Conférence avec Edward Snowden

Que faire face à la société de surveillance ? / Facing a surveillance society
Échanges avec et autour d'Edward Snowden en direct de Russie
Jeudi 6 décembre 2018
Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne
Conférence organisée avec le concours des associations d'étudiants : Débattre en Sorbonne et Alliance Panthéon-Sorbonne
Intervenants :
William Bourdon, avocat au barreau de Paris
Paul Cassia, professeur à l'université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne
Judith Rochfeld, professeur à l'université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne
Patrick Weil, directeur de recherche au CNRS

[@maninthemirror216]

Edward you are the voice for all the people who are not the government. Words can not do justice for the amount of gratitude 🙏🏻

[@aidenjenkins9488]

It's really cool to see videos of Snowden where you can go to the comments section and see all of the tremendous support that Snowden is being given by people. It's a really amazing thing to see. Edward Snowden, you are an awesome person. I'm glad that he is receiving support from people, even if it isn't a lot.

[@safir2115]

Le bétail est si impressionnable et naïf.

[@dickstab]

dude hes not saying anything that if u watched u wouldn't have gotten from some news sources over time or read bills they pasted.

[@andrewspeegle9954]

HELLZ yes. the best werejj z n syrup.keep. Uppp u Eli mus k okay have a very interesting brain very good hearing your speeches always and I hope to God that they never do anything to you because you don't deserve it it's not treason Nancy pelosi needs to be behind bars that she gets a new tunnel she's a joke hope we can get California back in order and recall this so-called newsome character you know I'm only 2 years older than you brother and you came a long way so I salute you for cuz you know the dangerous you have a great year!!

[@beccareynolds4625]

I have so much love for this man. God bless Edward Snowden. 🙏

[@eagletvv4926]

This video deserve more views !!! Merci a l'université Paris d'avoir fait naître cette conférence.

[@juliarobin3653]

Yes

[@juliarobin3653]

Lll Yes ppp

[@tracymacwhorter3577]

I’m

[@michelleh260]

@@juliarobin3653 k

[@moniquejacobosky9566]

@@juliarobin3653 noknk

[@kamelmebhah4122]

Without a doubt you and Julian assange and all the rest like you are bigger than a stars at least you will be remembered after your deaths, in 50 years time from now. Extremely brave gentlemen. The highest respect.

[@ants_in_my_eyes_Wilson]

Don't forget about Chelsea Manning. It's a trifecta of heroes.

[@ants_in_my_eyes_Wilson]

I really wish that Snowden could come home. I can't even tell you how much we need people who are willing to speak of revolution in this country. I'm afraid we are so incredibly fucked without it.

[@rexrocker1268]

Some folks want him dead... If he came home he might die in a “car accident”...

[@drivinsouth651]

We`re totally fucked and so are the Kennedys, Malcolm X, MLKJ, Robin Hood, Zorro, Guy Faulkes, Jesus, and anyone else who tries to do a revolution. Bernie Sanders was lucky. But I think Bernie`s whole campaign was a scam just to get rich off the rich. That`s what he did, on purpose or not... 😞I wish we could program A.I. to make all the politicians do their jobs morally and competently... Nous sommes baisés; c`est la vie! 😱

[@ants_in_my_eyes_Wilson]

@@drivinsouth651 Sanders is the absolute least of our concerns as far as politicians go. He's the one that planted the seeds of revolution, at least in the mainstream today; if he didn't point out directly that things in our country are fucked and need to change, I have a strong feeling that a lot of people would never even question it.

[@ants_in_my_eyes_Wilson]

@@rexrocker1268 they would never let him come home without dying in a cold dark prison cell after decades of solitary confinement. Just like Julian Assange. Chelsea Manning was very fortunate to get out, not that she's without persecution today. However, out of the three, Snowden's the only one who is staying so entrenched in the current conversation of mass surveillance and technology pitfalls; he wouldn't be able to do it in America even if he could come home without dying in a cold dark prison cell somewhere. He definitely seems to be adapting well to his new home. And as much as it sucks, I am forever grateful that he is remaining vocal, regardless of his situation.

[@drivinsouth651]

@@ants_in_my_eyes_Wilson He was just pointing out the obvious; the masses didn`t care then and they care less every day. Bernie Sanders was Our Savior and Messiah; now he lives in one of his several palaces...

[@kat_c225]

Thank you for all you have done for us. Appreciate your work you have done for us. Thank you for your advice and wisdom. Praying for your safety and well being. 👍❤😘

[@kimberlycrichton2932]

He’s a hero & took tremendous risks. He’s so thoughtful & far sighted. His optimism is remarkable given his exile and isolation. Let him come home ❗️

[@neoncat9573]

I do not think it would be safe for him to come home. I would not trust any promises he may be given.

[@davidoaikhena4380]

He shouldn’t go back that’s my honest advise even if pardon!

[@nanabluect1]

@@neoncat9573 Our current Congress is more corrupt than any cartel or mafia has ever been, in the history of mankind. The majority has managed to somehow f i x the v.o te , ensuring their ree-le c-tion, term after term. They all fear that this man knows all of their c rime s. If he were to ever come home...he would be k. ill e.d. w/in a week of his homecoming, most likely in a single car accident...which seems to be what the F ake B ean I diots and the C at I diot A sses love to use against anyone who could hurt the Democratic Party members....

[@elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633]

@@nanabluect1 It's not just Democrats, it's Republicans too.

[@dannygibson6123]

My top 5 lecturer in the world✊🏿✊🏾✊🏽✊🏼✊✊🏻 His advice is indispensable♻️

[@ruthdenova5984]

Mr. Edward Snowden, my gratitude and stay free for us. Love and Revolution.

[@svetlanaspielberg282]

Bless you and THANK YOU from the world!

[@PiseyKhat]

I respected this man for what he did to all us, as a human being. nobody can stop you even NSA. Stay free Mr. Snowden

[@N0itUL0V3]

He did what he did so the NSA couldn't track the CIA doings. He's a clown.

[@davidoaikhena4380]

If GOD is for you and your time has not yet come! No gang-up of politicians, President, CIA, FBI, NSA can take you down!

[@davidoaikhena4380]

Money cannot buy the comment sections in social media! That’s where the public temperature is!

[@andrewspeegle9954]

Free Edward Snowden!!!!! KO NO ROUNDS

[@Rabia_Burak]

@@davidoaikhena4380 absolutely! God has chosen him to fight against evil, anti christ forces of today disguised as social media companies, governments etc.. he is the messiah and that's why all evil forces are pinched by him because they can swallow the truth.. well whatever if God is shielding him and has chosen him to fight and expose the Allies of the evil Anti Christ, He will keep Edward Snowden safe even if the whole world is against him, period!

[@madeleinerutten1305]

Bravo bravo edward snowden and assange respect respect we love you😍😍😍

[@mjs1231]

We have not forgotten about you. Someday brother.

[@johnburgess7376]

Be confident dear Edward there are more people thinking the way you do in the nation of men ....

[@saheranoman]

You are proud of humanity. I really respect him. And Gosh he is so handsome 😍

[@patriciaervin2879]

Sir Edward, I am 72 years old. I think I've seen every one of your presentations, some more than once. My boyfriend was in the Vietnam war when Daniel Ellsberg spoke out. He( my boyfriend stepped on a landmine but eventually recovered with 100 percent disability, and became my husband if only for awhile. Yourself, Chelsea Manning, Julian Assange have all been at the top of my list of heros and I believe have suffered greatly for your altruism. Wish you were here and free

[@ProgrammeringPC]

The forgotten hero and a voice which will be listened to when it is too late.

[@nanabluect1]

@Karter Arjun What ?

[@BRM101]

I think it’s already too late the masses have been very successfully brain washed

[@1sthawkfeathers547]

We can't give up. Share.

[@elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633]

He's far from forgotten.

[@elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633]

He's not forgotten. His talks are all over the internet.

[@cosmicflowstudio]

If WE the PEOPLE enjoy the WEB... WE should elect Sir Edward Snowden the "President of the WEB". I VOTE YES!

[@amywalker7515]

I'll bet there's even much more out there being hidden from us even Snowden doesn't know about.

[@andrewspeegle9954]

U are so sMART, are you into COLLEGE. LEARNING ABOUT THE PRICE, TRUENESS I'VE LEARNED SO MUCH THRU SHUTTING MY MOUTH AND LISTEN TO BECOME INFORMED CORRECTLY WHATEVER IT IS 😃 THAT WE ARE CONVERSING ABOUT AND ITS SO AWESOME TO HAVE THE FEELING'S OF ,YO THIS FOXX HAS GOT SUM CONVERSATIONS THAT WOULD BE GREAT RIDE WITH. Now THATS ABOUT What I can remember bout my dream...PEACE BE WIT YOU🤪☘️ .

[@andrewspeegle9954]

I I meant it like a compliment yeah they know the shit out there will never know the full extent so I was saying he's going to be smart for you so it's a haha have a nice day and may God bless you and whatever you do but maybe I took it wrong but what were we talking about again.. .

[@andrewspeegle9954]

Back WHEN I WAS A YOUNG MAN MY DAD SET UP BBQ 4 ME HIM. HE STARTED TALKIN BOUT HIS TIME IN VIETNAM YEARS AGO WAR THAT BROKE WAS A JOKE MEDIA TOLD THE WRONG INFORMATION THAN WAT MY DAD AND MY UNCLE BILLY DUTCHOVER WAS MY DADZ SERGENT AND THATS HOW MY MOMZ MET MY DAD IN BASE AT BUEFORD, SOUTH CAROLINA, ND THE REST IZ HISTORY......

[@buddyroe61]

They done a good job keeping this away from the people, two years and I just found it,. OMG 😳

[@playgamers9591]

I have to say united we stand, Divided we fall. God bless America.

[@adrianeyre3630]

Edward Snowden is so captivating I could listen to him all day so so interesting. He wants to go home , he’s done nothing wrong. Let him get on with his life. God bless you Edward Snowden.💚💚💚

[@fantaisiepreludes1285]

The Most Brilliant Assay of Despotic Powers at Plato I have ever had the Pleasure to Be Witness...

[@michelleru3541]

Edward Snowden is great!!

[@dianeclark8256]

The remnant better wise up and wake up! Much love and appreciation for you Edward Snowden ❤️

[@etttlesaintfrusquin2670]

your name will remain wow wow wow what they say here in france at universite Paris 1 pantheon sorbonne

[@tammyslooking1]

This was put on KZbin 2 years ago. I'm curious what your opinion is today regarding our government & what's transpired since this was made public? Many things have transpired. USA

[@denahamm9841]

If Snowden and Assange did this for the better of man kind. They seemed to have tried many legal avenues, but were shut down in every way. Why have they not been pardoned. And put to work to make this wonderful world better.

[@buddyroe61]

There is no dought that this Man is a Hero for America and the rest of the world that just want to live in Peace and be left alone, Thank you MR Snowden!! 👍👍

[@leighatkins22]

Edward was lucky, he got away... Julian Assange did not... may God keep him safe and reward him for risking his freedom and ultimately losing it, for the freedom of his fellow human being...

[@Rabia_Burak]

may God save Julian Assange as well.. Amen

[@happygilmore2100]

That was great.

[@lunalynd]

Appreciate your boldness to stand up against big brother. I posted this on my fb page, propbably will be removed by them.

[@davidoaikhena4380]

They don’t like the expose on them! But like us know about most of their programmes so we can’t for prey to it. We know the tactics, we know their foot soldiers! Keep your friends close, keep your enemy more closer!

[@davidoaikhena4380]

I love this young man!!

[@georgebrittain5269]

=we need more ED SNOWDENS in the world.... i have been on the roller coaster since 2013.... i have had my eyes opened, educated, and most of all... INSPIRED........ THX ED... my respect

[@shoshannaisrael]

Will never be forgotten. A real Superhero, A real Super real man. Who loves and respects himself and especially the other, the people of America, the Land of America and the all the world He loves to serve the pure power for our children all over the world, Edward Snowden A conscience real Super real man who deliver all people to The Highest wisdom to all people who love freedom of choice for all, Truth protects all sons' of freedom. Same love and the intentions of President Donald Trump.

[@freedomlife3623]

I agree with your comments till your last sentence. As we saw from the information came to light last week, Trump will use all the government machine to force private companies to investigate and spy on anyone disagree with him. Snowden will find repulsive.

[@madeleinesheffield8626]

This guy made me feel better about my paranoia about my phone lol

[@keithpierce8871]

Hc h, u , v, H, , , W h, ,h,h, h,w ,, , very , v , , H , , H h , , w h,v , & ,, , , ., Uhh.hhh h. H , , H,he, , h. , 8. H H. . H H H H , ,, U B h W 9 H H H Hg H . Yesh H h H H , H H h. High h Hh Hhhhghhhh 8 , W i ,h ,H h U G H H H H G H Hh , U I H , .

[@keithpierce8871]

.v H Hhh ,, HHh HHhug. Hh Haha H8hgh Uughhuhhhhhhgghh. H .h. , H U H , H Gh H H,, I Gh. , H G H U H G8 H H H h Hhhh Hg H U H G G H,H 8 H

[@helenhagos6277]

Ed Snowden Bravo

[@web3982]

“Those who give up liberty for security deserve neither.” __Benjamin Franklin

[@Dawne]

Stay Free! :)

[@mdte5421]

STAY FREE! STAY FREE!

[@Rabia_Burak]

the greatest man of this century is none other than Edward Snowden

[@etttlesaintfrusquin2670]

she immediately answered positive because it was you she was enthusisatic wow wow wow

[@deedurose1765]

What an impeccable, highly evolved Warrior this man is..!!! Everyone should watch this.. Big Love & Respect 🙏🏽✌🏻

[@abhishek14002]

You protect freedom

[@desyinglish9145]

Qww

[@kimberlycrichton2932]

You are right. He would be thrown in prison awaiting trial under the Alien and Sedition Act.

[@andrewspeegle9954]

Thank you Mr Ed I think your statue should be going up!!!

[@andrewspeegle9954]

@TruthMaster2020 L. O. L.

[@andrewspeegle9954]

L. O. L.!!!!

[@andrewspeegle9954]

😂 L. O. L.... C

[@andrewspeegle9954]

ITZ A DECENT AMONT OF 💡 IDEAS THAT ALWAYS GETS THE Z, X,

[@pollockconstructioncleanin3352]

Upmost respect

[@neoncat9573]

He is highly intelligent and a wonderful speaker. He expresses himself crisply and everything he says is clearly understood.

[@enlightenedinterstellarbei8020]

I LOVE THIS MAN!!!!

[@mohamedtoure2300]

Ya man, you are the great!!!

[@Montrosesister12]

Edward. I love you 😍 💗 💛 💓 ♥️ 💖

[@rexrocker1268]

He’s smart.

[@Ulomka]

Edward Snowden for President ASAP. 🙌

[@tara-leebell8713]

he is a hero,/

[@brianveall9613]

I am commenting on a friends you tube channel . I have witnessed everything this man is saying I will keep my identity blank but thank you for helping me realise I was not cracking up iv been ripped of my life and now in a place where I could take my life Easley for my own life as been distorted destroyed and I have no no more fight in me but plenty of proof this man seals the truth thank you x

[@daviddavies5322]

Is this what democracy is about, freedom? I agree with Mr. Snowden.

[@etttlesaintfrusquin2670]

my name is delphine I live in france wow what a public here in my country wow wow wow very dear friend of mine it is said

[@bakanndy]

Ca devient intéressant à 20:38. Des entreprises s'intéressent à vos données et vos contacts pour en déduire une étiquette de prix. Le produit c'est vous.

[@trefl5661]

Même nos commentaires son classifier PORTEURS de données

[@hansjohan3150]

C'est deja intéressant a 10.30 min. Il dit des choses, illégal et decision faut, mais comme jurist, qu'est ce que il a fait après? RIEN, peur de perdre son position.

[@SylviaPerezMorenoESPANA]

I am totally healthy with no disabilities: I can speak, hear and write. I am a genius and Polyglot: English, Spanish, French, Italian, Catalan, Portuguese, High German.

[@joseafv]

Grandioso muchas bendiciones 🥰❤️🙏🏽

[@amyheddin7640]

Thank you mr snowden.

[@etttlesaintfrusquin2670]

the 500 seats were booked in 3 hours apllause from public wow wow wow

[@ontheroad9121]

3 minutes

[@sarac.tramble290]

THANK YOU FOR YOUR SACRIFICE

[@pierreangy]

Est-il possible d'avoir la transcription dans un fichier qu'on puisse la traduire, j'aimerais utiliser des extraits dans mes cours.

[@djkk464]

Thank U Mr. SNOWDEN

[@annawarner1078]

What is he doing nowadays? I did not see any videos recorded recently. This video is 2.5 years old.

[@esenci-aleart2631]

Gloire Snowden!

[@MoritaJunichiro]

Snowden is a good person😌

[@stevenmiller4329]

Lol I’m pretty sure he could come back to the U.S. and no one would tolerate the government locking him up. I’ve never heard anyone call him a criminal besides the department of defense and even they refer to him as a whistleblower more often than traitor. Strange how he’d even need a pardon, charges should be dropped.

[@buddyroe61]

I really wounder Why Donald Trump did not pardon Him and Julin Assad.

[@ernestpark7125]

thank you

[@learner9660]

He was right and few listened. Look at where we are now.

[@davidmorin1440]

on est en France, les paroles du présentateur auraient tout de même pu être traduites en Français (quand même plus de 13mn), ainsi que celles de E Snowden lui-même. on n'a pas à contraindre les français à parler anglais (combien d'américians parlent français?). c'est un manque de respect envers la France. cela dit, je trouve qu'on en fait beaucoup pour Snowden, beaucoup moins pour Assange. pourtant Julian Assange a bien plus de mérite, c'est d'ailleurs lui et son équipe qui ont aidé Snowden à se réfugier en Russie. donc Snowden peut librement faire des conférences vidéo dans les universités ou ailleurs mais Assange en est privé? on est en droit de se poser certaines questions. la nouvelle URSS sous tutelle des USA, qu'on peut aisément appeler d'UESS, est une réelle dictature US, d'ailleurs fille directe de la précédente "Nouvelle Europe" nazie sous le régime de Vichy. Merci tout de même bien évidemment à Snowden ET à Assange

[@kumartrendzz1840]

U r hero of the world

[@davidoaikhena4380]

Snowden is like a dead man that resurrected with evidence of his killers in tact!

[@joanholland3438]

I’m here!

[@gallermaez]

Edouard , vous êtes un grand homme !

[@Cl1pgodzeditor]

Billy the kid saw this game coming. Please God protect him, don’t let the government shoot him in the back

[@gunsandguitars6678]

Excellent ☆.

[@Crabtree1844]

Now that IS a man! Snowden, keep up the good fight. You exhibit the difference between a boy and a man. I stand with you in your fight for freedom.

[@SylviaPerezMorenoESPANA]

University of Miami 2002 International Finance & Economics with dear Dr. Andrea Heuson.

[@michaelpileggi1271]

The previous one had sketchy audio issues. Hopefully this version does not.

[@ants_in_my_eyes_Wilson]

Audio gets better a few minutes in.

[@AllThingsFunny77]

If people agree with snowden. How can the govt by the people and for the people be against snowden.

[@outtahere321]

Because the federal government is no longer truly a government of the people, by the people, and for the people. It stopped being that many, many moons ago. Americans only have an illusion of freedom now. As long as they pay their taxes and keep in step then they will be allowed to have lesser freedoms, but if they step out of line and try to exercise true freedom as was lived long ago by our forefathers then you find out how much a slave you really are to the government. The lack of true freedom is caused by the love of money and power in the hearts of those who "govern".

[@JCX-9]

The moment you’re born you are assigned a number. Your slave number SS (Super Slave 😂). Also your birth certificate with your name spelled in caps is your mother’s approval of that state. We are nothing more than property to the powers to be. Hopefully it’s true that The US corporation is bankrupt and ceased to exist and we are no longer their property.

[@ants_in_my_eyes_Wilson]

@@JCX-9 that's incredibly wishful thinking, I'm afraid. We can't even get decent unemployment benefits for people who have lost their job due to no fault of their own. They have reduced it. I would say probably the majority of these workers have lost their jobs due to the fact that the government force them to close their doors. Now millions of these people are also on the brink of homelessness. Our government seems to think that the average American will cease to look for work if they are given a grand total of $2,000 to subsist on, over the period of almost a year, frankly. Think about that for a minute, all these people who have lost their jobs, and their health insurance due to that fact. They're supposed to feed their families, pay their mortgage or rent, somehow afford get health care during a pandemic for an entire family without insurance, and they seem to think that people will just be living in the lap of luxury, and refusing to look for work. Not really sure what's supposed to happen when the eviction moratorium ends. Personally, I vote that we start burning shit down. Not like we'll have much else to do when we're all homeless...

[@ants_in_my_eyes_Wilson]

@@outtahere321 well said. Even the Democrats are actually conservative these days, or rather, neoliberalism has taken control of our country. Free market capitalism at all costs. I am so incredibly fucking ready for everyone else to get as pissed off as I am. But I have a feeling that's not going to happen anytime soon.

[@jackhandy2165]

Love you Ed.

[@SylviaPerezMorenoESPANA]

Chere Sorbonne, oui he suis origin Espanol, Portuguese, Sedardic Judiaque, Catalans (FR), Greque, Alemande et Britanique, premiere generacion nait en Etat-Unis. Salut, merci por votre exposicion a cuitatan Informative Educative Avant Garde Fellow Whistle Blower Americain. Je suis Economiste, Financier et Journalists d'Unicersite du Miami Coral Gables Class 2002. Mon deux colleagues on travaille en IFC. Grande Madame Christine Lagarde a observe kidnapping abuse a moi en DC pour terroristes Equatorienne du Rafael Correa Criminal massive du terroristes.

[@mikecrady3292]

Yes! Yes ! Yes !

[@susangaik36]

Do not patronize Great Clips or SportClips for hair care.

[@SylviaPerezMorenoESPANA]

President Jacque Chirac came to me in North Harley Canada 2004.

[@SylviaPerezMorenoESPANA]

That is probably why I received Jacque Chirac.

[@elizabethforsyth4814]

Free citizens human rights equality these r all things we must truly work for..c history

[@CoreyChambersLA]

Reform or Revolution

[@leilagomulka5690]

The collection of “ just in case “ is frightening.

[@denahamm9841]

So is the cloud, the problem in the end?

[@SylviaPerezMorenoESPANA]

J'aime adore France !!!!!!!!

[@celestecarrillo4254]

What about Julian Assanch he was the one who helps him, he’s the real Hero!

[@elizabethcsicsery-ronay1633]

Great man! Great leader! But yes, he exhorts us to act. Don't just admire him, do something.

[@knuckletherapyserveothersf6092]

Wish Trump had pardon you. You are courageous sir. They should give you the medal of freedom. Just wanted to say thanks and good luck to you if you ever read this comment.

[@DeborahREvans-eh5lu]

Stay safe, you're young and you were very justified by your leading of your Holy Spirit. The "Fire Within," Dubay.

[@mollybrown3370]

Whistleblower is so awesome he knows what he's saying listen to this one

[@kimberlycrichton2932]

STAY FREE

[@ants_in_my_eyes_Wilson]

We'd have to get free, first...

[@udynara4169]

Well done.

[@ModernConversations]

Quels que soient leurs sentiments sur d'autres sujets, les personnes ne le soutiennent pas auront toujours l'air d'abrutis.