Comparing more Vocaloid producers' first song with their recent works

[@derryair9419]

Neru really went from names like "Chronicles of the Wind Noise" to "Becoming Potatoes". What a glow up

[@tigersandflowers]

they just went from “life sucks 😔🥀” to “life sucks 😎✌️”

[@nerf.ashton]

@@tigersandflowers ok but no joke thats exactly how neru's music progressed fjdkfjks

[@leonidesbabanto1585]

@@tigersandflowers neru the true nihilist icon

[@khadizabhuiyan.random2758]

@@leonidesbabanto1585 Indeed.

[@ahollowsmile]

It went from depression to I don’t care anymore

[@sankyumiku]

The fact that Kikuo asked his music teacher back then about music theory but his teacher was like "don't learn that lol it'll make the music you make boring" lmao

[@nomoretwitterhandles]

Imo, music theory is only necessary if you're bad at making music haha. Kikuo naturally listens to the sounds he creates, and he has a good ear for it too.

[@xp_.tv1]

@@nomoretwitterhandles woah same

[@sberky98]

gigachad music teacher

[@childeofepickness]

that’s a great teacher

[@hachijuhachip]

yeah that’s my favorite thing about him

[@slytherinlady3907]

neru went from "life has no meaning 😭💔💀" to "life has no meaning 😘🥳🎉"

[@oldchannel1312]

life has no lean 🛶🤺🕯🕯🤺🕯🤺🕯🤺

[@rui.superfan]

“i’m so sad, please just end me already. ☹️” to “i’m so sad,please just end me already! 🤪”

[@oldchannel1312]

@@rui.superfan yes ok

[@azunomes]

y u p

[@TheMutantCreeper]

I was like that too. I used to think everything was meaningless because we are floating in space. I then thought about how so many people are experiencing what we are experiencing. Nothing has meaning, but why wallow in sadness when you can do whatever since in the end it won’t matter.

[@lordartsy3124]

> properly researched every song > properly showcases every song > leaves the original uploads in the description you are doing god's work, friend

[@N30-LUCIF3R]

Total W from Blue Star

[@Kalashimi]

Another W for the vocaloid community

[@N95j]

Just a gigantic W all around

[@NeeveeBoogerBurger]

Big fat W

[@miao243]

kikuo's mixing has always been so well done, i remember listening to one of his songs when i was a kid and being blown away by the difference in quality, he's so talented

[@michelebenson5922]

I agree with you

[@elliot__agares]

Yes, some songs from kikuo actually made me have goosebumps, they are unique and different from each other in an entire different way

[@hugs4zhongli]

@@elliot__agares especially the lyrics

[@vivictinimoved]

yes honestly. he's able to bring chaos into beautiful composition in a way i have not seen from any other musical artist

[@cutecumbber266]

@@vivictinimoved mawaru cult

[@Anaea]

absolutely love how MARETU went from "unnecessarily edgy" to "unnecessarily edgy with musical experience" this is why they're one of my favorite producers

[@tomatuteee]

kikuo's evolution sure is...........beyond this world

[@Nia_lovesyouu]

I agree

[@patch7151]

Dude went from peak to peak

[@Nochat3]

Sounds like, let’s go to heaven

[@childeofepickness]

@@patch7151peak to peak to peakest 💥💥

[@kanna-kamuiUwU]

@@patch7151 FACTS

[@archiviscera]

I noticed some rock/metal influence in Maretu’s songs and him being a metal producer in his early days makes a lot of sense

[@kuroshi_anaki]

it's actually the type of song's he'd make before he eventually he started making vocaloid songs. i've never paid attention but i do know that there are some heavy bass in SIU and drums in eye have you. or the entirety of Toutetsu

[@ghostlislime]

he’s also a fan of some metal bands like Slipknot, Korn, lamb of god. and you can hear some parts in his music where he takes inspiration from these bands.

[@archiviscera]

@@ghostlislime wait no way I love Lamb of God omg I need to listen to Maretu again

[@deppudeppudeppu]

@@archiviscera His Rational Time song is basically a Lamb of God tribute song

[@entr3_nou5]

That little drum beat in Forced Slavery reminded me a lot of Metallica’s One, that would explain why

[@parkernathaniel2062]

As someone who listened to Creepy Toast once as a child and hasn't thought of it's existence ever again until seeing the thumbnail of this video... Discovering that it was made by CircusP is the most surreal as fuck thing I've ever had to learn

[@hanyuukawaiinanodesu]

Remembering that it even existed was already a trip.

[@jaxhayes4372]

That’s a goddamn mood

[@marveludus]

same

[@lilywhitetouhou]

SAME BRO

[@dannyp9044]

I was thrrooooown

[@siteswap4510]

Wow I didn't know that kikuo knew nothing about music theory, as a musician myself it seems unbelievable. Great vidéo !

[@bluestar3939]

He explained how he never learned it in this video kzbin.info/www/bejne/qHvdeKF9na1kapI

[@noodles9411]

Oh wow no wonder it was so unique

[@indie_gamer7]

I mean, one of my favorite remixers also doesn't know much about music theory, he just know how to do the instruments, but i think remixes and original music aren't tje best exemples, his name is Nick Nitro if you're wondering.

[@wafflesthearttoad6916]

Personally I think if you have a good enough ear, knowledge music theory isn’t necessarily needed. I actually think all the rules might hold some people back.

[@dannyh_music]

Geez, he must have a killer ear then. I've always considered him a brilliant composer

[@anotherdaybreak]

to be honest seeing circusp's most popular song not being insanity after that was such a cornerstone of my early vocaloid experience is jarring to me. the glowup is intense though

[@Lunaliladee]

Agreed! Insanity has been one of my favorite songs since I first discovered it in elementary school. Use to listen to it all the time. I was pleasantly surprised to see the new music CircusP released.

[@Ecliptic-P]

You can thank animation memes for copycat being it

[@melotiik]

That was me when I didn’t see circus monster there instead of copycat

[@loonela]

It's so funny seeing CircusPs tiktoks about his song process and half of the ones on his older songs are like "Oh god people still like these? I cringe so hard when I hear my own music"

[@nomoretwitterhandles]

Honestly I still really love insanity, because the flow of the lyrics are really smooth. I could do without the "edgy emo kid" vibe of the lyrics themselves, but overall, it's a really nice song. I wish the instrumentals were better too. I recently found a cover of that particular song with 2 different vocaloids, and the cover artist also redid the instrumentals. While the instrumentals were modernized to sound better, I think they tried really hard to keep the music sounding as close to the original as possible. I can't remember who made the cover, but it was incredible to hear one of my childhood favorites as an actual nice-sounding song lol. Like, I don't mean to sound snobbish, but a lot of Vocaloid music is... VERY Vocaloid. Idk how else to describe it. Just look at classics like Romeo + Cinderella, or World Is Mine. Those songs don't have a lot of sound depth; and musically, they kinda hurt the ears. I love Romeo + Cinderella for the chord progressions and for the lyric flow, but overall, the music is so empty. It would be so cool for those classics to get redone, almost like how Yuyoyuppe redid Leia (granted, I still love the original bc the depth was fine to me, but the remake is even better). Anyways, pardon my rant. I am just very passionate about Vocaloids and synthetic singing. I've always been a bit of a tech geek, and I love watching the Vocaloid community change and become even more serious about the music. The old music was fun though!

[@batteryacid1]

i cant believe im from a time where kikuos most popular song was "gomen ne, gomen ne".. the fact that its been dethroned... ive been here for a while

[@morfonicas]

IT ISNT!?

[@batteryacid1]

@@morfonicas used to be, now his most popular song is "love me love me love me"

[@shotrash]

I was also expected to his most popular song be "gomen ne, gomen ne", it was shocking! But "aishite, aishite, aishite" it's such a banger too, so I understand

[@oshawott946]

@@shotrashI wanna say it might b because of Project Diva

[@roby3523]

I went to his concert back in March in LA and it was the first song he played!

[@grinchyskellington]

I love how circusp starts with “creepy toast D:” and then punches you in the gut with “COPY THAAAT COPY CAAAT”

[@raffaelefrau9789]

Yeah, that's kind of... as evil as the toast.

[@_meriessa]

Okay, but Becoming Potatoes is a bop. Like, I love all of Neru's music from Tokyo Teddy Bear to SNOBBISM, but Becoming Potatoes is my favorite song from him right now.

[@spaciousdawgg]

Bro true! Abstract nonsense is one of my top favorites from Neru but becoming potatoes is a close second ☆〜（ゝ。∂）

[@virginiemaltais8994]

I first heard becoming potatoes when playing prosekai and omg it was love at first hearing 😆

[@ok286]

I LOVE TOKYO TEDDY BEAR

[@Splatastic]

@@virginiemaltais8994 Everyone picks it in pro rooms and then there's me being picked with MORE! JUMP! MORE!

[@xp_.tv1]

@@virginiemaltais8994 same :)

[@Uhhhhhhhhhm]

The way Kira was only FOURTEEN when his first song came out, and it was already *that good*

[@harmonydew6486]

I remember finding it out myself when I was 14, god it was a huge blow to my self esteem

[@Violauglur313]

Wait, Kira is male?

[@diazackbc7297]

Yes you can hear his self cover with Giga in Getcha!@@Violauglur313

[@Eikogacha]

Yes. ​@@Violauglur313

[@grandon4507]

4:34 That typo is so wholesome, it warms my hart.

[@SqueezyQueez]

💀

[@shinoataya]

@@SqueezyQueez what

[@SqueezyQueez]

On the timestamp the typo is the title ‘my little “hart” ‘ and they used the typo to make the joke if you were wondering what was the joke-

[@shinoataya]

@@SqueezyQueez no I'm wondering why you used the skull emoji

[@SqueezyQueez]

@@shinoataya the skull emoji represents the words ‘I’m dead’ In gen z culture (easier representation is the crying emoji to represent laughing so much you tear up)

[@dementedcheesepuff99]

Huh, so KIRA’s always been at a pro level, but what I want to know is how he had worldwide industry connections by the time he was in high school.

[@cybergalacticnova]

luck pure luck There are plenty of smaller producers who never had that moment where one of their songs blew up. From, someone who knew KIRA since 2016 and had witnessed firsthand how Circles blew up.

[@manulittle]

@@cybergalacticnova dennoko-p is making (imo) top tier music for 7 years and only has 7 thousand subs

[@someoneelseee_]

As stated, KIRA started with UTAU Covers. But he's also UST-ing songs. This help him gain some of his followers. People will try to find USTs for the song they want to cover and they'll find him. I'd say he's always been at pro level even when being UTAU User. So, he started getting some of his "basic followers" . It isn't only because he USTs, but he also befriend with some UTAU users too, as example Ekkoberry (who's now usually work as artist for most of his works). With that, he got his first songs at least known among his "basic followers". As time goes, he made more songs, his friends and "basic followers" try to spread his songs. KZbin algorythm might also help new people to find his songs. That's at least what I thought.

[@KyouBeanie]

UTAU covers also just used to be incredibly popular, sometimes they would even pop up in the recommended after listening to the original song provided you were already consuming a fair amount of Vocaloid content. Another point is that Kira was one of the first Vocaloid producers making English songs to become popular in the community to the point where if someone searched for English Vocaloid songs Kira would be the top result.

[@vivictinimoved]

@@manulittle IKR

[@elizabeth3506]

kikuo having no idea how music theory works makes so much sense. ironically though, his songs are some of the most complex pieces of music i’ve ever heard in my life

[@joni4867]

MARETU really just decided "I will produce music that will never leave your playlists" from day 1, huh?

[@cosmicfloweyYT]

YESS

[@Mewkityy]

I never realized Maretu made Let's Say the P names 😭 I always thought it's such a cute song in comparison to what he makes now

[@otomachirabbit.3.]

Then there's teretterettee

[@Tommyjoe577]

xD

[@myraclepeeks711]

Wait he made that

[@AlenBear]

@@myraclepeeks711 It's in the video

[@_Abnormality_bugs_]

True

[@Mangoeater45]

Neru's first's song: "life has no meaning.." Neru's most recent songs: "imma potato."

[@yourwhale5910]

I love how it was just a meh song about Luka being scared by toast and then just *I WILL BECOME WHAT YOU LIKE, THIS IS WANT YOU WANTED RIGHT?!* Most epic shit in my life

[@killiehall5928]

Ikr

[@v1nnimo]

The toast damaged her

[@starryskies113]

@@v1nnimo haha

[@asianinthetree8912]

The Toast forever scar her and the lore deepen.

[@raffaelefrau9789]

Plot twist: the toast dragged luka in all that and then luka dragged gumi in

[@gvnlessktchn]

sometimes i forget that “let’s say the p names” and “mind brand” are by the same person lmao

[@Lizaaaaaa]

Sometimes I forget that most of the inappropriate len songs are made by the same person that made electric angel

[@sweetdreamix]

@@Lizaaaaaa WAIT WHAT-

[@Lizaaaaaa]

@@sweetdreamix yeah and drop pop candy

[@sweetdreamix]

@@Lizaaaaaa REOL?

[@Lizaaaaaa]

@@sweetdreamix giga made it but reol helped

[@bl00dedsaints]

Woah I didn’t know MARETU was a metal producer, no wonder there’s a lot of metal elements in his songs!

[@shatteredarling]

Yes, I've noticed that his songs kinda sounded like metal but it wasn't metal per se, so that made lots of sense Not surprised that he used to be a metal producer because of this tbh

[@islayverymuch]

You've never noticed?

[@katresan1059]

So Kira was always a pro, how the hell did he get to work with Yunosuke when he was a literal kid tho lol

[@ineptsoybean]

If I remember correctly, he sneaked on a server like discord or something and no one knew how old he was until he blurted it out lol ed: oops, english be cringe lol

[@nomoretwitterhandles]

@@ineptsoybean "he stunk on a server" lmao???

[@swagballs5646]

@@nomoretwitterhandles i cannot stop laugjing ay this😭😭

[@monarchatto6095]

@@nomoretwitterhandles he was a STINKY. absolutely skunky and nobody had the heart to say it before he the stinky said it himself

[@KUYAMIN]

i was 9 when creepy toast came out and i remember being genuinely frightened by it 😭

[@WriteOverMe]

Neru went from "nothing in life matters 😔💀💔" to "nothing in life matters 😎"

[@TwoTailedCaperer]

It's kinda sad that a lot of producers delete their oldest videos, I wonder if they think they're not "good enough"? I'm not so keen on my old videos either, but I'm not going out of my way to delete them. It's interesting to see people's beginnings and compare it to where they are now.

[@biowbe4522]

From some art advice ive heard is that for a portofolio its better to delete your oldest as it showcase your currently worst product. But I think for archive reason its better not to delete them.

[@naolucillerandom5280]

I have some vocaloid covers in my playlist that aren't avaliable anymore. Either because copyright went copyright or because they think it's bad now. Kinda sad that others can't find them now.

[@Nudoru]

yuyoyuppe's growth with Luka is absolutely incredible, surprised more people hadn't mentioned it already.

[@hanthonyc]

While definitely not unpopular, I feel that yuyoyuppe is very underrepresented in producers... I don't often see others agree that he's a favorite of theirs, but he is mine!!

[@ただの人-s9e]

@@hanthonyc He was in billboard 100

[@2SilverMoon2]

Ok, I was totally blown away that MARETU made Let's Say The P Names cuz like it differs so much to his nowaday style. Also that Forced Slavery for some reason gave me Saw and Pendulum vibes 👀

[@cuppu4525]

Kikuo is a godsend for creepy songs, hole dwelling has a special place in my heart.

[@gingerizard3262]

YES ME TOOO I LOVE HOLE DWELLING

[@rewriteofficial]

SAME

[@Panzystubbedtheirtoe]

Hole dwelling is def my favorite!! Id recommend listening to that one other type of voicebank program thignies english cover of it! (I forgot what it was called but i think its eleanor smthing just searcn holedwelling english cover and u should hopefully find it)

[@шәует]

@Panzystubbedtheirtoe eleanor forte

[@Panzystubbedtheirtoe]

@@шәует tysm !!

[@azunomes]

Neru did a good one First-len Most popular-rin Most recent solo-rin and len

[@_Abnormality_bugs_]

Lol it's all about the kagamine mainly.

[@yume_ucchi4535]

I think he loves the Kagamines:)

[@kurigohan7800]

I really love how maretu's style is consistent but he also improves everytime

[@organichotchoco]

Yeah his music still has bits of Metal and Rock, like the drums in New Darling

[@goldie1943]

Kikuo not knowing music theory is really interesting! His songs often have very distinctive and unique chord structures, so I wonder if that is in part why. His music is always so good!

[@aidey833]

i mean i think his creativity and skill is more of a factor than being uneducated, as many other musicians dont know music theory and come nowhere close to such a unique style :p

[@Raemey]

papiyon really went from cute shooting star to badass sexually based lyrics in 2 years

[@awfulsoup324]

ok holy shit, ive known about maretus metal past but i never knew about his actual first song how in the world did you even find this. where has this been all my life cause im in love thank you so much

[@crumbfused]

Same, I knew his second song, Atashi Baito!ww but I couldn't find his first song-

[@Kirineko__]

can we talk about how pretty first Neru's song is?

[@Kirineko__]

69 LIKES

[@_Abnormality_bugs_]

Yeah

[@BritishRajBall]

​@@Kirineko__ 4 more until 420

[@UmLammyJammer]

God I love the direction Neru went. Neru’s music was always good but the most recent songs are BANGERS

[@probablyjinxed]

knowing maretu, with his track record of dark and macabre songs made the goddamn P-NAMES has me in shambles still

[@lavenderhaze_]

Great video!! It was really cool to learn that Kira used to be Yunosuke's tuner! I also can't believe I didn't know that Maretu did Lets Say the P Names lmao

[@puckc5533]

i think kikuo understands some music theory but all his music before 2015 is almost completely experimental outside what he learned in school

[@maurguri]

it's crazy the difference between circusp's creepy toast && copycat ,, def my fav song ever

[@akfc.6978]

It’s coincidental that both Circus P and Kira’s most popular song is a Gumi English song and their most recent songs at the time of the making of this video was a Hatsune Miku English song!

[@starfruitkirby6962]

I remember when circles first blew up, and I remember the absolute shock middle school me was in to find that Kira wasn’t much older than I am. So while I’m not a fan of their music aside from a song here and there, I am really proud of them. It was just like what the-

[@islayverymuch]

Love me, love me, love me was my very first vocaloid song I have ever heard. I actually used to think kikuo was a girl and miku was an actual person 💀💀 but it does bring back memories

[@kyleag86]

servant of evil was my first vocaloid, i didn’t even know about vocaloid back then, i was like 5 and just liked the song haha. who knew it would send me down this path

[@akemi_444]

Same, and i found the song from my friends gacha video💀

[@dollythepuppet5211]

Creepy toast is just the most silly and adorable song I’ve ever known to exist

[@bludraws094]

circusp had an amazing glowup like we went from “AAA TOAST” to “WOOO PUZZLES”

[@Lad-u8s]

It has the same vibe as Caribbean Toast ft. Merugine Luis

[@Lad-u8s]

Creamy Toast ft. Merugine Lunch

[@Lad-u8s]

Creep toast

[@Lad-u8s]

I FUFIIFJYU GiNVS UP

[@seducedbysasquatch]

love how kikuo's style has remained consistent yet has gotten even better with time :)

[@batteryacid1]

i like how a lot of them keep using the same vocaloids as back then its like an homage its kinda cute

[@Indigoblu2]

also they’re pretty darn expensive

[@artemisphantom831]

Circus'P is the definition of glowup ,,,, creepy toast is a iconic phase tho

[@pastelguts6182]

kinda reminds me of when i go through my old sketchbooks. I guess it never occurred to me music could be the same way

[@mariacoeur27]

You start with Kikuo, you're the best!!

[@northernsunset1]

New recent songs: Kikuo: Emptiness Emptiness Emptiness of Emptiness Stupid dance remix Neru: Just praying Yuyoyuppe: Burning Burning Burning CircusP: Sabotage Picco: Daybreak Papiyon: Avocado MARETU: Angel 92 KIRA: Wildcard

[@bluestar3939]

Kikuo : you're right Neru : Kaze to Nare yuyoyuppe : you're right CircusP : CMYK album picco : Tiny Cat papiyon : Lunar Eclipse MARETU : you're right KIRA : you're right

[@pink_entity5227]

Copycat feat. GUMI was one of the songs that got me into Vocaloid. I’m also a huge Kikuo fan so seeing them in this video is awesome. I love Maretu but their first song is worse for wear. Mind Brand is also one of my favorites.

[@Mushybff]

me too! oh to be 9 again

[@MidnightsGalore]

same I was looking for a different copycat song but then I found an mlp mv with copycat feat. Gumi lol

[@anotherdnb]

MATERU went from talking about abuse to talking about killing your abuser. What a turn

[@maritsaalmira3477]

Its wonderfull seeing how the producers evolved troughout the years. But its sad that AkunoP wasnt on the list, he's one of the greatest producers i've ever know.

[@OG_Its_Cosmic]

When I first found out about Maretu, he was NOT known (I found about him around 2016 Summer, end of July) and I was overwhelmed because the way he produces the songs hit different from the ones I've always listened to and you could say I fell in love? After a year I somehow forgot about vocaloids but the main reason why I even started watching anime was the vocaloids. All hail running Sakuya and Po Pi Po!

[@nimloc1670]

Even in Kikuo's first song, you can hear his shtick. He's so amazing

[@moistfloorsock]

i knew there was a lot of metal influence in maretu’s music, but it never really crossed my mind that he could’ve made metal music in his beginnings. how interesting!!

[@cognizant3252]

14:55 Kira was 14-16 when they made that song

[@sapnupua5]

holy shit

[@sssuperiorr]

woah

[@aesthetic_blssom9521]

Becoming potatoes is one of my favourite songs to play on pjsekai! I was really surprised when i found it wasn't as popular as i thought it was-

[@8bitidiot671]

I was surprised it was made FOR project sekai, I never played jp sekai but kept up with it, I was surprised when I learned it was made for sekai

[@doggiedock]

Kikuo is just built differently

[@fishmaels]

BECOMING POTATOES HAS TO BE ONE OF THE BEST SONGS COMMISIONED FOR PJSK. I love Nerus music sm

[@hanasan4845]

I'm impressed by now much work went into this video. Finding erased videos, providing interesting bonus information... I'm not even much of a Vocaloid fan anymore, I used to be a big one in 4th - 6th grade(Just few days ago, I was thinking about how back then, going to a Vocaloid concert was one of my biggest dreams. Not anymore, but maybe...), but Vocaloid content still makes it's way to my recommended, and I don't mind, I like to watch it once in a while. I'm glad that I recognize some of the producers' names, since back then, I didn't pay much attention to who made the music. I'm happy to see some of the names burned themselves into my memory enough to remember.

[@c4tma4sk]

kikuo is insanely talented

[@Oliveww__]

FINALLY MARETU! I love all his work I've thought that his first song was Let's See The P Names even that I knew abt Forced Slavery :0

[@yumeyumedi]

creepy toast to copycat is such a jump ngl

[@duckie5182]

CircusP’s improvement was so amazing, i keep watching the video..

[@UrSammich]

I feel bad because I only knew a few of the producer's on the list just because of a few songs (mostly popular songs). Like I recently discovered Kira because Kira's songs have been showing up frequently on my pandora playlist (Digital Girl, Master Piece, Monster, Circles; just to name a few). I don't know why, but I was expecting Crusher-P to be on the list for some reason. Crusher has some bangers.

[@H3ntaigh0st]

Don’t worry I recently just got back in to Kikuo and discovered other producers

[@cyclicalkaouthia]

MARETU MADE THE P NAMES SONG???? THE P NAMES WAS ORIGINALLY SANG BY HATSUNE MIKU??? WHAT

[@RosellaMae_]

Actually MARETU's first song is Kaitten Soukai Zangyaku ver but his first full song would be Forced Obedience

[@heartroll8719]

I love Kira’s song “Monster.” He is so good at tuning Gumi same as tons of other English voicebanks like Miku.

[@イヤレ]

She*

[@netto-matcha]

maretu's earlier songs slappppp i love his music sm

[@notstarry_T-T]

0:36 MADE MY TV LAG AND FREEZE

[@galaxyworldbuddy]

BRO THAT HAPPENS TO ME TOO 😭

[@Lorax69]

The tv couldn’t handle them *extreme* vibes

[@MklikesBTS]

And the captions lol😂

[@Flimsytuna]

Thanks for the part 2! Gotta love how Maretu's style in tuning and mv has been pretty consistent throughout the years. Ps. Can you make a part 3 and include Mikansei-P?

[@Snowstriken]

Yonosukes tuining of kafu makes me smile and i don't normally like kafu at all. It feels unique but familiar??

[@bluestar3939]

Yunosuke doesn't do the vocal tuning himself, it's Osamu who does it. He also doesn't write lyrics, it's Gyuniku.

[@mikuwi]

that transition between monster and 4blood was really good

[@stardustcleaninglady]

ive been down the rabbit hole with kikuos music and even some of his very early works- im talking some even from 2003 aren’t even half bad 😭 i think the fact that his music is experimental allows for more creativity with sounds which is probably why his music has a specific sound

[@platesmcplates9057]

I love it It's like watching a friend grow as they create

[@bellsAblub]

I can’t believe circus p most popular song isn’t circus monster anymore 😢 it was my introduction to vocaloid and creepy pasta! So many memories!!

[@Faustus960]

I've never heard of DIVELA but thank you for putting them in this video because holy fuck, I had to click off less than five seconds after vocalo-colosseum started playing and listen to the whole thing lmao its so good

[@grimmed_]

my whole life i never knew who made lets say the P names and hearing now that its maretu (which mind you is my favorite vocaloid producer) is. very obsurd to me but i am not complaining this man made my childhood im giving it out to him

[@chocolalain9385]

MARETU MADE LETS SAY THE P NAMES?? no wonder i like it so much

[@yana1907]

Roleless Weapon is a frickin bop!!! Holy shit, how did I miss this song until now????

[@KEiVYXX]

It's literally so good 😍

[@CursedCatTruffa]

Neru's musical evolution is amazing to see, he is my favorite composer so I enjoy hearing how far he has come since his first song!

[@koifish3332]

Really cool video! If you plan a part 3, you should add Masa Work Designs

[@MorbidCherryBlossom]

MARETU really surprised me with this one. Metal and Vocaloid music mixed is my huge favorite. Utsu-P was my first metal Vocaloid producer I ever heard and I got hooked. I wonder what Utsu-P’s first song was and what his most popular song was. 💜

[@bluestar3939]

This is part 2. Utsu-P is in part 1

[@juiceboybox2287]

I like how you included MARETU, He's my favorite producer

[@PS1APE]

Good job putting this together, it’s really cool to see how producers have evolved over the years. There are a couple of producers I definitely need to have on my radar now too! Edit: I used to listen to Yunosuke’s first album all the time so learning it was Kira that did the tuning for it is blowing my mind

[@NekkuruWolfie]

Yuyoyuppe improved SO much their tuning with Luka, amazing!

[@neetamoori8690]

Don't tell me about Kikuo's origins, i've been in a whole rabbit hole the last few months trying to search for his old songs. So, if you do a part three, can you include Sasakure and Hachi?

[@peppersalt]

Have you checked out Asian Melancholic? I think it was what he made before he became Kikuo. Only three videos remain on the channel but I think some are reuploaded on youtube. kzbin.info/door/xchJJp6MuxwF5jwVkxnmDg

[@queroooo151]

Idk if you have this playlist saved but this is all of kikuos songs lol kzbin.info/aero/PLHlV6hJ48ptBlo-IenzBeuRbcRnDWgS67

[@vivictinimoved]

@@peppersalt he has a full asian melancholic album up on spotify (under asian melancholic ofc)

[@hamsonHams]

@@NJackie what did rerulili do?

[@UT4iTE]

@@NJackie YESS

[@AlfajorcitoDeMaicena]

i watched the whole video expecting Ryo because he has so many popular songs, also Wowaka for the same reason, i would like to know what was his last song

[@bluestar3939]

I want to focus on producers who are still active in vocaloid. When you say they made so many popular songs, the truth is not really. They both made about 20 songs which is extremely low when you compare to producers like DECO*27 or PinocchioP who made well over 100. Wowaka's last song was Unknown Mother Goose made in 2017. It was requested by Crypton for Miku's 10th anniversary. The song before that was in 2011. Wowaka left the vocaloid scene and I'm sure he wouldn't have come back if Crypton didn't request Unknown Mother Goose.

[@AlfajorcitoDeMaicena]

@@bluestar3939 ok, thank you!

[@nomoretwitterhandles]

Personally I feel like it would be inappropriate to do a video about Wowaka's "last song" seeing as he has been dead for a while now. It's pretty easy to find out what his last song was before he passed away. Just have to look for it.

[@Mushybff]

this makes me want to become a vocaloid producer

[@arsony1775]

do it!! please!!

[@Mushybff]

@@arsony1775 awww thank you for the support!! however i have no musical skill so idk if it's viable ;w;

[@masonsauce]

@@Mushybff You can still do it! It just might take more practice than a musically gifted person! Still, I bet some of the more popular producers weren’t gifted yet they still made it

[@rt2gd]

I could sit and talk about vocametal all day and seeing utsup and okamep be talked about outside of the group of people who are fans is mind blowing

[@graaarh]

yk i thought vocaloid producers who made songs wayyyyy back were dead now- but NOPE- they still alive and kicking making banger songs still

[@abdulaisiyoup3912]

vocaloid isnt that old, and most vocaloid producers are usually young, most are usually 16~25 and a lot of the older ones are usually just around 30 it doesnt make sense that everyone who was making music back then would be dead by now...?

[@forkymety]

@@abdulaisiyoup3912 i think op meant dead as in not trending anymore or smn?? 🤸‍♀️

[@lazyivann]

When I saw the "my little hart" typo I immediatly imagined "shart" "hart"😭

[@silliest.humann]

Real😭

[@anticycloner]

I'm so glad that PaIII.Sensation got into Groove Coaster in the arcade version, hopefully it comes to the Switch in the future

[@caligula1130]

Wow, what a great idea for a video, very interesting. I didn't know you had a video like this before, now I have something to see.

[@Indiegamefan-1987]

MARETU LIKES UTSU-P! I WANT A CROSSOVER NOW!!!

[@kdandsheela]

I appreciate you including the non-vocaloid synthetic singer, I think alternate programs, like utau, should always have space in the community :)