Low Honor Vs High Honor - Return For The Money (Brutal End) - Red Dead Redemption 2

[@michaellorah9051]

Let's face it, If they made this into a movie, the scene where Arthur charges through the woods, shooting the pinkertons, while screaming Micah and Dutch's names in rage would be one badass movie scene.

[@MegaSteven011]

Michael Lorah it basically feels the same as a movie already haha

[@kodabear464]

*Michael Bay has entered the chat*

[@thejackswavy]

Michael Lorah i just hope they choose the go with john ending

[@elliotgabriel4580]

Hollywood: Ooh, that's a nice idea for a rdr movie. Shame if someone where to... butcher it completely.

[@fzdreaddy]

J Swavy The dishonerable John ending is THE ending to me. "Damn us both!!" BOOM

[@Angel-lk2yd]

Arthur: Donates thousands of dollars to camp Micah: Donates a feather and a pebble "Its mine"

[@Camelotsmoon]

Dutch aswell, he didn't donate shit either.

[@pedrosolorio8243]

Shit I never donated

[@ayoniftekhar1447]

Pedro Solorio lmao me too

[@leenmachine9380]

He took money from the box

[@unclebuns5286]

@@Camelotsmoon dutch used the money to customize his sexy revolvers

[@thegrammarpolice69]

This probably appiles to 90% of the people who played this but... When the game began...all I wanted to do was play as John...and when it ended...I'd have given anything to see Arthur live...

[@StrongSolo]

The Grammar Police I honestly wanted to play as Arthur because I thought he was a interesting character since trailer 3.

[@dog8438]

I never played RDR1 so immediately liked Arthur a lot

[@reapa.h]

Same but i got scammed JOHN CANT SWIM I GOT SCAMMER MOM

[@MrBlack252]

Anything huh? So if you had to give up your game system, TV, and whatever money you have you'd give it all up to see a fictional character live?

[@mariuscorman6997]

@@MrBlack252 its an exaggeration, calm down.

[@labibya6170]

I love the "You let him damn us all" line Arthur says to Dutch. It gives the same intention as " I gave you all I had" but more sinister and shows the low honor side of Arthur.

[@fallen3384]

yeah I agree

[@BaronVonPurp]

Hosea said that before the Saint Denis robbery, when Dutch went after Bronte

[@TheRubberMatch]

That’s the only thing I prefer about the low honor endings. It’s never enough to make me do it, can’t give Micah the satisfaction

[@lionmountain804]

@@TheRubberMatch that's why I've never played Arthur low honor feels wrong

[@here9087]

Low Honor endings make you feel much more of a burning hatred for Micah and Dutch.

[@eltypical1337]

Return for the money: badass 101% Help John: Loyalty and true brotherhod and a true ending

[@victorpleitez768]

I wouldn’t call return for the money badass. It’s just greed, and retribution. Arthur fighting off the pinkertons by himself up on the mountain and beating the tar out Micah despite his tb is looks equally badass as him going after the money.

[@edwardm8292]

No matter what ending I'll say making a last stand, killing pinkertons on a mountain and having a fist fight is a bit more badass for my taste.

[@BongdudeMMA]

If you didnt help John the first time you played the game through, you belong to the streets.

[@eltypical1337]

@@BongdudeMMA lmao ofc I helped John

[@siennapereira8893]

Anony mous the first time I played I had high honour and I went with John

[@calis8]

Only real men cried when Athur said "Thank you" to his horse. Edit: I don't care if you killed your horse so many times and what not. It's just a comment lmfao.

[@ClearLoki]

@@Erakelus why?

[@adolfsmith5191]

wtf I killed my horses 30 times before why would I care they all were bonded fully aswell

[@65firered]

I have a horse for that... It didn't work, you lose all of your horses.

[@gingerale2131]

Adolf Smith i pre ordered it so I got the Ardennes from the start and until the end

[@Esteban-xu8zm]

I had that horse for half my playthrough, my balls dropped at that moment.

[@tonknka7392]

If arthur wasent sick he would probably obliterate micah

[@iAmTheFoeOfInhumans]

Definitely

[@JohnDonovan1968]

julian hernandez Obviously

[@dariusmnc9153]

julian hernandez yeah probaly

[@mightybrighty73]

Trump 2020 I think so. This man can barley breath and he had first shot. Author would play with this men if he never got TB

[@liquidcurse4190]

In fist to fist hell yeah Micha get bodied by the circus guy

[@imakememes3885]

Everybody gangster till “Unshaken” starts playing.

[@sykosyxx1728]

True

[@DutchsTopGoon]

It's gangsta

[@ahhhhhshit1478]

It's Crash Of Worlds, but yea you right

[@gokentuckywildcats]

Yep

[@Smashedhiskeyboardupinthewoods]

Bruh I love the song

[@stylinbarham9502]

Instead of my main horse dieing. I got on my secondary horse and he died. So somewhere my horse Biscuit is alive and well.

[@burntcocaine5794]

I let my main horse die cause when Arthur dies he can be in heaven with Royal

[@PhillieDXO]

@@burntcocaine5794 you just helped me cope with my dear horse lily dying. Thank you, burnt cocaine.

[@lilytheflower-4004]

I named my horse satan, oops

[@aphresuax]

(Finds biscuit in the wild eating classic oatcake) You: (visible confusion)

[@thouxanbandchris]

@Lily the flower •-• bruh i named mine La'Saquan

[@cardiaccoder9622]

Arthur: been with Dutch since he was a child, genuinely cares for members of the camp doing favors daily, donates thousands of dollars Micah: literally some dude Dutch found in a bar, is obviously a back stabber and consistently ruins things Dutch “I just don’t know who to trust”

[@eistee_47_27]

Its all because Hosea died. Dutch was never a Bad guy. I hope in red dead 3 we See Hosea, dutch and arthur at young Age

[@veronicaguerreropantza7545]

@@eistee_47_27 "I dont want to play as Arthur I want to play as Hosea."

[@saviour1754]

@@veronicaguerreropantza7545 Same because young arthur wouldnt sound the same but hosea would probably have the same voice actor

[@mooslatt3599]

Micah literally shot Miss Grimshaw in the stomach in front of everyone and Dutch asked who is betraying me.

[@thesmilingdog3629]

@@eistee_47_27 rdr3 will most likely be about uncle he's in both rdr and rdr2 he's the only one we have no back story for apart from when he mentioned he went to Africa

[@moistvibes5697]

Despite being stabbed and already weak Arthur still kicked micah’s ass meaning if Arthur wasn’t sick he would finish the fight in seconds

[@owenraymond5243]

I don't think he would of even though Arthur is tough micah is amazing with weapons but if it was a fist fight micah would be on the floor

[@MB-zy6gv]

@@owenraymond5243 micha was a quick draw remeber the shootout in Rhodes he was incredibly quick to kill the sniper on the roof but if it was a fist figth Arthur would have finished him in seconds

[@owenraymond5243]

@@MB-zy6gv I know he's a coward in a fist fight (in chapter 1 he punches bill and quickly walks away)

[@Whentanfanle]

Owen Raymond Personally I think if Arthur weren’t sick he’d kick his ass but before that’d happen Dutch would come to stop or Micah would run off

[@fierce4453]

Nah just call his horse the horse be like pow bitch he gets a pistol boom

[@monstermonty9074]

Fun fact: Your here because you can't bring yourself to abandon John. Edit: before you comment a "errr actually" you don't sound like this 😈 you sound like this 🤓

[@retromikexd1198]

I dont know but i just cant leave john

[@novakittypoppyhusky]

I don’t have the heart to get this ending

[@roachct9076]

But you draw the pinkerton's attention to you and give john better chances of survival

[@Anakin_Skywalker47]

I always going back for the money and i always play as a bad Arthur:)

[@szymonbernaciak1963]

Yeah but be honest.Even if u pick Revenge only the high honor is acceptable.I just cant stand watching my boy Arthur being massacred by some rat

[@Doctor_Yodel]

Dutch’s realization that Micah was the rat in the end is perfect

[@spider6579]

K1NG W01FF but the fact that he is still with Micah at the epilogue is still confusing.

[@spider6579]

K1NG W01FF That's a stretch.

[@stoicavasilicamihail95]

@@spider6579 no because then He shoot at Micah and He "save'd" John and Sadie...but then (spoiler)

[@redemption7704]

@@spider6579 if you pay atention in the end, you'll realise that dutch was there to kill Micah

[@spider6579]

Diamond Dog how would you know they weren't working together before john convinced Dutch.

[@brian_the_person]

"I'm half dead and you still can't kill me!" Damn...

[@meris8486]

Going back for the money route had some badass stuff. Cutting out Micahs eye is top of the list

[@nicepfp8958]

Timestamp???

[@AKA_trent]

@@nicepfp8958 7:00 although you prolly already heard it by now

[@nicepfp8958]

@@AKA_trent thx

[@AKA_trent]

@@nicepfp8958 np

[@HobbNoblin]

Low Honor: *Gets stabbed trying to break free* High Honor: *Freakin' bites Micah's hand*

[@savyen]

@Ace Saylor TB zombie 🤣 probably the start of undead nightmare

[@idontcareaboutyouropinion8999]

Ace Saylor it could’ve, but since it was his hand and not anyone near his mouth eyes or nose it’s likely it didn’t take.

[@cominooculto]

@Ace Saylor TB is contagious through air only.

[@CRAZY-M6641]

@Ace Saylor If he spat on his face or cough on his rat ass shit face Micah would get TB Because it is contagious through air only

[@freedomenjoyer1686]

@@CRAZY-M6641 only if

[@cashbanucita0025]

Micah literally stabbing arther in the back its poetic to show his betrayel

[@fellascallmethedrink]

There's a moment in the game that actually foreshadows this too, I think it might have been when Arthur was talking to Lenny but he says not to get too comfortable around Micah because, "He'll stab you in the back." And what do ya know, in the low honor go back for the money ending that happens literally.

[@fauzanmorgan]

Arther

[@skeleton599]

@@fellascallmethedrink micah also says to strauss “ain’t nothing better than stabbing a guy in the back who thinks you like him” something like that

[@huh3804]

No matter how it happens, Arthur’s death is one of the saddest moments in gaming history

[@shawnlittle3091]

I’m not a big gamer but I agree The top 3 as I know to be the saddest and here’s the list. 1. Arthur Morgan 2. John Marston 3. Cole Phelps from LA NOIRE

[@Joe-el2wx]

I personally never really liked Arthur. He may be a good person towards his friends but not other people. Killing innocent people all the time

[@backwhenthingsmadesense9418]

Eddie Pulaski I don’t know about you but my Arthur didn’t kill any innocent people, at least not while I was playing as him

[@Joe-el2wx]

@@backwhenthingsmadesense9418 in missions tho

[@queentrix212]

@@Joe-el2wx That can be said for like, 90% of all protagonists tho...

[@ronnieverma6677]

I’m staying in chapter 2 forever....

[@OutlawKING111]

I liked Chapter 2. Everyone was so happy there.

[@JohnReedy07163]

Personally I would stay in Chapter 3 at the lake forever. But early chapter 3 not late chapter 3.

[@GroovyAsh69]

I would like to be in chapter 4 because I like the camp it’s my favourite spot

[@rus778]

Only thing is alot of the weapons are locked

[@yeah3096]

I didnt know arthur died and the gang turned terrible but i still stayed in chapter 2 most the time and decided to finish the rest in a day

[@jttekton]

Dammit, Arthur forgot to use his Health Cure.

[@dx_Rain_xb]

Late comment: I mean,he did give his satchel to John along with his hat.All he needed is ammo and 2 sidearms.It is possible to get tonics from the agents but it won't do much help

[@AA-bz1pr]

@@dx_Rain_xb Its a joke...

[@dx_Rain_xb]

@@AA-bz1pr I'm exaggerating.

[@Pir-o]

Just like Goku android saga

[@Zur3]

Dang bro you got the whole squad laughing

[@averagejobogio]

Its weird, the High Honor ending where you help John Hits home emotionally , But the high honor ending where you go back for revenge leaves me feeling so badass

[@Slenderslayer351]

@Sam It definitely does and from how I see it, it's going back to kill Micah than returning for the money

[@indykkowalski9366]

It’s not canon Arthur said revenge is a fools game

[@cat.8977]

​@@indykkowalski9366mf was gonna die of tb a week later, killing micah and taking the money is securing john's family for the future

[@Nikawlos]

@indykkowalski9366 Arthur to Milton: "I'm a fool."

[@SliKJonZe]

I was super sad after Arthur died lol. I couldn't believe how attached I was to him. I got the mountain top ending. That music didnt help either. They did a great job on this story.

[@ChengTeoh]

Agreed.

[@brownpanther2953]

i wish you would be free of it all in the end, have arthur with money and just roaming the map, but it wouldnt be the same impact and story which makes it a meaningful one

[@crusadercowboy5712]

Z.o.H it’s crazy how attached I can get to a video game character it really feels like I lost someone

[@rmnlmao5569]

Hit me as hard as when i actually lost a loved one. They have written Arthur *TOO* well

[@jackzter04]

@@ChengTeoh even though I new the ending It hit me like a truck

[@RenMagnum4057]

Arthur should've coughed on Micah

[@nuclearsenshi]

he bit micah so TB can still transfer

[@thesinofwrath092]

@@nuclearsenshi then how is he still alive in 8 years

[@nuclearsenshi]

@@thesinofwrath092 ask rockstar

[@theheck2535]

Arthur never coughed in his face, here's the problem

[@nuclearsenshi]

@@theheck2535 he did

[@santiogo369]

In the beginning of the game Micah says he looks up to Arthur. He Watches all of Arthur's decisions so when you have a high honor Arthur he doesn't kill Arthur but if you have a low honor Arthur Micah can justify killing Arthur to himself because he sees Arthur as just as bad as he is. You can actually see a little bit of remorse in Micah when he stabs Arthur and he says" oh shit look what I gone and done"

[@ashen6579]

He said that out of sarcasm 😂

[@stanlytherobot4933]

He does has some remorse. I think he genuinely thinks Arthur is the one who started the downward spiral, doubting dutch. He has a giant ego. When dutch walks away, you can hear the fear and awe turning into hate.

[@wraith7657]

@Young Thug Leak Station Well that's because Arthur shat on Micah's big ego by saying that even if Micah kills him, Micah still lost in the end.

[@stanlytherobot4933]

@Billy Hindley true, that makes sense. He thought he would get away when Arthur died, but in the end, Micah was the one to lose it all.

[@chillyconmor]

i think he felt remorse when he said "oh shit", but then quickly realized that his emotions were getting the better of him, so he shook it off and put the knife deeper.

[@EliteSpark-tf7kw]

"You let him damn us all, Dutch" Summary of the whole game

[@ye7170]

_"I'll see you around, John Marston"_ That line has a deep meaning to it if you think about what happens to John as well...

[@jaradanthonyhiggins9538]

Rdr1

[@Ek1_xtg]

Holy shit that’s what the top hat man said holy fuck rockstar are good

[@adamknibbs6277]

@@Ek1_xtgrealising that just made my hair stand on end

[@stanlytherobot4933]

I had that little deja vu moment, cause the words had a familiar tinge. Then I realized that *the strange man says it too in the first game.* Seems like everyone's just gonna see john again eventually. They're all waiting for him.

[@TheJzsteven]

Wow dude that’s so deep. Like whole 5ft

[@tommiddleton6590]

Although the high honour and helping John ending is more satisfying. You have to admit that the high honour and go for the money ending is way more badass

[@jeffmates1619]

Low honor and go back for the money hits the hardest

[@jinnybucko3353]

@@jeffmates1619 ya if this was a movie arthur wuld go back to stop micah but get the low honur ending

[@NinjapowerMS]

I wish I could have burned the money on high honor.

[@NinjapowerMS]

@joseph Stalin That's the black water money as far as I'm aware. Not the one they accumulated over the story

[@heyyou9472]

Well, even then Arthur technically is still damned to hell. He may have helped people, but he dies, at the bottom of the mountain, right next to the cave surrounded by fire letting his greed take him. It’s still pretty badass.

[@joeynsenda]

this "I see ya around, John Marston" line hit me directly in my heart

[@agent_toxic8716]

The strange man also said “ I’ll see you around John Marston” 😳😳😳

[@Kanal7Indonesia]

Both went to Heaven 😇

[@Griffolicious]

@@Kanal7Indonesia or Hell. The Strange Man may be the Devil and that theory makes even more sense than the God theory

[@gamedoughnut575]

Like the knife

[@keelandaly1218]

It hit me when Dutch said all I done for u boys

[@Reiza]

No matter the honor, Arthur still care for the horse

[@jgali4049]

@Sam nothing happens, just ignore the horse

[@lololololol3908]

@Sam It is I belive

[@sausagerobbery8215]

Arthur doesn't care for the death of the horse depending on the bond level

[@Nikawlos]

@@sausagerobbery8215 really? the details damn

[@danielhammond9562]

High honor was a better ending in my opinion, made me feel like I at least accomplished something for Arthur's story.

[@bakedlizard6429]

Yeah but which is more fun?

[@hanzohasashi844]

@@bakedlizard6429 the high one.

[@bakedlizard6429]

@@hanzohasashi844 sure

[@Ukaronong]

Of course it is, thats how this game supposed to played tho

[@bakedlizard6429]

@@Ukaronong EVER HEARD OF ROLEPLAY? YOU PLAY IT HOW YOU WANT

[@SocialTag]

Arthur saying thank you to it’s horse when it died was so sad 😭

[@ChengTeoh]

Agreed, especially if that is the only horse you've had contact with for the entire game. RIP Horse.

[@myrez_]

@@ChengTeoh Man, i had that white rare Arabian since chapter 3. I knew my horse would die in a cutscene near the end, so i kept using her until chapter 5. Then, i forgot the horse on the fucking train rails lmao. It was that Gunslinger Quest that i dueled on top of a train. When i saw the saddle icon i knew right away, but i couldn't believe. Almost cried there (and i didn't even saw her dying), imagine how i would cry on the ending cutscene

[@hoopsonwheels]

[tHinK] SocialTag the horse I was on was a stolen nokota since chapter 3 my previous horse died due to an accident involving a hill and some Ó Driscoll gang members chasing me

[@SocialTag]

i have the black arabian horse and i burned someones camp only to realise my $1050 died of the fire so i was so i just loaded the last autosave

[@auzziemozzie7236]

I always got the bad endings

[@Outlaws4life18]

i helped john than died looking at the sun rise

[@familyboy5886]

Your honor was high then

[@pasi2844]

I helped John, and got shot in the head, I wish I could change that.

[@history_addict136]

@@pasi2844 You need to help people, help in the camp, greet people..etc to get high honor. This is the only way to have the ending of looking at the sun. Don't make Arthur an equal to Micah in evil.

[@history_addict136]

@@filleshive7321 Arthur is sick and dying, of course he will always lose the fight. It depends on the honor he has, high or low.

[@Robert-el2kj]

You got good ending

[@m4aragon306]

i only went back for the money with the mentality that i could use the money to support john and his family

[@James-ru7nz]

But isn't john's safety more important than money

[@Maurcie]

@@James-ru7nz but then john would be on the bones of his ass with nothing I see where your coming from though :D

[@abirasamia225]

In that moment I literally thought the same as you and hesitated for a moment at what option should I take, but Im so glad I ended up helping him.

[@edwardbrampton6476]

@Bernardo Andrade Picorelli same and I thought I would be able to help John in the future because I knew he would be safe because of the next game

[@mrmojorisin41]

I went for the money in my first playthrough, knowing he would survive and go to california, in a sanatorium..(i had low honor, cuz' i robbed and killed a lot of folks)

[@aegis8157]

I tried to prevent the ending 1. *_I wore a bandana when I came to Mr. Downes...well of course, its a cutscene... it wont work_* 2. *_I tried to shoot Mr.Downes and it wont let me_*

[@ChengTeoh]

lol, I DO love what you are trying to do. Can I tell you, I actually tried doing things like that just to see if I can break the sequence too.

[@louislin199]

I tried raiding the downes farm and kill every living thing there and burn the fields and house down before the mission even pop up, but well, not even volatile fire bottles work

[@belianthir]

@@louislin199 even if they did, they would just respawn

[@aegis8157]

Cheng Teoh I also noticed something *_Micah survived 28 STAB WOUNDS_*

[@zaokdimenoms7670]

@@aegis8157 Micah was playing non-stop so the cheats carried over

[@Natenator77]

Makes me think Arthur should have attacked Micah with his TB. A well aimed glob of blood-spit, or a few heaving coughs in his face could have sealed the deal. Even if he wasn't strong/lucky enough to win head on, he would have doomed Micah to the same fate. Now that I think about it, Arthur could have done it to him in his sleep - before it all came to this point.

[@chaddeus8131]

lol I'm imagining Arthur sneaking in Micah's tent just to spit on his face

[@normaaliihminen722]

I would have do that if I were in Arthur's position. Man Micah would have no clue what was coming to him.

[@jcie3424]

There was a similar story to this where a centaur got his revenge to hercules even after his death

[@normaaliihminen722]

@@larrymunn5279 ''TB doesn't work like that.'' You obviously know about TB however How then Arthur got infected with TB?

[@LegendaryGooseling]

Normaali Ihminen he got mr. Downs blood in his mouth

[@empurata7894]

When Arthur said “thank you” to his horse I just started bawling my eyes out

[@brolynotbroli.]

Me to TokeyTF me too

[@nickitysplit1232]

Crying over a horse XD You're such a wimp

[@empurata7894]

@@nickitysplit1232 if you even play the game, you’ll understand 😄

[@nickitysplit1232]

@@empurata7894 I did complete the game, 3 times to be exact, and never cried at the horse's death a single time.

[@empurata7894]

@@nickitysplit1232 people cry at different things, don’t be a dumbass

[@cameraman4549]

Micah's "Oh Shit..." Almost sound genuine, like he wasn't expecting to win.

[@jonas-savimbi3765]

It sounds more like a "Oh shit I just broke a window" than an "Oh shit, you're dead"

[@jlm5743]

When?

[@melvinbigsmokeharris7640]

Yeah he was genuinely surprised that he beat Dutch's right hand man. Even though, he's already dying from TB.

[@JoseMora-wc5zz]

It really was lol, like “oh shit, you couldn’t beat me after all.” Lol

[@StefanWinchester]

He knew even a half dead arthur kept alive by sheer hate and adrenaline would be the toughest fight of his life

[@the1plaguedoctor]

I think when Arthur is about to die (in all endings) and spills his heart out to Dutch, that when Dutch finally loses it all. I feel like he realizes what he did to everyone and regrets what he did, that’s why he shoots Micah when John brings it back up in the end

[@Anakin_Skywalker47]

I always going back for the money and I always play as a bad Arthur

[@hulkbelowall9532]

@@Anakin_Skywalker47 YEAH YEAH thing is Jason will ALWAYS be better than you

[@matthewfreiley645]

Yes!!! Whatever the reason, I'd say Dutch kinda makes up for all the bad he did by shooting Micah.

[@Anakin_Skywalker47]

@Riley MacDonald thanks i appreciate now where is my sister!?!?

[@Anakin_Skywalker47]

@@hulkbelowall9532 i know jason is better than me but I'm more evil

[@am57950]

How did this not get the Game Of The Year Award?!?!?

[@buttfacemcgeegaming7964]

Anghus Mulder because god of war

[@PokemonTrainerVince]

Bad gameplay mechanics.....

[@AlfredFJones1776]

SuperVince93 Except it doesn’t have those

[@basegnome]

@@AlfredFJones1776 I wouldnt say it is bad but it cant compete with god of war combat

[@micha45399]

Because this get the game of the history award

[@unicornrainbow6916]

4:13 *not even colm* hit me directly in the heart.

[@brolynotbroli.]

Not even your worst enemies but your friends

[@n01r.007]

No

[@Vanerov]

@@n01r.007 Stop trolling low life.

[@coolsceegaming6178]

@@brolynotbroli. it hits hard when someone says even you enemies aren’t that low, and the O’Driscols are the definition of bad people

[@adamchavez8616]

honestly, even colm’s death was sad to me because even though he was a bad person you really got to see that genuine fear in his eyes right at the end…

[@connormitchell6446]

In the high honor version of this scene Dutch seems genuinely heartbroken when Arthur and Micah are fighting

[@beastak2207]

No He Is Heartbroken In Every Version High Honor and Low Honor

[@Selhanee]

Arthur: * exists * Every single living thing: * shoots arthur * Arthur: ouch Arthur: * get stabbed during a cutscene * Also arthur: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH

[@darthvader3078]

WE JUST NEED MONEY ARTHUR

[@SlySinatraa]

Do you have a plan?

[@xcyanidegamerx4402]

He thrusted and twisted the knife though.

[@HumanCucoo]

I imagined the Snake death yell

[@johnnyp7289]

Dutch Van Der Linde Jesus Dutch have some GODDAMN FAITH

[@Videosrockyouuup]

Low Honor: You lose and get killed by Micah. High Honor: You kick Micah's ass and die Peacefully. Personally I preferred the go John Marston ending but this was another great ending option. :)

[@kmck1008]

I had low and it seriously made me mad 😂😂 It kinda made killing Micha as John a lot sweeter tbh 😂

[@gutsngonads661]

Which is bullshit because low honor Arthur is a bad ass and should stomp Micah's teeth in

[@erezben14]

Tbh the only logical ending is to help John imo

[@miatinsley8524]

Technically Arthur won in my opinion because his main goal the whole time was to get John And his family to safety and he accomplished that goal, I think it doesn't matter if you have low or high honor.

[@xcyanidegamerx4402]

@@gutsngonads661 Not really, the game is pretty much saying with high honor the effects of tuburcolosis are less (which you can see in some cutscenes)

[@feelsman7837]

Micah: **Shoots miss Grimshaw, rats on everybody, stabs Arthur in the heart** Dutch: *in disappointed dad tone:* _„Oh Micah, you fool.“_

[@cominooculto]

I fuckin hate dutch more than i hated micah

[@taeminoutdid]

Dutch: thinks Arthur and John betrayed him

[@a3milia_875]

cOmInO YESSSSSSSSSS SAME HERE

[@dennishuang7764]

Dutch is just SOOOO fucking USELESS in both endings, he literally just walks away still knowing that Micah was the one who destroyed his gang

[@miss.brun0]

Arthur’s death when he goes back for the money is straight up sickening to me. It’s such a sad, pathetic way for such a beautiful character to die. I can’t imagine how anyone would be remotely happy with that ending.

[@AnacondaVice]

It's the most realistic ending, Arthur did talk about getting the money for John's family, also in this ending Dutch seems to realize that Arthur was right.

[@rinzler1801]

some people like hardcore and gritty endings more than endings where the main character stares off into the sunset

[@WinsomeFaun60]

I always have high Honor and I Help John

[@aruen4575]

@@rinzler1801 doesn’t make sense for Arthur to do it

[@Matthewgaming20]

@@WinsomeFaun60 same

[@florvillota5]

Low honour: Wolf/coyote High honour: Deer/Buck

[@union4814]

Low honour is more iffy because it could be a wolf or a black coyote but high honour is definitely a buck

[@DeliciousOrphanToes69]

Max high honor I'm pretty sure is a eagle

[@nixility2139]

SahgamerZ nah, it isn’t. I dont think you even see the eagle at the honor scenes, [S P O I L E R A L S O] if arthurs honor was in the middle, he probably would’ve gotten a gravestone but instead of a wolf/coyote or a buck, it would be an eagle

[@DeliciousOrphanToes69]

@@nixility2139 kzbin.info/www/bejne/d3nYcn6mhsaohZY Just saw this, go to bottom comment and read the subcomments

[@ctm479]

PS4 Gamer5672 no it’s a fox I think

[@yaeldiazruvalcaba9698]

It would have been great if instead of saying "Return for the money" said "Revenge", because they remember Arthur's phrase: "Revenge is a game for fools" at that time the player would have to remember it to do the other way, the which is much better and is where he would achieve redemption (sorry if my English is bad, I don't speak English usually :c)

[@alexkhaid]

English is fine, agree with you. But Arthur also achieves redemption by helping john

[@owenraymond5243]

I think it should of said hold micah off then more people may have gone for this ending (oh mate your english is fine)

[@nickdapeeps]

bud your English is great

[@willcresson8776]

You've better English than a lot of native speakers I know.

[@louiswaze4603]

@@alexkhaid agreed, there’s no logical reason for Arthur to return for money since John refused the idea and even revenge feels like a pretty poor motive after Arthur’s transformation as a character (assuming the game is played as intended)

[@idontleavestillchill4371]

If Thomas Downes did not owe money this would not have happened 🙁

[@ChengTeoh]

True.

[@paulgeorge2695]

TB changed Arthur if it wasn't for that he'd be selfish

[@HumanCucoo]

Oh yeah Oh yeah

[@Biggdaddy-y5y]

@@youknowmyswagnotmystory9319 fuck off

[@spotty4849]

If Arthur didn’t get tb he would’ve kicked Micah’s ass

[@Karlonsan]

07:03 "I'm half dead and you still can't kill me." Fuck, that is such a badass quote, damm. This single phrase here shows even the gap in skill the two had. Arthur being way more skilled than Micah, who, in all healthiness, is struggling to fight a half dead, sick Arthur.

[@crankymcgee]

Don’t even have to select Antagonize 🤌

[@jameshay3664]

micah is an excellent gunslinger, he just cant brawl

[@memecliparchives2254]

For those who choose low honor endings and say it's better than high honor, I WANT NOTHING TO DO WITH ANY OF YOU.

[@dutchvanderlinde4668]

I think they mean the last cut scene with the wolf looks cooler than the deer. I agree, but I chose high honer

[@radias2589]

Likewise

[@QuackingDragon]

I got the high honor, and I love that he dies somewhat peacefully. But the low honor endings feel more realistic with Micah coming back to finish him off, rather than just walking off.

[@gamerambassador5066]

k

[@memecliparchives2254]

@@QuackingDragon Micah is all about survival, looking after only for himself and living. With Pinkertons on his tail, he won't waste his time and precious LIFE out of a grudge. Like he has an obsession over Abigail and probably wants to take her away from John for himself, but he's willing to let her be executed when she got captured. It's not like Arthur is gonna live after the beating he had and kill him someday. "I wanna live cowpoke, I still got the choice"

[@footballnotsoccermrn1186]

4:25 when Dutch slowly looked at Micah, I thought for a second that Dutch would have killed Micah. And said sorry to Arthur just before he died. And the reason why he went mad, is because he lost someone who felt more like a son then anyone else. And he blames himself for the death of Arthur, therefore he went insane.

[@Joe-qw6xg]

He lost Hosea too.. That's when he got insane.. He knew that he was alone in keeping the gang safe and that was a difficult thing for him.. So he started doubting his friend who knew so many years and started trusting the one knowing only months just because he promised him glory and money..

[@footballnotsoccermrn1186]

Joe I was talking about him full on going mad in rdr1, but that was a huge factor in it.

[@Joe-qw6xg]

@@footballnotsoccermrn1186 Oh yeah.. I suppose that was the outcome from losing all of his friends-family (well I'm pretty sure back in rdr 1 times rockstar didn't think for the future rdr2 so we can say that losing all of them made him insane 😅)

[@samsonstevens7181]

The reason he originally started to go insane was because of all the people he lost. Hosea, lenny, and more. I feel like he was perfectly sane when he brought the gang to get Jack. That was one of the best moments ever.

[@otobakashvili705]

Dutch was insane even before Arthur died.

[@IcyianCanehdian]

The way Arthur rises his voice at 8:04 gave me chills when I first played this ending

[@grapefruitjuice9473]

In go for the money Arthur's voice is normal instead of the weak one he has in help John

[@edwardm8292]

If you hear Arthur screaming out your name in the middle of a forest... RUN

[@jovannyosorio8276]

@@grapefruitjuice9473 Maybe because he fell 2 or 3 meters in help john, instead here he just gets stabbed.

[@Ryuxun]

@@jovannyosorio8276 "He just gets stabed." Since when falling 3 meters is more damaging than being stabed ?

[@jovannyosorio8276]

@@Ryuxun Well falling directly in the back hits your lungs, instead he gets stabbed in the lower back.

[@DannyProton]

Watching Arthur get up on his elbows and slowly fall to the ground, is absolutely heart breaking. he just survived the worst raid they'd gotten since blackwater, and he was left to himself, but it was too late because his body was just too weak. I honestly feel like he could have just barely gotten himself out of there man

[@captainbeastwinger4940]

High honor mountain version still the best

[@sethbuckles3474]

I think low honor mountain scene is the most realistic and hurtful to watch. It actually brought me to tears

[@barrymccockiner773]

NaWlePen you’re not lying. I was borderline depressed after my first play through and seeing Arthur die the way he did.

[@EthanBradburyVlogs]

@@sethbuckles3474 shut the fuck up

[@lipebauducco]

perfect final

[@rstriker21]

captain beastwinger disagree

[@OhdeerOhfrancis]

Arthur: *dies and goes to heaven* found ya Lenny

[@Dancing-Bomb]

Lol

[@Zombiewho117]

LEEEEEEENAAAAAHHHHH!!!

[@mifikdays2040]

Dont think Arthur would go to heaven well maybe god would make an exception

[@faustus4443]

the spirit animals in the end of the game have meaning. the sun rising on arthurs spirit animal shows god forgave him.

[@kermit1082]

@@faustus4443 and the dark spirit animal means that Satan is leading arthur to hell

[@sshadowsiight1503]

Did you know? Somewhere in HorseShoe Overlook Hosea, Charles and some others i think had a conversation and asked Arthur something, i dont know what they said but his answer was this: "Face me to the setting sun so i can remember all the happy times we had together." If you choose to help Johnnand have high honor, when he dies, he watches the setting sun! What a beautifull masterpiece, i played the game and its amazing

[@ChengTeoh]

Hmm, I wasn't aware that Hosea, Charles & Arthur had such a conversation. Do you remember if it was at night near the fire when they said that?

[@sshadowsiight1503]

@@ChengTeoh No, it was at that round table (im not sure if it was round) next to Dutch's tent and Pearson's butcher table. It was day when they had it. Im also not really sure if Charles was there, but i know 100% that Hosea was there. Edit: Tilly and Lenny were there Edit 2: It was still a bit light but night begun to rise. Also the table wasnt round, its just like any other dining table. The table right infront of Pearson's butcher

[@unoriginalhazard]

he watches a sunrise at his death lol

[@julianfletcher1912]

It's the rising sun but ok

[@thebruh1883]

he dies watching the sun rise. but his grave is facing the sun set.

[@Jurr]

5:06 Best part about this ending is that you get to see that Micah literally is a backstabbing rat

[@canaldamia8393]

Arthur a rat?

[@canaldamia8393]

Sorry I misread

[@JusticeForTheWin]

​@canaldamia8393 did you read "backstabbing a rat"

[@cocob0l0]

I feel like a part of me died with Arthur. I’ve never felt anything like this towards any fictional character in my entire life. Arthur... you did your worst... you tried your best... now it’s time to rest. And rest easy. You got your Redemption.

[@myrez_]

Saaame, i kept crying for like 3 days straight when i remembered the ‘Thats the way It is’ scene and when Arthur says he was afraid. Really sad indeed

[@Dom_510]

best protagonist ever

[@StanleyKubick1]

because all you've read in your life was YA novels and y/n

[@Dom_510]

Foxtrot Mike Lima what the fuck is a YA novel?

[@4skintim962]

Foxtrot Mike Lima wtf are you talking about you extra chromosomed idiot

[@Jawunleashed]

Arthur is so powerful, whether or not he's honorable controls the weather! *GOD RESPECTS ARTHUR MORGAN CONFIRMED.*

[@WinstonSempai]

Weather report

[@java-x1w]

This is actually right. The Pagan ritual site will lower Arthur’s honor when damaged Same for native burial site

[@MFShroom5]

6:16 Micah: gets slashed 4 times Also micah: is that all you got black lung?!

[@jeremyrich123]

I know right.

[@Camelotsmoon]

Ikr, I'm like bro, he slit your throat 3 times in a row. Though, when John shoots him in the epilogue, he walks off 6 shots to the face a few seconds.

[@BLVCK-VINCI]

I don't even know why they let us fight it out. I would destroy micah if he wasn't in God mode.

[@BLVCK-VINCI]

@Ace Saylor I mean why didn't they just make it a cutscene I liked fighting himbut I preferred it to be a cutscene.

[@bishopjackfrost]

@Vermin Supreme and uncle

[@asylumskp4391]

Say what you will but we can agree the low honour money ending has the best dialogue. You can see Arthur's emotions much clearer here. He's trying to make Dutch guilty and realize what he'd done, and showing all the hate he had for Micah. That one line especially hits hard, "Not Molly, Dutch. Him! Kill him. Not Molly, not Miss Grimshaw. Not even Colm." Really puts the point on how crazy Dutch was at this point. Not even his biggest enemy, Colm O'Driscoll, would even do shit like he did. While I think high honour help John ending is canon, this is really damn good voice acting, especially when Arthur sounds like he's about to cry on that line.

[@domclegg1225]

yeah facts, low honour ending here is way better. but I still think the 'true' ending is high honour after saving john

[@coltbusick6644]

The image of Arthur and Micah fighting as the camp burns is one of my favorites in the whole game. The lighting, the emotions, the dialogue. I go with John most of the time so I don’t get to see it a lot though.

[@diablosghost3403]

I know John kills Micah but I want a zombie Arthur to absolutely beat the shit out of Micah in a possible non canon dlc Thanks for the likes and comments.👍

[@xXxpowerbagxXx]

Michah gets killed so he would be a zombie too

[@NanaNEET]

Diablosghost Undead nightmare was very popular in the first rdr and so it maybe it should come back.

[@Agent.K.]

He was already dead after Dutch shot him.

[@diablosghost3403]

Khrys Zeverilion this made me think what if ever other gang member that died would also return as part of the undead

[@NGG716]

I think that arthur morgan gonna kill micah in undead nichtmare

[@TheAwesomeDarkNinja]

4:09 "Kill him! Not Molly! Not Miss Grimshaw! Not even Colm..." Wow that hurt. Honestly this option is still phenomenal. I wish it wasn't 'go back for the money' but instead 'stop Micah and Dutch'. I feel like a lot more people would choose this ending.

[@Melly_Wayy]

Yeah that dialogue stands out to me in this ending definitely, I just wish it was a way we could know what was going through Dutch’s head then

[@EricToTheScionti]

@@Melly_Wayy Its obviously he realized he fucked up.

[@GuitarHeroHardyMaste]

@@EricToTheScionti it seems that arthur wakes dutch up from his fantasy where everything in his head is a game, micah had been slowly turning everything into a game for dutch, boosting his ego and making dutch believe he is essentially an incredible mastermind, arthur calling micah out to his dying breath and truly realising that arthur is dying shatters the fantasy and truly drives him mad but also makes him realise he is nothing more than a bandit running from the law, and every plan he made was set up in a way to play off of his prideful nature and arrogance to keep failing and getting people to die. micah drummed up a hatred for john and arthur to fuel his egotistical mindset as he probably believed they just didn't understand how great he thought he was which kept his mind away from questioning micah since he only sucked up to dutch and played on his weakness of being afraid of being isolated after molly left him. dutch was probably dragged into arthur's pace at that point since he was the only person after shady belle to be able to speak to him and get through to him that wasn't planting ideas in his head and was talking realistically. before he could just blow it all off as people being small minded and high strung, at that point arthur didn't beg to live or ever asked for help so he got through to dutch, abliet at the cost of his life and far too late. it's also why i think dutch ditches the savings in the epilogue and just lets john take it, arthur shattered his fantasy and he no longer had an attachment to the money or his dreams, dutch realised he had let everything slip and did it willingly, he no longer has the family he would die for so he knows the money is meaningless and he also knows he had just killed his family by branding people as traitors and being unwilling to let people go since it would damage his ego.

[@BLVCK-VINCI]

Dutch is a bitch for letting Micah live i would've hated him less if he killed him.

[@JuanmaUG]

Its verh crude

[@digbick9415]

That song when he was walking through the woods back to camp was so epic I crapped my stomach out.

[@bigmute9533]

whats the song

[@jovannyosorio8276]

@@bigmute9533 search "i cannot be stopped rdr2" and there it is.

[@joe_z2042]

@@bigmute9533 its mountain finale. It's on spotify in the soundtrack

[@spudly98]

It's been a year and this still gives me the feels :'l

[@CatchTheMarmosets]

Jim Pickens w h a t

[@noobplayer-_-1232]

Well 2 now

[@ieuannicol6283]

I never even knew the high honour return for the money ending existed

[@dinaz9111]

I think it's the best ending

[@HDeppix101]

Msk Tnsi my personal favorite

[@cabbagepenelope5743]

Msk Tnsi I kinda do like it but I do prefer the high honor mountain one it’s more satisfying

[@MouseR985]

@@cabbagepenelope5743 more satisfying than taking Micha's eye? Hell nah

[@cabbagepenelope5743]

Nyan Cat - Gameplays but as arthur said revenge is a fools game

[@paxman4854]

Btw if you do it with high honor when you meet Micah again as John he has the scar on his eye

[@ChengTeoh]

Thanks for the info, yes I have a video that shows Micah with the scar and without. :D

[@fizzycolapop362]

Good. Fuck that no-good bastard.

[@michaelbennett1350]

Damn I’m gonna have to redo it just to see Arthur leave that piece of shit with a battle scar.

[@Theguywithwrizz]

breen bright.everyday cool!

[@codybethel4142]

Micah: “I’m taking every cent of that money!” Also Micah: “YoU CaMe To StEaL fRoM dUtCh!”

[@fellascallmethedrink]

Bruh moment

[@wanderingwalrus137]

@@fellascallmethedrink bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh bruh

[@kittyisbutter8974]

Even my teacher played red dead redemption 2

[@OutlawKING111]

That's one cool teacher.

[@nicholastabatadze]

My 9th grade math teacher played it, someone asked if he had a PS4 he said yes, then I asked him what's his favorite game, and he said rdr2. and basically the entire class was just talking to him about. It for 20 minutes. It's a good way to get out of doing calculus

[@viewer1755]

Why not it is the best game I’ve ever played

[@kohnermahan]

Kitty is Butter one of mine did too

[@sethwagner6902]

Same

[@landonallen8099]

Rdr2 undead nightmare Arthur comes back John ties him up John stops the plague and boom Arthur comes back to life

[@ayobi2038]

You definitely don't understand how it works...

[@ayobi2038]

@@qqe9745 LOL HOW TF DO YOU THINK R/Whoosh WORKS?

[@mrbruh2689]

Ayobi you didn’t play the first game dumbass

[@neiljohnson291]

@@ayobi2038 The first game states that a mask can be returned as its a cure. If its returned then the plague is cured.

[@arthurviana7353]

@@neiljohnson291 the plague is cured, and the deads became Deads again

[@alexpollock6932]

I personally think helping John with high honor is the best ending. It’s so climactic and really gives Arthur good bitter sweet ending

[@rstriker21]

It's anticlimactic IMO bc Arthur basically says I'm tired and can't go on any longer, going back for the money is much more powerful

[@ondeaddogsyahurd4648]

Idk man.. Arthur charging down that hill, taking out a squad of Pinkertons and slicing Micahs face open beat him running up a mountain, giving up and dying to TB. At least in my opinion.

[@myrez_]

@@ondeaddogsyahurd4648 agreed

[@sulkii9437]

@Layne G No one asked for you to exist, and you sadly did.

[@popcornfilms1]

OnDeadDogs YaHurd then you have missed the entire point of the game

[@aisonjorgenson5492]

It’s sad to see Dutch finally see the truth at the ending. He knows what Micah has done and he knows Arthur is still loyal but he can’t save him :(

[@wavenomad9658]

No lie I cried so much in the ending, I connected so much with Arthur and I just felt sad in the end, it was a very good story

[@billylewis319]

It's a sad scene because its so human

[@JoaoBrasil_]

Same here :(

[@ajjohnson3416]

Same here man I was disappointed

[@moodylad2033]

Especially when that God Damn horse the fool got scared whenever he'll see a mountain lion or panther, I miss her already and the way Arthur just says "Thank You" is well enough especially with Buell

[@landonhough6905]

Edrell Mandrique I wanted to cry so bad!!! I really tried but I couldn’t make myself cry

[@Dom_510]

High honor return for the money is the best ending, Arthur still gets redemption but also displays that regardless he's still a flawed man. I feel like it also has a better ending between the three of them

[@Erakelus]

Yeah it was best

[@NoU-pf8fc]

Yea I wished I had picked that one instead of helping John now, Arthur goes down in a badass manner, and how can I forget the fact that you can scar Micah’s face?

[@NoU-pf8fc]

Jimmy S Yea, and I guess you can say that John isn’t the only “Scar Face’’ (as Micah says it) anymore

[@NoU-pf8fc]

Jimmy S agreed

[@arceuslegend4605]

No, not really, no. I agree that it's a play on him being flawed, but the entire Chapter 6 he's constantly told to be a good man and he even put an end to Strauss's loansharking business within the gang. I like helping John better because it emphasizes that, now that he's faced with his own mortality, Arthur decides to do something right before he goes. The sister tells him to make a loving act. Blind Man Cassidy also constantly tells him to save John or, at the very least, not go after the money: >Make your final moments your best moments, sir. Know glory and forget about shame. >Your whole life is one of regret... but it can end better than it began. >You must decide between your past and other's future, friend. Decide, for it will be too late. >That which is killing you will help you, finally to see. And see clearly friend. See and hear. >Even when all reason is lost, and all truth has become lie, you will stand firm. For loyalty is both your saving and your curse. Really it feels like such a let down to not make something meaningful out of Arthur's last moments.

[@taq6448]

I just realized that on the mountain John said too Dutch "Why are you here?" and Dutch said "Same as you I suppose." meaning that dutch played micah and joined back with him just too kill him when john came.

[@joshuagross3151]

4:25 The symbolism here is striking. Micah is beckoning Dutch towards him as our camp burns in the background, indicating his way has brought ruin to our family. As Dutch walks away, his figure is split between a calm darkness and a fiery Hell, suggesting his mentality is walking a very tenuous line. He trips at the last second, seemingly staggering towards the fire, indicating that he's begun to slip.

[@scullyf2254]

The good honor endings are just good and sad BUT DAMN DID I ENJOY SHOOTING MICAH WITH ARTHUR'S GUN!

[@jackstafford3986]

,how'd u do that

[@flyboyarch6776]

Jack Stafford probably just used a gun he mostly used throughout the game

[@xcyanidegamerx4402]

I used arthurs gun (my personally first made vulvanic pistol) and played through the whole game and epilogue

[@radias2589]

I think he ment the golden double action

[@chefofthetrash]

I made sure I was only using Johns cattleman and Arthur’s cattleman which I had the hero grip on and is the same one that I had from the start during American venom

[@ulqourra6624]

Low Honor: Wolf for the savage thing you have done.. High Honor: Deer for the Good things you have done.. I guess thats that..

[@agent_toxic8716]

“YOU LIBE SAVAGELY THAN YOU SHALL DIE SAVAGELY”

[@agent_toxic8716]

*live

[@arthurmorgan9560]

Coyote

[@Anakin_Skywalker47]

I play as a bad Arthur for 2 years

[@taeminoutdid]

If Arthur didn't have Tuberculosis he would have ended Micah

[@hyperraidsaerofrights5649]

For those who disagree, Arthur was sick and literally stabbed and still held his own against micah.

[@hulkbelowall9532]

@@hyperraidsaerofrights5649 I mean no one did......so.......BUT I AGREE

[@hyperraidsaerofrights5649]

@@hulkbelowall9532 I've seen alot of people who disagree with similar comments like this.

[@hulkbelowall9532]

@@hyperraidsaerofrights5649 they have less than one atom of a braincell so I wouldnt be calling them people

[@mariomorgan6083]

@@hulkbelowall9532 it's logic, Javier almost knocks out Micah in one punch Javier gets his ass handed to him by Tommy Arthur whoops Tommy's ass Now imagine Arthur's strength compared to that rat's on the spectrum

[@zottorus6176]

I love how in the high honor ending, Arthur can only see a glimpse of the sunlight. This shows that he tried his best to overcome the giant he had inside him, but he just wasn’t able to at the very end. He was a good person, but something just held him back, thus granting him a glimpse of what he *could’ve* been

[@godzillazfriction]

Arthur was never a good person

[@freezedupfrost6064]

It ain't that deep bruh, it's just sunlight

[@zottorus6176]

@@freezedupfrost6064 If that’s how you want to view it, go right ahead.

[@freezedupfrost6064]

@@zottorus6176 You are acting like they meant it to be exactly like you said which they didn't, a guy dying after seeing a sunrise ain't no new way of showing a sad death

[@zottorus6176]

@@freezedupfrost6064 Okay, whatever you say. Go about your day.

[@aregisteredpyromaniac2629]

Arthur: can survive multiple bullets to the chest Also Arthur: *dies to one stab wound* (Edited because i changed my profile stuff)

[@Lakers24bn]

plot armor went off

[@Kapone.313]

wE StiLL nEed MoNeH

[@noahharris276]

Multiple actually, like six or seven, and you know, TB. Your were also probably shot multiple times before.

[@Lumbago-box]

T W E N T Y - S T A B - W O U N D S

[@CRAZY-M6641]

*slices Micah 5 times in a row* Okay i guess i'll catch you later then...

[@olliemakesvideos125]

“Greedy snakes always die first!” *”Then why are you still alive?”*

[@SillyChickenMan1]

"Still making jokes!"

[@rossdlggamer1034]

Arthur is up in heven...or hell in a saloon partying with Lenny and the rest of the gang that died through the tough journey

[@asl1218]

Arthur is up there with Hosea, Lenny, Jenny, Mac, Sean, his wife and kid and Davey.

[@thetramitrain8431]

I would like to think that

[@radias2589]

He is not in heaven

[@furiousape7717]

Even if you have Arthur on high honor he still ruined countless lives with all the innocent police he killed. He may have been good on the inside, but he did some horrible things.

[@radias2589]

@@furiousape7717 finally someone gets it! All the people Arthur kill had wives and children back home and I wouldn't be surprised if Arthur orphaned some poor kid

[@Yougotcaged102]

I love how John dosen't take Arthur going back personally. With all they did even in that situation he can understand why Arthur wants revenge, despite if it was all he stood against.

[@alimotlagh8177]

Everyone, let's have high honnor in real life. 😔

[@madman-mw2kk]

I'll give a like my boah

[@davartheberserker]

Amen

[@Fraizer-_-106]

No

[@krater9256]

yes give a like my boah sausage and arthur rip

[@asylumskp4391]

@Schoby elaborate why?

[@grimreaper_cz]

When my horse died .what saddened me even more was the fact that I took Hamish's horse Buell after he died 😭😭😭 May they reunite in the afterlife

[@mariomorgan6083]

Who??

[@sideways_chip_eater6420]

@@mariomorgan6083 theres a side mission where you help some veteran and after about 3 or 2 side missions with the dude he dies by a boar then you get to take and keep his horse

[@mariomorgan6083]

@@sideways_chip_eater6420 where can I find him I'm playing as John right now

[@sideways_chip_eater6420]

@@mariomorgan6083 its sort of near annesberg at some pond with a legendary fish and can only be found as Arthur but if you do the first side mission as Arthur then you play as John then you can interact with him later

[@mariomorgan6083]

@@sideways_chip_eater6420 oh ok thanks

[@thewall0669]

Micah would've lost to healthy Arthur in fist fight, gun fight, hell any fight

[@dinorex3464]

Everyone here is talking about Roger Clark's amazing performance and you're right, but is no one going to talk about Peter Blomquist? 4:41 is one of the most perfect line-delivery I've ever heard. It really feels like someone who just realised all his plan just failed.

[@Dark-gb5xx]

This ending is wayy better than helping john (no matter the honor) -You go to kill micah intentionally (arthur says he's been waiting for this early in fight) - The knife fight scene with the whole camp burning around literally feels as if we are fighting in hell and dragging our enemy rather than fighting with fists at night on a mountain -Arthur slices micahs eye and bites his hand , and in epilogue micah has one eye (damn i love that micah spent almost 8 year without an eye and everytime he remembers why he lost he remembers arthur) -Arthur doesn't look like a sad helpless guy who barely able to speak/ (after dutch came in other route , he could barely speak like "oh dutch" or 'john made it') -Dutch tells/requests to stop fight you can he has that regret expression here from the start resulting that arthurs action and words impacted more , rather than stepping on a gun and ordering - Arthur works as a distraction for john as he leads pinkertons ,micah and other to beaver hollow or to him as he charges forward like a gladiator , and john can protect himself he has deadeye and the pinkertons will be after us that way. - If you think this is about money then you are completely wrong , sure arthur wanted money to give to john since he will die but he wanted Micah to have his own taste of medicine after him manipulating dutch , mocking him and being an asshole. - The soundtrack when you make this choice and Arthur says "dutch , micah come and get me you bastards" implies that arthur knows dutch is beyond the point of saving and why he wants to finish the job not for himself but for everyone who helped him and died on the way Extra space I really like how arthur screamed "Not molly dutch" "him" "HIM!! " and proceeds to say micah is dead from inside since he practically lost dutch and all , so yeah I prefer this one rather than other one

[@skyranger4335]

Exactly but fanboys just support the other ending even in low honor this ending is pretty descent but the other one will give you you nightmares and in high honor this ending shows how much of badass gunslinger was arthur in the west and why he had a bounty of 5000 dollars in his head.

[@vrhehdbd3453]

@@skyranger4335 "fanboys' bro let people have their preferences.

[@skyranger4335]

@@vrhehdbd3453 people can have their own preference but fanboys hate others preferences. That's my point

[@spider-manunknown9193]

@@skyranger4335not all of them.

[@spider-manunknown9193]

I wouldn’t say this ending is better than helping John. It doesn’t feel right for Arthur to do in his final moments.

[@collectionreviews1897]

1:33 this part made me think of Arthur way more badass

[@lawrence5851]

The moment where Arthur is all boo hoo about the horse dying wasn't as sad for me considering I've ran like 20 horses off cliffs previously.

[@fizzycolapop362]

The only horses I ever killed were Stella Artois I, Stella II, and Stella III. Long story short, we stopped naming horses Stella.

[@tonyglock6161]

Those are accidents, ive cold blooded executed like 20 horses when i couldnt take a pint of gin out of the saddle bags

[@uy9572]

I literally bought the horse right before the mission so when it died I was like ._. My real horse a beautiful white one that I had since chapter 2 really got me tho, but the death was so stupid I was heading to Annesburg, tried to take a shortcut, slipped and fell at the entrance of the mine, my horse was almost dead but ready to revive and the game wouldn’t let me get in position to revive him so the guards at the mine got mad and shot me and my horse to death lol

[@fatnerd2005]

@@uy9572 White Arabian?

[@dinubogdan8859]

I killed my horse only at the end of The main story

[@beastslayer1674]

I just wish that in the next red dead redemption we play as young arthur when he just joined the Vander linde gang

[@marloncarbajal5492]

he woulda been like, 14 or something lol

[@Matthewgaming20]

@@marloncarbajal5492 15 he was 15 when dutch found him

[@marloncarbajal5492]

@@Matthewgaming20 imagine playing as some young teen and doing chores around the camp for the whole game lmao

[@Matthewgaming20]

@@marloncarbajal5492 or maybe you could play as davey callander until they move up north besides don't you want to know how each character came into the gang i mean some are already explained

[@marloncarbajal5492]

@@Matthewgaming20 true

[@adamgraves3453]

Arthur: *Slashes Micah across the face 4 times* Micah: “is that all you got black lung”

[@dennishuang7764]

Deer: Loyal and will fight to protect its family Wolf: Fierce and violent but will defend its pack

[@Matthewgaming20]

Sorry its a coyote just want to point that out

[@wanderingwalrus137]

@@Matthewgaming20 your mom is a coyote

[@LemonManIII]

It’s literally a wolf matthews

[@Matthewgaming20]

@@wanderingwalrus137 why gotta be an ass

[@Matthewgaming20]

@@LemonManIII its a coyote its to small to be a wolf look it up

[@christianalvarado9946]

"Kill me then, come on!" Dang, Arthur sounded so brutal and angry

[@PHZanoni]

Arthur: Destroys Micah with knife in high honor ending Micah: feels nothing Arthur: bites Micah's hand Micah: That's a LOT of damage my guy.

[@irishbattletoster9265]

Poison damage

[@user-qc1mc2ly8j]

Micah got TB most likely, just didn't show up before John and Dutch got to him. TB can incubate for decades..

[@i-ate-bread]

@@irishbattletoster9265 black lung damage over time

[@cayleesanchez]

First good-honor play-through, I was so torn between going with John and getting the money. Micah says that Arthur was greedy coming back for the money, but I figured he would go back to steal it all, and dispose of it for good. Arthur knew he was dying, so he would have no use for it other than to sabotage Dutch and Micah's plans. Their moments of betrayal would of been a waste, and they would suffer the consequences of their actions. And as they both valued the money over the gang, it would hit them as hard as the losses Arthur had endured. And onwards from the moment he realized things could be different, throwing away the money shows that both Dutch and Arthur changed--Arthur, for the better, and Dutch, for the worse. Nevermind Micah, he was always an asshole.

[@papafrankux7064]

ElementarWRRRYYY WRRRYYYcess i had preferred thinking that arthur was trying to steal it for the others like john and his family along with sadie

[@cayleesanchez]

​@@papafrankux7064 That sounds even better. Makes me wonder why Abigail didn't use the key the moment she got it...no one would suspect her.

[@tskwared667]

That's a good way to look at it. When it gave me the choice I couldn't picture Arthur doing anything other than following John to help him get out of there. Even though I figured he'd try to get the money to him and Abigail, I thought it was more fitting to help protect him on his way out. Also, Arthur gave them all the money they had grabbed from the train so I figured there was atleast enough to keep them going for a bit

[@mustaphamond5819]

That was my thought when i went for.the money, because John had to survive anyways bc of Rd1

[@fizzycolapop362]

MISSION FAILED: MICAH DIED Me: I’m sorry, that’s my problem why?

[@joes46985]

Now i regret having low honor

[@ChengTeoh]

I actually find things more entertaining in the world with low honor. the bounty hunters randomly stalking you is fun.

[@joes46985]

Cheng Teoh yeah I agree, but i prefer the ending where he dies peacefully

[@aleisshiki3649]

José Eduardo Silveira that’s probably a good thing

[@PokemonTrainerVince]

@Grimreaper Shadow You're right. People forget that Arthur and John did horrible things. They may have turned their lives around but that can't undo the damage they caused. In a way, they are like Kratos from God of War. Their past will always haunt them.

[@jenniferesham7289]

It's hard to have high honer

[@zakrzycha8592]

Thank You John for killing this rat !!!

[@them.]

Honestly, high honor helping John is probably the best ending morally and, in my opinion, the canon ending, but taking Micah's eye out feels AMAZING

[@godzillazfriction]

Try out a low honor playthrough.

[@obi-wan2]

@@godzillazfriction low Honor sucks for multiple reasons.

[@godzillazfriction]

@@obi-wan2 you suck as a person for multiple reasons.

[@godzillazfriction]

@@obi-wan2 lol

[@obi-wan2]

@@godzillazfriction I appreciate ur input but fuck off

[@tijnvanderweijden3541]

When I started this game I thought "let's get low honour and be a bad person for once", but after some time I began to feel so bad about myself that I just had to switch to high honour. I think that was one of the best choices I could have made because the mountaintop sunrise was simply beautiful.

[@Erakelus]

But it was slow and painfull death