How much did Vocaloid producers improve ? Comparing producers' first song with their most recent

[@bluestar3939]

I'm working on a part 2 with 10 more producers. I'm trying to finish it for the end of January. Some people seem a bit confused by the most popular song for some producers so here are the actual numbers. Those numbers are from January 2022, 6 months after I made the video because that's when KZbin decided to recommend the video to more people. The difference between old and new songs was a bit bigger when I made the video. I'll write a separate reply for each producer and I'll put them in the order of the video so it's easier to find the producer that interest you.

[@bluestar3939]

DECO*27 Top 3 on Niconico : 1. Mozaik Role, 11.8M views 2. Ghost Rule, 10M views 3. HIBANA, 6.9M views Top 3 on KZbin : 1. HIBANA, 46M 2. Mousou Kanshou Daishou Renmei, 39M 3. The Vampire, 37M Top 3 on Spotify : 1. Ghost Rule, 17.6M 2. The Vampire, 12M 3. HIBANA Reloaded, 8.5M Conclusion : there is no doubt HIBANA is number 1 if you count only official uploads but Vampire will most likely take that spot in the future. If you also count reuploads and fan works Ghost Rule has a bigger presence but it's hard to tell if it makes it more popular than HIBANA or not because of the huge amount of videos I would need to consider so I counted only official uploads. And for simplicity I used the same rule for each producer.

[@bluestar3939]

Utsu-P Top 3 on Niconico : 1. I thought I was an angel, 1.7M 2. Heart Sutra Hardcore, 693k 3. Poster Girl's Prank, 589k Top 3 on KZbin : 1. I thought I was an angel, 3.9M 2. OGRE, 1.3M 3. Hyper Reality Show, 1.2M Note : Hyper Reality Show was above OGRE at the time I made the video Top 3 on Spotify : 1. Corpse Attack!! 1.7M 2. Hyper Reality Show, 1.2M 3. Living Ghost is Alive, 771k Conclusion : There is a surprising difference between each website but I thought I was an angel is clearly above because of its much higher view count on KZbin.

[@bluestar3939]

cosMo Top 3 on Niconico : 1. The Disappearance of Hatsune Miku (LONG VERSION), 10.1M 2. The Singing Passion of Hatsune Miku (LONG VERSION), 2.2M 3. Rampage of Kagamine Len (LONG VERSION), 1.9M Top 3 on KZbin : 1. R.I.P. Gossip Sea, 13M 2. THE END OF HATSUNE MIKU (2018 remake of Disappearance), 10M 3. The Intense Voice of Hatsune Miku (2018 Remake), 7,2M Top 3 on Spotify : 1. R.I.P. Gossip Sea, 1.6M 2. MACHINEGUN POEM DOLL, 650k 3. SHOUSHITSU (I don't know why it's called like that on Spotify, that's Disappearance but they didn't use the full title for any of the songs of that album), 412k Conclusion : I can see why people in the comments were confused but as you can see Gossip Sea is above if you take the number 1 video only. If you start adding views from multiple websites it's still above if you count the original and the remake of Disappearance sepparetely but it becomes number 1 if you count it as the same song. But I was using the same rule for each producer so I put Gossip Sea in the video. Also note that Machinegun Poem Doll (which wasn't out yet when I made the video) is getting views extremely fast and may become number 1 in the future.

[@bluestar3939]

irucaice Top 3 on Niconico : 1. Brand New Day, 323k 2. Orca, 66k 3. Sherbet Stream, 42k Top 3 on KZbin : 1. Brand New Day, 1.2M 2. Orca, 52k 3. Sherbet Stream, 37k Top 3 on Spotify : 1. Brand New Day, 363k 2. Black and White (collab with picco), 14k 3. iceQuarium, 13k Conclusion : there is absolutely no doubt that irucaice's most popular song is Brand New Day

[@bluestar3939]

HachiojiP Top 3 on Niconico : 1. Kimagure Mercy, 4.6M 2. Violence Trigger, 3.2M 3. Gimme×Gimme (collab with Giga), 2.5M Top 3 on KZbin : 1. Kimagure Mercy, 21M 2. Gimme×Gimme, 18M 3. Violence Trigger, 9.1M Top 3 on Spotify : 1. Gimme×Gimme, 8.9M 2. Kimagure Mercy, 6.2M 3. Weekender Girl (collab with kz-livetune), 4M Conclusion : Kimagure Mercy is number 1 but Gimme×Gimme will take that spot in the future. It's a collab though, Kimagure Mercy stays number 1 for solo works

[@lieutenant_lucky_rocks]

I feel like working with Reol really impacted Giga’s signature style and the way he tuned his Vocaloids.

[@joannamysluk8623]

She sure did, there's even a sample of her voice in Gimme×Gimme from what I've heard!

[@lieutenant_lucky_rocks]

@@joannamysluk8623 Yep, it’s the sort of throaty pitch-shifted “Yo-!” It’s in more songs than just that one, too.

[@joannamysluk8623]

@@lieutenant_lucky_rocks I think it's also in Rettou Joutou but I could be wrong.

[@xKaby]

@@joannamysluk8623 it is also in Bring It On

[@joannamysluk8623]

@@xKaby So that confirms it.

[@VocaloidRules101]

Is it just me or are producers using V Flower a lot now a days? No complaints! I personally think V flower has the most unique voice out of the modern vocaloid, aside from Otomachi Una or Rana (rip :c)

[@606aichan7O7]

I've personally seen a lot of ppl using KAFU, but I think that's 'cuz it's one of the newest ones rn and everyone's experimenting w/ it

[@bluestar3939]

For KAFU it's more because a lot of artists have been asked to make official demo songs to promote her so she became popular before even being released

[@bichonfrise6248]

Ikr! I’m so happy cuz v flower has always been my favorite

[@darthestar8791]

@@606aichan7O7 There's also Solaria who has a similar story going on as I'm writing this.

[@plantinapot9169]

Tbh I don’t personally like it that much, feels the most (monotone?) of everything I heard, like it’s always singing the same way

[@spiritwarhol707]

Even in their first songs you can feel their styles so clearly.

[@pizza_36]

I dropped my fucking pudding

[@MazzieOnPaws]

I know exactly what song your profile pic is from and that song is the best

[@judahosborne8868]

It's crazy how some of these producers have had the SAME tuning style forever and the only thing that's changed is the quality of the vocaloid

[@Rein377]

Hearing early songs of now-famous producers makes me want to try my hand at making a Vocaloid song myself. I might not succeed, but it's worth a try, isn't it?

[@lifeline7371]

^^)/ Go for it! I believe it's a really valuable experience to try.

[@wevebi]

me too! i was working on an original for gachapoid because very few people make stuff for him and it's honestly very fun even if i struggle to make songs myself, so i recommend trying even if you don't have vocaloid experience!

[@zephyr_monochrome]

Go for it! Good luck and have fun!

[@alme4898]

Haha kinda the feeling of "greenlight serenade"😅 the same famous producers tell you to give it a shot ^^

[@altairbucklebub8888]

good luck and have fun mate!

[@artmaster500]

Wow didn't know Electric Love was Hachioji's first song! It really sounded very ahead of its time

[@forkrolls]

electric chair

[@EL-ls6nx]

@@forkrolls STAPPPPP NAURRRR

[@QieQieQuiche]

@@forkrolls bleugh tora is actually a terrible person

[@oshawott946]

@@QieQieQuiche what whyy

[@rubythebitch46]

@@QieQieQuiche what'd they do?

[@shadowl.dragmire8531]

Its interesting to see that most of them started that cute pop style but as time goes they get heavier, OR there dark and heavy and they start out of nowhere they start making straight sugar untill you read the lyrics.

[@aiaikawa4012]

Its honestly bc "pop" is one of the most neutral styles you can go for. Its an easier start for beginners

[@PancakesTsuki]

And there’s pinnochioP that started ummmm yh like dat lol

[@lolineko2083]

@@PancakesTsuki I feel like he started EDM and techno styles and also unique imagery.

[@PancakesTsuki]

@@lolineko2083 he has a lot of GOOD song that I lov and they're awesome, quirky and i enjoy he's good artist :)

[@Buick_GSX]

And then you have Kikuo

[@your.local.person6809]

Non breath oblige is one of my most favorite songs from PinocchioP

[@themel0nman1]

based

[@warfu_]

And it's such an AMAZING song. Pinocchio is going so good, I'm happy for them.

[@angelvu]

@@serendipidie it’s not wrong them still works

[@johnrobert4486]

Can I just say I love the attention Flower is getting nowadays? When she first came out it was SO hard for me to find songs of hers and she instantly became my favorite. I’m so happy all these big producers are giving her a shot!

[@digital_pyth0n]

FLOWER IS ONE OF MY FAVS

[@beomkaslana]

Her popularity is 100% deserved

[@pupthemusicman]

if you do a part 2 you should include some english producers like ghost or kira because then there would be lyrical improvement that wouldnt need translation

[@bluestar3939]

I chose producers I know well for this video but next time I'll try to have more variety and choose producers for multiple langages

[@prawnactor1278]

@@bluestar3939 I have some suggestions for part 2 as well: Maretu Mitchie M Jin Yunosuke Ayase(?) Niki Circus p

[@TXFlyveon]

@@prawnactor1278 Maretu changed SO much, it's amazing

[@laconicdraconic697]

@@bluestar3939 steampianist is a bit more obscure but I think in the horrorish niche they are pretty well known? They have 4+ vids over 1 mil.

[@QuinnArgo]

@@prawnactor1278 This has me wondering, would x0o0x/Wakame/ count as a vocaloid producer? Like a lot of his songs did start as VL at least

[@nayutalien7473]

Great video concept and history lesson! Glad to see Nayutalien featured as well, he's my favorite producer.

[@JosiahRobert14]

I finally found another NayutalieN Stan!

[@luminacake588]

Yesssss fr, he deserves more attention, I rarely hear him mentioned among the other big names in the community

[@AustinWithAHead]

He?!

[@luminacake588]

@@AustinWithAHead On the wiki, he's refered to with he/him pronouns, so I guess so lol

[@waferae]

@@luminacake588 right

[@hilma8073]

PinocchioP's is such an incredible improvement- that first song sounds awful, especially in comparison. Definitely one of my favorite Vocaloid producers

[@ukimenustah7932]

Idk bro hanauta goes slappy

[@krishnavinesh5638]

He switched aesthetics

[@mikusmom]

AND THE IMAGE ON THE FIRST ONE FUCKIN SCARED ME, (I've seen way way more messed up shit than that but idk why it scared me lmfao)

[@efu2046]

Deco-sama is just quality since day one. Reference, sequels, (Does song even use the term sequels?), remasters, wordplay, and all that jazz. I like that in songs. And now with the whole Mannequin idol group with similar style of music. I am loving all his works

[@raccoonchild]

Same with Hachi, Kikuo, wowaka (RIP), Furukawa-P. Very unique, standout talents from their very first upload. Of course I'm leaving out some others but these four have always been my personal musical role models because of their wonderful use of sound.

[@usako_jpn]

I cant believe you add UtsuP in this list!! Been listening to Utsu’s songs since middle school and he does improve a lot by vocals and music style!! I’ve been going on and off on his newer songs since I prefer his older songs (mostly CD-R to P.T.S.D album)

[@silverfan9611]

I'm fairly new to his channel and prefer mostly his new stuffs. But when I look up his older works on Spotify I can't help but just be in awe. Some producers were good from the start but the dedication to improve really makes I admire him. Using Miku English to give her a more human-like singing is also very innovative, and something no other producer have think of

[@johnlake2545]

I miss those raw emotions his production once had. Sure, he skyrocketed in quality but, imo, that came with the sacrifice of new content being so damn sterile.

[@r3dros3ss74]

P.T.S.D is so good istg

[@nico-ly2sx]

i love cdr sm

[@billlee3851]

Imo the album songs without PVs sound really reminiscent of his older songs. They're weird, sinister and chaotic, just like how I remember it lol. But I do have to agree that his older songs have a lot more identity to them

[@rubylillies867]

It’s pretty cool how newer fans are joining to the vocaloid fandom and slowly discovering these well known producers. Vocaloid music has changed a lot over the years

[@Raiden-le7up]

That giga one threw me for a loop! I can definitely sense the signature impact of the vocals, but the instrumental sounds something akin to the style of Butterfly Right Shoulder and Piano x Forte x Scandal...

[@hachijuhachip]

woahh this is such a cool concept- next time you should add maretu!! hes improved massively

[@bluestar3939]

Sadly he deleted his older works so I don't know what is his actual first song. I found reuploads of 2011 songs but I can't tell if there is more from earlier and which of these reuploads is the older song. His style was completely different back then, he was making metal. Edit : I think I found his actual first song so I can include him in the next video. It's one of the most violent vocaloid songs I have ever heard

[@8pierrot89]

@@bluestar3939 i think that's fitting, he used to be called "Gokuaku-P" after all - literally something like "heinous" or "atrocious", I wouldn't be surprised if a person with a name like that made...diiiiiifficult things to listen to

[@ReigoVassal]

@@bluestar3939 Make sure you put the Magical Doctor in the best part. I think that was the song that make Maretu...Maretu.

[@geminide4772]

@@ReigoVassal Hard disagree, magical doctor is awesome but Coin Locker Baby or Mind Brand are way more iconic in the history of vocaloid

[@ReigoVassal]

@@geminide4772 one of my point is that Magical Doctor were one of the most memed song. I get your point. In fact mind brand were the most viewed in his channel.

[@EnergA3564]

Congrats to PinocchioP for making a song 2 months after release of this video which got FOUR TIMES MORE VIEWS than their former most popular song!! Yes I am talking about God-ish What a legend.

[@MaryArts]

Some suggestiond that never make any list, weirdly though they are super popular: Jin, Hitoshizuku-P, Mothy, Mitchie M, Manbou-P, Atols would be nice to have on a list like that for once. And Neru-p must be so interesting

[@djrydell]

a lot of this feels like "how much faster can we make them sing now" LMAO

[@needzzzsagain]

You should totally do Neru in the next one!! His style has changed a ton

[@geminide4772]

it sounds like he went to therapy or something 😭

[@Dopinoi]

@@geminide4772 LMAOOOOO such an accurate description!

[@needzzzsagain]

@@geminide4772 haha maybe, I really like his newer music

[@Ianayru]

@@geminide4772 PLEASE this has no business being this funny 😭😭

[@HyLo-rule]

@@geminide4772 bye

[@thylacinefan]

so cool to see utsu-p and pinocchiop in this :] its cool how much different producers’ tuning style changes and improves over time

[@johnloverman]

I think a good part two that focuses on western producers should include KIRA, Circus, Crusher, Empath-P, nostraightanswer, AlexTripSands, flangermoose, and GHOST. a note on ghost's most recent work for your future video-- they have not been active in the community as they have sort of left the vocaloid scene. however they were commissioned to make a demo song for the SynthV voicebank SOLARIA called Aura and its great!

[@MarioLuigi0404]

If you do a sequel to this, I think Mitchie M would be a good inclusion. His tuning is insane.

[@Retrorama_Replay]

CosMo’s earlier work had such an endearing touch of realistic tuning that I miss in current work, though both are lovely.

[@daifukumochi3686]

Electric love is a bop!

[@bluestar3939]

It's really impressive that it was HachiojiP's first song. Btw Electric Love eight mix (the 2016 remake of the song) is even better.

[@whittledraws]

Something I think is fun is that Pinocchio P has like a redo of one of his early songs, Eight Hundred; if you make another that might be cool to hear for ppl who haven’t :}

[@ruffianchattino]

I personally think utsu p is one of the best vocaloid producers but i love how his old songs are more brutal

[@octo5114]

I like your pfp

[@8bitidiot671]

yeah! i love his newer songs but his older ones are just more heavy metal than metal and i love it

[@ruffianchattino]

@@octo5114 thanks

[@ruffianchattino]

@@8bitidiot671 yes he has very amazing songs

[@spaghetti2222]

THANK YOU FOR PUTTING YURRY. As a huge fan of him I'm really happy Also the video is really interesting, I wonder if a part 2 will ever be made in the future. Is cool how producers first songs like Pinocchio, cosmo or deco are very basic at first, but they still have something in common with their current style, being voice tuning, or the song's melody. They really resambles their future style.

[@bluestar3939]

Considering a lot of people seem to like the idea, I definitely can make more videos with other producers. But I'm just not sure how I can do with producers like Maretu or Masa since they deleted their older works.

[@Aklumia]

i love 僕みたいな君、君みたいの僕 (you who resemble me, i who resemble you).. it just has a charm to itself that i can’t quite describe, but it’s just so wholesome and beautiful in its own sense

[@nchiakinqayyim]

This really helpful for someone like me. I stop hearing vocaloid much since 2014. Watching this do really makes me want to listen vocaloid song like usual :")

[@vii7797]

Wow, Deco*27’s songs were good from the beginning. By far my favorite vocaloid artist.

[@halowars400762]

Pinocchio-P's one of the few producers where the original vocaloid song is up to par with real people/singers for me. He just has a way of producing and tuning that instantly allows me to recognize it and it feels like it's a perfect fit for the song rather than taking away from it. Inabakumori is another one which hits a similar sweet spot I've recently found.

[@whitecoffee05]

Non-breath really was a whimsical song. I love the chorus

[@aerodixx777]

a lot of the improvement in these producers really blown me away, especially with Giga and Pinocchio P

[@galaxyfrostrose2925]

This bringing back some heavy nostalgia for certain songs/producers. Amazing work!

[@eeveeevolved2611]

Happy to see Utsu here, he’s my favorite producer!!

[@oetm6823]

Mmm...🤔 I feel the years specially on pinnochiop, but in all of the examples, the characteristic style of vocal is here. Pinnochiop more sweet, nanawo more robotic, Deco more human, omoi more vibrato. The aspects that have improved the most are the soundtrack, above the vocal.

[@juancrich]

I think kikuo would fit in great in the second part, his style has changed a lot through the years

[@bluestar3939]

Already made part 2 and Kikuo is included kzbin.info/www/bejne/jJatdHeVq7NljNU

[@geneviagayden]

Just found this video. God, I love Giga-P so much. His style is so distinctive, I could listen to it forever. His work with Reol definitely was a huge improvement step for him.

[@kiyukikinjo]

I love that producers who have been working with vocaloid for so long are also getting to work on big projects like sekai, it’s very nostalgic !

[@yashiraisu]

Through this video I got to meet producers I've never heard of and amazing songs!

[@CaZuL]

That's really a great video concept !

[@mysticmaya9426]

I look forward to see what the future brings as well

[@Idontknow-gf8hr]

Oh my god another person who knows irucauce She's so underrated tho the songs she makes are always amazing😭 Thanks for including her in this list i'm so glad to know that some more people knows her!

[@marshall7439]

i'll just drop it Non-Breath Oblige is an amazing song tbh

[@NevascaGamerr]

pinnocchiop god-ish is much more than his most recent sound i'm am addicted to it

[@fujiwarachika2187]

These are some really interesting videos, great work!

[@Rene99999]

Wow Pinocchio p has improved significantly over the years

[@davimag2071]

This makes me wonder about my favorite Vocaloid producer (Wintermute). His songs were great and they are all 2009-2012 something like, but he ceased his works. I can only imagine how amazing he would be today.

[@alisonnyanyannya]

AHHHH I LOVE GIGA'S FIRST SONG ITS SO GOOD!!!!! I wish he used luka more !!!

[@kavinaderrow3269]

I think it's kinda sad that Electric Love only ended up in Project Mirai.

[@inkling_kaito4728]

it's also a meme

[@gabosor64]

The next part you should add MitchieM (that has a large trayectory by now), Kinoshita and Chitana(ちいたな)! They are great producers!

[@amiigoesmuu]

11:39 *”Bring it On” starts playing * Me: *HYPE *

[@arepadequeso711]

Sipasa

[@ariannapaulino5690]

Sameeeeee

[@SLINGSH07]

THE HYPE WHEN NAYUTALIE-N CAME WAS>>>> SHE ALSO MADE MY FAVORITE SONG (dance robot dance!) AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

[@exchange5677]

Thanks for the video!! No conocía la primera canción de Giga-P, él es uno de mis productores vocaloid favoritos! No conocía aquella canción reciente de NatayulieN, voy a escucharla~ 😍

[@soynormiexfavornomegolpees2593]

Sisisi, pero nada le gana a la saga de memoria innmoral de Van'ice (Natsu-P)

[@GweenOfTea]

I didnt actually realize Shit was Utsu-P's first song, I remember it being the first song of his I listened to

[@ranuarga7510]

I started listening Vocaloid in 2014 but IDK why it feels already more than a decade lol. Although, I do have to admit that I am just a casual listener because even after 7 years there are still many producers that I don't know, from this video I only know deco27, 8prince, Giga, pinnochioP, nayutalien and all of them are my favorite Outside of this video, my favorite is supercell, Hachi/Kenshi yonezu, livetune, wowaka

[@janevim11]

never heard of irucaice but their songs sound lovely! thank you for introducing me to them!

[@fsaczb]

Thank you for this. I found a new producer (can't believe I have not heard of irucaice before).

[@jojoserloi]

YESS you added utsu-p here!!!! i love him sm :))

[@arcademotherhex0104]

Oh man, discovering and enthusiastically diving into Vocaloid since 2009 and sitting here now is indescribable with all the memories, the development and so on Makes me so happy it's still going strong

[@squidgyelder3567]

I'd argue CosMo's most popular song is Disappearance, cause game + it was a song that defined a period in vocaloid history

[@Z3nniO_125]

If you’re going to make more of these, please include Inabakumori, they’re so underrated

[@ruikasasfixer]

I feel the nostalgia flowing through the video. Ah the memories

[@mikufan1212]

i need this this off my chest. Does anyone think mothy(akuno-p)'s tuning is worse than before? He redid some of his seven deadly sins songs and they sound really bad. Like evil food eater conchita or the tailor of enbizaka. The voices do this weird high flip and low dip and they sound nasally, more mechanical, and even less real when they do the talking bits. His new songs sound okay and they fit more to the newer tunes he's making but any of the remakes is like...no. I can't tell if I'm feeling nostalgia for the older songs.

[@MissMystery1412]

Yes!!!!! And it doesn’t even have the benefit of having that charming older sound to it, like I can excuse lackluster tuning with older songs and VBs but when you have the benefit of new software and years of skills, you have way less of an excuse for sounding like crap haha

[@spaceaster]

Are you watching the official uploads? Bc his tuning sounds so much better

[@paigelacina23]

this is really interesting, good job!!

[@lizzydarkrose]

Giga's improvement is staggering. We all start somewhere

[@dalsoval]

Thank you for including LIQ, I love their songs

[@neppytunez39]

OMG IVE NEVER HEARD THE NON-REMASTERED VERSION OF UTSU-P'S FIRST SONG AND IM CONCERNED NOWW

[@ketsuekikurochi7647]

I dunno why I chuckeld a bit when you wrote he also worked with human singer 😂 And damn YOURBE DESCRIPTION BEEN IMPROVING WITH A LOT OF FUNCTIONS

[@weabooavatar399]

UtsuP has been ahead of his time since his first song.

[@chrysoprased]

makes me feel a little better about myself to know that some of the most famous producers in vocaloid made things that sounded REALLY REALLY BAD at first.

[@dizzyparanoiagirl]

note if you ever make a part 2 to this and include ghost- their first song isnt on their channel, you can still find it but the pv to it is lost also unrelated to what i said above, if you ever do a part 2, id suggest rip and masa works design

[@_zero_05]

gotta say as an UtsuP fan his work has improved quality and vocal wise but music wise GOD DAMN its always a good day when a new song is put out by him. PinnochioP very much improved and imo i prefer his newer songs over his old works. DECO, cosMo, LIQ, and HachiojiP i got into their music a bit late so hard to tell how much they improved. Giga OMG THAT MAN IMPROVED. irucaice and YurryCannon i have not listen to. Man NayutalieN iirc the YT was taken down and that was sad but damn i love their music, not much change though but still banger songs. Also UtsuP older songs are still good, i still say that his best album is Traumatic, but DAMN Unique fucking kills it with the tracks it has. His weakest album though is Galapagos, as much as i love some of the tracks it just doesnt hit like the others.

[@griddymaster6900]

When electric love came on I sang "electric chairrrr" and then was like: 👁👄👁

[@DarkCartoon_music]

For part 2, you should put Chinozo, Iyowa, and BCNO. Especially because BCNO has over 70 songs on YT

[@hoshiimochii1466]

OMG YES IYOWA

[@supernenechi]

Ahh, but Giga really is incredible aren't they??? Streamline Prism is already such an amazon song!

[@wahoo4369]

the pinocchio-p evolution is CRAZY, so proud of where he's at :)

[@DotDotDotDashDashDashDotDotDot]

Man old vocaloids are very nostalgic

[@Garb4ge]

Kikuo :(

[@bluestar3939]

I will include him next time

[@SateiTraductions]

Hachioji-P's first song being Electric Love is honestly such a flex

[@cendrecovfefe2496]

Great concept. I subscribed. :)

[@cendrecovfefe2496]

Omg I had totally forgetten about Utsu-P's "shit" !

[@meadowblossoms2849]

Man I had no idea hanauta was pinocchio P’s first song!! I’ve listened to his updated one but my god gotta check out his original one now too

[@The_Tenmas_have_my_soul]

15:31 We now have a vocaloid only version!

[@kaimiz]

bro utsu-p's first song was such a banger back then, i didnt even know it was his first!

[@renchonet]

Thank you for making this! Make me goosebump so much! I know vocaloid since 2014 and still hear their song rn, i love it so much! ♥️ Can know this is so interesting for me. Their history is always in our heart. ♥️

[@ExoticBankai]

That was a good video !

[@Crdavis1996]

Fun/Cool video. Appreciate the text you put on most of the vids giving other titles that would be selected under different criteria!

[@numberoneiafan6849]

Genuinely surprised that cosMo's most popular song isn't machine gun poem doll or the disappearance of Hatsune miku

[@kalambda]

May i suggest add Nilfruits in part 2(if it will be released). BTW really glad to see Utsu here.

[@cadenzaviolet]

PinocchioP coming from that first version of Hanauta to the recent Non-Breath Oblige is so wildly inspiring, he's come so far

[@Luchiinku]

Non-breath obligue is a masterpiece

[@mrtoast244]

I like this video, I'm new to vocaloid so I'm finding a lot of new artists

[@15_heidune72]

0:40 I'd think that'd be about to change soon. Vampire already has 50M views by the time of writing this comment. It'd probably overtake hibana by...the end of this year at most.

[@neppytunez39]

maretu's difference in music style is insane but he wasnt included here so ima do smth rq (srry for commenting twice): first: kyousei reijuu most popular: mind brand recent: new darling

[@ghostagent3552]

I really wanna know how people of the 2000s and early 2010s will think of the style of the late 2010s and 2020s

[@memoowo]

flower has such a unique voice

[@Shana3_8]

Ayyy, thanks for introducing me to some artists!!

[@djwess100]

9:49 First time I heard this song was when I got my Exit Tunes Presents: Vocalostream album, now I NEED MOAR!!!