Commander Clash S5 E19: Mono-Black Week! (Phage vs. Geth vs. Ob Nixilis vs. Marrow-Gnawer)

[@onefightone]

I'm unsure if Crim is actually here this week or if the group just edited in a laugh track and called it a day.

[@federicozacchi6722]

If he didn't giggle so much I would've had a hard time distinguishing his voice from Richard's

[@jasonkorf7700]

Tomer is avoiding Mono-Black Week so he doesn't have to play Yargle this week. Also, Seth with Dark Depths and Thespian stage to start the game, live the dream Seth, live the dream.

[@limeshredder]

I feel like crim would be a really cool addition to the roster for a season, I really like his bubbly personality

[@Entropic_Alloy]

This episode was pure comedy. I just want to see colorless week.

[@johnperseo1044]

Everyone would play the same deck though 😂

[@Volvary]

Yes. I'd love to see some Karn or similar.

[@TheRealWormbo]

Three eldrazi vs a thopter or something. :P

[@kingfuzzy2]

I'd love to see traxos scourge of kroog

[@Gingerbreadley]

Best color time. Is crim high? He is laughing so much. Honestly it’s kinda hilarious.

[@starvingboyinafrica9463]

Bradley Kirsch some people laugh a lot when nervous. I personally enjoyed all of it 😂🤣

[@xakuyer]

Agreed best color

[@Valdreag17]

Starving Boy In Africa Best week in the season.

[@Minastir1]

You can't get on mtg goldfish unless you laugh at your own jokes, he' just making sure.

[@RosieAndLowKi]

I feel like I laugh as much as Crim does when I'm in a new environment or don't know what to say...

[@DoctorDenny]

The first card Seth draws after his betrayal was Damnation, meaning if he had kept digging for the wrath he would have found it and Crim would have lived. Classic.

[@PacManTheSoulEater]

Crim is the giggliest of men!

[@LunaLasceria]

-Look at the comments. -Fifty percent of them are about Crim giggling. -Ok guys he can't really laugh thaaat much. -Turn on the video. -Crim starts giggling at 1:07 and basically never stops.

[@FuturePreference]

Best episode in a long long time :D Suddenly the drama is gone and everyone is having alot of fun.

[@nickposoin8898]

I want Crim to be apart of the lineup next season. Thumbs up if agree👍🏼

[@finley8408]

yes, i love seeing crim here

[@JRandCoKG]

Imma gonna cry eventually, when Vince leaves, but Crim would be a fine substitute

[@ErasMcras]

I was dissapointed when I heard Toner wasn't on this week. But Crim being involved is hype.

[@DonovanPresents]

Man! Their printer must be not running this week. No toner at all 😂

[@CSDragon]

@Ethan Rasumussen: Yeah, laser printers just arn't usable without it.

[@ErasMcras]

Omg that guy had autocorrect on. Better be clever and original by trolling him for the misspell. OMEGALUL.

[@Big_Dai]

yeah, that Ethan guy is an idiot for not paying attention to something so simple

[@skullmead]

Great episode guys, seemed really fun! Also, Crims giggling is so contagious 😆

[@MyT1m3]

I can't wait to see the mono green week. I came up with a fun idea of Nylea's zoo. It's all about playing creature types that don't have much representation in magic.

[@thebirdnerd6675]

Brushwagg FTW!

[@thebirdnerd6675]

@@MyT1m3 Could I see the deck list?

[@MyT1m3]

@@thebirdnerd6675 sure! Nylea God of the Hunt-commander Rabid wombat Jackalope herd Kavu primarch Deepwood wolverine Whiptongue hydra Meandering Towershell Zodiac ox Nimble mongoose Majestic myriarch Rysorian badger Prowling serpopard Wolverine pack Crocanura Scarwood hag Isao, enlightened bushi Decimator of the providences Spore frog Spitting slug Zodiac rooster Cockatrice Lurking crocodile Brushwagg Rhonas the indomitable Wily Bandar Spike breeder Pathbreaker ibex Hooded hydra Rooting kavu Skalla Wolf Joven's ferrets Bronze sable Dryad Arbor Loyal guardian Champion of rhonas Kavu titan Gibbering hyenas Bull hippo Krosan beast Llhurgoyf Brown ouphe Sprouting phytohydra Grazing gladeheart Charging badger Jugan, the Rising Star Giant Badger Experiment one Planeswalkers: Vivien of the arkbow Vivien Reid Artifacts: Hall of triumph Enchatments: Lurking predators Elephant grass Asceticism Burgeoning Growing rites of itlimoc Beastmaster ascension Cream of the crop Greater good Bow of nylea Bear umbra Sorceries: Seasons past Primal command Sprouting renewal Uncage the menagerie Rishkar's expertise Selvala's stampede Overwhelming stampede Lands: 30×forests Homeward path Pendlehaven Khalni garden Mosswort bridge Nykthos shrine to nyx

[@TheHortoncrow]

@@MyT1m3 Awesome deck man!

[@justatraveler09]

"Staying on D.... Fence." C'mon Seth, keep it PG

[@JustDan_777]

I like how this was crims first time in commander clash and he played demons

[@nikdogers2]

I am a huge fan of Crim on commander clash, sometimes he over giggles but i like his light hearted and friendly personality! Bring him in more please!

[@theLogicblade]

If you're looking for more suggestions on what to do for weeks why not do something like a White + Support colour. Like someone would be Boros, someone would be Selesnya, third would be Orzhov and the other would be Azorius. And then you could do same for the other colours in the cycle.

[@tonyw1983]

they can do this with all 5 colors for 5 weeks of content.

[@kionis6648]

The problem with this is the colors repeat quickly. So all fresh decks the first week, second is one reused color pair, by the third week half of the decks are repeats, by the final week they are all repeated.

[@tonyw1983]

@@kionis6648 so. how is this an actual problem? 1 rule. cannot repeat commanders during the 5 weeks.

[@kionis6648]

@@tonyw1983 Primarily from an entertainment perspective. People tend to get bored with the same color combinations repeatedly, so with so many repeats, they are unlikely to do it. The other side is certain color combinations tend toward using the same cards to be successful, so it would be hard to build that many decks without them mostly being the same. Three color combinations would be better from that standpoint, but two color ones are rough.

[@tonyw1983]

@@kionis6648 then they dont have to do it 5 weeks in a row. can do it once a month for 5 months. how about take the negativity stick out of your bung hole and contribute to creating an idea that could provide content?

[@nathanjohnson5088]

This was a breath of fresh air for this series. The lack of constant bickering was actually enjoyable to watch for a change!

[@inzizor]

Crim did a great job! I like the deck and the personality, he fit in well.

[@Luffarjevel]

Crim was such a delight. Please bring him back again in the future!

[@elijahramos3898]

Havent watched streams in a while but Crim has been one of my favorite mtg streamers. Just having fun with jank. Dude fit in so well, please have him on more!

[@Let_It_R1P]

So if Seth draws one more he hits damnation and stabilized?

[@adamschrier2575]

I love this! New people! It’s always great to have the same crew, but sometimes it gets stale with the same shenanigans with the same people. Adding new people maybe like once every 4 episodes or so will spice things up. Crim you were great! Love it. Also maybe have like an anything goes episode for when you have new peeps so they can show you and us what they are really made of. I feel the mono black theme was somewhat limiting in Showcasing what crim can do. But love this show. And keep up the great work guys!

[@MTGGoldfish]

There's an anything goes game next episode!

[@JohnSmith-en8xf]

Crims awesome, winning or losing his just having fun

[@1AlasBabylon]

Good god. Spoilers, it's a double game week, and game 1 was absolutely nuts for so many reasons.

[@noodlewizard1852]

I wonder what Tom thinks of the new guy

[@sonofheru]

I actually enjoyed the Crim and Richard interactions. Want to see more. :)

[@andrewf6167]

Vince has that rare ability of turning memes into functional decks.

[@jcal2.11]

that boom pike was epic. richard and crims interactions are hilarious

[@8Scientist]

Can Crim become a regular guest? Dude seems cool

[@Apkooi1]

Crim is such a cool guy, man.

[@DonovanPresents]

OMG! The deck I would have suggested for mono black this week would have totally dealt with Pleasant Kanobi's commander deck. It was a -1/-1 deck lol.

[@Flickstro]

I think "rats fleeing a sinking ship" was the metaphor you were looking for there.

[@lamppostmagic2635]

Great video. I just put together a Marrow-Gnawer commander myself, can't wait to play it! Though I didn't add Thrumming Stone, because that's more than I want to pay until I know I'm keeping this rat deck for the long term. In terms of mono-color, I have red, green, and black now. I need to make a white and then a blue to complete the set. My red is Etali, which is an entire hoot to play in a big group.

[@fateweaver9]

In b4 Circle of Protection Black.

[@Battleguild]

Circle of Affliction. 😈

[@MTGGoldfish]

Tomer wasn't here, or else I'm sure we would have had an anti-black black deck.

[@TheHortoncrow]

@@MTGGoldfish Just use oppressive enchantments. Black decks would crumble.

[@Zickzag]

This episode was great, definetly need to invite Crim over again. maybe as a member of the crew in a new season ?

[@PrisOwner16]

I just instantly fell in love with Crim. After just nine words he just started giggling for two hours straight and I giggled all the way with him. My jaw hurts now.

[@ankhi3585]

Always hyped to see the Phage deck. It never works out but it so interesting to play.

[@alexaurisch9530]

Really enjoyed seeing Crim here! Very entertaining

[@Apkooi1]

"Tell us what youre working with, Crim" "Well, Im playing Ob Nixilis of the black oath, and you can build this deck in paper for only 3 dollars"

[@ctomsky]

This video just helped me realize that with Dark Depths getting reprinted AND with new art, we should also be getting more Marit Lage TOKENS! And POTENTIALLY with new art!

[@ODIRGO]

BEST GAME EVER!!!!!! Crim should be a regular on the show!!!! It was so fun!!!

[@UTUB2kholle]

Vince's deck looked really good here :o I didn't expect the rat tribe to be so scary

[@theDizzyO2]

Crim's laughing at every card played was hilarious

[@totalcoward]

Richard: I’m gonna play to win. Me: Yes! You go Richard! Show these scrubs! Richard: So I’m gonna grab Boompile. Me: Wut. Richard: *wins the coinflip* Me: He’s a God.

[@kieranscott8007]

😂

[@PalPlays]

The mono weeks have all been fun thus far. I can't wait until colorless week rolls around.

[@ashra8281]

THIS IS WEEK 20 NOT 19 YOU HAD TWO WEEK 18's!!!!!

[@MTGGoldfish]

Counting isn't our strong suite. I'll update it!

[@ashra8281]

@@MTGGoldfish thanks

[@enricogobbo7327]

You must hate me:it is 6o'clock, i cannot get a sleep and you just give me an looong video to watch. Thank you @mtggoldfish for a sleepless night

[@milesguinprower]

Crim is genuinely enjoyable to watch in a commander slash lineup. He seems like alot of fun.

[@JonathanHecht]

im really happy I acquired a copy of thrumming stone last week because it might spike in popularity because of this video

[@phillipmele8533]

Ah nice one Vince. Rats, we’re rats, we’re the rats! We prey at night, we stalk at night, we’re the rats!

[@erikchupela7074]

Haven't you watched commander clash before? He's gonna play beast master ascenion next turn off a forest. Best line of the episode

[@treyconover4107]

Oh my goodness, Vince is playing my favorite commander and rat tribal, I'm so excited. Edit: game 1 was everything I love in life. The rats have been dispensed.

[@EvanFarshadow]

He didn't run Swarmyard or Thornbite Staff tho ;-;

[@Cangaroombi]

One of the best episodes of CC ever! Too bad Tomer didn't participate this week, but Crim was a nice addition to the crew (though, if I may say, I would tone down the laughs by at least a 10% :P). P.s. Vince that rat win game 1 was sooo spicy. Great job.

[@PalPlays]

Vince had so much fun playing rats. Bring it back for a revenge week!

[@scotturquhart8567]

Yes Vince marrow gnawer is brilliant

[@panichappy9785]

Yo this rat tribal deck is the best shit tho I love it! Good work Vince!

[@alpharius282]

Really enjoyed this group of players.

[@faceoctopus4571]

Rat deck with no swarmyard?

[@PleasantKenobi]

Total oversight from me haha. Whoops!

[@drakeconsumerofsoulsandche5761]

@@PleasantKenobi the truth? You. Hate. Value.

[@kept1226]

should have been 25 relentless rats 25 rat col and a thrummingstone.deck

[@EvanFarshadow]

Also no Thornbite Staff+Marrow Gnawer? Boy what are you doing?

[@dactorwatson4313]

Why am I not surprised that Seth had the spiciest deck :)

[@imasiontist653]

49:14 "welcome to commander clash" top kek

[@SkittleWolf]

Marrow-Gnawer was my first commader and will always be my favorite.

[@Volvary]

I saw that Marit Large, I was like "They will be resetting soon and play another one." then the deluge came in. This week is complete redonculus-ness.

[@stevenguitink5947]

Somebody needs to build an Infernal Kirin deck and bring it to Commander Clash one week. Just to totally tilt Tomer ;)

[@Guavamente]

you know youre playing momo black edh wrong when the whole table is mysteriously short of edict effects

[@GrayDeath66666]

I am disappointed that Thornbite Staff wasn't in the Marrow Gnawer deck.

[@EvanFarshadow]

And Swarmyard

[@joshuahartsell2140]

You guys should do a no shave theme week where you have all bearded commanders and creatures.

[@Acraviotot]

I liked Crim. Let's bring Crim back.

[@scotturquhart8567]

These mono coloured restrictions are awesome

[@Archtrend]

ok im sold, you gotta have more crim on now

[@poipoi9816]

Can't believe Seth was such a fool he didn't go for the strip mine.

[@elm0damian166]

Haven't watched the video yet but just going to assume it's 90% more enjoyable to watch because tomer isn't here to beat Vince to a pulp and not let up ever even when he's got better things to do. Let's see.

[@dmany13]

Yay commander clash

[@nickjoeb]

Awe Seth you didn't see the line. You can exile Sidisi with the exploit trigger on the stack and Vince won't tutor since Sidisi's other ability says when she exploits a dude which means she has to be in play when the sac happens.

[@ryanhansen9779]

Rest EN Peace Gaming Products. R.E.P.

[@wynn3333]

Crim was fun but did anyone find his voice eerily similar to Richard's? I kept getting them confused lol

[@wynn3333]

I think it's the chuckles

[@EvanFarshadow]

Friggin pigeon decks are great xD i actually run a rat tribal deck with eldrazi monument, though it isn't a relentless rats or rat colony deck sadly. Getting enough copies is tough.

[@mtgplayer4327]

34:40 everyone was taking about Seth locking someone with wasteland, and then he drew strip mine.

[@stephenhousman6975]

1st game last turn drew damnation. 2nd do i have a board wipe that i can use. I swear Seth tends to have a short memory.

[@saniwada]

RIP crim. F ^was to pay respects.

[@RockStar5656]

Hey Vince.. I thought the same thing.😂 @1:13:19

[@PalPlays]

"Rats have lips." - Seth-Probably-Better-Known-as-SaffronOlive 2018

[@michielhoeree7604]

I like the history lessens with Vince.

[@chekl1982]

Whoa, Seth, that opening hand is 😘

[@andrewf6167]

Lmao at Seth's starting hand. So funny

[@andrewf6167]

"I apologise for my opening hand"

[@yahelhotam1777]

in game one, Seth could have strip mine - crucible locked Vince before he could cast the board wipe

[@christopherwoodbury7520]

Wait... is onslaught considered old school now? It's set after the death of Urza. I always thought that was the cut off for old school. It is pre-gate watch though... is that now the cut off for old school? Bah... I think I'm just getting old

[@kaszael]

there's a whole bunch of sets in between Urza and the gatewatch! I mean, Onslaught is pre-modern era. Feels pretty old-school to me.

[@nightwingaven69]

@@kaszael been playing tournament magic since 96, apparently 02-03 is old school. CRY

[@TriangularPrism]

I mean, 15 years isn't exactly a small amount of time - there are people playing this game who are younger than that

[@christopherwoodbury7520]

So... definitely just getting old. Damn time slipping past without me noticing.

[@franksmith8298]

Old border == old school IMO

[@joshua_lee732]

Haven't watched it yet, calling Get the winner will update when episode over to tell whether I'm right or not.

[@superiorsoy]

"Get your rat out" Vince, is this an MC Devvo reference?

[@alexhayden507]

beautiful game one haha

[@CSDragon]

At 1.0x speed they're fine and distinct, but 1.25x speed, Crim and Richard's voices sound eerily identical. I think Richard talks something close to 1.25x faster than Crim, so when it's sped up, Crim sounds like Richard talking normally.

[@OnlyBadSalmon]

I wonder if we’ll get a new Marit Lage token too

[@davidmorris6254]

Did he say" let's start smorking?" at 1:12:32 Man I think Crim was "smorking" something lol

[@RyuPlaneswalker]

20 Life toxic deluge, even when you don't get attacked Marit Laige makes you pay the toll. 49:00 : Top Ten Anime Betrayals.

[@ArxMega]

Welcome to Commander Clash! Lmfao

[@rhinovirus1614]

Bruce Tarl definitely has the broadest shoulders in magic

[@zacharymccutcheon8607]

Richard! you should have cast the compass rather than the dagger! Good game though.

[@Big_Dai]

No Tomer, no drama.. Only fun!

[@tmlrules2]

is it just me or is this another vince deck that is so much higher in power then everyone else?

[@basicpigeonbee]

many magic the gathering players ask the question "who has the broadest shoulders in magic? "