Wings｜Animation Short Film 2020｜청강애니

제작 : 정혜리
한쪽 날개가 찢어져 있는 소심한 소녀 틸틸. 그런 틸틸의 앞에, 같은 처지의 소녀 미틸이 나타난다.
Tyltyl, a timid girl with a torn wing. In front of such Tyltyl, a girl in the same boat, Mytyl, appears.
shitajung.creatorlink.net/
청강문화산업대학교 애니메이션스쿨 2020년 졸업작품
#2D #animation

[@whatever6701]

This animation school really likes to make people cry, doesn't it? 😭

[@itz_natalioz4618]

Yeah,really!😔😔🥺😭😭😭😭

[@xiao_shortdaddy6141]

Yeah😭😭😭

[@thesmallfrog7832]

Wiping away the tears right now 🥲

[@krizamaepinera7811]

Yup,I'm even crying right now😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@averyexpensivefrog9341]

I would cry if I could

[@Gundam-Prime]

"The Jian, also known as “the bird that shares wings,” only possesses one wing. Unless a male and female pair lean on each other and act as one, they're incapable of flight. They're imperfect, incomplete creatures. But, for some reason, their way of life, struck me as profoundly beautiful."

[@Lily-gz3ip]

*gay birds crying rn*

[@Mewwiee1]

Darling in the FranXX????

[@satans_first_born]

Darling ohayo

[@Gundam-Prime]

aug 2022 edit: Guys, I know the two characters are both girls. It's just that this video and specifically the part where they "share wings" reminded me of this anime quote, so I figured I'd share it, that's all. Idk why y'all gotta focus on the "male and female" part. And tbh, I wasn't even shipping anyone in the first place; that would be kinda creepy since they look like kids ngl.

[@Mewwiee1]

@@Gundam-Prime have you read the Manga yet?

[@tofutorud1142]

"The Jian [鹣], also known as birds that fly together [比翼鳥], are mythical birds that possess only one eye and one wing. These creatures are born imperfect, and they need to lean against each other and act as one in order to be able to fly. Their mutual dependence is eternal, lasting through death and rebirth." 🥲 So cute

[@kjgold1387]

They don’t have one eye

[@k.cthedogofficialtheog]

@@kjgold1387 they di

[@Samithecutie]

@@kjgold1387 they said that

[@yoru9345]

This reminds me of darling in the franxx...

[@Otter0084]

Darling in the franxx-

[@MimzyFlimzy]

It’s funny how you know from the beginning what’s going to happen but still gets goosebumps. This is truly art 💕

[@waffrentrager8216]

Well, I thought he is about to steal the girl wing so he can fly

[@KiyoshiroClips]

@@waffrentrager8216 thats....dark

[@lucidfangirl1030]

I thought the girl was gonna be a bully and snatch back the apple as he reached for it

[@MimzyFlimzy]

@@lucidfangirl1030 LMAO

[@mras3715]

I really thought one of them will sacrifice a wing for the other and it's a lesson of letting go and the friends that made reach the skies when we're so down in life.

[@user-uo3kv9ur7i]

엥 아니 저게 어떻게 졸업작품이야 저 정도면 상업용 애니메이션 아닌가???? 진짜 티비에서 틀어줄 것만 같은데

[@user-ei1lp6uy6z]

맞아요 넷플릭스나 라프텔 보는 느낌..

[@Cotai.]

@@user-oe8zd6lu6w 그치만 혼자서 상업용 애니메이션 퀄을 내긴 힘들죠!

[@user-dd9cx8te2m]

@@Cotai. 호혼자요??????.???.??????..미친혼자서ㅜ이러ㄴ퀄리틸,ㄹ

[@ttabual]

@@user-oe8zd6lu6w 근데 그게 중요한게 아니라 본론은 "혼자서"상업용 애니 퀄만큼의 작품을 만들었다는 게 대단한 거라는 거죠!★이상 애니덕후의 한마디였습니다!!

[@0w0v-_-v]

@@user-oe8zd6lu6w 진짜 극혐ㅋㅋ 본인은 냉철한 평론가라고 생각하겠지만 주변인들이 보기엔 걍 찐따일뿐

[@user-xz5fy9xm2o]

우리나라가 애니를 제작 못하는게 아니라 안하는거구나•••절실히 깨닫고 간다

[@madj9921]

우리나라는 아동애니밖에 없음...

[@Mi-xi1yx]

인재가 있어도.. 마땅히 설 자리가 없다는게..

[@user-jt6gd2bt2r]

수요가 없으니 안하는 것 뿐... 우리나라에서 애니는 아동용으로 내서 장난감으로 돈을 버니까요

[@user-iq3tu6pt3x]

수요가 없음 우리나라가 그런 애니 만들면 씹덕이나 오타쿠라고 거부감느끼는 사람이 태반이라 잘 안봄

[@MeaBBab]

다 떠나자나..

[@HiritoKaitsu]

In my whole life of being an artist, this is the best animation I've ever seen (made by one man or a small studio , I had to clarify this so people won't get confused)

[@null7211]

you must have not seen a lot of animations then lol

[@HiritoKaitsu]

@@null7211 I've seen Alot of animation Very bold of you to assume I only did a couple

[@yourfriendlynerdViv]

Demon slayer

[@HiritoKaitsu]

@@yourfriendlynerdViv quality and frames are incomparable Plus this is made either by a 1 guy or a small studio Demon slayer is a big group like literally a whole 50+ people if not more helped on that

[@agatra8795]

@@HiritoKaitsu yes but you said youve never seen animation this good...

[@travishudson9796]

Absolutely beautiful. I knew they were gonna take flight from the moment I saw her wing, but my heart still dropped when the branch cracked. It's amazing how much emotion can be conveyed without even uttering a single word.

[@godzilla4191]

😊

[@orangeslash1667]

@@godzilla4191 Disney's Fantasia was to first to do non dialogue storytelling.

[@rattersworld1016]

YES!! THIS VIDEO IS SO BEAUTIFUL!!

[@FormerlyAMuffin]

uh no?@@orangeslash1667

[@System_trananer_2004]

Anime name

[@user-in3xy2qr7j]

대사 하나없어도 감정이 다 전해진다 이런게 연출을 잘했다는거겠지..

[@hannanna1004]

ㅇㅈ...이래서 연출이 중요함.. 보는 내내 이분 연출에 매초마다 감탄함 ㄹㄴ 천재임

[@user-mh6cb9fp6p]

진짜 어떤대사를 하는지 어떤감정이 있는지 그런 모든게 나 느껴진다 이게 진정한 애니지

[@user-dr7ej8fr7x]

와 찢었다.... 프레임 이게 다 얼마야 그 일정에 와 ..... 당장 데뷔하셔도 문제 없으실 듯.

[@alerx-iy6cl]

La tuya por siacaso

[@minkitsu9044]

"Wow, it's impressive... How many frames? Wow... I think you're really talented for a beginer. "

[@vivdex5512]

@@minkitsu9044 thanks for the translation, my yt translation says: "wow, I broke it... How much is that framework? Come on, program."

[@MemberoftheUnusAnnuscult]

Reminds me of a jian, a Chinese mythological bird that is literally half of a bird: one eye and one wing. Because of its lack of another wing, it cannot fly, which represents its incompleteness and imperfection. It can only fly when it has found another mate that is the other half. Together, they lean on each other, giving both Jian the ability to fly, which represents wholeness and perfection. One of the most famous example of a pair of jian in the media is Hiro and Zero Two from the anime, Darling in The Franxx. For some reason, ever since I've heard of that bird, I was almost obsessed with it. Like, I really enjoyed the concept of having to literal lovebirds sticking together in order to fly.

[@noxxelor5364]

I was searching for this comment, I also thought about Pihis

[@MemberoftheUnusAnnuscult]

@@noxxelor5364 Ngl, I'm surprised my comment was (probably) the first one you found about the Jian, since there are other comments explaining the same thing

[@lovelyloveS2]

음악, 연출, 스토리, 작화... 그 어느 하나 부족함이 없네요... 보는 내내 소름 돋앗어요 꼭 애니메이션 업계에서 혜리님을 볼 수 있길 소망합니다

[@user-it1pk1lw9z]

ㄹㅇ.....

[@user-eq9dp7qu2c]

진짜 이런분들이 국내에서 꿈을 펼칠 수 있게 애니 사업 좀 확장했으면ㅠㅠㅠ 이런 인재를 해외로 보내는 건 국가적 손실이다ㅠㅠ

[@user-hr7jo6js9z]

고졸들도 입시미술만 잘 못하거나 시작조차 못했던 사람들은... 개잘그리는데 가난하고 대학안갔다는 이유로 뜨질않음.. 웹툰작가 조석님같은 인재가 더 많아지길..

[@user-xk3hh5cl4o]

환경이 너무 열악하죠.. ㅜㅠ

[@user-cf2rn3qe5o]

뭐 애니메이션 사업들을 규제로 싹다 죽여놔서 남은 건 일본 애니메이션 하청 업체 밖에 없는데 ㅋㅋ 많은 연봉을 받고 더 높은 자리에 가기 위해서는 해외로 이민갈 수 밖에요

[@user-hr7jo6js9z]

@@user-cf2rn3qe5o 사실 애니는 한국쪽에서도 유일하게 미술에서 좀.. 많은 사람들이 돈 많이 벌고 살 수 있는 직종임.. 근데 웹툰계에 프리랜서들이 죽어가는것처럼 프리렌서로 접근하면 굶어죽기 십상이라ㅜㅜ

[@user-pb7fj1hq2v]

@@user-hr7jo6js9z 개 잘그리면 고졸이여도 떠요...

[@IIlIllIlIIIlIllllI]

대한민국 미래는 어두운데 인재는 무슨 눈이 멀것네 이런걸 보고 개천에서 용난다 하는건가...

[@user-hr7jo6js9z]

수영장에서 용난다

[@user-vm8dl3hu4h]

@@user-hr7jo6js9z 개천도 아니고 수영장이네;; ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅅㅂ

[@user-mn6cp4gh5g]

시발수뎡장시발ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ좆같다 인재좀살려줘라

[@user-fn5iz7gf6x]

@@user-hr7jo6js9z ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ개너무 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-tp6py6qv1t]

근디 우리나라는 다른 나라에 비해 애니에 대한 혐오감이 좀 있음 특히 학생들 사이에서 애니 좋아하면 다 씹덕이라고 불리는 곳도 있다고 함 저희 학교는 그러지 않았지만..

[@Munchkin.Of.Pern09]

The artist in me is nearly crying at how beautiful this is. The biologist in me is laughing and saying “that’s not how flight works!”

[@dragonslayer101]

I love the symbolism here. It's so beautiful. While some people can succeed on their own, others need help or aren't developed enough to achieve their goals on their own. This is good symbolism for disability, how despite our disadvantages, we are stronger together rather than alone. So we should help each other especially those who struggle more than us.

[@llIlIlllII]

I quite like the symbolism of the boy gaining confidence. We don't often see stories that deal with a young, fragile boy becoming a man. In this case, the girl looks to be a bit older. She's stronger, tougher, and more experienced. She encourages him to push outside his comfort zone and do something scary. And then we see him being brave once again, but this time when it isn't fun & games. I find it interesting that he's supporting her, flying above her, and initially we don't see his eyes. We just see the grim concentration of his mouth set firmly in a line. In the end, they're more equal in terms of confidence and strength. He has grown up a little. Just small details that stood out to me 😊

[@levitheghost]

​@llIlIlllII the boy is also a girl

[@ainel]

그냥 청강 애니메이션 회사를 만들었으면 좋겠다ㅠㅠㅠㅜ 너무너무 좋아요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@user-mh6cb9fp6p]

진짜 만들면 좋겠다....

[@poor_mi]

작화엄청해...분위기 굉장나...진짜 대박이에요!!!이걸 진짜 어떻게 표현해야할지모르겠네여 롸..진짜..

[@poor_mi]

틸틸이랑 미틸 진짜 너무 예쁘고 사랑스럽고 귀여워욥...그리구 완젼 멋있써..

[@user-fp9sx5be2w]

굉장해 엄청나!

[@cheolsu4842]

작화가 진짜 사람을 갈아넣었네요

[@sigan_time]

음..따뜻하고 포근한 느낌? 같네요

[@seolhaul]

포근한 느낌이야... 세상에...

[@WobblesandBean]

It took me 40 years to finally find my other wing. Now that I have, I'm never letting him go. 💜

[@elaineturnervkookforlifep.3775]

I love how they both flew in the end together. ❤

[@gepijolpark2583]

40대 후반의 가장입니다. 지나가다 짧은 동영상에 울컥해서 한글 남깁니다. 우리시절 향수를 자극하는 일본 애니메이션 느낌의 훌륭한 영상도 좋았지만 부족한 사람들끼리 채워가며 살아가야하는 내용이 갈수록 능력의 모자람을 느끼는 우리세대에게 주는 젊은세대의 답 인것 같아 너무 좋았습니다. 졸작이면 자식또래의 세대인것 같은데 좋은 작품을 보여주셔서 진심으로 감사하며, 좋은 능력이 더욱더 발전하시길 응원하겠습니다.

[@user-fr2xu4my6s]

...아빠 아니지? 설마 아니죠?아니면 말규

[@user-hr7jo6js9z]

아빠....?

[@minkitsu9044]

"I'm the head of a family in my late 40s. I got emotional while passing by and left a Korean message. I liked the great Japanese animation video that stimulates nostalgia in our days. I was so happy that the content that I had to fill up with people who were lacking was the answer of the younger generation who felt that they were lacking in ability. If it's a graduation work, I feel like I'm in the generation of my child's age, and I sincerely thank you for showing me a good work, and I hope that your good ability develops even more."

[@user-dl1nc6hz5x]

빠빠..?

[@whateveru]

@@minkitsu9044 에?

[@sh000ng]

와 진짜 얼마나 피땀 눈물로 만드셨을까 대박이다 ㅠㅠ.. 근데 헬퍼 한분 계시고 개인이 만드셨네요...? 미친.. 진짜 살아계신건 맞죠..? 정말 대성하실분..

[@fgjjdgb3949]

For me personally, in terms of emotionality and symbolic message, this animation is equivalent to the first flight of Hiccup and the Night Fury. When friendship and unity help two wounded beings fly to heaven.

[@cloversnek6751]

ok but one being wounded the other in the end. Hiccup ruined half of toothlesses tail (the night fury) and at the end of the first movie toothless rescues hiccup but not all of him I.E hiccup loses his foot so they both kinda wounded eachother tail for foot seems fair enough in this animation they did not wound eachother nor did they begin as enemys though i see what you mean and where you are coming from it is a truly beautiful animation and the meaning had me bawling

[@fgjjdgb3949]

@@cloversnek6751 The meaning is simple: "Together we will move mountains" and friendship helps people complement each other. It's just that sometimes people need to be reminded of this through similar works.

[@cloversnek6751]

@@fgjjdgb3949 "together we fly alone we fall" this is what i have learned through my expirences and this annimation perfectly shows it

[@user-uj1vc2mt9v]

서로의 부족한 점을 채워서 다시 날아간다 라는게 너무 감동적이에요..

[@user-ko2tw9he3t]

와 그림체 너무 몽글몽글 이쁘길래 프레임은 끊기겠지 생각했는데 부드럽고 진짜 미쳤다 분위기있고 내가 딱 좋아하는 느낌

[@user-mh6cb9fp6p]

프레임이 한 10~20정도 더 높았으면 그냥.....와....우리나라는 [가능성]이 이렇게 큰데 왜 발전을 못하는걸까....진짜 미스터리네....

[@user-ko2tw9he3t]

@@user-mh6cb9fp6p 진짜 와 1.25배속이나 1.5배속해보세요 ㅜ 진짜 약간의 끊긴다거나 어색한부분도 완전 부드러워지고 노래도 배속해도 분위기있고 잔잔해서 좋아요 ㅜ

[@SnowcatArt]

This looks PHENOMENAL! The story is conveyed so nicely, and the animation is smooth and soft! I absolutely adore this, great work!!

[@Evilriku13]

u say that when some animationframes feel like missing, especially during the beginning parts where the animation of the boy feels a bit choppy. Nonethelss a stellar perfomance of art

[@ramen8618]

0:40 the bird looking down on him "Pathetic"

[@music.notes7]

Tyltyl is actually a girl.

[@user-sl3wl4fi4y]

두 명 다 날개가 한쪽만 없어서 한명이 다른 한명을 위해 본인 날개를 희생하는 스토리일줄 알았는데 그 반대네요. 연출이 너무너무 완벽해서 마지막에 소름이 돋았습니다.

[@user-px5bk7li8x]

썸넬보고 기겁하며 들어옴;; 진심 개쩐다... 농담아니고 사람하나 갈렸을 것 같은데...

[@user-fq7vu9tl5f]

헐!?!?!?!? 그림체가 뭔가 익숙햇는데 제작 정혜리.... 이 분 다른 과제작들두 너무 좋아요.... 진자루 이 분 움직임이나 막 그런 것들 넘 좋아서 검색하구 그랫엇는데 아 진자루 대박이다ㅠㅠㅠ!!!!

[@Earth_1top_Cute]

혹시 이분이 제작한 다른 작들 영상 링크 보내주실ㄹ수 있나요ㅜㅜㅜ 이분 작품이 너무 제 취향이라서 더 보려고 찾아보고 있는데 못찾고있어서요...

[@bu7611]

@@Earth_1top_Cute 고스트러너러너런: m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/goHGcniajtKFaZo 빨간망토: m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/d3-9gougd85gaNU 저는 이렇게 두 개 찾았는데 더 있는지는 모르겠네요ㅜㅜ

[@Earth_1top_Cute]

@@bu7611 앗 감사합니다 🥺🙏

[@wapan_]

와 대박...... 진짜 너무 다 멋져요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@Itsrainingoutside]

@@bu7611 뭐야 다 유명한 작품들 이잖아..

[@user-zk2lq9zo3d]

이분 지금 메이플 애니메이션 회사에서 일하시는걸루 아는데 대박임

[@tulsibarai222]

Doesn't It feels like yinyang energy??!! 💞 ☯️.... So beautiful and magical✨🌈

[@user-gs7og5ue5q]

??? 알람떠서 그냥 오아앙 대학애니다 하고왓는데 썸네일보고 깜놀햇자너 완전 잘만드겼네요,,,,,,

[@goatring]

아니 어떻게 이런 퀄리티가 나올수가 있는거예요 스토리도 너무 완벽해...

[@marenillustrates4497]

It’s these kinds of cartoons that I like most. No talking, only motion and the flow of music. I LOVVVEEE these kinds of portrayals because I think it speaks out and reached out more than a cartoon with speaking in it.

[@malou4600]

that sounds really beautiful! Do you have any suggestions for longer films like that

[@marenillustrates4497]

Well…Fantasia by Disney is one example

[@marenillustrates4497]

It’s probably an hour plus

[@marenillustrates4497]

Two stop motion channels I enjoy are Tomosteen and I Like Home

[@QDWorks]

-- Great job! It's a peace of art !

[@user-tj8dd8fc9w]

Nema Aname

[@DBA_090]

엥? 이게 학생작품이라고오ㅡ?? 엥? 엥? 신작 애니 선공개 영상아닌가요?

[@user-mh6cb9fp6p]

게임 티저영상하고 맞먹는 수준 어쩌면 그이상

[@user-re9do4qe2x]

@@user-mh6cb9fp6p 뭐래

[@user-xu2fv7qh9w]

와 둘이 같이 나는 장면에서 진짜 온 몸에 소름 돋았다,, 청강대 애니과가 목표인데 하찮은 내가 들어갈 수 있을까 싶기도 하고... 언젠간 이 체널에 내 졸작도 올라왔으면 좋겠다..

[@user-gn1dq6ri8i]

화이팅❤️

[@user-un6dm2kd3s]

저 영상의 아이들처럼 예쁜 날개를 필 수 있을 거에요!

[@user-wg2nk1yr3t]

진짜 예쁘다는게 아름답다는게 이런거구나 세삼 느낍니다... 서로의 부족한것을 채워주고 비둘기를 동경하며 마지막엔 같이 미소지으며 나는 모습 까지.. 오늘부터 제 최애 애니 등극입니다 ㅜㅜㅜ 😭 사랑해요❤❤❤

[@arestotle]

By 3:32, I thought the white-winged one was gonna fall and die and black-winged one would find his resolve and use the fallen one's other wing to fly ;-; .... ending was happier than I thought

[@prokiller1509]

Her Both are girls

[@dontlookatmyplaylists]

Oml this is so gorgeous, I can’t wait to see more if there is. The ending when they are able to fly when they are together brings a tear to my eye 😢

[@threeyoungmanthreeyoungman8697]

Right , I just want to know one thing is ...........

[@prokiller1509]

@@threeyoungmanthreeyoungman8697 that is?

[@AI-Artist-]

If you want to watch more of it, Watch the anime Darling in the Fraxx. It is based on the same story 😢

[@molilollen4853]

@@AI-Artist- Well, you're not wrong but it ain't completely based on that scenario. I mean, it's mecha

[@AI-Artist-]

@@molilollen4853 yes it is mecha and just another way to tell the same story. First they mention the complete story of the birds with one wing and than beautifully portray that in post apocalyptic scenario and the ending is well.. together for eternity.

[@user-qn3zh1xe6w]

대박..제작에 이름 하나 있는데 너무 멋지고 존경스럽다..이거 만드려고 얼마나 고생했을거야ㅜㅜ

[@runaru4494]

혹시 심규선님 뮤비보고 오신분 계신가요? 원본버전도 뮤비버전도 너무 예쁜작화같아요!

[@user-qh9ot7vz8y]

진짜 너무 대단하고 너무 잘 만드셨다 ㅠㅠ 컷 하나하나 얼마나 정성 들이셨는지 잘 보여요

[@user-gx5qz8wt7z]

와.. 진짜 영혼을 갈아서 만들었을듯.. 연출이나 스토리나 그림이나.. 너무 멋지다

[@rymaix]

this looks like an actual show. i'd love to see it get an actual animation series!

[@rymaix]

@@Gundam-Prime no thanks, i'll be sticking to jjba.

[@winter7091]

Definitely!! I can't wait for this student to graduate and make more animations ❤

[@rymaix]

@@Gundam-Prime i said i'd be sticking to jjba.. can you not read

[@rymaix]

@@winter7091 agreed! i'd like to see how they'd improve and get better with time

[@braindeadotaku3520]

@@rymaix haha that sounded way to mean man

[@user-eh6vw5oe5k]

와 진짜 숨죽이면서 보다가 둘이 같이 나는 장면에서 소름돋았어요 .. 연출이며 구도며 뭐 하나 빠짐없이 다 좋아요 .. 꼭 애니메이터로 활동 널리널리 해주셨음 좋겠네요 응원할게요 !!

[@S2_sayak]

수많은 졸업작품 중 유일하게 찾아서 보고 알고리즘에 뜰떄마다 꼭 챙겨보는 작품ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@jennyduong2466]

I can’t imagine the sheer amount of work that had to go into this animation! The whole team did an amazing job creating this.

[@user-jc6hu9mx5x]

This is actually a graduation project of one student... although there are some ppl for special thx and helping but still can you imagine??

[@euntro40]

@@user-jc6hu9mx5x one student! that's amazing!

[@minnarin7324]

@@user-jc6hu9mx5x truly truly amazing😭

[@CC_Zhang]

The animation has such a beautiful meaning and is one of the best I've seen! The emotions were conveyed perfectly even without the characters talking, the animation and music is very bountiful and helps a lot in enhancing the emotions felt by not only the viewer but also the characters themselves! Beautiful, to say the least!

[@yachirosan]

بليييز اسم

[@naotokamigire-terumi9912]

I thought so as well

[@norbertatya4018]

Beautiful comment

[@showtime4964]

This so cute I can’t help but this remind me of Hyunjin and Felix from stray kids. So much of their warm and kind relationship towards each other.❤

[@erischan08vii19]

I really searched "angel boy with short black wing anime" here on YT and this is exactly the first video on the results. This is a wonderful masterpiece!

[@TheKevinGames]

I cannot understand any of the comments lol, but I just wanna say, this is fantastic, incredible work!!

[@user-qm1zl8sl8d]

This is a graduation project from a student at CK animation university from Korea

[@user-qm1zl8sl8d]

And it was made alone 😟

[@TheKevinGames]

Wait whaaaaattt????

[@TheKevinGames]

Ig i'm giving up being a animator now lol

[@jeyceethebaddest3760]

You're the english comment im looking for

[@yippie_]

진짜 온몸에 소름돋음...애니 정말...힘든 거 뼈저리게 느껴봐서 더 대단하다

[@user-fp1er9wh7l]

TikTokから来たけど素晴らしい… 絵も綺麗だし、物語も考えさせられる内容でした…

[@elijahkrnk]

이걸 이제야 보다니. ㅠㅜ 진짜 프로다. ㅠㅠㅠㅜㅠㅠㅜ 작화, 퀄리티, 스토리 라인까지 다 완벽하네

[@toast9260]

man, I love whoever made this, the animation’s super smooth and the expressions are amazing. I hope they keep up the good work and find a decent job

[@user-agugu]

이런 따뜻한 색감 오랜만이다... 첫 장면부터 색감보고 감탄함... 몽글몽글한 움직임, 따뜻한 색감, 마음이 편해지는 사운드까지...

[@sonalpadhiyar303]

It touched my heart without saying any word

[@user-tn7qn2wo4e]

와씨 릴스 보고 왔는데 당연히 일본애니라 생각했건만 우리나라가 만든 애니였다니 진짜 대단하다,, 우리나라도 충분히 명작 애니 만들수 있는데 왜 위에서는 막는겨,, 내 국뽕,,

[@Whyyo-3-]

1:11 웃는거보고 온몸이 녹아내림 ㅠㅠ저기 금발단발씨ㅠㅠㅠ 햇상룽 머금으셨습니다 아주ㅠㅠ 하아ㅠㅠㅠㅠ그리고 앞에 뱁새같은 귀여븐 칭구ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 둘이 어떡해ㅠㅠ

[@oneka3662]

진짜 청강대 애니메이션 대단하다...ㄷㄷ

[@gulso_]

오랜만에 다시봐도 진짜 너무 잘 만들었다ㅠ 프레임이랑 작화도 좋고 편안하고 아름다운 분위기가 너무 좋은 것 같습니다

[@lunerlilly]

Omg I'm crying and so happy for them. This beautiful! Thank you so much for sharing this with us. Edit: was so captured by emotion I couldn't critique lol. All involved put so much soul into this. I was cheering for them both from the start. The Animation is fantastic 👌 but no one can deny the story and emotion that was wonderfully expressed in this. From start to finish I couldn't stop being drawn in. Wonderful simply beautiful. I wish I could express stronger complimenting words. ♥

[@user-rw3hc4qd8k]

와..ㅠㅠ마지막에 반쪽밖에 없는 두 날개가 합쳐져서 결국에는 완벽한 날개가 되는거 너무 좋다

[@lane_01_ki]

와,,,, 무료로 보는게 죄책감이 들 정도로 너무 엄청난 작품이에요....

[@user-wj9hu7is6f]

約5分間の動画なのにとても素敵な映画を見た感覚でした、、満足感がすごい、 イラストも綺麗で好きです！

[@wolfoxyt8781]

this helped inspire a character for a book :D

[@st4rryk]

Oh my god this style is so beautiful. I love how each character is drawn. And the emotion.. the sky reflected in the eyes.. The story truly coneys that no matter what happens, you're never alone. This is just amazing.

[@user-sg8ui7ho6f]

검은 날개는 틸틸 하얀 날개는 미틸... 너무 짠하고 울컥한다 작화며 음악 내용 너무 훌륭해요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ허엉

[@gamedokter]

Man, Sephiroth was cute as a kid.

[@nichkhunbuck232]

This so cute this reminds me of Hyunjin and Felix omg the warm relationship is definitely them!❤

[@dydor6670]

3:52 와 진심 몸에 전율이 돌고 나도 모르게 울컥함 진짜 와...

[@whatthe460]

날개 움직임 너무 좋음... 귀여운 와기 천사들...

[@user-bl3fo1wh8b]

원래 인간은 너무 좋으면 원시적인 말 밖에 안 나온다고 하죠 이것. 좋다.

[@MayaSaleh-fb9ug]

Who needs studio gibli? Bro can make a whole anime on ur own

[@jakjang6896]

이런 유능한 인재가 있는데 항상 티비와 애니채널엔 키즈용만 주구장창.. 존경합니다

[@user-we6ct6sr6n]

그러게요 키즈용 애니메이션이 아니라면 다 적자나서 망하니....다들 외국으로 떠나죠...

[@dreamerbell_]

That was beautiful 😭❤ when I saw both of them had torn wings, I thought that they could just fly together, and they did! This was so wonderfully done, the animation was pretty and the story was well expressed. This is so nice 🤧

[@user-tv6ie2lj6c]

대박이다... 붙잡았을 때 어떻게 되려나 했는데 두 외날개가 한 쌍의 날개가 되어서 함께 날다니...연출 스토리 작화 배경음악 다 멋지다...

[@user-wi9sn3bc4u]

素敵すぎる……！！！！ 言葉がないから言語を気にせず見れるしほんとに美しい……

[@user-ji7jb8iw8m]

와 진짜 색감도 너무 예쁘고 프레임까지 너무 부드럽고 내용도 너무 감동적.. 그냥 나쁜점 하나도 없이 너무 잘 만드셨어요

[@user-el7is1nd2i]

아무런 대사도 목소리도 안나오는데 모든 게 다 전달되는 느낌임 프레임도 끊김없이 부드럽고... 우리나라 애니쪽 상황을 자세히 아는건 아닌데 상업적으로도 잘 팔릴 것같음... 졸작 수고하셨어요

[@blackwings2885]

Officially my favorite non-dialogue animation video on KZbin...

[@zion620]

진짜 정혜리씨 애니메이션계의 기적임 거의 무형문화제

[@user-ih4ty1pk2y]

쿄애니 단편작 보는 느낌이다..💕

[@user-fs4hp6nq7t]

그림체를 보니 없잖아 영향받은 듯

[@winter7091]

This is so beautifully made. I cannot believe its from university students ♡ The story, rendeding, art, music, directing is all superb

[@user-ir5gg7tp1k]

헐 진짜 역대급인 듯.. 그림체도 좋은데 안 끊기고 이어지는 거 ㅜㅠ

[@zxcvbnm5897]

4:29 This will be my new desktop wallpaper

[@ha2il]

보는내내 입꼬리가 안 내려감.. 작화 스토리 구도 연출 다 미쳤다 ㅠㅠ 이게 졸작이라니...

[@Wintering1997]

" 대한민국은 wings 소유국이다. "

[@user-mh6cb9fp6p]

하지만 우리나라는 애니산업에 대해서는 알에서 깨어나지도 않았다......

[@user-vn9ed3ow6t]

대박... 어떻게 대사 하나 들리지 않는데 표정과 행동 하나만으로 모든것을 표현 할 수 있을까 그림체도 너무 내 취향이라 안 좋아할 수가 없다.. 내 기준 이렇게 짧은 애니메이션 중 진짜 맘에 든 TOP5에 든다...

[@user-es1ms6fk6x]

와 진짜 대박이다 스토리도 좋고 그림체도 예쁘고 노래밖에 안들리는데 진짜 감정 그대로 전해지는거 같음

[@myHJFL]

진짜 너무 멋진 작품이라고 생각해서 감동해서 sns찾아봤는데 파쿠리범이란 말 듣고 짜게식음...ㅎ 어쨌든 작품 자체는 정말 멋있다.

[@bombasticsideeye123]

Am i crying? Yes. Am i gonna watch it again? *Yes.*

[@RTOmega]

Who else was screaming "JUST HOLD HANDS WHILE FLYING" internaly?

[@user-pb5su4ry3b]

와우~넘 멋져요. 다음 작품이 기대되네요. 영상 잘보고 갑니다 ~

[@user-dl6uh4ok2u]

진자 개입브네요♡ 니시타만 아니었음 눈물 줄줄흘렀음

[@user-lz5sg2gg8w]

너무 감동적이에요 오랜만에 이런 뭉클한 감정을 느껴 보는 거 같아요.. 정말 얼마나 많이 노력해오셨을지.. 너무 대단하고 존경스럽습니다. 좋은 작품 만들어주셔서 감사합니다! 성함 꼭 기억해놓고있을게요 앞으로 많은 작품으로 만나뵐 수 있길 바라며!

[@harang_owo]

진짜 너무 감동적이다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 소리빨 없이 봐도 울컥하게 만드네

[@lunarglow75898]

I love how the two characters share the name of the two main characters in the Blue bird screen play/movie/anime . That is a really nice touch and reference.