Can Indonesia Harness Nuclear Power By 2045? | Insight | Full Episode

By 2045, Indonesia could harness one of the world’s most controversial energy sources - nuclear power. A New and Renewable Energy Bill, that is currently tabled in parliament, will make nuclear a key energy pillar, to mitigate climate change.
With three nuclear research reactors already operating in the country, Indonesia has been considering nuclear as a power option for almost seven decades. But despite most of the population supporting the use of nuclear, there are still pockets of opposition, among activists and politicians alike, who fear a nuclear fallout like Fukushima.
Does Indonesia have the required expertise and governance to run nuclear power plants?
For greater INSIGHT into issues affecting Asia:
• Insight
===============
ABOUT THE SHOW: Insight investigates and analyses topical issues that impact Asia and the rest of the world.
==========================
#CNAInsider #CNAInsiderInvestigates #indonesia #nuclearpower #energy #sustainability
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider

[@michell7361]

Singapore is actually afraid that Indonesia will become a developed country, that's why they make news that scares the public about the dangers of nuclear power plants

[@abcddef2112]

Or they are afraid Indonesia is getting more developed, their superiority complex can't take it. They can't say indonesia is underdeveloped in nuclear capacity since they have to show the operating reactor, can singapore even produce samarium? It is clear, they even talk offtopic alot about other renewable but failed to mention Indonesia is 2nd biggest geothermal energy producer in the world. Well bear in mind this is Singaporean government propaganda.

[@as-1982]

Why are you jealous of Singapore? Why are they afraid of Indonesia if Indonesia become a develop nation? They don't care at all. Why do quite a lot of Indonesians get easily suspicious and defensive when others from outside the country make reports or documentary about Indonesia, even though they're not about negative things? Indonesians have too much BAPER.

[@xcre8ionx]

No Singaporean in the video bod0 🤣

[@feryahmad6181]

@@xcre8ionx jangan gitu tidak baik

[@uwaisal-qarni8364]

@@xcre8ionx kau itu yang bodoh, semua negara maju memang tidak ingin negara berkembang maju liat aja africa mereka tidak peduli dan hanya meperkaya kaum mereka sendiri

[@fredo4842]

Ini negara Indonesia, kami tidak mau terus menerus di perbudak oleh orang luar. Mari bersama sama orang Indonesia memaju kan bangsa ini, Karena kalau bukan kita siapa lg

[@okkyjellydrinks6131]

Kagak nyambung

[@metalextras]

Indonesia already have Nuclear program since President Sukarno's 1954 with a proofing power reactor done in 1987 and BATAN already enriching and exporting it for radiology currently, so it's just a matter of political will. Indonesia have zero tectonic fault line in Kalimantan and Riau Islands, so it is normal that Singapore may finds it upsetting as that region share the same sea.

[@abcddef2112]

Kinda funny documentary about nuclear that did not talk about the nuclear project at all. Just watch thorcon videos, one of the nuclear project in the pipeline.

[@metalextras]

@@abcddef2112 Which part of it is funny? do you even watch the doc or failed to understand English? Choose subtitle on your own language and you will come at very similar conclusion.

[@abcddef2112]

@@metalextras No, im just criticizing the documentary that did not talk about nuclear projects that is currently underway (one of the lobbyist if you will of the law that about to be passed in november is attached to one of this project), around half of the documentary length is instead talking about other renewable, its solar anyway to create the impression Indonesia isnt investing in renewable, why not mention geothermal, Indonesia is already the second biggest producer in the world. The reason is clear they tried to make Indonesia look incompetent, im laughing at the blatant bias of cna.

[@kuyaatnic9257]

@@abcddef2112 bang itu mulai dari menit 1:30 itu bahas reaktor nuklir terbesar di asean indo sudah punya 3 powerplant meskipun belum untuk komersil ... nonton videonya gak sih

[@abcddef2112]

@@kuyaatnic9257 Have you finished watching it? Around half of the documentary length is spent not talking about nuclear. Why not talk about the project which is currently underway. They talk of 3 potential sites but not listing any projects. Its clear they don't know what they are talking about (since one project alreayd have timeline and progress) or maybe they do but intentionally not show them. Its clear what they (singapore) are trying to say to the question in the title is, Indonesia can't harness nuclear power plant by 2045. Its not an honest discussion.

[@salixalba9677]

Negara luar takut kalau Indonesia bisa kembangkan PLTN nuklir, bukan sebab ketakutan bakal bocor atau meledak, tapi lebih kepada kekhawatiran dan ketidakmauan melihat negara kita ini mandiri di bidang energi. Mereka pengen negara kita itu bodoh, ketergantungan selamanya dengan negara asing, Kemajuan sebuah negara sebesar Indonesia ini adalah suatu ancaman buat negara luar, apalagi negara tetangga Malaysia, apalagi negara kecil macam Singapura

[@davidivory3234]

Indonesia itu bahaya banyak teroris jd politikus disana.

[@muhammadsecret8783]

Indonesia has already had nuclear reactor, the best in SEA. They just dont want us to make N bomb

[@kucingoyen9965]

Itu benar, orang indonesia adalah konsumtif dari barang negara maju

[@yayadafa8166]

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@hawaandroid2786]

Balik balik Malaysia yang kamu tuduh, negara kamu gagal kelola petrol himgga beli dari Singapura, yang dibenci Malaysia. Bukan Malaysia yang tetapkan harga minyak dunia mahupun minyak sawit. Tetapi trader dunia. Kalau kami yang tetapkan harga maka pasti kami mahu harga petrol dan sawit mahal sentiasa. Tetapi tidak, jika pasaran dunia harganya rendah, kami pun terimpak sama. Mahu pakai nukleur silakan, bukan masalah nukleur yang ditakuti, masalah safety. Jepun saja gagal jaga reaktor nukleur mereka. Sedangkan mereka itu teliti orangnya. Sebenarnya masalah tenaga bukan masalah jiran tetangga. Masalah pencemaran nukleur boleh ganggu jiran tetangga. Jika negara jiran merasa risau maka itu adalah normal. Bukan kerana iri hati atau pembodohan negara Indonesia.Tiada siapa yang mahu membodohkan orang Indonesia, yang membodohkan itu diri kamu sendiri dengan asumsi berburuk sangka. Pertamina diuruskan orang kamu bukan orang Malaysia mahupun Singapura. Jika wang pembangunan dibuat kilang minyak oleh pemerintah kamu bukankah lebih baik. Kes minyak masak tak cukup, siapa kartel minyak yang tinggal di Singapura? Taikun Indonesia kan? Kami orang Malaysia perhatikan saja tindak tanduk pemerintah kamu, apabila berlaku kelemahan pemerintahan, maka salahkan Malaysia, maka publik dan media sosial pun gencar membenci Malaysia, fitnah itu ini. Sementara kamu membenci jiran kamu sendiri , tambang nikel kamu dikuasai China atas nama orang Indonesia, smelter juga dikuasai China tapi kamu tidak benci China kan.

[@drphilipk]

I get the unmitigated tone of self interest CNA is pitching SIngapore foreign policy and fears of nuclear accidents. More to the point, Singapore supplies refined petroleum products to Indonesia and has no interest in a energy independent Indonesia. Much of Indonesian wealth is also in Singapore and much of that from wanton destruction of rainforests for palm oil plantations. The SIngapore based Asian Pulp and Paper being chief in that regard.. The nuclear FUD just is too hypocritical coming from 99% fossil fuel dependent Singapore with the bling bling lifestyle which Indonesians are burning Kerosene lamps. Please stop.

[@f4u21ramon8]

Don't liar, karosene lamp ??singapore ? 50% appartment in singapore is indonesian owner, many indonesia company use singapore flag just for export actually their owner is still indonesian (secret)

[@f4u21ramon8]

Actually indonesia have batan (nuclear for electric) since 1954, and PLTN muria energy nuclear since 80s, first in south east asia

[@m2heavyindustries378]

I think they're making too much money to care Philip :)

[@lyq232]

@@f4u21ramon8 bruh, ya need to reread OP

[@abcddef2112]

@@f4u21ramon8 they mentioned this is the doc, though neglect to mention the power plant projects which are underway.

[@totoabubakar1008]

Indonesia already have nuclear reactor research facility for many years, and also its safest for many years. So not imposible for Indonesia.

[@abcddef2112]

Indonesian nuclear priority definitely go up after AUKUS. Even if Indonesia did not take France offer of nuclear subs (apparently not violation on NPT), it definitely will want to invest in nuclear. People seemed suprise Indonesia had nuclear reactor. Why CNA did not talk about one of the projest that is underway by thorcon, they have been hiring some veterans from Oak Ridge, BATAN and SINAP. Also agreements with PAL, Empresarios Agrupados, ministry of defense and energy as well BRIN. Bob Effendi is basically the proponent of that bill you talked about.

[@hikashia.halfiah3582]

I think nuclear energy generation itself is independent of AUKUS. There's already some talk about thorium energy generation long way before AUKUS became a thing. Well at least that's how it was when I was in university during latter half of last decade.

[@realgrilledsushi]

I’m happy with what Indonesia is achieving toward sustainable energy. Hoping many success to Indonesia!

[@muchafdlolludin]

2045 Indonesia will become the 3rd largest economy in asia and make country zero emission with electrical transportation with : 1. Hydro power 2. Wind energy 3. Thermal power Nothing impossible if Indonesia make nuclear power for it to become the biggest electrical country producers. 🇮🇩

[@firdaus99031]

*geothermal

[@namazlur78]

Lol. Upgrade infrastructure which is so bad now. Inter district’s connectivity is next to nothing, human development still low & poverty is high.

[@sayidafzal7534]

@@namazlur78 wow 😝😝😝😝 you can say anything about my country cause your country very small and easy to maintance , and you dont have natural resources 😜

[@namazlur78]

@@sayidafzal7534 that is the truth and it might be a painful one. Over depending on china gonna bring a lot of problems later. 23 nickel smelter in Indonesia, 21 are owned by China.

[@insomnia0140]

@@namazlur78 there is no such thing called over dependency, that's why we are moving our capital city and build a lot of new infrastructure, and talking about foreign investment, china investment in indonesia is still far behind Japan & USA, and our national debt is below 50% of GDP mostly come from domestic debt not foreign debt.

[@auzan1313]

One more thing that CNA has been missed on this documentary is, they’re not interviewing the Regulatory Body for nuclear energy in Indonesia (BAPETEN). BRIN (previously BATAN) is the operator for nuclear reactors in Indonesia, you can’t ask the operating body related to the safety and security aspect.

[@buserroni]

As i know BRIN previously is LIPI.

[@auzan1313]

@@buserroni Yes, not only LIPI, BATAN, BPPT, and LAPAN also merges into BRIN 😊

[@Alpha-kl4jo]

More like safety and security aspects regulation. The operator itself definitely know and understand their own technical facility safety SOP which was built according to the HAZOP. Thus they know how safe is their facility. If you want to talk about the regulation then yeah it should had been better to interview the regulatory body.

[@auzan1313]

@@Alpha-kl4jo yes exactly, but I mean to show to the public related to how safety it is the nuclear research reactors in Indonesia, its better to ask the Regulatory Body rather than the Operating Body. The public trust is the main issue here, and media must show in the objective point of view, since the nuclear energy itself is quite sensitive issue in Indonesia and also the Region in Southeast Asia

[@KBProduction]

Sibuk aja lo Singapura, dari dulu tenaga nuklir sudah ada di Indonesia 😛

[@toguofficial385]

Biasa aja dong 😅

[@ismail_soekarnopoetra]

Visi Pak soeharto memang sangat jauh buktinya beliau dilengserkan intelejen singapura lewat sara etnis tionghoa dan juga dibantu australia lewat pergerakan mahasiswa separatisme diberbagai daerah hingga konflik sesama anak bangsa dimana itu semua dimodali barat. sayang kita gagal dengan tujuan itu dan sekarang china sukses besar karena sistem politik mereka komunis gak semudah era orde baru untuk diruntuhkan.

[@INDONESIABUBAR2030BYSPIZYDORI]

Singapore susah untuk digertak karena banyak negara Banckingannya

[@pesmobile-lh5fs]

@@INDONESIABUBAR2030BYSPIZYDORI susah bukan berarti gak bisa kalau direncanakan dengan matang dan bukan instan

[@jimbas777]

The content of this report is a bit misleading. As far as i know, Indonesia is pursuing different kind of nuclear technology for it's power plant to replace coal-based. Much more safer then conventional nuclear. it's the MSR (Molten Salt Reactor) technology with the main source is Thorium not uranium and it would be built in a ship. it would suitable since Indonesia has so many islands and it has very large Thorium deposit in Sumatera island. It's a join project with US based company called Thorcon since 2015

[@Nata4]

bukan hanya menyesatkan, Tapi sudah distorsi, hanya menampilkan sisi buruk! Terus desa yang disorot hanya satu. Coba daerah lain, terang benderang

[@muhammadyunan2811]

I think nuclear is the future of Indonesia. Maybe it will take about 10-20% of energy sources. As a Indonesian, I'm totally support nuclear project, simply cz we are a huge country, the 4th most populous country, and one of economic power, is a necessity for us to learn advanced technology. And there is one thing you missing out in this documentary video, That is BAPETEN. You cannot interviewd BATAN (BRIN), bcz they are operator. You hv to also interview BAPETEN as a regulator, who assure about risk management.

[@Mitrandhir]

it'll just like other projects (mangkrak), corrupted

[@muhammadyunan2811]

@@Mitrandhir mangkrak? 3 Reaktor Nuklir Indonesia udah dipakai riset bertahun-tahun lamanya 😅🤣 hasil produk industri nuklirnya jg diekspor udah dari lama. Kok bisa dikatakan mangkrak itu loh 😅 kalau PLTN tidak bisa dikatakan mangkrak, krn belum dibangun. Bahkan anggaran pun belum ada

[@Mitrandhir]

@@muhammadyunan2811 mangkrak🤣, wacana doang😂

[@muhammadyunan2811]

@@Mitrandhir mangkrak itu kalau udah disetujui, udah dibangun, tapi gk selesai. Itu makna mangkrak. Kamu arti mangkrak aja gk tau 🤦‍♂️ udah ngomong mangkrak. Keputusan penggunaan nuklir itu gk semudah bangun PLTU PLTA PLTS. Indonesia mau bangun PLTN, ASEAN pasti khawatir, Australia khawatir. Gk semudah itu. Krn PLTN ini bisa dikatakan kalau bocor berbahaya, dan bisa digunakan sebagai senjata pemusnah. Jadi perlu kesatuan politk. Gk ujuk2

[@YoanShaputraa]

Nuclear for Weapon ❎ Nuclear for Energy ☑️

[@dimasaditya5363]

For weapon 100% √

[@standard-carrier-wo-chan]

@@dimasaditya5363 Because of increasing global tensions, we do need to start developing nuclear weapons. There's no telling when (not if, when) regional wars from somewhere out there would expand and eventually hit the nation. Non-block politics is great to stave off conflicts and maintain neutrality, but we also need to be prepared to defend when someone inevitably stops respecting our neutrality.

[@sunder739]

@@standard-carrier-wo-chan nah, I don't think we want one, like... not even one. None of us wanted M.A.D to occur.

[@standard-carrier-wo-chan]

@@sunder739 What's necessary is not always what people want.

[@yohannesbeethovenladopoera7811]

its possible to us have nuclear weapon brother we need nuclear

[@Justmyopinionlol]

Singapore is a family run business. Crazy rich Chinese don’t want to see Indonesia surpass them.😂

[@imansas]

Banyak negara luar tidak senang jika Indonesia bergerak maju, termasuk Singapore, Indonesia bebas mengembangkan teknologi dan energi nuklir sendiri. Dalam hal ini negara luar sebaiknya jangan ikut campur! ini demi kepentingan dalam negri Indonesia.

[@INDONESIABUBAR2030BYSPIZYDORI]

Akan dibuat programnya seperti menjatuhkan Saddam Hussein. Media CNA ini pun yg punya adalah Singapore!

[@pesmobile-lh5fs]

Siapkan mental karna lo dikelilingi sekutu semua hanya Indonesia non blok dan mereka akan bekerjasama menjatuhkan kamu contoh Australia Singapore malaysit mana mau mereka Indonesia maju apalagi dengan potensi yg sangat tinggi, pertama mereka akan menyuap pejabat pastinya kalau ini gak berjalan pasti mereka akan menggunakan cara licik internasional atau dengan cara hitam

[@pesmobile-lh5fs]

Negara besar maju akan kalah dengan negara kecil maju jadi mati matian tuh akan menjatuhkan kita semoga aja pejabat kita mengerti ini

[@fatkhurohman2230]

Kenapa CNA polanya selalu seperti ini media Singapura!! Dan untuk LSM kayak Greenpeace buat nuklir diributin buat geothermah diributkan. Maunya gimanasih!!!! Kalau perlu LSM audit investigasi penuh aja supaya nggak ada motif tersembunyi

[@Enseaclopedia]

"Kenapa CNA polanya selalu seperti ini media Singapura!!" lah kan emang media singapura ...

[@TheTeknus]

@@Enseaclopedia Takut tetangganya lebih maju dari mereka sendiri 😅

[@fajartiyarabdulmajid7807]

Dengan terpenuhinya listrik maka ada industrialisasi dan akan mengangkat perekonomian...negara yang terancam kalau indonesia makmur itu..Malaysia karena mereka butuh tenaga kerja murah ..kalau Indonesia makmur mereka bakal kehilangan itu.... Germany...mereka butuh pemasok supply chain murah..mereka butuh tenaga kerja murah...kalau Indonesia makmur..tenaga kerja mahal...Singapura itu proxy pengusaha tadi...makanya beritanya wow

[@muhammadsecret8783]

Greenpeace kenapa enggak kritik negara Eropa dan America yg punya banyak Nuclear Reactor ?

[@wapleviathan4006]

Liputannya komprehensif kok, balance malah kalau saya lihat. Jangan apa2x langsung dihubungkan ke "Asing Asong Ga Suka Indonesia Maju" deh. Dan concern nya si Greenpeace juga patut diperhatikan demi keselamatan bersama.

[@RE-uk2ml]

Dongeng dongeng SJW mengenai nuklir, tidak lain hanya ingin kita tertinggal. Lebih murah membayar SJW daripada meng Invasi suatu negara.

[@JuJun12345]

SJW sih bisa dilawan dengan debat bro. Yang susah itu, nanti 2024, seorang capres didanai asing. Kalau pemilih gak tau, ya gini2 terus Indonesia 😂

[@INDONESIABUBAR2030BYSPIZYDORI]

Sekali² Singapore itu perlu digertak juga!

[@pesmobile-lh5fs]

@@INDONESIABUBAR2030BYSPIZYDORI pembully aja kalau kita diam terus mereka tambah jadi sama hal nya dengan bisnis atau ekonomi dan politik kalau kita maju Singapore dan malaysit bahkan australian jadi babu t

[@RE-uk2ml]

Itu negara negara maju sini Invest lah. Kalian juga mempunyai tanggung jawab moral. Kalian sudah menikmati TIPPING POINT dan COMPOUNDING dari energi fosil, sementara negara bekas jajahan masih menggunakan fosil persis seperti dahulu kalian membangun neagra kalian juga dari energi fosil hanya timeline saja yang berbeda. Jadi kalau Indonesia masih mengunakan Coal itu wajar, zero emission target mundur sekalipun juga wajar, Yang terpenting sini negara- negara maju hanya ngomong doang uang nya gak cair cair, ngomongnya besar climate change, tapi ketika diminta uang untuk Investasi di Indonesia renewable energy Banyak alasannya ~ by Mr.Luhut Pandjaitan.

[@julianhost3953]

GREEN PEACE IN INDONESIA IS PAID BY BIG OIL COMPANY

[@DeihanDzilky]

*_Indonésia punya banyak poténsi, bahkan para ahli nuklir Orang Indonésia banyak bekerja di Negara lain, jadi untuk apa ngembangin Negara Orang sementara negara sendiri dibiarkan. Makanya Pemerintah sekarang sangat serius dengan slogan Énergi Terbarukan yang sa'at ini sedang digaungkan di KTT G20!!!_* *_HIDUPLAH INDONÉSIA RAYA!!!_* 🇮🇩❤️🇮🇩

[@DeihanDzilky]

👌😎👍

[@jaredspencer3304]

One of the biggest casualties of the US-China trade war is that collaboration has stopped between companies that were working on building small-scale nuclear reactors; small enough to fit on the back of a delivery truck. Very safe and very cheap because they can be made in a factory instead of having to be built onsite like the huge reactors. Hopefully progress can pick up again soon.

[@KGopidas]

There is the possibility of a floating reactor if suitable size, given so many nuclearpowered aircraft carrier s and submarines in the world!!!

[@bernadmanny]

Russia already made a floating reactor and guess what it came in way over budget and over schedule.

[@zil1832]

yeah I was watched that. About the small scale reactors in "tech for luddites". It seemed exciting.

[@sayidafzal7534]

Typical CNA lah berita negarif terus tentang Indonesia 😂 padahal negara maju lain seperti Jepang , Korea dan China , Rusia menggunakan nuklir

[@dharmasatya3265]

Amerika bahkan gk mau ninggalin nuklir reactor uraniumnya karena ada hasil akhir yg bisa di pakai di senjata nuklir. Mungkin ini yg di takuti CNA.

[@pesmobile-lh5fs]

Dijatuhin jangan sampai rakyat Indonesia terhasut negara negara tetangga maunya mereka kita selalu dibawah mereka padahal potensi kita sangat besar

[@Nata4]

anggap saja CNA lgi ngelawak

[@fajartiyarabdulmajid7807]

It's so stupid for Singapore to think that nuclear reactor would be built in ring of volcano island ...there is Kalimantan/ Borneo which save for earthquake problem..and in Borneo there would be built future industrial complex replacing java

[@moronhunter]

Dijawa pun sebenernya juga bisa bang, tpi yg sebelah utara. Jadikan jepang sebagai contohnya yg mampu mempunyai nuclear power plant walau wilayahnya masuk ring of fire

[@muhammadsecret8783]

In Kalimantan, better make electricity from dam, there are many rivers there

[@bebekkurus]

Indonesia already have nuclear powerplant for years. It is safe.

[@fajartiyarabdulmajid7807]

@@bebekkurus no...batan built that for research purpose and produce some isotop for manufacturing x ray...but power plant haven't built yet

[@bebekkurus]

@@fajartiyarabdulmajid7807 Doesn't they also generate power from nuclear reactor for themselves in those facilities?

[@alexlanzuela6004]

As a Filipino, we had The Philippine Nuclear Program that started in 1958 with the creation of the Philippine Atomic Energy Commission (PAEC) due to the "ENERGY CRISIS" and "hardwork and effort of the Filipino Nuclear Physicists and Researchers" with the support of political will and government funds created the Bataan Nuclear Power Plant (BNPP) but was never used and continued due to social pressure and political instability in the Philippines as well as Corrupt Oligarchs and State Officials... Hopefully Indonesia can do it and build it like us but never fall like us in the Philippine Struggle.

[@Heavenlyrules]

Well, we did have nuclear power plant (I think more than one, but I forget the exact number) and some of the electricity generated was used comercially. The thing is they are just too small to have an impact for a nation as large as indonesia. My lonhest dream is for indonesia to secure advanced nuclear techs, build mega nuclear power plants, and produce our own nuclear warheads

[@zulfiakram]

@@Heavenlyrules baca awal-awal comment sih wholesome, kok akhir-akhir sebut "Nuclear Warhead". serem kali kau ini kak

[@supercat1997]

@@Heavenlyrules we don’t need a nuclear warhead.

[@ghtrl8]

@@zulfiakram kenapa tidak untuk warhead. Saya sangat mendukung kalau memang punya kapasitas dan kapabilitas.

[@zulfiakram]

@@ghtrl8 Indonesia merupakan salah satu pendiri Non-Aligned Movement jadi kurang pas saja kalau negara non-block yang seharusnya mempromosikan kedamaian dunia mempunyai senjata nuklir. menurut saya akan terlihat munafik.

[@muhammadfazrimanurung2009]

West kalimantan was the best place to make nuclear power plant because it's safe from earthquake, flood and other disaster

[@user-lr6hw4dq4t]

Indonesian : Lets build nuclear reactor also Indonesian : but not in my backyard fun fact : also people in the entire world : yes, but not in my backyard !!!!

[@mistermorphescarnoe2898]

Nuclear power is great if it can be developed, applied and distributed properly. Indonesia, like many other Southeast Asian countries, is known to have deep-seething corruption when it comes to government projects, but I hope the process of development can be overseen by a veteran third-party, several engineers (maybe even foreign) whom have extensive experience in building and maintaining nuclear reactors. I hope the government spares no expense in hiring and assigning the right people for the job, and really increasing the standards of safety when it comes to maintaining nuclear reactors. Despite advances in nuclear safety technology, a lot of the responsibility is held on the operators therefore they must be truly up to the task. Indonesia cannot afford any form of nuclear disasters, even if plants are in remote locations, due to the intense population density.

[@abcddef2112]

Bwahahaha deep-seething??!

[@andipejalan3382]

there are 3 location for Nuclear Power Plant in Indonesia : Semenanjung Muria (Central Java), West Kalimantan and Bangka Belitung. The 2 latest location are free from earth quake and near the source of Uranium. Why Indonesia didnt have nuclear PP until now? its because of POLITICAL WILL. Indonesia has many nuclear expert, some of them are expert in IAEA and has capability to design and operate Nuclear Power Plant.

[@MrTrigraffiti]

you don't need to worry... we will entrust to russia and iran all the process..😂😂😂

[@ukmkotabandung3609]

Uranium. = NO Thorium. = YES In addition to nickel, the mineral is very rare in the world, thank God, in Indonesia there is the highest amount of nickel in the world. In addition to nickel, another hot issue is 'rare earth', what are rare earth metals: Rare earth, often informed contains 17 mineral elements, including: The 17 elements that make up this metal include: scandium, yttrium, lanthanum, cerium, praseodymium, neodymium, promethium, samarium, europium, gadolinium, terbium, dysprosium, holmium, erbium, thulium, ytterbium, and lutetium. element ? , because there are some mineral elements that are hidden. What's that : Example ... Rare Earth Metals. Thorium (Th) is an element that is included in the collection of rare earth / rare earth metals, often intentionally in every news or scientific journal, thorium is always not included in the elements contained in rare earth metals, even though thorium is part of the rare earth metal elements, why is this conducted ? Because so valuable Thorium contained in rare earth metals. Thorium is the main energy source of energy in the world. Thorium is a very effective and efficient source of energy that is currently known in the world. Can produce energy for power generation . Ships are very large . Thank God again, thank God, thorium is very abundant in the nature of the Motherland of the Republic of Indonesia, it has not even been used by western countries due to its scarcity. Moreover, it was informed that Lapindo mud is a high grade mud of rare earth metals. Another name for thorium is a green nuclear energy source. Because the western world is afraid of the revival of Indonesia's energy sources with thorium, they always prevent it with the slogan prohibiting nuclear development on the grounds that they are wary of making nuclear bombs. Why is the western world afraid of Indonesia going forward with Thorium energy? Because nuclear thorium is different from their nuclear source which is made of uranium, it is even estimated that Thorium mine reserves are 4 times larger than Uranium on this Mother Earth, this amount is abundant. Rare earth metals are rare, because they are located deep in the ground, the excavation costs are very expensive. Unlike in Indonesia, Lapindo mud contains a lot of rare earth metals, it comes out by itself continuously, so the term is just taking it from the ground, without drilling costs. The question is what is the difference between uranium and thorium-based nuclear materials? Thorium is the fuel that has the densest energy density. As a result, 1 ton of thorium which is only the size of a basketball can be used as fuel for a 1,000 MW power plant for 1 year. Compare with uranium: thorium = 200: 1, meaning that the power of 200 grams of uranium is proportional to the power of 1gram of thorium, Very Fantastic! , or comparable to the thermal energy of coal which requires 3.5 tons. - and what is more encouraging is that Indonesia has thorium reserves for 1,000 years. (This does not include Lapindo mud). Radiation waste: If the waste of 250 tons of uranium can reach 35 tons, uranium waste that still contains radioactive tens to hundreds of years. Compared to the waste of 1 tonne of thorium, he said it was only 30 grams. “In 10 years the thorium waste also no longer contains radioactive reactions. thorium must contain oxygen, and other elements that form minerals with phosphate (P) to become monazite (Ce, La, Nd, Th)PO4. “So monazite consists of several rare earth element minerals, and thorium is included in it. It is very good that cooperation with Russia is further enhanced, the roadmap for development of bilateral cooperation in the sphere of nuclear fuel cycle between Rosatom fuel compant TVEL and Batam is very good. PT Timah Tbk (TINS) is ready to provide raw materials for the Thorium Power Plant (PLTT). The provision of this raw material is to supply Thorcon International Pte, Ltd who want to build a PLTT in the country. How to ? Simple Process of Extracting Ultra Pure Thorium from Rare Earth ores: Thorium is an important related element in rare earth ores and is also an important nuclear fuel. The most efficient method of recovering it from rare earth sulfuric acid solution is by solvent extraction with the primary amine extractant N1923. TBP is a traditional extractant for further purification of the extracted thorium. However there are some problems with TBP such as high water solubility and complicated extraction mechanism. Several extraction systems have been developed to overcome this difficulty. Process for recovering and purifying thorium oxide from aqueous solutions containing thorium by liquid-liquid extraction (Christensen and Prater, 1960). The procedure includes: (1) leaching of the ore material with hydrochloric acid; (2) extracting thorium with an organophosphate selected from a group consisting of mono-heptadesyl-orthophosphoric acid, 2,6,8-trimethylnonyl-orthophosphoric acid, 2-monotridesic-orthophosphoric acid, and 5-ethylnonyl-orthophosphoric acid; (3) scrubbing dirt with hydrochloric acid; (4) partial stripping of thorium with sulfuric acid and complete stripping of thorium with alkaline carbonate solution; and (5) precipitating thorium with oxalic acid and calcining it to form thorium oxide. High purity thorium (99.99%) was obtained.( ). Go forward Indonesia, only by leaders who are trustworthy in Pancasila & the 1945 Constitution, be honest, Amen. Semangat !

[@ianhomerpura8937]

@@andipejalan3382 nuclear power plants can be built in earthquake prone areas. Fukushima #1 and #2 initially survived the earthquake fully intact. However it has a major design flaw: the backup generators were built below sea level to cut down on expenses. When the tsunami hit, those generators were inundated and were destroyed. That caused the meltdown. Meanwhile, nearby Onagawa Nuclear Power Plant, located in one of the most devastated towns in Miyagi, survived fully intact without any problems, because it was designed and built properly.

[@nusantara1642]

I am one of those who fully support the existence of nuclear in Indonesia.. something new is something that can advance a nation, if the government supports it it is certain that this dream will come true.

[@misiangelaputri5839]

maju terus Indonesia ku jgn mau di atur..ma negara sebelah kita bangsa besar yg berdaulat laksanakan apa pun demi kemajuan bangsa dan kemakmuran rakyatnya

[@f.s.firdaus8106]

Nuclear power? Nah! We're into NUCLEAR WEAPON

[@jo-wo3we]

nuclear war must never be fought, saudaraku.

[@BloodyofHistory]

Yes yes ,good idea ,you must become our presiden ,ayo tunjukan ke sg ,klau satu bom ,kabooom tu negara 😂😂😂

[@muhammadsecret8783]

LOL rahasia harus dijaga rapat wkwkwkwkwk

[@fergutin8689]

Soo ...memang pemerintah indonesia akan merencanakan membangun pembangkit listrik tenaga nuklir untuk sektor sipil dan industrial karena apa?? ...Karena indonesia mempunyai penduduk yg lebih dari 276jt jiwa ... dan pemerintah menargetkan mereformasi sektor industri di dalam negeri ...pemerintah juga sudah merencanakan ketahanan pangan dengan food estate,membangun jalan tol, jembatan,bendungan dan meratakan pembangunan di pelosok" kota atau desa ... walaupun belum maksimal tapi ini menjadi awal yang bagus untuk kedepannya Peace. ✌

[@pesmobile-lh5fs]

Negara sebelah kepanasan kalau kita maju mereka ga dapat untung tenaga kerja mahal dan barang barang mahl apalagi dengan potensi ekonomi kuat

[@reallive8525]

@@pesmobile-lh5fs yap betul

[@harukrentz435]

We are the 2nd biggest geothermal power producer in the world (soon to be no. 1 in 2024 or 2025) i'd rather we stick with geothermal especially in the earth-quake prone regions, but perhaps we can build a nuclear power plant in Kalimantan considering its relatively safe from natural disaster except flooding.

[@hawaandroid2786]

Actually, Borneo region is increasingly having small quakes, the reason why previous investors back off from investing in IKN Nusantara other than flooding etc. I guess Geothermal would be more beneficial for Indonesia and less threatening for public safety.

[@harukrentz435]

@@hawaandroid2786 since when investors afraid of earth quakes? Otherwise there wont be any investment across Indonesia. Dont be ridiculous.

[@OverseerMoti]

As an Indonesian, I'll tell you this: We are good at cutting corners in procurement projects, and even better at scalping funds for maintenance. You know what happens when something as volatile as nuke being handled this way.

[@NS_MarCh]

I am proud to work in the nuclear field and to be part of this video, even if it is only in a few scenes.

[@_Alfa.Bravo_]

... wait for the laser fusion reactor !!!!!

[@KGopidas]

All the very best for all your current and future rndevours!!!

[@gedecandra7722]

The new model Small Modular Reactor can help provide power for Indonesia.

[@noadie2937]

If you don't act now, then when do you start? we need courage, even though there are many challenges ahead. Don't be afraid to lose, a great nation, a nation that is not afraid.

[@2008amiame]

Brothers, build it in Malaysia, where it’s less prone to earthquakes. In another 100 years, we’ll become one country anyway. Let’s start something together now

[@yr2985]

kaum melayu teroris ketar ketir.. nuclear akan kami bangun untuk holocaust malon melayu teroris😎😎😎🙌

[@yr2985]

Mimpii malonnn bntr lagi negara mu hancur😎🙌🙌

[@Jacobsoetsrto3211]

No Malaysia. We don't need Malaysia

[@envoguecalifornia]

Yes according Jayabaya prediction in less than 100 years time... Soon all malay archipelagos will be united as one not only Malaysia but whole Maritime ASEAN and becomes The Great of NUSANTARA

[@Jacobsoetsrto3211]

@@envoguecalifornia where are u from?

[@teenchai]

Nuclear power is the cleanest energy among all.

[@_Alfa.Bravo_]

Plutonium is the most poising element , you id*ot

[@pietersiahaija4698]

" ... as one of the places on "the ring of fire" Indonesia should be very carefull for nuclear enery, besides the danger of 'tsunamis" is very much existing also, Indonesia have to keep in mind what had happened with the Japanese nuclear plants ( if you want to play with fire, you have to know what you are doing) besides there are a lot of incidents with earth quakes too ... we also have to look into the future, the situation is very much 'tensed' the chance of war is very much existance ( in the SCSea) .... "

[@alean13]

learning from fukushima reactor was failed. its still minor radiation and easy to handle. but, you cant control panic-attack of it neighbours town.

[@solomonlee4503]

Further researches should be done to use thorium in nuclear reactor. It is a much safer and clean element. The down side is the huge emission of gamma rays

[@lateupload]

we have a lot Uranium in West papua , West Kalimantan, East Kalimantan, Central Kalimantan, North Sumatra, Bangka Belitung, Singkep and West Sulawesi. Just combo it with Pu number 94

[@Hasan-we7qp]

bro ive lived in indonesia for all my life, never ive heard that we had nucluar reactor wtf

[@muhammadsecret8783]

hahahaha

[@barayanusantara5862]

Ada 3 bang hahahah

[@exgangster843]

Greenpeace's job: roasting gov in terms of environmental issue ..... Without thinking th energy crisis in some regions outside java

[@vsovereign3]

Not sure why Indonesia needs nuclear power. We have geothermal power galore here, just need to harness it and prepare the infrastructure for it

[@vincentthendean7713]

Here's some update, lads. Indonesia has approved the development of its Nuclear Power Plants. The president has also permitted mining the materials needed to power it.

[@WorldInterestingNews]

Indonesia akan menjadi negara superpower dunia

[@muhammadyunan2811]

C'on we dont only have BATAN, but we also have BAPETEN as regulatory body.... you're missing out one of the most important thing here

[@baladewakakrasana8200]

Indonesia has uranium and plutonium, a beautiful country, a military with the best guerrilla war skills, friendly, religious, its people have immunity to suffering, have simple necessities of life

[@rekeke6251]

One day. I'll have my own media company that make these kind of amazing documentaries. You are an inspiration CNA

[@fauziahmad7054]

I know right

[@abcddef2112]

CNA is exemplary of government propaganda.

[@gh8066]

pls work on the sound balancing a bit, some parts are really loud and some really soft

[@masmulmul5009]

If I were Indonesia Goverment, I will keep go on the nuclear energy project. If we never try, we never know. Every resources always has risk, so we must prepare the mitigation to minimize the risk. Remember, elecitry demand always increase every year and we cant depend on coal and gas anymore. Most of developed countries use nuclear, so what the problem? they can start, why we cant start?. Ignore about green peace and focus on developing nuclear energy. Go Indonesia for becoming global player 2045 !

[@kesatria_gelap]

Clean energy

[@yacubtanasyah2874]

Geographically speaking, to avoid Fukushima nuclear incidents happening in Indonesia, we need to select some provinces with zero earthquake history, such as Central Kalimantan, West Kalimantan, Bangka Belitung, and Riau Islands; Central Kalimantan is the best candidate to build the nuclear power plant because it has no seismic activities with few minor geological fault lines. Also, the Java Sea in the southern part of Central Kalimantan has a shallow depth (about 46 meters only) without major fault lines. The other three provinces are slightly different, considering the number of fault lines. Through the perspective of history, we need to learn about the nuclear disasters worldwide throughout our nuclear development history, at least from 1954 when humanity ran the nuclear power plant in Obninsk (Russia) for the first time, to lower the risk as close to zero. However, running unsustainable energy (something we have now) is not even better for future generations. Coal-based energy is 'safer' for a short period. But will we run the same method to generate power for the rest of our existence? Showing up (some) bar chart(s) to compare fossil fuels VS renewable energy will help your viewers better understand which ones we must choose for our future, not only for Indonesians but for ASEAN and the whole world. I know that bar charts have been taught to middle school students, not to mention elementary students. However, please keep in mind that nuclear energy is just one of our options to generate power for our country, not the only one. In addition, CNA Insider needs to cover more opinions from the local related institutions, such as BAPETEN (Indonesia's Nuclear Energy Regulatory Agency), to have better coverage regarding Indonesia's nuclear development. By the way, only some Indonesian have a positive understanding of nuclear power, as some of us learn from media coverage only, not considering any aspects out there, especially geography and history, to make a better decision. I won't be speaking about the economic aspect as I believe we already know about the effects.

[@manuelmoraleda9684]

Somebody will say that what happened to Fukushima and Chernobyl wouldn't happen in Indonesia. Indonesia should focus on geothermal in which they're already quite successful.

[@abcddef2112]

If you dont notice they already have, Indonesia is the second biggest geothermal producer already. Those same 'environmental activists' complained indonesia should 'protect' the forest and not to develop them for geothermal. You can't and should not please everybody especially foreigners/foreign funded ngos.

[@manuelmoraleda9684]

@@abcddef2112 Indeed Indonesia can lead the world in geothermal.

[@albertsunaga8802]

If the government of Indonesia want to convince its people about nuclear power plant, it need to built it in close proximity to or part of Indonesia new capital area (Nusantara). Then, it also needs to deal with the security and safety of the plant. Traditional/technical points such as natural disasters or operational malfunctions maybe already included in the plan & development. But there are more than that. Terrorist attacks, sabotages or even cyber attacks need to be included in the risk scenario.

[@biologiforfun1874]

If one country already used it from years, why the other country can not? The most important is the purpose of use and safety.

[@captainmee3469]

i am Malaysia but if indonesia will have nuclear reactor then nuclear power... i also want be indonesia people... and if we really want take solar power as electricity... we need start develop more equitment that using just 12 volt power... now many are using 24 volt....

[@MuhtamAmalana]

This is the exact time for Indonesia to start developing Nuclear Energy further..

[@gakpakenama116]

We already have 3 nuclear reactor here TRIGA reaktor in Bandung 2000, Kartini reactor Jogyakarta, G.A Siwabessy Serpong 1987. All working well as research reactor, the problem is most people in Indonesia didn't realize it was there and still afraid something goes wrong but infact it's already 35 years in Serpong Tangerang Selatan, Banten

[@alean13]

its mini (micro) reactor. if it meltdown, but it wont because of its size. it has small effect, compare to big nuclear power plant

[@travel.secrets]

Indonesia jaya

[@WorldInterestingNews]

Indonesia is amazing country

[@Werday-bv7eh]

actually Indonesia is not dangerous at all really they are very friendly, just please don't trigger them, they suffered enough during the world war and don't want to experience it again, greetings of peace 🇮🇩

[@dharmasatya3265]

Nuclear is energy that is quite cheap and clean, cleaner than coal power plants that are still operating today in Indonesia and cheaper than coal when compared to the electricity capacity provided. although the final waste needs extra handling. With all its advantages, Indonesia can export cheap electricity to Singapore or Malaysia

[@chvhndrtntlr3482]

As Indonesian I support nuclear power plant to be the catalyst for Indonesia while Indonesia converting from fossil fuel to renewable energy before Indonesia develop much more efficient renewable energy to produce 100% energy that Indonesia needs, but like what greenpeace Indonesia said, Indonesia government is not ready yet, there's no room for error when managing nuclear powerplant yet Indonesia still struggle with corruption in their government. Indonesia also need to plan a funding for nuclear waste management and nuclear disaster prevention and restoration if there's a nuclear disaster happen in the future. so it's a lot of money and brain works, I don't think Indonesia can handle it.

[@user-bb2ln1ys9t]

I think the Philippines will be the first coubtry in ASEAN to operate Nuclear Power Plant since they have in 1986 but mothballed and not operate, but as of 2022, Bataan Nuclear Power Plant is under feasibility study to revive the plant around 2028-2030

[@jdrudolfp2]

Thanks to the Soviet Union the reactor was built decades ago. Indonesia is so rich in energy natural resources so much so that it doesn‘t see the necessity to build nuclear energy capabilities all accross Indonesia. Singaporeans don‘t need to worry of their bleak future No block and peaceful nature of Indonesia is a stabilizing power not only for the region but also to the world. Take Ukraine and Russia example.

[@PurboMBOT]

Indonesia is already surplus of energy.

[@hatewarwar]

I am proud to be Indonesian

[@livingwater888]

The NPP will be a mini Thorium NPP will be built with China or France in a minimum earthquake prone zone. We have a huge deposits of uranium ( more than 120,000 MT )

[@hasilkanduit]

NUCLEAR FOR ENERGI, YES THATS TRUE

[@Nata4]

INDONESIA AKAN MENJADI NEGARA BESAR!!!

[@livingwater888]

We intend to develop renewables such as Geithermal, Hydro Wind, Solar , Waves, Biomass, EV ( bikes, rail, car, buses, trucks ) first including NPP using Thorium maybe using China's 4th generation NPP.

[@pororo9804]

I will support if everything is prepared carefully

[@zarina_llh]

Saya tidak mengikuti perkembangan teknologi nuklir. Saya juga belum mengetahui detail kondisi nuklir dan pembangkit listrik di Indonesia. Tapi ada hal yang menurut saya harus bisa diterapkan oleh semua pihak yang meriset, mengembangkan, dan mungkin nantinya membangun dan menjalankan PLTN. Yaitu paham akan sisi baik dan buruknya, paham cara mencegah kesalahan akibat manusia, paham upaya mencegah kerusakan akibat bencana alam, dan bisa selalu menjaga agar bidang nuklir ini "bersih". Bersih dari korupsi, menyepelekan prosedur, kepentingan politik kelompok, penyalahgunaan nuklir, dan lain-lain. Sehingga bidang nuklir ini benar-benar membawa manfaat untuk masyarakat di sekitar PLTN, seluruh warga Indonesia dan lingkungan, tanpa membiarkan atau bahkan mempercepat dampak buruknya terjadi di negara ini

[@zarina_llh]

Oh iya, sebaiknya kita tidak menjadikan kondisi negara maju saat ini sebagai perbandingan Indonesia juga bisa, tetapi yang bisa dijadikan perbandingan adalah ketika mereka mengembangkan PLTN-nya. Sehingga kita tidak sekedar tahu "mereka bisa begitu, kita juga bisa, bahkan lebih baik" Tetapi "bagimana mereka memulai?" "Bagaimana mereka menghadapi tantangan-tantangan yang muncul?" "Apa yang ada pada mereka dan tidak ada di Indonesia?" "Apa yang Indonesia punya tapi mereka tidak?" Kondisi tiap negara, tiap zaman tidak sama, kita harus sadar plus-minus berbagai negara dalam mengembangkan PLTN

[@andrewj3177]

We have abundant renewable geothermal. But if nuke will be realized, it should be in borneo, or northern coas of sumatra/java, relatively free of tsunami

[@sullivan6661]

"There are no two or more suns" Singapore is afraid that there are other developed countries in Asean besides them. Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam, the Philippines have the potential to become developed countries.

[@oliverfarmer611]

Yg masih diragukan adalah tempat lokasi, karena Indonesia itu berada di cincin api dan patahan tektonik antara samudra Hindia dan Pasifik

[@nazda2007]

hampir pemili 2024 muncullah program "keren"... sayang sekua sebatas program

[@raizen007]

wow they managed to interview maradona in indonesia

[@LTP23]

Opposants concerns are fair enough! As an Indonesian resident myself, when I see the level of maintenance of the buildings here I'm wondering why would it be different regarding nuclear facilities buildings.... 🤔 People are always there to take the money but not to do their job correctly... Furthermore with the level of corruption and the Indonesians mindset it's quite worrying and the day the country goes nuclear I'm gonna move right and far away!!!

[@andipejalan3382]

pantesan Indonesia nggak jadi negara maju pola fikirnya masyarakatnya begini..

[@uwaisal-qarni8364]

@@andipejalan3382 sotoy banget kayak dia tau segala nya haha

[@dariyahdariyah8179]

How narrow mind .. That way Indonesia selalu terbelakang

[@pace2999]

@@andipejalan3382 itu bule bang yang tinggal di indonesia

[@muhamadmiftahurrizqi5909]

Yes, Sir

[@oliverfarmer611]

Dan juga Indonesia itu tidak luput dari yg namanya korupsi, yg bikin proyek" ada yg rusak atau gak bisa terbangun

[@tanjoy0205]

Hopefully Singapore can adopt these technologies effectively !

[@pace2999]

they need energy for it

[@AndreasDewatmoko1]

Floating Modular Molten Salt Fast Breeder Reactor powered by Indonesian owned Thorium mining potential will reduce Indonesian dependency of petrol products from 7 Singpore's refineries which must be paid in US Dollars terms.

[@Schneizel1208]

Even after you convinced the population that nuclear is inherently more beneficial than conventional coal/gas plants, the real hurdle is the capital cost and lengthy time to go nuclear. Making it earthquake proof will add cost, but the real challenge is whether it can sustain its energy output during or after shock.

[@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk]

All nuclear power plants have earthquake countermeasures already designed and built in. Small modular reactors could easily be installed in two years or less in many places all over the country as they are needed for regional energy.

[@lyq232]

@@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk Small modular power plant is at this point still impractical.

[@lyq232]

One can also build nuclear plants as far away from tectonic fault lines as possible.

[@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk]

@@lyq232 Tell that to the many countries that have been building and using small modular reactors for many decades, built in two years or less, for millions not billions.

[@danadurnfordkevinblanchdebunk]

@@lyq232 No nuclear power plant in the world has ever been destroyed by an earthquake. They are built to withstand the worse, just like Daiichi and Diani did.

[@user-gb4rp3tm6g]

Sbagai orang Indonesia saya yakin jika orang Indonesia mengelola nuklir itu 100% aman,krena nuklir itu sangat berbahaya... Cuma Orang Indonesia mah jgn disuruh mengang duit negara yg sangat banyak, krena mereka merasa itu duit pribadi, maka mereka korupsi😂😂😂

[@One007]

Wait What happened to Bill?

[@dediprakosa7727]

Im a indonesian. I think the government instead of going full nuclear power plant should think about empowering their citizen the ability to generates their own electricity by all means through solar and/or wind. The government should push a bill about independent energy bill that force people in indonesia including the land developers to raise the standard of building they about to build by adding energy generating devices on the structure (rooftop or lawn). Indonesia is at the ring of fire, IF something unwanted and unpredictable happens it would be too late to fix it, the damage already done.

[@lyq232]

Solar and wind requires battery to be reliable for daily use. That itself will also lend a lot of environmental destruction via Nickel mining

[@akashahan75]

asal ngomong, IF something², dikira buat PLTN ga ada banyak safetynya layernya kali.

[@dediprakosa7727]

@@lyq232 Can you guarantee 100% if the government will stop mining nickel? It got so many uses and high value, you know that right? otherwise jokowi will not bother improving its processing standard. And second,can those safety measures/procedure handle multiple types of catastrophe ? Mega crust effects for instances?

[@lyq232]

@@dediprakosa7727 I can't guarantee that mining will be stopped. What I can guarantee however, is that solar and Wind, plus the EV craze will drive nickel demand through the roof, unless alternative batteries are found. Today's nickel usage will seem miniscule if Li-ion batteries start being used everywhere as large-scale energy storage. That's why I prefer if we minimize the use of battery reliant power source. The sheer amount of effort that one needs to put to 'clean-up' nickel mining process is enormous, thanks to the large scale of operation alone. I would go so far as to say that making nickel mining 'clean' is much harder than building a modern reliable nuclear plant. to also reply your second question: Today's nuclear power plant designs are much more robust than ever before, thanks to decades of research and case study, and also the drive to overcome the great fear of nuclear in the cultural Zeitgeist. If you are still worrying about failing power plants, I suggest you start researching about past incidents of nuclear power plant catastrophe, see why they happened and what has been done since then to avoid the same incident. And no, please don't take your technical information about nuclear power plants from HBO's "Chernobyl". That's like getting relationship advice from teen dramas and soap operas.

[@KGopidas]

I deed very progressive, free development of each becomes free development of all. Solar wind and tidalenergy be explored to fullest especially rooftop solar and wind projects!!!

[@majujaya8217]

In the era of President Soekarno, nuclear reactors were used to make atomic bombs, then the coup d'état by General Suharto, who was supported by the west, the power of President Soekarno fell and was replaced by General Suharto, then the atomic bomb-making project was stopped, then nuclear reactors in Indonesia were used for research and power plants not to produce nuclear power. weapon. try if in the past the success of making a nuclear bomb could be like North Korea and of course ASEAN was threatened

[@achmadmarendes]

It is strange that the state owned electric provider PLN actually disincentivized private/home owned rooftop solar producers.

[@muhammadsecret8783]

They have surplus electricity at the moment

[@Aldnon]

@@muhammadsecret8783 And therefore they want people to buy it from them. It's all for profit reason. 😂

[@rean6717]

the village declined the electricity, otherwise they have been installed long time ago

[@denisatria3873]

Of course, can. Why not?... Singapore should be happy 😊

[@tanujSE]

It's good if we have things for future ready and there must be sustainability with environment where we live,therefore private property with class relation must end

[@namazlur78]

Before trying nuclear power maybe indonesia should upgrade their infrastructure & human development. Then only talk about nuclear.

[@Spokenwords24]

Indonesia juga mau maju seperti Singapura. Kami hanya butuh stabilitas politik dan keamanan di kawasan dan internal.

[@endeforlaugh]

Sejak kapan singapur masuk negara maju??? Ahaha lawak loe bos.

[@MADRIDISTA_GarisKeras]

Sekarang indonesia yg mimpin ekonomi terbesar no1 di asia tenggara & masuk 7 besar ekonomi terbesar di dunia indonesia berhasil nyalip brasil.inggris & france . Mangkanya baca berita biar tau

[@MADRIDISTA_GarisKeras]

Dulu emang singapura yg mimpin asia tenggara . Skrg sdah di tendang semua sama indonesia . Skrg indonesia yg mimpin no1 ekonomi terbesar di asia tenggara

[@yohanneslong1970]

Don't preach us about the danger of nukes while you yourself want to build it... Just say you're afraid😅 From NCSS site: "While some existing technologies such as nuclear may not be viable today, we will continue to monitor the progress of nuclear energy technologies and build capabilities to better understand nuclear science and technology."

[@m.hidayatullohmustafid8596]

Russia will help indonesia to build new reactor in new capital

[@lordagung2394]

Source : trust me bro

[@m.hidayatullohmustafid8596]

@@lordagung2394 lah?

[@AbdulMalik-dh6dw]

Keuntungan nuklir banyak tapi biasanya yang untung nya banyak pasti resiko nya besar. Indonesia masih kurang disiplin terutama Indonesia negara dengan banyak bencana

[@pesmobile-lh5fs]

Sekelas japan bisa buat rumah tahan gempa dan juga Indonesia besar ada beberapa pulau yg jaran gempa dan lahan besar dan gak banyak dihuni masyarakat kalau lo takut duluan Indonesia gak akan ada perubahan signifikan dalam waktu dekat ambil resiko dan pikirkan dengan perencanaan matang,

[@AbdulMalik-dh6dw]

@@pesmobile-lh5fs maksudku Jepang aja yg pengalaman dan disiplin aja bisa chaos gara gara nuklir bayangin kita jangankan bencana alam huru hara gegara bola aja dah panik jadi makan banyak korban

[@pesmobile-lh5fs]

@@AbdulMalik-dh6dw udah banyak contoh tinggal tiru aja bagaimana yg aman nya kalau lo selalu dibelenggu rasa takut 100 tahun lagi gak akan lebih maju dari Singapore apalagi negara Eropa toh mereka aja aman aman saja buat tenaga nklir bahkan senjata nuklir

[@pesmobile-lh5fs]

@@AbdulMalik-dh6dw kalau mau setara dengan negara maju perubahan besar mau tidak mau harus diikuti toh jg negara kita bukan pembuat pertama banyak contohnya tinggal ambil ilmunya, negara kita besar kalau jalan kayak siput gak akan lebih maju dari negara negara asean bahkan asia

[@freethinker4991]

With what is happening in Ukraine it is obvious that building a Nuclear power station in any country leaves the country with a strategic risk. Further Solar PV with storage is cheaper then nuclear. Fixed-axis PV plus storage $58-178 per MWh to Nuclear energy costs $112-189 per MWh. Also Solar PV with storage can meet base load power demands.

[@ihsanulfikri9812]

Solar power bullshit... We must go nuke