Casting Jeff Probst's Nightmare Survivor Season

In this video, I finally do a sequel video to my Casting video for Jeff Probst's dream season and instead do a Casting video for his Nightmare Season.

[@iansunbury987]

When I saw this video title I immediately thought of Colton

[@58twright]

Lol

[@regularperson7380]

And he's on the video

[@lucasmack3727]

me to

[@emilybirks1840]

Same lol

[@chowman550]

same

[@KeyToAeris2024]

Spoiler for the season Half the cast quits as soon as the game starts and Jeff gets a brain hemorrhage from it and the season ends in 20 seconds

[@larstem2080]

Haha

[@googlyotterr]

Jeff Probst’s Nightmare is a season of people not willing to be swayed by him, people who are racist/homophobic/sexist, people who are boring, people who quit, and Julie.

[@paulieluce5303]

Thank you! Now I don’t have to watch it all lol

[@chilltown5829]

Who are racist homophobic and sexist on survivor besides shannon & Rocker

[@straightblackgirl]

@@chilltown5829 Jeff Varner is transphobic.

[@chilltown5829]

@@straightblackgirl yes I know that

[@josephmeeks240]

@@straightblackgirl Is he really? I know about the whole Zeke situation but I don't think he's actually transphobic

[@ThePercyJacksonDude]

I don’t know why but seeing that Dan (worlds apart) is on this cast made me laugh so hard. Maybe I’m thinking of his “adopted child” speech.

[@zbee6422]

Tbh i would watch any season with Courtney Yates on it. I’m down

[@crimbleland]

Right love her

[@connorhickson846]

same

[@daltonfarris]

Her, Brian, and colton would run this season.

[@carleebrew3831]

im really surprised Aras is here considering he was called for winners at war

[@gabrielcamilleri1193]

Ozzy was called for game changers and he didnt want him

[@Nintendoshi]

@@gabrielcamilleri1193 yeah but like production really pushed for him. I think Jeff has faves he would keep going, but he isn’t crazy about Ozzy.

[@loganbrown6987]

Wasn’t Aras on the main cast than said that he didn’t want to leave his family

[@carleebrew3831]

@@loganbrown6987 ya that’s what I heard

[@kodakohl]

@@loganbrown6987 now I want to know who the alternate was that ended up in Aras's place

[@connorspencer4283]

prefer this cast to one world

[@tubagal13]

I think if you were going to pick one Borneo player to give Probst nightmares, it has to be Greg. Apparently he drove Probst and production nuts during every Tribal Council.

[@siwap3809]

Russell actually finds Jeff alright. he actually defended Jeff in his “players that will never return” video on his channel, when he talks about Shane Powers in the video. go check it out

[@divdesmitpieci6767]

This is the video we've been waiting for.

[@nightaronipepperoni]

I did a BrantSteele simulation of this season and Judd won. That is all I have to say.

[@MvpNew]

Omg 😳

[@robbierotten2874]

makes sense tbh. Judd wished that everyone else would get bit by a bunch of freakin crocodiles (man), and they did.

[@sophiadelrosario6526]

Me before even watching the video: waiting for Colton to be on here

[@ci_blanch5407]

I might have considered: Lex. I know that he has been in consideration for seasons since All-Stars, but I seem to remember Jeff saying somewhere that Lex doesn't seem to like him. Though that doesn't mean that Jeff has anything against Lex, I thought that I should mention it. Lil. When Jeff did his ranking of the first 19 seasons of the seasons of the show right before Heroes vs. Villains aired that the Outcast twist in Pearl Islands was bad and Lil never should have been a finalist. I keep hearing that Jeff doesn't like Chris D., but I should point out that Jeff also said about Vanuatu in his ranking of the first 19 seasons: "I always liked this season more than the audience did, and that has probably influenced why it has dropped since my last ranking. Chris has to be acknowledged for doing such a good job of turning the women against one another so that they gave him the million dollars." Chris is still a good choice, though I have heard that he may not have been in consideration for Winners at War at least partly because of his health. And I love the choice or Purple Kelly, since she said in her EW interview that she would like to play again.

[@objectreality2889]

How can anyone hate lil 😢

[@MultiSkins4life]

I immediately knew Johny FairPlay would be on this list lol

[@blr_blur]

I love all the behind the scenes research you do for your videos, a lot of this stuff I had never heard of before. And the concept of Probst’s nightmare cast is funny 🤣

[@pmichaelreed103]

On the commentary track on the Vanuatu DVD's, Probst apologized to Chris Daugherty and admitted his feelings for Julie (which was recorded during their relationship) got in the way. He doesn't harbor issues for Chris.

[@thefirespecialist9007]

Brandon Hantz, Colton, Varner, Naonka, Purple Kelly, Dan S30, Dan S39. LMAO

[@theman1213]

How did nayonka not make the cast

[@DizzyMapping]

@@theman1213 Probst liked Naonka until she quit I’m pretty shre

[@francesca-selfproclaimed-bleep]

@@DizzyMapping She was the only person actually doing and saying anything around camp. lmao

[@kamaltaylor3068]

Crazy how only 3 of these people made the list

[@jedmojica861]

I would TOTALLY watch this season tho.. 😆

[@HousewivesUnHinged]

I struggle to think of a worse contestant than LISI. She has to be his biggest nightmare.

[@58twright]

He openly said that she will never return

[@auguststrain3462]

Oh god. I don’t even want to think about her 🤢🤮

[@anthonyjunk2197]

Wendy joe

[@freddybarton8544]

Are you sure about Aras? He got the call for WaW apparently?

[@devin9338]

I don’t think that is true, I thought he said in an interview that the first 20 people called back didn’t say no

[@MegTalksGlee]

@@devin9338 Nah, he said on a RHAP interview he got the call but said no

[@edendorra7231]

@@devin9338 Earl and Cochran both said no, so Jeff was lying here.

[@derekbroekhoven5498]

Yeah, Earl and Aras were both called and said no due to having young kids. Cochran said no because he feels he has nothing to gain from playing again, he just wants to stay "on top" after his win

[@dakinwatson3782]

Would have been good to see pictures of the castaways for the ones up for consideration, since some people, myself included, remember faces better than names, especially ones that are from years ago

[@landonweaver1040]

Colton is on everyone’s nightmare cast

[@airtempest8945]

Lowkey, I want to see this season play out

[@laurelmahler7274]

I know you put Wendell on the Dream Cast, but I honestly feel like he's a better fit here.. I feel like the beef between Wendell and Jeff is very evident especially after WAW but just my opinion!!

[@Mentally_Will]

I'm out of the loop, can you elaborate?

[@mariachase2384]

I think deep down they like each other, like a healthy back and forth between the two

[@Mentally_Will]

@THEODORE KUM Now I was already familiar with those, but I had interpreted that as playful ribbing rather than actual vitriol.

[@laurelmahler7274]

@@Mentally_Will This is the vid for the nightmare season, but in a previous video, he put wendell on Jeff's dream season. I felt after Winners @ war Wendell got a lil mouthy with Jeff more times than not, could have been the circumstances or whatever but I'm not sure i'd consider Wendell one of Jeff's favorites!! Just my opinions tbh

[@laurelmahler7274]

@@mariachase2384 could be!

[@loganharris1669]

"But I was an adopted child." - Dan

[@aperson22222]

There was the first boot from S2--Deb, was it?--who really talked about what a negative experience she had and how she wished she hadn't taken part. And this at the height of Survivormania.

[@alexandramarsolais3616]

2021 - giving the people what they want! Love this concept!

[@cjoh29n]

You should do a season of past contestants that got arrested/became criminals

[@58twright]

Russell hantz did it

[@nolanrussell6326]

Off the top of my head there's Hatch, Skupin, Silas, Fairplay, Heidik, Jenna Morasca, Fabio, and Russell Hantz. I'm sure I'm missing some but it still might be tough to fill out a full cast, especially on the female side.

[@aydrianna]

yo wait what did russell do????

[@chickenchicken9072]

@@aydrianna Pretty sure he pushed a woman to the ground

[@snazzyzaddy]

@@aydrianna russell explains what happened in his video

[@katoscott6692]

Jeff almost quite when he and Julie broke up. He hated Chris because Julie was the love of his life and she was really hurt when Chris voted her out.

[@ilikualot7546]

6:50 I think on an interview with I think Courtney on his podcast he said he was almost on heroes vs villians but was replaced last second

[@dominicbernard8880]

He even pregamed with Randy, Corinne, and Ace. Clearly that worked out... lol

[@58twright]

Jonny FairPlay & Brian Heidik are the top 2 I’m surprised Shane powers isint on here Shane powers hates probst Colton would just quit again for a 3rd time lol

[@slimbish605]

2nd*

[@petermartin2886]

Didn't brian shoot a dog with a bow and arrow or something?

[@58twright]

@@petermartin2886 yes he was also a male porn star & tried to cover that up until production noticed a tattoo that he had that resembled that &when he was asked back for all stars he said he would only come back if he received an extra $50,000 regardless of his placement in the game & probst & production did not like that & he got in fights with probst behind the scenes in Thailand

[@jeffreysg]

Colton should only be cast if Vacepia is cast again. Then he can quit for the third time after she gets voted out first for the third time. *Edit - I mean Francesca.

[@58twright]

@@jeffreysg I think your talking about Francesca

[@dominicbernard8880]

Fairplay and Aras both got called for season 40, though I doubt either of them would make the final cast of any season.

[@MistaUnicorn]

Fairplay never won though

[@dominicbernard8880]

@@MistaUnicorn They called a bunch of different people before deciding on a theme

[@apecentury228]

@@MistaUnicorn Yeah Lex was called as well

[@MistaUnicorn]

@@dominicbernard8880 Oh interesting, I didn't know that :P

[@kyletucker3811]

Yeah, I really think you whiffed on having Courtney on here. I mean, your main rational is he made a comment about the fact she looked healthier at the reunion? That's the stretchiest of stretches. Nah, you should've chosen Jean-Robert from that season.

[@ab5382]

love this... my note would be to add visual examples - the twitter block / articles / clips

[@Bazzlieo]

Oh my god there's a good amount of absofavos of mine in here. Chris, Courtney (

[@jewski6852]

Yeah, this is already a season, Gabon

[@NDiamond25]

Do this with Julie Chen and big brother!

[@skinnycolt]

aaron, jack and jackson, christie, that’s 4 i can think of

[@ariellee2329]

The majority of season 21 I’d assume lol

[@vaporterra]

@@ariellee2329 and Season 15

[@nizzle428]

pretty much the whole bb15 cast

[@jordanskeleton8197]

Most of 15, 19, and 21 would be on it. Absolute nightmare!

[@natemenzel6026]

My jaw dropped when you said JP, I loved him tbh

[@morgankingsley4992]

I don't think jeff would feel as strong against osten now

[@Rp10101]

Could you maybe do a video or possibly series on behind the camera stuff. You always mention things about stuff that happened and I don't always know what your talking about lol. Im not a reddit person! Maybe season by season things that happened ( rumors ,heresy exc ) I would be super interested. I still don't know what happened with Stephanie Johnson!

[@ZavidWebster]

My Nightmare Cast: James (Heroes Vs.Villains ext.) Rupert (Heroes Vs. Villains ext.) Coach (South Pacific ext.) Jeremy (Second Chances ext.) Woo (Cagayan ext.) Gervase (Blood Vs. Water ext.) Will (Worlds Apart) Phillip (Redemption Island ext.) Dan (Island of the Idols) Troyzan (One World ext.) Sugar (Gabon ext.) Shambo (Samoa) Angela (Ghost Island) Alicia (One World) Tasha (Second Chances ONLY) Amanda (Heroes Vs. Villains ext.) Dawn (Caramoan ONLY) Jenna Lewis (All Stars ONLY) Karishma (Island of the Idols) Ashley (Heroes Vs. Healers Vs. Hustlers)

[@jacoblangguth5125]

I honestly thought Jeff liked Alicia on Kaoh Rong

[@tempest6357]

Jeff’’s hate for Lydia has always been undeserved…

[@Ryan12334]

Jeff really hates Vecepia for no reason tbh...

[@thebeardedwondercorbin8058]

I had no idea Jeff felt that way about her she seems like an underrated winner I never saw her season but she seemed ok.

[@apecentury228]

She was horrible TV.......dryer than sandpaper

[@cameronholmes5590]

I don’t think he hates her personally but when it comes to the show she’s pretty boring and I wouldn’t even say her game is that impressive honestly

[@MvpNew]

This video is funny as hell. Love your content bro w

[@gavinjohn5165]

do jury speech ranking

[@brendanfechter4889]

JP Hilsabek. was a last minute replacement when Eric Hafeman (who went on to play in Season 38 EOE, blindsiding Aubry pre-merge but being 2nd boot postmerge after Joey A) had to back out for some family obligations. Casting director Lin told him now she literally had a short time to go out and find a player his exact archetype. Imagine how different HHH woulda been with Eric on the Heroes instead of JP. No hilarious Alan Ball "power couple" accusations, I think he'd be Chrissy's #1 over Ben. He would probably make the merge then he'd be in a power spot. He did get blindsided big similar to.JP but honestly Eric wasnt bad at the game like JP I think things woulda gone differently and Ben doesn't win HHH.

[@drchomp]

If Susie is not on this cast I will be confused

[@jamesg0725]

are you planning on continuing the amazing race retrospectives at some point?

[@OnceUponAnIsland]

I don't think he reads the comments. He is still using super low res versions of the Survivor logos when on past videos people have commented how he can easily get high res versions.

[@Chris-jk7yn]

@@OnceUponAnIsland omg hi I love your videos

[@OnceUponAnIsland]

@@Chris-jk7yn Thanks Chris!

[@guyfierimtwi]

@@OnceUponAnIsland i think he reads comments, but never replies.

[@moy9301]

@@OnceUponAnIsland I remember seeing him reply to a comment about how he shouldn't dream cast rodney. So I think he reads the comments, and will only reply if it's a serious issue.

[@JoeyDaPal]

I just wanna point out that the 5 winners on this list would break the record the most winners on a season of Survivor other than Winners At War. The only way it doesn't is if you stretch the definition by including that Boston Rob and Tyson would later win after Heroes vs Villains.

[@jeromegoh6293]

Also im shocked the girl who quit with purple kelly was gonna be there

[@chilltown5829]

NaOnka is my least favorite player EVER. In the history of Survivor. Ever

[@raeb4451]

Colby...Jeff ripped on him hard in Heroes vs. Villains lol

[@ChandlerTingle]

Jonny FairPlay recently got arrested for stealing from his grandmother

[@apecentury228]

yeah i don't think Fairplay is playing again. I mean he would have to sucker up to to Jeff big time, like, "Well Im a huge fan of yours, you know we hugged when I was voted out. Also, I would make great TV and get ratings." Even then though, Jeff may pass. However, I do see Russell playing again.

[@ShroobInvader]

I saw the first frame of the video, you should have edited the photo to make his smile upside down Also congrats on almost 7k

[@SB-jq8jj]

Haven't watched this yet but will be hilarious I bet. This could just be most of the quitters lol then add in people like Dan from WA and Dan from IOI

[@medmax5941]

I would actually watch this season

[@58twright]

It would be funny to see how pissed probst would be to see some of these people

[@Higgy8]

Really fun idea! That is really creative lol.

[@sssamui286]

I wouldn't put Brian on the list because of the fact that he's problematic, but other than that I could see why.

[@GrrumpyPants]

I want an all quitter season. All they need to do to win is not quit the longest!

[@regularperson7380]

Imagine if they all quit again

[@CbabyDavy5703]

@@regularperson7380 Colton definitely would 3/3

[@djspencer6498]

Here’s who I would but on Jeff’s nightmare casts Men Jeff Varner Brian Heidik Osten Taylor Jonny Fairplay Gary Stritesky Shannon Elkins Brandon Hantz Colton Cumbie Keith Sowell Dan Spilo Women Sue Hawk Julie Berry Janu Tornell Kathy Sleckman Dana Lambert Sarah Dawson NaOnka Mixon Kelly Shinn (Purple Kelly) Lindsey Oogle Julie McGee

[@gabihunter1749]

Will you discuss the merge boot edit and rank the and rank the premieres/finales?

[@survivoramazing9460]

Request: do a nightmare cast with Production

[@58twright]

I think it would be pretty similar to this

[@survivoramazing9460]

@@58twright it would

[@survivoramazing9460]

@@58twright but Production is different from what probst wants

[@B-Mag]

Im surprised that theres no mention of John Rocker from SJDS

[@crspwl1950]

I thought of Colton, then I was reminded of Brian, what a slime ball he is.

[@totaldramatyler4484]

This cast has some pretty great people. Jonny Fairplay is iconic, the public loves Courtney Yates, and Chris is my favorite winner of all time. Although I don't want to see douchebag's Dan Colton, and Shannon

[@philbox3productions]

This is such a unique theme and I love it

[@manarlazar3726]

Can you do who would jeff vote at the ftc

[@superraul6449]

I put this cast into a brantsteele and here the results: Pre-Jury 20th Brian 19th Vecepia 18th Natalie 17th Judd 16th Osten 15th Colten 14th Aras Jury 13th Courtney 12th Jonny Fairplay 11th Chris 10th Julie 9th J.P 8th Lydia 7th Shannon 6th Stacey 5th Kaite 4th Lisi Final 3 3rd Dan 2nd Dawnson 1st Purple Kelly

[@daltonfarris]

Dan (island of the idols), colton, osten, Fairplay, Brian heidick,

[@nickyes3072]

Did he film this before island of the idols? Dan is a shoo-in for his nightmare season

[@jakeyoung2696]

It makes me so sad that Probst dislikes Vecepia. I hate that probst has so much power. V was a fantastic player!

[@apecentury228]

maybe, but horrible TV.......dryer than sandpaper

[@chickenchicken9072]

@@apecentury228 no one cares

[@jacobwilliams1223]

But Survivor Gabon already exists.

[@coolnerdlll6053]

Can you do Phil Keoghan's dream and nightmare Amazing Race cast?

[@thebeardedwondercorbin8058]

Yes I second that

[@daltonfarris]

Morgan needs brought back for a returnee season...

[@Thesportsmusicgod]

Good video

[@ilhamari3351]

What about YOUR nightmare season?

[@helloh7158]

My way 20 Stacey Stillman 19 Judd Sergeant 18 Osten Taylor 17 Lydia Morales 16 Kelly Shinn 15 Dan Foley MERGE 14 Shannon Elkins 13 Lisi Linares 12 Julie Berry 11 Katie Hanson 10 Sarah Dawson 9 John Hilsabeck 8 Brian Heidik 7 Aras Baskauskas 6 Vecepia Towery 5 Chris Daughtery 4 Colton Cumbie FINALE 3 Courtney Yates 2 Natalie White 1 Jonny Fairplay

[@djflatline86]

What is the deal with Big Ted from Thailand besides the incident with Ghandia? It seemed at the time like a "he said, she said" is it now because of the Dan situation from s39? Or am I missing something??

[@piznoctsauo8141]

Courtney's in it?! An audience boost for sure!

[@owengette8089]

yOU BLOODY LEGEND

[@spenjaminn3846]

Jeff Probst: Dream vs. Nightmare Dream: Tyson Apostol, Spencer Bledsoe, John Cochran, Rob Mariano, Coach Wade, Sandra Diaz-Twine, Ciera Easton, Cirie Fields, Parvati Shallow, Kelley Wentworth Nightmare: Colton Cumbie, Jonny Fairplay, Dan Foley, Dan Spilo, Osten Taylor, Julie Berry, Kelly Shinn, Stacey Stillman, Vecepia Towery, Natalie White

[@LeboShu]

Here after watching the U. Drag Race Nightmare Cast

[@piznoctsauo8141]

Could you give your take on an "All Stars: Rats vs. Snakes" season?

[@sethrollins4230]

What’s an interview where Jeff talked negatively about Vecepia, I’m interested in seeing it

[@chwaftka9775]

You should do a video ranking survivor quitters/med evacs

[@rosiellagrace]

Moral of the story - Julie Berry ruined Survivor. Chris is a top ten winner, and all the surrounding circumstances are such bullshit. I still wish he'd have been on WAW; him, Yul, Denise and Danni were my preseason hopefuls.

[@gabrielcamilleri1193]

Not Julie's fault just probst's biases

[@rosiellagrace]

@@gabrielcamilleri1193 yeah, should have added /s after the first bit as it was just a joke, dude.

[@nizzle428]

he was a great player, but idk about top ten winner. yeah he overcame being outnumbered 6-1, but he put himself in that situation during the swap and early merge

[@rosiellagrace]

@@nizzle428 tbf, I don't really keep like, a dedicated ranking like a lotta the community.. I can appreciate different styles of play, but I do keep Chris pretty high, for me and overall, because I love the social manipulation. Sure, he got himself into it and I love watchin' people get themselves out of sticky situations, especially in the days without advantages or idols. Players like him, Brian Heidik, or Tommy I tend to enjoy a lot more than most people.. some days I'd say it'd be players like Parv, Sarah or Tom I'd throw into 'my top ten', I'm flexible.

[@jeromegoh6293]

I love courtney tho

[@LB-py8ls]

*This is gonna be fun...*

[@iddiolgames]

Me 1 second after this drops

[@thecaptainmlb]

Dan is likeable and needs to play again

[@lukassvoboda4107]

I think more then JP Jeff Hate Patrick (in HvHvH)

[@radicalswampert7980]

I want to see cast assessments

[@TheRobinBestia]

just say san juan del sur he really hated that season

[@francesca-selfproclaimed-bleep]

Put me on there and it would be the ultimate nightmare. I can't handle the outdoors for a prolonged period of time. 💗

[@rea7859]

But if you actually did great on this season, you would have the Cirie story arch of someone who got up of the couch, and Jeff would love you

[@francesca-selfproclaimed-bleep]

@@rea7859 PLSS, I can't even go hiking for an hour without wanting to go home or be in a restaurant.😭

[@mikeriggio9801]

Where is Shane Powers??

[@MusicNerdDavid]

Crystal from Gabon not even in consideration? Maybe also Scot from Kaoh Rong? Or Chris or Wendell in Ghost Island

[@nizzle428]

he liked wendell tho

[@bhaddie2586]

crystal is fantastic tv like naonka, so i don't think she would make it

[@58twright]

No probst & production loved Wendell

[@ralphie3086]

I think the main reason why Jeff didn't liked Chris or was annoyed by him is that All-Stars just happened (Rob/Amber showmance), and Chris tried to play the same game as Boston Rob in a way, which was kind of a repetitive storyline. Jeff was just annoyed with that repetitiveness imo

[@roweyurboat573]

Do the HvV cast redivided to BvBvB :)

[@Guitarfreak12345]

I'm surprised you didn't mention anything about John Rocker from an Juan Del Sur being that before he was on the season, he was the homophobic racist jerk and also seemed kinda hostile on there especially when Natalie confronted him directly and he said "If you were a man, I'd knock your teeth out" or something to that effect

[@lijenny6731]

You Should Replace Aras With Vytas Because Of The Prondressa Thing

[@lijenny6731]

and sherri