CHARLOTTE TILBURY UNREAL SKIN STICK FOUNDATION | Dry Skin Review & Wear Test

Today I’m checking out the Charlotte Tilbury Unreal Skin Sheer Glow Tint stick foundation in shade 4 Fair. Let’s see how it applies and wears on dry skin over 40. All products linked below. #foundationfest #makeupover40
Charlotte Tilbury Unreal Skin Foundation Stick in 4 Fair $46 - go.magik.ly/ml/23lun/
Charlotte Tilbury is a cruelty free brand and is Leaping Bunny approved.
★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★
Does your skin care routine feel totally random and you can’t tell if it’s working? The fix is simple: plan out your routine and track it. I've made an easy printable planner/tracker worksheet to help you get started!
skincaretracker.geekoutofwate...
Get more behind-the-scenes updates from me over on Patreon: / geekoutofwater
Want more geeky goodness? I send out weekly updates, free samples to help me test recipes, makeup fun, and skin care info by email! Don’t miss out - sendfox.com/shelly.hokanson
★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★ ☆★
FREE MINI-COURSE on how to choose the best foundations for dry skin - foundation.geekoutofwater.com
CHECK OUT MY FRIEND JENNY the FOUNDATION LADY! bit.ly/jennyfoundation
FOUNDATION & CONCEALER FEST MASTER LISTS!
All the foundations and concealers I’ve reviewed, ranked and searchable:
Foundation - geekoutofwater.com/foundation...
Concealer - geekoutofwater.com/concealer-...
I’M WEARING:
NAILS Curtain Call by Color Street - 100% real dry nail polish strips - no dry time, no smudges, no heat or tools needed, and made in the USA! We’re international - US, Canada, & the European Union! Hop into my Facebook group / goownails or visit shop.goowbeauty.com
Check out the Color Play sub box: www.colorstreet.com/geekoutof...
FACE
Charlotte Tilbury Unreal Skin Foundation Stick in 4 Fair - go.magik.ly/ml/23lun/
Seraphine Botanicals Periwinkle + Pop Blush in Seashell - bit.ly/3WdtTQH
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Matte Bronzer in Medium - go.magik.ly/ml/23luo/
EYES
MAC Paint Pot in Painterly - go.magik.ly/ml/1sj6x/
Laura Geller Wildflower Wishes Eyeshadow Palette ( July 2024 Ipsy) - bit.ly/3LdA0OD
CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus liner in black onyx - go.magik.ly/ml/22sg5/
Tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight - go.magik.ly/ml/23lur/
Polite Society Greatest Lashes of All Time Mascara - go.magik.ly/ml/22qcw/
Maybelline Super Lock Clear Brow Glue - go.magik.ly/ml/22sgl/
LIP
What’s Up Beauty Egyptian Queen Lipstick in Seba - bit.ly/4cuxnDZ
Lawless Forget the Filler Lip Plumping Line Smoothing Gloss in Velvet - go.magik.ly/ml/22qcv/
CHECK OUT MY ETSY: geekoutofwater.etsy.com
MY HANDCRAFTED SKIN CARE - bit.ly/goowskin
NECKNOTZ hand-crafted hemp necklaces by my friend Lindsay - 3% off with code: GOOW www.necknotz.com/discount/GOOW
10% OFF SCIENCE SERUM TIGHT EYE - code SHELLY - bit.ly/4aCCrVj
BK BEAUTY - awesome cruelty free brushes! get 10% off with code SHELLY10 - www.bkbeauty.com/
BANISH Skin Care & Dermarolling Stamp - code GOOW - www.banish.com/SHELLY42677
YESSTYLE - extra discount with code YESGOOW - bit.ly/yesgoow
ALTER EGO COSMETICS - 10% off with code SHELLY10 - bit.ly/alteregoGOOW
My Amazon Favorites - www.amazon.com/shop/geekoutofw...
SOCIALS!
Facebook: / geekoutofwater
Instagram: / geekoutofwater
TikTok: / geekoutofwater
Snail Mail Shelly Hokanson PO Box 184 McGaheysville VA 22840
Inquiries: [e-mail]
EQUIPMENT
Fancy Canon camera & lens - amzn.to/3fkCmyZ
Fancy microphone - amzn.to/3DLUds1
Fancy studio light - amzn.to/4bExGfE
Fancy ring light - amzn.to/37Qmf2c
Fancy software - go.magik.ly/ml/519m/
(lol none of it is fancy)
ABOUT ME: My name is Shelly and I’m a 49-year-old web geek that jumped off the deep end into the makeup and beauty world. I’ve got normal to dry skin, fine lines, and hyperpigmentation caused by sun damage. Cameo appearances by my rescue cats Daffy, Ziva, and Charlie (all girls). Rest in peace, my pretty girl Polly 2014 - 2024.
I purchase most products shown on my channel myself. Occasionally I receive PR, products that were gifted to me with no obligations to review them, which I state verbally when applicable. I was not paid by any product provider to make this video. Paid product placements will always be indicated in writing and verbally; I rarely do them. All opinions are honest and my own. Thanks to KZbin for sending me the Shop with KZbin light! When you shop products from within my videos/links, I earn a small commission at no cost to you. I appreciate your support of my work!
FTC: This video is not sponsored.

[@themerz6982]

Pretty expensive highlighting stick! Thanks for the review.

[@Cornwall3]

I saw someone else review this and she said it’s like the flawless filter in a stick, not a foundation. She uses it under foundation because of how shiny it is and little coverage. Seems misnamed.

[@lisak7997]

I’ve seen people powder in the T-zone and liking it much better. Thank you for sharing ❤

[@rhondaludbrook7369]

I bought this right when it came out. I tried it a few ways. The best I found was to go very minimal as it looks very nice without multiple layers. I also found I like this over a slightly natural finish foundation. But less is a lot more.

[@lindseylouise8312]

I feel like this amount of shine will come in handy in Jan-March when my skin is so dry and nothing will give me a glow. I think it could work well for me if used strategically.

[@bjornolson21]

I’m one of the ones who loves it on me 🤪😂 That and some merit beauty blush balm. Yes

[@viviantaunton9783]

I have to say I kind of like it for the summer, it looks fresh and glowy. Probably too glowy for you however, with my 63 year old skin, it may add some youthful looks. Thank you for the review.

[@neneg.4264]

Hi Shelly! well the Tin Man look's not what I usually go for 😆 it seems like too much, but I like me some glow, just more subtle, I guess this product might look good under a more matte or satin finish foundation, but nothing you can't get with any other Hollywood Flawless Filter dupe 🤣 there's no need to spend that kind of money for the brand and the cute packaging, IMO you look good, a bit glazed donut-esque 😁 but maybe some powder around the nose and forehead would've toned the shine down ... and I just ordered the Thighteye using your discount code, can't wait to try it out, thnx! ... take care, say hi to Ziva... hugzzz 💜🤗

[@ambergerhelper7852]

You can use eyelash glue to secure the clasp to the back of your neck. Wedding hack. Shelly, I’ve said it before, I 💕💗💕that light pink on you! Just absolutely perfect. I have a similar tunic style top that’s close to that thistle-y color, and I love it too! 🤓

[@sarahstroud6021]

I can see the weight loss in your face, you’re jawline is coming back!

[@goow]

I almost saw a collarbone the other day and gasped! 🤣

[@hbarlaam]

I picked this up the other day in shade 2. According to the Sephora match thingy I should be 3, but when swatched 3 looked a bit yellow. 1.5 was too light. So the Sephora employee and I agreed 2 would be best. You and I are often similar shades so I'd be curious about 2 or 3 on you. I know it's sheer and the shades are allegedly flexible, but I think if you go too dark or too light or apply too much, that might be what causes the texture emphasis, makes the glow look unreal, etc. I have only used fingers to spread, not a sponge or brush. But I like it a lot!!! I did powder my t-zone with Pat Mcgrath after. This is what I saw Wayne Goss do. I don't think it looks bad on you; I think you look great especially outside--but I'd powder it a bit.

[@SarahMcAshan]

It's almost metallic--like you're headed to the Emerald City to ask the Wizard for a ❤ ✨ When the light bounces around that much, it isn't super flattering to hollows, puffs, and texture. Dewiness is a real art. This ain't it for me--loads of mica usually isn't. This would be such a nightmare in a Zoom meeting 😆 I thought some of my sunscreens were shiny (looking at you, R&R Sun Serum) but this is next level!

[@calidreamin2441]

I’m not sure why CT calls that product a foundation? At any rate, there is not much product in that little tube, if one used it daily, it would go super fast! I’d like to see CT herself demonstrate it on her own skin for us! It might look wonderful on the likes of Hailey Bieber! Maybe UNDER foundation to take advantage of hydration and to prep the skin??? Or lightly on the high points of the face??? Hmmmm? Good demonstration though Shelly! Another good video, per usual! (My sister had a Jeep too, and she spent way too much time/money in the repair shop!) Better luck to you! 💸💸💸

[@lauraw83]

Always love Friday nights with Shelly! I can tell this one won’t work for my skin. By the end of the day I’d look like I was sweating. Thank you for the amazing review as usual! 😍

[@beachfrost3367]

I think it looks like a stick version of Charlotte's Hollywood Flawless filter. It looks so much like a highlighter. Would probably be beautiful as a base for a matte foundation, but I wouldn't spend that much on just a base for another foundation. The name says it all "unreal skin". Sorry to hear about your Jeep, Shelly.😖 Maybe it's time for a trade-in? Jeeps do hold their value, so it might be something to consider. Hope your DD game was a success! I myself am addicted to Fortnite. If I miss a few days, I am in withdrawal. Gotta love gaming!😁 Thanks for the review, I was looking at this foundation, and now I know it's a hard pass.👍

[@goow]

Since I leased my Jeep and then bought out the lease I'm about a year away from not being underwater on my loan. I am hoping the incentives on the plug in hybrids will still be there when I'm break-even on the loan because I'll probably look at trading it for a 4xe Jeep.

[@LdowL1234]

Thanks for that in store swatch matching idea!

[@user-bw7ce5eb2w]

Thank you! I may try this one in the winter

[@noname-vz5wx]

hope you are doing good! cant wait to watch ur new vid :)

[@tonya5762]

Shine on Shelly! I have really been loving the Lancôme Teint Idole Ultra Wear 5-In-1 Foundation Stick. I know you reviewed the original version back in the day, but it was reformulated in 2021. For obvious rona reasons I never tried it until this year. It is a full coverage matte foundation that feels so lightweight, creamy and hydrating. I only use a minimal amount for medium coverage, but it’s definitely build able. You should give it another try if you have a lull in new releases. I know you will love the quick and easy application along with the blurring benefits of the matte finish.

[@belindafischer2920]

Hi! I have this, I use a little bit of it under my foundation for a slight glow that peaks thru. It looks beautiful that way. Try it that way. Then I set with powder.😊

[@cindymarble1270]

Wow that’s some shiny foundation! You look good but wow! Thanks for the review.

[@raafiaahmad4454]

Thanks for the review Shelly, I already purchased this stuff (impulse buy😕, everywhere there is great review on this thing ) but haven’t used it. Now after watching your review I think I’ll use it as a highlighter instead of a foundation or maybe try the glazed donut look for once to check how I feel. Anyway, have a great day ahead and take care you too.❤❤❤ P.S - could you please review the new Fenty glow foundation and the new ABH stick foundation.

[@susanmcintyre9934]

You and I have the exact same tastes when it comes to foundation and base. I didn’t think I would like the finish of this foundation stick and your review confirmed my suspicions. Thanks so much for the review AND for once again saving me money! 😁 Have a great weekend!!!

[@joylewullis9538]

Thanks for reviewing this for us. I knew before you even started I was not gonna purchase this. So expensive, not enough coverage, and so on. Thanks for taking a hit Shelly and reviewing this!

[@laurastr1]

Hi Shelly, I do the same as you in the store, finding a foundation I already use and swiping it to compare to products I’m checking out. I rather do this than put testers on my face. I had a hard time deciding between the Charlotte Tilbury foundation stick in shades 2, 3 and 4. I’m a touch darker than you and I went with shade 2, however, I think because the product is so sheer all three would’ve worked. Honestly, it was a big waste of money, but it was one of those fun purchases that I couldn’t resist. It’s like a shiny primer. Some people are saying it’s like the CT flawless filter in a stick.

[@user-cs2ij5mo3o]

Love your matching hack using your color Estee Lauder color match in Sephora!!! We have a beautiful Sephora store over here in Short Pump, VA!

[@goow]

That's my favorite Sephora in Short Pump!! I usually make the trek out there once a year or so 🤣

[@user-cs2ij5mo3o]

@@goow bad for me it's less than 10 minutes from home :)

[@jenniferdixson860]

I haven't purchased foundation since before COVID, but I've been thinking about refreshing what I have and had my eye on this one. You just saved me some money.

[@carolwong9279]

Always appreciate your reviews so I don't waste my money. You can use it as a highlighter😂

[@chlojoe100]

I have to agree with you. This foundation is just too glowy and give a bit of a tin man effect and looks a bit greasy. Maybe they'll do one without the glow with the same formula. I love that blush. I looked it up and I don't see it anywhere. I see the Serafphina Botanicals but the color Sunshine is no where to be found. Maybe Ipsy doesn't always send out new products.

[@MyCleverHandle]

You are such a trouper - love your demonstrations! The product is too shiny, but your color blending - eyeshadows, blush, bronzer, lips - is always impeccable. Thank you so much for restating how to use the Laura Geller Wildflower Wishes palette. I'm finally learning how to use mine, and now I love it!

[@goow]

I love when brands organize eyeshadow palettes that way! It makes life so much easier!

[@patriciapelletier1981]

It actually looks better outside…I don’t mind the glow

[@marionallen2222]

I just got my yummy skin tint back out and idk why I ever stopped wearing g it bc my skin looks like perfection plump and juicy all day!!! The concealer is not good to me I’m gonna return it but the hourglass blush in scene is gorgeous perfection!!!! I also got Huda in Cotten candy it’s gorgeous but has glitter This one’s not for me I don’t like so much glowyness! The DIOR foundation stick looked divine!!!!

[@louisemcmillan3576]

It seems this product does not melt into the skin, it kind of lies on top and just looks weird. I would stick with the Flawless Filter and totally skip this "foundation". So thanks, Shelley, for this review as I'm sure she's pricey. Love the Laura Geller eye shadow palette, however. Would love to watch you create some eye looks with this ❤

[@DLF1122]

I have seen a few other reviews and most feel like it is the Hollywood Flawless Filter in stick for and should be used the same way. I am oily, so I have no plan to purchase it, but it does look extremely shiny.

[@playsintraffic2]

Wanted to let you know I ordered my Tight-eye serum today. Can’t wait.

[@goow]

Yay let me know how you like it!!!

[@mickeyh6763]

It looks gorgeous on you on camera, I wear it mixed in with a lightweight foundation and I like the mix, and I don’t need to use any highlight with it

[@bjornolson21]

I know. It looks really nice, huh?

[@sleepyheadsarah]

I usually agree with your opinions about new foundations, so I'm very interested to hear what you have to say about this one!

[@Alittleferal]

The Krispy Kreme look is not for me either, sadly. Thank you for helping me from making an expensive fomo purchase! I appreciate your input so much!

[@_dewinther]

Its weird, outside it looks like you have doll skin. Thanks 💖💖💖

[@marionallen2222]

Bahahahaha Just Empty Every Pocket!!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I love it !!!! … it’s been a full year I’ve been on Tretnoin and my spots are almost all gone I heard of a new product Euceurin ANTI PIGMENT is supposed to have a new ingredient that’s demolishes sunspots and freckles and is a blocker!!! I gotta find some to try!!!

[@goow]

I need to look into that!!

[@phoenix9ty]

I get what you say about the donut glaze. Still I think you looked beautiful. I tried ot in Sephora, but the suggested shade didn't work for me. Nor did the lighter or darker shade.

[@lizzieholland7051]

to wash the sponges put them in one of those small netted wash bags and put them in the washing machine

[@goow]

omg I need to try that! Never thought of that! Thanks, Lizzie!

[@minervasowl7658]

Helloooo, Shelly! I appreciate this review, as usual. I feel like CT really missed the mark with this one. Who is the intended target consumer? Can't be mature-skinned people. It seems to accentuate every nook and cranny and fine line. Loving your nails today ✨!

[@happymusics]

It looks like a highlighter more. :D

[@binderkim]

I didn't expect it to be so shiny when I swatched it at Sephora, that's why I didn't buy it. Thank you for the review.

[@joylewullis9538]

PS. Hi Ziva! Love when she cuddle’s around you. So sorry to hear about your jeep. I cringe every time that check engine light goes on in my car, but mine is a lot older than yours. That sucks! Hope it’s not major problems for you. Also, you still look pretty through that glaze donut look ha ha.

[@Diane0123]

I’ve been absent., I’ve missed you.💜🇨🇦💜

[@goow]

Welcome back, Diane!!

[@Diane0123]

@@goow Thanks Darlin 💜🇨🇦💜

[@nurtegan1215]

I've been watching your reviews for many years.... I am sorry to say this did not look good. I have mature, super-dry skin and will not be buying this one. Thank you for taking one for the team!

[@cindypowell6358]

Yikes!! A warm version of the Tin Man!! I agree with you Shelly 💯 too shiny!! You & I like most of the same foundations & have similar skin types. It even made you look like you have bags underneath your eyes ( which you definitely don’t ). It threw shadows in places I didn’t know existed lol.😂 You’re gorgeous as always, but a definite NO to that foundation. You & I like a little natural glow, but not a disco ball or human version of a PEARL. 🤭

[@sashaxian]

I love this foundation!! I powder with Jones road powder in my t-zone and it looks amazing. The powder totally makes the glow look more subtle and lovely

[@marshamiddleton5910]

Have you ever reviewed the Makeup Forever stick foundation? I like it. Am curious what you would think.❤🎉

[@megcormack681]

💙💙

[@chabangful]

Watch how Wayne Goss applies it....I think you'll like it better.

[@strawberrycupcake4471]

Its giving me Data vibes from Star Trek! In my opinion, Charlotte Tilbury is the most over hyped brand out there...her foundations are not good, I have tried so many products from the range and being from the UK, we cannot take ours back! Your skin is looking amazing (without the foundation!) btw...are you doing anything different?

[@goow]

LOLOL Data 🤣 YES!!! As for my skin... I've been trying to find the sweet spot in exfoliation right now. I stopped for a while because I just wrecked my skin barrier exfoliating too much, and now I'm trying to get back into a routine without going too far... I still get peely here and there but knock on wood I think it's going OK!

[@wiseowl1580]

Lol 🍩 yea imo CT is overrated. She has a great brand image, and packaging but very hit or miss products. Thanks for the review ❤

[@meganchandler9078]

👋 Do you think you'll review the Dior stick foundation?

[@goow]

Hi Megan! It's on my list to buy!

[@mgromz]

Hi Shelly, do you think this would make a good primer??

[@goow]

Yep I haven't worn it that way yet but I did wear it the other day more as a bronzer/highlight area and it was lovely. I think it's best to think of it as a highlight rather than a foundation. But it feels lovely so I think it'd work as primer too.

[@greenbeauties]

I didn’t get it as it’s the CT flawless filter in a stick form a few reviews have pointed out. I think they should not call it foundation as it’s not! All I do with glazed donuts is eat them not rub them on my face 😂

[@goow]

Right?! Yummmmm lol

[@timsjulie]

Wonder when it will be available for sale?

[@hbarlaam]

It's already available in the US and Italy. (Edit to add that my comment was so specific because I've personally seen it in stores there due to travel over the past 2 weeks, lol.)

[@janetn9942]

Do u return the products u don’t like and/or won’t use ?

[@goow]

I usually do not return them unless they're an absolute disaster. If it's a brand I buy regularly I'll keep it for swatch comparisons when future products come out. Then a couple times a year I go through all of my foundations and anything I haven't used or swatched since the last time gets put in a box and donated to Project Beauty Share, unless I have a friend or relative locally that would like it (which is rare because I'm paler than everyone I know). 🤣

[@barbaranelson5177]

Most of the review say it is like the liquid form of her glow type serum

[@playsintraffic2]

all the reviews I've seen talk about the overly glazed look. I like a slightly dewy skin-like finish but not a glazed look.

[@goow]

Yep I love a dewy finish but when it leans into that white/silver glaze... I just can't do it 🤣

[@cindystewart121]

Hi Shelly, Wanted to let you know by watching some other videos especially the one by Nikki Larose she explained that this stick is not a foundation but a stick form of the flawless filter and to use it all over under your makeup or just to highlight with it and instead of trying to tote the flawless filter bottle around this stick is much easier to put in your purse and for travel. I just wanted to give you a heads up about this stick. I like the side that you used with the brush better too because it looked smoother. Take Care Shelly you are great to watch and listen too.

[@cf8595]

I saw the same thing, but how are we expected to know that when they call it a foundation stick? Super bad marketing if that's the case. This does look exactly like Elf Halo Glow, which is the CT dupe for flawless filter.

[@cindystewart121]

@@cf8595 I know it does look like the Elf. I think they really need to take the foundation off the label.

[@bjornolson21]

Maybe that’s just how she uses it, along with many others. Nothing wrong with that. I’m just saying because the ct website calls it a foundation stick. I use it as foundation

[@ChrissieSM]

I'd rather buy a box of Kristy Kreme than that foundation. I saw it first on the UK TV programme Lorraine, Charlotte herself was applying it on 2 ladies, one looked as if she was dipped in cooking oil.

[@neneg.4264]

"she looked like she dipped in cooking oil" 😂😂🤣 no thnx 😆

[@evydarling]

Hell naw, to the naw naw naw. Hell to the naw, to the naw, naw, naw. 🍩

[@karlaharvey2623]

lol Oh my word Shelly, Noooo! Way too glazed looking. Has it been labeled incorrect? Maybe use it under a foundation? If you try it under a foundation, and your WOW’d please share with us! You’re just too cute and kuddos for wearing it for 9 hrs. Take care of you and your precious kittys.

[@CatKim2]

Glass skin is not really for those of us with more mature skin, is it? Sorry to hear about your Jeep.

[@sassysweet2ok269]

Besides magic cream which I refuse to buy bc the price is absolutely ridiculous but I do not like charlotte tilbury products…

[@albireadingromance]

On camera, it looks gorgeous.

[@clairebougie3114]

I love this foundation but it’s definitely not for everyone:)

[@lynndecarlo6704]

This is definitely a pass for me.

[@ceresida]

Looks like an expensive melt-down in the middle of a heatwave. It is ridiculous how a well-known brand can put out anything these days, and it will generate sales anyway. MAC strobe cream is a cream, one can work with that formula combined with other formulas. But this is just a skin hued super shiny lipstick formulation marketed as foundation, all one can do is smear it around ad infinitum.

[@lisasanders4818]

let me get my oil can Shellie, cause once u shower youre gonna rust, lolzzzz

[@goow]

🤣

[@sfkat]

Yea, too glowy but not great glowy; it looks like you put oil over your skin first.

[@mistytells]

Ugh! That’s a greasy mess for my face. It just is flawless filter in a stick. I know what not to waste my money on. False advertisement if you ask me. It’s like she could slap foundation labels on flawless filter and people would still buy it just to say they got it. Not me. I’m informed first. From the reviewers on here. Did you not see other reviews?

[@TheBelilu]

Looked so much better outdoor. I loved it on you. Your skin looked literally peachy, in the best sense of the word.

[@TheBelilu]

But the texture part had your bronzer / blush on it. So it's hard to say which caused what? Or what if the combination of your bronze/blush (because of their formula) didn't work well with the foundation formula? Either way, i really really liked everything about it, in the outside shot. Your skin looked really good.

[@bjornolson21]

I think it looks good on her outside too

[@jmbutler5]

you always look troubled.🫤

[@goow]

These are troubling times.

[@ambergerhelper7852]

You can use eyelash glue to secure the clasp to the back of your neck. Wedding hack. Shelly, I’ve said it before, I 💕💗💕that light pink on you! Just absolutely perfect. I have a similar tunic style top that’s close to that thistle-y color, and I love it too! 🤓

[@goow]

Whoa I have never heard that trick! I need to try that!!!