Cinemare Sins: Everything Wrong With Every Little Thing She Does

[@awesometwitchy]

Little did Twilight know, there was a 7th more mystical element that was significantly more important than the traditional 6: CONSENT.

[@FHBStudio]

People always forget the other half of consent: *INFORMED*

[@nocturnalpisces1299]

and some forget that little stickler… ENTHUSIASM

[@nocturnalvisionmusic]

That's an amazing element. 😊

[@Ruby2P]

Best elemant for people who don't have it and have be- wait, no, don't make jokes on stuff so serious, bad Ruby.

[@nocturnalvisionmusic]

@@Ruby2P that's actually a good element if you think about it :)

[@edenanimates1465]

“These lyrics are ripped straight from lazytown” This is the number one joke

[@82dorrin]

"Starlight, I'm not mad at you. But I am disappointed." Twilight is Equestria's Susan Collins! Ding!

[@pegagatorgal_lps4]

We are number 1

[@nukemanthe501ststormtroope5]

Have you ever been a real villain?

[@bluesun5247]

"A precious family photo sacrificed in the name of *BANANA* "

[@TheMovieAndCartoonFan]

Funny because the Minions sequel came out today

[@yondaime500]

4:20 So you're saying this whole episode could have been avoided if only two of the least neurotypical ponies in Equestria managed to communicate effectively with each other?

[@moonbowcraze1632]

I laughed a bit too hard at this comment. They probably are two of the least neurotypical ponies.

[@lunar_proxy]

LEAST NEUROTYPICAL GHAHAHAH as a nd, felt that... wait so that's why i kin twilight........

[@trumpeterjen]

Neurodiverse people actually tend to communicate with each other pretty well, and neurotypicals communicate well amongst themselves. It's only once they intermingle that wires start getting crossed. If anything, someone who's capable of Lesson Zero should've been more wary in the first place.

[@lunanote-cassettemeower]

Hahahahaha 420

[@moonbowcraze1632]

@@trumpeterjen Yeah, but communication is still really hard.

[@MarsNotPlanet]

The only good thing at the beginning of the month: A Littleshy Video

[@Dominant_Jest]

Wdym?

[@Dominant_Jest]

Do you mean Technoblade's death?

[@garrenty_35]

And a new Humor me episode (its a webtoon)

[@colouredsun7919]

Absolutely

[@timwoods2852]

We are closer to *any other season but Summer!*

[@JCBro-yg8vd]

Maybe Twilight could've specified what she wanted from Starlight, but Starlight herself could've spoken up if she was afraid of doing things like baking a cake or sewing. She was sitting on those possible lessons for a while, she was intentionally blowing off the very thing she was supposed to be doing.

[@PramkLuna]

And I'm pretty sure Twilight is the type of teacher to allow alternatives. Starlight could have taught others how to do or show off her spells to her friends since the main part of the lesson is connecting with others rather than the activity itself.

[@trumpeterjen]

This is one of my favorite episodes because it's so goddamn horrifying in its implications, but it has stellar comedy to perfectly compliment the chaos. It made me wonder how the hell Starlight's morality got this skewed. She's my favorite character because there's so much extreme and off-kilter about her, and she connects with villains and "gray" characters in a really interesting way because she never fully eradicated her dark side.

[@JellyFishGell]

I love how Starlight casts a mind control spell that had physical side effects on the girls and instead of anyone being distrusting or mad in the end they're all just "haha yep! Classic Starlight!" I'd expect Rainbow or AJ to at least be wary of her after the stunt she pulled but I guess not! Glimmer really is the writers pet huh?

[@JaeyunYD05]

Compared to the time they were stripped of their special talents and kept in a small confined space for literal days - only being let out for less than 3 minutes to see if they’ve “converted” yet - I’d say this isn’t that unusual of starlight. Either way, the mind control is still as fcked up as everything else she’s done but the “all-forgiving” ponies didn’t put it against her.

[@JellyFishGell]

@@JaeyunYD05 I have a problem with both of these, her "redemption" was terrible, she did nothing to earn it, her backstory was poorly thought out and didn't justify anything she did yet she still gets a spot next to the Princess of Friendship herself, how unfair is that? At this point I'm convinced the girls just forgave her so quickly because they were afraid of what she'd do to them otherwise lol

[@JaeyunYD05]

@@JellyFishGell You make a fair point, her entire character really could have been written better. For example, sunset shimmer had to build back her reputation from scratch, starting with all the people she bullied. Another example would be trixie who had to face the backlash of her past fraud and everything she did to ponyville. But Starlight? The fate of the world turned on its side; imprisoning the six protectors of modern day equestria and then mind controlling them after they forgave her? Yeah, I totally get you now. They may get away with “haha we’re so used to it” but it doesn’t make it right.

[@JellyFishGell]

@@JaeyunYD05 Someone else commented that Starlight should've stayed in the village she mind controlled to make amends and pop in from time to time like all the other reformed villains instead of joining the main cast. I think that would've been a much better direction for her character, she could properly redeem herself and in my opinion she'd be much more entertaining in small doses. You can still have her make friends with Trixie, Maud and the others just don't force her into so many episodes. We also wouldn't have gotten the whole mind controlling thing *again* if that happened. Though someone would've still needed to make a proper backstory for her because "my childhood friend moved away boohoo" is the worst backstory ever you could give to a villain who forcefully brainwashes ponies and can alter time itself

[@rendomstranger8698]

@@JellyFishGell You do realize that Starlight is pretty much the most powerful unicorn in Equestria, right? As in more powerful when she is angry than even Twilight was as a unicorn. Keep your friends close and your reformed enemies closer.

[@Scarletdex8299]

5:17 Littleshy's inner fluttersimp takes over and forces him to do this sketch *ding*

[@NOTDeezy.]

Imagine if the episode just ended there tho

[@Scarletdex8299]

@@NOTDeezy. nah, nah, I'd love to see Starlight finding a way out of that bin of reality for the rest of the episode at least

[@NOTDeezy.]

@@Scarletdex8299 and it becomes discords episode to learn about friendship by trying to hang out with all 5 ponies at once instead of starlight

[@PearmareAnimation]

I can relate to Starlight on so many levels. I also have no idea how to handle leading, or how to communicate properly in a group environment. Starlight got so relatable over the series, getting better as time went on! Also she has the best mane style of the entire main cast no question.

[@chaconneind3777]

Thank you...

[@princessstar512]

Same here, I also relate to Starlight in a lot of ways.

[@timwoods2852]

Sunset Shimmer's mane is pretty great.

[@RixskyIcarus]

The best Kin and Pon

[@NotSarahGacha]

Okay, I have to agree, she's pretty. But I really don't like her character and the way that she never learns out of her mistakes 😅

[@yetanotherfnfplayer208]

nothing feels more rewarding than sucessfully waiting patiently for 1 month waiting for the next Cinemare Sins video to come out, to watch it 30 mins after its release

[@robbys5236]

How about having your suggested sin be in the video? But then again, I think both if those things are on equal levels of rewarding.

[@yetanotherfnfplayer208]

that must be beyond rewarding lmao

[@rizdubpony1235]

4:38 To be fair, Starlight did give what seems to be a proper apology and seemed to show actual remorse for her actions. Better than I can say about certain other episodes...

[@noobsaibot3747]

Fluttershy: What episodes are those?

[@rizdubpony1235]

@@noobsaibot3747 Off the top of my head, A Canterlot Wedding, The Cutie Re-Mark, and the first Equestria Girls movie all have quick forgiveness after half-hearted apologies.

[@noobsaibot3747]

@@rizdubpony1235 "A Canterlot Wedding" raises an eyebrow, lol. "The Cutie Remark" I understand but don't agree with the haters. Starlight Glimmer's mindset reminds me of Madara Uchiha. I'll go into more detail if you're interested. Not sure if you've seen Naruto... As for Equestria Girls, I completely agree. Sunset Shimmer was beat and immediately said "I'm sorry, I never knew there was another way." with tears.

[@tejukanaparthy]

@@noobsaibot3747 celestia and the mane 6 were trash to twilight in a canterlot wedding

[@UltraSonicRainboom]

I just calculated and realized that Litteshy won't finish this series until 2029, 7 more years. By that time, the series would have been going on for 15 years! That's crazy! It's so amazing how loyal Littleshy is to the series, that he never fails to upload a new video on the 1st of every month for the last 8 years. Like, that's crazy!

[@82dorrin]

Also, according to Kelly Sheridan, Starlight likes Pineapple on her pizza. She's *still* a villain. In fact, she's eviler than Tirek, Cozy Glow, and Chrysalis combined.

[@MajoraWaffle]

...and i thought glimglam could not get any more based

[@FirewormTheTiny]

No wonder I like her, I also like pineapple on pizza

[@ajshiro3957]

That fiend! She's evil!

[@EssexAggiegrad2011]

Pineapple on pizza is good

[@cadjebushey6524]

I love pineapple pizzza!

[@Galistarwater]

Starlight, you used magic to bake a cake back in season 6 episode 6! How have you forgot to do the same with Pinkie in this episode? SIN!

[@מאורניסיםוקנין]

‏‪0:28‬‏ Captain Equestria throw her mighty shield!

[@TheCommenterDragon]

I always loved how this episode became a key point in Starlight's development, as she learns that magic isn't the answer to every problem and that it only makes things worse. in fact casting a spell on Twilight's friends is one of the many absolute worst things that Starlight has ever done. anyway some of my favorite parts of Twilight's friends being under Starlight's control was the parts where Pinkie Pie said-"Whatever you want to do first Starlight Glimmer" and when Rarity said-"Whatever you want me to have in my mind Starlight Glimmer" the way they said those words made me laugh, and then there's the part where RD flooded the castle with storm clouds Starlight should've been more specific when she said "We need water" and the part where Fluttershy is covered in animals and bugs always made me think that Starlight should've been less specific when she said to find all of the animals in the castle. and in conclusion, i give this episode a 6/10.

[@NotSarahGacha]

Actually not. She still used her magic after this episode to make things easier for her. Starlight doesn't learn from her mistakes and that is what I dislike about her 🤷🏻‍♀

[@Hexstream]

0:53 Pretty sure I've heard this exact sin before?!

[@LittleshyFiM]

I think it's a running joke by now XD

[@tittlesuckular3293]

And does anyone else remember when she first met Ms. Cake and she made a cake with ease?🤔

[@izunadara1894]

And then Mrs Cake got upset at her for "trying to put her out of business". Most likely triggering Starlight's anxiety. Starlight was just trying to help and be social, yet was awkward. Similar to Zuko and Azula from Avatar. And hopefully we all know how much Zuko is adored.

[@victorhurwitz5559]

I'm sorry but what's with your channel name? It's unique to say the least.

[@starrywisp]

the biggest problem I have in this episode is something you didn’t even touch on- oven smoke does not mean fire. water is useless in this situation.

[@Nazo-kage]

0:41 The sad thing is the phrase “as you know“ can’t really be seen as a sign of clumsy exposition anymore. Because I have seen multiple instances in real life of people using that phrase. Because they’re about to relay information the other already knows but there’s more to it now, Or they’re not really sure if the person you’re talking to actually does know.

[@coyotix]

You know the video's good when it's less than 25 seconds in and we already hear "Precious family photo sacrificed in the name of *b a n a n a* "

[@HeartCloud]

I liked how Starlight learns that using magic isn't always a good idea to solve her problems.

[@timwoods2852]

Visible spider webs mean that the spider has abandoned that web. Spiders work meticulously to keep their webs clean and free of debris and water droplets as to keep them hidden. If the prey can see the web, it won't get caught. So, all of those spider webs are fixer-upers at best, and the equivalent of dumping a pile of broken bits that used to be a house at worst.

[@cutercills9x9productions9]

For the Fluttershy rounding up the bugs part, I'm surprised she didn't try to collect the bacteria airborne. You know, certain microorganisms are also considered animals (virtually, every non-plant creature is).

[@82dorrin]

"Starlight, I'm not mad at you. But I am disappointed." Twilight is Equestria's Susan Collins! *Ding!*

[@baliyae]

That episode was Starlight Glimmer’s Lesson Zero.

[@Mattcai2004]

With a few elements of the Sorcerer's apprentice from Disney's Fantasia

[@FHBStudio]

1:03 little does LittleshyFim know Rarity came across the castle while it was still in the ground during one of her gem gathering sessions. It was too difficult to excavate so she just left it there. After visiting the dusty old library of course.

[@nullingmulberry]

The end where discord just snapped Starlight out of existence-

[@doobie_mouse2083]

This episode really turned the corner on Starlight for me. By the end of the series she was far and away best pony

[@MoonlarkSpirits]

Yes! A new video! I forgot that it was July 1st! *That’s a sin* (for forgetting)

[@MCLegoboy]

Never realized that Pinkie was saying the lyrics to a Lazy Town song, but I guess that shouldn't surprise me given her ability to break the fourth wall and "have hunches" about the goings on of different dimensions.

[@daddymarcus8343]

4:40 i was thinking that the moment she got redeemed they were afraid, I'm a huge starlight fan but i absolutely see this as the case, like what else was twilight supposed to do when she was ripping star swirl's spell??

[@XaidynPinckney]

1:52 not only lazytown reference, but also Andrea singing even though it's a fake out

[@pingpongya795]

its funny how dash says theres no where to chillax in the castle, but then they proceed to do it in the castle at the end of the episode

[@Megumin88]

Best way to start the day is with a great video from littleshy

[@FuzzyStripetail]

The tipping point for Starlight to mind-control five of the Mane 6 was probably when Pinkie Pie activated that frosting dispensing baked goods item without even pressing the tip.

[@efaristi9737]

3:55 Well, she is the chief pony in charge of the weather, a wonderbolt, a nationale hero and the close friend of a princess. So why wouldn't they obey her orders without questions ? 4:09 Why wouldn't she be angry? Her castle has just literally been flooded by pegasus! She didn't accuse anyone, she just angrily asked what was going on.

[@BeautifulShine935]

Agree. If I came back early and saw my house flooded with paw prints up the walls and everyone's eyes looking wired , I would be very mad and want answers.

[@efaristi9737]

@@BeautifulShine935 Lol, it does look like a party gone wrong XD

[@MysteryMan3351]

Something I noticed is that everyone while under the spell calls Starlight "Starlight Glimmer", her full name, whereas Applejack only calls her "Starlight".

[@User47928]

2:48 EVIL I HAD BEEN IN IT FOR MONTHS

[@Deleted_Eevee]

0:23 imagine they accidentally teleported so that their feet were stuck on the roof of the cave so if they didn’t teleport again they would just be stuck there forever

[@mcrxsolidarityarchives]

0:24 This joke feels to convenient considering a new movie that has recently been released. (ding) 0:34 Also, this sin gives me deja vu. I feel like another Brony has said these EXACT SAME WORDS about this EXACT SAME SCENE. (ding)

[@Fictionboy16]

You want to know something? Apparently, there's a short where Starlight hypnotized Twilight, and you'd think they'd learn from this episode, but apparently not. Now, all of Mane 6 has been hypnotized by Starlight. Yes, I'm aware one situation was an "obey my commands" situation and the other was more of a way to help overcome fear, but still...

[@codyfan1413]

Hypnotism isn’t really mind control, I learned that online, you can’t force someone to do something they wouldn’t willingly do in hypnotism, however with mind control, there’s no limits. Plus Twilight actually consented to the whole thing anyway.

[@Naekrohs]

That’s the best end clip yet

[@dovargorath2722]

0:36 a changeling it's the only exception

[@PurpleFlames87]

The way Spike enters a room is literally how everyone in my family enters my room. If my door is open, yeah sure, come on in, but if it's closed, please knock!

[@mathyno]

Everything Wrong With Every Little Thing She Does has to be best title yet

[@kowaihanashi6921]

1 sin mark Subtitles 4:41 "To forgive the ex-cult leader's crimes against humanity" quickly fixed but none the less there.

[@Ruby2P]

*Discord snapping Starlight out of existens* Monika: I like this guy.

[@windygleam9821]

Now that I think about it, the mindless Fluttershy could be the reason why animals ran away.

[@crushermach3263]

4:42 Forgive me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't it be "crimes against equinity"?

[@ryangreen6255]

Hasbro, as much as they've acknowledged him, needs to canonize his OC and make him an official toy with him getting a cut of the sales.

[@JohnDoe-tl4gm]

I doubt they would go so far as make him a toy (perhaps only one toy for him to own specifically) but I was hoping that sometime in the series, they might have put his OC in the background at some point.

[@SonicJrandSarah]

Fluttershy: Maybe if you get to know... Starlight: In a minute, Fluttershy! Discord: I'm banishing you to the chaos realm! Starlight: NO! (Disappears) Discord: Much better!

[@PhantomAarantula]

Of all the ponies to freak out over doing stuff with, Starlight had to name Pinkie Pie. The one and only pony confirmed where Starlight did spend time with the task of baking together as early as Starlight's reformation. Yeah... I hate how OP unicorns are sometimes.

[@Khadi-C]

While I overall like Twilight, one of my gripes with her character is how forceful she can be when it comes to friendship lessons (something she probably got from her own mentor). Yes, I get it's a show about friendship, but I feel like a lot of the episodes run on poor communication and sometimes pride. But I don't think any episode ever shows Twilight in the wrong for how she goes about some of her lessons (besides the one where she disliked Starlight and Trixie becoming friends). Probably unpopular, but I honestly grew to like Starlight more than Twilight.

[@WhopperMan725]

I KNOW BRO AND I FIND IT HILARIOUS THAT DISCORD IS THE ONLY PERSON THAT BE SOMETIMES CALLING THEM OUT AND ROASTING THEM 💀💀 BUT EVERY TIME THEY GET MAD AND SAY SOMETHING THAT MAKES SENSE THEY AUTOMATICALLY SHOULDN'T HAVE SAID THAT AND IT WAS MESSED UP ☹️

[@D1ckM4ster_Solar]

That end scene just 👏 Perfect

[@sundayok2307]

This might be the best thing I have ever seen ever

[@gachagwen8259]

I love the outro where shes like "in a minute fluttershy" and discords like *die*

[@MoonberryJam93]

2:48 bruh why u gotta do me like that

[@defeateddirector7753]

It was scary when Rainbow Dash yelled at Starlight Glimmer for casting the spells.

[@rusticrails1812]

3:57 That wasn’t dense water, that was ‘thicc’ water.... 👌

[@astrobookwormsinger]

That ending with Discord? A++

[@bluwasabi7635]

Love that foyYAY edit. Bellissimo 💛

[@Lpsdingo.allyson]

She wasn’t reformed, she’s a super villain now!

[@ajshiro3957]

Pinkie singing in her natural voice? Well, no song this episode. Right?

[@TheMovieAndCartoonFan]

It's definitely a case where unless you have context and actually take time to look at some of these with perspectives that isn't just 1 side, episodes likes these may get looked down upon from the pretentious upside

[@SonicJrandSarah]

I was wondering when this was coming out.

[@Sponandi]

0:27 I need another #TheBanana drawing stream. You don't understand, I need this kind of energy in my KZbin recommendations.

[@crazieman]

Ahh, my favorite pony of all time.

[@youkai20]

Best episode of the season.

[@haralabospapadogiannis2782]

0:24 this part still makes me laugh

[@funmibukola9207]

2:05 Hasbro is the new Robbie Rotten

[@valeriedominguez607]

Discord at the end made this even better

[@princianorvz]

Gonna watch this "Everything Wrong" in DOUBLE SPEED! Humanitarian Speed!

[@ThatRandomEncounterGuy]

This was the episode that made me realize Starlight was completely unsalvageable as a character. But, y’know, by the time you’re 8 seasons in, it’s too late to tap out.

[@stryke-jn3kv]

I managed to tap out at the end of this season and yes Starlight was absolutely the main reason for that decision. Did come back for a couple of eps in the last seasons for that amazing villain song and the finale so wasn't a total ragequit.

[@CyberWarezz05]

In a way, I love how inconsistent the writters are with their characters/story and the fact that it never ticked them the wrong way that they made the decision to forgive a mind controlling villain, only for her to do the same shit in a later episode without consequences.

[@JellyFishGell]

Yep, it's funny because I loved Starlight as a villain but when she's "reformed" she just makes me audibly groan. I only enjoyed Glimmer episodes where she was either still a villain or hanging out with Trixie. Villain Glimmer and "reformed" Glimmer feel like two completely different characters to me

[@ThatRandomEncounterGuy]

@@JellyFishGell the issue is that, after they redeemed Starlight, they never gave us a reason WHY she’d still be around as a Sixth Ranger. Sunset Shimmer had a whole movie showing how she had to *prove* that she changed and she brought a new, stronger dynamic to the HuMane 6 there. Starlight...just doesn’t. There’s nothing unique about her personality, she has no unique skills or talents, she doesn’t even have a defined role aside from just being ‘Diet Twilight Sparkle’ but with a more extreme background. Pairing her up with characters with actual personality like Maud, Thorax, Discord, or Trixie (the last two having much stronger motives and redemptions) doesn’t make her look stronger by comparison; it just emphasizes the weaknesses of Starlight’s lack of character. They could’ve just left her at her original village to atone for what she did and pop up every now and then for a friendship lesson or something and it’d actually make more sense. Also, we wouldn’t get episodes like this.

[@JellyFishGell]

@@ThatRandomEncounterGuy I actually love the idea of her staying at the village and popping in every once in a while, honestly something the writers should've gone with instead. Starlight is just such an unnecessary addition to the show (along with Twilight's library being destroyed and the friendship school in my opinion) she's always felt as if she were missing something and I think you described what perfectly. She doesn't have anything going for her, her only purpose is to be a writers pet and that really hinders her personality. It's a shame because we could've even seen her actually earn her redemption and make new friends while still making these sorts of mistakes and blunders but the show doesn't treat her that way, she never had to earn her redemption like every other redeemed villain did she just got handed the position of Princess Twilight's student because what? Her friend moved away when she was younger?? Yes that definitely justifies brain washing ponies into becoming members of your cult. Cosy Glow gets thrown in prison immediately but Starlight gets off the hook and secures herself a position at the top of the ladder, and even after all that she still doesn't add anything to the main cast. It just makes me sad that the potential for a really well done villain redemption got thrown away like that

[@Mindless_entertainmenr]

Gotta love that little ending edit

[@purehyper124]

Your points are great, and the edit at the end is always entertaining.

[@Figgy_Jub]

As much as I adore her, Pinkie scares the shit out of me

[@TheMovieAndCartoonFan]

Try Pinkamena Diane Pie in the Season 1 Episode "Party of One". She makes Pinkie in this episode less terrifying

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

Well this is amazing XD. Happy July!

[@rain7382]

I've been waiting for sooo longggg Finallyyyyy I love your videos

[@lunadakat343]

Not discord erasing starlight glimmer frome existence- 💀

[@imtrying2969]

Concerning 4:45 Not everyone seems to realize, Twilight never *won* that original fight between Starlight and herself in the season finale- philosophy about 'fighting isn't winning' aside, and the real victory being friendship aside.

[@milesfreilich968]

1:30 foy-yay!

[@malsharked]

How do these never get old

[@thewolfed1687]

THANK YOU FOR MENTIONING ‘THE GAME’

[@goldengirl42827]

I was waiting for this video for so long… also I knew you were gonna say mind control

[@nocturnalvisionmusic]

Aw come on I was just reviewing this episode two days ago! That's the craziest coincidence 🤯😁 Great review of a great episode 😁

[@cristopherrose9356]

5:04 If no mistakes were made, there would be nothing to learn.

[@FanSeitz]

0:56 Oh that reference XD

[@SeriousPony]

"In My Little Pony, it's more efficient and more rewarding to fix your own mistakes than it is to do good in the first place" In the Bible too. And it's not a coincidence 😉

[@OfficialWestside4124]

0:27 banana

[@lol-rl4wq]

They could have just agreed on location beforehand when teleporting

[@chanabanannaanimations6884]

there are probably lots of times discord wanted to do that but didn't want to remind the girls he is constantly eavesdropping

[@EpicMuttonChops]

i actually totally forgot about this episode

[@cian.o]

Oh boy I can't wait for the next episode.

[@spectrumstars_]

this episode was the first 'talking about' from FOB equestria I ever saw and I JUST remembered wtf

[@elishawilliams5460]

I do miss when magic had limitation and rules

[@ponyhorsemuledonkey.1635]

the starlight mind control episode.😵‍💫😳

[@cvcvdfetghgbbhg]

Aw yes who could forget the Starlight MindF*cks the Mane 6 episode