Chainsaw Comparison: Husqvarna 455 Rancher vs. Stihl MS 271

#stihl #husqvarna #chainsaws
Two time-tested brands. Two 20-inch residential chainsaws. Which is right for you and your property?
In this video, we dive right in and compare the weight, power, and design intricacies that will help you answer this question. Remember, whichever way you go, you’ll want to make sure that you purchase through a dealer in your area so that you know exactly who is going to stand behind your new equipment and help you get the most out of it!
Have questions? Give us a call, 360-384-0799 or email [e-mail]
Subscribe to our channel to stay up to date on the latest and greatest, as well as the time-tested power equipment that will power your outdoors.
Follow us on Instagram for daily inspo! @carlsmower
/ carlsmower

[@toobeer]

One thing he did not mention is that the only place to buy most parts for the Sthil is at a dealer. With the Husky, parts are available from a number of different sources.

[@jshapiro34]

Lowes Home Depot ace manards Amazon etc. I got no discount or help from sthil dealer and I scored my 455 rancher on sale at Lowe’s with also military discount out the door with bar oil jug and pack of 2 stroke oil a gas jug and file and bar oil gun for 429.89 no joke and I’ve done zero maintenance on mine for 5 years now but will need a spark plug soon it keeps getting dirty

[@DB-oz2ki]

There are Sthil dealers all over. Sthil out performs all others.

[@mattthepolarbear]

Been at Ace for nearly 5 years, and personally selling Stihl for 4 years. Unfortunately best I can tell you is it all depends who you get. You might get someone who cares and wants to help or you might get someone who doesn't give a shit. Stihl products are great, same as Husky. There's a ton of KZbin videos comparing the two brands. Ultimately it comes down to you. Myself, personally, I'd go Stihl, but only cause I've been familiar with them the past several years. I know their machines like the back of my hand, know where to get parts, etc. Husky is probably just as good, I just prefer and know Stihl better

[@bobrees4363]

This is the first Husqvarna vs. Stihl comparison video I have seen that actually compares comparable saws, usually it is one homeowner version against the other brand's pro saw. Thank you for an apples to apples comparison. I think you hit the nail on the head with your recommendation of dealer support. Either company makes good saws. That being said, I have a 455 Rancher that I bought for $50 at a Sheriff's sale. I am predisposed towards Husqvarna's anyway, Dad ran a 61 for for years.

[@billduffack2817]

This comparison is thorough and, in my opinion, extremely well done. You touch on pretty much every aspect of both saws that might interest a customer without being overly technical. I use both husqvarna and stihl saws to collect firewood but I found your comparison here educational. Thank you taking the time.

[@Carlsmower]

Thanks Bill we appreciate your support and are glad we hit the high points.

[@tgsgardenmaintenance4627]

As a self employed gardener I don't really use chainsaws that much but I went for the 455 Rancher. Mostly used for firewood but occasionally taking down the odd tree, it does everything I need with ease, so a great purchase for me. Very happy with it!

[@Carlsmower]

Great size for your applications.

[@themodrocker1]

Thanks for the video! I learned a lot about the two. The amount of hardwood trees in my area is a major deciding factor. I can’t wait to go buy my farm boss!

[@dentondunn4346]

That's a great comparison video between the 2 saws. Best comparison I've seen yet

[@BillTheTractorMan]

We have been running Husqvarna on the farm for atleast 15yrs, probably longer. The dealer is a great family and every saw they have sold us has been great to own and get serviced or parts. They also sell the Stihl products and I've used them as well. Very comparable and reliable machines. I never thought the battle should have been Stihl vs Husqvarna. I've been in the woods with a lot of guys running the box store saws. Those saws and their owners need some serious help. They spend half the day working on them and the other half of the day loading the trailer while I get sore shoulders and back doing all the cutting. Proper and maintained tools are essential.

[@jamesf4244]

There is no difference in a box store 455 Rancher or a 455 Rancher from a dealer

[@BillTheTractorMan]

@jamesf4244 a dealer will have more models to pick from than the 3 a box store sells. My local dealer carries farm grade and pro grade saws. I have a farm grade saw and a professional grade saw. There is a big difference in quality, both are great saws but the prograde saw will last longer. Having a good dealer to buy parts is also really nice. The box store only carries the basics. The dealer carries parts like the recoil, clutch, handles, caps, etc.

[@michaelgibson5638]

Husq fan for life here! For bucking firewood in BC anyway. First saws i used were husqvarnas. My first saw i bought; 1974 pioneer p40 - great old saw! Heavy, but just takes some muscle to run it, seperates the men from the boys. I've bucked about 75k of firewood in the last 3 years. I used the stihl 291, 362, 462, and the 660 while employed at a mill and we were having to send in the saws all the time for servicing from overheating and worn out air filters not sealing right (saws were on their second/third year when i got to the mill). Bucking full time stihl would always overheat, and we actually burnt out the clutch on the 462. I myself own a new stihl ms250 (1 year old now) for camping and home, and some light bucking. and an old husqvarna 257(1996): the stihl feels like a toy. And the clutch and the chain brake in the outside rather than in body i find it to be a huge advantage for reliability, just slip the chain on the clutchside first. Anyone who think the stihl is easier are the type of people who eats ice cream cones instead of using a bowl and spoon because "it's easier" haha. Its not hard or a pain in the butt at all. Husqvarnas seem to be built to last; Compression release, adjustable oiler, higher quality plastic & material, (and air filter! I'd rathrr a metal pin or even a screw than plastic screw-on that wears out). Husqvarna 257 (57.9cc)comes in only a couple pounds heavier than the ms250 while being 12cc bigger, and roughly same body size! Stihls are made to be serviced. Only advantage is the marginal difference in weight in my opinion, for me reliabilty is much more important. Felling trees i do like to use my stihl, just because it is lighter and i usually have to hike to the tree. Stihl is capable enough, but does not seem to be built to work hard or for too long.

[@Carlsmower]

Good on you! If it’s right for you go Husqvarna!

[@applesbighatranch6906]

Holy Toledo, Ohio! This may well be the perfect KZbin product information vid. THANK YOU. I've been eyeballin' the 455 Rancher for some occasional firewood and road-clearing work. Not a professional, but a retired truck driver planning on some wilderness time. You, sir, are a credit to your business and profession. Thanks again.

[@ericduckett9247]

Purchased my first chainsaw when I was 16. It’s a husqvarna 340. I love it and still have it to this day. Since then I’ve also owned a couple stihl chainsaws, but have sold them. Twenty years later, I prefer the Husqvarna and have 3 currently, a 340, a 372, and a 455 rancher. Both are high quality, durable saws, but I prefer the chain system on the husqvarna. If you treat them right, they’ll last a lifetime. However, I do love my stihl kombi.

[@outdoorsnevada4138]

While an older video, I am sure many will see it later. My father was a timber cutter for nearly 10 years. During those years his father, brothers, and him all ran stihl chainsaws! Excellent reliable saws! He still uses them to this day 30+ years later! There were also those on the mountain that ran Husqvarnas! And the rivalry was real of which saw was superior and why! In the end though both brands rip and get the job done. The biggest factors though was the operators and how they maintained their saws and keeping them sharp. My father was a 3 star logger for his first few years and became a 5 star logger in later years with awards to prove it. Husqvarna operators were also 5 star loggers with awards to prove it! Find a saw that is comfortable to you and get proper instruction in how to be efficient and safe with your saw of choice!

[@davidashcraft8259]

I own 9 Stihl saws, a small Echo and an Echo pole saw. One of the Stihl is 25 years old and the small Echo is about that old. Looking forward to trying my first Husqvarna this year. A lot of it is like the Ford vs Chevy debate but I think dealer support is a big factor as well. Obviously I have worked on more Stihl than anything. They are all good saws. Thank you for the comparison, it was well done.

[@dangrimes5078]

I learned a lot. Have only owned Husqvarna and Echo but there are some good things I didn't know about with the Stihl.

[@truckercowboyrobertharris6787]

My dad and i have a Stihl MS 291 and a Stihl MS 180. Both are great chainsaws and my dad bought them both at are Stihl dealer called Centennial Lube in Grace Idaho. Same with our Stihl FS 56 RC trimmer and Toro Recycler lawn mowerower.

[@KASHAKA1]

One of the best comparison videos ive seen thus far! Great points!

[@tacman2893]

I prefer the 455 Husqvarna. I use mine on ranch and northern woods of Saskatchewan. Very good saw.

[@gradybaswell558]

I have never had or used a Stihl but I bought a Husqvarna 55 in 1998 and love it. Never a problem.

[@Carlsmower]

Great saw

[@donnyjohnson2229]

Excellent review. Thanks!

[@rodneysweetnam8653]

Hi Carl - it's Big Rodders in Ireland. I've just replaced my beloved Husky 365 with a Rancher 455 as due to my age I couldn't justify the extra cost of a new 565, plus the fact that that they now have autotune, which I detest. I bought a 555 with a 16inch bar & .335 chain five years ago and was very impressed with its very aggressive cutting ability and heneral agility when it fired up BUT it broke my heart either erratic starting, despite 2 trips to the shop and a new ignition module at $165. I pledged I will never buy another electronic carb saw. The Rancher 455 is listed here at $866US though I was lucky to get a deal at $733. You chaps across the pond don't realise how cheap you can buy equipment compared to us poor relatives this side of the pond!

[@Carlsmower]

We won’t complain about our prices. 😉

[@ciphercode2298]

I feel ya on the autotune design. I've got both stihl and husqvarna and my husqvarna 550xp just got its 2nd top end rebuild. It's a firecracker of a saw,but has always run hot. The piston I took out this time had blisters on it. I've never had that problem put of my stihls,even the mtronic ones. I'm sure it's not all of them,but that 550xp has left a sour taste in my mouth.

[@lasabras506]

Great video. Husqvarna has a dealer in my area so I go with that one. It is a pain in the back to get the pin on the right hole when adjusting the chain. Anyhow, there are both great saws.

[@Carlsmower]

Practice makes perfect. You will become a pro at installing the bar and chain. 😉 Enjoy the saw

[@dj-nr8nm]

Husqvarna fan here, good memories with the family running these saws, never an issue. I have used Stihl trimmers though which I really like. Just got an echo which I'm returning. The old ones were great, now they have plastic handles and overall much cheaper build - never again. Awesome comparison! I know some people that swear by Stihl.

[@Carlsmower]

Both are great units

[@c.saragian9502]

Great review! I have a 545 mark 2 and a 455 rancher and love both of them! I would love to get a Stihl as well. Both companies have great saws and are #1 and #2 as far as chainsaws go. I liked the honest review. Both have strengths and weaknesses. I love seeing a Stihl dealer say good things about their competitor's products. It shows me they have faith in their own products as they should cuz Stihl has excellent products.

[@Carlsmower]

That 545 is a sweet saw!

[@ranmangolf]

We used Stihl when I was in the Fire Service many years ago. Therefore, I am familiar with the saw and I like them. I purchased a homeowner version, the Wood Boss, and it has served me fairly good. I notice that saw dust can gather around the area where the oil cap is supposed to seal and it can't screw down properly, causing one to think that the threads are stripped. If you take a thin jig saw blade or something similar, and scape around the small area where sawdust gets trapped, the cap will go on tight and the seal works fine.

[@Patrick-uu5xg]

I went out on a hand crue with the BIA years ago and always wanted to go out as a signal resource sayor. What do you know about that? In already a Fire fighter 2.

[@ranmangolf]

@@Patrick-uu5xg Don't know anything about it.

[@mattmoore6795]

As a structural firefighter with a truck company and talking with many brothers from other departments none of us have ever seen a husky on a truck or rescue. When life and property are on the line Stihl baby!

[@mattmoore6795]

@@Patrick-uu5xg I'm a structural guy but my buddy's in Montana that only fight wildland some not all prefer husky

[@stevehardeman7209]

You sir,are an excellent instructor! I run several 271's no problem . They make me money . My servicing dealer is top notch. I tell everyone if there is no service dept you can't give me the eqpt.

[@UFRooster]

I went with the MS391, it does have the compression release and starts the third pull every time. I do think I should have spent the extra to go to the pro series but overall am happy with the saw.

[@robbiebaker2412]

I have 2 Husqvarna 345 saws. They are pretty good saws. Both are over 10 years old and still run fine. I have run a stihl saw that my friend owns as well. It is a great saw and is also over 10 years old. For someone like me who only uses a saw a few times per year I think either one is a good choice. My uncle was a logger who ran saws every day though and he preferred a stihl. The only stihl product I've ever owned personally was a weedeater. I think it was an fs90r? It was the best weedeater I've ever used. Unfortunately it was stolen several years ago so I've been using my dad's echo (also over 10 years old) but I will be buying another stihl weedeater the next time I need to buy one

[@stephenbrown5844]

Fantastic review my friend, best one I've seen yet, and funny enough i am after a new saw, at that range, but wasn't sure if i should buy husky or sthil,,,, which I've always bought 💪😀🤘🇬🇧now I'm thing still to stick with sthil ms271 looks good 😀👌stay safe and keep the excellent work up🇬🇧🇬🇧from England ❤️

[@mikescaffo4850]

I have a husqvarna 455 rancher and I absolutely love it

[@ChosenOne9387]

Good comparison, I love my Stihl MS 311, which has a compression valve 👍💪

[@joshuarains5650]

Great video, still don't know which 1 to buy

[@NotThatBob]

Late to the party but glad I watched this video. So I'm my 60's but I still get a lot done. I need a larger chainsaw And I really wanted the Husky. But I do agree with the statement on dealer support. So to that end I'll have to go with Stihl. What an amazing video. LOVED the breakdown for maintenance.

[@jakeschisler7525]

Now that i have seen the comparison between the two, i think I would stay with stihl. I have a 170 which at the time I bought was okay but now I want the 271. I had another stihl about 12 years ago and I used it one time and sold it cause I retired but for the life of me, i can't remember the number of it. My 170 I've changed the caps out 3 times and the gas one leaks and sometimes I use pliers to tighten it. The other one had the flip caps which I thought were good thing.

[@rajon25]

I bought the Husky because the Husqvarna dealer is less than a mile from my house. Thanks for making me feel better about that reason!

[@vapnut]

Great review and I have both of these saws, but when I have to grab one for a quick cutting situation, my go to saw is my Echo 440. It comes with a five uear homeowners warranty without stipulations attached and I can buy replacement parts anywhere.

[@jimmylarge1148]

Aren’t echo saw’s supposed to be just as good as Stihl or husky? Nobody talks abt echo. Japan makes the highest quality cars, and motorcycles that are the most reliable. Does echo fit into that category? Seems like the only place around me to get one is the depot tho so service might b an issue I suppose

[@ALL4SCUBA05]

@@jimmylarge1148 I have all 3 brands. Echo is my most reliable. ALWAYS starts quick. Never needed repairs. And it happens to be my oldest saw. We used them in my fire department.

[@lorriehiner4049]

Thanks for your extremely thorough and helpful comparison. Seriously…Ive been doing some intense research for my first real chainsaw investment for almost a year and I don’t know how I ve missed you. You covered everything I needed to know! Internal clutch/brake over external. (Husky Men?) doesn’t the external clutch get all gunked up with bar oil and sawdust? Having a larger surface area locking air filter instead of a tool needing, tiny one is a no brainer...no wonder they’re concerned about the clutch causing heat. Big nuts. They’re more important than you’d think the older you get. And the most important mitigating factor that not a single soul on the internet has ever thought to tell me, if Im cutting hardwood, its gotta be the Stihl. Which Stihl (or other brand) would you recommend for felling and bucking, that also has enough hp and versatiity of bar size to use with a chainsaw mill? MS391 comes to mind. Just thought I’d pick your brain.

[@Carlsmower]

Sorry for the delayed response. If you are thinking about a mill there is a lot to consider. How large of slabs are you thinking/dreaming of? Remember once you get into it you will always want to get bigger :) I would recommend a 70cc at minimum for a mill. Check out the MS462 its weight vs the 391 it weight a bit less and has 1.6 more HP. You will be much happier milling with that saw.

[@halfdollar86]

This is an extremely good presentation.

[@stantilton2191]

This is a very thorough and helpful comparison, thank you and well done! I've had a 625 Jonsered version 2 for about 35 years. I've never owned an inboard clutch saw and I'll buy the stihl this time. It'll outlast me I think. I like the features on the saw and the price point is about the same.

[@Carlsmower]

Can’t wait to hear how much you love it. It’s a bit smaller than your Jonsered.

[@monti409]

You didn’t go into the adjustable oiler on the Husqvarna, I have a 450e and just started to learn using it, also do you have a website to place orders. Thank you

[@dentondunn4346]

My new 271 Farm Boss burps on 2nd pull everytime on full choke and always starts on 1st pull on half choke every single time. So from a cold start it starts on 3rd pull everytime and after warmed up starts 1st pull every single time. I love the the Farm Boss and worth every penny I paid for it. Cuts great with little to no effort. Great choice in a new daw

[@Carlsmower]

You’ve got that thing figured out. Enjoy that awesome chainsaw.

[@johnwashingtoncountyor4954]

Well done. Enjoyed the video. I own/run a mix of both brands for different purposes around the homestead. I really don't have any brand preference.

[@Carlsmower]

What is your go to saw?

[@johnwashingtoncountyor4954]

My go to is a Jonsered CS-2258. My others are a Husqvarna 455 Rancher and a Stihl MS 362 pro.

[@dkat1108]

WOW great video the only thing stopping me from getting the Stihl is that "start rope pull" that looks like a real pain in the shoulder way to start a chainsaw especially if your having problems with it starting.

[@jtschwinghammer]

Great comparison video! I appreciate that you go through both with no bias towards one or the other! I decided to go with Stihl because I have a dealer network that I trust and plus they had a discount going on when I bought my saw.

[@carlsmowerandsaw]

Thanks for the feedback enjoy your Stihl

[@carlsmowerandsaw]

Thanks for the feedback

[@clover8183]

I have the ms 271 and really like it. I now want the husky 572 xp but don't have a need for it, I just want it. I love chainsaws.

[@primeenforcer177]

I've used my 455 Rancher for several years mainly for firewood with zero issues. The Stihl is a great choice as well. It really comes down to maintaining them.keep them serviceable and you shouldn't have problems

[@ni1469]

I’ve got a 455 rancher and a 391 Stihl. I’ve had the 455 for 13 years now and ran the original plug for 10 of them. I like the husqvarna better than the Stihl but I haven’t gotten rid of the Stihl either so it’s not a bad saw at all. I run identical Stihl 20” chains on both saws and have a 441 Stihl running a 36” bar that I’ve ran for 8 years now. Both brands make good saws I lean more towards husky but I very much like the tractor dealer I’ve bought farm equipment and both stihls through. The local husky dealer near me is also great to work with. I’ve had to get the 441 warrantied once and that was handled well by the dealer. All in all both brands are great and really seem to come down to preference

[@josephbucci3749]

Great review. Both will last a lifetime if properly maintained, which is easier to do with the Stihl even without a dealer nearby (mine’s only 10 minutes away so I’m lucky there). The big differences between these saws are the internals. The Stihl’s motor is better built and uses 2 piston rings to the husky’s one. Big dif? No but does provide for better compression over time and oil swipe. Also stihl has much better low end torque while husky has more top end so it will cut faster at speed but the stihl will power through on tough cuts better with less bogging down. You really can’t go wrong with either.

[@Carlsmower]

Good point

[@bobbyhempel1513]

Do you have any statistics that back up your claim that Stihl has a better engine? In my experience is a small engine mechanic I would have to disagree. Also there are double ring Pistons available for Husqvarna chainsaws. Service on both steel and Husqvarna are almost identical in terms of difficulty. I can order OEM parts direct from the manufacturer for a Husqvarna at a much lower cost.

[@FargoNDRoland]

Good points. Still have my 25 year old husky that just simply works

[@garyweaver6985]

I just purchased a husqvarna 455 it’s an amazing saw, way better than the saw I had before which was a echo I’m not sure what the number was but i had a lot of problems with it, so now I should be set for awhile, the husqvarna dealer is 20 minutes from my house.

[@SpynCycle57]

I think it comes down to "Buy the dealer". Find a good dealer with a good service department that is convenient to you, and buy the brand saw they sell. If both are available, then you can't go wrong.

[@xdude2x]

Have had my ms290 for 20 years, it’s been bulletproof

[@rwr2643]

great review , i run both husky and stihl ,it's like apples and oranges or ford and chevy, i find stihl's a little easier to work on , husky's seem to cut a little faster in general , out of the 7 saw i run .my fav are the stihl 044 mag and the 562 xp husky . Thanks again for the best chainsaw review on you tube

[@carlsmowerandsaw]

Thank you for the feedback

[@johncasey4077]

I am thinking of getting a stihl chainsaw because the timber is impossible to cut with a hatchet would one with a small chain be ideal what do you think

[@ArlynEmrys]

good comparison. I noticed many design items used in Craftsman & Poulon saws are direct from Husqvarna, but Husqvarna is using better materials in things like the chain cover.. where the knock-offs are virtually unreinforced plastic. only able to see this due to your disassembly of both units side by side. & my experience with those other saws.. which in the later name, never ends well for me.

[@philipraymond8377]

I believe the reason for an adjustable bar oil is for two reasons and it’s not to save on oil, but you can adjust the oil to help you depending on what type of wood you are cutting not to mention in cold-weather bar oil flow as good so you can increase The oil Flow in order not to burn up your bar

[@rball690]

Just today I added a 455 Rancher to my collection. Bigger than my others which are Poulan's 5020 & 3314 and Stihl MS 170 and a Husqvarna 235.

[@RaysDad]

I bought my Stihl Farm Boss 16 years ago and it's been very reliable. It still has the original spark plug. But I have changed the 20" bar a few times. My saw always requires more than 3 priming pulls. Although I only cut about 4-5 cords of firewood per year several professional loggers in my area use a Farm Boss daily for bucking out big softwoods like Doug Fir, Spruce and Redwoods. I mainly cut Alder, Pepperwood, White Fir, and Bigleaf Maple. About one in three people in my area use Huskies, which is their right as Americans I suppose. The rest use Stihls. I have a Husky lawn mower that I keep only because it has a Honda engine -- The rest of the mower is made by Husqvarna and it's not well-designed or well-made.

[@xeverettx2564]

Great Video dude!! I’ve always ran STIHL but I’m currently looking at Husqy. Prob 455 for around the property so my kids and dad will have a manageable saw but I’d like to pick up a 372xp for myself. I feel if you’re a saw man little things like gas cap and stuff aren’t really a concern. Maybe for John and Jane homeowner but for serious work I want Power and in my opinion you get more power for the money with Husq! Not that STIHL hasn’t and continues to make some great saws. I have a AV066 and an MS250 and have no complaints but now that I’m getting into serious work I talked to my cousin and when he had his company it was all Husqy. He said listen Everett do me a favor just try a husky and if you like it I’ll buy you the 455. So of course I couldn’t turn that down. Side not though any fans of the vintage McCulloch 125C?

[@m998hmmwv7]

I like the husqvarna because of the thicker chain and gas bulb. The other one not so much. My favorite is my McCulloch I had it since 1984

[@roscoebean5995]

Just bought a ms271 a few months ago, a buddy has a 455, after using both of them they perform very similarly, aside from the primer on the husky im partial to the stihl

[@dentondunn4346]

Which one cuts faster and starts better? Say you're partial to the Stihl?

[@ciphercode2298]

@@dentondunn4346 They both start within 3 or 4 pulls,and cut time is pretty well even. I've always disliked husqvarna's outboard clutch,but otherwise they're nice saws.

[@IJLook]

The Makita 5600F is similar to the ms271/455Rancher and had had captured bar nuts and duel spikes and in board clutch and the chain tensioner is on the saw like the Stihl for the same price range

[@chuckmccollim]

Great info

[@jimp7181]

Thanks for the review! My Stihl 180 failed because the control lever on the choke mechanism failed. It was a crazy way to lose a saw, but it couldn't be repaired for a reasonable amount of money, totaling the unit. This makes me want to abandon Stihl on principle, but there's less nonsense with operation as compared to the Husky. I contemplating the 460 and the 311.

[@gunterbecker8528]

I have a 180 n 251 they serve me well! U must've done something wrong with the 180 I've got no problems with mine n work it hard as well

[@bobbyhempel1513]

What nonsense are you referring to when operating a Husqvarna? They're simpler and easier to use than any power saw I've ever used.

[@leethaow4170]

Very interesting

[@bertb8900]

One of the best comparisons I've seen between both great saws. I recently owned each, but took the Husky back. The Husky had a problem I've never had with my Stihl. I was cutting on a felled large red oak on a funky hill. Difficult to not pinch the bar sometimes due to gravity. Three times the Husky bar when pinched, bent in the bar grooves and locked the chain. Had to take off the chain and open the grooves up with a screwdriver. Only had half the tree done and exchanged for a Stihl MS271. The bar still got pinched a few times, but never locked-up once. To me, Stihl wins the bar strength contest hands down.

[@Sudz1911]

I'd buy from you. I wish I hadn't already picked up a saw

[@Patriot-Logic]

Love carls shops! Carls cycle and saw shop in Boise ID ! Legends

[@bigjoe4030]

I like the flip top caps

[@mas3ymd]

This is a fantastic video. No long-winded bullshit. Just a quick assessment of each chainsaw and its functionality for real consumers and a useful comparison with its chief competitor. Very nicely done. Any possibility of reviewing Stihl abd Husqvarna electric chainsaws?

[@henryalvares7672]

very well done , the reason that a have 455 is because friend of mine "gave it " to me, nice saw next time i am gone ask for a 362 ja

[@dominicmogridge3920]

used saws for 37yrs and more.full on and I've ended up using huskys.matter of opinion.once stink started using electric assisted start I gave up on them.can fix my husky in the woods with basic tools.the stihls,I gotta track back and dig specialist tools out of the van.thanks for the info my friend but I find husky easier to fix/maintain with tools on my harness and customer support has looked after me quicker and better.understand your talking about part time(non prof saws too.I'll stick with the husky anyday. stay safe and lucky.maddog.full time tree worker.West cork.eirw

[@lovestihlquality1369]

Many Husqvarnas have inboard clutch which is a little pita. I have a Stihl 020T top handle with has inboard clutch so yeah that is a little pain.

[@mikeveine]

I have both saws. I also have a Stihl 29. Both Stihls alway take 10 to 12 pulls when they are cold. The 455 only takes two pulls.

[@guygeaudreau4612]

I love my 455 rancher Husqvarna

[@carlsmowerandsaw]

What is your favorite thing about it.

[@paulraymondstamp4111]

The bar tensioning pin on the inside makes assembly more positive

[@Carlsmower]

At least way easier to get the bar on

[@mrpboddy6015]

That clutch, brake and tensioner system is a deal breaker. I had to put a chain on one the other day and I felt like throwing it over my shoulder. Stihl is a much better system especially when using it several times a day.

[@jeffcarinda1719]

Why is it difficult to start a warm saw after refueling a new MS 261?

[@user-nx8vp5sy5d]

Husky decompression valve last a yr, dealer replaced it with a bolt. Priming pump has to be replaced on average every 2 yrs. never made sense why they added unnecessary things to a saw that failed regularly

[@leethaow4170]

I like Stihl

[@dentondunn4346]

Which saw is more recommended because I bought the 271 Farm Boss but also considered purchasing the 455 Rancher but even though the Rancher is supposed to be a more efficient saw for cutting I preferred the the Sthil myself due to the name and the advice giving to me by local people that uses both saws.

[@Carlsmower]

I’d say you made a great decision.

[@dentondunn4346]

I choose the 271 Farm Boss

[@mikeyspeeds1056]

The Echo 590 Timber Wolf at the same price point seems to be the winner overall if you look up the reviews. Larger engine means more weight is the only downfall.

[@Ecksterphono]

Awesome

[@ciphercode2298]

It seems odd to me that with this series of saw the husqvarna has a deco valve,but the stihl doesn't. However, on their pro saw equivalent it's the opposite. The ms261c has a deco valve,but the 550xp doesn't 🤔

[@Carlsmower]

It is head scratching

[@woodspirit98]

Used to cut 100 facordd a year using a stihl farmboss and a husqvarna both. The husky was smaller but would scream thru logs and was lighter. But I used that stihl for over 30 years. Have to replace it today. The Husqvarna is 100 dollars more and a little bit heavier so I'm going to stay with stihl.

[@donz8501]

EY there chainsaw cutting friend... Can you tell me wich Husky is comparable with the Stihl ms 231? Hope to hear from you soon. 💪👍

[@06m50blue]

For the price of the 455, which is $499 where I live, I would step up to the Stihl MS 291. Only $10 more than the Husky and more horsepower.

[@Carlsmower]

Can’t argue with that 😀

[@rhk9992]

Just a personal experience, bought the husky and I’ve had trouble keeping it running from day 1. Followed starting instructions use husky fuel, husky bar oil, it burnt up the clutch after 8 hours of work had to get it fixed still doesn’t stay running.

[@joeparker7508]

Do you have a solution for ,ms 210 leaks chain oil all into case .

[@M5tworude]

I prefer Husqvarna because it starts easier and I think that they are better built, I own both. I live 80 miles from the nearest road in Alaska, my saws are important! I really dislike the Stihl choke switch, and that it doesn't have a priming bulb. On the battery saws I absolutely love our MSA 200c since I don't have to start it in the winter, the saw isn't a toy.

[@SkiddingF350]

I have a 455 and it's been good for me. Kind of a pain to start sometimes but I'm getting used to it. Great comparison. I never knew some of the major differences. Thanks for this review!!!

[@Carlsmower]

Thanks for the feedback and so glad to hear the 455 is treating you right!

[@bobbyhempel1513]

The 455 rancher is one of the easiest chainsaws to start ever. If you follow the directions on the saw you can start it in two to three pulls every single time unless you do not maintain your equipment.

[@aksourdough4890]

Another consideration: much easier to access Husky parts from non-dealer sources than Stihl.

[@paulsherrod1365]

Where does the weight difference come from (cylinder wall)?

[@joryclouthier]

I've also herd you need a special tool to remove the husqvarna clutch

[@justindavis7564]

Purchased my Stihl MS271 yesterday, 2 year warranty off the shelf, extended to 4 years after my 6pk purchase of oil. Maybe this was recently changed. Purchased at Ace Hardware. Love this saw, cuts with ease!

[@Carlsmower]

For your sake I hope your local hardware store found a way to get chainsaws a 4 year warranty. My thought is they are unfortunately mistaken. Here is a link to Stihl’s warranty policy. m.stihlusa.com/information/warranty-service-info/limited-warranty/ Either way it’s a great saw. And any failure past 2 years is generally self inflicted. Not a manufacturer defect.

[@dentondunn4346]

Just bought a 271 Farm boss last week and after purchasing the 6pack of 2 stroke oil it extended my warranty from 1 years to 2 years thought Huskys warranty was 2 years and 4 years after purchasing the 6 pack of 2 stroke oil.

[@06m50blue]

@@dentondunn4346 you are correct.

[@j.chrisbeck7492]

1 year warranty. 2 years if one buys the Stihl Ultra 6pack.

[@barrysensing7672]

Have a Stihl MS 290 for years, great saw, no problems. Never owned a Husky.

[@Carlsmower]

If you are a man of Stihl stick with it.

[@mitchellcrager9933]

My Husqvarna always takes 3 pulls but always starts on the 3rd pull. But after she is warm it's 1 pull every time!!

[@williamhartsell6390]

Should compared a 291

[@mrzooner]

Thank you! I've spent hours researching which direction to go. After 45 years living in suburbia, moved to the backwoods of WV 2 years ago. Bought an echo and it successfully fell 20+ trees. It's underpowered and poorly designed. Needed a new one and you answered every question I had. Thank you!,

[@ed-net]

Great job👏👏☝☝

[@markbryant5724]

Ok, but I worked in logging for 25 years. I can hands down tell you something he didn't mention. A Husky has a tendency to cut off when not in use. It's cold natured. A Stihl once it has been ran a while ,you can sit it down for 10 minutes and go back and it will crank w/o choking. I've used both a lot but if you don't buy a pro you're buying junk.

[@DarkSim77]

Totally shallow but I went with the Stihl just because of the name.."Farm Boss" sounded cooler to me than "Rancher"..

[@Carlsmower]

The name says it all!

[@ericcarter2533]

Jonsered ,Shindaiwa, or Redmax have been good to me