Chandrayaan-3: India reached the Moon. Where’s Pakistan? | Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy

[@anujay81]

Majority of Scientists and Engineers in ISRO are non-IITians.

[@shanmukhappamuttagi5310]

Prof.for your information, ISRO responded to Right to Information Act query, that it has only 2% IIT and NIT products. This shows ordinary engineering college products have achieved this feat.IIT,NIT products mainly they go abroad or join private sector to earn more money.

[@MrKinu30]

Respected Sir the difference can be seen here in this hall where not even 50 people gathered to listen to scientific rationale,had it been an Islamic sermon millions would gather as we see in TLP Rallies........loads of respect to your efforts from India......

[@tqm790]

Sir why are you stuck on Mughals?? Seems that's the reason why Pakistan never progressed. Your history started before Mughals but somehow you feel you from turks or arabs..

[@dineshshetty875]

99.99% viewers are Indian🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳.... Which answers the condition of "SUPARCO"

[@samip3124]

Funny thing is 95% your audience is Indians that's shows situation of Pakistan 😂

[@codewithovi997]

A sad reality

[@rajeevganeshgarh]

The list of major companies who supplied equipments to ISRO for the Chandrayaan-3 mission :- *Tata Advanced Systems *Larsen & Tubro *Godrej Aerospace *Hindustan Aeronautics *Bharat Electronics *MTAR Technologies *Bharat heavy electricals Ltd *Mishra Dhantu Nigam *Omnipresent Robotic Technologies Ltd *Centum Electronics *Walchandnagar Industries *Taneja Aerospace *Semiconductor Laboratory (SCL) *KELTON *Kerala Minerals and Metals *Kortas Industries Pvt Ltd *ElectroSteel Castings *Ankit Aerospace *Paras Defence & Space Tech *Venkateswara Aerospace *Ananth Tech *Kineco Kaman *Vajra Rubber Products *Uma Polymers *Mysore Polymers (Total space startup in 🇮🇳 - 140)

[@shivashukla354]

Definition of scientist in ancient India was Rishis. Kanad rishi established the foundation of partical theory. Varah mihir founded theory of spherical astronomy, Aryabhatta founded theory of mathematical as well as spherical astronomy, Charak and Shushrut founded theory of biological and medical concepts including surgery etc. Please watch the video of ISRO chairman S Somnath when he opined recently in Bhopal University.

[@bamar200]

Professor, just to let you know that Indians had mastered engineering centuries before foreigners came to India! The ancient temples of India are a standing testimony to our civilisational knowledge and skills in science and technology.

[@sumandas8979]

1)Stop going madarasa, 2) stop doing jihad, 3)protect minorities, 4) do respect other religions, 5)stop thinking yourself superior, 6) study true history.. and then you people think about scientific achievements 😊

[@premprasad3511]

I have been following Hoodbhoy's writings and talks for over 20 years now and srongly differ with him and even regard him sometimes as a ill-informed about Hindutva and the Hindus, but I must admit his purpose and intent are honest and extrordinarily courageous

[@JD_Rockets]

Major #ISRO missions in few years 🙏 1) Mars(orbiter or rover work in progress) 2)Venus orbiter mission 3)Aditya L1 mission (to 🌞) next week 4) Gaganyaan mission (3 indians will go to space using indigenous technology) 5)LUPEX (Chandrayaan 4)🇮🇳🇯🇵

[@AA12434]

May godess sarawati enlighten us with knowledge and wisdom for betterment of humanity.

[@orunabho]

The central consciousness of indic civilization is knowledge, not submission to ideology of books.

[@shanmugasuntharamsankarali8108]

Small correction: first country to land on South pole (not fourth country)

[@glorytitangamers2781]

Let me tell you in a moment that our rocket is made by ourselves, its engine is made by us, its satellite is made in India, its rover is made in India, I smell burning in your way of understanding.Let me tell you that you are explaining in an allegorical manner and telling India in such a way that all this technology has been given by others, anyone can do it.Landed on Dakshini dhruv, we reached it first on Mars already in Attempt, the way you are telling that 4 countries have gone before this but you did not tell that India is the first country which landed on the south pole of the moon That's why we are celebrating, you are telling that it is a very small thing, it is not a big deal, you have not uprooted anything till date, whatever you have done, you have done it on the basis of China and we have done all our space missions ourselves.

[@anupamkumarsingh8829]

Since Antiquity... Ancient Indian systems... Rishis,Munis,Vedas,Upnishads and Gurukuls were never anti science...but rather many of them were technically very much advanced.. For example.. Charak.Sushruta Aryabhatta and many many more...

[@bibhutidash350]

Professor sir, with all respect I would like to introduce an Indian MAHARSHI, Shankaracharya of Puri who has vast knowledge of mathematics and physics. Pls go through his lectures and you can find a smooth transition of spirituality and science.

[@SaurabhKumar-ej5kw]

With all due respect ancient Indian Science was extremely advanced ..kindly check abt Aryabhatta , Bhaskara, Varahamihira..etc...Arab traders spread this knowledge to Europe that sparked rennaissane..

[@RavindraKamath55]

Majority of scientists in ISRO are from IISc and post graduates...I have 5 classmates from our class of 16 PCM and graduates from NIT Suratkal...

[@Indus720]

When Kashmir Fatah, Jihaad and Sponsoring terrorism is main focus so why this discussion and comparison.

[@nishpakshagupta8331]

Inka kul mila ke ye kahna tha ki Bharat ne koi badi top nahi maari. Agar inke yaha engineer aa jaye to 75 million dollar aa jaye to ye bhi kar denge. Japanese astroid se sample to le aye lekin vo bhi aaj tak moon landing nahi kar sake. Aur agar distance factor hata de to moon landing, mars landing se jyada kathin hai. Kyoki mars par land karne ke liye aap parachute use kar sakte hai, par moon par nahi. Moon par to apko controlled thrust se hi land karna hoga. Khair jaisi jiski soch😢

[@shivuputta]

Professor, one intellect from Pakistan had visited to Bengaluru by name Dr Ishtiaq Ahmad recently and he was shocked to see 20 lakh engineers are employed in MNCs. And more number of quality engineering college in one city outnumbered entire pakistan. All big laboratories like astro physics, ISRO, BEL, BHEL, BEML, etc in Bengaluru.

[@shashwattripathi4559]

Just a tiny correction sir since you mention this metric again and again, Indian software exports in FY23 was 320 billion USD.

[@pspsdan]

How could you forget Sir J. C. Bose ? the father of Modern Indian Science ?

[@sunala1265]

*Current Chairman of "Suparco" is Major General Amer Nadeem Hi from Pakistan Army whereas chairman of "ISRO" is S. Somanath a Aeronautical Engineer from Indian Space Sector* *For period 2006-23* *Chairman of Suparco were Major General from Army* *whereas, All Chairman of ISRO were experts / Scientist from Space Sector since foundation of ISRO* 😂😅🤣

[@dharmascan]

SN Bose was a teacher in Dacca University when he contacted Einstein. The same Einstein didn't agree with Chandrasekhar contribution. MN Saha was senior to SN Bose.

[@RavindraKamath55]

Chandrasekhar was not from Pakistani area it was Har Gobind Khurana...please be precise...

[@orunabho]

Beyond the engineering, it is deep knowledge of astronomy and mathematics and the laws of physics. Precision is the key here.

[@baazinews1027]

Mars Helicopter sent By NASA was also Designed and Engineered by an Indian Hindu Scientist. 🥰

[@experimentnation3612]

Pakistani sitting there are like we just want to go to sleep just let us go 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@srinivasanranganathan7159]

Where ignorance is bliss, wisdom is a liability. Where intolerance is fanned, reasoning is a liability. Where beggary is unabashed, self respect is a liability. Where false narratives are habitual, trust is a liability. Where religious extremism is piety science and technology is a liability. Finally, where desperation is palpable, isolation is a reality. I am an IITian myself and the most important thing that I understood is that to excel you need passion and self confidence, clarity and an unwavering focus.

[@sameervarpe1052]

First time I thought Sir downplayed what India did, sounds like, not like big deal. But still like listening to him

[@arungupta3509]

INCOSPAR - The Indian National Committee for Space Research was founded in February 1962. TERLS - Thumba Equatorial Rocket Launching Station was founded in 1963, in Trivandrum, Kerala, and like with SUPARCO, the first rockets were sounding rockets. The first launch was in November 1963. At 8 degrees north of the geographic equator, TERLS is at a prime spot to study the ionosphere near the magnetic equator. Around 1965, India decided to develop its own launch vehicles, and the SSTC - Space Science and Technology Center - was formed in Trivandrum. The apex body for space research started with the Department of Atomic Energy, moved to PRL (Physical Research Labs) and ultimately in 1968, ISRO - the Indian Space Research Organization was formed. Dr Hoodbhoy confuses the apex body with the constituents. Pakistan, if it ever had a lead, is at most of a few months.

[@Robert_austia]

Here yogi are more educated then your foreign minister and army staff 😂😂

[@rajneeshsharma9049]

Indian women started wearing Burqa post the advent of Islam. 😊

[@mc7685]

Indian culture and civilization has been one of inquiries. asking questions. Indians are rooted in their civilization yet changing with time.

[@sarangib]

Some correction - Most lunar missions, so far, targeted lunar equatorial region, not North polar region. Chandrayaan 3 landed in South polar region. Latest Russian mission failed at deorbiting phase while Chandrayaan 2 failed at fine braking phase.

[@Safarnamabysid]

Prof you made a mistake of keeping Madarsa chaap Maulanas and Maharishis at the same level…While there is sky high difference between both of them…We had maharishi charak(Father of Medicine(Ayurveda)), Maharishi Sushruta(Founding father of surgery in india) he had tools to do surgery inspired from nature…we had Aryabhatta (who invented zero) and many more such people.

[@ManyataGajare2503]

Chandrayaan 3 has its unique engineering and scientific importance for India and India never downgraded other missions while comparing it with Chanrdayan 3.

[@MuhammadUsman-nz8pv]

So disappointed in level of questions. Black hole deserves much informed audience. May be open it online ,,,,

[@aashirashrafi275]

There's lots of Muslim scientist and engineers in Isro too not only Muslims but from all religions in India people are there but its matter of good education nd opportunities.

[@Kochhaak]

I had the very doubtful privilege of supervising two Suparco sponsored Ph D research students. I only accepted them because they were sponsored by the Pakistani Government. They had no idea about what is involved in undertaking research. Nor could they put together more than 2 sentences of English. In spite of detailed supervision on a day to day basis and help with the writing of the thesis it took them more than 6 years to submit their theses. Both of them were the worst students I supervised during my academic career.

[@experimentnation3612]

Hoodboy doesn’t know that india has also gone to Mars 😂😂

[@THUGSofMUKHARJEE_NAGAR]

Shakil Chaudhary sahab ko dekh ke Khushi hoti hai, unka critical patriot achha hai

[@premprasad3511]

Burka was not a common practice in India - never. It was forced on the Hindus due to ruthless islamic invasions. In fact Indian women occupied a higher status than men as the presiding deity of vedanta (the highest spiritual form of Hinduism is goddess , not god; ). This does not mean that women always had it that easy. Islamic invaders made Hindus realign their parctices to what is acceptable to ruthless islamic rulers ! Many muslims actually take pride in this, but what they oppressed was plural and liberal culture which valued eclecticism and syncretism

[@speedbird109]

India’s software exports in FY 2023 was 320 billion not 180 billion

[@shakeelabhatta467]

Please Zaid Hamid ko bhi apne black hole par laaye😅

[@biorig]

Actually Chandrayaan II had two components: A Moon orbiter which is still functional and a Lander which crashed. So Chandrayaan II was not a failure, but partial success/ partial failure. The Chandrayaan II orbiter will orbit the moon for a long time to come and keep the Chandrayaan II mission going. Its own output is successful and we continue to receive important research data.

[@agonnoga6100]

Space technology is helping reduce poverty. Therefore those who think space exploration and its allied activities are pure luxury and vanity projects need to educate themselves. This view has been expressed by several western journalists wrt India's advanced space program through which services are provided at lowest cost to the most remote parts of the country.

[@subbiahsivakumar]

In addition to what Prof. Parvez said , there is yet another thing: Hindus are profiundly curious and Pragmatic.. even with their Gods! This is at the heart of the India's Indian fascination with S&T

[@explorer1161]

I have read the major Islamic texts and am able to connect with the behavior of Muslims, which is the actual issue. This doesn't only apply to Pakistani Muslims but is also relevant to Indian and Bangladeshi Muslims. In India, the participation of Muslims in the technology or corporate world is only 0.5-1%, and the participation of Muslim women is 0%.

[@narayan524]

Mr hoodbuoy you are absolutely correct passing entrance IIT is tough, one of participant asked why student of pakistan are not able to compete? In my place there is one professor, professor offered one crore rupees in kota (an iit coaching centre)) looking to his abilities but he refused given reason though you are offering much more than my expectation but "i in this area only one who prepare students for IITs if i quit from this place this poor studens will left out because they are poor" this is the vision of our gurus in india

[@Nokapp23]

57:00 As per google (1) Professor's salary in Pakistan Rs.62, 022 per month. At 300 rupee rate it is about $206.74 (2) Professor's salary in India Rs 90,620 per month. At 80 ruppe rate $ 1,132.75

[@devshetty7465]

ISRO chairman said india has capability to send mission to Mars and Venus.

[@IndiaHereNow]

Dr. Sahab thinks that the diversion between the trajectories of Hindus and Muslims happened after the Mughals. That's whack! The mutazallites were persecuted by Muslims much before that. Printing press was banned much before that. On the other hand, you have Bhaskara 1, Bhaskara 2, Aryabhatt, Brahmagupta and Varahamira.

[@amjadhussain2648]

We live in a society exquisitely dependent on science and technology, in which hardly anyone knows anything about science and technology. Proud of you great Dr. Sab, We appreciate Indian scientists and engineers for such brilliant job...

[@gyroscope_of_morality.]

The better title:- Chandrayaan-3: India reached the Moon. Where's Pakistan Physicists?

[@user-ed9qp2qv8i]

Vinod Dham is an Indian-American engineer, entrepreneur and venture capitalist. He is known as the 'Father of the Pentium Chip' for his contribution to the development of Intel's Pentium micro-processor[2][3][4] He is also mentor, advisor, and sits on the boards of companies, including startups funded through his India-based fund Indo-US Venture Partners,[5] where he is the founding managing director.

[@anirudhsinghdeora9032]

Parda came into Hindus by the introduction of Islam in India, there is no parda in southern India.

[@banyan-tree]

54:37 explains it all. It is the basis of all the differences these two nations have. Furthermore, Rishis-Munis had a scientific temperament e.g. medical, geometrical, etc and much of the astronomical, and mathematical knowledge went to Europe via Arab.

[@jagan66jaguar71]

Pakistan should focus on ghazwa ae Hind concept... Today Pakistan is going on well direction 😂😂😂😂

[@sarveshvishwakarma1349]

Pak be like-- Pakistan is an atomic mulk they don't need do such a stuff..

[@taraprasadbehera6516]

A society where you can't criticize stupid beliefs openly but you want to go to moon 😂

[@RohitSharma-rz6ph]

Sridharacharya was a Rishi, and he invented the well known formula for getting the roots of quadratic equations.Yes it's true that we Indians don't mix Science and Religion. We never claim ourselves Best,but we always efforts honestly to become better.

[@qwerty6-6]

Please search about the ancient books related to astronomy and aeronautics from ancient India written a few millenia ago.

[@vkchaitanya2003]

He is so I’ll informed about Hindus and it’s history. Even hindu Rishis and maha rishis were advocates of science. Eg aryabhatta, susrut and countless others

[@daughterofindiaandchildofw357]

He says science came in India with Angrejs it's absolutely not true because he studied in Pakistan and he didn't know about Ayabhatta , Susruta, Chankaya , and many of them

[@madhusreedharanpathirapilli]

mathematicians plays a big role.. as equal to engineering

[@niteeshmishra2790]

Itna sukoon mujhe life me pahli baar mil rha hai ki padosi jo India ka pakka dushman desh hai wo hamari tareef kar rha ho , Jay Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@rahallivex]

It's also the culture of astronomy and science of India which is over 5000 years old. India respects their scientists and engineers. Sad to say but in Pakistan if you look at history scientists and intellectuals are ridiculed.

[@vanni.]

To your Surprise, (ISRO) Chairman S. Somanath visited the Sri Chengalamma temple in Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh on July 13, 2023, the day before the launch of Chandrayaan-3:

[@parveenswami3693]

The Golden Age of Islam, which saw a flourishing of science, notably mathematics and astronomy, especially during the 9th and 10th centuries, had a notable Indian influence.

[@rajeshkumar.99]

is it so difficult to understand that root cause behind Pakistan's or all the Muslim countries situation is their religion. Without oil most of the middle east countries will also be in the same boat as Pakistan.

[@pspsdan]

Excellent... Raja Rammohan Roy's historic letter to Lord William Bentinck led to their subsequent meeting , arranged by Dwarikanath Tagore. Rammohan Roy's strong advocacy resulted in the introduction of new education policy which led to formation of university, medical college etc in India. Charles Macculay's appointment was the direct result of Rammohan's advocacy.

[@Komal_US]

Thank you, Hoodbhoy Sir, I am an Indian American and I really enjoyed the 1st few mins of this discussion where you explained how India managed to accomplish this in such low budget. I was really looking for this info and you explained it very well 🙏 One observation that in the beginning of the video, that guy specially requested everyone to switch off their phones, but I noticed that so many students sitting their were playing with their phones and some seemed not interested in what you have to say. And it is not a large audience.

[@shivam_nagar69]

Pervez sir should tell their students ISRO is not competing NASA/JAXA , it was created for development of India, and making a place for India in space sector which it has achieved. Reaching mars and landing a rover is MOM2 mission, NASA is far ahead of everyone, thing is USA is advanced in everything from defence sector to aerospace. NASA is connected ESA always, these guys are developing themselves on their own with helping each other while ISRO has to everything alone.

[@taraknathpanja7486]

Sir, 1Doller - Rs.400 pak rupees, and 1Doller -Rs. 83 Indian rupees, This speaks everything

[@akshaysingh9829]

Sorry to say but prof.A.K khan brilliant scientist of Pakistan who gave you the atomic power and what did your government respond to him you know better than me...on the orther hand Dr. A.P.J kalam sir who make India atomic power and India requested him to become the president of India...Pahle apne talent ko respect karna sikhe tabhi kuch ho skta h...jai hind

[@RahulSaini-du9vg]

I'm guessing more people watches his intellect from India, then from Pakistan.

[@rajotavo]

Appreciate what you are doing to kindle interest in science and tech in Pak, Dr. Hoodbhoy sir! As an Indian, hope and wish Pakistani ppl adopt science and rationality to get out of the situation where the world sees your ppl with suspicion...best ✌

[@abhalera]

First Pakistani Channel which deserves True respect. This is the Truly educated show. Or else all the other channels which I watch have no understanding of space technology. Respect from India.

[@rudhisundar]

It is obviously clear that some "Hindu culture of debate" or "TARKA" or "call it introspection" is still living inside Pakistan. It is honestly great to see that. Just do these things more frequently. Because, you are just the Converted Hindus, after all.

[@NibaranNath-bx4ee]

Even a primary school teacher in India has to prepare the lession at home before presentation.

[@csreddy1518]

you have great Team in Mr Abdul basith and Mr Zaid Hamid they will make pakistan heaven.

[@samyakjain4142]

Me bhi IIT se hu, ISRO me majorly Non IITans hote hai

[@aarambh3616]

Our rishis were not like maulana and do only religious teachings, they taught science, astronomy, medicine, nuclear science, mathematics, philosophy and many more. We have our thousand years old history which guided us and still guiding us.

[@glorytitangamers2781]

Al-Khwārizmī is famous for his mathematical works, which introduced Hindu-Arabic numerals and algebra to European mathematicians. In fact, the words algorithm and algebra come from ( he is only a transletor not a methemetian )

[@krushnanandadas8100]

The whole atmosphere is look like 80's

[@pavonekumar8454]

HI Sir,,I would request you to change the timing bit earlier ,now its 12.36Am.But I love to listen to your lectures.....

[@pankajchavhan7705]

South pole pe pahunch ne wala first country hai...india 4th nahi

[@guldukan]

for so many questions bureaucracy and issues In India We had a similar issue all our talent until 90s left India known as brain drain. However India in 90s liberalized the economy and kickstarted that did a reverse brain. However institutions such as ISRO, IIT, IIMS etc were left alone and they struggled really hard to get to this stage

[@debajyotinath5021]

29:35 look how enthusiastic he is talking about Abdus Salam. This man loves science! It really pains me to think that Pak never gave its scientific talent the respect and recognition they deserved.

[@mohib024]

If you have so many issues with Indian technology then why don't you guys do it for your country? The only thing is that India is the first country to do soft landing in the south moon where there is availability of water. Our nation's ISRO team is so talented that with less expense we landed on the moon whereas no other nation could have done it. Moreover you are nowhere in competition with us

[@moulics]

When you believe earth is flat what else can happen

[@raghunathpatil7905]

half people are using phones..while a one man trying to educate you so hard and now we know why they are unsuccessful..they dont know power of education 😮‍💨 hope they will understand it

[@life_sway]

Our Science and mathematics are based on Vedas .. Sir you need to check the facts

[@rahulrahangdale1787]

1st country on south pole not 4th

[@jrs2002]

He is wrong. JAXA's asteroid missions were significant, but nothing is more difficult than the complexity of soft landing a vehicle on the surface of large cosmic objects like Planets or Satellites, not to say about landing on conspicuous sites like the South polar region of moon. The very technical expertise and accuracy required with careful planning is more immense in the later. There's a reason why only 3 countries till now had been able to land on moon. Not even Japan or ESA. There's a reason again, why Chandrayaan 3 is getting so many media coverage from around the globe, when compared to Japan's asteroid missions.

[@ddkarel]

Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy, you are not only a great physicist, you understand sociology and it’s effect on education as well. I always believe that money spent on education is not expenditure, it’s investment in future. The nations, which understand and evolve with the changes, can prosper and grow, with their heads held high.