Coraline Theory - Part 12 - Coraline Doll and Wybie are NOT Filled with Sand! - The Fangirl

Let's talk about how we've all assumed that the Beldam is using sand in her creations. In fact, if you stop and look closer, there is no sand being used in the Coraline doll at all!
Great Coraline stuff on Amazon: amzn.to/2SD0ews
Please watch the Coraline Core Theory (at least!) before trying to view this video.
Find me elsewhere:
sayhalogoobye
the_fanily
SayHaloGoobye Gaming - / @sayhalogoodbye
The Fanily Family Vlogging - / @thefanily
Links in this video may be affiliate links, which offers me a small commission for referring you to that store. These links help support the channel and keep up making more videos. Thanks for your support!
#coraline #coraline10 #wybie #laikastudios #thefangirl

[@Duckandthelemonade]

I like the theory, but I think the reason one doll is filled with cotton and one is filled with sawdust, is because the "Other Mother" knew that the twin would sleep with it and snuggle it, and Coraline isn't the type of person to be all cuddly and snuggly with the doll. Anyway that's just my theory, I hope someone (if anyone) sees this they like it

[@miarose2079]

Aarmau That’s actually really a great theory! It makes a lot of sense!

[@meganmyers2450]

Aarmau that’s what i was originally thinking too edit: maybe to make the doll more appealing would make the child want to be around it more, therefore helping the beldam gain more information?

[@twigwigsoso]

I think so!!

[@leahstarin8215]

I know this was commented a long time ago but I’m glad to see another Aphmau fan watching this as well

[@jellyjamraccoon7775]

I think so to but she had to see if the kids would sleep with it or not so she made her own material out of saw dust and used some dead fairy stuff with the items to make it softer the if it was sand\saw dust

[@user-dy7ls7uo9j]

I think you overlooked something crucial, the sand and the cotton represent their personalities: coraline is rough like sand (or in your case sawdust) and Wybie´s grandmother´s sister is soft like cotton (we see this in the ghost children scene)

[@foxer2628]

I don't feel so good...

[@susanagc2087]

Foxer omfg

[@wingsoffire2356]

So basically if I'm kind, it would have a heart? O_O

[@carolinesunicorncannel7435]

Nice

[@bee748]

i mean is it right to judge the children based on that scene aren’t they being controlled by the beldame

[@sawa-san5417]

I still feel like the reason Wybie revealed he was made of sawdust/sand/whatever was to show her that he didn't NEED to go. Because Coraline wants him to go saying "C'mon, she'll hurt you" but he shakes his head and reveals that he can't be hurt, as he is only made up of saw dust/whatever.

[@heidibarker9550]

When the beldam says she has been waiting for coraline for a long time, couldn't that just be her lying to make coraline feel even for special rather than the beldam being able to see into the future?

[@KyrstOak]

Heidi Barker - 'even for special'? You mean more. And yes, I agree she is known to us for her sometimes lying if she needs/wants to.

[@aa688]

Heidi Barker exactly, and if that was true, wouldn't the beldam know exactly how coraline would react to everything and know how to make it all go her way?

[@candyc3314]

I'm more inclined to believe this, as the beldam's portal is located in the pink palace and nobody had lived there since her last victim I believe.

[@teriaunam.4012]

I think she says that because the last kid she would have taken was the grandma's twin. That's what I think anyway.

[@marywallace5708]

Maybe your but I thenk she sisnt real and thet she maks the kids thenk thet she is real But I just theot thet

[@TheTheorizer]

It is indeed sawdust.

[@TheTheorizer]

Enchanted of course ;D

[@nicodiangelo2764]

The Theorizer I subscribed to you I love you notice me senpai

[@conniehan2340]

The Theorizer ur a smartass lmao

[@laurawright5926]

😁

[@shinitaru]

I always thought it was sawdust

[@spencersuen3360]

Wybie mentions to Coraline that that well is so deep "You'd see a sky full of stars during the day" if you fell into it. The dolls at the beginning of the movie float through a sky full of stars.

[@kahsosilly]

Oooh that's actually a very interesting point. **ah btw Wybie says exactly "It's heard to be so deep if you fell to the bottom and looked up, you'd see a sky full of stars in the middle of the day." **

[@TheTheorizer]

Wait hold up. Why would it be sand to start with?

[@artisan3006]

because it looked like sand, daddy

[@mumvale9019]

The Theorizer hey, it's you! I really liked your videos of Over the Garden Wall! Aren't the Coraline theories The Fangirl has really interesting?

[@sophierose5987]

you and the fangirl should do a joined video

[@ollieisfab3922]

Exactly what I thought.

[@mya5275]

The Theorizer Because it looks like it? Idk

[@aprettygothichick]

Just woke up and ready to start my day with a Coraline theory :)

[@TheFangirlWatches]

You must live very far from me! It's almost 5PM here!

[@Xyphrenn]

*yawn just woke up*

[@Hannah-qg3fp]

Alexis Thwing its 11 pm over here huh

[@Xyphrenn]

It's 6:54am and I'm from Australia

[@aprettygothichick]

I live in Kentucky. It's almost 5 pm here too. My S.O. works 3rd shift and Im on his schedule. Thanks for replying :)

[@willowowens1283]

Just a random question. If the child being lured by the Beldam was motherless (maybe she dies in childbirth) would the Beldam take on the form of the father because we have only ever seen her in feminine (and very creepy!) forms?

[@TheFangirlWatches]

uuuuhhhhh... I don't know. 0.o I'll have to think about that one!

[@willowowens1283]

Oh okay, great theory like always anyways cant wait for the next :)

[@XxCOOKEExxMONSTARxX]

I still want to know 🤔 she could possibly still be the child mother because I’m sure the child would want to meet the mom they never met and pretending to be the mom that they envisioned by getting info from her victim directly or through fake dad, the Beldam can masquerade as becoming the mom of their dreams after the “puppet dad” tells her everything.

[@fightinglucario]

I saw that the sand didn't sit right either though I thought it was just lack of detail

[@TheFangirlWatches]

I thought it might be a scale issue until I looked at Other Wybie more closely. I am honestly shocked at how often I catch something in a screen shot for this movie - there's so much to see you can't take it all in!

[@sarahsuper1688]

The Fangirl it could be genetic sand because I have a whole bag full and it kind of reminded me of it. jk

[@mollyrocks9947]

fightinglucario I thought he never had used moisturizer

[@SweetBabyBrooke]

sarah super v

[@eye5349]

fightinglucario same

[@Kinga-wg7gf]

I was just about to get some sleep BUT this video popped up in my subscription box and it was impossible not to click. By the way, I love your videos!

[@TheFangirlWatches]

I'm so sorry to keep you awake! I hope it was worth it!

[@organics9890]

The Fangirl I was wondering if I could make a video on my yt channel using some oh you theories? And I'll definitely credit you.

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Yeah as long as you credit back go for it!

[@organics9890]

The Fangirl thanks also watching Coraline with you theories in mind

[@daphnebrown7157]

Kinga Przyziółkiewicz I watched cod I’ll

[@PitaGene]

I like what you did with the sawdust and fairy dust. it might tie into the theorizer's theory on calling it "soul sand", because it someone acts like a SAND, but is actually sawdust mixed with a magical substance(fairy dust) therefore making...a SOUL SAND! Because a fairy is magical and the Beldam may be part fairy, she could probably manipulate it into a soul sand, that's why she can control the copies. also going into the theorizer's theory about how too much means less control.

[@KyrstOak]

Raven Blade Kitty - 'because it someone acts like a sand'? Ummm... What?

[@KmanBlock]

I like to think that the sawdust is the "life essence" of the children and maybe even the beldam herself and the reason it turns into cotton is the life essence running out and turning to a regular object and she uses the essence to give life to her creations

[@KyrstOak]

Dapper - That makes sense to me.

[@nemz8324]

Dapper wow

[@sophiehale1171]

Yeah it makes sense

[@user-dy7ls7uo9j]

the beldam does have future vision, Wybie said the doll she gave Coraline was there since her grandmother was a little girl

[@gamingwithcryss5329]

i noticed that 2 but i noticed also that the doll in the first scene look just like the grandmothers sister.

[@topher7379]

I love these so much, I started to watch the theroizer, but I like when people talk more like a podcast so I can press play and just listen for hours, so thank you and keep it up I LOVE THIS CHANNEL

[@antoinelk00]

I'll be so astonished if she dedicates the majority of her channel about Coraline

[@TheFangirlWatches]

hopefully not the majority, but I have gotten a lot of notes out of Coraline to go on for a while longer.

[@antoinelk00]

The Fangirl It's because your really observant and really specific and percise on the book and movie details

[@DamHuongThao-wd9ou]

the lastest victim is one of the twins, it means that belldam's lastest meal is about 60-70years ago??? How long could she handles her hunger? Neh, she ll never die from starvation i know it

[@rebajoe]

Sometimes I wondered if the cobwebs on the Beldams sewing machine was foreshadowing her being a spider person and not just that it'd been a while since her last doll.

[@willowowens1283]

I really like this theory, and all of your other ones for that matter, but why did the Beldam switch to sawdust? If she had access to wool (or cotton) then why make the switch to sawdust when the mills came into business. I mean she only ever uses one doll at a time and presumably its the same one so its not like she doesn't have enough wool because she pulled the amount of wool she would always need in the start of the movie. Also wouldn't a doll with wool in it be more appealing to a child than one filled with sawdust?

[@WitchVampZoe]

I think if the saw mills did find the well and decide to dump a load of sawdust down it, the beldam would probably want to make use of it to get it out of the way

[@willowowens1283]

But the Beldam is already using it for her lesser creations (Other Wyborn) so why also use a small fraction of it to create a doll which will come right back with the sawdust, it would make sense for the Beldam to keep using the wool or cotton for the doll (as its more appealing for children) and maybe store the sawdust (if we are following The Fangirl's theory the beldam has plenty of room with her Other World and Pink Palace look a like who knows what else she has) and then use it for future needs like if another child found their way to her and the Beldam needs to create one of their friends etc. I don't know if I'm missing something (I usually am) so please correct me if so.

[@WitchVampZoe]

good point, I don't know but maybe the sawdust in the doll does get replaced after one use, as the cotton wool she pulls out in the beginning doesn't appear to have anything wrong with it, but she still replaces it so maybe she uses all new things for each doll with the exception of the material used for the doll itself? maybe because the fabric used is special or maybe she only gets 2 uses out of that material because she turns it inside out...and as we don't see her make a third one we don't know what her manufacturing pattern is for the dolls 🤔❤

[@mariavalitno1543]

Callum Johnson don't know u gotta point

[@dcarter020809]

Maybe it's the way the doll is used?

[@hannahmay8169]

I always thought the insides of the dolls were connected to the models' personalities,

[@noomre9105]

That's a really good idea

[@bobadotjpg]

I LOVE your coraline theorys! ❤

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Thank you

[@cloudyhearts4578]

your* you're =you are your=An owned object

[@cloudyhearts4578]

The doggo animations 😭😂😂

[@missKonstante]

*theories :P

[@danielav9596]

The Doggo I think coraline is boring in my opinion but I love watching this 😃

[@orleansartist6095]

4:04 notice the top of the head of the child on the left. The upward curls look like the hair of the ghost boy. The other side of her hair has a pin so it's pinned down. Maybe they're related. Also she looks not jealous, but actually afraid.

[@direofchaossavior1058]

Wow fans of coraline or maybe nostalgic people are still alive for this theories in 2017 like 9 years since the release in 2009

[@ClintonomoBay]

I started watching these theory videos last night and they honestly freaked me out a bit diving into what the Beldam could be capable of. I've been watching the film almost every night this past week on Netflix.

[@katherineofarrogant6370]

The beldam is kinda like the witches in madoka. Being able to make different dimensions, inviting people and objects into it and there have been examples of both controlling people like with the witches kiss. Plus the witches have some type of form based off something in real life, like the beldam with insects and she looks kinda like a spider in the end. I don't think there is a real connection, just something I noticed.

[@zeera9788]

I just discovered your channel while watching The Theorizer and after seeing all your theories on Coraline, Don't Hug Me I'm Scared and The Babadook I gotta say I'm glad to have found you. Your calm voice brings fresh and logical perspectives to each movie and show. Keep up the great work, I'm going to become one with the bell crowd for all your future videos. Greetings from Iceland :D

[@etherealtarot1181]

my theory is the stars in the window in the beginning of the movie are the stars you see at the bottom of the wall according to wybie.

[@leahmae172]

These theories are awesome! I love how you take your own time up just to satisfy our needs for Coraline Theories! You deserve much more attention

[@siroma_xo]

❤️ I honestly enjoy longer videos. And can you maybe do a theory on some Tim Burton movies?

[@TheFangirlWatches]

I will look for some to add to my watch list! It will take a WHILE to get to them though, I'm moving and already have a bunch of unrecorded scripts.

[@lilliknight-hynes8294]

Found your channel this morning and I binged watched them all today! Not a day wasted, I loved it! Your theories are so cool and the Theoriser and your channels inspire me.

[@TheFangirlWatches]

You are too kind!

[@gabrielasanchez1464]

The Beldam never says that she's been waiting for Coraline for a "long time". She only says that she's been waiting for her. Meaning, since she made the doll and it got to Coraline, the Beldam has been waiting for Coraline to go through the portal. So I think that statement brings no evidence that the Beldam can see into the future.

[@RuthlessTides]

These theories have made me rewatch Coraline so much. Keep it up, you're really making me study it.

[@MSquared95]

I was thinking about the gap between the 1960s and 2009. what if that cat is a Wybee's dad hence how protective the cat is of him and the accent. My thought is that the dad gave up his own "life" as a way to keep his son safe knowing what happened to his aunt but knowing that the Bedlam can't be trusted the cat and the grandma set out to keeping Wybee away just in case.

[@KyrstOak]

Matison - 'a Wybee'? What makes you think there would be multiple?

[@may.k_me]

The Beldam is only interested in children so I doubt the cat us Wybee's father

[@jessiexxx6717]

That Pike Family No because Wybees parents named him wyborn and to Coraline its basiclly " Why were you born" so J think that his parents DIDNT want him so they gave him to his grandma to rasie, and that another reason why they arent there for him.

[@edenmetcalf9930]

i'm glad i've finally came across your proximate answer to the sand question. i always wondered why sand had anything to do with the story anyways, considering the setting and theme. the sawdust and fairy dust theory makes total sense to me. you really know how to do your research!

[@pocketcookie0x087]

Haha I turned on captions and instead of Wybee (I probably spelled that wrong) it said y beef

[@KyrstOak]

Natalia Armas - lol

[@hat9527]

Why beef

[@kahsosilly]

**Wybie

[@smolchild1230]

Stayed up til 2 to watch all of your Coraline videos and then re-watch the movie with your perspective. No regrets XD Seriously though, I can't believe how much sense this makes! The Pink Palace Limbo was actually something I had been wondering about myself, so I was happy to see that you managed to figure it out in a way that fits the world so well.

[@DisasterEnby]

Not sand, you say? 'Coraline, I don't feel so good...'

[@jadez4863]

This is a pretty cool theory! Before this, I kinda thought that maybe the soul sand was magical. When it was filled with heaps of magic, it was this thick, dense, heavy sand (like it was at the start of the movie with the doll). But when the Beldam was loosing her magic closer to the end of the movie, the sand was loosing it's magical properties and because thin and lighter - sawdust. Therefore, the sawdust could not contain enough magic for Wybie to leave the other world, but maybe if he had tried earlier, he would have been able to? There are a lot of things that could probably falsify this theory, like what about the mice? But I thought it was a cool thought that adds on to your's/the theorizors videos :)

[@NRGCH-yo6vj]

OMG who’s watching this on Christmas Eve if you are the. Merry Christmas and a happy new year but if your not the same to u

[@DANIELLE_BREANNA_LACY]

And how about the Nightmare before Christmas the movie that has the same director as Coraline?

[@gavingould5158]

I'M SO GLAD YOU FIGURED OUT IT'S SAWDUST CUZ I ALWAYS THOUGHT IT WAS SAWDUST

[@nylin460]

Wait. So if the other mother can get things that go down the well. Then coraline gave the other mother the key?

[@k.poe.edwards_836]

I literally just watched all of your Coraline theories in one day. Great channel.

[@iakgle]

I have committed a crime. I'm late to watch the video :(

[@TheFangirlWatches]

I forgive you, my dear

[@julianatuaoi3795]

ㄥ工爪モ you're late? I'm late😂

[@thescoundrel5265]

*Laughs*

[@iakgle]

@@thescoundrel5265 this was years ago when I would watch every single one of her videos the second they would be uploaded lmao

[@ahhh8558]

I just started binge-watching all of your Coraline theories... (i love them)

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Well thank you for watching all my insanity! You are appreciated!

[@sarahsuper1688]

kenetic sand

[@oatbunches]

this is actually really interesting. i never really paid attention so the stuffing of the dolls so when you went into how one was cotton and the other was sawdust that made a lot of sense!

[@turtledragon4227]

Today is eclipse can't go outside so I'm going to watch dis cause I have nothing else ta do 😊

[@KyrstOak]

Lara Jones Why couldn't you go outside?

[@KyrstOak]

TheWolfSVK GamingTV - But it doesn't make sense and jokes make sense.

[@DisabledPsychedelica]

If we're continuing with the magical aspects of the beldam, like a witch or fairy etc, then the "sand" COULD actually be herbs and stuff for magic. Sawdust is used with magic too, so it being also herbs would solidify the dolls magical nature.

[@danielav9596]

Again there should be a second movie for coraline come on movie people

[@ZelkovaSalts]

Dear The Fangirl I really love you videos you really make my day when I sneek my phone into the rest room to watch your videos

[@koolwaiikolb6857]

Really great theories,can u do one on ParaNorman?

[@TheFangirlWatches]

I have thought about ParaNorman, and I need to sit down and watch it again, but I recall the story being really well explained so I couldn't think of a foothold to theorize on!

[@koolwaiikolb6857]

The Fangirl thank you for replying,I still think u have good theories I like the one u did of Corpse Bride

[@clowww3204]

Thank you for making these incredible videos, I've been watching your channel for a little while now only to realise I hadn't subbed until now! I've loved coraline since I was a little girl, and I live being able to see different people's perceptions of the film... it's such a beautiful movie:)

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Aww, thanks for checking the channel out and subscribing!

[@sumutahkanen6581]

Can I ask something... Can the Beldam change it's appearence? I mean, because she is the "other mother" of the children, she has to look like their mother. She looked like Coralines mom so she also had to look like the other kids mothers. 😏

[@zoeparker2897]

Of course the Beldam can change its appearance. It does so canonically at the end of the movie, in fact.

[@cutesytemmie9654]

Fanni Tähkänen çd,dçdşdşdşşsşdşxşxşşdşd

[@KyrstOak]

A little theory of my own is what if Coraline going through the door that was previously bricked off, but mysteriously not bricked up despite no previous evidence that it had been taken down, symbolises her passing away (dying)? And everything she experiences is the after life? Alternatively, Coraline going through the door could symbolise her entering a coma and her living with the beldame (or however it's spelled) is what she experiences while in the coma, but when things start to go wrong (when her parents go missing and no-one bothers lifting a finger to help find them, etc.), that's her body dying/doctors performing surgery to try and save her, but failing and the fake real world is herself making it up because she doesn't realize she's no longer among the living.

[@RokhayaCameron-t9s]

Its ummm umm kinetic sand!!!!

[@AdaraFukuchi]

BOI this channel is growing FAST!!!! kudos for your work finally paying off.

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Thanks! Somehow my Moana Theory got recommended by KZbin like everywhere and it seemed like the channel took off over night after that (of course, 90% of viewers seem to HATE my Moana theory, but there's no such thing as bad publicity, right?).

[@AdaraFukuchi]

ehhhhhhhhhhhh i disagree with that but im still glad ur channel's growing :3

[@rebekahconley6496]

why is the beldams hands needles? can anyone answer this/

[@pixelunknown7717]

She made the doll to spy on her... maybe sewing? Its symbolizing it, I'm guessing.

[@Lion-Mutt]

Rebekah Conley The Beldam's body is also incredibly old, so it's starting to wither and break down -- She likely replaced her hands and fingers with needles because they cannot decay.

[@KyrstOak]

brudda, Pixel Unknown - Both of those theories sounds right to me.

[@avabousfield7993]

Rebekah Conley her hands are needles because you sew buttons in with needles

[@candyc3314]

Now i'm thinking about Edward Scissorhands lol

[@radicalrecreations5377]

What if the cat knew the well was a portal to the other world? That would perfectly explain why he stood in front of Coraline, blocking the door when she was about to leave to dispose of the key down the well. It was as if he knew what she was thinking.

[@zqueen1229]

Second

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Silver medal recipient!

[@ratdickz9196]

I saw a comment on a KZbin video referring to the dolls in the intro for Coraline. It stated that the reason Lovat's twin sisters doll was made of cotton was because her twin had a softer personality. Her soft personality is what led her to be tricked and killed by the beldam. When the beldam went to make Coraline's doll, she made it with saw dust. The saw dust is mean to represent Coraline's personality and that Coraline's more stubborn and resilient. This is why she escaped(even though she's still in the other dimension) the beldam but Lovat's twin sister didn't. I believe in your theory about the different dimensions and the pink palace limbo but Coraline wasn't tricked by the beldam to the extent of getting killed like Lovat's twin did. Also, if the beldam can create a whole other dimension then why is it weird that she has dust? Can't she just create the dust like she created a whole other dimension instead of trying to make a theory out of it? I still love your video's though

[@XxKawaiiCookies]

First

[@TheFangirlWatches]

I have no prize other than my congratulations! :)

[@ideletedmychannel5936]

The Fangirl how old is coraline

[@BocolatePlays]

Itz Snow About 12

[@ideletedmychannel5936]

Bocolate thx

[@MsYugioh20]

isn't there a part in the movie, i think its the part where shes going through the house counting the windows and such, where she goes to get the doll to go to the next room and it's mysteriously not where she had left it, but in a different spot in the room entirely. Like it moved there on it's own when she wasn't looking. Meaning that the doll can move on it's own.

[@charleenfabe4672]

i just found you and watched all your coraline videos today!! 😆 so fun listening to all these theories!

[@glennjenkins891]

loved it😍 I've watched all your Coraline videos, and I watch em all the way through

[@TheFangirlWatches]

I seriously need to make an award for people who watch them all!

[@andylynxxx4974]

Please make some more Coraline videos cause after i watched your vids i re-watched the movie and all of your theories made sense.

[@TheFangirlWatches]

The next Coraline video is in the works, but it will be a little ways off. I have a ton of other scripts to record and I'm still working on the next Coraline one, so I don't have a release date planned yet (but they will come eventually!).

[@mareofmaers3590]

Hello! Greetings from Germany, I love your videos and theories on Coraline, I just watched all of the videos. Keep up the great work!

[@fightinglucario]

I want to bring up a good point for your previous theory by the fact that the trees in the other world also seem to be in bloom much like when she returns to the real world which is magically spring

[@Pinxy_P]

You know what I just realized. I've been watching your channel since I was like five forgot about and now I am subscribed.

[@the_holographic_charazard3971]

I love your theories I watched Coraline with my mom a couple years ago and your Coraline theory videos made me think of a lot of things in the movie that I didn't think of when I was watching the movie

[@carolinaluna9407]

Omg, now that you mention the Shakespeare festival in Ashland it all makes sense! Years and years ago my cousin went on a trip with her English class to Ashland to go to that same festival! Wow, mind blown that is interesting...

[@Lea_Zencer]

I think in context, it is more viable to use sawdust for production purposes. Wybie blows his hand away and sand would not have been able to have that effect on film -so something lighter would have been needed, hence sawdust. I don’t think these movies are meant to be theorised to such a deep extent (though it IS one of our favorite things to do because it keeps things super interesting!). I just think to make a good movie, so many things go into consideration to make it work. And it’s a real headache (I would know!)

[@giannapotato6827]

Kinda small theory about the time whybi left the doll on the steps. In the movie Coraline goes to the well, we all know this and the stick is poison oak, when she gets home she says to her mother “I almost fell down a well yesterday” and her mom replies “ah huh”. Coraline says “ I would’ve died” but. Note she says yesterday giving whybi Time to get the doll and put it on her door. But the doll looks old the jacked is frayed as if it has been moving and it has mud on it. Then later in the movie the first time Coraline goes through the door if you look at the windows it’s just swirls which is kinda weird. So it might suggest that there are actually three floors to the theory and every time she sleeps she goes back to the first floor. And when she gets out of the tunnel there are stars out. These are just some things I’ve found out. I don’t know about them though. So yea.

[@Majorawesome003]

I know I’m three years late but the idea that the other mother makes the dolls in advance with future vision also explains why the coralline doll was in Mrs. Lovat’s possession. She’s too old to be wandering around and finding it recently

[@darquecadenza4834]

I LOVE all of your videos. Especially these Coraline ones. I've officially watched the whole playlist~ I feel accomplished lol.

[@mollykimball]

I watched ALL your Coraline theories. Very interesting videos to watch! I love Coraline so much. I remember seeing it in theaters with my mom when it first came out, (I was 9 years old) then buying the movie when it came out on DVD

[@kirakiwi5457]

About what you said in the beginning, I'm a loyal viewer that watches your videos all the way through.

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Why thank you!

[@marrissalo2221]

i luv u fangirl! and all your coco theories!!!!

[@delagreatness]

I love this channel so much! Thank you for uploading ❤️❤️❤️

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Thank you for watching!

[@adamnur1883]

The Fangirl, can the beldam enter the limbo pink palace? And wonderful theory as always!

[@jordangreen9201]

I was into dollmaking as a kid so I always thought it was sawdust. That said I'm going to pause the video and go watch 1-10 to understand what's happening because I FRIGGIN LOVE CORALINE!!! Your channel is so cool. 😎

[@phoenixmitia4014]

first time to watch Coreline theories*_* this would make the movie so much more detailed :)/love it !!!

[@rikarikaw1090]

I thought that the material inside the doll reflected the personality of the child it was "copying"Like, the doll of the missing twin had cottom, a fluffy and delicate material, kinda matching how sweet the girl's personality is shown to be(at least how much we seen of it)And coralines is sawdust because she is a rebelious adventurer with a very strong personality, so it makes sense why the hardy remains of something as resistant as an enormous tree would be used to stuff her copycatMaybe the dolls of the other kids were stuffed with other kinds of ingredients to match them as well

[@katk3489]

I can't imagine wanting to leave your vids before they end... I generally wish they were longer. Even when I don't agree or haven't seen the subject matter. Seriously enjoy, thank you!

[@sedi2066]

These theories are amazing .....give this movie so much more depth but I wonder if its creators actually put as much effort into the intricacies or if they were just creative and thoughtful enough that they created a movie that just keeps on giving like the matrix

[@burmiester1]

The Shakespeare Festival was actually put in there to explain Spink and Forcible, British actresses, living in the Pink Palace. They either looked for parts in plays and such or enjoyed the festivities. Maybe both.

[@veilvillage9873]

I always just figured the twin sisters doll was filled w/ cotton bc The Other Mother knew that the twin sister was at the age where kids are more likely to play w/ dolls( in the picture w/ the two twins Mrs.Lovett seems a bit jealous/envious of the doll her sister is holding) so she stuffed it w/ soft materials, whereas Coraline's doll was filled w/ sawdust bc The Other Mother knew that Coraline was "Too Old For Dolls" and would keep the doll mostly for decoration(even tho she does carry the doll around at the beginning) I just wonder what the doll used to look like/ what The Other Mother used to spy on the ghost children when they were alive, especially given the different time periods those children come from.

[@salt7505]

I live near the oregon border on I5 and there's a sign that specifically marks the Shakespeare festival as a location on the freeway

[@uoy46]

Okay Fangirl, first I love your channel and I watched all of your Coraline theories. You have inspired me to really look into this movie more. One of my theories is that you give the "other mother" too much credit and power. I believe that the other mother needed Coraline to complete the magic needed to get to the other world. What if the children unknowingly brings magic. This would explain why she says that she needs them, why her magic becomes drained over time, and why she needs them to love her. I believe that the magic is bigger than her , because if she so powerful she would just take the children outright. I believe that the magic well is magic she feeds off but is more powerful than her. I do believe that because she is evil, the universe provides things that can stop her like the cat, the seeing stone, and the key. The key is not hers but something she uses until it won't work for her any more. What if the more she uses her magic, the more she is drained of powerful magic. This is why some of her less powerful creations starts to defy her.

[@katvand4170]

I'm so glad you take time to do this

[@mollymakesthings1458]

 the first scene when the Beldam makes the doll is set 8 years before the rest of the film so the Beldam can see the future +The Fangirl

[@mollymakesthings1458]

+The Fangirl

[@maddiesmith7866]

I've watched all of your theories and I love them and your Chanel! I've been waiting for videos like yours. 👍👍✌️😉

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Thank you! I'm so glad that you're here!

[@georgia5813]

You’re a freaking genius, I’m shook rn

[@ambermarshall29]

I love these videos so much!!! I loved Coraline as a kid!!! ❤️❤️ keep it up!!

[@WitchVampZoe]

holy crap another awesome theory/part of the puzzle Fangirl! :)

[@TheFangirlWatches]

Thank you! I have to agree that they are feeling more like puzzle pieces over theories any more.

[@off-whitecomic7577]

I LOVE THESE! I subbed, but won't do notifications cuz it's kinda annoying.. but still VERY good videos I could watch these for the rest of the year straight!

[@DanicaMarieYT]

Im legit BINGING YOUR CORALINE THEORIES FOR THE THIRD TIME 😍😍😍😍😍

[@chromaticgreys8320]

I just realized the other day that in the photograph of wybie's grandma and her twin, the girl with the doll who's smiling might actually be wybie's grandma and the unhappy girl is the twin that was taken. Wybie said that his grandma wanted the doll back because it was hers, and also if the twin didn't get the doll and was unhappy with the normal world then wouldn't she be more willing to go into the other world forever? I don't know what this would mean about the doll's properties, though...

[@kindaapoptart19]

I love you for these videos. I'm obsessed.

[@everythingcollectibles]

When Wybie asked Coraline for the doll back, she couldn’t find it. The reason why was because the Beldam once again took it and modified it to turn it into a two sided doll that looked like Coralines Parents, hence, the one she found under her parents bed.

[@isabelkate22]

I knew this girl who told me that the creators where going to make a seccond movie of coraline . idk if that was true or not but maybe in the seccond film Coraline realizes shes in the pink palace limbo .