Carrier Good, Better, BEST Review

If you're interested in learning the difference between the Carrier Comfort vs. Performance vs. Infinity series, this is the video for you. The models that we review are the 24SCA5, 24TPA7, 24VNA9, and 24VNA6. These are the Good, Better, and Best air conditioner systems out of Carries product lines.
NOTE: All three systems in the video are 4-Ton and the pricing also is for a 4-Ton complete system and installation.
Find out the cost of a new AC system in seconds
New AC Unit Cost: atlasacrepair.com/blog/new-ac...
New HVAC System Cost: atlasacrepair.com/blog/hvac-r...
Best Air Conditioner Brands: atlasacrepair.com/blog/best-a...
Find us at: atlasacrepair.com
Timecodes
0:00 - Intro
0:14 - Good / Comfort Series
2:07 - Better / Performance Series
4:22 - Best / Infinity Series

[@George-fy7tt]

Thanks Kenny for the informative videos!

[@armintahoori6524]

Hi thanks for your great channel. In your another program you mentioned variable speed hvacs can cause more humidity as we don't have condensation. In this program you are mentioning the opposite. May be I didn't understand well. Please explain. Thank you

[@biomedlib]

Hello, enjoyed the video. However, I don't have the space for either of these heat pumps. The footprints are too large. However, I see Carrier has the Performance18 Compact Heat Pump. Can you offer information about this heat pump? Thank you.

[@SunSun-hk8eg]

👍👍👍👍👍 Excellent video Thanks for sharing this information.

[@silvertbird1]

Very useful info, now I have a a little bit better understanding of the options. If you service Rockwall County I will be contacting.

[@jackfrost-fu7hz]

I had a 4 ton, 2 speed performance system installed last year, they are not built like a tank as he says. The condenser base is so thin the system would not sit flat on the concrete pad, the base is very flimsy, they need to go to a composite base that is very sturdy , other brands are already using them. The top cover for the condenser had screws going in at an angle because the holes did not line up, one screw is half way in and at angle, but QC passed it. The condenser coil has black plastic spacers where the coil meets the base and the coil was not a perfect fit and some of the fins were crushed at the base, but they had those spacers to try and level out the coil, it is hard to describe. The louver side panels do not offer much protection, there is no screw in the middle of the panel on the edges, so when they move it around to position the condenser and push on the louver panels they make contact with the coil and bend the fins, at 4:10 in the video you can see fins already bent on the right side of the unit, probably from someone moving the unit around. Then they put a 16 seer label in the condenser box, I had to call Carrier and give them the serial numbers to confirm it was a 17 seer unit. Quality control is lacking at Carrier. I replaced an Amana system, aka, Goodman, it was not reliable, but it was built like a tank.

[@geffreyacosta8821]

I'm thinking about getting the 4 ton 2 speed Carrier condenser as well. Over all would u recommend it? Is there any energy savings that u seen?

[@kg811]

My Goodman just crapped out after 6 years. It will cost more to fix it even with a warranty. What did you go to next?

[@geffreyacosta8821]

@@kg811 It's only my condenser unit giving me issues. I'm gonna go with a 4 ton 2 stage Carrier to match my Carrier furnace. After six years that sounds relatively quick for a big repair. I heard who does install matters alot. I'm hiring an BBB accredited company not fooling around with it.

[@moderndaycaveman2519]

You sound like you're working for a competitor (Trane, Lennox, etc...)

[@jackfrost-fu7hz]

@@moderndaycaveman2519 No, just a person who had a Carrier system installed and thinks the quality of the condenser construction is poor. Brands I did not want was Trane , Lennox and Goodman, aka Amana. Trane is too expensive and I don't like their spiral coil, looks too fragile and hard to clean; many ac techs don't like Lennox, too complex and costly to repair. Goodman/ Amana; I had Amana and went through two evap coil leaks, 6 years then 4 years

[@metaltera86]

We install Bryant. My personal favorite are the preferred series. Or for Carrier that would be the performance

[@captnweb1]

In reference to this company residential service call, Taylor was quick with his response and was able to get Warranty parts for me thank you! Found failed air handler motor. Two days later a replacement was available and Dave came out this time and did a professional install along with checks of the AC performance and Freon check. It is nice dealing with a Company that still believes in customer service and not ripping off folks.

[@rogerhodges7656]

The more expensive and the more costly the system, the more complicated it is. The more features, the more parts to fail and the more expensive the repairs.

[@ACitizenOfOurWorld]

One needs to balance complexity with the comfort and quiet operating benefits each can provide. That's why I like the middle one the best.

[@kens.3729]

AND you Forgot to Mention that the Most Expensive is also the Most Efficient and Least Expensive to Operate. 10-Year Parts Warranty.👍

[@rogerhodges7656]

About three years ago, I calculated the time to recover the difference in cost between 14 SEER and 18 SEER AC based on then the current electricity costs in Little Rock Arkansas. The cost recovery period was about 10 years. It made no economic sense. @@kens.3729

[@yolo_burrito]

That’s not a great take. A VFD is electronically “more complex” but eliminates a lot of the issues. There’s no inrush currents. There’s no hard starts and no mechanical relays or contractors.

[@rickyisaacs4345]

No. The parts last longer. So there is no need for maintenance bro

[@mr.boniato6402]

My furnace has a 5 inch 11 merv filter. I also have 2 return vents.. 20"x21" and 12"x12". Do I need to add filters on those returns? I think If I don't, won't the duct system get full of dust?

[@zlandar1]

How about repair cost of the variable and 2 stage systems vs single speed? I’ve heard horror stories on cost/wait if something breaks with a variable speed.

[@FrostBlueFire]

if its outside of warranty, it's very expensive, either buy a new unit or have them replace it with a basic component...or shovel the cost. Tis the risk of high efficiency, but honestly cost of everything keeps raising so, we're just fkd period

[@Quentyn73]

Do all of them have NG furnaces in the cabinets, or electrical, or what?

[@steveprs]

Do these system come with a hepa filter in that attic between the return plenum and the furnace?

[@sokola311]

It's about time someone put out a straight up honest and to the point video about a product. Well done good Sir.

[@mongo312]

Good stuff. We have an 20 year old infinity system that is still going strong but have started looking at an eventual replacement. Have to research the Honeywell options as our contractor never mentioned a noncarrier thermostat. Does Bryant have an equivalent system for these three series?

[@atlasacrepair]

For Bryant, their upper end systems are their "Evolution" series so their "best", "Preferred" is their mid tier model, and "Legacy" is their base model. Hope this helps!

[@Wingzero3802]

I currently have a Carrier heat pump system in my home. Built in 2007 and it has multiple leaks. I am looking at the performance and comfort series but am wondering if the coils are copper in them or if they were changed to the cheaper all aluminim coils.

[@CarreraTrackOntheFloor]

Can you match the two stage 24ACB7 with the infinity furnace 59TN6 and use the Carrier Infinity System Control thermostat?

[@sergioblanco4504]

Are those prices for the system and installation?

[@leonardocespedes7876]

How many tons are those units?

[@satxification]

I replaced my Goodman with a comfort series 4ton. The Goodman lasted almost 20 years. The electric bill is much lower with the Carrier unit.

[@MrRjnr]

did u consider another Goodman?

[@JosephWett-vw7zp]

I’ve been installing carrier for 35 years so I’m very familiar with it. All brands have good units and bad units. But as far as efficiency, you’re better off going with a lower efficiency. The actual efficiency units achieve can be less than they are marketed at. The new seer2 rating system helps with this a bit. You have to pay way more for a couple points of efficiency. Sometimes you can’t reach a balance point where it saves you money before it needs replacement. A federal tax credit only works if you owe money on your taxes April 15th. They will not pay you any money if you get a refund. You have to owe. So save yourself money and get a 15 seer heat pump or a/c. Put in a 95% gas furnace instead of a 97%. You will only save a few bucks a month with the higher efficiency. I always find what will be the most cost effective for my customers.

[@garykinard7553]

Yes I was a small HVAC owner contractor. Just go for the least efficient , that gets the rebate, and get a good small business to install it. They are reliable and when the die rinse and repeat.

[@kg811]

I need help from both of you guys in this thread. My Goodman died and it was just shy of 6 years. More to fix than worth. Do you have a brand you suggest for the least efficient? I am in Phoenix so need this a lot. This will be the main AC as I do have a 2nd unit.

[@katazack]

A federal tax credit is deducted from your total tax bill, not the refund. If you had $10,000 in income tax withheld during the tax year and you received a $1,000 tax credit, your taxes owed would be $10,000 minus $1,000 equals $9,000 taxes owed. The only way you would not receive a tax credit is if you did not pay any income tax for that tax year.

[@JW02828]

On the Infinity and professional model, would you have to run a compressor saver or does the unit already has one in it?

[@lp2565]

Soft Start?

[@JW02828]

@@lp2565 Compressor saver or hard start what it's called. A Soft start is a little different.

[@Ryan-RM]

Inverters (or variable speed equipment) don’t need hard starts. They start soft already to protect the compressor.

[@JW02828]

@@Ryan-RM thank

[@zer0ed779]

My biggest issue with any of these handler chassis, in Florida, when they're put in the attic, they rust and fall apart over time.

[@lp2565]

Doesn't TRANE offer a plastic based cabiner evaporator chassis now?

[@zer0ed779]

@@lp2565 They do! I want one when I replace my current Lennox crap, garbage HVAC system. My friend has the TRANE system with the plastic in his attic and loves it. Not a lot of places seem to offer them.

[@markg999]

Friends Trane been good? I got a crap Lennox system from 2015...want a reliable brand that can deal with Florida heat.

[@gimmedaloottheloot1035]

What are your thoughts about mini splits, especially for single story homes?

[@AnkitSinghAnarchoAtheist]

They are the best.

[@darylslaughter]

In your video you mention a 10 year parts and 2 year labor warranty but on your website it shows only a 1 year labor warranty. Is the labor warranty 1 year or 2 years?

[@Floormusic440]

The video was recently posted but he references the low end at 15.2 SEER but the current models are 16.5 and the upper end was mentioned at 19 but it is now at 24 so it would seem the video is actually a few years old. Maybe the quality of the product has gone down and they can no longer afford the warranty labor.

[@elainecathey7417]

He stated “All three come with: Parts warranty: 5yr Labor warranty: 1yr” However, he also quickly stated that you can “register the equipment with the manufacturer which can extended your Parts warranty another 5 yrs and Labor warranty another 1yr” I believe with his company Atlas AC. That they have a department that will actually process the additional warranty. Ideally, you’re notified within 2 weeks by text. If not, contact them or search on the warranty website that the manufacturer uses. Hope this helps.

[@MeMe-in8tj]

Shady way for Carrier to save money, hoping 1/2 the people don't remember to register for the full warranty

[@LouisS-cs7bh]

@@MeMe-in8tj the a/c industry is a huge legalized ripoff.

[@enjoythedreamlife5658]

why is the units so expensive. I got a price on the Comfort Series which the lower of the 3 you are showing for $5,500 Canadian. Your price starts at $7,339 USD. You offer 2 year Labour warranty I got 5 year labour warranty through Lowes. Plus 10 years on the parts.

[@NeverFollowTheCrowd]

What state are you in your installation Prices are insane. $9,000+ parts and labor highway robbery

[@venvnco6259]

That is why people are putting in mini splits them selves some are going back to window a/c. Sad part is after spending all this money all brands today are junk. I have a 3 yr old ruud and have had to replace the coil. Few months later had to replaced the fan motor. Warranty did not cover labor. HVAC has become a major rip off and people are getting sick it.

[@Ryan-RM]

I most states that’s a great deal. Where do you live? Also he’s transparent with pricing online which is refreshing. Most companies hide the price ranges until they get into your home.

[@LouisS-cs7bh]

@@venvnco6259 agreed!!!

[@StevePuckett-lm2rn]

You do realize United Technologies/ Carrier bought ICP in the 90's because the 1st time in history they were outsold by Goodman.

[@Stevonoles1]

Be very careful offering the 2nd year labor warranty yourself. Anything over the one year warranty requires an Insurance license. The Insurance Commission can find out and there are penalties. Speaking from experience. Use a 3rd party insurer and save yourself the headache that goes with an audit. Soeme states may be different. I am in FL.

[@bosoares]

73dB is like a dishwasher? That’s gotta be one old and crappy dishwasher. Most decent and moderns ones are in the 40s and 50s decibels.

[@pilljr.3331]

Why no discussion of the Heating Performance? I live in Ohio and it gets a bit “chilly” here in Winter so a Heating Performance review is absolutely essential. This review is incomplete so no thumbs up☹️ It is after all called a “Heat Pump”.

[@foghornleghorn8536]

"It is after all called a “Heat Pump”. Wrong.

[@katazack]

You are better off with a furnace in Ohio. Heat pumps aren't designed to work in below freezing climates. Here in Florida they struggle to heat the house once it drops into the 30s.

[@williamzinser2378]

What my house needs, hmmm. How about what I want or need

[@George-fy7tt]

Its not what you want its about your square footage and they correct system for your home. Your not buying a new suit.

[@ScottSellsSoCal]

Wow two whole years warranty…. My Trane system came with 10 years parts and labor

[@joehernandez7163]

Thanks

[@mikelagarratesta8089]

Get a Goodman. Cheapest n longer lasting.

[@MeMe-in8tj]

Bad reliability compared to Carrier. Look at the brand ratings

[@kg811]

My Goodman just died just under 6 years. Not happy.

[@MrRjnr]

@@kg811 mine is going still, after 24 years!

[@scottdaniels5976]

You'd save more money using a stand-alone energy star dehumidifier on home less than 1800sf vs paying an extra $2-3k for a 2-stage system especially in a state like FL (which the Governor F-cks the citizens by rejecting the Federal Tax credits)

[@philippusviridi6527]

Two years parts and labor how disgusting.

[@williamedwards3002]

2 years labor, 10 years parts. He said that about 5 times.

[@philippusviridi6527]

@@williamedwards3002 Yea and a twenty dollar part will cost you over 300 dollars to have it installed. What exactly is your point? Again a two year labor warranty is a joke.

[@williamedwards3002]

@@philippusviridi6527 My point is your original comment was obviously incorrect.

[@metaltera86]

Yeah some companies offer only 1 year labor and your point

[@philippusviridi6527]

@@metaltera86 Don't go away mad just go away.

[@gtrguyinaz]

2 stage is best for your buck….

[@JohnLee-db9zt]

All parts made in China 😂

[@daveladd7046]

assembled in mexico afaik.. yes , parts from all over

[@hightech346]

I have the entry level Carrier gas pack...3.5 ton and noticed that it was not cooling like it did when it was brand new...(6 years old) but it was still getting the job done...IT just did'n feel like I was stepping into a walk in freezer when entering the house on a hot summer day....I simply cleaned the outside coils..However, those with understanding and wisdom know there is another coil that needs to be cleaned inside the unit...After 6 years it was about 50% clogged and I do change my filters regularly....After cleaning the entire system it is performing like new....It's 91 degrees outside with a heat index of 96 today and this 1800 soft house is at 70 degrees...no shade at all on the house with a dark roof...I do have attic fans....This unit would keep the house in the high 60 degree temps if I let run but when I'm not home the thermostat switches to 78 degree on temp....That's the first maintenance on the system...Gas pack section has had ZERO issues....I'll probably get them to check the charge on the system this week...