do. Edgy clip for achilles last and.

[@jebpleb1803]

A legend and still under rated. Their best song.

[@MrBarnardoo98]

Damn! I absolutely love how you play Since I've Been Loving You! You are fantastic!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you Alejandro!

[@funguy29]

Thank you sir. You’re a scholar and a gentleman

[@nickcosta8062]

Once again you nailed it down professor... I always learn some aspects of JP I never knew before.. Because of this series.. Can't thank you enough for this great treasure trove of everything you bring to KZbin... You ROCK Dude!

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Thank you Nick!! I’m so glad you’re liking the content. I know you’re a serious student and if I’m able to please you, I’m on the right path! Blessings my brother! Carl

[@OzziesRobots]

Every element of the song came together perfectly. So moody & vibey 💙

[@billott5660]

Really nice playing and breakdown...

[@bradpoole400]

One of my favorite Led Zeppelin songs. This video is a great resource.

[@stephenflowers8516]

I've loved this song since I bought ZePPeLiN lll when it was released. And it just never gets old.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Same!!!

[@kentmains7763]

This is the go to Zeppelin channel.

[@FenderTeleDeluxe]

In a word….yes! Could not agree more.

[@301gobluehailmich1]

100....my fav band of all time

[@VanDiemensEffects]

One of my top 5 songs to play on guitar, I just love it. Thanks so much for all the great information and the breakdown. It was excellent.

[@straycatflauter5377]

It's not only a great explanation but your passion sells it more. Ty

[@hokkym.6348]

I think the most underrated and overlooked part of the song is the kick drum sound. It just crushes right through your soul! It’s so heavy.

[@Louisthefur]

Especially the squeak it makes

[@5150show]

Carl You are a ⭐️

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Aw! That’s so sweet!! I hope you subscribed?!

[@5150show]

@@CarlBaldassarreMusic absolutely, I’ve even put a post about your channel on our community page .

[@helwic]

really best bluesrock song of all time

[@timaddison707]

Also love the passion for this song, it oozes out of the video.

[@antarcticorb9197]

Lovely breakdown of such a stellar slow blues song! Appreciate all you do, please continue to shine your insight on such a timeless band.

[@benlagow1290]

I've been looking for an an explanation on the theory of this for so long! Especially the end to the verse turnaround. This is awesome!

[@dperry7309]

My altimeter favorite song!

[@geraldfawley5557]

Great analysis. Since I've Been Loving You is often overlooked in the Led Zeppelin popular imagination but it's always been my very favorite. And you are right, all 4 members are at their very best.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

Agreed!!!!

[@joet_swbo101]

glad to finally see someone who made the connection with new York city blues. been telling people that for a good part of 40 years.

[@CarlBaldassarreMusic]

You were on top of it!!!

[@Mandrahale]

This and Achilles Last Stand are my favorite Zeppelin songs…

[@davidgeorge5863]

My favorite zeppelin song

[@Madhatter975]

it is an amazing song and I’ve always loved it but i appreciate it even more having watched this video. You have really done justice to the song with this fantastic review. Thank you.

[@lescaster2179]

My favorite Zep tune, hands down. So many other fantastic songs but for me if I could only put one zeppelin song in my playlist, this would be it.

[@joet_swbo101]

I love this song. I first learned it at 16, 40 years ago. I still love playing it.

[@luvbasses5487]

Hi Carl. As usual, this was a wonderful synopsis on this incredible blues number. In addition to the beautiful guitar playing here - it’s Jones’s Hammond organ foot pedal work that I find equally as impressive. At bars 34 & 35 especially during the pre and main choruses there. It’s been a challenge for me to replicate this on electric bass but it can eventually be done. I’m not any sort of advanced music student by any means. Jones certainly was their secret weapon. This is a subject that’s been widely known for years. Thanks Carl.

[@jimmylawrence576]

No doubt when I saw the title. This is real Mississippi blues.

[@Richard_Lush]

When I first heard this in the 70s it blew me away. Especially when he slowed down the lead. It was perfect. Thanks Carl. Totally I agree.

[@libertatem_semper]

Thank you for the wonderful video, Carl! My all-time favorite Page solo. So good.

[@tomcreighton3801]

By far, Zeppelin’s most emotional evoking song. Lest we forget John Paul Jones organ fills that blend in to this masterpiece.