Causing a Doggone Injury

[@boriqua1222]

Douglas: "You're thinking awfully loud." 🤣 This show never fails to disappoint!

[@linkdx245]

Douglas is usually quiet and because of that I lost it 😂😂😂

[@seantimmons5900]

So it always disappoints? Or.. it never doesn't not fail to be the opposite of making one happy?

[@ec-kj4yp]

So many dog owners are just stupid and uncaring. HOW they could think they shouldn't pay every penny of that vet bill is beyond me.

[@FenderBender5150]

Oh, Come on they are just poor, poor victims of society. They cannot even afford a proper fence.

[@nneekaestelle4732]

I can't believe that's the best excuse the defendants came up with

[@alexckelly1]

Ahh, the ol' "My pallets fell over de-fence"!

[@antdogg5041]

People are incredibly stupid when it comes to their dog.

[@newsflash7609]

We don't have a fence, we put up pallets. Really?! Then don't have dogs. I guarantee this is not the first time her dogs went roaming. I also love the common response of "I was harassed" when someone doesn't take care of their responsibility. No, that's not harassment, that's just someone not willing to let you get away with crap.

[@saramichele7366]

💯💯💯

[@quarrynate153]

Couldn't of said it better myself. Well spoken 👍

[@MaverickMan77]

Exactly. People! Lol

[@chrispellicci6587]

Liberal Democrat thoughts

[@sufferedlearnedchanged]

Get out of here with all your logic and well reasoning. 😊

[@robynrutkowski1950]

"I need you to join me back on Planet Earth" lmao

[@saramichele7366]

The defendants are embarrassing and ridiculous. Get tf out of here. They take zero accountability or responsibility.

[@FenderBender5150]

Oh, Come on they are just poor, poor victims of society. They cannot even afford a proper fence.

[@shrutefarms4741]

Saw the defendants hair and knew without a shadow of a doubt….guilty!

[@AC081361]

That defendant should not have dogs

[@LoveNicolette.]

The defendant said she “ran”. 😂 Ummm, girl, you can’t even walk correctly, you definitely didn’t “run” anywhere, anytime!

[@eloahnon4952]

Imagine what that "run" looked like?! 😂

[@Pepper9873]

I don't understand how people don't realize that if you're dog is not under your control or on your property and it is involved in an altercation with an animal it's 100% your fault no matter if the other animal was "aggressive" or not.

[@aerotaken5357]

Exactly. Years ago a neighbor's dog (Chopper) attacked my dog (Rex) on our back deck. Had to sue her for vet bills & stuff. Her excuse was Chopper was trying to play & Rex growled at him. Yeah, it didn't fly - she had to pay for everything.

[@trekgirl65]

It is the same when they do not follow the leash laws and their dog attacks an elderly person or a child. They play I could not control my dog. Sad days in America.

[@The_Real_Mier]

@@trekgirl65The “My dog always stays with me”-Card

[@missy67]

Defendants have an excuse for everything. They actually blamed a pallet falling down as to why their dog got out ( not themselves) and they didn't pay because they didn't know how to get in touch with the plaintiff. You would think they could have obtained the contact information from the police that came that day, if they actually cared. They shouldn't be pet owners with attitudes like that.

[@whathappensinenugu]

They could've responded to the fb message..that's one way to get intouch with the plantiffs 😂

[@missy67]

@@whathappensinenugu True!

[@human_kittenz]

The look on her face when the judgement was rendered... such ignorance

[@mymonkey10]

Wow!!! I honestly can't stand how ignorant some dog owners are... I was at a hotel once with my two "yappy" dogs approaching the door to go inside... a man with a pitbull (muzzled and short leashed) was inside the vestibule... he cracked the door open and politely asked me if I would take my dogs around the corner so that he could bring his dog out to the backside of the building... I very much appreciated the awareness of his dogs possible reaction to my small dogs... I did, however, pick up my dogs before going around the corner, out of sight, before they exited... THAT is a responsible dog owner... IMO...

[@human_kittenz]

Very good opinion

[@mymonkey10]

@@human_kittenz His dog actually scared the 💩 out of me when he jumped against the glass door... The owner had a very short and tight grip on his dogs leash... Any conflict or problem was avoided... Judge Milian and Judge Judy always have so many dog attack cases, and I never want to be one of them...

[@MaverickMan77]

Yea and these are the dog owners we don’t see or hear about cause they aren’t on these shows 😂

[@mymonkey10]

@@MaverickMan77 Exactly... because they're responsible!!!

[@MusicTennis]

Yappy yorkies, bichons, malties, etc are signaling another dog to fight. Small dogs don't rationalize size difference and think they can beat a large dog. I train my clients using the "Cesar Milan" method. Tug the leash to the side and tell your dogs to be quiet. If they don't then bend down and go "hands on" and gently get the alpha dog to sit. If you address the "dominant" alpha dog in your pack it will automatically influence your other dogs to submit/be quiet AND influence any approaching dog to calm down. Results are immediate.

[@bjohnson1149]

The defendants are totally at fault. She's at a loss for words because she knows she's wrong for not having her dogs under control. Love JM's theory, we don't blame the animals we blame the humans. And on what planet does the defendant think pink hair looks good???

[@carriepriegel6477]

Planet Delusional, where the inhabitants are clueless and can't grasp the rationality life on Earth requires 💁

[@sashachitownvillegas6850]

exactly

[@christibarrick1768]

Grown ass woman with pink hair. But after hearing her, it doesn’t surprise me.

[@HorrorShow694]

I walk my dog aggressive dog on a 4 foot leash everyday. We've had her for 11 years. She became aggressive after being attacked twice by other dogs off leash. It's terrifying

[@josefwashere]

There’s a certain stigma that are attached to people who don’t take accountability for their actions and make up every excuse in the book to avoid penalties. I just leave it at that 😐 Glad the plaintiff won and hope her dog doesn’t have long term issues.

[@nerdalieisasleepyhead104]

This show did a service to dogs because they always show how important it is that you restrain your dog at all times!

[@noahbarrett4650]

My mothers dog was mauled by neighbors pit bull & died due to being bitten so many times he bled out. My mother called the law & dog warden but nothing was ever done about it. My state doesn’t have strict enough rules & regulations when it comes to animals & the community we live in doesn’t have any rules about keeping contained & on leash. It’s just crazy! It blowed my mind when plantiff said they didn’t send flowers or nothing. First time I’ve ever heard that said in here! I don’t think I would even expect flowers!?

[@ded66]

Judge: What's your stupid de-fense? Defendant: Those pallets are the-fence

[@shelberz1]

Thank you Doug. Trying(!) to teach the defendants.

[@frankvee]

I can’t believe this case went to trial. It’s obvious defendant was negligent.

[@navynick7307]

Yeah, her defense was weak. If u have dogs, u have to be the best at protecting everyone.

[@shannonking1096]

What is wrong with people outside that Harvey is talking to???? If a dog is OFF leash and not under your control it's your fault

[@shrutefarms4741]

What is wrong with Harvey asking stupid questions every episode getting stupid answers. Everyone would benefit if he would just. Stop!

[@HeatherWho11.10]

​@@shrutefarms4741he's not the one that writes the questions

[@marlaholmes6706]

Whether you have a fenced yard or not. It is not difficult to put the dog on a tether! That’s how mine go out. The tethers are just inside my door. Door does not open unless all 3 are on one! People need to be more responsible and careful!

[@anacondaadultlearningcente4522]

"Gosh, for some reason (that can't be predicted) a pallet fell down.

[@shannonking1096]

I always walk with pepper spray for this very reason

[@shellk71able]

Me too

[@EnzFab73]

People always make fun of the stereotypical CRAZY CAT LADY🙃which I always found unwarranted, but we need to consider calling out the CRAZY DOG PEOPLE because these dog owners are not only delusional in their logic, they're dangerous. Case after case after case, they make excuses for their precious doggie attacking another dog (or a person) & always refuse to take responsibility. And this is coming from a dog lover, we have 2 in our household. These cases always make my blood boil.

[@thistles]

Exactly! A roaming cat isn't going to eat a toddler. People are on notice with dogs with multiple bite histories, and they still act like their precious poochie wouldn't hurt a fly. It's sickening.

[@coachbobg]

What outstanding members of society.

[@mymobilebuddy4392]

NOT

[@DavesHangar1958]

Pallets? Really? If you can't afford to have a real fence built, then you can't afford to have a big dog like that!

[@kristyneknodel8395]

Well golly, I bet the pallets are real pertty too ! 🙄

[@ninosimone]

“ Yappy dogs “😂😂😂 the narrator is hilarious , we need a face to that voice .

[@traceyaz125]

That’s Kurt. He used to do the hallway interviews as well.

[@ninosimone]

Judge Judy said “ animal kingdom thing?”😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@tamekadavis6641]

The pet owners are always at fault.💯

[@PeopleRTheProblem]

“We don’t blame the dogs…..except when we put them down because they’re dangerous animals….i guess then we blame the dogs”

[@synnove1046]

Usually that happens when a person has been killed or severely injured. That’s why a dog owner who loves their dog should protect them by making sure they are always 100% under their control. Then they can’t kill or injure people, or even another dog. When someone is killed it’s pretty hard to argue in favor of keeping the guilty dog alive. If its’ owner wasn’t able to maintain control in the first place how will they ever be able to convince anyone that they will do so after a fatal dog attack?

[@fenrichvega6166]

This is one of those cases where a pet owner like the defendant shouldn't own a dog cause ignorant and irresponsible. Sheesh

[@jake_]

Why people think it is OK to allow their dogs to freely roam the streets. Are they stupid or something?

[@jennifernordhoff6478]

Thank goodness their dog is ok.

[@they-live1]

old woman with pink hair, not surprised she isnt taking responsibility at all

[@ryukiravenwing8530]

If you dont have a fence yet, even if the dog is generally friendly, you need to have them on leash until you get the fence up.

[@Tony_417]

Um duh. Did you just learn that?

[@ryukiravenwing8530]

@Tony_417 it was a common sense comment on the episode I was watching at the moment. So your rather rude response to a comment not in any way meant towards you was rather unwarranted.

[@Tony_417]

@@ryukiravenwing8530 sometimes you need to learn to edit yourself so you don’t make a fool of yourself. Here’s one: never touch hot stoves. Never leave children in hot cars also. I’m sure you can watch the Teletubbies and learn some more

[@synnove1046]

@@Tony_417No need to be a jerk about it.

[@synnove1046]

@@Tony_417Take your own advice: learn to edit yourself.

[@luispineda9255]

I hate people like this. I have 2 small dogs who aren't aggressive...but I still ALWAYS have them on a leash and I ask other dog owners if it's ok for them to play together. I would be devastated if my dog harmed any other dog.

[@snappingbrute02]

As soon as I heard "they admit their dog got out" I knew who was winning lol

[@Babyyoshi_]

She sounded as goofy as her hair color 🤣

[@tsunamicroissant444]

right 😂😂

[@st.gregory]

Defendants, slobs, physically, and responsibility wise, probably financial also

[@kitaboo2245]

Not him saying “can you STEP over here lol

[@carriepriegel6477]

Dog attack defendants, the usual : smug, apathetic, reckless & lazy @ dogs' containment...how can it possibly be their fault?? 🤦

[@jamesfetherston1190]

Love the hiking stick.

[@KayB-l5h]

The defendant is crazy. She came back to planet earth after the ruling. Over 2k floated her back to reality real fast.

[@zuritribe4844]

OH THE STUPIDITY IN THAT DEFENSE

[@josefwashere]

@4:14 This was the defendant’s attempt to try to get out of the responsibility by claiming she didn’t know how the make shift “fence” was down…..oh but wait for it.. @6:39 👩🏻‍⚖️ M. calls her out on her BS story to let her know that’s not gonna work 😂 Classic

[@Lillylilster]

The defendants will never get it. Is that a Wizzard staff.

[@LoveChild71]

It goes with that charm necklace with the ankh, heart and key - the one you get for free when you order the witch's tarot deck from your favorite psychic.

[@TheSharona10]

Irresponsible/delusional dog owners and the worst people. They set their dog up for failure then blame everyone else.

[@russianrobbie]

The only thing more indefensible than that defence, is the defendant's hair!

[@msfranklin2650]

TYPICAL LIARS THE DEFENDANT LOOKED & SOUNDED SOOOOO DAMN STUPID. MAKE IT HER BUSINESS TO FIND OUT SHE SHOULD'VE JUST PD NO QUESTIONS ASKED IF IT'S TO MUCH TO PAY @ ONCE DIVIDE IT BY {4} EVEN PYMTS BECAUSE NEITHER {1} OF THE DEFENDANTS ARE SKIPPING ANY MEALS / SNACKS GOOD CALL NOW PAY UP

[@GigiRulesTheRoost]

oh my goodness what losers. In court AND out. How embarrassing for them. wow.

[@happycamperproducts]

Why'd she bring a hiking stick to court XD

[@howardhudson9592]

Stop interrupting the plaintiff, JM! Lol

[@EliSeventhRose]

She said my man my man my man u go girl

[@alinaluna8615]

“Not eVeryOne loVes Lucy” 😅😂

[@Vv08991]

I cant believe she said that 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@vivoyeur]

That jacked up dye job must have really added to the cluelessness of her reasoning for her why she thought she should win the lawsuit. She had started to defend her reason for the pallets before Judge Milan interrupted her. I wish I could've heard what else she was going to say. I'm glad she lost. I hope the little doggie fully recovers.

[@mistergamerguy]

"we put up pallets".... Growing up my aunt had a pomeranian and a fenced in yard, and had a "zip line" installed from the porch to the back fence, and still put that dog on a lightweight line... only because the "gate" didn't latch! I agree with the judge. Then DONT have dogs if you cant contain them or cant put them on a leash!

[@thefonzkiss]

Defendants will have to buy less anime collectables and Domino’s pizza for a while to pay the money.

[@michaelrusso6822]

Liars. She said she ran after her dog, pulled the little dog out of her dog's mouth, offered to help, then told the grandpa to bring the dog to the vet. But she didn't give them her information, and says she didn't know who they were... or that the little dog went to the vet hospital until the police tracked them down.

[@punkgaopher]

"We have this janky, ghetto fence made out of pallets, and for some reason it didn't work?!?" -- Defendant.

[@sarahbarton4977]

Some people don’t deserve pets .

[@chrispellicci6587]

I got only ONE word LIBERALS

[@ronniecrop]

These people have a giant empty void behind those dim eyes! smh

[@firfuxsake]

Defendant could recoup some of her money by suing her hair stylist ... if she has one.

[@Mimi197-f2z]

Defendants should not have pets!! Very irresponsible!!!

[@JayJay-me8zk]

I love all PC episodes, but I definitely perk up when it is not ANOTHER dog case. OMG 😅

[@skyelersullivan7336]

Only here to point out he said “the dog came up behind me” as well as “I saw where the dog came from” so which is it? No one has eyes in the back of their head

[@lolamaude3449]

Oh brother! Defendants should not have animals. Of course you were harrassed, not! .Asking you to pay is not harrassing you, pay them!

[@KamiiiKam]

Yeah he definitely has a bad attitude lol 😂

[@sashabenoit1518]

You didn't know where they were or how to find them but they were hitting you up on Facebook...

[@evocharbonneau856]

You're going to be on national TV. People, get your done before appear. Have some pride in your appearance.

[@elvickRULES]

The defendants are absurd, and they want to act like victims over reasonable statements made by people their dog nearly killed 🙄

[@marystar6021]

I wonder why the defendant used / carried what looks like a long stick one might use for hiking?

[@nerdalieisasleepyhead104]

Labs aren’t known for being dog aggressive, having prey drive, or shaking its prey to death…

[@keithkemp3008]

Another case of people that should not have dogs !!

[@alyssapalmer1995]

Who also wants to bet that this wasn't the first time Lucy got out and attacked a neighbors pet/pets. And I also highly doubt Lucy is a "Lab" and most likely is a Pitbull along with the other dog from the same house. "Lucy is a sweet dog, and everyone just hates Lucy for no reason" I can't stand Pitbulls. A couple of my friend's cats, my grandpa, and my Grandpa's cat all of whome was on their own property was attacked by neighbors Pitbulls. My grandpa nearly escape the attacking Pitbull's jaws when it tried pushing it's way in to my grandparents house before my grandpa closed the door in it's face. Unfortunately all three cats 2 of my friends and my Grandpa's cat passed away. Attacking is in Pitbull's DNA just like a hunting dog will hunt and a herding dog will herd. Just because a Pitbull hasn't attacked before and seems sweet doesn't mean that it wouldn't one day turn and show it's true colors and what's in it's DNA. Pitbulls were breed to attack and bring down Bulls and then other animals and not breed as "nanny dogs".

[@oldageisdumb]

I’m sure it’s a lab as even the plaintiff’s think it’s a lab. If it was a pitty mix the plaintiff’s would be yelling it from the rooftops. I’m sorry you’re biased against pitties but labs actually have pretty high bite statistics. They are not as sweet as people think they are.

[@MusicTennis]

That's a great point. Also, in addition to a fence they need to walk their high energy Lab every morning for 30 minutes. After the walk they need to fulfill the 200 year old "retriever instinct" in it's DNA and have it chase/return a ball. Lucy is bored and escapes for exercise. She wants to retrieve a duck or pigeon.@@oldageisdumb

[@ree_ree]

Defendant totally didn't care

[@anastacia0189]

"no flowers or anything." give that man an oscar 😭

[@Widnu]

before I had heard a word I could adjudicate the woman with the purple hair guilty.

[@makaylabrooks8908]

Literally unacceptable dog owners and even then people should really take the time to off leash train there dogs so they don’t go after others and if you don’t have time simply get a dog that you can properly take care of instead of what you want

[@Ivy_4000]

“I need you to join me back on planet earth” because wtf did she say? That ACTUALLY made sense to her? 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@anacondaadultlearningcente4522]

What's with the stick?

[@wakeup-y3t]

they will never pay that,

[@oldageisdumb]

You’re right, because the show pays for the judgements

[@momoboolman8820]

THE DEFENDANTS HAIR AND DEFENSE IS RIDICULOUS!!!! NO FENCE WND PALLETS! ABSURD! 🤬

[@jennifermartin4631]

What turnip truck did the defendant fall off of

[@LeviAaronx]

FINALLY! A great title by Harvey! Love it! *not everybody loves Lucy * genius!!

[@jb3702]

What is up with the two first people on the street?! Just clueless.

[@dodgek5270]

If the dogs got out and got mugged by another dog on a leash. It's still the unleashed dogs fault because it should have never gotten out in the first place.

[@roxane7432]

I have a poodle/schnauzer mix and if a dog harmed my Lucille Ball, the owners would feel my wrath. I dont play fair either, when it comes to my fur baby

[@seantimmons5900]

On this episode of "why are we here?"

[@LeviAaronx]

Dumbest defendants ever

[@elzaaltmann]

An animal suffers yes, but not like people, they live by the day.

[@antdogg5041]

My dog got out. The end,it’s your fault 💯

[@kellll3420]

9:03 Not into the defendant’s smirk or her silly defense.

[@seanhallahan9176]

Asian chick on the street w Harvey looks good

[@ariannasantina]

blocking off your unfenced yard with a couple pallets and expecting them not to escape.... these people are kind of dumb,