Everything Wrong With Prince Caspian in 15 Minutes or Less

Thanks to CuriosityStream for sponsoring this video! Use this link to get an annual subscription for just $14.99: curiositystream.com/CinemaSins Code: CinemaSins
Prince Caspian is one of them there Narnia movies. And I'll be honest with you: it's not very good. But it does have sins, and checking out those is always fun!
Next week: classic animation sins and early '90s supernatural sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin. Which movie's sins should we count next?
•CinemaSins website: www.cinemasins.com •
•Channels•
--TVSins: / @tvsins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/stores/cinemasins
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy, Chris and Barrett about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.libsyn.com/
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/shows/behindthe...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com/book

[@CinemaSins]

Thanks to CuriosityStream for sponsoring this video! Use this link to get an annual subscription for just $14.99: curiositystream.com/CinemaSins Code: CinemaSins

[@ricardocardona9193]

Make everything Wrong with Beavis and Butthead do America

[@rkingdomminstries5677]

Do Everything Wrong With All Dogs Go To Heaven.

[@baddriversofgeorgia3387]

The next Cinemasins video should be The Impossible or The Quake 2018 film

[@voxdeus]

Army Of The Dead next

[@XBANGARANGX]

100 sins for the 25 seconds of ad time when CinemaSins should be Cinemasinning Roll credits

[@fionahall9722]

I love that Prince Caspian isn't the whole title of the movie, so it sounds like this is about everything wrong with the character

[@Igorcastrochucre]

Have you seen the sins of the the first Narnia and Percy Jackson movies? The titles alone covered 70% of the thumbnails and there wasn't any space for the "Everything Wrong with"

[@fionahall9722]

@@Igorcastrochucre Fair point, it's still funny tho

[@coolidgedollar2154]

" Sin #1 - He's just too darn cute!!! _Swoon._ "

[@excessivelyfangirlingbookw3339]

@@coolidgedollar2154 absolutely. One of my first teenage crushes 🥰

[@coolidgedollar2154]

@@excessivelyfangirlingbookw3339 Username checks out.

[@phoenixdark9]

After watching her sister make out with Prince Caspian, Lucy comments “I'm sure when I'm older, I'll understand.” totally forgetting that she lived an entire lifetime already. Either her memory has gone the way of the dodo bird, or she lived a super virtuous lifestyle. Ding.

[@monmothma3358]

Never noticed that. That's actually a pretty big sin.

[@AtarahDerek]

It's Lucy Pevensie. She's probably modeled after Elizabeth I in terms of personal virtue. And in her day, you didn't learn those things until you learned them on your own or your mother told you on your wedding day what to expect that night. Also, Lucy could be ace for all we know.

[@AntediluvianRomance]

All those former memories got dulled, and the movie has the characters being full-time obnoxious teenagers instead of ruling royals. So yeah, dodo bird it is.

[@Sweaterlatethannever]

@@AtarahDerekLucy is now ace in my mind. Thank you for this representation :)

[@_Twink]

Maybe shes lived so long she has alzhimerz

[@kierstenpratt894]

"I once saw a horse startle itself with its own fart," As a someone who works with horses for a living, can confirm that this happens far more often than you'd think.

[@eyeballheadinalabcoat]

It could be a talking horse.

[@brookelee9745]

My dog is scared of his own bowel movements so I believe it

[@gentblue]

Me after my first Mexican restaurant experience.

[@Expialidocious46545]

I've startled myself with my own fart.

[@dogman15]

@@eyeballheadinalabcoat Even Bree and Hwin would get scared sometimes.

[@beastwriter3915]

I'm pretty sure Peter's plan was to have people sneak into the castle, open the gates, and ambush them at night while they're asleep, but Caspian ruined the plan by going on a personal revenge trip to Miraz's bedroom, so Mira alerted the army... The sneak into Miraz's bedroom is not part of the plan

[@Statalyzer]

Yeah the movie was pretty clear on that, the plan didn't involve confronting Miraz directly at all, but to sneak attack them at night on the logic that they had sent the whole army out towards the forest and left their castle relatively undefended.

[@beastwriter3915]

@@Statalyzer Trojan horse style

[@zjjohnson3827]

I don’t know why this line gets ignored, but outside the Professor’s window, Peter says something like, when they’re planning, “You (Caspian) get to the gatehouse. You (Susan) and I can handle Miraz.” The plan was for Caspian to go open the gatehouse while Peter and Susan went and captured Miraz, presumably with directions to the royal quarters from Caspian. But Caspian messed it up upon finding out his father was killed by Miraz and since he knows the palace well he got there first

[@Krezznet]

1:34 he's checking to see if it's been sharpened or not, castle armories were often combined with forges so some swords could still be works in progress or awaiting final touches

[@GeneralKenobi75]

I know right. Its like CinemaSins doesn't realize blades can dull.

[@Krezznet]

@@GeneralKenobi75 I was just saying that as more of a fun fact than a criticism 🤣

[@harrisonbaylor1432]

@@GeneralKenobi75 cinema sins gets real bit picky and tries very hard to get extra “sin” in the video. It’s common for most of their videos to not make much sense.

[@ColetheFlame01]

@@harrisonbaylor1432 is that not just them ensuring they have some hilarity? cause tbh I find the nonsense to be hilarious and lets be real, they are just doing it because someone out there will and so they are just saying "screw it" and nitpicking everything possible.

[@GeneralKenobi75]

@@harrisonbaylor1432 Oh believe me I've noticed.

[@barbyonabike]

"This episode is brought to you by - " SKIP! Ping!

[@ixl911ixl]

This but the god awful new intro the channel uses. It’s 14s long, and this man is out here complaining about intros on every video. Irony?

[@ddragonwhistler]

Oof big Cinema sins energy

[@JeremyMaldonadoSTK]

@@ixl911ixl Don't worry... SKIP

[@tsmdaniel1375]

The irony

[@nothingyet120]

Yeah, sellouts. Pff imagine needing money...

[@greyworld6242]

This is the lion that the lion king remake needed.

[@raydunakin]

But not the lion it deserved.

[@captainvandyk6849]

the lion the witch and the wardrobe: 124 sins prince caspian: 123 sins what is happening to cinema sins sequels?

[@ElMessi-wq3vj]

The Lion the witch and the wardrobe was my childhood and nothing can convince me it was even close to being worse than this movie

[@Beacuzz]

Caspian has bigger sins not more

[@triple-d2640]

@@ElMessi-wq3vj Epic Movie > Narnia

[@mtarango]

Dawn Treader: 122 sins

[@Strongest_under_heaven]

@@ElMessi-wq3vj but the uncle king's army and the uncle king himself have such badass fucking armours..

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

4:19 Cinema Sins *actually* had me waste 30 seconds looking up to see if Ben Barnes was Timothy Olyphant's nephew. (Which, for clarification, he is not). *ding*

[@MarielaQue]

Time well spent

[@samanthastone8277]

I’m glad you did so I don’t have to 😂

[@jasondowns940]

Took me 5 minutes 🥺

[@GeneralKenobi75]

Yeah, really not a "sin" but that's never stopped these bozos before.

[@d0ct0rh0lliday]

HA! Did the same thing, and when I couldn't find anything checked the comments and found yours.

[@narnianpotterhead8811]

They took that long to realise it was Cair Paravel cause while they still lived in it it wasn’t on an island. During those 1300 years that they were gone the place turned into an island of course it would take long for them to realise

[@autumbreeze1129]

7:29 also a CGI Disney Lion who, despite being animated over a decade ago, still looks better than ANYTHING from The Lion King remake.

[@JCDavis314]

“Doom and Gloom to Womb Zoom” is my new favorite phrase.

[@FlamingAtheist]

IN DEXTERS LAAAAAAAB

[@mjkesby]

The Narnia trilogy will always have a place in my heart, but damn there are a lot of mistakes 😳

[@KhanMann66]

Only one that exist to me is the first one. Sequels don’t exist.

[@mjkesby]

@Mr7Reality Fingers crossed 🤞🥺

[@mjkesby]

@@KhanMann66 How do you feel about The Voyage of the Dawn Treader?

[@PittsburghSonido]

@@KhanMann66 Wardrobe supremacy

[@user-eh1gc7xo7q]

The first one is the best and only one. The rest are just bad

[@moviewolfreviews875]

This is my biggest guilty pleasure movie, I absolutely LOVE this movie and the series like actually

[@Sol-Amar]

No shame in liking what you like ☺ ! I think the concept is good which is why I like it but it could've been executed and written so much better (in my opinion).

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

Not to mention the fact that a character who I've been told was like 12-13 in the book was aged up to about 17-18 in the movie AND got played by a then 26-year-old. 😆

[@rilian226]

@@Sol-Amar It was 'written' better...as in the book! I'm a big narnia nut since I was a kid (see my username!). Read the series more times than I can count. Thoroughly enjoyed the first movie. This one, IMHO, was not so good. I really disliked the drastic change in Peter's character from the book and the utterly unnecessary invasion of Miraz' castle. While I get the powers-that-be wanting a "strong woman" character, I'm not sure Susan was right for it. In the books, she was a real softy and hated hurting anything. In the movie's she's Susan Warrior Princess.

[@Sol-Amar]

@@rilian226 Well said! I had ment to add "adapted" but thought people will get what I ment since even movies based on books still have to have their plots and scripts written. I have yet to read the books though, so I'll take this as a reminder to follow through on that. Your description is a good motivator too!

[@brookelee9745]

This isnt even a guilty pleasure. I own that I’m obsessed with all things Narnia.

[@jasondowns940]

I’m a huge fan of these books, and Lucy sitting on the stone table is like Dumbledore yelling at Harry. YOU DONT SIT ON THE STONE TABLE!!!!

[@fukuriu9707]

*calmly telling Harry

[@misterminutes4504]

Aslan said calmly,

[@AntediluvianRomance]

But she isn't even jumping on it like the movie Gimli in the movie Moria.

[@DreamyMelodiesLounge]

Lol

[@NMN_CP]

DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET OF FIRE HARRY

[@brentparker7359]

13:39 -- In the first movie, Peter had a swordfight with that universe's version of SATAN and while he ultimately needed Aslan to finish her off, he held his own against her. In this movie, Peter has a swordfight with...some dude...and we're meant to be worried about his chances.

[@caracaes]

If this were a deeper though out movie, I'd argue that Peter was purposefully stalling the fight because if he killed King Miraz right away, the Telmarians probably wouldn't keep their word and attack anyway. But since this is the Narnia movies, this is just another sin.

[@DreamyMelodiesLounge]

Hahahaha

[@carissaluttonmovietalk]

I used to watch the Narnia movies when I was sick, they were the movie equivalent of a hot bath, they just made me feel better lol.

[@mariahdibben4066]

I used to listen to the soundtracks to sleep. Always had to skip past the battle music though lol

[@Panda72021]

"This movie is long" I'll just sit quietly with my extended editions of 'Lord of the Rings'.

[@hannahbellegamble2972]

Fun fact: Ben Barnes used Inigo Montoya from the Princess Bride as inspiration for his accent in this.

[@WoodyWoodpecker19843]

My name is Prince Caspian. You killed my father. Prepare to die.

[@bodaciouschad]

1:39 He was checking the blade for visible damage. It seemed polished, so it stood to reason the blade was maintained so he picked it.

[@sanjaymatsuda4504]

But damaged weapons are sent for repair, not stored in the armory. Nobody picks up a rusted, chipped sword outside and thinks "I better put this back in the armory, from whence it clearly came in this state of disrepair".

[@DR-420-69]

According to the books, he's actually checking to make sure it's not a pool noodle in a scabbard.

[@ImaLooker9]

@@sanjaymatsuda4504 that is true. maybe he was checking if it was sharp? that's the only thing I can think of.

[@GeneralKenobi75]

Exactly. He was checking to see if it was sharp, so he wouldn't be running from his murderous uncle with a dull blade so he could actually defend himself if Miraz's soldiers catch up to him. Its like CinemaSins has no critical thinking skills.

[@roak1566]

Have seen countless characters do this in so many movies. These guys have been getting even more nitpicky lately, if that was even possible.

[@JennFaeAge]

Somehow I literally only just realised Peter Dinklage is in this movie, despite having watched it more than once

[@hiimcrazyfordrwho]

He is in a lot of makeup

[@E-G-G-O-Fall]

SAMEE!

[@katearcher8514]

It happened to me with James McAvoy and the first film.

[@safsren]

and I only realized it when I read your comment XD

[@747lch]

"doom and gloom to womb zoom" may be your best line ever

[@1993seanmcg]

“Next week: classic animation sins” Oh no, please not 101 Dalmatians. This is gonna break my heart.

[@3.1415Ds]

Well apparently a new movie called Cruella, i hope they arent trying to make a movie feel bad for that BI*CH. She doesnt deserve any sympathy

[@emiliobullough9640]

@@3.1415Ds no I heard she is basically becoming disney Harley Quinn.

[@bloggerblogg5878]

@@emiliobullough9640 wow, they don't know where to stop...

[@MobileComputing]

I bet there's gonna be 101 sins.

[@owenmaleski2203]

@@emiliobullough9640 They made two or three movies trying to make Harley Quinn into some sort of relatable antihero, and Maleficent into a tragic villain, so I wouldn't put it past them

[@Tensolin01]

10:27 What’s hilarious about this moment is that it actually makes sense. The bow and the quiver of arrows are both enchanted to hit the desired target no matter what. So she cold probably throw the entire quiver in the air and all the arrows would kill one enemy each because she wills it, hitting no one else.

[@socialgoat5519]

Well, as the first movie establishes, she has to trust in the bow for it to "not easily miss". She trusts Narnia and her bow at this stage, hence the arrows land true

[@trickshotsmoviesandcubing2317]

No they aren't

[@Tensolin01]

@@trickshotsmoviesandcubing2317 They don’t go over it in the movie, but it’s what’s written in the books and said in the audio books. But go off. I’m sure you know more?

[@trickshotsmoviesandcubing2317]

@@Tensolin01 actually maybe they are. I had said that thinking she had missed the apple in the archery contest, but then I remembered she hit it. Though I hope they aren't because then nothing about it would be impressive lol

[@seatbelttruck]

1000 years passed since they'd been in Narnia. Cair Paravel looks a little different now. I saw this in theaters with my school when it came out. The ending song makes the scene really cheesy, and it was hilarious watching one of the boys in the row in front of me squirming and saying "no... NO!!!" when Susan and Caspian hugged and gave each-other goo-goo eyes.

[@sarahprince2412]

That was my beef with the movie. They shouldn’t have tried to force Caspian and Susan to be an item. It would have been so much better. Also the stupid accent. Caspian was much better in The Voyage in the Dawn Treader because he lost the accent. Other than that the movie was actually really good in my opinion. The music was great as well.

[@nickclark18]

It wasn't 1000 years... Stop making shit up

[@cantbetamed2210]

I really loved the Peter vs Mraz cause the fight is freaking realistic for a fantasy movie. We can see the frustrations, the sweat, heavy breathing. No majestic zoom ins where the MC is looking all pretty. (yeah I am talking about you c-dramas).

[@monmothma3358]

Yeah there are far too many "pretty" duels that leave you cold

[@darkhorsedouglas4789]

the fight is brutal. even if it is in slow-mo for the stunt actors. It's still super easy to follow every hit and move of that fight.

[@biggles1852]

Harry Potter, Dr. Who, Star Trek, LoTR, AND Zelda references? Am I in nerd heaven? I like it here!

[@luciferparker5063]

And GoT/ASoIaF and Hunger Games reference

[@tobybartels8426]

Welcome to Cinema Sins!

[@bargoladexterjay5424]

MCU

[@sleepytime903]

it would seem so 😩👌

[@mariahdibben4066]

Wait I missed the Zelda reference. What did he say?

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

1:40 What Caspian is checking for is to make sure the sword isn't secretly a pen underneath.

[@dragonrider7101]

"This is a pen. THIS IS A PEN!!!"

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

@@dragonrider7101 Yay, someone got the reference! 😊

[@GeneralKenobi75]

More like checking to make sure the sword is actually sharp before he makes his escape from his murderous Uncle's soldiers. Something anyone with critical thinking skills should realize, but not CinemaSins.

[@dragonrider7101]

@@GeneralKenobi75 *In Elmo voice "And today's word is... JOKE! A joke is something not to be taken literally, and is usually supposed to be funny!"

[@GeneralKenobi75]

@@dragonrider7101 Then maybe he should tell better jokes.

[@UltraDuo-dw2nx]

clicked on it faster than mom could say get back to school

[@KvotheofAdemre]

Facts

[@tonyspaniol1966]

I knew I wasn’t the only one!

[@benjaminlewis2910]

School's for wimps. (Just kidding! Stay in school, kids.)

[@insomnitis]

Than* Go back to school

[@UltraDuo-dw2nx]

@@insomnitis thx i'll fix it

[@user-kv5jk5dg5n]

The mention of the Doctor and the actors who played him is highly appreciated) Also, I totally agree, they all are cool, but David Tennant is just brilliant)))

[@paulbennett2284]

Just ignore Whitaker!

[@alessiodelcastillo1613]

@@paulbennett2284Doctor Who?

[@brandonwalls4032]

Man, I'm glad he shouted out the song at the end. I love that song.

[@triciaramgoolam4045]

What song was it?

[@immyw8]

@@triciaramgoolam4045 The Call by Regina Spektor

[@triciaramgoolam4045]

@@immyw8 thanks.

[@brandonwalls4032]

@@triciaramgoolam4045 The Call

[@triciaramgoolam4045]

@@brandonwalls4032 thanks.

[@scienceface8884]

2:40 That's almost literally how the series ends: Three of the four Pevensie kids and a number of other main characters show up to save the day, and when the trouble is over the kids are all "awe, now we have to go back to Earth again." and Aslan is all "lol, you can't go back: that train wasn't magic, you died in a horrific train accident!" and then everyone cheered.

[@oneandonlysound3453]

and susan can't come because "she didn't believe it all happened." That last book was really just...off. Think I am good with Silver Chair being the finale chronologically.

[@scienceface8884]

@MJR ZZZ Read "The Last Battle". Or, hell, read the plot synopsis on wikipedia: "Aslan reveals that the Friends may also stay, as they had died in a train accident on Earth."

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

How timely of Cinema Sins to review Prince Caspian when the recent release of Netflix's Shadow & Bone adaptation has resurrected the age-old trend of being up Ben Barnes' ass. 😆

[@MarielaQue]

Amen.

[@animesloversunited9069]

He made the vid to get the reach

[@johnstriker480]

BOY, Instead of Hollywood pointlessly “remaking” all these Disney Classics (ie. fixing what isn't broken) , what about dedicating the time, money, energy, & effort to make the rest of the NARNIA books into movies? Or the ERAGON series into proper movies? 😮❓📚

[@KnightsaysNi]

Eragon NEEDS a remake, that series was done so dirty with that first trainwreck of a film...

[@drcheekymonkey1982]

Caspain hitting the branch is not a sin. That’s what happens in the book. It’s the most accurate bit of the opening scene

[@Colechamdiceman]

These kids have functional immortality and it's amazing, lol... Live an entire life in a world, go back to being a child their original world, then go and live an entire lifetime in a world, and go back to being a child in their original world...

[@thalmoragent9344]

Welp knowing Cinema Sins.. Prince Caspian is about to be dethroned 😅

[@Shaden0040]

When drawing a sword you are shecking that the blade is set firmly in the hilt and that the blade is sharp and undamaged to render it useless in a fight.

[@llarmstrong783]

I wish there had been a Silver Chair movie.

[@dagonvaldez2878]

well, there was a BBC production with Tom Baker as puddleglum. I think it was released late 70s-early 80s.

[@llarmstrong783]

@@dagonvaldez2878 I know. I actually have that on an VHS

[@paulbennett2284]

The BBC did this story & Dawn Treader in two episodes each whereas Lion/Witch & Silver Chair took 4 episodes, so yeah this film was stretched out somewhat!

[@josephfisher426]

@@dagonvaldez2878 1990, says IMDB. Tom Baker is weirdly appropriate for that. That book gave me a dream about the ending of Underworld, except that the baddie was Sauron instead of the Green Lady.

[@AtarahDerek]

With Matt Smith as Puddleglum. He'd be the perfect successor to Tom Baker in that role. We already know how well he can give a speech. Plus he's built like Puddleglum.

[@greenbugs5909]

since Caspian is my name I will be taking all of this personally

[@joshjohnson2753]

The castle invasion was one of the most amazing and infuriating scenes as a kid. Completely avoidable lol

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

Ikr! The cut-backs to the minotaur holding up the gate were so intense, and it broke my heart as a kid when they had to leave all those fellow warriors behind. 😔

[@joshjohnson2753]

@@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose 100%. The intial invasion of the castle was one of my favorite scenes in any movie as a kid, and the retreat+the reason for the retreat was one of the most hated, because it was so hard to watch lol. I actually liked the castle battle over the final battle, they didn't capture the same amazement that they did in the final battle of the original movie, in my opinion

[@bigpapamagoo8696]

I rewatched Prince Caspian a few weeks ago as a teenager and I started crying when the Minotaur died.

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

@@bigpapamagoo8696 I watched Trin Lovell's reaction to Caspian last week and felt so bad for her when she started crying at that scene. It never made me cry necessarily (it usually takes a lot for me to cry at a movie) but it was still quite powerful for a character we hardly known. (But once she felt better she cut-back to crushing on Ben Barnes and everything was fine again 😆).

[@jacklau2558]

Here's what gets me about the gate scene WHY DID NONE OF THE OTHER MINOTAURS HELP!!! And why did not one narnian a shield. But again help your boi out, a little help goes along way

[@alm2187]

"...girls can't carry a map in your heads." So it seems, seventy years ago when the book was published and/or eighty ago when it's set, there were some sexist associations about geographic memory going around. But Sue doesn't just take it. She hits back with "...because there's [already] something in them." What are you wtf'ing, exactly?

[@Annie_Annie__]

I mean, this stereotype that girls/women don’t have a sense of direction and all boys/men do was around when I was a kid in the 80s and 90s. I knew adults in my family back then that firmly believed it.

[@alm2187]

There you go, @@Annie_Annie__. :-) And does it tie in with the whole men-won't-ask-for-directions thing, I wonder?

[@davidsteinmetz7256]

To be fair though, Peter would have been right, he just forgot to take into account the landscape changes over a hundred years. Also, given that Susan rarely left the castle in her later life, she prolly would be the most oblivious to where they were even going. (Not that he needed to be sexist about it or anything, just saying.)

[@ceceliakueffner430]

Also I'm sure Peter is mainly saying this just so he can roast his sisters a bit, that's what siblings do lol

[@tarpan365]

You know, if armor is too heavy then the soldiers can actually drown in shallow water

[@Statalyzer]

Some paratroopers on D-Day drowned in 2-3 feet of water because of all the gear they were carrying.

[@biosaari]

The White Witch cameo didn't come from the writers of the movie. It came from Lewis. It makes sense as a personification of evil within the character development of the book - something the movie chose to ignore.

[@AtarahDerek]

In the book, they never accomplished resurrecting Jadis. They were stopped before they could.

[@biosaari]

@@AtarahDerek Yes. Hollywood took it another step further, but arguably Jadis wasn't really resurrected in the movie as well. Of all the differences between the two, I count this as more excusable; it doesn't appreciably change plot or theme, and it's understandable that they want to make it more "cinematic".

[@NicolaeHolley]

"I once saw a horse startle itself with its own fart" is such a true statement. I was laughing so hard I could barely pay attention to the rest of the sins.

[@coolidgedollar2154]

The book is somehow both cuter and darker than the movie. And _The Last Battle_ was dark, and incredibly strange as well. No ready-made Disney family film to be found there.

[@julius477]

whisker jesus had me rolling lol

[@davidjohnson8231]

You thought it took too long to realize it was Cair Paravel here, you should see how long it took in the book

[@dagonvaldez2878]

the problem is we come here to be entertained. but so few of us read the books. I have this 7 book set virtually memorized.

[@coolidgedollar2154]

@@dagonvaldez2878 Do you consider the last book to be "unfilmable" as written? The imagery all seems too dark and weird to me.

[@dagonvaldez2878]

@@coolidgedollar2154 yes and no. writers of that era didn't dumb down stories for children. but the society's feelings might be hurt making a movie as the last battle was written. if you want a real treat try reading the jungle book and ignoring the movies.

[@Statalyzer]

@@coolidgedollar2154 I think Horse and His Boy would actually be tougher.

[@Memecious]

Can we appreciate how his videos never get boring?

[@MikeKing001]

They do this is the first one I've watched in a while and I remembered why I stopped watching.

[@royalgecko5683]

They never get boring.... UNLIKE THE NARNIA MOVIES!! OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHH

[@ISirSmoke]

@@MikeKing001 same here

[@benjaminlewis2910]

They never get funny, neither.

[@guistheslim-sumo3361]

Yes tf they do and the singing is cringe asf

[@ThatSoddingGamer]

I know it's just silly nitpicking on the part of Cinemasins for our entertainment, but it's actually good practice to check your gear before going on whatever adventure you're embarking upon. Whether it's swords, guns, tools, etc. it's better to make sure what you grabbed is good _before_ you need it. Inspecting the sword to see if it had nicks, rust, and whether it was well fitted in the scabbard is sensible.

[@SaltedMeats]

He's checking to make sure the sword hasn't rusted and become stuck in the scabbard. Sinning a movie because you don't understand something... That's a paddling

[@Statalyzer]

Yeah, it's funny I think this movie was pretty weak, but a surprising number of his sins are quite dumb. E.g. "movie never satisfactorily explains while Miraz agrees to fight Peter 1 on 1 - I guess all movie villains are just dumb and egotistical" ... when the movie shows pretty well that Miraz's hold on the throne is fragile and so the Lords are able to maneuver him into a situation where he basically *has* to accept the challenge to save face in front of them.

[@jimmymiller1313]

"We've waited long enough!" "Man, remember school?" Hahahahaha

[@miraculousismyguiltypleasu9372]

Just waitin' for Dawn Threader, folks.

[@Phoenix-lb2bw]

Cinemasins would have a lot to say about Eustas 😂😂

[@eleanorheslinga4918]

@@Phoenix-lb2bw He would probably say "Eustace would be excellent at CinemaSins" at least once.

[@Phoenix-lb2bw]

@@eleanorheslinga4918 definitely 😂

[@AtarahDerek]

The VDT film wrote Eustace the way he would've deserved at the beginning of the book, but definitely didn't deserve by the end of the book.

[@irrelevanttous95]

Cinema Sins: “Oh shit, you were serious?” Me: *laughs nervously in Marauders fancast* He is, actually.

[@PoppCulture94]

7:08 Of course, because when you're out in the wilderness, everyone knows to sleep standing up.

[@seaweedbrain2101]

Bruh these movies were my whole childhood. Voyage of the Dawn Treader was my personal favorite

[@bobbyfeet2240]

I am sorry. As one of your elders, I admit we have failed you.

[@seaweedbrain2101]

@@bobbyfeet2240 lol why?

[@AVR7771]

@@seaweedbrain2101 because Dawn Treader is considered the worst of the trilogy. I mean don’t get me wrong, I like it, I’m just saying what the fandom says

[@dvg4868]

@@AVR7771 don’t speak for all of the fandom

[@julianr8544]

I have it on DVD, used to watch it all the time when I was younger.

[@lesbianScottishGirl]

I hate what the movies did to Peter's character. The books were my fave growing up and I still go back and read them when I need to escape from reality for a while.

[@maricls26]

💯 agree!!

[@ashy1587]

2:43 bestie I'm afraid to tell you this....

[@themorrigan7224]

Well, three of the Pevensie kids...

[@katiestanhope5289]

I've known this fact for months and I've still not come to terms with it

[@jasminatounsi]

Pls i only learned about this a month ago dont mention it😩

[@mariahdibben4066]

Wait what? What am I missing here?

[@jasminatounsi]

@@mariahdibben4066 spoilers but if you wanna know google how they died 😬

[@JohnThomas-no9hs]

Eragon had a scene with terrible arrow accuracy. Surprised he didnt remember seeing as how he absolutely shredded that movie

[@absalom38]

An edge, that's the only time, I'm gonna be like that. The reason he's pulling the sword halfway is to check for an edge

[@priscillajimenez27]

That subway scene gave my Harry Potter vibes. I thought they were gonna end up going through that wall lol

[@Patches2212]

In a way they did, they just didn't do it at a running start. So obviously the walls of London's subway stations have specific methods you need to use to get to specific fantasy worlds

[@larkynria2223]

I wonder if it was in the book

[@darkhorsedouglas4789]

@@larkynria2223 yes the subway travel was from the books. so you could say JK stole it along with the centaurs from CS Louis

[@XxMCRroxnonstopxX]

@@darkhorsedouglas4789 mmm not really on the account of Centaurs. They're from Greek mythology so they would have both gotten inspiration from that.

[@thoughtsofaleo2916]

After watching Shadow and Bone, I was just thinking about this movie! As rough as it was, though, I am sad they never finished the series off, but I suppose they wouldn’t have as much of a draw since, if I remember right, the series switches from the Pevensie kids to different kids in the next book?

[@coolidgedollar2154]

It does, to their cousin Eustace and others, and I like that: a sort of "inheritance" of responsibility for Narnia's fate across many different figures and ages -- including, finally, a distant descendant of Caspian! (The last book would be very difficult to film, though.)

[@oneandonlysound3453]

true, but the third one still has the two youngest and adds there cousin (and the movie version even has cameos by susan and peter). The 4th one has caspian, and his son, returns the cousin. The 5th is technically a prequel so it'd be kinda hard to have them in that one. 5th one has them be encountered when they are older which by the time they filmed it would've been pretty easy to pull off, and i imagine they've have given them a bigger part. I'm mostly will always be annoyed they didn't move forward with silver chair and magician's nephew. We never got an "end" to the three with Prince Caspian and even though it's the 2nd to last in order it would've felt far more like a functional franchise end, even if they did the prequel afterwards.

[@royalgecko5683]

Ok, I was lowkey JUST looking at the Wikapedia page for this movie when I got a notification XD

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

Cool! Don't you just love when those kinds of freaky occurrences happen? 😆

[@alphasierra.]

Why lowkey?

[@SeraphimCramer]

Should've been a sin off for "so you're bravely refusing to fight a swordsman half your age?"

[@nath9091]

As you mentioned it's hundreds of years later so there have been geographical changes too for Cair Paravel. They also figure it out within a day which isn't too bad

[@monmothma3358]

More than a thousand years. It's an overgrown ruin.

[@michaelmedina4990]

Wasn't a big fan of this movie, but I did get a great amount of enjoyment out of Reepicheep's body count. I loved that murderous little rodent for some reason.

[@coolidgedollar2154]

Maybe because he was voiced by Eddie Izzard?

[@ashleytuchin7693]

My excitement over the fact that you made a Doctor Who reference, was immediately replaced by anger when you dissed my second-favourite Doctor, Paul McGann.

[@wutthabuck8772]

I love the Narnia books, always will but the movies be having so many mistakes and plotholes 🤣 still fun to watch tho. Anyways PLEASE DO WILLY WONKA & THE CHOCOLATE FACTORY W/ GENE WILDER

[@leemichael2154]

I think he already has done that? Or maybe I'm thinking about screen rant they definitely did it and it hilarious

[@wutthabuck8772]

@@leemichael2154 Pitch meetings did one. Cinemasins did the Johnny Depp version Charlie & the chocolate factory, I been asking for the original one for a while lol

[@leemichael2154]

@@wutthabuck8772 yes I would like to see the original sinned! As it sure is full of em!

[@Promthanius]

This is one of the best examples of adapting a book to film where you add stuff and it actually makes the story so much better. I love this movie

[@paramitch]

I love the books, but Prince Caspian is my least favorite of the books, and this movie is terrific. I didn't mind any of the changes at all.

[@randyhartford1909]

The BBC version are better and the are four story and some of the books never have been made in to movies like the magicians nefew were you learn were and how the white which got in Narnia and the back story of the professor in the lion the witch and the wardrobe

[@kimberlynguyen3192]

3:10 I’m sure they did spend time outside, but like the whole castle is destroyed and they kinda left before the attack of Cair Paravel. Also it’s been like thousands of years since they saw it , therefore eroding so yeah makes sense why they don’t notice it. 4:10 Missed the scene of both of them pushing a giant rock to get to that wooden door, then ripping the shirt for light.... 5:30 didn’t want to lose anymore people, also as said Narnians are suppose to be extinct. Hence hiding from humanity till they are needed. 5:42 agree 7:11 a dream 7:17 he’s freaking immortal 9:48 needed to know the true about his father 9:57 Caspian knocked them out 11:09 he was a great king in the past, but ever since he got back to his own world he felt useless. Therefore returning made him a arrogant young king 13:25 well it is a Christian like movie, and it is sorta about Jesus. Literally meaning yes Jesus is the answer, which I find a bit meh

[@GeneralKenobi75]

All good points CinemaSins failed to make. Especially the fact the door was blocked off.

[@danhurl1349]

I feel the need to point out that arrow throwing was an actual thing that medieval archers did when when the need arose

[@criteriaz5063]

Could you make a video covering the movie “Love and monsters”? I saw a few “sins” in it myself and I’m curious to see if you find the same as I did.

[@matthewmusgrave6673]

Fun fact: the Matrix and Prince Caspian got the same rating in either Australia or New Zealand, (can't remember which one for sure). Kind of makes sense, with the Matrix being a very light R movie and Prince Caspian being a very heavy PG movie.

[@lordofthenarnians6472]

I love the Narnia movies, and no matter how many sins it gets I will still love them. I do agree with some of the sins although he does put sins in there that are ridiculous. (Like the forest is pretty bright for it being night. Yeah we kind of want to see what’s happening and not stare at a black screen. And the moon can be really bright).

[@rshiell3]

Dude, your work is the funniest stuff I have ever heard. Please keep making videos! I actively look for new stuff from you, and I regularly listen to your old stuff while I’m working. I work alone, so I’m starved for human contact.

[@adamthompson6669]

I love this channel it’s the best and narrator is awesome at what he does, I’ve been binge watching the last few days. Great work and thank you 🙏

[@mattgrostick1499]

Tennant really WAS the best Doctor... That seething rage.

[@movieman410]

This came out 6 days before crystal skull...wish I had seen prince caspian instead

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

Yeah, probably would've at least had more fun with Caspian, *and* be less annoyed by it. 🙃

[@joshuawoodbridge6267]

I thought that him checking the sword at the start was to see how sharp it was, also nice THE GREY reference

[@GeneralKenobi75]

It was, which anyone with half a brain would realize that was what Caspain was doing.

[@jayvansickle7607]

Probably the biggest sin of this movie, is that it turns Peter from someone who is wanting to help establish Caspian as King...into a little whinny b*tch for most of the movie.

[@LeaF-vo2mx]

However, movie Peter is a lot more realistic than book Peter, like if you think how a face off between two teenaged wannabe kings would turn out in real life... I really appreciate that the filmmakers thought about this when concocting the various decisions both Peter and Caspian make.

[@jayvansickle7607]

@@LeaF-vo2mx "wannabe kings" I think that's the difference. That the book Peter knew that his sole purpose was to help establish Caspian as King. It wasn't a contest....or a power struggle. He is content being High King regardless of where he is...either Earth or Narnia...and accepts it. (I don't remember the books as well to be honest)

[@ginahi6073]

Now that I'm looking at it, it has a lot of flaws, but the trilogy still holds a place in my heart.

[@msnat1304]

My favorite sin is how he blamed the script writers for the forced white witch cameo... which was in the book...

[@Statalyzer]

They talk about resurrecting the White Witch in the book, and claim it's possible, but she doesn't actually make an appearance, and we never find out if they really could have done it.

[@msnat1304]

@@Statalyzer I dunno why, but I thought I remembered that one of the conspirators who were trying to resurrect her spoke as if they were possessed or claimed to speak her will and so I thought that counted as a cameo, but the wiki doesn't say anything about it, so maybe not

[@Statalyzer]

@@msnat1304 I don't think the book was going for "possession" but I could be wrong, I think they were just evil dudes who also wanted Miraz gone and were even willing to sub the White Witch in his place to get it to happen.

[@liamwarner5749]

I know its not a great adapation but I love the scene where the centaurs offer him their swords and the one on the left is looking around not sure what he should be doing. I can just see the thought process "Yeah you tell him, make him . . . wait what my sword, oh crap um yes er right sword I'm just like everyone else."

[@ragnamoe1850]

never getting bored of these videos, thank you jeremy:)

[@YoursTrulyChris]

The professor obviously found Susan's horn in the treasure chest. That's a whole buffet of artifacts hidden down there! I'm surprised he didn't take everything else but of course, exposition.

[@tammiewaanders34]

I thought she said she left it with her horse in the saddle when they found the closet again. Or am I just stupid....

[@tammiewaanders34]

@techno bee okay thanks, glad to know I at least remembered something xD

[@NewMessage]

I'll never understand why some swears are bleeped, and others are not.

[@bradley5008]

One thing that I have to compliment these guys for is that they are never shy about what they actually do

[@hamaljay]

Last time I was this early the Prometheus School of running away from things had not been established yet.

[@sparklingdeath1730]

When you’re in England and CinemaSins says jaywalking: *we don’t do that here*

[@Raven-yv6di]

is walking across a busy road legal in England? Or is there just another name for it?

[@the_once-and-future_king.]

@@Raven-yv6di Perfectly legal.

[@Raven-yv6di]

@@the_once-and-future_king. that seems very annoying but i don’t live there so i can’t say

[@the_once-and-future_king.]

@@Raven-yv6di Well the vast majority of people know how to cross the road so laws really aren't necessary. The only exception are motorways but even then it's not just pedestrians prohibited. Bicycles, learner drivers, tractors cannot use them.

[@Raven-yv6di]

@@the_once-and-future_king. sounds nice! here in canada people will just stand directly in front of cars and stop the flow of traffic. absolutely zero fucks given.

[@galacticcactus5530]

Only Cinemasins could ever make me envision a badger/ dwarf/ centaur orgy and now my body is confused.

[@cadidelythdavage1862]

For the record, McGann was actually a great Doctor, his 8 minute special in 2013 was spectacular and he's contributed more to Doctor Who lore outside of the main show - mainly through incredible audiobooks with Big Finish - than any other Doctor!! Ok rant over 😂 appreciate the reference all the same, along with this looong awaited video!!!

[@liveonceproductions6688]

I clicked because I faintly remember the nostalgia from the good ole days.

[@illCMAC]

Reepicheep is basically Golem so your analogy holds up imo

[@malikmalchan2525]

how are you so early

[@jker4802]

How do u comment so early..

[@TheBatmanvs1]

@@malikmalchan2525 exactly

[@gv5676]

14 hours? What?

[@robpagenkopf5829]

P-A-T-R-E-O-N

[@skiqu]

been waiting for this one :pray:

[@3218675309]

Six timeline commercials plus your promo commercial, I’m added ten sins.

[@dagonvaldez2878]

a hundred and ten, brother

[@limerence8365]

This movie will always be great just for introducing me to Ben Barnes....

[@jakobalgeblad6732]

This ending song "the call - regina spektor" is a certified banger

[@coolidgedollar2154]

The song "Waiting for the World to Fall", written by Jars of Clay for the previous movie, was great as well -- probably more appropriate for _The Last Battle_ which will never get filmed, however.

[@skywardprincesoftime]

I loved the Narnia series so much when I was young, but my gosh was this movie infuriating. They completely decimated Peter’s character. The night raid was so dumb. That did not stop me from buying all related merch and the movie 6 times when it was released though.

[@suzieb4087]

I have been waiting for this for a long time!!