Voice Teachers React to Big Mama The Killing Voice Pt. 2 | 2022

[@shj7346]

The arrangements are all done by Yeon-ah Shin. She has an extraordinary understanding of music theory and just as a cute tidbit, her classes are actually specifically highly praised mostly because of her intimate understanding of musical theory.

[@3366larryandrews]

She's brilliant. The level that this group has been able to achieve is reflected in the brilliant songs/arrangements.

[@jinsoul7805]

Yes she really good at that !

[@kpopscenario1406]

yea

[@Jontae4288]

Wow I was thinking she had to be the leader or captain of the ship lol

[@M.J_KIM]

Korea has grown into an unprecedented cultural powerhouse in East Asia. People around the world know that idol groups are the representative form of kpop today, but the spectrum of kpop you think is more diverse than you think. Of course, ballads that Koreans sing with their own emotions are unprecedentedly emotional genres of music. Korea is a world-class music art, but it is undervalued.

[@oldsoul_anth243]

You can tell Shin Yeon-ah is highly influenced by jazz she phrases like one. As well, on top of her being the head of one of the most prestigious music universities, she does most of the arrangements of their songs. She also started the first girl group to debut from a University, Azer. And as you said, as an Adult Contemporary fan, I am really obsessed of her classic tone. Reminds me of my favorites, Ms. Dionne Warwick and Ms. Karen Carpenter.

[@TheSeeking2know]

Shin is such a classy lady to me. She carries herself so elegantly and intellectually. Yes, Karen Carpenter vibes indeed. Just that Karen didn't go breathy or speak-y like Shin does sometimes (I am sure just for effect or expression in a more modern pop setting). When Shin connects and sings legato all the way through, her tone is velvet to the ears; a gentle caress.

[@keykth4040]

By far the most vocally stacked group. From being some of the best music professors in SK (their classes, especially Shin’s, are highly highly HIGHLY praised), to being also known as one of if not the most legendary kpop groups of all time.

[@lincolnfineblanket5446]

Please do Park Hyo Shin’s Wildflower next! He has an incredibly rich voice, and I am very interested in your analysis!!

[@ukiiyoooo]

OMGG YESS PLSS

[@nusrxh]

YAS

[@clark.chronicles5967]

Yesssss

[@Ivanna051198]

OMG YES!!!

[@AditJ28]

YASS PLEAAAAAASSSEE

[@bluemoonhouse2135]

I enjoyed watching it. They debuted in 2003 and disbanded in 2012. I came back last year. Two are university professors, one quit teaching, and one is steadily active as a soloist.

[@cjunchoi7003]

actually all of them are professors of Uni, Lee was soloist and resently became a professor,

[@wewenang5167]

and all oh them are a mamas xD

[@stevenle1498]

Far-left, Shin Yeon-ah, has an ease to her voice because she's always in her mix or starts her mix very early like the guy in Melomance or Sam Smith. Since she so often has a higher placement hearing her juxtaposed to Lee Ji-young beside her is so nice with her heavier sound. It could be personal taste but being the low harmony having that depth to her sound is something you wouldn't find in female groups. Park Min-hye on the far-right sounds louder than Lee Young-hyun, even though LYH is the belter. If you could combine them into one they'd be the perfect singer but you'd miss out on these amazing live harmonies.

[@TheSeeking2know]

Your point abut Shin being in her mix always is interesting. The juxtaposition is the charm of this group. If they all sounded alike or approached their vocals similarly then they would just be an average KPop girl group, but they are much more than that. I also agree that Lee Ji-young having to lower her larynx often as the low vocal harmony has become habitual even though I am sure she's capable of singing lighter or more mix-y. She is also a bit of a belt diva like Lee Young-hyun to her right and very soulful, dong growls and all sorts of riffs and runs. I was surprised when I realized that Shin was singing above Lee Ji-young in the harmonies because I feel her speaking voice is in a similar place to hers in terms of range. I feel Shin could sing low but maybe since like you said she's more of a mix singer, she would need to lower her larynx more to sing fuller lower notes if she was the lowest in any three-part harmony. Park is the Disney princess and the youngest, with the voice Chase and Melia prefer to sound like, which is all good.

[@andrescsla]

​@@TheSeeking2know later response lol, but Shin actually sings lots of the low harmonies (Woman, Refusal, Love Alone and many more)

[@JaeMinJung.]

Imagine if you were their students back at the univerties watching their DINGO KILLING VOICE performance you would feel tons of emotions from being pressured to being hopeful. Pressure - to living up to the expectations of being under their class and being one of their students Intimidated - because your professors are extremely accomplished Happy - because your're being thought by legends Proud - because you get to be thought by them and let alone be in their class and watching them in their element through KILLING VOICE Hopeful - you hope to make them proud and exceed their expectations through your hard work and talents

[@TheSeeking2know]

You can point to them and say "that's my professor" but then the expectation for you goes up.

[@comsatteur6893]

shin yeon-ah does the vocal arrangement! a vocal beast and a music theory queen too!

[@khaleesi7139]

The harmonies are unbelievably good. clashing yet beautifully blended. They breathe at the same parts. That dissonant/clashing harmony that feels kind of ethereal. Shins mix belt also just floored me. Supported, resonant. Ji Young grabs her ear a few seconds before she goes; telling me it must be incredibly resonant

[@ThankYou2NE1]

Shin Yeon is my favorite voice of the group sounds so unique , she can be unstable sometimes but i think thats because of her lower notes i think lower is harder than high sometimes.

[@TheSeeking2know]

My favorite voice too. Someone above mentioned that she sings mostly in her mix rather than chesty so that may affect her going lower.

[@Piupiupiuipiu]

YEES MY FAV TO I HAVE SOME SIMILAR TEXTURE TO MY VOICE AND I NEVER LIKED UNTIL I HEAR HER

[@OscarTuyen]

Thank you for this!! Definitely recommend Ailees killing voice! She’s a vocal queen 😍😍

[@yazmins.2157]

yess Ailee next please!

[@tea4471]

yes !! the 2 i wanted most was bigmama’s and ailee’s

[@waveon6088]

난 이분들꺼 누가 자막좀 넣어줬으면 좋겠다.. 발성적으로 진짜 중요한 부분을 딱딱 말씀해주시네

[@황준승-r7v]

I agree

[@pjuojuo]

17:33 I WAS WAITING FOR SOMEONE TO PICK UP ON THAT AMAZING MOMENT 👏

[@oldsoul_anth243]

Right!

[@Yooki7788]

Only Chase and Melia picked up this moment. They picked up not only this but also many other vocal characters and technique by comparing them.

[@lucasalonso_r]

I'm so happy to see that you noticed this queens. Hugs from Brazil and that your baby comes healthy! 💜

[@3366larryandrews]

Shin Yeon-ah and Park Min-hye released songs starting in 2011 under the name "Big Mama Soul." Since you mentioned that you like both these artists I thought I'd mention it.

[@oldsoul_anth243]

I like Big Mama soul!

[@TheSeeking2know]

As a duo?

[@winterso8589]

Such a treat to see your reaction!! Loved the smiles. Oh, and i learned a new expression, "crunchy chords" 😂 just love this reaction all around 👏👏👏 TY!

[@marqessanzcora4089]

Doesn't matter if I understand, I love❤ their music soooooo much !!!

[@yrraljaime]

As a new fan of big mama, I've been reviewing their discography and they sound so better now.

[@hyunmyunglee1183]

Enjoyed a lot. Let's go with Ailee killing voice next.

[@shj7346]

I'd recommend Kim Feel's Dingo Killer Voice session. His voice will break your heart and feel a longing that is hard to describe.

[@cryingbug134]

They were legend at their time. and ... Now they are all professors in the Department of Applied Music

[@hero4963]

More killing voices please

[@munirah6256]

I really enjoyed their performance even though I don't understand Korean because no screaming just singing ❤️ their songs, their interaction with each other, gem 💎

[@jasonvan6742]

I've been waiting this pt.2 for so longgg!! Love it!

[@채윤정-t1k]

빅마마 4분다 소중하고 최고 👍 💕 😍

[@migwi17]

You should probably watch Shin Yeon-ah's performance of Spica's You Don't Love Me in The Masked Singer.

[@freedomkim4677]

Wonderful BigMama group. Really killing voice. Thanks for reaction.

[@leechs515]

신연아 님에 집중하는 채널은 처음보네요ㅎㅎ 자랑스러워요ㅎㅎ

[@mood.swinger]

Park hyo sin - wild flower!!!!!!! He is the legend 🙌

[@huskydelight]

Big mama releases a new album recently!

[@camimolala]

Jung Seung Hwan killing voice; you are going to love it.

[@아몬드-f6g]

❤big mama ❤lee young hyun

[@soulzaara]

I just cant stop looking at Chase. He looks like a real life Superman 🤣 so handsome ! 😍

[@lam1995522]

I really love your reaction! It’s great to learn and enjoy the music at the same time^^👍🏼

[@MeLodiCarAma]

Very inspiring indeed... Love it.. So much to digest here

[@mzs2453]

I love the way both of your face was crack ….crack and finally jaw crack 😂😂😂

[@h.s.4246]

I enjoyed your reaction to this so much. Thank you for this. Much love and stay safe.

[@salonaterra8631]

Ok, I have been perusing your site, and this video is my favorite of yours. Why? Because I was jamming with you from 01:52 on and both your facial expressions when watching mimicked mine. LOL!

[@stanloona8518]

You should be check Dingo "Urban Zakapa". They are awesome!

[@ella549]

Hi, I recommend you another killing voice from Taeyeon! she's one of the best SK's vocalists and I'm sure you guys will enjoy her vid too, thanks for the video reaction!

[@makima1868]

Finally, you came again, literally thank you and i'm enjoy of your reaction ♥

[@slalomie]

The one on the 2nd left reminds me a bit of Toni Braxton? IMHO these women as a whole are stronger vocalists than the 90’s R&B girl groups I grew up loving to listen to. I’d love if you reacted to the vocalist Golden/GSoul. He’s one of my favorite singers right now and reminds me a bit of Musiq Soulchild & Maxwell.

[@antoinetteantigo6600]

I respect that you guys are experts of music. And you probably sound great. It's great that you are reacting to the singing of these singers who have more experience than you. Half the time you sounded like you guys are saying that Lee Young Hyun has awful techniques. As one of her biggest fans , I felt like I really needed to leave this comment because it is almost as if you're saying that she has no idea about what she is doing. I can tell you a lot about her, her group and their role in Hallyu but I think there isnt any point to doing a litany of what the group has done over the years to many Korean and Southeast Asian Professional Singers and those who sang in hotel lobbies and small venues, like myself because your channel dissects singing and voice as an instrument not much as an expression of the soul and a journey. Reading the description of your channel, I sort of understand why you are so particular about the technical aspects of singing. I agree that the voice is an instrument and we must look after it for it to stay in great condition for a long time but I think music isn't just governed by the science of singing. I think there's a lot to it than just techniques. AND I think that's the reason a lot of singers and groups who stay in the industry for a long time not only for their techniques but for their expression, their emotive ability to connect with people. You probably know this one too because you are experts. I love Big Mama, each and every one of them . I adore them not only for their singing abilities, but their stage presence, their charisma, their laughter on stage. If you would be keen to look for more videos, you'll find that there is so much more to them than what meets the eye and what travels through the eardrum. From Lee Young Hyun's health journey to everyone's commitment to professional development, this group is quite inspirational, which I think makes them really special as musicians and as a group because it is reflected in their performance, the way they deliver the message of their songs. Anywho, I'm talking way too much when all that I wanted to say was you went overboard with the criticism of Lee Young Hyun's voice that you seem disrespectful to her institution and your compliments were not sounding sincere either. Of course, each to their own and I respect your opinion. I just thought you need to hear a "reaction" of your reaction to Lee Young Hyun from one of her fans. All the best!

[@alexiell2]

이분들 기술적으로 설명하는 거, 해석하는 거 한글자막으로 보고싶어요🥲

[@M.J_KIM]

자막 보이기 누르면 영어로 나오는데 옆에 톱니바퀴 설정 모양 누르시면 자동번역하기 누르고 한국어로 번역하면 한글자막 나옵니다.

[@여상현-o4k]

@@M.J_KIM 근대 결국은 번역기 수준이라 뭔 말하는 건지 알아먹기 힘드니 아무래도 제대로된 자막과는 차이가….

[@Horace7]

@@M.J_KIM 자동 번역기 별로 에요 ㅠㅠ

[@-hyejeong-angel-1118]

Ahhhhh i need AILEE KILLING VOICE reaction😬😩🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@TYGsyther]

I hope they listen to the original solo. She sang it down for this performance...

[@5concepts_]

빅마마 bigmama😍🥰

[@Rosannasfriend]

Well, you were talking about how the woman on the left doesn’t use audible breaths like the other lady who is doing a lot of belting, and I just wanna say that that’s really the difference because when you’re singing more gently you’re gonna need to take in less of a breath in the first place. So that’s the reason why she’s able to take in less audible breaths.. It’s not necessarily like a technique issue in the one who’s taking audible breath[In fact she’s using the best technique considering the style she has chosen to sing with], it’s just that her approach to singing is different and makes her need to take audible breaths. She needs more power and more support to do that, which is why she’s using audible breaths.

[@Imosshie14]

That's awesome! 🥰

[@ishansantos8937]

I've been waiting for this!!

[@jasonje125]

The third from the left is currently a professor of a music department of a Korean university.

[@preciousalamu]

It's great watching and learning with you guys. Could you do IU's killing voice and Punch's as well? Thank you!

[@rowanthea2673]

You are so correct that we are drawn to people who sing like us. That's why Lee Jiyoung is my favorite because I'm a alto also love Shin Yeon jazz tone since I'm from New Orleans

[@haineko1989]

I cannot sing and I speak pretty high and childlike, people think I'm like 22 but I'm 35, and Jiyoung is THE voice for me here O.O Just love that O.O

[@blackmeetsred]

I found myself bristling at the way you described the 2nd to the right singer. It felt like a criticism of what is the proper style for the genre. Gospel, R&B, soul, etc. is stylistically covered and supposed to be a heavier sound. I hear you say that you're just "listening technically" but I think you're concept of technique is rooted in a Euro-centric technical framework and a misunderstanding of technique appropriate to style and genre. If you listen to soul and R&B singers these women are emulating (Whitney Houston, Patti Labelle, Toni Braxton...) you'll notice that the technical choices are integral to the genre. The technique of soul is sometimes contradictory to European style vocal technique and if you aren't trained in it, it can cause strain and possible damage. "Technique" is a word used like it's a system with firm rules but all technique is framing. In the Korean genre of Pansori, professional singers are expected to sing in a way that intentionally causes damage to the folds to build on the vocal equivalent of calluses which allows them to sing in a way that European technique would say is "bad technique". As an opera singer who comes from a southern gospel background, I took issue with your framing of technique in these videos as something that simply is good or bad when technique is relative to the musical context and that's especially clear in this group. The singer on the far right is incredibly consistent and stable which is pivotal for a group like this with so many soloists but individually I don't believe she is as successful stylistically. The minute Park sings, the style is shifted to a more Pop and Ballad sound. It's nice contrast in the group and she's definitely a linchpin for the overall sound, but it's technically dissonant to the style. To my ears, it sounds like an opera singer singing musical theatre. It's not bad. It sometimes works really well, but it's not always technically appropriate. Overall, I recognize that you weren't intending to pit the artists against each other by revealing your preferences, but it's hard to do that when you're critiquing technique without regard for style. This was a whole dissertation and I'm sorry for that. I just feel like this commentary was lacking that nuance, and I wish more vocal coaches with platforms would recognize that technique is contextual rather than simply *is*. The technique that works for you is simply the agreed upon path to the genre(s) you would like to sing well in.

[@gentlemen4070]

What a sensational harmony! Thank you so much for great analysis and reaction. Absolutely I agree with you. They are just amazing and incredible group with breathtaking vocal technique and harmony. Please more react to last song "one more day" released in 2021. Have a nice day. kzbin.info/www/bejne/pH6nqaSZqdyerpo (live) kzbin.info/www/bejne/n2KpfqKdir6Kn8k (live)

[@airinre8692]

Check list 1. The Killing voice of Sung si kyung. 2. The Killing voice of Ben. 3. The Killing voice of Gummy. 4. Bohemian Rhapsody by "Forestella"

[@whencanIdie]

Thanks for your vids.

[@SeungJeonFL]

I like Lee's singing over Park's because she has really long phrase that seems to never stop. Even her breathing is part of her phrase!

[@zasharisanchez2627]

Thank you so much for your amazing reactions! I would recommend you watch: 2021 Festa BTS Room Live!! They sing a medley of some of their most famous songs and its a great way to hear more of their voices and styles.

[@davidmera4183]

Ailee killing voice should be the next.. she is an absolutely whole kingdom of vocals.

[@hypeyourmindnext]

You should check their latest song in a full version of it

[@hastiandishmand7613]

Make sure to react to Ailee killing voice.🔥🔥🔥🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻

[@callmemisspizza1665]

PLEASE REACT TO AILEE'S KILLING VOICE SHE'S A QUEEN

[@kimhaneulnim243]

you guys need to react to ATEEZ killing voice. I swear you'll gonna love it 💖💖💖

[@윈드밀-z3x]

우리 신선생님의 진가를 알아주셔서 너무 고마워요~!!

[@yehsuliya]

Loving your videos. I'm enjoying your breakdown very much. I think you guys will really love Aliee. She is an extraordinary artist. If you want to listen to something a little more unique I would also recommend the incredible Leehi. They both have participated in Killing Voice. Another gorgeous voice you would love is by Lee Su-hyun so beautiful!! Another great show is Begin Again, with multiple different artist that do busking, pop up live performances in different countries.

[@Rosannasfriend]

Great reaction

[@TheSeeking2know]

Basics of blending mini-lesson (or series), please! Like seriously. With your choral background you would have something to say. Glad that you noticed Shin's technique and tone some more here. I could listen to an album of Shin very easily. I feel like there's so much potential for expressing different colours depending on lyrics. Love how she navigates her register and just the smoothness (and I love her classy look as well). 20:18 Shin and Park. Peak dual harmonies. 😍 The smooth-voiced ladies, indeed. Just love the love and fun these ladies show to each other and to singing. P.S.: You guys need your own branded water bottle (noticed Melia drinking a large gulp from her red bottle) for your fans. Call it C&M? Chase&Melia? Etc.? Maybe have your favourite phrase printed on them?

[@fatikook221]

guys pls it's a dream of mine to see you guys react ti IU and AILEE's dingo killing voice ! u will not regret it !

[@del0880]

Please react to Ailee Killing Voice too. She is amazing!!!

[@bluezip7]

hey, They are all music professors in Korea.

[@arc2952]

you should check out Mamamoo's "Backwoods" Performance its their first win from the show Immortal Songs

[@kingkong4902]

They sing about 2 hours in concert like that.

[@kevs3702]

Thank you for nice video~! Can you plz react Forestella - scarborough fair?!

[@aangryttiger]

"Bohemian Rhapsody" (KBS Immortal Songs 2) too!

[@idylresaba4609]

IU DINGO KILLING VOICE next plsss💜💜

[@쪼꼬똥꼬-x5n]

Everything you said is wrong. They can sing whatever you want and make sounds any way they like, but they sing it that way to create harmony with the mood and emotion of the song and with each other. Making a blocked sound is also made to convey sad feelings. It's not like they have no choice but to do that.

[@soleilhomedecor7839]

I am really waiting for you talking about killing voice Ailee

[@밍재입니닷]

I would like to suggest you to react to a group called ‘FORESTELLA’ ! You will be impressed by them I confirm! Especially a stage ‘Lezenca save us’ from them!!!

[@IlIllllIII]

I have a question about 08:20. You mentioned about shin, super solid sound and really well supported,, But in the scene where you sing the bridge part, you sing lee's part. (내버려둬 nae ber ryer dwer) So I'm confused whether you mentioned Shin or Lee. Actually Shin sings the melody part and Lee sings high part. Please watch the video again and let me know who you mentioned. 😘😘

[@FlyBabyWhale]

The second singer's name from the right is Lee ji-young, not Linseyan.

[@veach737]

I would absolutely love if you reacted to IU's songs!!!! She has a stylistic but really unique voice, and dabbles into MANY different genres of songs! I would love to hear your analysis for someone who stylistically sings like she does! Not to mention a LOT of her songs are lyrical treasure troves that if you love meaningful songs--it would be an amazing amounts of treasure to dig into!!

[@msy6709]

I waited too long!

[@RickyTham]

Please react to Kim Jong Kook Killing Voice too, he debuted 27 years ago and please use CC to understand what he is saying and the lyrics because Kim Jong Kook song's have a very good lyrics, I assure you. Kim Jong Kook is the 2nd person only in Korea that receives 3 Grand Award from 3 major station for his song (SBS, KBS, MBC) in the same year. The first person who achieved this feat is Cho Young phil in 1980s and also the song that Kim Jong Kook remake in his last song on dingo killing voice is Cho Young phil's old Song. After Kim Jong Kook Receive 3 Grand Award in the same year, korean major station make changes to the rule that the same person cannot receive 3 Grand Award in the same year again. Thus Kim Jong Kook Become the last person ever receiving 3 Grand Award in the same year. So you will not regret it hearing his song, because he is Korean Legendary Triple Crowned Singer and Also Korean Legendary 1st Generation Kpop Idol in 1995 with million seller album everytime releasing the album. Also he is famous because his voice doesn't match his muscular body lol 🤣. Foreign people guessing Kim Jong Kook as Trainer or Bodybuilder before knowing he is a Singer and Entertainers 😅🤣😂

[@RickyTham]

Please react to Kim Jong Kook Music Drama (New Song 2022) the video just up today its an amazing song too please kzbin.info/www/bejne/qYO3h6yZgqdmqbs

[@jeongseoko6629]

빅마마~ 노래-화음 정말 끝내줌...

[@AJ-xb2pk]

❤💜🧡💛💚💙빅마마

[@꼬맹이마더]

박효신 굿바이 라이브공연 추천합니다I recommend Park Hyo-shin's Goodbye Live Performance

[@김기명-w8o]

항상느끼지만 저분들 나오면 지금도 1위 쌉가능이다 전설

[@jyh1299]

You guys should definitely hear them singing Baby Shark. kzbin.info/www/bejne/j2bFi6SdfJZopsU. They are singing it on a talk show for fun, but it's just awesome!!

[@skzstayforever4177]

You can watch them singing at dingo!!!!!!!

[@ppraiifah6089]

Nice reaction and a lot of knowledge 🤩 And please reaction to Ailee killing verse which is my another favorite video on Dingo music 🥰

[@glaubercandidopita]

React Quero Descer - Gabriel Henrique (Cover) React Easy on Me - Gabriel Henrique (Cover Adele) React Endless Love - Gabriel Henrique Ft. Jade Salles (Cover Mariah Carey, Luther Vandross) React O Holy Night - Gabriel Henrique ( Cover Mariah Carey) React Stand Up - Gabriel Henrique (Cover) React I Want to Know What Love Is - Gabriel Henrique (Cover Mariah Carey) React Stone Cold - Gabriel Henrique | Cover React Oceans (Where Feet May Fail) - Gabriel Henrique | Cover Hillsong United React Greatest Love of All - Gabriel Henrique | Cover Whitney Houston React Love By Grace - Gabriel Henrique | Cover Lara Fabian React Talking To The Moon - Gabriel Henrique / Bruno Mars Cover React Gabriel Henrique - All By Myself (Cover Celine Dion) React Gabriel Henrique - Halo (Cover Beyoncé) React Gabriel Henrique - Never Enough (The Greatest Showman)

[@여상현-o4k]

빅마마 킬링보이스 반응 영상중 이분들게 최고인것 같음 아쉬운건 자막이 없단게…;;

[@Iykyk0]

PLEASE react to ailee's killing voice, she is a legendary in kpop THE BEST SINGER FOR ME!

[@Rosannasfriend]

I don’t know if you guys make tutorials anymore, but I would appreciate it if you could do a video on how to sing with less audible breaths, because that’s not something I find natural at all. Thank you. Please.

[@jaemchang]

curious to know y'alls thoughts on Kim Jong Kook's Killing Voice performance

[@peplumtop9339]

Please react to Ailee at Dingo Killing Voice too. She is one of the top female solois in South Korea

[@Babo.Crafts]

Great video!! I'm not sure if this is the correct place to request a video, but please do a React video for Forestella~

[@ARIMY2]

I really enjoy your videos and learn so much from them without even knowing that I was interested and wanted to learn that so thank you for making them! I think you would really enjoy ATEEZ, an amazing K-pop boy group, especially their youngest and main vocalist "Jongho". I suggest their Immortal songs performances, in particular "Black Cat Nero"

[@naanaaya]

Please react to "Girls On Top - Step Back"🤗 You guys gonna love their vocals❤️💯