Evolution of Vocaloid producers part 4

[@bluestar3939]

I wanted to make a part where I quickly go over the producers covered in the previous videos to mention some things that changed and some things that I missed (for example PinocchioP's most popular song changed after I made the video and I missed some things about inabakumori's past) but the video was getting long so that will be its own video. Probably in a few weeks. Edit : here is the video kzbin.info/www/bejne/pJbOlXuha7-qh80

[@Someone-zn4dh]

I guess it's normal for it to be slower in beat. Vocaloid was a new program and people was trying to test and Figure things out, which than because of inspirations to others, who starts doing it in slower pace. ( Like how when there's a trend of art, artist starts getting inspirations from one another) Now that the program is fully known, people get more...daring and again, the inspirations cycle happen again

[@its_sanddi8194]

Yo we need Miku :)

[@m.i7211]

Did you choose the most popular song from KZbin? Niconico douga was a more popular platform in the early days of Vocaloid, so the results might change when you factor it in.

[@bluestar3939]

@@m.i7211 I used Niconico, KZbin, Spotify and Bilibili.

[@Mortin12]

God-ish blew up

[@sushitime5052]

Kariki bears new songs: depression, serious topics Kariki bears old songs: i dropped my fucking pudding

[@Jo-sx8yi]

These r literally the same thing

[@definitelynotnico3549]

just as depressing

[@cheeseman2070]

kairiki bear new songs: art not crying kairiki bear old song: art crying

[@hurgusburgus938]

i think ppl were just testing out what types of music they could make before

[@Jupiter-lm1pc]

Maybe not purposefully but like vaguely reflective of the very fast paced and chaotic environment we live in, trying to catch up with each new tragedy to occur and whatnot

[@girljellyfish]

“SAYONARAAAA PUUDDDINGGGG” is the funniest line ive heard miku sing

[@MonochromaticRival]

Time stamp?

[@earthbasket8971]

@@MonochromaticRival 2:17

[@mememaster6748]

@@earthbasket8971 Bro she dropped her fucking pudding it ain’t that deep

[@ThatOneChaos]

@@mememaster6748have you ever dropped your pudding? It’s a truly depressing moment

[@SakuraStarXD]

@@ThatOneChaosdone that, it was so sad

[@baguette3025]

There’s something I noticed, older songs tend to have a slower beat and feature vocaloids as characters while newer songs tend to be faster and lean more on OCs

[@catbroke1797]

Oh shit that is interesting

[@bluestar3939]

That really depends on the producers. For example Kairiki bear's recent songs are slower than is older songs. His older songs were often above 230 bpm (his fastest is 294) while his recent are usually bellow 200. For OCs it also depends on producers, some of them even alternate between OCs and the vocaloid depending on the song.

[@CompSomAnichi]

The thing you have factor in is that some recent songs have been made for rhythm games which can explain why some are faster.

[@nessyxx8638]

@@CompSomAnichi Slower songs also exist in rhythm games, just saying. Also, what was pointed out in the original comment, is exactly the trend of Vocaloid community in recent years. Songs become faster, the focus of the song is not longer on Vocaloids themselves.

[@bluestar3939]

Seeing this comment get so many likes makes me think I need to make a video to show that it's not the case. And I speak as someone who follow hundreds of producers and listen to hundreds of songs every month. Most people only see the popular songs so it might just be an illusion. The only trend I see is songs are getting shorter. And I never saw the general public talk about that, the only people I saw talk about that were vocaloid producers.

[@broomy39]

I cried when miku said "goodbye pudding", i felt that deeply..

[@PandorasWorldYT]

SAME :(

[@abbieyayy]

she actually said "sayonara" which means "farewell" and should NOT be used as "goodbye" in japanese. people say "sayonara" when it is their last time seeing someone/something and they are wishing it off. (JUST CLEARING THINGS UP^^ i also felt immense sadness to know that miku's gracious and sweet pudding had to be sent to the afterworld😔 RIP PUDDING: 2011-2011)

[@flyingairbusA380]

​@@abbieyayyi think they knew

[@abbieyayy]

@@flyingairbusA380 yea but others might not know

[@astrixthecat2779]

Its so nice to see how games like project sekai made a lot of these creators more well known to new audiences

[@agogole]

ikr and some people think that project sekai was a mistake

[@moonleafx]

@@agogole I was just properly getting into Vocaloid and playing proseka introduced me to a lot of amazing producers I didn’t know. Idk why they say proseka is a mistake:’)

[@Shawarma101]

@@moonleafx Same here, it even introduced me to amazing singers like Ado, her voice is amazing and I only got to know her through her songs (Useewa, Melty land nightmare, Bocca Della verita, Odo) in project sekai I checked out all her other songs and they are crazy amazing

[@Barrabarrita]

Ikr, project sekai showed me more producers that have great music that I didn’t know before playing!

[@beefboof6947]

@@moonleafx i don't think the game is a mistake, bc it's a great game and introduces a lot of people to new songs or producers, or vocaloid as a whole but its also that some players in the fanbase are just annoying and/or give the game a bad reputation but idk probably just me

[@thedragongirl27]

its crazy that mothy took 10 minute love a completley average first song and years later at the end of a 15 fucking minute song that was the evillious big finale to go "actually 10 minute love was cannon all along" the madlad

[@Lemon_Fiber]

“hey ik youve waited for like 10 years with headcannons and not, but 10 minute love was cannon lmao.”

[@thedragongirl27]

@@Lemon_Fiber i remember same happened with people argueing if re_birthday was cannon and if the len in re_birthday was allen and randomly more than 10 years after its release mothy dropped a remake staring allen what a legend

[@sarunightamber701]

i dont get this, i dont speak english very well either, could you explain this like i was retarded thank youuu >u

[@thedragongirl27]

@@sarunightamber701 ok so mothy the producer who made servant of evil made like a ton of songs in the same universe to make one big grand story this story is called "evillious chornincles" however he has a few songs that are not from this series and some that are vague so people debate if they are cannon 10 minute love being mothys first song was like 99% chance not intended to be part of the project at all eventually mothy made a 15 minute song that was the conclusion to the series, the song used tons of motifs from other songs and stuff and ended with all the vocaloids from the song getting reincarnated into another world a blank screen a bit of text and you can hear 10 minute love in the background and you can see rin in the same outfit as she has in 10 minute love running into the distance basically saying that after all the other songs 10 minute love plays as kinda the epologue ending with text that says something like "an 1000 year story turns into a 10 minute love" this probably is more confusing i tried my best to explain it lol

[@sarunightamber701]

@@thedragongirl27 oooooooo i get it nowww ty :D

[@anrowari]

I miss the style of 2000s Japanese music… It was right between pop and rock. I know I can’t change trends, but it makes me sad that I cannot find songs like those anymore.

[@ivanav.3136]

try math rock, progressive rock, or Midwestern emo. these wwre the genres back then

[@casshews]

@@ivanav.3136 i recommend paranoid void for math rock.

[@しとしと雨]

kiite上手く使えば結構見つけられるよ

[@tanatornkao]

If you don't mind about vocaloid. There a lot of JP pop punk / punk rock / metal / pop rock bands right now rock never leave japan. Some of them have 2000s vibe.

[@plastictreelover1209]

listen to visual kei artists or something idk

[@CursedCatTruffa]

Servant of Evil being the most popular mothy song since 2008 is amazing, like, this song traumatized a generation and it's still going strong on 2022 Also Karakuri Burst, my first HitoYama song was their first one, that's very amazing

[@yukis.763]

LMAOOO "Traumatized a generation" TOO REAL

[@robberandbouquet4041]

bruh really traumatised me when i was 8

[@弗雷德里克蕭邦]

when i first watched it i didnt even know what was going on and thought the song was weird but still was listening to it 💀

[@cartoondeathnoises8756]

It's funny, I recently learned that my bf likes servant of evil, but only knew about the English cover. He was driving and played it, and I was like "oh you know this was a vocaloid song? And there's like a bunch of other songs in the same story?" And he was baffled

[@sparklecat60]

bro my first evillious song was evil food eater conchita (for some reason it was recommended to me) and that BLEW my mind in middle school 😭 like now I knew she only ate her boyfriend because he killed himself first but still GODDAMN-

[@M00N_1X]

when miku said "sayonara pudding" i started tearing up. i held back my tears, even choking on them. never thought that id be crying over such words.

[@MEC1R7]

ujm HWO

[@nadebara]

the reason why mikito chose his name had me sobbing that's so cute 😭

[@elizabethramirezthezenshii9691]

aaaaah and confession is soo cute

[@tsunchina3040]

OOOO where did he say the meaning ?

[@avdolenthusiast4021]

FRRRRR

[@avdolenthusiast4021]

@@tsunchina3040 0:04

[@mayamayamaya2]

i cant find the song :(

[@frostedflies]

Really love how Sasakure has always stuck with cute and complex music. Really impressed with how much he’s improved, his stuff is truly one of a kind.

[@yayayatyan9663]

He is by far a top 3 producer for me 😭 I can't get enough of perio's voice either

[@insanospaz]

I was mildly surprised to not see 'Hello, Planet' as is most popular but that's just probably just my bias between being mapped in rhythm games and the one that really made me look at his other songs. I guess Negaposi*Continues is the second that came to mind so it's probably def a Project Diva bias lol

[@bremen7376]

the SASAKURE VIBES stay strong for yearsss

[@lilandeintheirl]

The old Kairiki Bear songs feel so strange, because they don't follow their modern 'format'

[@506Jikson]

I hated Kairiki bear before I watched this clip, but then I found that I like his past “format”

[@pelziig]

He kept that format up till 2015 iirc

[@jackierabbit]

@@506Jikson why did you hate kairiki bear?

[@506Jikson]

@@jackierabbit I just don’t like the style

[@Hi-bv3wq]

@@506Jikson I personally love it but I respect you opinion!!

[@youraverageguy8431]

1:46 i was like, aww.. She's crying... Then i saw the title and noticed the plate in her hand. Then the camera panned to the pudding on the floor. I laughed so hard that i had to slap myself to stop. It's so stupid. "Sayonara Pudding"

[@oak..]

SAME BROOOO..

[@theAsura505]

Such a qt patootie... Someone give her another pudding

[@spiritwarhol707]

So Toa just came out the musical womb tuning like that???

[@ignoreallmycommentsandreplies]

Yep 💀

[@atlix2]

musical womb…

[@Syrgarde]

@@atlix2 lmfao

[@Kirbyfan45]

Yeah... And i love it!

[@emuclan5914]

The fact karikis songs now are deep, brooding and edgy while old kariki songs was about miku dropping pudding Im sorry everyone for thinking dropping wasnt serious, ily all 😢

[@y0iime38]

the inverse neru

[@OrigamiAhsoka]

Dropping pudding is a very serious matter 😔

[@iwilldefenestrateyou]

@@y0iime38 neru before: i wish the world would end😔😔😔 neru now: I WISH THE WORLD WOULD END🤪😍😍🤩🤩😍🤩😍🤩🤪😍🤪🤩🤪🤩😍😝😝🤗🤭🤭🤗🤪🤪🤗

[@clydee6886]

Are you making light of dropping pudding on the floor??? 😡😡🤬

[@natapatamepatata]

aaAAAAAA pu-purin ga.... .....shinda-a-a-a-a-a......

[@user-rizzyshirokayano-009]

OH MY LORD THE BAD END NIGHT SERIES WAS MY WHOLE CHILDHOOD- 11:22

[@littlecherryartist]

legit, there is even a manga for it

[@melodicMisery]

@@littlecherryartist yeah there’s an official manga! It’s really good, I own all of the available copies

[@akiratakanashi2385]

@@littlecherryartist cant believe i just found out they got manga of that series.

[@Sakkaz]

Fr it was my fav song

[@ee-qg5nl]

DAME OMG I HOLD IT SO DEAR IN MY HEART BCZ I USED TO BINGE LISTEN AND WATXH IT ALL THE FUCKING TIME AS A KIDDDD

[@TheAncestralSpirit1]

It's sad to see so many of them delete their older works. no one should be ashamed of where they started from with vocaloid. Should just leave the older stuff there, especially when there's probably people that still enjoy the older music.

[@Meshisa]

Especially strange love stalker

[@mrmenobsessed]

​@@Meshisa fr

[@mari_3kyu]

It's also interesting to see how much wowaka actually influenced a whole generation. You can really tell when things started speeding up

[@marinamoraes6174]

I'm kind of surprised that IDSMILE hasn't surpassed Tsugihagi Staccato as Toa's most popular work

[@mycatisasupermodel4932]

Same, I personally like IDsmile better so I'm biased though

[@id10cyy]

@@mycatisasupermodel4932 same.. im biased because of 25ji lol

[@tellapathically]

probably because of how long patchwork staccato has been out, plus the nostalgia factor. when i think of vocaloid it’s one of the first songs i think of. IDSMILE is a really good song though so give it time and maybe it will

[@6012reasol]

i think there's a big portion of the vocaloid community who dont play proseka and haven't heard the song, whereas almost every vocaloid fan has heard patchwork staccato

[@kerberose]

sorry that's my bad i've got it playing on at least 12 tabs at all times

[@konoegiatanez3754]

Sasakure P really stuck with that kinda mystical, sometimes spacey feeling pop music, its kinda impressive. He knew what he wanted from the start music wise and improved and expanded on it.

[@kykeee2487]

I had no idea Kairiki Bear did Pudding Annihilation! It was my favourite song as a kid

[@kajino_p]

Ur an og for that

[@unluckyp]

I find it kinda cute how you can read MikitoP's name as "Miki and P(roducer)".

[@azuzabunny3yearsago766]

Yes i noticed too

[@QuinnActually]

I can't believe you haven't done Lamaze-P yet. Made such icons as Triple Baka (and FUKKIRETA/Mischevious Function as an illustrator), and is *still* releasing bangers constantly to this day.

[@azander1958]

Lamaze P is the most man of culture out of all producers

[@PastaV4]

​@@azander1958the meme ancestor of the vocaloid community

[@aremxlle]

reall

[@sugoiicat5064]

A producer that over time has improved a lot in both music and design is MASA WORKS DESIGN, I'm surprised that he still doesn't appear in this type of video

[@sillychuu]

I love masa works design sm omg

[@aquakit.133]

I love watching his art streams, it's lovely seeing someone improve in real time.

[@segles7095]

fr! And his music is always so lively !!! Their songs are always on repeat 😤🎉

[@theultimatearizona]

Oh yesss we need to see masa!!!

[@aremxlle]

i fucking love masa works design-

[@eevee2Glacia]

I am living for the drastic difference in Syuudou’s first and most recent and most popular songs it’s beautiful.

[@erial_]

Its crazy how the Virtual Singer in BUG (バグ) is actually Hatsune Miku. The tuning is so amazing I couldn't even tell.

[@PastaV4]

it sounds a bit like his old tuning style in "inai inai addiction" i like that

[@cellu1053]

Kairiki bear always makes amazing work on vocal parameters I was really surprised when they sound so naturally And Sasakure makes good songs on various genres, and tries whole different things everytime These two artist changed my mind and opinion like "vocaros are too robotic and I cant understand anything" Or "vocaro songs are always the same and the lyrics itself have depressions" Im really glad I was able to find these people

[@abia6760]

Well, dropping a pudding is pretty depressing

[@Lavendre]

@@abia6760 Especially when the nearest store to buy pudding from is closed :+

[@sunnekosuri]

Kairiki bears style is so different now, I really liked his style in the songs like disappearance addiction, lemmingming, affection underachiever, venom, barabara kokoro, those older songs. I love his music still, but that style is definitely cherished in my eyes.

[@starsscatter]

venom and bug are pretty similar in sound imo

[@sunnekosuri]

@@starsscatter yes sorta ! Now that I see this comment again, I think a better point would be comparing bug and his imitation gallery songs like inai inai addiction etc

[@kasaneteto6720]

upset that pudding annihilation kinda goes😭 as expected of kairiki bear

[@Imamotherfreakingavocado]

Project Sekai rlly boosted the popularity for alot of songs huh

[@emonatsume]

What

[@nessa2646]

@@emonatsume some songs here are songs featured in project sekai and since pjsekai has a big fanbase, it increased the popularity of those songs bc fans found the songs through pjsekai

[@vanillosophy]

@@emonatsume what?

[@idliketobeagummybear]

yeah i’m surprised older games like osu didn’t boost popularity of songs quite as much overall

[@Lonely_ace]

@@idliketobeagummybear I think it might be because of how closely tied project sekai is to the original songs and Vocaloid as a whole Kinda like that project sekai was made with the community in mind

[@unknownmotherkoose8868]

Older vocaloid songs has that feeling that awakens sentimental freaky side of me.

[@kappamaster7179]

You can't really say that Usseewa's popularity is justbecause of Ado, cause it's also that song that launched Ado's popularity.

[@eddyneedssleep]

I don't know why but it's so cool seeing how they went from just making songs to making the official demos for voicebanks and theme songs for games. Vocaloid is so cool in that aspect

[@didikagamine8568]

mothy is impressive. Who else can release 10pun no Koi (which isn’t bad though, we just really hear it’s their first one) and then the absolute masterpiece that is Servant of Evil two months later

[@MOREMOREJUMPHIGH]

The older songs give me a feeling of nostolgia, while the newest are bops

[@JustASunflowerSeeD]

Just got into project sekai recently, and damn I wish I had a Vocaloid phase because damn this looks really interesting. I never knew it was just a bunch of individual composers working with the Vocaloid voicebanks I thought they were an actual virtual band who had songs specially made for them. Edit: why is this getting likes .-.

[@cadeallison1102]

It's not too late to have a Vocaloid phase! It's never too late to have a Vocaloid phase :3

[@onix4194]

Its not too late but dont go deeper ok?

[@Sillyperson87]

@@onix4194 r u trying to be edgy or smth lmao… being in the vocaloid (or generally vocal synth) fandom is rlly fun and super interesting to learn about! even if sometimes lyrics are dark thats normal?

[@mikudayo_biggest_fan3939]

your vocaloid phase might start rn actually be warned though, once it starts it never ends (i speak from experience)

[@aliasofasort]

Just letting you know, proseka was the thing that got me into my vocaloid phase, so yknow you might fall down the rabbit hole as well

[@loonela]

This series is excellent; the research is on-point! Kyaami has some real evolution (mostly her covers, but some originals) and Aqu3ra is getting really popular thanks to project sekai and gabuli, both might be worth looking into!

[@RubyChocoCookie]

Vocaloid producers in 2011: Oh no, my pudding fell! :( Vocaloid producers now: *HAHAHAHAHA NEON COLORS GO BRRRRRR!!!*

[@Itz_Riku]

I know this is 9 months ago but i didn't expected to see you here XD Also,if you see this HELLO!

[@RubyChocoCookie]

@@Itz_Riku Hi! :D

[@Itz_Riku]

@@RubyChocoCookie :D

[@r_shanzhu]

So on point😂😂

[@Y0UZHE4E]

before "oh, no, I dropped my fuckin pudding!!" after:"murder go brrr"

[@lexws]

you can notice a song is old not just because of how bad the voices sounded before, but because of how the art style of the drawings in the MVs are, all of them have that 2010's anime art style lol im happy that there's more beautifull art styles now

[@aponyachuu]

Nah man Old anime style (or mid 2000 and 2010's) are fire and expressive as hell

[@lexws]

@@aponyachuu yeah i agree!! but now there's more variety, you can see styles like cartoon or realistic, i like that

[@fiona9041]

tondemo-wonderz being more popular than hello planet really threw me off

[@arinsanity0x0]

prob because project sekai boosted its popularity alot

[@slytherinlady3907]

i was so confused it makes sense but like HUH

[@aremxlle]

cause pf pjsk

[@astaganaga1906]

Omg im so happy to see mikitoP and kairikibear!!!

[@irithin1870]

You didnt include kikuo in here, but its interesting to see how his style has actually mostly stayed the same.

[@bluestar3939]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jJatdHeVq7NljNU

[@y0iime38]

actually is style changed a lot, his firstest songs were really happy and with a lot of techno sounds, I don't get any emotion from that. While his more newest works feels a way more deapeer, like an infinite travel through the space of your own mind, when the bad emotions become poetry. A explosion of sounds and experiences, it's a hole style. I recommend you to look over the video that Kikuo released like 10 months ago, about his career through the years (from 2003 to 2021)

[@y0iime38]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qHvdeKF9na1kapI

[@irithin1870]

@@y0iime38 actually i have watched that, and i do agree that it changes, but i think it always stays similar.

[@koba7816]

old vocaloid artwork feels so warm to me, it holds a special place :3

[@m0odiEsubz23]

Agreed, it feels so familiar. Like the food your mother used to prepare when you were in primary school

[@aajson2508]

if you are looking for more composers I would suggest Nanahoshi Kangengakudan or camellia but for both of them it is hard to pin down their early works but they are so good also ryo(Supercell), Omoi, Tsunamaru, MIMI, bibuko, APG550, papiyon, Harumaki Gohan, MuryokuP are also really good also also Astrophysics is a good English Vocaloid composer also also also suzie has some of the best tuning I know of also also also also good job this series has been fun to watch

[@bluestar3939]

I already did papiyon in part 2

[@aajson2508]

oops missed that

[@RalseiSmokinAFatBlunt]

CAMELLIA 🤤🤤

[@9cirno_]

camellia is amazing

[@soranohoshii]

mafumafu is technically one edit: i mean he is, but he mostly do covers and all

[@あきら-v7h]

I think my favorite thing abt being in the vocaloid fandom is being able to see producers grow over the years

[@yumikumooo]

I absolutely adore how Toa makes Miku sound so soothing

[@emerygrey1582]

Sasakure's music has always been absolutely amazing, from the very first song to the most recent one

[@randomdogewao]

mikitoP has always been one of my favorite producers in vocaloid, there's not a single song that sounds the same and it's a blast. It's really nice to see how the producers I've listened to as a little kid have grown too. Would love to see another part with nekobolo (sasanomaly now), yasuhiro, and 40mP!

[@RobinTheRandom]

I wasn't surprised at all when I saw Pomp and Circumstance as Umetora's most popular song 😂😂😂

[@beheadingdance]

Ifuudoudou*/j

[@id10cyy]

I WAS OBSESSED WITH TSUGIHAGI STACCATO IN 2020 TBH STILL A BANGER

[@ichi3864]

FR THAT SONG IS SO RELATABLE 😭😭

[@jammo7370]

Damn man I remember jamming to the X of evil series of songs when I was in middle school. The fact that that came out in 2008 is absolutely wild to me. Trip down memory lane.

[@luvmizuu]

To be totally honest, I would have thought that Bitter Choco Decoration would be syudou's most popular work. But I can also see how Cute Girlfriend could surpass it.

[@al_myfellas]

bitter choco decoration is still a total banger, lmao

[@miizuakiya]

Same but i still love bitter choco decoration

[@KogawaYuri-ENVtuber]

BITTA CHOCO DECARASHON~! 💖🤣

[@amberr3662]

I thought it would've been Usseewa at first but I then remembered that a vocaloid didn't sing it If Usseewa counted, it definitely would've been syudou's most popular

[@KogawaYuri-ENVtuber]

@@amberr3662 true

[@mokuRat]

Best 19 minutes and 17 seconds of my life.... Thank you as always!!!

[@biblecamp666]

mothy being immediately followed by HitoshizukuxYama's works really hit me like a truck. Both of those fuckers gave me permanent emotional damage and I love them so much.

[@maxrelax5940]

umetora goated. never bothered to look into the translations but hooooooly that sound is so unique

[@madamadadane7989]

It's astounding how many producers have changed and adapted to modern music and collabing with vtubers, music projects etc. I am really glad they can churn out consistently. So many other producers have died down, retired or release songs quietly here and there. EZFG was so peaked ten years ago and sticks with his signature sound and released a song a little while ago with Saki but hasn't got the reception I hoped it should have gotten. Adapting is tough. I love this culture and keeping up with it. Keep up the good work Blue Star.

[@rin0847]

"Sayonara Pudingu" i felt that

[@Yaeurii]

18:37 i was expecting bitter choco decoration tbh

[@2theriangirlss]

Same

[@spookybro1122]

I'm surprised hello planet isn't sasakure.UK's most popular song

[@RobinTheRandom]

yeah that's what I thought as well

[@ronelm2000]

It was... before Proseka changed everything.

[@emonatsume]

@@ronelm2000 bro got personal beef with a rhythm game

[@kuukanz]

@@emonatsume i do too

[@emonatsume]

@@kuukanz good 4 u?? Idk

[@zephyr2473]

if you haven't already covered them in other videos, i'd love to see you cover Guchiry, Vane Lily and Ghost and Pals. They're some of my faves :3

[@justaregularnoob8239]

I LOVE GHOST AND PALS OMFG my fav is prob honey im home

[@zephyr2473]

SAME! my other 2 favourites are appetite of a people pleaser and happy days

[@ignoreallmycommentsandreplies]

@@zephyr2473 YOO I LOVE THOSE TOOOO

[@jam-tea]

YESSS i hope they cover guchiry and ghost (if they havent)!!

[@newhumanrace]

GUCJIRYGUXHIRYGUCHIRU!!! i love them, hehehehehbfyvjkmvg

[@pikozi9506]

i wish producers used the vocaloids as characters again, vocaloids raised me and im so attached to them i could care less for ocs 😭

[@exiaax]

Yeah only Jin pulled it off, no one comes close and they aren’t doing similar projects to really invest in a character. The way j usually like it is Bad End Night or Evilluous.

[@aauz]

I don't mean to be rude, but isn't that kind of dismissing the producers' creativity? it's their music and they're entitled to create what they want. vocaloid isn't all about creating stories for/around the vocaloids themselves, they can be used as a substitute for a live singer, or maybe the producer just likes the sound better and doesn't want to use the vocaloids' design. don't get me wrong, I have nothing against producers using the vocaloids' design/character in an mv, or if the song is about them. I'm just saying that the producer is the one making the music, telling the story, and they get to chooses how they do that, wether that may be with ocs or not. not us. sorry if this sounds rude, just wanted to point out that we should let producers have creative freedom!

[@kagamineholo]

@@aauz what do you mean by dismissing the producers' creativity? . A lot of producers are creative for using the vocaloids as the characters (mothy, hitoshizuyama, etc.) and they're are very well known. Of course they can make whatever they want we aren't their managers, but we just prefer producers that are more story centric with the vocaloid charas. It just seems producers whose focus on the vocaloid are getting less and less nowadays.

[@eggi4443]

its way more expressive that way. I prefer the new age vocaloid songs

[@beomkaslana]

Naahhh, some of the producer ocs designs are rad as hell 🙅‍♀️ You don't know how much people simp for Guchiry's oc Tadashi Kunai lol

[@natsumisimp7519]

MOTHYYY YEAH also, if you do a part 5, could you please add EZFG and nyanyannya? Or maybe niki? Also this is great SKSKSKS

[@adiipocere]

OMG YES NYANNYANNYA

[@jijithirdeye]

NJOOOO MIJKU DROPPED HER PUDDJING NJOOO

[@carluwu2331]

Ur videos re-sparked my obsession for vocaloid! Thank you for ur contributions to the community fr 🤧 I’m looking forward to the content u produce haha

[@patchopaa383]

Thank you for making these!!

[@maxrelax5940]

i agree

[@makurei6888]

Past 20 years old and still rocking Hatsune Miku and co.

[@haleighmooring3682]

Turned 23 a few days ago, and same for me!❤️

[@sannya_32]

Same. "It's not a phase, mom"

[@transsnack]

@@sannya_32 oof, yeah, my parents thought this was just gonna be a phase I grew out of when I first got into vocaloid and anime at 14. I'm 22 now, lol.

[@cesar...0]

This video is very nostalgic, many artists evolved a lot and I am happy that their work is becoming better known through more media than just KZbin. (pro seka nicovideo project diva etc) It's even more surprising when you remember that Miku has only been around for 16 years.

[@ayo3850]

can i just say that toa's songs are very different from your fast catchy beat type of song and its not very fast or slow and it's like drinking water after having a heavy tasting meal, very refreshing. adding on, mothy's songs still follow the old format of Vocaloid depressing ass songs which is interesting to see I'm not saying that the catchy beats are bad as I love those too, but the ones different from them and those who still follow the old format ish just remind me of when I was a kid and obsessed with Vocaloid when I found them. i mean I did slowly listen to more rockish songs compared to old songs, but those old songs are such bangers still

[@grafomaniaco333]

vocaloid was such a part of my childhood and early adolescence, to this day i still find myself coming back to listen to it. be it old or new, it has a charm that no one else can replicate. i remember trying for years (not exaggerating, it took literal years) to find the song "failure girl" again, i couldn't remember the name and only the chorus remained in my mind, it made me emotional when i found it again, the same video by the same person who subbed it all those years ago.

[@Winu-bignsmall]

I am today years old to realize Mothy’s newest song was made for project sekai what the blazing hell

[@GassyBlackRabbit]

4:56 most fucking best transition ever

[@keiz_]

I have to day I miss the days of Vocaloid Trance being mote popular than it is now, producers like Aura Qualic, Aerial Flowx HanasoumenP, Clean Tears, etc. It does kinda exist still, but it's died a lot in popularity. Also miss the blow up of Utaite, and vocaloid music around the time. Still love the stuff coming out now, but the music has changed, and the Utaite scene is also vastly different, with most now making their own music, a handful of bigger names sticking around, or others having moved to vtubing along with covers. It's interesting to see how it's evolved, but I will always miss the past of Utaite.

[@eris_522]

syudou went from making a somewhat wacky song to producing absolute fucking bangers damn

[@mayanotopsleep]

ooh? mikitoP's tuning is actually super smooth. i rarely listen to the original ver of his songs

[@herohalv4543]

and it was today that i, having never seen that image of pudding annihilation (or "Babusai Pudding" as its called on spotify) learned that the song was about literal pudding incredible.

[@ryboits75]

hoping to get JIN in one of these upcoming ones, you're doing the lords work

[@yumerical]

Tondemo-Wonderz is actually my favorite song on Project Sekai!! Well, including Romeo and Cinderella ofc.

[@decoras.]

2:27 BRO IMPROVED SO HARD IN 7 YEARS

[@CloudyLionHeart]

It’s really weird hearing Kairiki Bear and syudou’s early songs sounding to different when they have such signature sounds now

[@HIKIZURII]

I remember party junkie was my first song on this topic, it was a bop and still is. Now I’m heavy into Utsu-p and his song. I mainly use them for video game but still fire!

[@linacat3121]

I like your videos, because this is a good way to find new vocaloid producers! I would find it really cool, if you stated the number of views of the producers most popular video, so that I can see the differences.

[@sweetbean.88]

I love these videos! You do such a great job

[@Chilldays-vz1vq]

pudding annihilation feels like either a how a kid would react or b how a drunk/high person would react

[@rhapsodyxvi]

ah, i see literally any mention of servant of evil still makes me sob, (jokes and angst aside great videos!! so fun to learn about all of these producers)

[@nyunyuw]

Servant of evil was my first vocaloid song i heard back in 2010. I miss it so much

[@eienryucho6648]

Wait, Tondemo Wonderz has become Sasauke-P's most popular song?? Wow Dang, Hitoshizuku×Yama I'd never really looked at them as separate people This is so cool Videos like these sure are great

[@Fishiepwincess]

I'm still surprised everytime I see hitoshizukuxYamas most popular song not being one of the synchronicitys 🤣 those had a choke hold on highschool me and my local cosplay community lol

[@Kirineko__]

thank you for including hitoshizuku x yama here, thye're my all time fav producers , the're rlly underrated, their songs are just wonderful. Edit 2023 Their most recent songs, those after Mr. Schadenfreude (idk i can't spell it) are sooo darn good but they don't get so much hype idk why they're wonderful. We can also see how Suzunosuke's art is improving over the years

[@peachypinkmoon]

So true and i love the maya pfp

[@MarbleMuseHasAppeared]

Rain Dream Tower still has a chokehold on me :''D

[@monkebrainiac]

im sorry but i love you for making this video 😭 ive been getting into vocaloids again and this is perfect

[@spaghetti2222]

I missed this video series

[@kassies.1182]

These videos are so interesting!!! I've been getting back into the vocal synth scene and a) it's so nice to see older creators I remember still creating b) I'm learning about so many new producers. It's super rad. Thanks for your hard work! I love that Servant of Evil is STILL mothy's most popular song. Traumatized a generation of tweens with that one. Also this isn't related but omg, sasakure made it to Magical Mirai that's so cool? It might just be the 2010 in me but I'm so surprised Hello Planet isn't the most popular song. If you do another one of these, JesusP/WonderfulOpportunity is still around about making bangers these days. JunkyP too I'm pretty sure? I'm sure you get a lot of these so don't worry any if you've got other producers to look into. Keep doing what you're doing =D

[@blazi64]

almost all producers do really high-pitched, fast chaotic songs now, I miss old vocaloid era so much...

[@flowerine06]

toa, mothy: am i a joke to you

[@eggi4443]

I don't

[@hqnaemu]

Me personally I love the chaotic fast sounding songs especially when the lyrics are very angsty 😭😭

[@crazygirl5386]

Honestly I was just waiting for Hitoshizuku x Yama, their songs have been my obsession since 2014 and I still keep up with the newest ones

[@catsittingonatable]

I never knew Wakare no Oto was kairiki’s first!! I always thought it was such a beautiful song.

[@NaomiAAAAAA]

Karikibear: instead of wakare no oto, I DROPED MY FUCKING GODDAMN PUDDIMG OH MY FUCKING GOD

[@EeveeFromAlmia]

A fun game is trying to guess what the artist is before the most popular entry.

[@mementomori1871]

You…… you don’t already know all their names by heart?????

[@EeveeFromAlmia]

@@mementomori1871 I'm the type of man who goes by vibes

[@Dgacha1306]

10 minutes of love to some brother dying because he loves his sister...

[@25_Hrtz]

Goodbye Pudding 😭

[@ilmatilan]

me going into the video fully expecting at least one proseka song. I was not disappointed.