Companions Reactions If You Kill Isobel | Baldur's Gate 3

[@rainestar82]

Ironic that Shadowheart makes that comment when if you take her down the dark Justiciar path, she "loses the run of herself" and GETS Isobel killed

[@BluuxP0]

Yes because in act 1/2 she is just a joke 😭

[@jimmymeridian5174]

Honestly, it makes no sense that any of them would stick with Durge after that lol

[@BluuxP0]

True but as gale said : we all have our burdens. They all have something bad stick on them 👀

[@dylanhu715]

This is why you gotta let Isobel die in the Marcus attack, kill everything except one Winged Horror for Xp then let that last one take Isobel, this way you can still take responsibility for killing her but your companions wont blame you.

[@BluuxP0]

For the dark urge you need to kill her yourself for bhal gift, he will give you monster shape 🏃🏻‍♀️🏃🏻‍♀️

[@Synthia17]

@@BluuxP0 Nope, you'll still get the slayer form if you let her go with Marcus, that's how I did it in my "semi evil" playthrough unless something changed with the last 2 patches.

[@dylanhu715]

@@BluuxP0 no you dont, I literally did it in an evil run and I got my slayer form the next long rest.

[@johnagninunes]

You can also let Shadowheart become a Dark Justiciar. You gain the Slayer too.

[@notverifiable3731]

Wasn't Act 2 Shadowheart supposed to be pseudo-evil and hate selunites?

[@BluuxP0]

But she’s not that evil to approve to kill everyone in Last Inn

[@notverifiable3731]

@BluuxP0 Likely the first time a Sharran witnessed the average tomfoolery in the name of Bhaal

[@karumina]

I think she's just being reasonable, problem is bhaalspawn is immune to reason in murder god mode. Plus they have brain damage so that makes them even more difficult to get along with. Story-wise it's a loose cannon regardless of how you play it.

[@karumina]

​​​​​​​@@notverifiable3731Sharrans have blood on their hands too but they're more assassins than cultists. Bhaal cultists are just plain insane. They murder for the sake of murder to the point they even sometimes kill their own effectively messing up their power structures and plans as Gortash remarked in his talk with the Durge. They're too unorganized and prone to murder instincts to maintain a clear objective. It's really funny because it is Orin who defeated Bhaalspawn and yet Kethric got called the weakest of the three. Meanwhile she just straight up f'd up the whole plan because bhaalspawn in its healthy mode would see the plan to the end. She was not even interested in the plan to begin with I think. If that's how most bhaal cultists operate it's no wonder they always fail. Bhaal must be really frustrated with the quality of his cultists

[@comicsbraze4336]

If you pay attention to her backstory or earn in her thrust to open with your tav. Shadowheart is the victim and claims that Sharrans saved her from a wolf, which is one of her fears. She was a child when she was taken in Sharran and became one of Shar. She didn't know anything better, but her wisdom is her highest stats, she knew that's wrong and right. She's not necessarily evil. She was afraid and only knew she could thrust on Sharran for protection. It's up to you if you want her to become Sharren or didn't let her become Sharren, but I'm on Act Two playthrough so far. I knew Shadowheart had amnesia because she is loyal to Sharren and must act for "fate," she claims.

[@annenym2222]

Minthy's reaction... now I feel just a little less guilty for having killed her in Act 1.

[@BluuxP0]

All of them they can be changed a bit except minthara, she’s Drow after all

[@annenym2222]

As much as I love Drow, she just won't fit into my current playthrough.

[@oxyman10]

​​@@annenym2222 I'm currently doing two, my good Tav along with an evil Dark Urge. Two completely opposite playthroughs, Minthara is definitely appropriate for an evil alignment. Her demeanor meshes better with Durge rather than anyone else.

[@annenym2222]

@@oxyman10 I am playing as Dark Urge myself, but resisting hard and trying to be a 'good' person. I also limit metagaming. No beating people KO for no reason (from his viewpoint). Why beat the Drow KO and kill the others? Unfortunately, this also means that Alfira is dead. Just couldn't think of any explanation why I would give her a beating. The Urge? Then I would kill her.

[@BluuxP0]

@annenym2222 there’s a way to save her tho

[@andreaguarriero9194]

Durge?

[@BluuxP0]

@@andreaguarriero9194 yes 🙌

[@malekiththeeternityking5433]

Oh no....I killed the self righteous Carpet Muncher???????? OH NOOOOOOO

[@bimbiman8495]

.... self-righteous? I swear that word lost its meaning when people like you use it anytime even when it's not applicable. Isobel is just a good person, is all.

[@malekiththeeternityking5433]

@kozhcaelum8495 People like me? Cause I'm black is that it?