Comparing tubing mascaras side-by-side - Caliray vs. Thrive + FOTD ft. BareMinerals 

Caliray Come Hell or High Water Volumizing Tubing Mascara (My favorite of the two)
$24
Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions™ Mascara
$24
So they are the same price it just comes down to your preference, but I think the Caliray holds up a tiny bit better and I prefer the look compared to the thrive one.

[@lorettapeters1]

I look forward to trying the Caliray. I've been using the Thrive for a few years, and it has been my "go to". I don't squench my eyes when it's on, but I have shed tears, and it doesn't come off when crying unless you touch or rub it. If you blot it lightly with a tissue and let it dry, it stays in place (although a tiny bit might come off on the tissue, but not the full fiber). What I love about Thrive is that for older women, it really lifts the eyelashes. I use an eyelash curler and 2 coats, and it gives a great look. Most days I don't even wear any other eye makeup, because the lashes look so good. But I will try the Caliray and see how it compares for me. Thank you for your review! :O)🙂

[@lindsayfaye]

Lol I happen to squench a lot. My eyes tear up like nobody’s business. 🤪🤷🏼‍♀️ maybe I just got it dud? It definitely looks so pretty on but it’s also quite a lot of mascara for what I normally wear. If I wear a lot of mascara it definitely has to be waterproof. Although….you know…I recently tried the it cosmetics Super hero, it’s not a tubing mascara but I really love it, it’s not waterproof but it does hold my curl. And does not tear off. Sooo weird. I wonder how that one’s different from the thrive, I’m curious now. I want to look into the ingredients. 🤔 Anyhow thank you so much for stopping bye, for watching and for commenting, I really appreciate it. Hope you’re having a great weekend, God bless. ♥️ Lindsay

[@kelseyc8242]

Really helpful! Thanks Lady 🙂

[@lindsayfaye]

Heyyyyy, that’s great, I’m glad to hear! You’re welcome. 😃😃♥️ I actually have a tarte tubing mascara and I think I’m going to compare that to the Caliray as well. 😎 thank you so much for watching! 🥰🥰

[@JD-ht7yw]

i recc going cruelty fre